Compton v. Commissioner, No. 6:2018cv00079 - Document 22 (W.D. Va. 2020)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Norman K. Moon on June 1, 2020. (ca)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Compton v. Commissioner Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 1 of 10 Pageid#: 763 $)(-%$ #-!-%, "(,-+(#- !*.+&%,-%+) "(,-+(#- *& %(+'()(! Doc. 22 6/1/2020 @0*#'".,& 8(/(-(+* 8%"+,!' 7'% 7!-% B+' /3*1&Qd&)))02 .;29=A966% A9ACE5B8HA CD=B=CB d' 5,%.&2 F#1*% 7-++)//)-,&. -' 0(& F-$)#* F&$1.)03 5%+),)/0.# 0)-,! >.$&% B+,)!* ?' A++* &565=42=A" GVWa [ObbS` Wa PST]`S bVS 7]c`b ]¥ Q]¥aWRS`ObW]¥ ]T bVS ^O`bWSao Q`]aa&[]bW]¥a T]` ac[[O`g XcRU[S¥b% 8Yba' *+% *-% bVS ES^]`b O¥R ESQ][[S¥RObW]¥ ]T H¥WbSR FbObSa AOUWab`ObS >cRUS E]PS`b F' 6OZZ]c% 8Yb' *2 "lE!Em#% DZOW¥bWTT 8SP]`OV 7oa ]PXSQbW]¥a% 8Yb' +)% O¥R bVS 7][[WaaW]¥S`oa `Sa^]¥aS bVS`Sb]% 8Yb' +*' Dc`acO¥b b] FbO¥RW¥U C`RS` +)**&*0 O¥R +1 H'F'7' i /,/"P#"*#"6#% bVS 7]c`b `STS``SR bVWa [ObbS` b] >cRUS 6OZZ]c T]` ^`]^]aSR TW¥RW¥Ua ]T TOQb O¥R O `SQ][[S¥RSR RWa^]aWbW]¥' =¥ bVS E!E% bVS >cRUS 6OZZ]c `SQ][[S¥RSR bVWa 7]c`b RS¥g DZOW¥bWTToa []bW]¥ T]` ac[[O`g XcRU[S¥b O¥R U`O¥b bVS 7][[WaaW]¥S`oa []bW]¥ T]` ac[[O`g XcRU[S¥b' GVS 7]c`b Q]¥RcQba O 45 =>C> `SdWSe ]T bV]aS ^]`bW]¥a ]T bVS E!E b] eVWQV DZOW¥bWTT ]PXSQba' /55 +1 H'F'7' i /,/"P#"*#"6#4 :SR' E' 7Wd' D' 0+"P#' 5 ^ZOW¥bWTT [cab [OYS a^SQWTWQ ]PXSQbW]¥a b] bVS E!E4 O ^ZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥ [cab PS []`S bVO¥ [S`S RWaOU`SS[S¥b eWbV bVS GVWa 7]c`b OR]^ba bVS `SQ][[S¥RObW]¥ ]T bVS 7][[WbbSS ]¥ 7]c`b 5R[W¥Wab`ObW]¥ O¥R 7OaS AO¥OUS[S¥b ]T bVS >cRWQWOZ 7]¥TS`S¥QS ]T bVS H¥WbSR FbObSa bVOb Q]c`ba ]¥Zg caS bVS TW`ab ¥O[S O¥R ZOab W¥WbWOZ ]T bVS QZOW[O¥b W¥ a]QWOZ aSQc`Wbg ]^W¥W]¥a' ! 5¥R`Se A' FOcZ PSQO[S 7][[WaaW]¥S` ]T F]QWOZ FSQc`Wbg W¥ >c¥S +)*2' 7][[WaaW]¥S` FOcZ Wa VS`SPg acPabWbcbSR T]` bVS T]`[S` 5QbW¥U 7][[WaaW]¥S`% BO¥Qg 5' 6S``gVWZZ% Oa bVS ¥O[SR RSTS¥RO¥b W¥ bVWa OQbW]¥' FSS -+ H'F'7' i -)."U#% :SR' E' 7Wd' D' +."R#' * Dockets.Justia.com Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 2 of 10 Pageid#: 764 AOUWab`ObS >cRUSoa Q]¥QZcaW]¥a' /55 15=5D C" #@A?B5% .,2 :' Fc^^' +R 1-*% 1-/ "J'8' IO' +))1#' :]` bVS T]ZZ]eW¥U `SOa]¥a% bVS 7]c`b Q]¥QZcRSa bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥a O`S eWbV]cb [S`Wb% O¥R Wb OR]^ba bVS E!E W¥ TcZZ' ,</81/:1 93 +2>52? 5 RWab`WQb Q]c`boa `SdWSe ]T O [OUWab`ObS XcRUSoa `S^]`b O¥R `SQ][[S¥RObW]¥ Wa c¥RS`bOYS¥ 45 =>C>' /55 +1 H'F'7' i /,/"P#"*#"7#4 '2?<5? C" ,3$?945% *00 :' 5^^of ,+0% ,,)j,* "-bV 7W`' +))/#' JVWZS bVS 7]c`b UWdSa ¥] RSTS`S¥QS b] bVS [OUWab`ObS XcRUSoa ^`]^]aSR TW¥RW¥Ua O¥R Q]¥QZcaW]¥a ]T ZOe W¥ bVS E!E% bVWa 7]c`b [cab c^V]ZR bVS TOQbcOZ TW¥RW¥Ua ]T bVS 5R[W¥Wab`ObWdS @Oe >cRUS "l5@>m# WT bVSg O`S ac^^]`bSR Pg acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS O¥R eS`S `SOQVSR bV`]cUV O^^ZWQObW]¥ ]T bVS Q]``SQb ZSUOZ abO¥RO`R' /55 -+ H'F'7' ii -)."U#% *,1,"Q#",#4 $95@A5: C" $5??D89;;% *,2 F' 7b' **-1% **.+ "+)*2#4 $9?4 C" %><<E? >6 //#% //2 :',R ,,0% ,-) "-bV 7W`' +)*+#' H¥RS` bVWa abO¥RO`R ]T `SdWSe% bVS 7]c`b [cab lZ]]YLM b] O¥ SfWabW¥U OR[W¥Wab`ObWdS `SQ]`R O¥R OaYLM eVSbVS` Wb Q]¥bOW¥a nacTTWQWS¥LbM SdWRS¥QSo b] ac^^]`b bVS L5@>oaM TOQbcOZ RSbS`[W¥ObW]¥a'm $95@A5:% *,2 F' 7b' Ob **.- "W¥bS`¥OZ QWbObW]¥a ][WbbSR#' FcPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS Wa []`S bVO¥ O [S`S aQW¥bWZZOkPcb ZSaa bVO¥ O ^`S^]¥RS`O¥QSk]T bVS SdWRS¥QS' /55 %?297 C" %82A5?% 0/ :',R .1.% .12 "-bV 7W`' *22/#' 5 TW¥RW¥U Wa ac^^]`bSR Pg acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS WT Wb Wa POaSR ]¥ l`SZSdO¥b SdWRS¥QS LbVObM O `SOa]¥OPZS [W¥R [WUVb OQQS^b Oa ORS_cObS b] ac^^]`b O Q]¥QZcaW]¥'m *>8=@>= C" $2?=82?A% -,- :',R /.)' /., "-bV 7W`' +)).# "^S` Qc`WO[#' JVS`S lQ]¥TZWQbW¥U SdWRS¥QS OZZ]ea `SOa]¥OPZS [W¥Ra b] RWTTS` Oa b] eVSbVS` O QZOW[O¥b Wa RWaOPZSR%m bVS 7]c`b [cab RSTS` b] bVS 5@>oa RSQWaW]¥' )4" A]`S]dS`% bVS `SdWSeW¥U Q]c`b aVOZZ ¥]b l`S&eSWUV Q]¥TZWQbW¥U SdWRS¥QS% [OYS Q`SRWPWZWbg RSbS`[W¥ObW]¥a% ]` acPabWbcbS LWbaM XcRU[S¥bm T]` bVOb ]T bVS 5@>' %?297% 0/ :',R Ob .12' lHZbW[ObSZg% Wb Wa bVS Rcbg ]T bVS L5@>M `SdWSeW¥U O QOaS% + Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 3 of 10 Pageid#: 765 O¥R ¥]b bVS `Sa^]¥aWPWZWbg ]T bVS Q]c`ba% b] [OYS TW¥RW¥Ua ]T TOQb O¥R b] `Sa]ZdS Q]¥TZWQba W¥ bVS SdWRS¥QS'm (2D@ C" /B;;9C2=% 2)0 :'+R *-.,% *-./ "-bV 7W`' *22)#' "/064:9=81 DZOW¥bWTT R]Sa ¥]b O^^SO` b] ]PXSQb b] bVS E!Eoa `SQWbObW]¥ ]T bVS TOQbcOZ POQYU`]c¥R O¥R QZOW[ VWab]`g ]T bVWa QOaS' 8Yb' +)' GVS`ST]`S% bVS 7]c`b eWZZ OR]^b bVOb ^]`bW]¥ ]T bVS E!E W¥b] bVWa ]^W¥W]¥" /55 E!E Ob +j,' 6g eOg ]T ac[[O`g% bVS 7][[WaaW]¥S` RS¥WSR DZOW¥bWTToa `S_cSab T]` RWaOPWZWbg W¥ac`O¥QS PS¥STWba OTbS` O¥ 5@> T]c¥R bVOb DZOW¥bWTT VOR bVS [SRWQOZZg RSbS`[W¥OPZS W[^OW`[S¥ba ]T bg^S == RWOPSbSa% UZOcQ][O% Vg^S`bS¥aW]¥% O¥R Q][^ZWQObW]¥a abObca&^]ab VgabS`SQb][g ^`W]` b] VS` RObS ZOab W¥ac`SR% Pcb VS Q]¥QZcRSR bVOb ¥]¥S ]T bVSaS W[^OW`[S¥ba [Sb bVS `S_cWaWbS aSdS`Wbg bV`SaV]ZR b] acabOW¥ O RWaOPWZWbg&PS¥STWba QZOW[' E!E Ob , "QWbW¥U E' *+j*,#'" GVS 5^^SOZa 7]c¥QWZ RS¥WSR VS` `S_cSab T]` `SdWSe' )4" "QWbW¥U E' *j-#' !8/7@;5; DZOW¥bWTT Z]RUSa T]c` ]PXSQbW]¥a b] >cRUS 6OZZ]coa E!E3 *# Wba ^c`^]`bSR TOWZc`S b] ORR`Saa bVS 5@>oa ZOQY ]T Sf^ZO¥ObW]¥ ]T bVS eSWUVb bVOb VS OQQ]`RSR b] bVS ]^W¥W]¥ ]T 8`' JWZZWO[a W¥ bVS ESQ]`R4 +# Wba Q]¥QZcaW]¥ bVOb O¥g S``]` bVS 5@> [ORS W¥ abObW¥U bVOb 8`' FW¥US`# T]c¥R ¥] aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥ba e]cZR PS VO`[ZSaa4 ,# Wba Q]¥QZcaW]¥ bVOb bVS 5@> aObWaTWSR bVS `S_cW`S[S¥ba ]T F]Q' FSQ' EcZW¥U */&,^ GWbZSa == ! KI=3 9dOZcObW]¥ ]T Fg[^b][a W¥ 8WaOPWZWbg 7ZOW[a% FFE */&,^% +)*0 J@ .*1),)- "F'F'5' CQb' +.% +)*0#% OZZSUSRZg eWbV]cb [OYW¥U acTTWQWS¥bZg a^SQWTWQ TW¥RW¥Ua OP]cb DZOW¥bWTToa acPXSQbWdS OZZSUObW]¥a ]T ^OW¥4 O¥R -# Wba Q]¥QZcaW]¥ bVOb acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS ac^^]`bSR bVS 5@>oa Q]¥QZcaW]¥ bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa UZOcQ][O% RWOPSbSa% Vg^S`bS¥aW]¥ O¥R " ¥c[PS`' GVS 7]c`b RS¥]bSa QWbObW]¥a b] bVS OR[W¥Wab`ObWdS `SQ]`R Oa lE'm T]ZZ]eSR Pg bVS ^OUS 8`' JWZZWO[a O¥R 8`' FW¥US` eS`S P]bV [SRWQOZ R]Qb]`a eV] OQbSR Oa ¥]¥&b`SObW¥U% ¥]¥& SfO[W¥W¥U [SRWQOZ a]c`QSa W¥ bVS `SdWSe ]T DZOW¥bWTToa RWaOPWZWbg QZOW[' E' Ob */4 @55 +) 7':'E' i -)-'*.+0' # , Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 4 of 10 Pageid#: 766 VgabS`SQb][g `SQ]dS`g RWR ¥]b [SSb bVS `S_cWaWbS aSdS`Wbg bV`SaV]ZR' GVS 7]c`b eWZZ ORR`Saa SOQV ]T bVSaS ]PXSQbW]¥a W¥ bc`¥' 5b bVS ]cbaSb% bVS 7]c`b ¥]bSa bVOb aSdS`OZ ]T DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥a acPabO¥bWOZZg `SaS[PZS bV]aS [ORS PST]`S >cRUS 6OZZ]c% O¥R aSdS`OZ ]T bVS[ O^^SO` b] PS ¥] []`S bVO¥ US¥S`OZWhSR ]PXSQbW]¥a b] >cRUS 6OZZ]coa Q]¥QZcaW]¥a W¥ VWa E!E' :SRS`OZ EcZS ]T 7WdWZ D`]QSRc`S 0+"P# `S_cW`Sa ^O`bWSa b] ]PXSQb b] O [OUWab`ObS XcRUSoa TW¥RW¥Ua O¥R `SQ][[S¥RObW]¥a leWbV acTTWQWS¥b a^SQWTWQWbg a] Oa `SOa]¥OPZg b] OZS`b bVS RWab`WQb Q]c`b ]T bVS b`cS U`]c¥R T]` bVS ]PXSQbW]¥'m 0=9A54 /A2A5@ C" ,9475AA5% -01 :',R /*/% /+* "-bV 7W`' +))0#' lESVOaVW¥U O`Uc[S¥ba `OWaSR PST]`S bVS [OUWab`ObS XcRUS R]Sa ¥]b Q][^Zgm eWbV bVWa `S_cW`S[S¥b' /2=4?2 +" C" $5??D89;;% B]' 03*0&Qd& ))-*0% +)*2 J@ **-)+,1% Ob $+ "J'8' IO' AO`' *+% +)*2#' l=¥RSSR% ]PXSQbW]¥a bVOb aW[^Zg `SWbS`ObS O`Uc[S¥ba `OWaSR PST]`S bVS [OUWab`ObS XcRUS O`S Q]¥aWRS`SR b] PS US¥S`OZ ]PXSQbW]¥a b] bVS S¥bW`Sbg ]T bVS `S^]`b O¥R `SQ][[S¥RObW]¥m bVOb VOdS bVS aO[S STTSQb Oa O TOWZc`S b] ]PXSQb' )4' "QWbW¥U 15=5D% .,2 :' Fc^^' +R Ob 1--j-.#' <S`S% bV]cUV ZO`USZg `SQgQZW¥U O`Uc[S¥ba >cRUS 6OZZ]c OZ`SORg Q]¥aWRS`SR% DZOW¥bWTT ORRSR a][S ZW[WbSR a^SQWTWQ Q`WbW_cSa ]T bVS E!E' 5QQ]`RW¥UZg% ]cb ]T O¥ OPc¥RO¥QS ]T QOcbW]¥% bVS 7]c`b eWZZ c¥RS`bOYS O 45 =>C> `SdWSe ]T DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥a b] bVS E!E' *' JSWUVb OQQ]`RSR b] 8`' JWZZWO[oa ]^W¥W]¥ GVS 7]c`b PSUW¥a Pg ¥]bW¥U% Q]¥b`O`g b] DZOW¥bWTToa TW`ab ]PXSQbW]¥% bVOb >cRUS 6OZZ]c 494 ORR`Saa bVS 5@>oa Sf^ZO¥ObW]¥ T]` eVg Wb UOdS ZWbbZS eSWUVb b] 8`' JWZZWO[aoa ]^W¥W]¥ bVOb DZOW¥bWTT aV]cZR `ST`OW¥ T`][ Q]¥QS¥b`ObSR Sf^]ac`S b] VOhO`Ra Oa O `SacZb ]T VS` RWOPSbSa RWOU¥]aWa O¥R 5*7 ZSdSZa' 8Yb' *2 Ob /' JVOb Wa []`S% bVS 7]c`b Q]¥QZcRSa bVOb bVS 5@>oa RSQWaW]¥ b] ^`]dWRS ZWbbZS eSWUVb b] 8`' JWZZWO[aoa ]^W¥W]¥ Wa O[^Zg XcabWTWSR Pg acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R' GVS`ST]`S% T]` bVS `SOa]¥a bVOb T]ZZ]e% bVS 7]c`b eWZZ RS¥g DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥' - Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 5 of 10 Pageid#: 767 GVS 5@> Sf^ZOW¥SR bVOb eVWZS 8`' JWZZWO[a T]c¥R bVOb bVS DZOW¥bWTT aV]cZR `ST`OW¥ T`][ Q]¥QS¥b`ObSR Sf^]ac`S b] VOhO`Ra% bVS 5@> RWaOU`SSR eWbV bVWa Q]¥QZcaW]¥ POaSR ]¥ bVS SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R' E' Ob */' F^SQWTWQOZZg% bVS 5@> RSbS`[W¥SR bVOb 5ZbV]cUV Wb Wa b`cS bVOb bVS QZOW[O¥b VOR SZSdObSR 5*7 ZSdSZa ^`W]` b] VS` RObS ZOab W¥ac`SR% bVS QZOW[O¥b RWR ¥]b `S^]`b O¥g ag[^b][a Q][[]¥ eWbV RWOPSbSa [SZZWbca ]bVS` bVO¥ a][S aWRS STTSQba T`][ 5dO¥RWO' :c`bVS`% ^VgaWQOZ SfO[W¥ObW]¥ TW¥RW¥Ua RWR ¥]b `SdSOZ O¥g RWOPSbWQ Q][^ZWQObW]¥a ZWYS ¥Sc`]^ObVg ]` `SbW¥]^ObVg' ESQ]`Ra T]ZZ]eW¥U bVS QZOW[O¥boa RObS ZOab W¥ac`SR OZa] R] ¥]b Q]¥bOW¥ [cQV W¥ bVS eOg ]T ^VgaWQOZ SfO[W¥ObW]¥ TW¥RW¥Ua' =¥XSQbOPZS W¥acZW¥ eOa acUUSabSR Pg bVS QZOW[O¥boa ^VgaWQWO¥ W¥ AO`QV +)** O¥R bVS QZOW[O¥b PSUO¥ caW¥U W¥XSQbOPZS W¥acZW¥ W¥ 8SQS[PS` +)*,' BSdS`bVSZSaa% bVS QZOW[O¥b `S^]`bSR TSSZW¥U `SOa]¥OPZg eSZZ W¥ >O¥cO`g +)*+ O¥R Sf^`SaaSR ¥] Q][^ZOW¥ba' E' Ob */ "W¥bS`¥OZ QWbObW]¥a ][WbbSR#' GVS 5@>oa Sf^ZO¥ObW]¥ [OYSa QZSO` bVOb VS UOdS ZWbbZS eSWUVb b] 8`' JWZZWO[aoa ]^W¥W]¥ PSQOcaS bVS`S eOa ]bVS` SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R bVOb eSWUVSR OUOW¥ab VWa TW¥RW¥U bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa RWOPSbSa O¥R 5*7 ZSdSZa e]cZR VOdS W[^]aSR acQV O ZW[WbObW]¥ ]¥ VS`' /55 +) 7':'E' i -)-'*.+0"Q#"-# "l;S¥S`OZZg% bVS []`S Q]¥aWabS¥b O [SRWQOZ ]^W¥W]¥ Wa eWbV bVS `SQ]`R Oa O eV]ZS% bVS []`S eSWUVb eS eWZZ UWdS b] bVOb [SRWQOZ ]^W¥W]¥'m#' GVWa W¥QZcRSa bVS ]^W¥W]¥ ]T 8`' FW¥US`% eV] T]c¥R bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa RWOPSbSa RWR ¥]b W[^]aS O¥g aWU¥WTWQO¥b ZW[WbObW]¥ ]¥ VS` O¥R% W¥RSSR% ¥]bSR bVOb Ob bVS S¥R ]T bVS `SZSdO¥b ^S`W]R V]e DZOW¥bWTToa 5*7 ZSdSZa eS`S RSQ`SOaW¥U' E' Ob 2/' "l<S` RWOPSbSa Wa a][SeVOb ZW[WbW¥U% V]eSdS`% Ob bVS S¥R ]T bVS bW[S T`O[S VS` 5*7 ZSdSZa eS`S RSQ`SOaW¥U'm#4 E' Ob 21 "lJS VOdS RSbS`[W¥SR g]c` Q]¥RWbW]¥ eOa ¥]b RWaOPZW¥U ]¥ O¥g RObS LbV`]cUV bVS `SZSdO¥b ^S`W]RMm#' GVS 5@> RWR ¥]b acPabWbcbS VWa ]e¥ ]^W¥W]¥ T]` bVS ]^W¥W]¥ ]T 8`' JWZZWO[a% Oa DZOW¥bWTT Q]¥bS¥Ra' =¥abSOR% bVS 5@> RcbWTcZZg TcZTWZZSR VWa ]PZWUObW]¥ b] eSWUV bVS SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R O¥R ^`]^S`Zg SdOZcObSR 8`' JWZZWO[aoa ]^W¥W]¥' (2D@% 2)0 :'+R Ob *-./ "-bV 7W`' *22)# "lHZbW[ObSZg% Wb Wa bVS Rcbg ]T bVS L5@>M `SdWSeW¥U O QOaS% O¥R ¥]b bVS `Sa^]¥aWPWZWbg ]T bVS Q]c`ba% b] [OYS TW¥RW¥Ua ]T TOQb O¥R b] `Sa]ZdS Q]¥TZWQba W¥ bVS SdWRS¥QS'm#' :c`bVS`% O 45 =>C> `SdWSe ]T bVS ESQ]`R RS[]¥ab`ObSa bVOb bVS`S SfWabSR acPabO¥bWOZ . Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 6 of 10 Pageid#: 768 SdWRS¥QS T]` bVS 5@>oa RSQWaW]¥ Oa b] bVS ZW[WbObW]¥ bVOb 8`' JWZZWO[aoa WRS¥bWTWSR' GVS`ST]`S% DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥ Wa ]dS``cZSR' +' <O`[ZSaa 9``]` ]T 5@>oa W¥bS`^`SbObW]¥ ]T 8`' FW¥US`oa ]^W¥W]¥ GVS 7]c`b eWZZ ¥Sfb OaaSaa eVSbVS`% Oa DZOW¥bWTT Q]¥bS¥Ra% >cRUS 6OZZ]c S``SR W¥ Q]¥QZcRW¥U bVOb lO¥g S``]` Pg bVS 5@> W¥ abObW¥U bVOb 8`' FW¥US` T]c¥R ¥] aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥ba Wa VO`[ZSaa'm 8Yb' +) Ob +' GVS 5@> O¥R bVS 7][[WaaW]¥S` VOR OaaS`bSR bVOb 8`' FW¥US` Q]¥QZcRSR bVOb DZOW¥bWTT RWR ¥]b VOdS O¥g aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥ba' 8Yb' *2 Ob . ¥'-' 5a >cRUS 6OZZ]c ]PaS`dSR% 8`' FW¥US`oa ]^W¥W]¥ ¥]bSa W¥ be] ^ZOQSa bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa Q]¥RWbW]¥a O`S ¥]¥&aSdS`S' E' Ob 2-' <]eSdS`% ]¥ ]¥S ^OUS W¥ VWa ]^W¥W]¥% 8`' FW¥US` [O`YSR c¥RS` bVS aSQbW]¥ ]T VWa ]^W¥W]¥ bWbZSR lASRWQOZZg 8SbS`[W¥OPZS =[^OW`[S¥b O¥R FSdS`Wbgm bVOb DZOW¥bWTT VOR l8WOPSbSa ASZZWbcam Oa O¥ W[^OW`[S¥b% [O`YW¥U bVWa W[^OW`[S¥b Oa lFSdS`Sm c¥RS` bVS lFSdS`Wbgm Q]Zc[¥' E' Ob 2.' DZOW¥bWTT O`UcSa bVOb O¥g S``]` bVOb bVS 5@> [ORS W¥ abObW¥U bVOb 8`' FW¥US` T]c¥R ¥] aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥ba Wa ^`SXcRWQWOZ PSQOcaS bVS 5@> e]cZR VOdS Q]¥bW¥cSR ]¥ eWbV bVS TWdS&abS^ ^`]QSaa T]` SdOZcObW¥U RWaOPWZWbg QZOW[a% `ObVS` bVO¥ ab]^^W¥U Ob abS^ be]' *>8=@>=% -,- :',R Ob /.- ¥'* "QWbW¥U +) 7':'E' i -)-'*.+)#' GVS 7][[WaaW]¥S` RWaOU`SSa% ^]W¥bW¥U b] V]e 8`' FW¥US` RWR ¥]b TW¥R O¥g Tc¥QbW]¥OZ ZW[WbObW]¥a Oaa]QWObSR eWbV DZOW¥bWTToa RWOPSbSa% SdS¥ WT VS VOR [ORS O TW¥RW¥U bVOb VS` RWOPSbSa eOa aSdS`S' 5¥ S``]` Wa VO`[ZSaa WT O¥g `SOa]¥OPZS 5@> e]cZR VOdS Q][S b] bVS aO[S Q]¥QZcaW]¥ VOR VS ¥]b [ORS bVS S``]`' /55 &2C9@ C" #@A?B5% B]' +3)0j+,*% +))1 J@ .-)122% Ob $, "8'F'7' :SP' ++% +))1#' 5b abS^ be] ]T bVS RWaOPWZWbg&QZOW[a O¥OZgaWa% bVS 5@> [cab [OYS O RSbS`[W¥ObW]¥ Oa b] eVSbVS` O QZOW[O¥b VOa O aSdS`S [SRWQOZZg RSbS`[W¥OPZS W[^OW`[S¥b ]` Q][PW¥ObW]¥ ]T W[^OW`[S¥ba' +) 7':'E' i -)-'*.+)"Q#' +) 7':'E' i -)-'*.++"O# abObSa bVOb lO¥ W[^OW`[S¥b ]` Q][PW¥ObW]¥ ]T W[^OW`[S¥ba Wa ¥]b aSdS`S WT Wb R]Sa ¥]b @97=96932=A;D ZW[Wb g]c` ^VgaWQOZ ]` [S¥bOZ / Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 7 of 10 Pageid#: 769 OPWZWbg b] R] POaWQ e]`Y OQbWdWbWSa'm "S[^VOaWa ac^^ZWSR#' 9dS¥ OQQS^bW¥U bVOb bVS 5@> S``SR W¥ abObW¥U bVOb 8`' FW¥US` T]c¥R ¥] aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥bakPOaSR a]ZSZg ]¥ 8`' FW¥US`oa W¥RWQObW]¥ W¥ bVS laSdS`Wbgm Q]Zc[¥ T]` DZOW¥bWTToa RWOPSbSa [SZZWbca W[^OW`[S¥bk¥] `SOa]¥OPZS 5@> e]cZR VOdS T]c¥R bVOb DZOW¥bWTT VOR O aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥b WT bVOb S``]` VOR ¥]b PSS¥ [ORS' GVWa Wa PSQOcaS 8`' FW¥US`oa ]^W¥W]¥ U]Sa ]¥ b] abObS bVOb lLDZOW¥bWTToaM RWOPSbSa Wa a][SeVOb ZW[WbW¥U% V]eSdS`% Ob bVS S¥R ]T bVS bW[S T`O[S VS` 5*7 ZSdSZa eS`S RSQ`SOaW¥U'm E' Ob 2/' lF][SeVOb ZW[WbW¥Um R]Sa ¥]b [SSb +) 7':'E' i -)-'*.++"O#oa aSdS`Wbg bV`SaV]ZR% eVWQV `S_cW`Sa bVOb O¥ W[^OW`[S¥b laWU¥WTWQO¥bZg ZW[Wbm ^VgaWQOZ ]` [S¥bOZ OPWZWbWSa W¥ ]`RS` T]` Wb b] _cOZWTg' =¥ O¥g SdS¥b% 8`' FW¥US` cZbW[ObSZg Q]¥QZcRSR bVOb DZOW¥bWTT RWR ¥]b acTTS` O¥g RWaOPZW¥U Q]¥RWbW]¥ Rc`W¥U bVS `SZSdO¥b bW[S ^S`W]R' E' Ob 21' =¥ ORRWbW]¥% ]PXSQbWdS [SRWQOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R ]¥ eVWQV bVS 5@> POaSR VWa RSQWaW]¥ Tc`bVS` SabOPZWaVSR bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa RWOPSbSa eOa ¥]b O aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥b eWbVW¥ bVS Q]¥bSfb ]T +) 7':'E' i -)-'*.+)"Q#' :]` SfO[^ZS% bVS 5@> ¥]bSR V]e DZOW¥bWTT VOR ¥]b PSUc¥ bOYW¥U W¥XSQbOPZS W¥acZW¥ b] b`SOb VS` RWOPSbSa c¥bWZ OTbS` bVS `SZSdO¥b ^S`W]R VOR S¥RSR' E' Ob *.' <S OZa] VWUVZWUVbSR bVOb bVS `SQ]`R RWR ¥]b RS[]¥ab`ObS bVOb DZOW¥bWTT acTTS`SR O¥g ag[^b][a ]T RWOPSbSa bVOb e]cZR VOdS `SacZbSR W¥ O aSdS` W[^OW`[S¥b ]¥ VS` OPWZWbg b] QO``g ]cb POaWQ e]`Y OQbWdWbWSa' )4" :]` bVS T]`SU]W¥U `SOa]¥a% DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥ Oa b] >cRUS 6OZZ]coa TW¥RW¥U ]T VO`[ZSaa S``]` Wa ]dS``cZSR' GVS 7]c`b TW¥Ra% T]` bVS aO[S `SOa]¥a% bVOb bVS`S Wa acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R ]¥ eVWQV bVS 5@> POaSR Wba RSbS`[W¥ObW]¥ bVOb DZOW¥bWTT RWR ¥]b VOdS O aSdS`S [SRWQOZ W[^OW`[S¥b' ,' 5@>oa :W¥RW¥Ua c¥RS` EcZW¥U */&,^ DZOW¥bWTT O`UcSa bVOb bVS E!E ]dS`Z]]YSR bVS 5@>oa TOWZc`S b] [OYS a^SQWTWQ TW¥RW¥Ua `SUO`RW¥U DZOW¥bWTToa acPXSQbWdS OZZSUObW]¥a ]T ^OW¥ O¥R ZW[WbObW]¥a% Oa `S_cW`SR Pg EcZW¥U */&,^% 0 Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 8 of 10 Pageid#: 770 eVWQV U]dS`¥a bVS SdOZcObW]¥ ]T DZOW¥bWTToa ag[^b][a' DZOW¥bWTT QZOW[a bVOb bVS 5@> [S`SZg ac[[O`WhSR DZOW¥bWTToa bSabW[]¥g O¥R bVS [SRWQOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS ESQ]`R% eVWQV aVS O`UcSa Wa W¥acTTWQWS¥b' G] bVS Q]¥b`O`g% bVS E!E RWR ORR`Saa DZOW¥bWTToa Q]¥QS`¥a bVOb bVS 5@> TOWZSR b] [OYS a^SQWTWQ TW¥RW¥Ua `SUO`RW¥U VS` acPXSQbWdS OZZSUObW]¥a' 8Yb' *2 Ob 1' JVWZS bVS 5@> RWR ac[[O`WhS bVS [SRWQOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R% Wb QO¥¥]b PS aOWR bVOb VS TOWZSR b] [OYS O¥g a^SQWTWQ TW¥RW¥Ua' 5a >cRUS 6OZZ]c T]c¥R% bVS 5@> laSb T]`bV LDZOW¥bWTToaM acPXSQbWdS Q][^ZOW¥ba OP]cb bVS W¥bS¥aWbg% ^S`aWabS¥QS O¥R ZW[WbW¥U STTSQba ]T VS` ag[^b][a W¥ VWa ]^W¥W]¥m O¥R bVS¥ ^`]QSSRSR b] OaaSaa eVSbVS` bV]aS OZZSUObW]¥a eS`S ac^^]`bSR Pg bVS SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS ESQ]`R% Oa `S_cW`SR Pg EcZW¥U */&,^' E!E Ob 1' GVS 5@> ac[[O`WhSR bVS SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R ]¥ eVWQV VS POaSR VWa a^SQWTWQ TW¥RW¥Ua% eVWQV W¥QZcRSR% Pcb O`S ¥]b ZW[WbSR b]% bVS T]ZZ]eW¥U3 lGVca% bVS QZOW[O¥boa UZOcQ][O VOa ¥]b QOcaSR []`S bVO¥ O aZWUVb OP¥]`[OZWbg VOdW¥U []`S bVO¥ O [W¥W[OZ STTSQb ]¥ bVS QZOW[O¥boa OPWZWbg b] ^S`T]`[ POaWQ e]`Y OQbWdWbWSa Rc`W¥U bVS `SZSdO¥b ORXcRWQObWdS ^S`W]Rm "E' Ob *-#4 l=¥ >c¥S +)**% bVS QZOW[O¥boa PZ]]R ^`Saac`S eOa Q]¥aWRS`SR eSZZ&Q]¥b`]ZZSR eWbV 5bS¥]Z]Z O¥R @WaW¥]^`WZm "E' Ob *.#4 lGVca% bVS QZOW[O¥boa RWOPSbSa O¥R Vg^S`bS¥aW]¥ VOdS ¥]b QOcaSR []`S bVO¥ aZWUVb OP¥]`[OZWbWSa VOdW¥U []`S bVO¥ O [W¥W[OZ STTSQb ]¥ bVS QZOW[O¥boa OPWZWbg b] ^S`T]`[ POaWQ e]`Y OQbWdWbWSam E' Ob *.' GVS`S O`S []`S' /55! 5"7"% E' Ob *-j*.' 5a ac^^]`b T]` bVSaS a^SQWTWQ TW¥RW¥Ua% bVS 5@> SfbS¥aWdSZg `STS`S¥QSR bVS [SRWQOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R% eVWQV bVS DZOW¥bWTT OQY¥]eZSRUSa' GVS 5@> RWR% ]T Q]c`aS% ac[[O`WhS bVS [SRWQOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R% Oa DZOW¥bWTT Q]¥bS¥Ra% Pcb Wb eOa OZZ W¥ aS`dWQS b] bVS a^SQWTWQ TW¥RW¥Ua VS [ORS OTbS` eSWUVW¥U bVOb SdWRS¥QS' A]`S]dS`% bVOb [SRWQOZ SdWRS¥QSkeVWQV RSbOWZa [SRWQObW]¥a bOYS¥% bVS ag[^b][a Sf^S`WS¥QSR% PZ]]R acUO` ZSdSZa% 5*7 ZSdSZa% O¥R []`SkQZSO`Zg [SSba bVS Z]e acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS bV`SaV]ZR% XcabWTgW¥U bVS 5@>oa Q]¥QZcaW]¥a bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa acPXSQbWdS OZZSUObW]¥a ]T TObWUcS% VSOROQVSa% PZW¥R a^]ba% PZc``SR dWaW]¥% TZcQbcObW¥U dWacOZ OQcWbg% O¥R 1 Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 9 of 10 Pageid#: 771 RWhhW¥Saa RWR ¥]b Q]¥abWbcbS aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥ba bVOb aWU¥WTWQO¥bZg ZW[WbSR VS` OPWZWbg b] ^S`T]`[ POaWQ e]`Y OQbWdWbWSa' GVS`ST]`S% DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥ Wa ]dS``cZSR' -' FcPabO¥bWOZ 9dWRS¥QS T]` bVS 5@>oa 7]¥QZcaW]¥a GVS`S QO¥ PS ZWbbZS R]cPb bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa T]c`bV ]PXSQbW]¥kbVOb bVS E!E S``SR W¥ TW¥RW¥U bVOb acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS ac^^]`bSR bVS 5@>oa Q]¥QZcaW]¥ bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa UZOcQ][O% RWOPSbSa% Vg^S`bS¥aW]¥ O¥R VgabS`SQb][g `SQ]dS`g RWR ¥]b [SSb bVS `S_cWaWbS aSdS`Wbg bV`SaV]ZRkQ]¥abWbcbSa O US¥S`OZWhSR ]PXSQbW]¥ b] bVS E!E' B]¥SbVSZSaa% ]¥ 45 =>C> `SdWSe% Wb Wa QZSO` b] bVS 7]c`b bVOb bVS E!E Q]cZR ¥]b VOdS S``SR W¥ Q][W¥U b] acQV O Q]¥QZcaW]¥% PSQOcaS bVS`S Wa ¥] _cSabW]¥ bVOb bVS 5@>oa TW¥RW¥Ua eS`S ac^^]`bSR Pg acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS ESQ]`R' 5a RWaQcaaSR W¥ bVS ^`SQSRW¥U acPaSQbW]¥a% bVS 5@> `SZWSR c^]¥ DZOW¥bWTToa [SRWQOZ VWab]`g O¥R bVS ]^W¥W]¥a ]T ¥] TSeS` bVO¥ T]c` [SRWQOZ a]c`QSa W¥ ]`RS` b] W¥T]`[ VWa ]^W¥W]¥' E' Ob *.j*/' GVS 5@> ¥]bSR bVOb eVWZS DZOW¥bWTT RWR VOdS SZSdObSR 5*7 ZSdSZa ^`W]` b] VS` RObS ZOab W¥ac`SR% aVS RWR ¥]b `S^]`b O¥g ag[^b][a ]T RWOPSbSa [SZZWbca% ZSb OZ]¥S Q][^ZWQObW]¥a acQV Oa ¥Sc`]^ObVg ]` `SbW¥]^ObVg bVOb Q]cZR ZSOR b] O aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥b' E' Ob */' 5a b] VS` ]bVS` Q]¥RWbW]¥a% bVS 5@> `SZWSR ]¥ [SRWQOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R b] [OYS bVS T]ZZ]eW¥U TW¥RW¥Ua3 bVS 5@> ¥]bSR bVOb bVS`S eOa ZWbbZS b] ¥] SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R bVOb DZOW¥bWTT VOR bOYS¥ ]` a]cUVb b`SOb[S¥b T]` VSOROQVSa "E' Ob *+#4 QWbSR V]e aVS VOR PSS¥ OPZS b] [O¥OUS VS` UZOcQ][O eWbV [SRWQObW]¥ O¥R VOR lU]]R dWacOZ OQcWbg Ob +)(+) PWZObS`OZZgm "E' Ob *-#4 `STS`S¥QSR V]e VS` PZ]]R ^`Saac`S eOa c¥RS` Q]¥b`]Z eWbV [SRWQObW]¥ "E' Ob *.#4 O¥R VWUVZWUVbSR bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa Q][^ZWQObW]¥a T`][ VS` VgabS`SQb][g O^^SO`SR b] VOdS PSS¥ VSOZW¥U eSZZ "E' Ob +)#' G] bVS SfbS¥b bVOb DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥ `Saba ]¥ bVS 5@>oa RSbS`[W¥ObW]¥ ]T VS` Q`SRWPWZWbg W¥ [OYW¥U VS` acPXSQbWdS OZZSUObW]¥a ]T ^OW¥ O¥R ZW[WbObW]¥% Wb OZa] TOWZa' DZOW¥bWTToa OZZSUObW]¥a OP]cb VS` ^OW¥ l¥SSR ¥]b PS OQQS^bSR b] bVS SfbS¥b bVSg O`S W¥Q]¥aWabS¥b eWbV OdOWZOPZS SdWRS¥QS%m acQV Oa Q]¥aS`dObWdS b`SOb[S¥b' &B== C" %>;C9=% /)0 :' 5^^of +/-% +0-j0. "-bV 7W`' +)*.# "W¥bS`¥OZ 2 Case 6:18-cv-00079-NKM-RSB Document 22 Filed 06/01/20 Page 10 of 10 Pageid#: 772 QWbObW]¥a ][WbbSR#' <S`S% bVS 5@> RSbS`[W¥SR bVOb lbVS QZOW[O¥boa abObS[S¥ba Q]¥QS`¥W¥U bVS W¥bS¥aWbg% ^S`aWabS¥QS O¥R ZW[WbW¥U STTSQba ]T bVSaS ag[^b][a O`S ¥]b S¥bW`SZg Q]¥aWabS¥b eWbV bVS [SRWQOZ SdWRS¥QS O¥R ]bVS` SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R'm E' Ob *-' GVS 7]c`b TW¥Ra bVOb bVS 5@> VOR []`S bVO¥ acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS W¥ bVS `SQ]`R ]¥ eVWQV b] POaS bVOb Q]¥QZcaW]¥' =¥ ac[% bVS 5@> eSWUVSR bVS SdWRS¥QS O¥R T]c¥R bVOb Wb RWR ¥]b eSWUV W¥ TOd]` ]T TW¥RW¥U bVOb DZOW¥bWTT VOR O aSdS`S W[^OW`[S¥b Rc`W¥U bVS `SZSdO¥b bW[S ^S`W]R' =b Wa ¥]b T]` bVWa 7]c`b b] `SeSWUV bVS SdWRS¥QS% O¥R% PSQOcaS O `SOa]¥OPZS [W¥R Q]cZR OQQS^b bVS `ObW]¥OZS ]TTS`SR Pg bVS 5@>% bVWa 7]c`b RSTS`a b] VWa RSQWaW]¥' -B== C" $5??D89;;% B]' /3*0&Qd&))).-% +)*2 J@ *-*.-0*% Ob $- "J'8' IO' AO`' +1% +)*2#' 5QQ]`RW¥UZg% DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥ Wa ]dS``cZSR' #9807=;598 9dS¥ Q]¥ab`cW¥U DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥a Oa Q]¥bOW¥W¥U a^SQWTWQ ]PXSQbW]¥a b] bVS E!E O¥R bVS`SOTbS` c¥RS`bOYW¥U O 45 =>C> `SdWSe ]T bV]aS ^]`bW]¥a ]T bVS E!E b] eVWQV DZOW¥bWTT ]PXSQbSR% bVS 7]c`b TW¥Ra bVOb acPabO¥bWOZ SdWRS¥QS ac^^]`ba bVS 5@>oa Q]¥QZcaW]¥a' 5QQ]`RW¥UZg% bVS 7]c`b eWZZ S¥bS` O¥ C`RS` ]dS``cZW¥U DZOW¥bWTToa ]PXSQbW]¥a% 8Yb' +)% OR]^bW¥U bVS E!E% 8Yb' *2% U`O¥bW¥U bVS 7][[WaaW]¥S`oa A]bW]¥ T]` Fc[[O`g >cRU[S¥b% 8Yb' *-% RS¥gW¥U DZOW¥bWTToa A]bW]¥ T]` Fc[[O`g >cRU[S¥b% 8Yb' *+% O¥R RWa[WaaW¥U O¥R ab`WYW¥U bVWa OQbW]¥ T`][ bVS 7]c`boa OQbWdS R]QYSb' 5¥ O^^`]^`WObS C`RS` eWZZ WaacS% O¥R bVS 7ZS`Y ]T bVS 7]c`b Wa VS`SPg RW`SQbSR b] aS¥R O Q]^g ]T bVWa AS[]`O¥Rc[ C^W¥W]¥ b] bVS ^O`bWSa' 9BG9E98 bVWa NNNNNN ROg ]T June, 2020. 1st *)
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
