Souter v. County of Warren et al, No. 5:2013cv00061 - Document 41 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 8/27/14. (kld)

Download PDF
l@ O e:eFFCEUS. S C I DIT OURT * I TH E UN I N TED STATES D I RICT COU RT ST FO R TH E W ESTERN D I RICT O F W RGI I ST N A A e lo B R V T s û uq ' ' HARRIONBIRGol sow S J w l FI LED ALC 28 2 1 29 SJULA U LEM CL ERK k. J. J A E.SOUTER, ULI Pl ntf , ai if Ci lA cton N o. 5: vi i : 13cv00061 V. CO U N TY O F W A RR EN , By:H on.M i chaelF.U r banski aPoicl u dvs n#' qii, .p. li S biio Vi na < ., ta i tJ a Unie St esDiti Judge td at srct D ef endant s. M EM O RAN DU M O PI ION N Tli cour pr ousy ent as t evi l ezed a O r adoptng i par tz repor a r n dez i n t le t nd ecom m endaton of i t ma itaej ea dimisngt sc e DktNo. Pli f ulaE. es z . ,he he gsrt udg nd s si hi as. . 35. andfJ i Soutr p . K t n q fldaplalngwhih s sye a t e tonst Sna or ra cai a t tof' Dk. le e ci c he tld s t ci o l de nd lticdon hee . tNo. obj ' 37.Thec ur c tue t sa amodont atrota ndt c tsj me purua t Fe tl o t onst d hi s o le me he our' udg nt s nt o dea Rul ofCi lPt e te5 e, oloquilyrfte t a amodon frr c i tdon.Tha moto e vi oc dtr 9()c l al eet d o s o e onsdea t in wasdeni ed. Soutrha no fldwha s sye asç antf' Objc e s w te t he tls < i ifs e donst Etot a Ommiso pl o r s nd sins gil' Thi pla ngdoesnotc mewihi t nt ihtda atrt e r ofj me a sc. s e di ' o t n ' peg ys fe he nty udg nt nd we Sout ' fr tm oton f reconsder ers l s i or i adon w asdeti Thus he m os r led. , r t ecentpladi i pr l e ng s opeêy viwe aRul 6 moton.Se Ra v. ve e Ba N. ,No.3:2CV-7, 3W L e d e 0$) i e hmi So ri nk A. 1 - 8 201 15 676 a * ( D. . . .1 201 ) f fr apat ma s e tle unde Rue6 $,a 63 , t 2 N. W Va Apr 2, 3 . f o e ry y ek eif r l 04 Be pat mus frts fmei s ameiotousdefns, lc ofunfi ptj c t t opposng ry t ls how t lnes, rt i i e ea ak ar eudie o he i pat,a e c ptona ctumsa es''I (uodngDo lv.SaeFam Fie& Ca . o.ns ry nd x e i l ic tnc . d.q ' wel tt r r s Aut l . Co.9 F. 46 48( hCi.1 )9seas Eva v. gsa veAfar Di . a 93 2d , 4t r 993) e lo ns Le ild fis v.ATF,No. 1 CV6:2- 0 41J 2 3W L 26 33 a * ( S. J 1 ,201 )(a ) afd,5 F. x72(t Ci. 06 -MC, 01 359 , t 2 D. C.une 1 3 sme, f 48 App' 4h t 201 ) Souttfist me tt ss tnda hltl.I ta s tieaeshe beift ts wa 3 . e al o e hi ubsa l zte nsed,he etrt r le ha he s unconsiutonaly deni couns atpublc expens i t scvt cas a tt i l ed el i e n hi i ' e, ccusestlscour ofbi ,and l li t as ass t t tzscour i ed cer an at ent s m a i herprorm oton. er s hat li t gnot t i gum s he de n i i The cour hasaleady fzl addr sed t sfr ti s i t o pr otw rten opi onsand wll t r tly es hi ls s ue n ' w i it ni ' l notr h isanal i on Sout ' ass t rghtt cour appoi ed couns i a ci lcas f a t r ehas t yss ets ered i o t nt el n vi e or hid tm e. A st t s i o he econd isue,Sout t cai st t cour ' des i i ofhetm odon f s e l m hat he ts crpton or rc i rtona tprmalyc nssg )ofablsei ,sta ofc couspolmi'e nc sbis e onsdeai s i i rl o iti ' ng itrng te m- -onsi e c' vi e a agni ther. I doesnot The cour i oblgat t as st pl ngsbef i and bele t t ns t . t s i ed o ses he eadi ore t ives hat he t a c e ofSo e ' pl a ng s a f t m s l s nal ,So e a s r s t tt sc t one nd ont nt ut ts e di s pe k ot he eve .Fi l y ut t s e t ha hi out i nor d c ra n a gu e s s m a a uta s a e c ts f i ue t a nthe c g e e t i r m nt he de bo t t out ' a l o ppoi t r ouns ldutng e i r at ltgaton. The cour addr s t el ed ii i t es ed hesear ent i t second f ot ofisprotopi on. gum s n he oom e t i ni See M em .O p. D kt N o.38,at2 n. , . 2. F rteet ao s t Rue6 :)mo o wi bed ne .Theceki dtce t sndac p o h s e s n ,he l 0 d n l e id l lt s ie td o e oy oft sM em or hi andum O piton t t pr â pl ndf and t al counse oft ri o he o . ai f ç o l l ecord. Ent r Augus 27,2014 e ed: t * * * .w. . v j hae F.Ur c j banski Unie Sae Ditit udge td tts src J

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.