Howard v. Abingdon Virginia, No. 1:2012cv00035 - Document 13 (W.D. Va. 2012)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION dismissing complaint without prejudice. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 9/19/12. (ejs)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
rlppŠs OFFI U. DI rnlr CE S. ST. - I AT ROANOKE, VA FIBB L I TH E U N I N TED STA TE S D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTER N DI STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A A BI G D O N D I I O N N V SI A ND R E J.H O W A RD e al , t . SEF 19 2 1 22 JULI C. UD P(CLERK A BY: r GRK d C i lA c i N o.1: 2c vi t on 1 v00035 Pl nt f s ai i f , M EM O R AND UM O PI IO N N A BI G D O N V I G I I I N R N A N W A SH I G TO N C O U N TY , N D ef endant . By:Sam ue G . is l W l on U nie St t sD i t c Judge t d a e s ri t Thi i a a ton bypr s pl n ifA nd e J H owa d1a d a i e e m i t num be of s s n ci o e ai tf r . r r n n nd t r na e Howad' fm iyme r a ns t t ofAbi on, r ni, alegi (mongot r s a l mbes gai t he own ngd Vigi az l ng n her t ngsno i ditl cea)t tt dee nt ha tke a ntgeofmi ii a t i hi t mme aey l r ha he fnda s ve a n dva a nortes nd her p o e t sf rp o i.Ho r s e s$ ,0 ,0 frp i a ds f rn a a ij cin r p ri o r ft wad e k 35 00 0 o an n ufeig, nd n nun to e or e i t t w n t S om pl t a co i .. m ai e nc ofTa orH il sr e l e .' d r ng he o o l c e e nd ntnue . nt na e yl l' ed ve opm nt' Abi ngdonha move t dim isHowa d' c s d o s s r s ompl i f f iur t sae acai .Howa d' tme ant or al e o t t l m r si 1Howa dhasa e e i tac rcor i t fde a co t. SeeHowa dv. ehoditHos Sys,Ci l r n xtnsve r k e d n he e r l urs r M t s p. . vi Acin1-521 2, t*-6( D. x De .1 , 0 5 ($ tels d cd , deJ e Ho r h sfldtnlws t t 40 - 4 a 1 S. Te . c 3 2 0 ) $n h at e a e An r o l wad a i e a ui o l e s i t sco t ...Openco t havelm is, Howa dha r c t m ....H owa dwilbepr cl n hi ur. urs i t and r s ea hed he r l e udedfom flng r ii a ohe lws ii ti c u t ndisajmcsu tl eh sa v n ewrt np r sino tij d ea du tl eh s n t ra utn hs o r a t dt t nih a d a c ie emiso f hs u g n nih a t ma eg o -at p y nso hi c s a dsncin o iain h r a di tec u t fa pe l.) d o dfi a me t n s o t n a t s bl to s ee n n h o r o p ash. h o g ' 2I i notw holy ce whehe H owa di ende t na eW a hi t n Couny,V igi a i t ss t The ts l lar t r r nt d o m s ng o t r ni n hi ui. ca in ofHowa d' compl ntlssû ngdonV igi ai W as ngt Couny'ast s epa t a Howa dhas pto r s ai it t Abi r ni n hi on t ' he ol ry, nd r nota e dhi compli .H o e ,i a r t Howa date ptd t s r W as ngt Count byha m nde s ant w ver t ppea s hat r tm e o e ve hi on y nddelve i as i rng umm onst t W as ngt Coun yCo m isone ofReve o he hi on t m si r nue.Co e f rW as ngt Co t ha uns l o hi on uny s m a as cila a a et i or Howa dandt c tha i Howa d i fcti e de pe a ppe r nc o nf m r he our t t f r n a ntndedt s t c y,s vc o ue he ount er ie o po eswa n n o la twi F d rl l o CiiPo e ue4j( )a dVigni Co ej8013 02.S eF d. f rc s s o c mpin t e ea Rue f vl rc d r ()2 n r i a d . -0 . e e h R. v P. j()A)( Ct sae amu cp l op rto , r n oh rsaece tdg v r me tl r a iain Ci. 4()2 ( -B) A tt, niia c r oain o a y te tt-rae o en na o g nz to ta i sbe tos imu t esr e b :A) eieigac p o tes mmo sa do tec mpan t i c if h ts u jc t ut s b ev d y ( d l rn o y fh u n n f h o lito t he v s e e uieo scr o ( sr igac p o e c i tema n rpe cie b ta sae' 1w frsrigas mmo s x c tv f e; r B) evn o y f a h n h n e rsrb d y h t tt s a o evn u n o I epo eso sc ad fn a t'; r i aCo ej80 -0 2(e urn sr ieo pocs o teCo ny r i rc s n u h ee d n.lVigni d .13 0. rq iig e vc f r es n h u t k ' Aton yo Co n at sAton y.Wh me e Ho r itn e t s e hic mpan sae nocam a ant tr e r mmo we l h' tre ) o v r wad ne d d o u , s o lit tts li g is a pa t ny ry. t r pond ha e a e a t ma tri rpef rde ii Viwi Ho a d' compl nti t o es s lps d, nd he te s i o cson. e ng w r s ai n he lghtm os f vor e t hi , he co ti wholy una e t di c n a pl i e cl i t r le a i t a abl o m t ur s l bl o s er aus bl a m o e i f nd 3 wilh r fr ds s t i ma trwih u p eu ie l teeo e imis h s t t o t rj dc . e Fe rlRul ofCi lPr ed e8()2)rquiesats t ndpli sae ntoft cai dea e vi oc ur a( e r çhor a an ttme he l m s ngt tt pl de i e ildt rlef' Fed. Ci P.8a( .Thi fmiirr l i howi ha he ea r s ntte o ei . ' R. v. ()2) s a la ue s gr a l r l xe f pr sepl ntfs a ltga t wih me iorouscl m ss d notbe sym id e ty e a d oç o ai if, nd ii n s t rt i ai houl t e bytcmia r e ofpl di Se Be udetv. t ofHn on,775F. 1 1 e l c l uls ea ng. e a t Civ mpt 2d 274, 277-78(t 4h Ci.1 5) Ther a tonofRul 8()2)i nothowe , t tlmis.A co tmus bea e r 98 . elxai e a( s , verwihou i t ur t bl t di c r f om t com pl ntt pa te be ng s d a t a l ed c o s e n r he ai he r i s i ue nd he leg onduc on whi h e h c ai t c ac l m r s s Tho h r l xed,t s a r s ilde a ge r c r nc and i do no r quie et. ug e a he t nda d tl m nds ne al ohe e e, t es t e r c u t Eoc n u eu q e to sn v rs u rl p e e tdt te ' l a 1 7 o rs d o j r p u sin e e q aey r sn e o h m. d. t 2 8. t ' I hi c pl i ,H ow a d ha a t m pt t de c i Abi n s om a nt r s te ed o s r be ngdon' a l ge w r s le d ongsaga ns a i t n l rofAbi n r sde s Among ot t ngs hem e i Abi lmbe ngdo e i nt . her hi , ntons ngdon' r t lai f a s e ai ton or n ol un i wae bil aneghbor d, pad tr l; i hood E ra n byt Ciy a Count t e ur t t s tke ove he t nd y o ns e ha m i ii s no l ra e t prm a y ow ne s ofs d pr pe tes' a l c ofr m a n e nc norte onge r he i r r ai o r i '; a k oad i t na e; w r ulc l c i ofpr r y t xe ;z ng;s i lc tons s op a f i ks na i ongf ole ton ope t a s oni oc a ondii ' t nd r s ; tonhood; , e lpr e i a ag di c i i ton. Atno poi , qua ot cton; nd e s r m na i nt howe r doe H o ar a s m bl a ve , s w d s e e c he e cli t r le .Notonl i i difc tt a c rai t lgalt ore on whih Howa d o r nt am o e if y s t fi ul o s e t n he e he i s c r r les i i i ei ,t s mpos i et gl n f c ua s sbl o ea a t l uppor f a s h lga t ore . W hiet plad ng t or ny uc e l he i s l he e i r l sd noti ue o mpos a exa tng sa r on Howa d, m us ofe s m ef hol on whi h e n c i tnda d r he t f r o oot d c 3 s rieaRue1 ( ()moin tepedigmutc nançn u hfcst saeacam t rl fh t To u vv l 2b)6 t ,h la n s o ti ç o g a t o tt li o ei ta o e e i pa sbl o i fc . Bel lCop. Two l 5 0U. 5 4 5 0( 0 ) ctto o t d.Co t mu t s lu i e n t a e' lAt. l v. mbv, 5 S. 4 , 7 20 7 (iain mit ) m' s s ' e s l eal c nsrerr s c mpans Erc s nv. r u , 51U. 8 , 4(0 7, nda c p tecama tsfcu l i r l o tu o e o lit, ik o Pad e 5 S. 9 9 2 0 )a ce th li n ' ata b y alg to sa tu .He Gru . v. t o N. ,l 0S Ct9 3 9 6 8 ( 0.Ho v rti tn ti le ain s r e mi o p LLC Civ f Y. 3 . . 8 , 8 - 7 201 ) we e,hs e e s tna ia et lgalc usons Thr dba er ial oft elme sofaca eofa ton,s < pplc bl o e oncl i . ea r ect s he e nt i us ci upporedbyme e t r c n ls r sae ns d n tsfke' As cot .q a,5 6U. 6 2, 7 (0 9 . o cu oy ttme t, o o u f . h rf v Ib l 5 S. 6 6 8 2 0 ) ' 2 Abn d n c nb s a a s ro o wh c tec u t a b s aj g n .Ac o dn l ,h c u t ig o a a e n n we r n ih h o r c n a e ud me t c r ig y t e o r wilds s Howad' comp1i wihoutprj c f fiur t saeac1i 4 l imis rs ant t eudie or al e o tt am. EN TER :Se e be 1 201 pt m r 9, 2. / < UN I TED STA TES DISTR I J DG E CT U 4Thecour dipe esw ih o alagum e be aus t fct a lgalc e i ar ade t yprs ntd t s ns t r r nt c e he a s nd e ontntons e quael e e e i temaeil b fr t c u ta ag me t udn tadted cso a po es S eLo a Rul 1 ()Ct n h tras eo e he o r, nd ru n wo l o i h e iin l rc s. e c l e lb l n a c r a c wihFe e a Rul o Ci iPr c d r 7 ( ) t Co r ma d tr n amo in wih u a o a c o d n e t d r l e f vl o e u e 8 b ,he u t y ee mi e t o to t n rl h aig'. e rn .) '
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
