County of Harris, Texas v. Eli Lilly And Company et al, No. 4:2019cv04994 - Document 66 (S.D. Tex. 2020)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM AND ORDER GRANTING IN PART DENYING IN PART 41 MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM (on behalf of PBM Defendants), 40 MOTION to Dismiss 20 Amended Complaint/Counterclaim/Crossclaim etc. (Signed by Judge Gray H Miller) Parties notified.(rkonieczny, 4)

Download PDF

County of Harris, Texas v. Eli Lilly And Company et al Doc. 66 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 1 of 43 =74<10 ;<-<1; 04;<:4/< /8=:< ;8=<31:7 04;<:4/< 82 <1?-; 38=;<87 04>4;487 =!++%, 8).(-1' H$0!,' <QFNSYNKK' f) :&% A%&&1 !(# 8)'*!(1 JY FQ)' 0JKJSIFSYX) k k k k k k k k k 8%/%& 6"-%)( =(+3(.33. 6$)+-!*#0) 8,&*&+* !*# " !" EU^TY^W RUV_bU dXU S_ebd QbU dg_ ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc)! 9[dc) .*' .+) 9UVU^TQ^dc :¥Y AY¥¥i Q^T 8_]`Q^i' C_f_ C_bTYc[ >^S)' Q^T GQ^_VY(6fU^dYc I)G) AA8 $S_¥¥USdYfU¥i' dXU nBQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dco% ]_fUT cU`QbQdU¥i Vb_] dXU `XQb]QSi RU^UVYd ]Q^QWUb TUVU^TQ^dc $S_¥¥USdYfU¥i' dXU nE7B 9UVU^TQ^dco%) 5I( E¥QY^dYVV =QbbYc 8_e^di bUc`_^TUT Z_Y^d¥i d_ R_dX ]_dY_^c) 9[d) .2) HXU TUVU^TQ^dc bU`¥YUT) 9[dc) 0+' 0,) =QfY^W S_^cYTUbUT dXU ]_dY_^c' bUc`_^cUc' bU`¥YUc' Q^T Q``¥YSQR¥U ¥Qg' dXU S_ebd Yc _V dXU _`Y^Y_^ dXQd R_dX ]_dY_^c $9[dc) .*' .+% cX_e¥T RU <F6CH:9 Y^ E6FH Q^T 9:C>:9 Y^ E6FH) 4$ .!"'%-+0*# E¥QY^dYVV =QbbYc 8_e^di $n=QbbYc 8_e^dio% Yc Q nR_Ti S_b`_bQdU Q^T `_¥YdYS e^TUb dXU ¥Qgc _V dXU GdQdU _V HUhQc)o" 9[d) ,* Qd 1) HXU W_fUb^]U^d _V =QbbYc 8_e^di cUbfUc ^UQb¥i VYfU ]Y¥¥Y_^ bUcYTU^dc) 5I( =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥c_ `b_fYTUc XUQ¥dX RU^UVYdc d_ Q``b_hY]QdU¥i -2'*** U]`¥_iUUc' bUdYbUUc' Q^T dXUYb TU`U^TU^dc $n7U^UVYSYQbYUco%) 5I( D^U _V dXU RU^UVYdc =QbbYc 8_e^di _VVUbc 7_dX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc bUaeUcdUT _bQ¥ QbWe]U^d) =_gUfUb' dXU S_ebd VY^Tc dXQd Q^ _bQ¥ XUQbY^W Yc e^^USUccQbi) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXUcU bUaeUcdc QbU 9:C>:9) " I^TUb ;UTUbQ¥ Fe¥U _V 8YfY¥ Eb_SUTebU +,$R%$0%' dXU S_ebd QSSU`dc =QbbYc 8_e^diqc Q¥¥UWQdY_^c Qc dbeU) >JJ AZQHFS 9FYJWNFQX /T( [( /NY^ TK ?JMZFHFSF' ,-2 ;)-T -2,' -21 $/dX 8Yb) ,**+%) ! Dockets.Justia.com Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 2 of 43 7U^UVYSYQbYUc Yc ceRcYTYjY^W dXUYb `ebSXQcUc _V ^USUccQbi `XQb]QSUedYSQ¥ TbeWc' Y^S¥eTY^W TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c ¥Y[U Y^ce¥Y^) 5I( =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥c_ `Qic V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c V_b Y^]QdUc Y^ Ydc S_e^di ZQY¥c) 5I( HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc ]Q^eVQSdebU' `b_]_dU' Q^T TYcdbYRedU `XQb]QSUedYSQ¥ TbeWc' Y^S¥eTY^W TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Q^T dXU Y^ce¥Y^c Qd YcceU Y^ dXYc SQcU) 5I( Qd 2l++) H_WUdXUb' dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc n]Q[U 33" _V dXU Y^ce¥Y^c Y^ dXU ]Qb[Ud d_TQi)o 5I( Qd ,1) G`USYVYSQ¥¥i' :¥Y AY¥¥i ]Q^eVQSdebUc' `b_]_dUc' Q^T cU¥¥c =e]e¥Y^ C' =e]e¥Y^ F' =e]Q¥_W' Hbe¥YSYdi' Q^T 7QcQW¥Qb) 5I( Qd 2) GQ^_VY(6fU^dYc I)G) AA8 ]Q^eVQSdebUc' `b_]_dUc' Q^T cU¥¥c AQ^dec' H_eZU_' G_¥YaeQ' Q^T 6`YTbQ) 5I( Qd 3) C_f_ C_bTYc[ >^S) ]Q^eVQSdebUc' `b_]_dUc' Q^T cU¥¥c C_f_¥Y^ F' C_f_¥Y^ C' C_f_¥_W' AUfU]Yb' HbUcYRQ' JYSd_jQ' Q^T DjU]`YS) 5I( Qd +*) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbU ^Q]UT Y^ dXUYb SQ`QSYdYUc Qc R_dX `XQb]QSi RU^UVYd ]Q^QWUbc Q^T ]QY¥(_bTUb `XQb]QSYUc gXYSX nTYc`U^cUNO TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c' Y^S¥eTY^W TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Qd YcceU Y^ dXYc NSQcUO ) ) ) dXb_eWX NdXUYb ]QY¥(_bTUbO `XQb]QSYUc)o 5I( Qd +/' +2' ,*l,+) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc n_g^ N]QY¥(_bTUbO Q^T c`USYQ¥di `XQb]QSYUc' gXYSX `ebSXQcU Q^T dQ[U `_ccUccY_^ _V `bUcSbY`dY_^ TbeWc' Y^S¥eTY^W dX_cU Qd YcceU XUbU' Q^T TYbUSd¥i ce``¥i dX_cU TbeWc d_ `QdYU^dc Ri ]QY¥)o 5I( Qd .,) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QT]Y^YcdUb XUQ¥dX `¥Q^cq `bUcSbY`dY_^ TbeW `b_WbQ]c Ri nTUfU¥_`NY^WO dXU XUQ¥dX `¥Q^qc TbeW V_b]e¥Qbi' `b_SUccNY^WO S¥QY]c' SbUQdNY^WO Q ^Udg_b[ _V bUdQY¥ `XQb]QSYUc' NQ^TO cUdNdY^WO dXU `bYSUc dXQd dXU XUQ¥dX `¥Q^ gY¥¥ `Qi V_b `bUcSbY`dY_^ TbeWc ) ) ) )o 5I( Qd .+l.,) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ S_^dbQSd gYdX ]Q^eVQSdebUbc d_ n^UW_dYQdU bURQdUc' VUUc Q^T _dXUb S_^SUccY_^c gYdX dXU ]Q^eVQSdebUbc dXQd QbU `QYT RQS[ d_ dXU E7BNcO)o 5I( >d Yc dXUcU bURQdUc dXQd QbU Qd dXU SU^dUb _V dXYc SQcU) 6SS_bTY^W d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di' dXU `bYSUc _V c`USYVYS Y^ce¥Y^c XQfU TbQcdYSQ¥¥i Y^SbUQcUT _fUb dXU `Qcd VYVdUU^ iUQbc' Q^T dXQd Y^SbUQcU SQ^^_d RU QSS_e^dUT V_b `bY]QbY¥i RUSQecU _V Y^V¥QdY_^ _b , Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 3 of 43 _dXUb ]Qb[Ud V_bSUc) 5I( Qd ,1l-3) HXU `b_TeSdY_^ S_cdc V_b Y^ce¥Y^ XQfU TUSbUQcUT' Q^T ndXU Y^ce¥Y^c Qd YcceU Y^ dXYc SQcU XQfU UYdXUb RUU^ QfQY¥QR¥U Y^ dXU cQ]U V_b]o V_b dgU^di d_ dXYbdi iUQbc _b QbU nRY_¥_WYSQ¥¥i UaeYfQ¥U^do d_ Y^ce¥Y^c gXYSX gUbU QfQY¥QR¥U dgU^di d_ dXYbdi iUQbc QW_) 5I( Qd ,2) ;_b UhQ]`¥U' Vb_] ,**1 d_ ,*+2' C_f_ C_bTYc[ bQYcUT dXU `bYSU _V C_f_¥_W Ri _fUb !/**) 5I( Qd -.) GY^SU ,**2' :¥Y AY¥¥i XQc Y^SbUQcUT dXU `bYSU V_b Q `QS[QWU _V =e]Q¥_W `U^c Ri _fUb !.**) 5I( Qd -,) 6c Q bUce¥d _V dXU Q¥¥UWUT `bYSU Y^SbUQcUc' nQc ]Q^i Qc _^U Y^ V_eb `U_`¥U gYdX TYQRUdUc QbU ^_g c[Y]`Y^W _^ _b c[Y``Y^W ¥YVUcQfY^W T_cUco _V Y^ce¥Y^' Q^T XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c QbU c`U^TY^W ndU^c _V RY¥¥Y_^c _V T_¥¥Qbco _^ TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c) 5I( Qd -+' -0) ;b_] ,*+- d_ ,*+2' =QbbYc 8_e^di S¥QY]c dXQd Yd c`U^d _fUb !,1'***'*** _^ dXU Qd(YcceU TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c) 9[d) ,*(+) =QbbYc 8_e^di S_^dU^Tc dXQd dXUcU `bYSU Y^SbUQcUc QbU dXU bUce¥d _V `eb`_cUVe¥ Q^dYS_]`UdYdYfU RUXQfY_b5 Yd Q¥¥UWUc dXQd Yd XQc RUU^ VbQeTe¥U^d¥i _fUbSXQbWUT Q^T XQc _fUb`QYT V_b dXU Qd(YcceU ]UTYSQdY_^c RUSQecU dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i bQYcU dXU `bYSUc _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Y^ gXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di SQ¥¥c dXU n>^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U)o 9[d) ,* Qd .2) >^ dXU Q¥¥UWUT >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U' nNdXUO BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU QWbUUT gYdX UQSX _dXUb Q^T NdXUO E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ bQYcU dXUYb `eR¥YS¥i bU`_bdUT `bYSUc ) ) ) Red ¥QbWU¥i ]QY^dQY^ dXU ^Ud `bYSU N_V UQSX TbeWO Ri `QiY^W Q cYW^YVYSQ^d `_bdY_^ _V dXNUO `bYSU RQS[ d_ NdXUO E7B 9UVU^TQ^dco Y^ dXU V_b] _V bURQdUc Q^T VUUc) 5I( Qd /*) HXU nBQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU Uh`_^U^dYQ¥¥i bQYcUT dXU bU`_bdUT `bYSUc _V Y^ce¥Y^ `b_TeSdc Y^ ^UQb `UbVUSd e^Yc_^'o Red dXUYb ^Ud `bYSU XQc ^_d Y^SbUQcUT RUSQecU dXU UhdbQ ]_^Ui Q¥¥UWUT¥i W_Uc d_ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Qc bURQdUc) 5I( Qd -3) >^ UhSXQ^WU V_b dXU bURQdUc' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc `b_fYTU `bUVUbbUT `¥QSU]U^d Qd dXU XYWXUcd Y^V¥QdUT `bYSU _V dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dcq TbeWc _^ TbeW V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc) 5I( Qd /) HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc S_e¥T `_dU^dYQ¥¥i ¥_cU RY¥¥Y_^c _V T_¥¥Qbc YV dXUYb TbeWc QbU ^_d Y^S¥eTUT _^ V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc RUSQecU dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU Q T_]Y^Q^d - Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 4 of 43 ]Qb[Ud cXQbU Q^T UccU^dYQ¥¥i QSd Qc WQdU[UU`Ubc Y^ TUdUb]Y^Y^W ngXYSX TbeWc Y^cebQ^SU _b XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c gY¥¥ `Qi V_b Q^T Qd gXQd bQdU)o 5I( Qd .3) >^ cX_bd' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU QWbUUT gYdX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ `eb`_cUVe¥¥i Y^V¥QdU dXU bU`_bdUT `bYSUc _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c gXY¥U bUVe^TY^W Q ¥QbWU `_bdY_^ _V dXU `bYSU _V UQSX e^Yd c_¥T RQS[ d_ dXU E7Bc Y^ dXU V_b] _V bURQdUc Q^T QT]Y^YcdbQdYfU VUUc Y^ Q VZNI UWT VZT d_ `ebSXQcU `bUVUbbUT V_b]e¥Qbi `_cYdY_^) 5I( Qd /+) 6TTYdY_^Q¥¥i' QSS_bTY^W d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di' dXU WQ` RUdgUU^ dXU bU`_bdUT `bYSU Q^T dXU ^Ud `bYSU _V dXU Qd(YcceU ]UTYSQdY_^c SbUQdUc Q n]QccYfU c¥ecX Ve^To gXYSX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc dXU^ ecU d_ nUhdbQSd XYTTU^ `b_VYdco Vb_] _dXUbc' Y^S¥eTY^W XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c ¥Y[U =QbbYc 8_e^diqc) 5I( Qd /*) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥¥UWUT¥i RU^UVYd Vb_] dXU >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U Y^ cUfUbQ¥ TYVVUbU^d gQic) 5I( Qd /0) HXUi Q¥¥UWUT¥i [UU` ncYW^YVYSQ^d `_bdY_^c _V dXU `Qi]U^dc ]QTU Ri NdXUO BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dco d_ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ Rei `bUVUbbUT `¥QSU]U^d _^ V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc Y^ gXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di SQ¥¥c dXU nGUSbUd EQi]U^d <Q]U)o 5I( HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUT¥i SXQbWU XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c ¥Y[U =QbbYc 8_e^diqc V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c RQcUT _^ dXU Y^V¥QdUT bU`_bdUT `bYSUc) 5I( HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc dXU^ cU`QbQdU¥i ^UW_dYQdU gYdX `XQb]QSYUc d_ bUY]RebcU dXU] Qd Q ¥_gUb `bYSU dXQ^ dXU Y^V¥QdUT bU`_bdUT `bYSUc gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUT¥i `Qic V_b dXU cQ]U ]UTYSQdY_^) 5I( HXU^ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥¥UWUT¥i `_S[Ud dXU TYVVUbU^SU RUdgUU^ dXU Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc =QbbYc 8_e^di `Qic V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Q^T dXU ¥_gUb `bYSUc Qd gXYSX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc bUY]RebcU `XQb]QSYUc V_b dXU cQ]U ]UTYSQdY_^c' gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ¥QRU¥UT dXU nEXQb]QSi G`bUQT)o 5I( 6TTYdY_^Q¥¥i' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥¥UWUT¥i ecU dXU Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c d_ Y^SbUQcU dXUYb _g^ `b_VYdc _^ TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c dXUi cU¥¥ dXb_eWX dXUYb _g^ ]QY¥(_bTUb `XQb]QSYUc) 5I( . Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 5 of 43 =QbbYc 8_e^di ^UW_dYQdUT S_^dbQSd `b_fYcY_^c Y^ S_^dbQSdc gYdX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc gXYSX bUaeYbUT dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ `Qi dXU] Q `_bdY_^ _V dXU bURQdUc _^ dXU Qd(YcceU ]UTYSQdY_^c' Red dXU^ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥¥UWUT¥i bU¥QRU¥UT dXU bURQdUc gYdX fQWeU dUb]c ¥Y[U nQT]Y^YcdbQdYfU VUUc' f_¥e]U TYcS_e^dc' cUbfYSU VUUc' NQ^TO `bYSU _b ]QbWY^ WeQbQ^dUUco c_ dXQd dXUi S_e¥T [UU` ]_bU _V dXU bURQdU ]_^Ui V_b dXU]cU¥fUc) 5I( Qd /1) ;_b UhQ]`¥U' :h`bUcc GSbY`dc Q¥¥UWUT¥i [UU`c e` d_ dXYbdUU^ dY]Uc ]_bU Y^ nQT]Y^YcdbQdYfU VUUco dXQ^ Yd `Qic d_ XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c Qc `Qbd _V dXU bURQdU cicdU]) 5I( Qd /2) 6SS_bTY^W d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq Q¥¥UWUT RUXQfY_b Yc `QbdYSe¥Qb¥i db_eR¥Y^W RUSQecU dXUi Q¥¥UWUT¥i ]YcbU`bUcU^dUT d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di dXQd dXUi g_e¥T ecU dXUYb ]Qb[Ud `_gUb Q^T Uh`UbdYcU d_ ^UW_dYQdU gYdX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ cQfU =QbbYc 8_e^di ]_^Ui _^ TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c) 5I( Qd 0+) HXUi Q¥c_ S¥QY]UT dXQd dXUi gUbU WYfY^W bURQdUc d_ XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c ¥Y[U =QbbYc 8_e^diqc Y^ Q dbQ^c`QbU^d `Qi]U^d cdbeSdebU gXU^ dXUi gUbU Y^cdUQT Q¥¥UWUT¥i [UU`Y^W ]_cd _V dX_cU bURQdUc) 5I( Qd 0/) ;_b UhQ]`¥U' Y^ Q^ Y^dUbfYUg gYdX 87G CUgc Y^ ,*+1' dXU 8:D _V :h`bUcc GSbY`dc cQYT dXQd dXUYb bURQdU Q^T `Qi]U^d cdbeSdebUc QbU dbQ^c`QbU^d Q^T dXQd dXUYb S¥YU^dc [^_g `bUSYcU¥i X_g bURQdUc Vb_] dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc QbU TYcdbYRedUT' gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^di S¥QY]c Yc e^dbeU) 5I( Qd 0/) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ S¥QY]UT dXQd dXUi SX_cU TbeWc V_b V_b]e¥Qbi `¥QSU]U^d RQcUT `bY]QbY¥i _^ dXUYb XUQ¥dX Q^T cQVUdim^_d _^ dXU Q]_e^dc _V bURQdUc dXUi bUSUYfUT Vb_] dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc) 5I( Qd 0+) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc ]QTU dXUcU ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^c c`USYVYSQ¥¥i c_ dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di g_e¥T bU¥i _^ dXU ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^c Q^T `Qi dXU Y^V¥QdUT bU`_bdUT `bYSUc V_b dXU Qd(YcceU ]UTYSQdY_^c) 5I( / Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 6 of 43 =QbbYc 8_e^di VY¥UT ceYd Q¥¥UWY^W ]e¥dY`¥U dXU_bYUc _V ¥YQRY¥Ydi)# 7_dX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc ebWU dXU S_ebd d_ TYc]Ycc 8_e^dc D^U' Hg_' HXbUU' Q^T ;_eb _V =QbbYc 8_e^diqc S_]`¥QY^d' gXYSX Q¥¥UWU fY_¥QdY_^c _V dXU FQS[UdUUb >^V¥eU^SUT Q^T 8_bbe`d DbWQ^YjQdY_^c 6Sd' +2 I)G)8) kk +30+l+302 $nF>8Do%) 9[dc) .*' .+) 7_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ Qc[ dXU S_ebd d_ TYc]Ycc =QbbYc 8_e^diqc cdQdU ¥Qg S¥QY]c Y^ 8_e^dc GUfU^' :YWXd' CY^U' HU^' Q^T :¥UfU^)$ 9[dc) .*' .+) 44$ 5$%!( ;/!*#!-# -$ :SKD %&!A"!*" n;UTUbQ¥ Fe¥U _V 8YfY¥ Eb_SUTebU 2$Q%$,% bUaeYbUc _^¥i pQ cX_bd Q^T `¥QY^ cdQdU]U^d _V dXU S¥QY] cX_gY^W dXQd dXU `¥UQTUb Yc U^dYd¥UT d_ bU¥YUV)qo .JQQ -YQ( /TWU( [( ?¥TRGQ^' //* I)G) /..' ///' +,1 G) 8d) +3// $,**1%) 6d dXU `¥UQTY^W cdQWU' dXU S_ebd ]ecd nQSSU`d Q¥¥ gU¥¥(`¥UQTUT VQSdc Y^ dXU S_]`¥QY^d Qc dbeU Q^T fYUg dXU VQSdc Y^ dXU ¥YWXd ]_cd VQf_bQR¥U d_ dXU `¥QY^dYVV)o ;a0FSNJQ [( 5SIZX( >JW[( >TQX(' 3,, ;)-T ,33' -*. $/dX 8Yb) ,*+3%) nB_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc QbU fYUgUT gYdX HXU S_ebd T_Uc ^_d QTTbUcc 8_e^dc ;YfU Q^T GYh RUSQecU =QbbYc 8_e^di Qc[UT dXU S_ebd d_ TYc]Ycc dX_cU SQecUc _V QSdY_^ gYdX_ed `bUZeTYSU) 9[d) .2 Qd . ^)-) 9UVU^TQ^dc T_ ^_d _``_cU TYc]YccQ¥ _V dX_cU S¥QY]c) 5I( 6SS_bTY^W¥i' =QbbYc 8_e^diqc bUaeUcd d_ TYc]Ycc 8_e^dc ;YfU Q^T GYh gYdX_ed `bUZeTYSU Yc <F6CH:9) $ >^ Q V__d^_dU' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Qc[ dXU S_ebd d_ TYc]Ycc dXU `QbU^d S_]`Q^YUc _V dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc' Q¥¥UWY^W dXQd dXU `QbU^d S_]`Q^YUc gUbU _^¥i ^Q]UT nY^ dXUYb SQ`QSYdi Qc S_b`_bQdU `QbU^dc)o 9[d) .+ Qd +,) 6bWe]U^dc bQYcUT _^¥i Y^ Q V__d^_dU ]Qi RU gQYfUT) >JJ @SNYJI >YFYJX [( 4FWIRFS' ,31 ;)-T +++0' ++-+ $+*dX 8Yb) ,**,% $n6bWe]U^dc bQYcUT Y^ Q `UbVe^Sd_bi ]Q^^Ub' ceSX Qc Y^ Q V__d^_dU' QbU gQYfUT)o%5 @SNYJI >YFYJX [( BMNYJ' 213 ;),T +/*3' +/+- $1dX 8Yb) +323% $nN7Oi VQY¥Y^W d_ bQYcU dXYc YcceU _dXUb dXQ^ Ri Q `QccY^W bUVUbU^SU Y^ Q V__d^_dU' NdXU `¥QY^dYVVO XQc gQYfUT Yd)o%5 .WFSHM [( /191C& 5SH(' C_) 8>J)6) =(++(+3/-' ,*+, KA ,-/1,2*' Qd &+, ^)2 $G)9) HUh) ?e^U ,*' ,*+,% $^_dY^W dXQd QbWe]U^dc dXQd QbU ^_d `b_`Ub¥i QTTbUccUT Y^ dXU R_Ti _V Q RbYUV QbU ¥Y[U¥i gQYfUT%) GdY¥¥' dXU S_ebd QTTbUccUc dXU QbWe]U^d _^ Ydc ]UbYdc' Q¥RUYd Y^ Q V__d^_dU) =QbbYc 8_e^di S_^dU^Tc dXQd dXU U^dYdYUc gXYSX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Qc[ dXU S_ebd d_ TYc]Ycc ngUbU TYbUSd¥i Y^f_¥fUT Y^ dXU E7B QSdYfYdYUc dXQd WQfU bYcU d_ =QbbYc 8_e^diqc SQecUc _V QSdY_^)o 9[d) .2 Qd ,25 9[d) ,* Qd +-l,*) HXec' dXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc dXUcU TUVU^TQ^dc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T Yc 9:C>:9) 0 # Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 7 of 43 TYcVQf_b Q^T QbU bQbU¥i WbQ^dUT)o ?JXY 9FXYJWX 1IZH( >JW[X(& 5SH( [( >NSLM' .,2 ;)-T //3' /1* $/dX 8Yb) ,**/%) >^ S_^cYTUbY^W Q ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc' eceQ¥¥i dXU S_ebd n]Qi bU¥i _^ _^¥i dXU S_]`¥QY^d Q^T Ydc `b_`Ub QddQSX]U^dc)o 0TWXJ^ [( <TWYKTQNT 1VZNYNJX& 5SH(' /.* ;)-T ---' --2 $/dX 8Yb) ,**2%) .$ :SKD ,!A" ;UTUbQ¥ Fe¥U _V 8YfY¥ Eb_SUTebU 3$R% bUaeYbUc Q `Qbdi Q¥¥UWY^W VbQeT d_ cdQdU gYdX `QbdYSe¥QbYdi dXU SYbSe]cdQ^SUc S_^cdYdedY^W VbQeT) BNQQNFRX [( B9C ?JHMX(& 5SH(' ++, ;)-T +1/' +11 $/dX 8Yb) +331%) HXU ;YVdX 8YbSeYd Y^dUb`bUdc Fe¥U 3$R% cdbYSd¥i5 d_ `¥UQT Q VbQeT S¥QY] gYdX dXU bUaeYcYdU `QbdYSe¥QbYdi bUaeYbUc dXQd dXU ngX_' gXQd' gXU^' Q^T gXUbU ]ecd RU ¥QYT _ed GJKTWJ QSSUcc d_ dXU TYcS_fUbi `b_SUcc Yc WbQ^dUT)o 5I( Qd +12) =_gUfUb' Fe¥U 3$R% ]ecd RU Q``¥YUT nQc `Qbd _V dXU U^dYbU cUd _V be¥Uc' Y^S¥eTY^W Fe¥U 2$Q%qc Y^cYcdU^SU e`_^ pcY]`¥U' S_^SYcU' Q^T TYbUSdq Q¥¥UWQdY_^c)o 5I( 8_ebdc cX_e¥T Q¥c_ S_^cYTUb ndXU RUQS_^ _V Fe¥U 2$V% dXQd pQ¥¥ `¥UQTY^Wc cXQ¥¥ RU S_^cdbeUT Qc d_ T_ ceRcdQ^dYQ¥ ZecdYSU)qo 5I( E¥QY^dYVVc ]ecd RU WYfU^ Q nVQYb _``_bde^Ydi d_ `¥UQT)o 5I( 444$ -*!(1.&. -$ :4/8 /K@HLQ GUSdY_^ +30.$S% _V +2 I)G)8) `b_fYTUc Q `bYfQdU SYfY¥ QSdY_^ Q^T dbUR¥U TQ]QWUc V_b dX_cU gX_ QbU Y^ZebUT Ri fY_¥QdY_^c _V F>8Dqc ceRcdQ^dYfU `b_fYcY_^c) >JINRF& >(<(=(8( [( 5RWJ] /T(& 5SH(' .1- I)G) .13' .2+' +*/ G) 8d) -,1/ $+32/%) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ fY_¥QdU k +30,$S%' gXYSX g_e¥T Q¥c_ RU Q fY_¥QdY_^ _V k +30,$T%qc `b_XYRYdY_^ _^ S_^c`YbY^W d_ fY_¥QdU F>8D) 9[d) ,* Qd 10l+,0) 7_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di T_Uc ^_d XQfU cdQ^TY^W d_ RbY^W Q F>8D S¥QY] RUSQecU Yd Yc RQbbUT Ri dXU nY^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUbo be¥U QbdYSe¥QdUT Y^ 5QQNSTNX .WNHP Q^T dXQd dXU S_( 1 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 8 of 43 S_^c`YbQd_b UhSU`dY_^ d_ dXU nY^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUbo be¥U Yc Y^Q``¥YSQR¥U XUbU)% 9[dc) .*' .+ $SYdY^W 5QQ( .WNHP /T( [( 5QQNSTNX' .-+ I)G) 1,*' 31 G) 8d) ,*0+ $+311%%) HXU TUVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc VQY¥UT d_ Q¥¥UWU Ydc F>8D S¥QY]c gYdX dXU `QbdYSe¥QbYdi bUaeYbUT V_b Q¥¥UWQdY_^c _V VbQeT Ri ;UTUbQ¥ Fe¥U _V 8YfY¥ Eb_SUTebU 3$R%' Y^S¥eTY^W Q¥¥UWQdY_^c _V VbQeT e^TUb F>8D) 9[dc) .*' .+) 6TTYdY_^Q¥¥i' dXU TUVU^TQ^dc Q¥¥UWU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d ceVVYSYU^d¥i Q¥¥UWUT dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc _`UbQdUT _b ]Q^QWUT Q^i F>8D U^dUb`bYcUc _b dXQd TUVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ fY_¥QdU F>8D) 9[dc) .*' .+) AQcd¥i' dXU TUVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d Q¥¥UWUT dXQd Ydc Y^ZebYUc gUbU `b_hY]QdU¥i SQecUT Ri Q F>8D fY_¥QdY_^ _b S_^c`YbQSi' gXYSX Yc bUaeYbUT d_ UcdQR¥YcX cdQ^TY^W e^TUb F>8D) 9[dc) .*' .+5 XJJ <WNHJ [( <NSSFHQJ .WFSIX& 5SH(' +-2 ;)-T 0*,' 0*0 $/dX 8Yb) +332%) H_ cdQdU Q F>8D S¥QY] e^TUb k +30,$S% bUaeYbUc Q `¥QY^dYVV d_ Q¥¥UWU n$+% S_^TeSd $,% _V Q^ U^dUb`bYcU $-% dXb_eWX Q `QddUb^ $.% _V bQS[UdUUbY^W QSdYfYdi)o >JINRF' .1- I)G) Qd .30) GUSdY_^ +30,$T% `b_XYRYdc S_^c`YbY^W d_ fY_¥QdU F>8D) +2 I)G)8) k +30,$T%) nF>8D Yc d_ RU bUQT Rb_QT¥io c_ Qc d_ TUdUb `_dU^dYQ¥ fY_¥Qd_bc) >JINRF' .1- I)G) Qd .31) 6 F>8D `¥QY^dYVV ]ecd Q¥c_ UcdQR¥YcX cdQ^TY^W Ri Q¥¥UWY^W Y^Zebi Q^T SQecQdY_^) >JJ <WNHJ(' +-2 ;)-T Qd 0*05 5S WJ ?F]FGQJ 9ZS( .TSI >JH( 8NYNL(' /+ ;)-T /+2' /,+ $/dX 8Yb) +33/% $nHXU cdQ^TY^W `b_fYcY_^ _V SYfY¥ F>8D `b_fYTUc dXQd 8YdY^W SQcUc dXQd QbU ¥UWQ¥¥i Q^T VQSdeQ¥¥i TYcdY^WeYcXQR¥U Vb_] dXYc _^U' dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di SQ^^_d `b_SUUT gYdX Ydc F>8D S¥QY]c RUSQecU Yd RU^UVYddUT Vb_] Q^T `QbdYSY`QdUT Y^ dXU Q¥¥UWUT cSXU]U) 9[d) .* Qd ,3l-* $SYdY^W =JUZGQNH TK 5WFV [( -.. -3' 102 ;)-T +./' +01l02 $,T 8YbSeYd ,*+.%5 /JSHT 5SH( [( >JNIRFS " >JNIRFS' 020 ;),T ..3' ./. $1dX 8Yb) +32,%%) HXU S_ebd TUS¥Y^Uc d_ QTTbUcc dXYc QbWe]U^d RUSQecU gXUdXUb =QbbYc 8_e^di RU^UVYddUT Vb_] _b `QbdYSY`QdUT Y^ dXU Q¥¥UWUT cSXU]U Yc Q TYc`edUT aeUcdY_^ _V VQSd gXYSX Yc Y^Q``b_`bYQdU Qd dXYc cdQWU Y^ dXU ¥YdYWQdY_^) 6TSJX [( 3WJSNSLJW' +22 ;)-T -,,' -,. $/dX 8Yb) +333% $`Ub SebYQ]% $nHXU YcceU NTebY^W dXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc cdQWUO Yc ^_d gXUdXUb dXU `¥QY^dYVV gY¥¥ e¥dY]QdU¥i `bUfQY¥' Red gXUdXUb XU Yc U^dYd¥UT d_ _VVUb UfYTU^SU d_ ce``_bd XYc S¥QY])o%) 2 % Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 9 of 43 pNQO^i `Ubc_^ Y^ZebUT Y^ XYc RecY^Ucc _b `b_`Ubdi Ri bUQc_^ _V Q fY_¥QdY_^ _V cUSdY_^ +30, _V dXYc SXQ`dUb ]Qi ceU)qo $ae_dY^W +2 I)G)8) k +30.$S%%%) %$ :4/8 9PDCHB@RD -BRQ nHXU dUb] pbQS[UdUUbY^W QSdYfYdiq Yc TUVY^UT d_ Y^S¥eTU Q X_cd _V c_(SQ¥¥UT `bUTYSQdU QSdc'o Y^S¥eTY^W ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU VbQeT) .WNILJ [( <M]( .TSI " 5SIJR( /T(' //- I)G) 0-3' 0.1' +,2 G) 8d) ,+-+ $,**2% $ae_dY^W I)G)8) +2 k +30+%) nNKOYbU VbQeT Y^f_¥fUc dXU ecU _V' _b SQecY^W dXU ecU _V' gYbU S_]]e^YSQdY_^c Y^ VebdXUbQ^SU _V Q cSXU]U d_ TUVbQeT)o -QQXYFYJ 5SX( /T( [( <QFRGJHP' 2*, ;)-T 00/' 01/ $/dX 8Yb) ,*+/%) nHXU ]QY¥ VbQeT cdQdedU Q``¥YUc d_ Q^i_^U gX_ [^_gY^W¥i SQecUc d_ RU TU¥YfUbUT Ri ]QY¥ Q^idXY^W V_b dXU `eb`_cU _V UhUSedY^W Q^i cSXU]U _b QbdYVYSU d_ TUVbQeT)o 5I( $ae_dY^W @SNYJI >YFYJX [( BMNYKNJQI' /3* ;)-T -,/' -// $/dX 8Yb) ,**3%%) ;UTUbQ¥ Fe¥U _V 8YfY¥ Eb_SUTebU 3$R% bUaeYbUc `¥QY^dYVVc d_ `¥UQT VbQeT S¥QY]c gYdX `QbdYSe¥QbYdi Q^T Q``¥YUc d_ `¥QY^dYVVc `¥UQTY^W `bUTYSQdU QSdc V_b F>8D S¥QY]c nbUcdY^W _^ Q¥¥UWQdY_^c _V VbQeT)o BNQQNFRX' ++, ;)-T Qd +11) 7_dX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^dU^T dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d `¥UT Ydc VbQeT Q¥¥UWQdY_^c gYdX dXU bUaeYcYdU ¥UfU¥ _V `QbdYSe¥QbYdi' Red dXU S_ebd TYcQWbUUc)& =QbbYc 8_e^di _ed¥Y^Uc Ydc ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU VbQeT Q¥¥UWQdY_^c gYdX dXU bUaeYbUT ¥UfU¥ _V TUdQY¥ Qd dXYc cdQWU Y^ dXU ¥YdYWQdY_^ RUSQecU dXUi `b_fYTU dXU ngX_' gXQd' gXU^' Q^T gXUbUo _V dXU Q¥¥UWUT VbQeT) 7_dX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU d_ <TJ [( .THP V_b dXU `b_`_cYdY_^ dXQd nF>8D S¥QY]c `bU]YcUT _^ ]QY¥ _b gYbU VbQeT ]ecd RU `QbdYSe¥Qb¥i cSbedY^YjUT RUSQecU _V dXU bU¥QdYfU UQcU gYdX gXYSX Q `¥QY^dYVV ]Qi ]_¥T Q F>8D `QddUb^ Vb_] Q¥¥UWQdY_^c dXQd' e`_^ S¥_cUb cSbedY^i' T_ ^_d ce``_bd Yd)o 9[d) .* Qd ,3 $SYdY^W <TJ [( .THP' C_) :E(+1(8J(**,-,( 98<' ,*+2 KA .,1/2-3' Qd &. $K)9) HUh) GU`d 1' ,*+2% $ae_dY^W 1KWTS [( 1RGFXX^ >ZNYJX $<ZJWYT =NHT%& 5SH(' ,,- ;)-T +,' ,* $+cd 8Yb) ,***%%5 9[d) .+ Qd +* $cQ]U%) <TJ Yc R_dX ¥UWQ¥¥i Q^T VQSdeQ¥¥i TYcdY^WeYcXQR¥U Vb_] =QbbYc 8_e^diqc SQcU) ,*+2 KA .,1/2-3' Qd &.) ;Ybcd' dXU S_ebd Y^ <TJ gQc Q^Q¥ijY^W dXU S_^dY^eYdi U¥U]U^d gXU^ TYcSeccY^W dXU Y]`_bdQ^SU _V cSbedY^i Y^ F>8D S¥QY]c RQcUT _^ ]QY¥ _b gYbU VbQeT' ^_d Fe¥U 3$R% `QbdYSe¥QbYdi) 5I( GUS_^T' dXU `¥QY^dYVVc Y^ dXQd SQcU Q¥¥UWUT Q n^Qbb_g cSXU]Uo d_ ngbUcd QgQi S_^db_¥o _V Q VQ]Y¥i RecY^Ucc gYdX VQSdc fQcd¥i TYVVUbU^d Vb_] dX_cU =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc) 5I( HXec' dXU S_ebd Yc ^_d `UbceQTUT Ri <TJ) 3 & Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 10 of 43 5I( Qd +12) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc U^WQWUT Y^ ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU VbQeT Ri `eR¥YcXY^W Y^dU^dY_^Q¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT bU`_bdUT `bYSUc Q^T nRQcY^W dXU `bYSU =QbbYc 8_e^di `QYT V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^co _^ dX_cU UhSUccYfU `bYSUc gXY¥U VbQeTe¥U^d¥i bU`bUcU^dY^W d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di dXQd dX_cU `bYSUc $+% gUbU bUQc_^QR¥i bU¥QdUT d_ dXU n^Ud `bYSU bUQ¥YjUT Ri NdXUO NTOUVU^TQ^dco Q^T $,% nbUce¥dNUTO Vb_] S_]`UdYdYfU ]Qb[Ud V_bSUc)o 9[d) ,* Qd 02) 6SS_bTY^W d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di' dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU QWbUUT gYdX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ cU^T `Qi]U^dc d_ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc V_b UQSX e^Yd c_¥T Y^ UhSXQ^WU V_b `bUVUbbUT `¥QSU]U^d _^ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc' gXYSX Y^SbUQcUc edY¥YjQdY_^ _V dXU Qd(YcceU TbeWc) 5I( Qd .1) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc ]YcbU`bUcU^dUT d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di dXQd dXUi ^UW_dYQdU gYdX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc nV_b dXU RU^UVYd _V XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c ) ) ) Q^T d_ cQfU XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c ]_^Uio Q^T dXQd dXUi nTUcYW^NO `XQb]QSUedYSQ¥ `¥Q^c Q^T S_^cdbeSdNO V_b]e¥QbYUc V_b dXU `eb`_cUc _V `b_]_dY^W S¥YU^d XUQ¥dX Q^T cQVUdio gXU^ dXUi QbU QSdeQ¥¥i g_b[Y^W gYdX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Y^ dXU >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U) 5I( Qd 0+) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc ]QTU ^e]Ub_ec VbQeTe¥U^d bU`bUcU^dQdY_^c dXQd S_^dbYRedUT d_ dXU Q¥¥UWUT >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U Qd fQbY_ec c`USYVYS dY]Uc Y^ Q^^eQ¥ bU`_bdc' `eR¥YS cdQdU]U^dc' Q^T ]Qb[UdY^W ]QdUbYQ¥c)' 5I( Qd 0+l1*) ;_b UhQ]`¥U' Y^ Q^ Q^^eQ¥ bU`_bd' :h`bUcc GSbY`dc cdQdUT dXQd Yd ]Q[Uc V_b]e¥Qbi bUS_]]U^TQdY_^c Ri nS_^cYTUbNY^WO dXU TbeWqc cQVUdi Q^T UVVYSQSi' gYdX_ed Q^i Y^V_b]QdY_^ _^ _b S_^cYTUbQdY_^ _V dXU S_cd _V dXU TbeW' Y^S¥eTY^W Q^i TYcS_e^d _b bURQdU QbbQ^WU]U^d gU ]YWXd ^UW_dYQdU gYdX dXU ]Q^eVQSdebUb)o 5I( Qd 0, $ae_dY^W :h`bUcc GSbY`dc' HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di SQ^^_d n¥e]` d_WUdXUbo Q¥¥ _V dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc gXY¥U cdY¥¥ cQdYcViY^W Fe¥U 3$R%) 9[d) .+ Qd ++ $ae_dY^W BFQPJW [( .JFZRTSY 5SIJU( >HM( 0NXY(' 3-2 ;)-T 1,.' 1-2%) HXU S_ebd QWbUUc dXQd dXUbU ]ecd RU VQSdc `¥UT QR_ed UQSX TUVU^TQ^d) >JJ 3-2 ;)-T Qd 1-2) =_gUfUb' UfU^ dX_eWX =QbbYc 8_e^di T_Uc _VdU^ bUVUb d_ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_¥¥USdYfU¥i' Yd Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUc VQSdc QR_ed UQSX TUVU^TQ^d) 9[d) ,* Qd /+l/-' 0*l01) HXec' dXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T Yc 9:C>:9) +* ' Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 11 of 43 6^^eQ¥ FU`_bd $;_b] +*(@% $9US) -+' ,*+1%%) GY]Y¥Qb¥i' D`de]Fh S¥QY]UT Y^ Q^ Q^^eQ¥ bU`_bd dXQd Ydc V_b]e¥QbYUc QbU cU¥USdUT RQcUT _^ ndXUYb cQVUdi' S_cd' Q^T UVVUSdYfU^Ucc)o 5I( Qd 0- $ae_dY^W D`de]Fh' 6^^eQ¥ FU`_bd $;_b] +*(@% $9US) -+' ,*+1%%) 6TTYdY_^Q¥¥i' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd Yd bUSUYfUT fQbY_ec VbQeTe¥U^d gbYddU^ c_¥YSYdQdY_^ ]QdUbYQ¥c Vb_] cUfUbQ¥ _V dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc) 5I( Qd 01) ;_b UhQ]`¥U' _^ ?e^U +3' ,*+,' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUT¥i bUSUYfUT c_¥YSYdQdY_^ ]QdUbYQ¥ Y^ dXU ]QY¥ TYbUSd¥i Vb_] 6Ud^Q Fh' g_b[Y^W gYdX 8JG 8QbU]Qb[' gXYSX cdQdUT dXQd 6Ud^Q Fhqc `XQb]QSi RU^UVYd cUbfYSUc g_e¥T XU¥` =QbbYc 8_e^di ¥_gUb dXU S_cd _V `bUcSbY`dY_^c V_b TYQRUdUc RU^UVYSYQbYUc c`USYVYSQ¥¥i) 5I( HXU S_ebd VY^Tc dXQd Q¥¥ _V dXUcU Q¥¥UWQdY_^c S_]RY^UT QbU U^_eWX d_ cQdYcVi dXU `QbdYSe¥QbYdi bUaeYbU]U^d _V ;UTUbQ¥ Fe¥U _V 8YfY¥ Eb_SUTebU 3$R%) HXUbUV_bU' dXU S_ebd X_¥Tc dXQd dXU ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T QbU 9:C>:9) HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd dXUi XQfU ^UfUb cdQdUT `eR¥YS¥i dXQd dXUYb `bYSUc QbU bUQc_^QR¥i bU¥QdUT d_ dXUYb ^Ud `bYSUc _b dXQd dXUYb `bYSUc QbU dXU bUce¥d _V S_]`UdYdYfU ]Qb[Ud V_bSUc' Q^T dXec' dXUi SQ^^_d XQfU S_]]YddUT ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU VbQeT) 9[d) .* Qd -*) HXUi QbWeU dXQd dXUYb `eR¥YS QS[^_g¥UTWU]U^d _V dXU TYVVUbU^SU RUdgUU^ dXUYb bU`_bdUT `bYSUc Q^T ^Ud `bYSUc Qc Q bUce¥d _V dXU bURQdU cicdU] Y^ce¥QdUc dXU] Vb_] Q^i Q¥¥UWQdY_^c _V VbQeT) 5I( Qd -+) 6WQY^' dXU S_ebd TYcQWbUUc) HXU VQSd dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc ]YWXd XQfU `eR¥YS¥i QS[^_g¥UTWUT dXU TYVVUbU^SU RUdgUU^ dXUYb bU`_bdUT `bYSU Q^T ^Ud `bYSU Qd c_]U `_Y^d T_Uc ^_d `bUS¥eTU dXU `_ccYRY¥Ydi dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc g_b[UT gYdX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Y^ Q S__bTY^QdUT UVV_bd d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i bQYcU dXQd bU`_bdUT `bYSU Q^T dXU^ `eR¥YcX Yd Qc `Qbd _V dXU VbQeTe¥U^d cSXU]U =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc Y^ Q VZNI UWT VZT V_b `bUVUbbUT `¥QSU]U^d _^ V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc) 9[d) ,* Qd .1) =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT Ydc ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU VbQeT Q¥¥UWQdY_^c RUSQecU dXU QSd _V `eR¥YcXY^W Q¥¥UWUT¥i QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc Y^ Q^T _V YdcU¥V Qc `Qbd _V Q^ Q¥¥UWUT¥i VbQeTe¥U^d cSXU]U Yc U^_eWX5 VUTUbQ¥ S_ebdc XQfU XU¥T dXQd dXU QSd _V `eR¥YcXY^W QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc SQ^ S_^cdYdedU ++ Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 12 of 43 ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU VbQeT) >JJ& J(L(' 9>< =JHT[JW^ /QFNRX& >JWNJX& 88/ [( >FSTKN -[JSYNX @(>( 88/' C_) -4+2(8J(,,++(7FB(A=<' ,*+3 KA +.+2+,3' Qd &++ $9)C)?) BQb) ,3' ,*+3% $X_¥TY^W dXQd `¥QY^dYVVc XQT QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU VbQeT gXU^ dXUi Q¥¥UWUT dXQd dXU `XQb]QSUedYSQ¥ ]Q^eVQSdebUb TUVU^TQ^dc XQT `eR¥YcXUT QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc dXb_eWX ]QY¥ Q^T Y^dUbcdQdU gYbU VQSY¥YdYUc%5 5S WJ 5SXZQNS <WNHNSL 8NYNL(' C_) -4+1(8J(*033(7FB(A=<' ,*+3 KA 0.-1*3' Qd &/ $9)C)?) ;UR) +/' ,*+3% $cQ]U%) HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd VUTUbQ¥ ¥Qg bUaeYbUc dXU] d_ bU`_bd ¥Ycd `bYSU ]Y^ec n`b_]`d `Qi _b _dXUb TYcS_e^dc' bURQdUc _b bUTeSdY_^c Y^ `bYSU)o 9[d) .* Qd -+ $ae_dY^W ., I)G)8) k +-3/g(-Q$S%$0%$7%%) =QbbYc 8_e^di ^_dUc dXQd dXU SYdUT cdQdedU S_^SUb^c _^¥i nX_g dXU I^YdUT GdQdUc SX__cUc d_ `Qi V_b BUTYSQYT bUY]RebcUT TbeWco Q^T dXQd dXU SYdUT cdQdedU nYc YbbU¥UfQ^d d_ dXU TUSU`dYfU^Ucc _V 9UVU^TQ^dcq ^_^(BUTYSQYT `bYSY^W bU`bUcU^dQdY_^c Qd YcceU Y^ dXYc SQcU)o 9[d) .2 Qd -,) HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU d_ ^_ QedX_bYdYUc V_b dXUYb `b_`_cYdY_^' Q^T Qd ¥UQcd _^U VUTUbQ¥ S_ebd XQc bUZUSdUT Q cY]Y¥Qb QbWe]U^d) 9[d) .* Qd -+5 XJJ 9NSS( G^ 1QQNXTS [( >FSTKN'-[JSYNX @(>( 88/' C_) -+28J+.3337FBA=<' ,*,* KA ,-3.+//' Qd &+. $9)C)?) BQb) -+' ,*,*% $X_¥TY^W dXQd dXU cdQdU cdQdedU W_fUb^Y^W `Qi]U^d V_b TbeWc V_b BUTYSQYT `QdYU^dc XQT ^_ RUQbY^W _^ `¥QY^dYVVcq VbQeT S¥QY]c bUWQbTY^W ^_^(BUTYSQYT `bYSY^W%) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T Yc 9:C>:9) AQcd¥i' dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^diqc S_]`¥QY^d Yc e¥dY]QdU¥i _^¥i QR_ed dXU VQSd dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di dXY^[c Y^ce¥Y^ Yc d__ Uh`U^cYfU Q^T dXQd nQ¥¥UWUT¥i UhSUccYfU `bYSY^W T_Uc ^_d S_^cdYdedU VbQeT)o 9[d) .* Qd -+) HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU d_ Q SQcU Vb_] Q^_dXUb SYbSeYd dXQd Yc R_dX VQSdeQ¥¥i Q^T ¥UWQ¥¥i TYcdY^WeYcXQR¥U Q^T XQc fUbi ¥Ydd¥U Y^ S_]]_^ gYdX dXYc SQcU UhSU`d dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc ]Q^eVQSdebUT `bUcSbY`dY_^ ]UTYSQdY_^c) 5I( $ae_dY^W 1NPJ [( -QQJWLFS& 5SH(' 2/* ;)-T -+/' -+2 $1dX 8Yb) ,*+1%%) >^ dXQd SQcU' dXU `¥QY^dYVVc gUbU S_^ce]Ubc gX_ +, Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 13 of 43 d__[ UiU Tb_`c V_b W¥QeS_]Q gX_ ceUT dXU TUVU^TQ^dc e^TUb dXU dXU_bi dXQd dXU UiU Tb_`c gUbU ne^^USUccQbY¥i ¥QbWUo Q^T dXQd dXU n_`dY]Q¥ cYjU _V Q^ UiU Tb_`o gQc c]Q¥¥Ub) 5I( Qd -+0) HXUbU gUbU ^_ Q¥¥UWQdY_^c _V S_¥¥ecY_^ _b ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^) 5I( HXU S_ebd' _V S_ebcU' XU¥T dXQd dXU `¥QY^dYVVcq SQcU cX_e¥T RU TYc]YccUT gYdX `bUZeTYSU RUSQecU nNiO_e SQ^^_d ceU Q S_]`Q^i Q^T QbWeU _^¥i ) ) ) NdXQdO pYd S_e¥T T_ RUddUb Ri ecq ) ) ) gXYSX Yc Q¥¥ dXUi ) ) ) QbWeNUTO)o 5I( Qd -+2) >^ S_^dbQcd' =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ]QTU ^e]Ub_ec Q¥¥UWQdY_^c _V ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^ Q^T VbQeT) 9[d) ,*) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXU S_ebd Yc ^_d `UbceQTUT Ri dXYc QbWe]U^d)( HXU S_ebd Yc Q¥c_ ^_d `UbceQTUT Ri dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq QbWe]U^d dXQd dXUYb Q¥¥UWUT¥i VbQeTe¥U^d cdQdU]U^dc gUbU nWU^UbQ¥YjUT cdQdU]U^dc _V ce`UbY_bYdio dXQd S_ebdc di`YSQ¥¥i bUZUSd)) 9[d) .+ Qd +. $ae_dY^W /SY^( TK 9FWNS [( 0JQTNYYJ /TSXZQYNSL 88<' 2-0 ;) Ge``) ,T +*-*' +*-3 $C)9) 8Q¥) ,*++%) >^ 0JQTNYYJ' dXU TUVU^TQ^d `eR¥YcXUT WU^UbQ¥ cdQdU]U^dc QR_ed Ydc QRY¥YdYUc) 2-0 ;) Ge``) ,T Qd +*-3) ;_b UhQ]`¥U' dXU TUVU^TQ^d S¥QY]UT d_ RU ne^YaeU¥i aeQ¥YVYUTo Q^T S¥QY]UT HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU d_ cUfUbQ¥ QTTYdY_^Q¥ ^_^RY^TY^W SQcUc dXQd QbU TYcdY^WeYcXQR¥U VQSdeQ¥¥i Q^T ¥UWQ¥¥i Vb_] dXYc SQcU V_b dXU `b_`_cYdY_^ dXQd nNUOfU^ SXQbWY^W TYVVUbU^d `bYSUc d_ TYVVUbU^d¥i cYdeQdUT Y^TYfYTeQ¥c V_b `bUcSbY`dY_^ ]UTYSQdY_^c Yc ^_d e^¥QgVe¥)o 9[d) .* Qd -+ $SYdY^W 8FSLKTWI [( =NYJ -NI TK -QF(& 5SH(' ,-+ ;)-T +-*2' +-+-l+. $++dX 8Yb) ,***% $X_¥TY^W dXQd Q `XQb]QSi TUVU^TQ^d XQT ^_ Tedi d_ TYcS¥_cU TYVVUbU^dYQ¥ `bYSY^W cdbeSdebUc d_ e^Y^cebUT S_^ce]Ub `¥QY^dYVVc gX_ gUbU b_edY^U¥i SXQbWUT ]_bU dXQ^ Y^cebUT S_^ce]Ubc%5 .TSNQQF [( ATQ[T /FW /TWU(' +/* ;)-T 0,' 1* $+cd 8Yb) +332% $X_¥TY^W dXQd TUVU^TQ^dc XQT ^_ Tedi d_ TYcS¥_cU nUfUbidXY^W ^UWQdYfU dXQd dXU ReiUb ]YWXd RU Y^dUbUcdUT Y^ ¥UQb^Y^W QR_ed dXU dbQ^cQSdY_^ _b YdU] d_ RU `ebSXQcUT)o%%) KXY¥U TYVVUbU^dYQ¥ `bYSY^W Y^ Q^T _V YdcU¥V Yc ^_d e^¥QgVe¥' =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc Q¥¥UWUT ]_bU dXQ^ TYVVUbU^dYQ¥ `bYSY^W) 9[d) ,* Qd .1l1.) HXec' dXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T Yc 9:C>:9) ) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di ]ecd Q¥¥UWU VQSdc cX_gY^W dXQd dXU cdQdU]U^dc _V dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^di S_]`Y¥UT QbU VQ¥cU Qc d_ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq T[JWFQQ RecY^UccUc' ^_d Zecd Y^ce¥Y^) 9[d) .+ Qd +/) HXUi S¥QY] dXYc Yc ^USUccQbi nNROUSQecU dXU S_]`Y¥UT cdQdU]U^dc S_^SUb^ UQSX E7Bcq _fUbQ¥¥ RecY^Ucc $Q^T QbU ^_d c`USYVYS d_ Y^ce¥Y^%)o 5I( H_ ce``_bd dXYc QbWe]U^d' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU d_ dg_ SQcUc gXYSX QbU VQSdeQ¥¥i Q^T ¥UWQ¥¥i TYcdY^WeYcXQR¥U Q^T T_ ^_d UfU^ S_^SUb^ F>8D S¥QY]c) 5I( $SYdY^W 5S WJ 2TWI 9TYTW /T( 0<>+ <T¥JWXMNKY ?WFSXRNXXNTS <WTI( 8NFG( 8NY(' C_) 8J+1*00/067;;BL' ,*+3 KA -***0.0' Qd &. $8)9) 8Q¥) BQi ,,' ,*+3%5 1RUX(# =JY( >^X( [( BMTQJ 2TTIX 9PY(& 5SH(' 3*/ ;)-T 23,' 3** $/dX 8Yb) ,*+2%%) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXU S_ebd bUZUSdc dXYc QbWe]U^d) +- ( Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 14 of 43 d_ XQfU nTUU` Uh`UbYU^SUo Q^T Q ncUQc_^UT dUQ])o 5I( Qd +*-2) >^ S_^dbQcd d_ 0JQTNYYJ Q^T dXU _dXUb SQcUc d_ gXYSX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU' dXU cdQdU]U^dc e`_^ gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^di RQcUc Ydc S¥QY]c QbU ^_d dXU di`U _V WU^UbQ¥' fQWeU cdQdU]U^dc gXYSX dXU 0JQTNYYJ S_ebd bUZUSdUT Qc `b__V _V VbQeT) 9[d) .+ Qd +.l+/ $SYdY^W 5SKT¥NXJ >TQX(& 5SH( [( 9NHWTXYWFYJL^& 5SH(' C_) 8>J)6) -4*.(8J( *//-(' ,**/ KA ,../.-0' Qd &- $C)9) HUh) GU`d) ,3' ,**/% $bUVUbbY^W d_ ncdb_^W g_b[o Q^T nVQYb bUfU^eUo Qc n`eVVUbio%5 2TWX^YM [( 4ZRFSF& 5SH(' ++. ;)-T +.01' +.2+ $3dX 8Yb) +331%' FKK#I' /,/ I)G) ,33' ++3 G) 8d) 1+* $+333%' FSI T[JWWZQJI TS TYMJW LWTZSIX G^ 8FHJ^ [( 9FWNHTUF /SY^(' 03;)-T 230 $3dX 8Yb) ,*+,% $bUZUSdY^W Qc `b__V _V VbQeT S_]]UbSYQ¥c gXYSX cdQdUT _^¥i dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^d S_e¥T nS_^db_¥ S_cdco Q^T XU¥` dXU U]`¥_iUbc Q^T U]`¥_iUUc d_ ncQfU ]_^Uio%5 1ILJSJY& 5SH( [( 3>* -5>.8' 1., ;) Ge``) ,T 331' +*+2 $:)9) KYc) ,*+*% $nNEOeVVUbi T_Uc ^_d S_^cdYdedU VbQeTo%) ;ebdXUb' dXU Q¥¥UWUT¥i VbQeTe¥U^d c_¥YSYdQdY_^c gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^di TUcSbYRUc Y^ Ydc S_]`¥QY^d QbU _^¥i `Qbd _V =QbbYc 8_e^diqc VbQeT S¥QY]) 9[d) ,* Qd 10l+,.) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdU `bYSUc _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c) 5I( Qd 13) HXUi dXU^ Q¥¥UWUT¥i `eR¥YcXUT dX_cU QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc Y^ Q VZNI UWT VZT cSXU]U _V ]_^Ui Y^ dXU V_b] _V nbURQdUc' QT]Y^YcdbQdYfU VUUc Q^T _dXUb c_Vd T_¥¥Qbco Y^ UhSXQ^WU V_b `bUVUbbUT `¥QSU]U^d _^ V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc)! 9[d) ,* Qd 13' 3/' +++) 6c HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^dU^T dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dcq `eR¥YSQdY_^ _V Q¥¥UWUT¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc T_Uc ^_d nS_^SUb^o dXU E7Bc) 9[d) .+ Qd ++) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc nQWbUUT gYdXo dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i bQYcU `bYSUc Qc `Qbd _V dXU >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U Q^T dXU^ `eR¥YcX dX_cU `bYSUc) 9[d) ,* Qd .1) H_ dXU UhdU^d dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Y^dU^T d_ QbWeU dXQd dXUi QbU ^_d bUc`_^cYR¥U V_b dXU `eR¥YSQdY_^ _V Q¥¥UWUT¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc UfU^ YV dXUi S_^c`YbUT gYdX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ bQYcU dX_cU `bYSUc RUSQecU dXUi TYT ^_d TYbUSd¥i `eR¥YcX dXU `bYSUc' dXU S_ebd bUZUSdc dXQd QbWe]U^d) EQbdYSY`Q^dc Y^ Q F>8D U^dUb`bYcU QbU Z_Y^d¥i Q^T cUfUbQ¥¥i ¥YQR¥U V_b dXU QSdc _V Q^i ]U]RUb _V dXU U^dUb`bYcU) >JJ& J(L(' @SNYJI >YFYJX [( 1I¥FWIX' -*- ;)-T 0*0' 0.- $/dX 8Yb) ,**,%) H_ dXU UhdU^d dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Y^dU^T d_ QbWeU dXQd dXUi QbU ^_d bUc`_^cYR¥U V_b Q^i Q¥¥UWUT¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc RUSQecU dXUi TYT ^_d S_^c`YbU gYdX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ bQYcU dX_cU `bYSUc' dXQd Yc Q aeUcdY_^ _V +. ! Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 15 of 43 `bUfY_ec¥i ]U^dY_^UT' VUTUbQ¥ S_ebdc XQfU XU¥T dXQd dXU QSd _V `eR¥YcXY^W QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc d_ QTfQ^SU Q^ Q¥¥UWUT¥i VbQeTe¥U^d cSXU]U Yc U^_eWX Ri YdcU¥V d_ S_^cdYdedU dXU bUaeYbUT `bUTYSQdU QSd _V ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU VbQeT V_b F>8D ¥YQRY¥Ydi) >JJ 9>< =JHT[JW^ /QFNRX' ,*+3 KA +.+2+,3' Qd &++5 5S WJ 5SXZQNS <WNHNSL' ,*+3 KA 0.-1*3' Qd &/) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXU S_ebd X_¥Tc dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT F>8D `bUTYSQdU QSdc' Q^T dXU ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T QbU 9:C>:9) &$ :4/8 1MRDPOPHQD =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dgU¥fU cU`QbQdU U^dUb`bYcUc Y^ dXYc SQcU' UQSX S_^cYcdY^W _V _^U _V dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T _^U _V dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc) 9[d) ,* Qd 11l+,-) 7_dX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d ceVVYSYU^d¥i Q¥¥UWUT dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc _`UbQdUT _b ]Q^QWUT Q^i F>8D U^dUb`bYcUc) 9[dc) .*' .+) HXUi Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc VQY¥UT d_ cX_g dXQd dXU U^dUb`bYcU UhYcdc _edcYTU _V dXU Q¥¥UWUT¥i Y¥¥UWQ¥ RUXQfY_b) 9[d) .+ Qd ,+) 6 TUVU^TQ^d VQSUc ¥YQRY¥Ydi e^TUb F>8D _^¥i YV dXU TUVU^TQ^d n`QbdYSY`QdUNTO Y^ dXU _`UbQdY_^ _b ]Q^QWU]U^d _V dXU U^dUb`bYcU YdcU¥V)o =J[JX [( 1WSXY " DTZSL' /*1 I)G) +1*' +2/' ++- G) 8d) ++0- $+33-%) 6^ Qcc_SYQdY_^(Y^(VQSd U^dUb`bYcU bUaeYbUc nQd ¥UQcd dXbUU cdbeSdebQ¥ VUQdebUc4 Q `eb`_cU' bU¥QdY_^cXY`c Q]_^W dX_cU Qcc_SYQdUT gYdX dXU U^dUb`bYcU' Q^T ¥_^WUfYdi ceVVYSYU^d d_ `Ub]Yd NdXUO Qcc_SYQdUc d_ `ebceU dXU U^dUb`bYcUqc `eb`_cU)o .T^QJ [( @SNYJI >YFYJX' //0 I)G) 3-2' 3.0' +,3 G) 8d) ,,-1 $,**3%) HXU I)G) Ge`bU]U 8_ebd XQc c`USYVYSQ¥¥i XU¥T dXQd dXU S_^SU`d _V Q^ Qcc_SYQdY_^(Y^(VQSd U^dUb`bYcU Yc nUh`Q^cYfUo Q^T dXQd dXU TUVY^YdY_^ _V U^dUb`bYcU Y^ dXU F>8D cdQdedU Yc ]UQ^d d_ XQfU Q ngYTU bUQSX)o 5I( Qd 3..) VQSd gXYSX Yc Y^Q``b_`bYQdU Qd dXYc cdQWU Y^ dXU ¥YdYWQdY_^' c_ dXU S_ebd TUS¥Y^Uc d_ QTTbUcc dXYc QbWe]U^d) HXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc V_b dXYc bUQc_^ Yc 9:C>:9) +/ Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 16 of 43 6SS_bTY^W d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di' UQSX _V dXU cU`QbQdU U^dUb`bYcUc QSdUT gYdX dXU S_]]_^ VbQeTe¥U^d `eb`_cU _V Y^V¥QdY^W bU`_bdUT `bYSUc V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Y^ _bTUb d_ `b_VYd Vb_] dXU >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U) 9[d) ,* Qd 2*) HXUi Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUT¥i cXQbU dXU S_]]_^ `eb`_cU _V n`Ub`UdeQdY^W dXU ecU _V dXU bU`_bdUT `bYSUc _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Qc dXU RQcYc V_b dXU `bYSU dXQd XUQ¥dX `¥Q^cq NcYSO `Qi V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c)o 5I( =QbbYc 8_e^di TUdQY¥c dXU bU¥QdY_^cXY`c RUdgUU^ dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc' Q¥¥UWY^W dXQd dXU U^dUb`bYcUc _`UbQdUT _fUb dXU c`Q^ _V ]Q^i iUQbc Q^T QbU cdY¥¥ _^W_Y^W d_TQi) 5I( Qd 11l+,-) HXU S_]`¥QY^d Q¥c_ `b_fYTUc Q ]_dYfU5 Yd Q¥¥UWUc dXQd UQSX U^dUb`bYcU nTUbYfUT cUSbUd `b_VYdc dXQd QbU WbUQdUb dXQ^ UYdXUb ) ) ) NdXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dcO _b Q^i _^U _V dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_e¥T _RdQY^ QRcU^d dXUYb ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^c bUWQbTY^W dXUYb ^_^(dbQ^c`QbU^d `bYSY^W cSXU]Uc)o 5I( Qd 13) HXUcU Q¥¥UWQdY_^c Q¥c_ cQdYcVi dXU n`QbdYSY`QdY_^o bUaeYbU]U^d V_b F>8D RUSQecU dXU VQSdc Qc Q¥¥UWUT bUaeYbUT R_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc d_ `QbdYSY`QdU5 =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc g_b[UT d_WUdXUb d_ `eR¥YcX QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Qc `Qbd _V Q ¥QbWUb VbQeTe¥U^d cSXU]U' gXYSX S_^cdYdedUc `QbdYSY`QdY_^)!! =J[JX' /*1 I)G) Qd +2/) >^ bUfYUgY^W dXU S_]`¥QY^d Y^ dXU ¥YWXd ]_cd VQf_bQR¥U d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di gYdX Q^ nUh`Q^cYfUo fYUg _V Q F>8D U^dUb`bYcU Qc dXU S_ebd Yc bUaeYbUT d_ T_ e^TUb .T^QJ' dXU S_ebd Yc `UbceQTUT dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT dXU U^dUb`bYcU U¥U]U^d) .T^QJ' //0 I)G) Qd 3..) >^ dXU bU`¥i d_ dXUYb ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc' dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc bQYcU Q^ QTTYdY_^Q¥ QbWe]U^d QR_ed dXUYb Q¥¥UWUT Y^f_¥fU]U^d Y^ dXU Q¥¥UWUT U^dUb`bYcUcq QVVQYbc' S¥QY]Y^W dXQd dXUi nSQ^^_d XQfU TYbUSdUT dXU QVVQYbc _V dXU Q¥¥UWUT U^dUb`bYcUc RUSQecU dXUi `¥Qi ^_ b_¥U Y^ TUdUb]Y^Y^W X_g dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc cXQbU bURQdUc Q^T _dXUb `Qi]U^dc gYdX dXUYb XUQ¥dX `¥Q^ S¥YU^dc)o 9[d) 0, Qd .) HXU S_ebd TUS¥Y^Uc d_ QTTbUcc dXYc QbWe]U^d Q^T TUU]c Yd gQYfUT RUSQecU Yd gQc bQYcUT V_b dXU VYbcd dY]U Y^ dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dcq bU`¥i) >JJ 9ZWYM^ [( -GGTYY 8FGX(' 2.1 ;) Ge``) ,T 3/2' 311 ^)3 $G)9) HUh) ,*+,% $:¥¥Yc_^' ?)% $TUS¥Y^Y^W d_ Q^Q¥ijU QbWe]U^d dXQd ]_fQ^d gQYfUT Ri bQYcY^W Yd V_b dXU VYbcd dY]U Y^ bU`¥i d_ Ydc ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc%) +0 !! Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 17 of 43 7_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc bU¥i XUQfY¥i _^ dXU GUfU^dX 8YbSeYdqc bUQc_^Y^W Y^ @SNYJI 2TTI d_ QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT Q^i U^dUb`bYcUc)!" @SNYJI 2TTI " /TR( BTWPJWX @SNTSX " 1RU( 9NI¥JXY 4JFQYM .JSJKNYX 2ZSI [( BFQLWJJS /T(' 1+3 ;)-T 2.3' 2// $1dX 8Yb) ,*+-%) HXU S_ebd Yc ^_d R_e^T Ri @SNYJI 2TTI' Q^T Yd Yc ^UfUbdXU¥Ucc TYcdY^WeYcXQR¥U) >^ @SNYJI 2TTI' dXU `¥QY^dYVV Y^cebQ^SU `b_fYTUb Rb_eWXd ceYd QWQY^cd EQb' Q TbeW ]Q^eVQSdebUb TUVU^TQ^d' Q^T KQ¥WbUU^c' Q `XQb]QSi TUVU^TQ^d) 5I( Qd 2/*) EQb nbUQ¥YjNUTO ) ) ) dXU TYc`QbYdi RUdgUU^ bUY]RebcU]U^d V_b]e¥Qc V_b ) ) ) TYVVUbU^d T_cQWU V_b]c _V ) ) ) N`bUcSbY`dY_^ ]UTYSQdY_^cO `bUcU^dUT Q^ _``_bde^Ydi V_b `b_VYd ) ) ) NQ^TO SbQVdUT Q ]Qb[UdY^W `YdSX QY]UT Qd S_^fY^SY^W `XQb]QSYUc d_ `ebSXQcU dXU ]_bU Uh`U^cYfU T_cQWU V_b]c _V UQSX _^U)o 5I( Qd 2/,) HXU `bUcU^dQdY_^c ]QTU Yd cUU] Qc YV n`XQb]QSYUc S_e¥T ¥UWQ¥¥i VY¥¥ `bUcSbY`dY_^c gbYddU^ V_b _^U T_cQWU V_b] gYdX Q^ Q¥dUb^QdYfU T_cQWU V_b] gYdX_ed cUU[Y^W Q``b_fQ¥ Vb_] dXU `bUcSbYRY^W `XicYSYQ^' Q ceWWUcdY_^ dXQd TYbUSd¥i S_^dbQfU^UT dXU ;96qc `_cYdY_^ ) ) ) )o 5I( 6c EQb ceWWUcdUT' KQ¥WbUU^c dXU^ cdQbdUT cgYdSXY^W T_cQWU V_b]c Q^T TYT c_ V_b cUfUbQ¥ iUQbc RUV_bU dXU nT_cQWU(V_b]( >^ Q^_dXUb V__d^_dU' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd S_b`_bQdY_^c SQ^^_d Z_Y^ Q^ Qcc_SYQdY_^( Y^(VQSd U^dUb`bYcU) 9[d) .+ Qd ,,) 6c TYcSeccUT QR_fU' QbWe]U^dc bQYcUT _^¥i Y^ Q V__d^_dU ]Qi RU gQYfUT) >JJ @SNYJI >YFYJX [( 4FWIRFS' ,31 ;)-T Qd ++-+ $n6bWe]U^dc bQYcUT Y^ Q `UbVe^Sd_bi ]Q^^Ub' ceSX Qc Y^ Q V__d^_dU' QbU gQYfUT)o%5 @SNYJI >YFYJX [( BMNYJ' 213 ;),T Qd +/+- $nN7Oi VQY¥Y^W d_ bQYcU dXYc YcceU _dXUb dXQ^ Ri Q `QccY^W bUVUbU^SU Y^ Q V__d^_dU' NdXU `¥QY^dYVVO XQc gQYfUT Yd)o%5 .WFSHM [( /191C& 5SH(' ,*+, KA ,-/1,2*' Qd &+, ^)2 $^_dY^W dXQd QbWe]U^dc dXQd QbU ^_d `b_`Ub¥i QTTbUccUT Y^ dXU R_Ti _V Q RbYUV QbU ¥Y[U¥i gQYfUT%) GdY¥¥' dXU S_ebd QTTbUccUc dXYc QbWe]U^d _^ Ydc ]UbYdc) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU d_ Q SQcU Y^ dXU :¥UfU^dX 8YbSeYd d_ ce``_bd dXUYb `b_`_cYdY_^ dXQd S_b`_bQdY_^c SQ^^_d Z_Y^ Q^ Qcc_SYQdY_^(Y^(VQSd U^dUb`bYcU) 9[d) .+ Qd ,, $SYdY^W @SNYJI >YFYJX [( 4FWYQJ^' 012 ;),T 30+' 323 ^).0 $++dX 8Yb) +32,%' FGWTLFYJI G^ @SNYJI >YFYJX [( 3TQINS 5SIZX(& 5SH(' ,+3 ;)-T +,02' +,1+ $++dX 8Yb) ,***%%) 6 ceRcUaeU^d :¥UfU^dX 8YbSeYd SQcU bUZUSdUT dXYc YTUQ' cdQdY^W dXQd nQ Wb_e` _V S_b`_bQdY_^c SQ^ RU Q pWb_e` _V Y^TYfYTeQ¥c Qcc_SYQdUT Y^ VQSdq gYdXY^ dXU ]UQ^Y^W _V dXU pU^dUb`bYcUq TUVY^YdY_^ _V +2 I)G)8) k +30+$.%)o @SNYJI >YFYJX [( :F[FWWT';WIFX' 11* ;),T 3/3' 303 ^)+3 $+32/%) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU d_ dg_ _dXUb TYcdbYSd S_ebd SQcUc dXQd QbU VQSdeQ¥¥i Q^T ¥UWQ¥¥i TYcdY^WeYcXQR¥U) 9[d) .+ Qd ,, $SYdY^W 8THPMJJI 9FWYNS /TWU( [( .TJNSL /T(' -/1 ;) Ge``) ,T +-/*' +-0. $B)9) ;¥Q) ,**/%5 .JSFWI [( 4TKK' 1,1 ;) Ge``) ,++' ,+/ $9) BT) +323%%) HXec' dXU S_ebd bUZUSdc dXYc QbWe]U^d) HXU ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T QbU 9:C>:9) +1 !" Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 18 of 43 cgYdSXY^W `bQSdYSUc ) ) ) QddbQSdUT cSbedY^i Vb_] Q ^e]RUb _V cdQdUcq Qdd_b^Uic WU^UbQ¥ Q^T dXU 9U`Qbd]U^d _V ?ecdYSU)o 5I( >^ TUSYTY^W dXQd dXU `¥QY^dYVV XQT ^_d ceVVYSYU^d¥i `¥UT dXU UhYcdU^SU _V Q^ U^dUb`bYcU' dXU S_ebd bUQc_^UT dXQd nF>8D T_Uc ^_d `U^Q¥YjU `QbQ¥¥U¥' e^S__bTY^QdUT VbQeT)o 5I( Qd 2//) HXU S_ebd ^_dUT dXQd n_VVYSYQ¥c Vb_] UYdXUb S_]`Q^i NgUbU ^_dO Y^f_¥fUT ) ) ) Y^ dXU QVVQYbc _V dXU _dXUbo Q^T dXQd Yd gQc nVQb Vb_] _RfY_ec dXQd KQ¥WbUU^c S_e¥T ^_d XQfU QSS_]`¥YcXUT dXU TbeW(cgYdSXY^W cSXU]U _^ Ydc _g^ Ri cY]`¥i `ebSXQcY^W Uh`U^cYfU T_cQWU V_b]c Vb_] EQb Q^T _dXUb ]Q^eVQSdebUbc $_V gXYSX dXUbU gUbU Q``QbU^d¥i cUfUbQ¥% Q^T VY¥¥Y^W `bUcSbY`dY_^c gYdX dXUcU Uh`U^cYfU T_cQWU V_b]c _^ Ydc _g^ Y^YdYQdYfU)o 5I( Qd 2/0) I^¥Y[U Y^ @SNYJI 2TTI' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc g_b[UT d_WUdXUb d_ `ebceU dXU Y^dUbUcdc _V dXU U^dUb`bYcU Ri U^WQWY^W Y^ Q VZNI UWT VZT UhSXQ^WU _V ]_^Ui Y^ dXU V_b] _V nbURQdUc' QT]Y^YcdbQdYfU VUUc Q^T _dXUb c_Vd T_¥¥Qbco V_b `bUVUbbUT `¥QSU]U^d _^ V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc5 dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_e¥T ^_d XQfU U^WQWUT Y^ dXU Q¥¥UWUT VbQeT YV dXUi gUbU ^_d g_b[Y^W d_WUdXUb RUSQecU dXU Q¥¥UWUT VbQeT bUaeYbUT Q S__bTY^QdUT UVV_bd) 9[d) ,* Qd 13' 3/' +++) I^¥Y[U Y^ @SNYJI gXUbU dXU `¥QY^dYVVc Qc[UT dXU S_ebd d_ Y^VUb S__bTY^QdUT QSdYfYdi cY]`¥i RUSQecU dXU QSdYfYdYUc _V R_dX TUVU^TQ^dc gUbU Q¥¥UWUT¥i Y¥¥UWQ¥ Q^T R_dX TUVU^TQ^dc RU^UVYddUT' =QbbYc 8_e^di `¥UQTc VQSdc Q¥¥UWY^W Q S__bTY^QdUT UVV_bd _^ RUXQ¥V _V Q¥¥ TUVU^TQ^dc d_ fY_¥QdU F>8D) 5I( Qd 10l+,-) HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU UfU^ `eR¥YS¥i QS[^_g¥UTWUT dXQd dXUi XQfU d_ Q¥¥_g ]_^Ui V_b bURQdUc c_ dXQd E7Bc gY¥¥ RU ]_dYfQdUT d_ `¥QSU dXUYb TbeWc _^ V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc) 5I( Qd /,) >^ @SNYJI 2TTI' dXU S_ebd V_e^T dXQd dXU `¥QY^dYVVqc Q¥¥UWQdY_^c gUbU nU^dYbU¥i S_^cYcdU^d gYdX NdXU TUVU^TQ^dcO UQSX W_Y^W QR_ed NdXUYbO _g^ RecY^Ucc)o 1+3 ;)-T Qd 2//) >^ S_^dbQcd' =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc Q¥¥UWUT dXQd R_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc QbU T_Y^W c_]UdXY^W ]_bU dXQ^ cY]`¥i S_^TeSdY^W RecY^Ucc Qc eceQ¥mdXUi QbU Q¥¥UWUT¥i S_^c`YbY^W d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i bQYcU `bYSUc d_ `b_VYd Vb_] dXU >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U) 9[d) ,* +2 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 19 of 43 Qd 10l+,-) AY[U dXU S_ebd Y^ 5S WJ 5SXZQNS <WNHNSL' dXU S_ebd VY^Tc dXQd nN`O¥QY^dYVVc XQfU Q¥¥UWUT S_^TeSd dXQd g_e¥T ^_d _SSeb Y^ S_]`UdYdY_^ V_b RecY^Ucc Y^ Q ¥UWYdY]QdU ]Qb[Ud)o 5S WJ 5SXZQNS <WNHNSL' ,*+3 KA 0.-1*3' Qd &0) HXU S_ebd Q¥c_ bUZUSdc dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq QbWe]U^d dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT nQ^ U^dUb`bYcU dXQd XQc Q^ UhYcdU^SU dXQd SQ^ RU TUVY^UT Q`Qbd Vb_] dXU S_]]YccY_^ _V dXU `bUTYSQdU QSdc)o 9[d) .+ Qd ,+l,, $ae_dY^W EFXYWT¥ [( 4TZX( -ZYT 5RUTWYX 3WJJS¥F^ 8YI(' 123 ;)-T //-' /0, $/dX 8Yb) ,*+/%%) >^ EFXYWT¥' dXU ;YVdX 8YbSeYd XU¥T dXQd dXU `¥QY^dYVV XQT ^_d QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT Q^ U^dUb`bYcU RUSQecU dXU `¥QY^dYVV nQ¥¥UWUNTO Q^ U^dUb`bYcU SbUQdUT Ri dXU Q¥¥UWUT bQS[UdUUbY^W QSdYfYdi YdcU¥V)o 123 ;)-T Qd /0,) >^ _dXUb g_bTc' dXUbU gQc ^_ Qcc_SYQdY_^ RUdgUU^ dXU dg_ TUVU^TQ^dc UhSU`d V_b dXU Q¥¥UWUT¥i Y¥¥UWQ¥ RUXQfY_b bU¥QdUT d_ dXU F>8D cSXU]U' Q^T dXU `¥QY^dYVV XQT ^_d cX_g^ dXQd dXU _bWQ^YjQdY_^ gQc _^W_Y^W _b Ve^SdY_^Y^W Qc Q nS_^dY^eY^W e^Yd)o 5I( $ae_dY^W 9TSYJXFST [( >JFKNWXY /TRRJWHNFQ /TWU(' 2+2 ;),T .,-' .,0 $/dX 8Yb) +321%%) >^ S_^dbQcd d_ dXU `¥QY^dYVV Y^ EFXYWT¥' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU Q^ Qcc_SYQdY_^ RUi_^T dXU Q¥¥UWUT `bUTYSQdU QSdc Y^ dXQd dXUbU QbU nS_^dbQSdeQ¥ bU¥QdY_^cXY`c' VY^Q^SYQ¥ dYUc Q^T S_^dY^eY^W S__bTY^QdY_^ _V QSdYfYdYUco RUdgUU^ dXU `QbdYUc) 9[d) ,* Qd 12) ;_b UhQ]`¥U' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^dbQSd gYdX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc nd_ ^UW_dYQdU bURQdUc' VUUc Q^T _dXUb S_^SUccY_^c gYdX dXU ]Q^eVQSdebUbc dXQd QbU `QYT RQS[ d_ dXU E7B)o 5I( Qd .,) 7_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc XQfU ¥_^WcdQ^TY^W bU¥QdY_^cXY`c gYdX UQSX _dXUb Q^T Y^dUbQSd gYdX UQSX _dXUb bUWe¥Qb¥i) 5I( Qd ./) ;_b UhQ]`¥U' dXU EXQb]QSUedYSQ¥ 8QbU BQ^QWU]U^d 6cc_SYQdY_^ X_¥Tc cUfUbQ¥ S_^VUbU^SUc UfUbi iUQb' Q^T Q¥¥ _V dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbU ]U]RUbc _V dXYc _bWQ^YjQdY_^) 5I( Qd ./) 9ebY^W dXU `Qcd cYh iUQbc' dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc gUbU nEbUcYTU^dYQ¥ G`_^c_bco _V dXUcU S_^VUbU^SUc) 5I( Qd .0) 6c c`_^c_bc' dXU +3 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 20 of 43 BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc X_cdUT ]UUdY^W b__]c dXQd _VVUbUT _``_bde^YdYUc V_b `bYfQdU Y^dUbQSdY_^c RUdgUU^ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc) 5I( 6¥dX_eWX dXU UfYTU^SU Q¥¥UWUT Ri =QbbYc 8_e^di d_ ce``_bd Q `QddUb^ _V bQS[UdUUbY^W _fUb¥Q`c gYdX dXU UfYTU^SU _V dXU Qcc_SYQdY_^(Y^(VQSd U^dUb`bYcU' dXU _^W_Y^W RecY^Ucc bU¥QdY_^cXY`c RUdgUU^ dXU TUVU^TQ^dc Y^TYSQdU Q^ Qcc_SYQdY_^ RUi_^T dXU `bUTYSQdU QSdc _V gXYSX dXU TUVU^TQ^dc QbU QSSecUT) >JJ .T^QJ' //0 I)G) Qd 3.1 $nNHOXU UfYTU^SU ecUT d_ `b_fU dXU `QddUb^ _V bQS[UdUUbY^W QSdYfYdi Q^T dXU UfYTU^SU UcdQR¥YcXY^W Q^ U^dUb`bYcU p]Qi Y^ `QbdYSe¥Qb SQcUc S_Q¥UcSU)qo $ae_dY^W @SNYJI >YFYJX [( ?ZWPJYYJ' ./, I)G) /10' /2-' +*+ G) 8d) ,/,. $+32+%%5 @SNYJI >YFYJX [( 1QQNTYY' /1+ ;),T 22*' 232 $/dX 8Yb) +312% $nN6O F>8D U^dUb`bYcU SQ^^_d RU Uh`USdUT d_ ]QY^dQY^ Q XYWX `b_VY¥U Y^ dXU S_]]e^Ydi) >dc QVVQYbc QbU ¥Y[U¥i d_ RU S_^TeSdUT Y^ cUSbUSi ) ) ) )o%) HXec' dXU ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T QbU 9:C>:9) '$ :4/8 9@RRDPM NE :@BJDRDDPHMF -BRHTHRV H_ UcdQR¥YcX Q `QddUb^ _V bQS[UdUUbY^W QSdYfYdi' nQ `¥QY^dYVV ]ecd cX_g R_dX Q bU¥QdY_^cXY` RUdgUU^ dXU `bUTYSQdU _VVU^cUcmXUbU ]QY¥ VbQeT Q^T gYbU VbQeTmQ^T dXU dXbUQd _V S_^dY^eY^W QSdYfYdi)o 9FQ[NST [( 0JQQZSN[JWXNYF' 2.* ;)-T ,,-' ,-+ $/dX 8Yb) ,*+0% $SYdY^W 4(6( 5SH( [( :¥( .JQQ ?JQ( /T(' .3, I)G) ,,3' ,-3' +*3 G) 8d) ,23- $+323%%) nNHO_ `b_fU Q `QddUb^ _V bQS[UdUUbY^W QSdYfYdi' Q `¥QY^dYVV ) ) ) ]ecd cX_g dXQd dXU bQS[UdUUbY^W `bUTYSQdUc QbU bU¥QdUT' FSI dXQd dXUi Q]_e^d d_ _b `_cU Q dXbUQd _V S_^dY^eUT SbY]Y^Q¥ QSdYfYdi)o 4(6(& 5SH(' .3, I)G) Qd ,-3) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc Q cSXU]U gXYSX Y^f_¥fUc dX_ecQ^Tc _V bU¥QdUT ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU dbQ^c]YccY_^c V_b dXU S_]]_^ `eb`_cU _V TUSUYfY^W =QbbYc 8_e^di Q^T _dXUb XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c dXQd Q¥¥UWUT¥i _SSebbUT _fUb Q `UbY_T _V ]Q^i iUQbc Q^T Yc cdY¥¥ _^W_Y^W d_TQi5 dXec' dXUbU Yc Q dXbUQd _V S_^dY^eY^W QSdYfYdi' Q^T dXU Q¥¥UWUT `bUTYSQdU QSdc QbU bU¥QdUT Qc `Qbd _V _^U Q¥¥UWUT cSXU]U) 9[d) ,* Qd /*' 0+l1.' 10l+,.) HXYc Yc U^_eWX d_ S_^cdYdedU Q `QddUb^ _V bQS[UdUUbY^W QSdYfYdi) 5I( ,* Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 21 of 43 HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc VQY¥UT d_ Q¥¥UWU nVQSdc TU]_^cdbQdY^W Q `QddUb^ _V SbY]Y^Q¥Ydi UhdU^TY^W RUi_^T dXU `bUTYSQdU QSdc dXU]cU¥fUco Q^T dXQd nNQO¥¥UWY^W `bUTYSQdU QSdc Yc ^_d U^_eWX V_b Q `QddUb^)o 9[d) .+ Qd +3) HXUi SYdU d_ SQcUc Vb_] dXU GUfU^dX 8YbSeYd gXYSX QbU VQSdeQ¥¥i Q^T ¥UWQ¥¥i TYcdY^WeYcXQR¥U) 5I( $SYdY^W 9JS_NJX [( >J^KFWYM >MF¥ 88<' 3.- ;)-T -,2' -., $1dX 8Yb) ,*+3%' HJWY( IJSNJI' ,*0 A) :T) ,T 2,/ $6`b) ,*' ,*,*% $X_¥TY^W dXQd VbQeT Q¥¥UWQdY_^c gXYSX _^¥i XQb]UT dg_ Y^TYfYTeQ¥c ngX_ Q¥¥UWUT¥i VU¥¥ fYSdY] d_ dXU cQ]U VbQeTe¥U^d cSXU]U ) ) ) Qd dXU cQ]U dY]Uo TebY^W Q S¥_cUT dY]U `UbY_T Y^ dXU `Qcd VQY¥UT d_ UcdQR¥YcX Q `QddUb^ e^TUb F>8D%5 @(>( ?J]YNQJX& 5SH( [( -SMJZXJW'.ZXHM /TX(& 5SH(' 3++ ;),T +,0+' +,02l03 $1dX 8Yb) +33*% $X_¥TY^W dXQd VbQeT Q¥¥UWQdY_^c bU¥QdY^W RQS[ d_ Q cY^W¥U S_^dbQSd TebY^W Q S¥_cUT dY]U `UbY_T Y^ dXU `Qcd TYT ^_d UcdQR¥YcX Q `QddUb^ V_b F>8D `eb`_cUc%5 8NUNS 1SYJWX( 5SH( [( 8JJ' 2*- ;),T -,,' -,. $1dX 8Yb) +320% $X_¥TY^W dXQd VbQeT Q¥¥UWQdY_^c bU¥QdY^W d_ TUVbQeTY^W _^¥i n_^U fYSdY] ) ) ) _^ _^U _SSQcY_^o TYT ^_d Q]_e^d d_ Q `QddUb^ e^TUb F>8D%%) HXUbUV_bU' dXU S_ebd bUZUSdc dXYc QbWe]U^d) HXU ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T QbU 9:C>:9) ($ /@SQ@RHNM F>8D `¥QY^dYVVc QbU bUaeYbUT d_ cX_g dXQd ndXU TUVU^TQ^dqc fY_¥QdY_^ ^_d _^¥i gQc Q pRed V_bq SQecU _V XYc Y^Zebi ) ) ) Red gQc dXU `b_hY]QdU SQecU Qc gU¥¥)o 4TQRJX [( >JH( 5S[( <WTY( /TWU(' /*- I)G) ,/2' ,02' ++, G) 8d) +-++ $+33,%) F>8D `¥QY^dYVVc ]ecd `b_fU dXQd dXUbU Yc Q nceVVYSYU^d¥i TYbUSd bU¥QdY_^cXY` RUdgUU^ dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq gb_^WVe¥ S_^TeSd Q^T dXU `¥QY^dYVVqc Y^Zebio d_ cQdYcVi dXU bUaeYbU]U^dc _V dXU `b_hY]QdU SQecU Q^Q¥icYc) >JJ .WNILJ' //- I)G) Qd 0/1l/2) 7ed nN`Ob_hY]QdU SQecU ) ) ) Yc Q V¥UhYR¥U S_^SU`d dXQd T_Uc ^_d ¥U^T YdcU¥V d_ pQ R¥QS[ ¥UddUb be¥U dXQd gY¥¥ TYSdQdU dXU bUce¥d Y^ UfUbi SQcU)qo 5I( Qd 0/. $ae_dY^W 4TQRJX' /*- I)G) Qd ,1, ^),*%) HXU F>8D cdQdedU bUaeYbUc `¥QY^dYVVc d_ nQ¥¥UWUNO UQSX U¥U]U^d _V dXU fY_¥QdY_^o Red nbUaeYbUc ^_ ]_bU dXQ^ dXYc)o >JINRF' .1- I)G) Qd .30l31) nKXUbU dXU `¥QY^dYVV Q¥¥UWUc UQSX ,+ Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 22 of 43 U¥U]U^d _V dXU fY_¥QdY_^' dXU S_]`U^cQR¥U Y^Zebi ^USUccQbY¥i Yc dXU XQb] SQecUT Ri `bUTYSQdU QSdc ceVVYSYU^d¥i bU¥QdUT d_ SQecU Q `QddUb^' V_b dXU UccU^SU _V dXU fY_¥QdY_^ Yc dXU S_]]YccY_^ _V dX_cU QSdc Y^ S_^^USdY_^ gYdX ) ) ) Q^ U^dUb`bYcU)o 5I( ;_b F>8D S¥QY]c RQcUT _^ ]QY¥ _b gYbU VbQeT' `¥QY^dYVVc T_ ^_d XQfU d_ `¥UQT bU¥YQ^SU' VYbcd(XQ^T _b _dXUbgYcU' d_ `b_fU `b_hY]QdU SQecU) >JJ .WNILJ' //- I)G) Qd 0.2 $nIcY^W dXU ]QY¥ d_ UhUSedU _b QddU]`d d_ UhUSedU Q cSXU]U d_ TUVbQeT Yc Y^TYSdQR¥U Qc ]QY¥ VbQeT' Q^T XU^SU Q `bUTYSQdU QSd _V bQS[UdUUbY^W e^TUb F>8D' UfU^ YV ^_ _^U bU¥YUT _^ Q^i ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^)o%5 >Y( 3JWRFNS [( 4T¥FWI' //0 ;)-T ,0+' ,0- $/dX 8Yb) ,**3% $nHXU Ge`bU]U 8_ebd bUSU^d¥i XU¥T dXQd ^_ bU¥YQ^SU bUaeYbU]U^d UhYcdc V_b SYfY¥ SQecUc _V QSdY_^ e^TUb F>8D V_b fYSdY]c _V ]QY¥ VbQeT)o% $SYdY^W .WNILJ' //- I)G) Qd 0-3%5 -QQXYFYJ 5SX( /T(' 2*, ;)-T Qd 010 $n>^ SQcUc `bUTYSQdUT _^ ]QY¥ _b gYbU VbQeT' bU¥YQ^SU Yc ^_d ^USUccQbi)o%) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QccUbd dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^diqc F>8D S¥QY]c cX_e¥T RU TYc]YccUT RUSQecU dXUi SQ^^_d `b_fU bU¥YQ^SU' Q^T dXec' SQ^^_d `b_fU `b_hY]QdU SQecQdY_^) 9[d) .+ Qd +0l +1) HXU `bY]Qbi SQcU d_ gXYSX dXUi SYdU V_b dXU `b_`_cYdY_^ dXQd c_]U ¥UfU¥ _V bU¥YQ^SU Yc bUaeYbUT Ri F>8D `¥QY^dYVVc d_ cX_g `b_hY]QdU SQecU QTTbUccUT dXU YcceU _V gXUdXUb `¥QY^dYVVc Y^ Q S¥Qcc QSdY_^ gUbU U^dYd¥UT d_ Q^ Y^VUbU^SU _V bU¥YQ^SU d_ cX_g dXQd bU¥YQ^SU gQc S_]]_^ d_ dXU U^dYbU S¥Qcc) 5I( Qd +0 $SYdY^W ?TWWJX [( >(3(1( 9LRY(& 8(8(/(' 2*/ ;)-T +./' +/+ $/dX 8Yb) ,*+/%' TS WJM#L JS GFSH' 2-2 ;)-T 0,3 $/dX 8Yb) ,*+0%%) >^ dXU SQcU dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU' dXU ;YVdX 8YbSeYd TUS¥Y^UT d_ QTTbUcc dXU UhdU^d d_ gXYSX bU¥YQ^SU gQc bUaeYbUT Y^ Q SYfY¥ F>8D SQcU RUSQecU dXU `¥QY^dYVVc nS_^SUTUNTO dXQd `b_hY]QdU SQecU Y^ dXUYb SQcU TU`U^TNUTO _^ bU¥YQ^SU)o 2*/ ;)-T Qd +/+) D^ bUXUQbY^W U^ RQ^S' dXU ;YVdX 8YbSeYd bUYdUbQdUT dXQd dXUbU Yc ^_ bU¥YQ^SU bUaeYbU]U^d V_b SYfY¥ F>8D S¥QY]c) ?TWWJX' 2-2 ;)-T Qd 0-1) HXU _dXUb SQcU d_ gXYSX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc SYdU Yc Q cdQdU S_ebd VbQeT SQcU dXQd XQc ^_dXY^W d_ T_ gYdX F>8D S¥QY]c) 9[d) .+ Qd +0 $SYdY^W BTWQI¥NIJ -XXJY <ZWHMFXNSL& 8(8(/( [( =JSY'-'/YW( 1(& 5SH(' ,3* G)K)-T //.' /00 $HUh) 6``)m9Q¥¥Qc ,**3' ,, Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 23 of 43 ^_ `Ud)%) HXec' dXU S_ebd bUZUSdc dXU QbWe]U^d dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT SQecQdY_^ RUSQecU Yd XQc ^_d `¥UT bU¥YQ^SU!# V_b dg_ bUQc_^c4 $+% F>8D `¥QY^dYVVc Q¥¥UWY^W ]QY¥ Q^T gYbU VbQeT QbU ^_d bUaeYbUT d_ cX_g bU¥YQ^SU' Q^T $,% UfU^ YV dXUi gUbU bUaeYbUT d_ cX_g c_]U di`U _V bU¥YQ^SU' =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT bU¥YQ^SU) >JJ .WNILJ' //- I)G) Qd 0/2 $n>^ ]_cd SQcUc' dXU `¥QY^dYVV gY¥¥ ^_d RU QR¥U d_ UcdQR¥YcX UfU^ Red(V_b SQecQdY_^ YV ST TSJ bU¥YUT _^ dXU ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^)o $U]`XQcYc QTTUT%%) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd Yd _fUb`QYT V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c gXYSX gUbU QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i _fUb`bYSUT Qc Q bUce¥d _V dXU >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U) 9[d) ,*' /3l1.) =QbbYc 8_e^di bU¥YUT _^ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq Q¥¥UWUT ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^c dXQd dXUi S_e¥T Q^T g_e¥T cQfU =QbbYc 8_e^di ]_^Ui Ri ^UW_dYQdY^W _^ Ydc RUXQ¥V V_b dXU Qd(YcceU TbeWc) 5I( Qd 0*l0+) 6TTYdY_^Q¥¥i' =QbbYc 8_e^di bU¥YUT _^ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq Q¥¥UWUT ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^ dXQd dXUYb TbeW V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc gUbU SbUQdUT Q^T ]QY^dQY^UT d_ `b_]_dU S¥YU^d cQVUdi Q^T XUQ¥dXm^_d Qc `Qbd _V Q^ Q¥¥UWUT VZNI UWT VZT QbbQ^WU]U^d RUdgUU^ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ UhSXQ^WU ]_^Ui Y^ dXU V_b] _V bURQdUc V_b `bUVUbbUT `¥QSU]U^d _^ V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc) 5I( Qd 10l+,.) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq TbeW V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc gUbU edY¥YjUT Ri =QbbYc 8_e^di d_ TUdUb]Y^U `bYSY^W V_b dXU Qd(YcceU ]UTYSQdY_^c' Q^T =QbbYc 8_e^di gQc Q¥¥UWUT¥i `eb`_cUVe¥¥i _fUbSXQbWUT Ri dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T `QYT dXQd _fUbSXQbWU TYbUSd¥i d_ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc) 5I( Qd 3*) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc gUbU Q¥¥UWUT¥i _^¥i QR¥U d_ ecU dXU QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc nQc Q RQcYc V_b dXU `bYSU =QbbYc 8_e^di `QYT ) ) ) RUSQecU =QbbYc 8_e^di bU¥YUT _^ 9UVU^TQ^dcq ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^c Q^T RU¥YUfUT dXQd dXU `bYSUNcO Yd `QYT 6c `Qbd _V dXU SQecQdY_^ Q^Q¥icYc' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd dXU S_ebd cX_e¥T S_^cYTUb =QbbYc 8_e^diqc _bYWY^Q¥ `UdYdY_^ VY¥UT Y^ cdQdU S_ebd) 9[d) .+ Qd +1) HXU S_ebd TUS¥Y^Uc d_ S_^cYTUb =QbbYc 8_e^diqc _bYWY^Q¥ `UdYdY_^ RUSQecU nQ^ Q]U^TUT S_]`¥QY^d _bTY^QbY¥i ce`UbcUTUc dXU _bYWY^Q¥ Q^T bU^TUbc Yd _V ^_ ¥UWQ¥ UVVUSd' e^¥Ucc dXU Q]U^TUT S_]`¥QY^d c`USYVYSQ¥¥i bUVUbc d_ _b QT_`dc dXU UQb¥YUb `¥UQTY^W)o .TJQJSX [( =JIRFS 4TRJX& 5SH(' 1/3 ;),T /*.' /*2 $/dX 8Yb) +32/%) ,- !# Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 24 of 43 gNUbUO bUQc_^QR¥U Q^T bUce¥dUT Vb_] S_]`UdYdYfU ]Qb[Ud V_bSUc)o 5I( Qd 1*l1+) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc [^Ug dXQd dXU `bYSUc _V dXU Qd(YcceU ]UTYSQdY_^c gUbU dXU bUce¥d _V dXU >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]Um^_d S_]`UdYdYfU ]Qb[Ud V_bSUcmQ^T `eb`_cUVe¥¥i nUh`¥_YdNUTO dXUYb ]Qb[Ud `_gUb d_ SQecU ceRcdQ^dYQ¥ Y^SbUQcUc Y^ dXU `bYSUNcO _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Y^ _bTUb d_ SbUQdU ]QccYfU `b_VYdc V_b dXU]cU¥fUc Q^T NdXUO BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc)o 5I( Qd /) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXU S_ebd VY^Tc dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT R_dX Red(V_b SQecQdY_^ Q^T `b_hY]QdU SQecQdY_^ RUSQecU dXUi XQfU Q¥¥UWUT dXQd dXUYb Y^ZebYUc g_e¥T ^_d XQfU _SSebbUT Red V_b dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq S_^TeSd Q^T dXUi XQfU cX_g^ Q TYbUSd bU¥QdY_^cXY` RUdgUU^ dXU Q¥¥UWUT S_^TeSd Q^T dXUYb Y^Zebi)!$ HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT SQecQdY_^ RUSQecU =QbbYc 8_e^diqc S_]`¥QY^dc QbU nTbUccUT Y^ F>8D S¥_dXY^Wo Red QSdeQ¥¥i QbU nW_fUb^UT Ri ) ) ) S_^dbQSdc)o 9[d) .+ Qd +1l+2) HXU S_ebd bUZUSdc dXYc QbWe]U^d RUSQecU =QbbYc 8_e^di Yc ^_d QbWeY^W dXQd Yd TYT ^_d [^_g QR_ed dXU bURQdUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc bUSUYfUT _b dXQd Q c`USYVYS S_^dbQSd XQc RUU^ RbUQSXUT) 9[d) .2 Qd -/) >^cdUQT' =QbbYc 8_e^di Yc Q¥¥UWY^W dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc ]YcbU`bUcU^dUT dXQd dXU bURQdUc gUbU V_b =QbbYc 8_e^diqc RU^UVYd Q^T dXQd dXU bURQdU cicdU] UhYcdUT d_ ¥_gUb `bYSUc _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c V_b =QbbYc 8_e^di) 9[d) ,* Qd 0+) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc ]Yc¥UQTY^W¥i bU¥QRU¥UT bURQdUc c_ Qc d_ Qf_YT `QiY^W dXU] d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di) 5I( Qd /1) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i bQYcU dXU `bYSU _V Y^ce¥Y^ Y^ Q VZNI UWT VZT UhSXQ^WU gXYSX ¥UT d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di _fUb`QiY^W V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c) 5I( Qd /' /,' 13' 3/' >^ dXUYb ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc' dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc T_ ^_d QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d QTUaeQdU¥i Q¥¥UWUT SQecQdY_^ Qc d_ dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dcq Q¥¥UWUT S_^TeSd) ,. !$ Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 25 of 43 +++) =QbbYc 8_e^diqc F>8D S¥QY] Yc ^_d Q TYcWeYcUT S¥QY] V_b RbUQSX _V S_^dbQSd) 9[d) ,*) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T Yc 9:C>:9) )$ :4/8 /NMQOHP@BV /K@HL GUSdY_^ +30,$T% _V F>8D `b_XYRYdc S_^c`YbY^W d_ fY_¥QdU F>8D) +2 I)G)8) k +30,$T%) nH_ TU]_^cdbQdU Q SYfY¥ F>8D S_^c`YbQSi' Q S¥QY]Q^d ]ecd cX_g dXQd4 $+% dg_ _b ]_bU `Ubc_^c QWbUUT d_ S_]]Yd Q ceRcdQ^dYfU F>8D _VVU^cU' Q^T $,% dXU TUVU^TQ^d [^Ug _V Q^T QWbUUT d_ dXU _fUbQ¥¥ _RZUSdYfU _V dXU F>8D _VVU^cU)o 0F[NX'8^SHM& 5SH( [( 9TWJST' 001 ;)-T /-3' //+ $/dX 8Yb) ,*+,%) HXU U¥U]U^dc _V Q F>8D S_^c`YbQSi SQ^ RU UcdQR¥YcXUT dXb_eWX SYbSe]cdQ^dYQ¥ UfYTU^SU RUSQecU S_^c`YbQd_bc di`YSQ¥¥i dbi d_ S_^SUQ¥ dXUYb S_^TeSd) >JJ& J(L(' @SNYJI >YFYJX [( 0JQLFIT' .*+ ;)-T ,3*' ,30 $/dX 8Yb) ,**/%5 @SNYJI >YFYJX [( <TXFIF'=NTX' +/2 ;)-T 2-,' 2/1 $/dX 8Yb) +332%) 6¥¥UWUT S_^c`YbQd_bc n^UUT _^¥i XQfU [^_g^ _V Q^T QWbUUT d_ dXU _fUbQ¥¥ _RZUSdYfU _V dXU F>8D _VVU^cU)o 0JQLFIT' .*+ ;)-T Qd ,30) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd dXU k +30,$T% S¥QY] V_b S_^c`YbQSi d_ fY_¥QdU F>8D cX_e¥T RU TYc]YccUT RUSQecU =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT Ydc k +30,$S% S¥QY] Q^T XQc ^_d `¥UT VQSdc dXQd ceWWUcd Q S_^c`YbQSi d_ fY_¥QdU F>8D) 9[d) .+ Qd ,/) HXU S_ebd XQc Q¥bUQTi S_^S¥eTUT dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT Q k +30,$S% S¥QY]) HXU S_ebd Q¥c_ VY^Tc dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT Q k +30,$T% S¥QY]) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QWbUUT d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdU dXU bU`_bdUT `bYSUc _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Y^ Q cSXU]U d_ TUVbQeT =QbbYc 8_e^di Q^T _dXUb XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c) 9[d) ,* Qd 10l+,.) 6c `b__V _V dXQd QWbUU]U^d' =QbbYc 8_e^di S_^dU^Tc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Y^SbUQcUT dXUYb bU`_bdUT `bYSUc Y^ ¥_S[cdU` gYdX UQSX _dXUb _^ ]e¥dY`¥U _SSQcY_^c Q^T QbWeUc dXQd dXU `bYSUc _V dXU Qd(YcceU ]UTYSQdY_^c _^¥i Y^SbUQcUT QVdUb E7Bc RUWQ^ `¥QiY^W Q ]_bU `_gUbVe¥ b_¥U Y^ dXU `XQb]QSUedYSQ¥ Y^Tecdbi Y^ ,**-) 5I( Qd -+l.*) =QbbYc 8_e^di T_Uc ^_d ]UbU¥i Q¥¥UWU `QbQ¥¥U¥ S_^TeSd5 Yd Q¥¥UWUc ,/ Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 26 of 43 dXQd R_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc U^WQWUT Y^ Q VZNI UWT VZT UhSXQ^WU _V bURQdUc V_b `bUVUbbUT V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycd `¥QSU]U^d) 5I( Qd /+) =QbbYc 8_e^di `¥UQTc VQSdc dXQd ceWWUcd Q `bUSUTY^W QWbUU]U^d RUdgUU^ dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc) >JJ 5S WJ 5SXZQNS <WNHNSL' ,*+3 KA 0.-1*3' Qd &1 $X_¥TY^W dXQd `¥QY^dYVVc XQT QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT Q F>8D S_^c`YbQSi Ri nQccUbdNY^WO VQSdc dXQd ceWWUcdNUTO Q `bUSUTY^W QWbUU]U^do Q^T nQ¥¥UWNY^WO cU`QbQdU S_^c`YbQSYUc _V `bYSY^W U^dUb`bYcUco%) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXUcU Wb_e^Tc Yc 9:C>:9) *$ 4MCHPDBR#9SPBG@QDP :SKD 7_dX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^dU^T dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^diqc F>8D S¥QY]c QbU RQbbUT Ri dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U) 9[dc) .*' .+) HXU I)G) Ge`bU]U 8_ebd ¥QYT dXU V_e^TQdY_^ V_b dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U Y^ 4FST[JW >MTJ gXU^ Yd bUZUSdUT dXU n`QccY^W( _^ TUVU^cUo _V Q^ Q^dYdbecd TUVU^TQ^d gX_ QbWeUT dXQd dXU `¥QY^dYVV S_e¥T ^_d bUS_fUb dbUR¥U TQ]QWUc V_b S_cdc gXYSX gUbU e¥dY]QdU¥i n`QccUT _^o d_ Ydc Secd_]Ubc) 4FST[JW >MTJ& 5SH( [( @SNYJI >MTJ 9FHM( /TWU(' -3, I)G) .2+' .3.' 22 G) 8d) ,,,. $+302%) >^ 5QQNSTNX .WNHP' dXU 8_ebd UhQ]Y^UT Q bU¥QdUT YcceU4 gXUdXUb Q^ Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb `¥QY^dYVV S_e¥T _VVU^cYfU¥i ecU Q n`Qcc(_^ dXU_bio QWQY^cd Q^ Q¥¥UWUT Q^dYdbecd fY_¥Qd_b) 5QQ( .WNHP' .-+ I)G) Qd 1,0) HXU GdQdU _V >¥¥Y^_Yc Q^T Xe^TbUTc _V ¥_SQ¥ W_fUb^]U^dQ¥ U^dYdYUc Rb_eWXd ceYd QWQY^cd Q Wb_e` _V ]Q^eVQSdebUbc gX_ XQT Q¥¥UWUT¥i U^WQWUT Y^ Q `bYSU(VYhY^W S_^c`YbQSi Y^f_¥fY^W _fUb`bYSUT S_^SbUdU R¥_S[c Y^ fY_¥QdY_^ _V dXU GXUb]Q^ 6Sd) 5I( HXU GdQdU _V >¥¥Y^_Yc TYT ^_d `ebSXQcU dXU R¥_S[c TYbUSd¥i Vb_] dXU ]Q^eVQSdebUbc) 5I( >^cdUQT' dXU ]Q^eVQSdebUbc c_¥T dXU R¥_S[c d_ ]Qc_^bi S_^dbQSd_bc gX_ dXU^ ecUT dXU R¥_S[c d_ ReY¥T ]Qc_^bi cdbeSdebUc) 5I( <U^UbQ¥ S_^dbQSd_bc dXU^ `ebSXQcUT dX_cU cdbeSdebUc Q^T ecUT dXU] d_ ReY¥T U^dYbU ReY¥TY^Wc' gXYSX dXUi c_¥T d_ dXU GdQdU _V >¥¥Y^_Yc) 5I( HXU 8_ebd XU¥T dXQd dXU cdQdUqc `ebSXQcUc _V dXU S_^SbUdU R¥_S[c gUbU d__ VQb T_g^ dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^ V_b dXU cdQdU d_ RbY^W ceYd QWQY^cd dXU ]Q^eVQSdebUbc) 5I( Qd 1-/) HXU 8_ebd bUQc_^UT dXQd Q¥¥_gY^W Y^TYbUSd ,0 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 27 of 43 `ebSXQcUbc cUfUbQ¥ cdU`c T_g^ dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^ d_ RbY^W ceYd QWQY^cd Q^ U^dYdi VebdXUb e` dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^ g_e¥T bUce¥d Y^ ]e¥dY`¥U ¥YQRY¥Ydi V_b TUVU^TQ^dc Q^T n]QccYfU ]e¥dY`Qbdi ¥YdYWQdY_^c Y^f_¥fY^W ]Q^i ¥UfU¥c _V TYcdbYRedY_^ Q^T Y^S¥eTY^W ¥QbWU S¥QccUc _V e¥dY]QdU S_^ce]Ubc bU]_dU Vb_] dXU TUVU^TQ^d)o 5I( Qd 1.*) HXec' e^TUb 5QQNSTNX .WNHP' _^¥i TYbUSd `ebSXQcUbc SQ^ RbY^W ceYd QWQY^cd Q¥¥UWUT Q^dYdbecd fY_¥Qd_bc) 5I( Qd 1-/) =QbbYc 8_e^di ebWUc dXU S_ebd ^_d d_ Q``¥i dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U d_ dXYc SQcU RUSQecU dXU ;YVdX 8YbSeYd XQc ^UfUb Uh`¥YSYd¥i QTTbUccUT dXU YcceU _V gXUdXUb dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U Q``¥YUc d_ F>8D S¥QY]c) 9[d) .2 Qd ,+) =QbbYc 8_e^di bUaeUcdc Y^cdUQT dXQd dXU S_ebd V_¥¥_g dXU ]Y^_bYdi be¥U QbdYSe¥QdUT Y^ 5S WJ, 1UN<JS' gXYSX Q¥¥_gc F>8D `¥QY^dYVVc d_ UcdQR¥YcX cdQ^TY^W d_ QccUbd Q F>8D S¥QY] UfU^ YV `¥QY^dYVVc QbU Y^TYbUSd `ebSXQcUbc) 9[d) .2 Qd ,,l,-5 XJJ 5S WJ, 1UN<JS $1UNSJUMWNSJ 5SOJHYNTS& @><% 9PYL(& >FQJX <WFHYNHJX " -SYNYWZXY 8NYNL(' --0 ;) Ge``) -T +,/0' +-,/ $9) @Q^) ,*+2%) HXU Ge`bU]U 8_ebd XQc ^UfUb QTTbUccUT dXU YcceU _V gXUdXUb dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U Q``¥YUc d_ F>8D S¥QY]c' Red Y^ 4TQRJX' dXU 8_ebd Q``¥YUT Q^dYdbecd `bY^SY`¥Uc d_ dXU YcceU _V SQecQdY_^ Y^ F>8D S¥QY]c) 4TQRJX [( >JH( 5S[( <WTY( /TWU(' /*- I)G) Qd ,0/l02) HXU 8_ebd bUQc_^UT dXQd n8_^WbUcc ]_TU¥UT k +30.$S% N_V F>8DO _^ dXU SYfY¥(QSdY_^ `b_fYcY_^ _V dXU VUTUbQ¥ Q^dYdbecd ¥Qgco Q^T dXec XQT Y^dU^TUT V_b dXU ¥Q^WeQWU Y^ F>8D nd_ XQfU dXU cQ]U ]UQ^Y^W dXQd S_ebdc XQT Q¥bUQTi WYfU^o dXQd ¥Q^WeQWU Y^ Y^dUb`bUdY^W Q^dYdbecd ¥Qgc) 5I( Qd ,01l02) =QbbYc 8_e^di QbWeUc dXQd' Y^ S_^dbQcd d_ 4TQRJX' 5QQNSTNX .WNHP gQc TUSYTUT QVdUb F>8D gQc QT_`dUT Q^T dXec 8_^WbUcc nS_e¥T ^_d XQfU [^_g^ QR_ed Q^T Y^dU^TUT d_ Y^f_[U 5QQNSTNX .WNHPqc Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U Y^ dXU cQ]U gQi dXQd Yd [^Ug QR_ed Q^T Y^dU^TUT d_ Y^f_[U S_]]_^ ¥Qg `b_hY]QdU SQecU `bY^SY`¥Uc)o 9[d) .2 Qd ,,) HXU 5S WJ, 1UNUJS S_ebd bUQc_^UT dXQd dXU I)G) Ge`bU]U 8_ebd _^¥i UhdU^TUT Q^dYdbecd `b_hY]QdU SQecU be¥Uc d_ F>8D S¥QY]c Q^T dXQd dXU 4TQRJX 8_ebdqc TUSYcY_^ TYT ,1 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 28 of 43 ^_d ^USUccQbY¥i ceWWUcd dXQd Q¥¥ Q^dYdbecd `bY^SY`¥Uc cX_e¥T Q``¥i d_ F>8D SQcUc) --0 ;) Ge``) -T Qd +-,.l+-,/) =_gUfUb' dXU I)G) Ge`bU]U 8_ebd XQc nbU`UQdUT¥i _RcUbfUT dXQd 8_^WbUcc ]_TU¥UT k +30.$S% _^ dXU SYfY¥(QSdY_^ `b_fYcY_^ _V dXU VUTUbQ¥ Q^dYdbecd ¥Qgc)o 4TQRJX' /*- I)G) Qd ,01 $SYdQdY_^c _]YddUT%) HXec' dXU S_ebd TUS¥Y^Uc d_ aeUcdY_^ dXU Ge`bU]U 8_ebdqc X_¥TY^W Y^ 4TQRJX dXQd ceWWUcdc dXQd Q^dYdbecd `bY^SY`¥Uc Q``¥i d_ F>8D S¥QY]c) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXU S_ebd TUS¥Y^Uc d_ V_¥¥_g dXU ]Y^_bYdi be¥U Q^T Yc Y^S¥Y^UT d_ V_¥¥_g dXU dXbUU SYbSeYd S_ebdc dXQd XQfU QTTbUccUT dXYc YcceU Q^T XU¥T dXQd Y^TYbUSd `ebSXQcUbc ¥QS[ cdQ^TY^W e^TUb F>8D) ?WTQQNSLJW [( ?^XTS 2TTIX& 5SH(' -1* ;)-T 0*,' 0+0 $0dX 8Yb) ,**.% $nN>O^TYbUSd `ebSXQcUbc ¥QS[ cdQ^TY^W e^TUb F>8D ) ) ) d_ ceU V_b _fUbSXQbWUc `QccUT _^ d_ dXU] Ri ]YTT¥U]U^)o%5 9H/FWYM^ [( =JHTWIJ] >JW[(& 5SH(' 2* ;)-T 2.,' 2// $-T 8Yb) +330% $nN6O^dYdbecd cdQ^TY^W `bY^SY`¥Uc Q``¥i UaeQ¥¥i d_ Q¥¥UWQdY_^c _V F>8D fY_¥QdY_^c)o%5 /FWYJW [( .JWLJW' 111 ;),T ++1-' ++11 $1dX 8Yb) +32/% $nHXU 4FST[JW >MTJ`5QQNSTNX .WNHP be¥U `b_]_dUc U^V_bSU]U^d Q^T dXUbUV_bU Q``¥YUc d_ F>8D' d__)o%) HXU S_ebd X_¥Tc dXQd dXU 5QQNSTNX .WNHP 8_ebdqc RQb _^ Y^TYbUSd( `ebSXQcUb ceYdc Q``¥YUc d_ F>8D S¥QY]c) 7_dX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di Yc ^_d Q TYbUSd `ebSXQcUb _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Q^T dXQd dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U Y^ 5QQNSTNX .WNHP RQbc =QbbYc 8_e^di Vb_] QccUbdY^W Q F>8D S¥QY]) 9[dc) .*' .+) :QSX Wb_e` _V TUVU^TQ^dc ceR]Ydc Xe^TbUTc _V `QWUc _V VQSdeQ¥ Q¥¥UWQdY_^c' gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^di TYc`edUc' Y^ Q^ QddU]`d d_ cX_g dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di Yc ^_d Q TYbUSd `ebSXQcUb) 5I( 6]_^W _dXUb QccUbdY_^c' dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥¥UWU dXQd nE7Bc T_ ^_d `ebSXQcU `bUcSbY`dY_^ TbeWc dXU]cU¥fUc' ^_b T_ dXUi ]Q[U Q^i `Qi]U^dc d_ TbeW ]Q^eVQSdebUbc)o 9[d) .* Qd 1) HXUi Q¥c_ S¥QY] dXQd nNYO^cebUbc' XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c' Q^T E7Bc QbU ^_d Y^f_¥fUT Y^ dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^o Q^T dXQd E7Bc nT_ ^_d dQ[U `XicYSQ¥ `_ccUccY_^ _V ]UTYSQdY_^)o 5I( Qd /) 7_dX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc `_Y^d d_ dXU ,2 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 29 of 43 TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^ Qc UfYTU^SU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di Yc ^_d Q TYbUSd `ebSXQcUb) 5I( =QbbYc 8_e^di QccUbdc Y^ bUc`_^cU dXQd nNdOXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^ ) ) ) Yc ^_d Qd(YcceU NcYSO Y^ dXYc SQcU ) ) ) )o 9[d) .2 Qd +/) >^cdUQT' =QbbYc 8_e^diqc S¥QY]c QbU QR_ed dXU `bYSY^W SXQY^) 9[d) ,* Qd .*) 7USQecU dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc `¥Qi TYVVUbU^d b_¥Uc Y^ dXU `bYSY^W SXQY^' dXU S_ebd Q^Q¥ijUc dXU] cU`QbQdU¥i Q^T gY¥¥ QTTbUcc dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Y^ dXU ^Uhd ceRcUSdY_^) >JJ EQbd >>>)6)1' NSKWF) HXU S_ebd gY¥¥ ^_d QTTbUcc dXU ]Q^i VQSdeQ¥ TYc`edUc Y^ dXU bUS_bT RUdgUU^ dXU `QbdYUc Qd dXYc UQb¥i cdQWU Y^ dXU SQcU) 6d dXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc cdQWU' dXU S_ebd ]ecd QSSU`d dXU `¥QY^dYVVqc Q¥¥UWQdY_^c Qc dbeU) 7FNXJW -QZRNSZR " /MJR( >FQJX& 5SH( [( -[TSIFQJ >MNU^FWIX& 5SH(' 011 ;),T +*./' +*/* $/dX 8Yb) +32,% $nNKOU ]ecd QSSU`d Qc dbeU Q¥¥ gU¥¥ `¥UQTUT VQSdc Y^ dXU S_]`¥QY^d' Q^T dXU S_]`¥QY^d Yc d_ RU ¥YRUbQ¥¥i S_^cdbeUT Y^ VQf_b _V dXU `¥QY^dYVV)o%) 6SS_bTY^W d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di' nNdOXU `XQb]QSUedYSQ¥ Y^Tecdbi ) ) ) Yc e^YaeU Y^ dXQd dXU `bYSY^W SXQY^ Yc TYcdY^Sd Vb_] dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^)o 9[d) ,* Qd .*) E7Bc nS_^dbQSd gYdX Q ^Udg_b[ _V bUdQY¥ `XQb]QSYUc) EXQb]QSYUc QWbUU d_ TYc`U^cU TbeWc d_ `QdYU^dc Q^T E7Bc `Qi dXU `XQb]QSYUc V_b dXU TbeWc TYc`U^cUT)o 5I( Qd .,) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUT¥i ]Q[U ]_^Ui Ri `b_fYTY^W `XQb]QSUedYSQ¥ TbeWc TYbUSd¥i Ri n_`UbQdNY^WO dXUYb _g^ XYWX¥i `b_VYdQR¥U N]QY¥(_bTUbO `XQb]QSYUc)o 5I( Qd /3) 6SS_bTY^W d_ dXU S_]`¥QY^d' ndXU XYWXUb dXU `bYSU dXQd NdXUO E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbU QR¥U d_ WUd dXUYb Secd_]Ubc' ceSX Qc XUQ¥dX `¥Q^c ¥Y[U =QbbYc 8_e^di' d_ `Qi V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c' dXU XYWXUb dXU `b_VYd NdXUO E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc bUQ¥YjU dXb_eWX dXUYb _g^ N]QY¥(_bTUbO `XQb]QSYUc)o 5I( BQ^i E7Bc n_g^ ]QY¥(_bTUb Q^T c`USYQ¥di `XQb]QSYUc' gXYSX `ebSXQcU Q^T dQ[U `_ccUccY_^ _V `bUcSbY`dY_^ TbeWc' Y^S¥eTY^W dX_cU Qd YcceU XUbU' Q^T TYbUSd¥i ce``¥i dX_cU TbeWc d_ `QdYU^dc Ri ]QY¥)o 5I( Qd .,) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd Yd `Qic dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc INWJHYQ^ V_b dXU _fUbSXQbWUc _V dXU TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Qd YcceU Y^ dXYc SQcU' n^_d Q^ Y^dUbfU^Y^W TYcdbYRed_b _b _dXUb ¥Y^[ Y^ dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^)o 9[d) ,3 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 30 of 43 .2 Qd +-) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUT¥i `Qic E7Bc d_ ]Q^QWU dXU QT]Y^YcdbQdYfU RebTU^ _V Ydc `XQb]QSUedYSQ¥ `b_WbQ] Q^T bU¥YUc _^ E7Bc d_ S_^db_¥ TbeW S_cdc' Q^T _^¥i dXU nE7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^db_¥ gXYSX Y^ce¥Y^ `b_TeSdc QbU QfQY¥QR¥U d_ S_^ce]Ubc)o 9[d) ,* Qd 1.' 9[d) .2 Qd +.) 6SS_bTY^W¥i' dXU S_ebd X_¥Tc dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di Yc ^_d Q^ Y^TYbUSd `ebSXQcUb e^TUb 5QQNSTNX .WNHP' Q^T Ydc F>8D S¥QY]c QWQY^cd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbU ^_d RQbbUT Ri dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U) HXU Ge`bU]U 8_ebdqc ]_cd bUSU^d TUSYcY_^ Y^f_¥fY^W dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U XU¥`c U¥eSYTQdU dXU S_ebdqc VY^TY^W dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^diqc F>8D S¥QY]c QWQY^cd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbU ^_d RQbbUT Ri 5QQNSTNX .WNHP) >^ -UUQJ 5SH( [( <JUUJW' YEX_^U ecUbc gX_ `ebSXQcUT Q``c Vb_] 6``¥Uqc Q`` cd_bU Rb_eWXd ceYd QWQY^cd 6``¥U V_b Q¥¥UWUT¥i fY_¥QdY^W Q^dYdbecd ¥Qgc Ri ecY^W Ydc Q`` cd_bU d_ _fUbSXQbWU S_^ce]Ubc) -UUQJ 5SH( [( <JUUJW' +-3 G) 8d) +/+.' +/+2 $,*+3%) 6``¥U QbWeUT dXQd dXU S_^ce]Ub `¥QY^dYVVc gUbU Y^TYbUSd `ebSXQcUbc Q^T TYT ^_d XQfU cdQ^TY^W d_ `ebceU dXUYb S¥QY]c RUSQecU nQ`` TUfU¥_`Ubc' ^_d 6``¥U' cUd dXU bUdQY¥ `bYSU SXQbWUT d_ S_^ce]Ubc)o 5I( Qd +/,+) HXU Ge`bU]U 8_ebd bUZUSdUT 6``¥Uqc QbWe]U^d Q^T XU¥T dXQd dXU S_^ce]Ub `¥QY^dYVVc gUbU ^_d RQbbUT e^TUb dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U RUSQecU dXUi `QYT dXU _fUbSXQbWUc TYbUSd¥i d_ 6``¥U Q^T dXUbU gQc ^_ Y^dUb]UTYQbi Y^ dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^ RUdgUU^ dXU]) 5I( Qd +/,,) HXU 8_ebd gQc cY]Y¥Qb¥i e^`UbceQTUT Ri 6``¥Uqc QbWe]U^d dXQd dXU S_^ce]Ub `¥QY^dYVVc cX_e¥T RU RQbbUT Ri dXU Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U RUSQecU TQ]QWUc g_e¥T RU TYVVYSe¥d d_ SQ¥Se¥QdU Q^T _dXUb `_dU^dYQ¥ `¥QY^dYVVc Y^ dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^ S_e¥T Q¥c_ ceU 6``¥U V_b dXUYb Q¥¥UWUT¥i Q^dYS_]`UdYdYfU RUXQfY_b) 5I( Qd +/,.) HXU 8_ebd ^_dUT dXQd n5QQNSTNX .WNHP Yc ^_d Q WUd(_ed(_V(S_ebd(VbUU SQbT V_b ]_^_`_¥YcdYS bUdQY¥Ubc d_ `¥Qi Q^i dY]U dXQd Q TQ]QWUc SQ¥Se¥QdY_^ ]YWXd RU S_]`¥YSQdUT)o 5I( >^ dXU `bUcU^d SQcU' dQ[Y^W dXU VQSdc Q¥¥UWUT Y^ dXU S_]`¥QY^d Qc dbeU' _^¥i dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^db_¥ dXU `bYSU =QbbYc 8_e^di `Qic V_b dXU TbeWc Qd YcceU' Q^T dXUi XQfU Q¥¥UWUT¥i S_^c`YbUT d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdU dX_cU `bYSUc V_b dXUYb _g^ WQY^) 9[d) ,* Qd -* Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 31 of 43 1.) 6¥¥UWUT¥i dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc cU¥¥ TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c TYbUSd¥i dXb_eWX dXUYb _g^ ]QY¥( _bTUb `XQb]QSYUc) 5I( Qd /3) AY[U Y^ -UUQJ gXUbU nNdOXU QRcU^SU _V Q^ Y^dUb]UTYQbi NgQcO TYc`_cYdYfU'o dXUbU Yc ^_ Y^dUbfU^Y^W TYcdbYRed_b _b _dXUb ¥Y^[ Y^ dXU SXQY^ RUdgUU^ =QbbYc 8_e^di Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc) +-3 G) 8d) Qd +/,+5 9[d) ,* Qd .,) AY[U Y^ -UUQJ gXUbU dXU 8_ebd gQc `UbceQTUT Ri dXU VQSd dXQd dXU `¥QY^dYVV S_^ce]Ubc `QYT dXU _fUbSXQbWUc TYbUSd¥i d_ 6``¥U' dXU Q¥¥UWQdY_^c dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di `Qic Ydc _fUbSXQbWUc TYbUSd¥i d_ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbU TYc`_cYdYfU Qd dXYc cdQWU) >JJ 9[d) .2 Qd +/) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc `_Y^d d_ TYcdbYSd S_ebd SQcUc Y^ CUg ?UbcUi Y^ gXYSX dXU `¥QY^dYVVc ]QTU cY]Y¥Qb Q¥¥UWQdY_^c QWQY^cd Y^ce¥Y^ ]Q^eVQSdebUbc Qc UfYTU^SU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di Yc ^_d Q TYbUSd `ebSXQcUb) 9[dc) .* Qd +.' .+ Qd 2) HXU S_ebd Yc ^_d R_e^T Ri dX_cU SQcUc' Q^T dXUi QbU ^UfUbdXU¥Ucc TYcdY^WeYcXQR¥U Y^ bUWQbT d_ dXU TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U Q^Q¥icYc) >^ 9>< =JHT[JW^ /QFNRX' dXU `¥QY^dYVVcq S_]`¥QY^d Q¥¥UWUT Q SXQY^ _V TYcdbYRedY_^ cY]Y¥Qb d_ dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^ Y^ 5QQNSTNX .WNHP Q^T S_^SUTUT dXQd dXUbU gUbU ]e¥dY`¥U Y^dUb]UTYQbYUc RUdgUU^ dXU `¥QY^dYVVc Q^T dXU TUVU^TQ^dc5 dXUi TYT ^_d Q¥¥UWU dXQd dXUi `QYT _fUbSXQbWUc TYbUSd¥i d_ TUVU^TQ^dc Qc =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc XUbU) 9>< =JHT[JW^ /QFNRX' ,*+3 KA +.+2+,3' Qd &+-l+.5 XJJ FQXT 9NSS( G^ 1QQNXTS [( >FSTKN'-[JSYNX @(>( 88/' ,*,* KA ,-3.+//' Qd &3 $X_¥TY^W dXQd dXU GdQdU _V BY^^Uc_dQ gQc RQbbUT Ri dXU Y^TYbUSd `ebSXQcUb be¥U Vb_] `ebceY^W S¥QY]c QWQY^cd Y^ce¥Y^ ]Q^eVQSdebUbc RUSQecU dXU cdQdU TYT ^_d Q¥¥UWU dXQd dXUi `ebSXQcUT Y^ce¥Y^ Vb_] Q^i TUVU^TQ^dc%) >^ 5S WJ 5SXZQNS <WNHNSL' dXU `¥QY^dYVVc gUbU nY^TYfYTeQ¥c ) ) ) gX_ VY¥UT ) ) ) _^ RUXQ¥V _V dXU]cU¥fUc Q^T Q `b_`_cUT ^QdY_^gYTU S¥Qcc _V Q^Q¥_W Y^ce¥Y^ S_^ce]Ubc'o ^_d XUQ¥dXSQbU `b_fYTUbc ¥Y[U =QbbYc 8_e^di) 5S WJ 5SXZQNS <WNHNSL' ,*+3 KA 0.-1*3' Qd &+) HXU `¥QY^dYVVc Y^ dXQd SQcU Q¥c_ TYT ^_d Q¥¥UWU dXQd dXUi `QYT _fUbSXQbWUc TYbUSd¥i d_ TUVU^TQ^dc Qc =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc XUbU) 5I( Qd &2 $nE¥QY^dYVVcq 8_]`¥QY^d ]UbU¥i Q¥¥UWUc dXQd 9UVU^TQ^dcq QbdYVYSYQ¥ `bYSU Y^V¥QdY_^ ) ) ) SQecUT dXU] d_ `Qi Q^ Y^SbUQcUT `bYSU -+ Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 32 of 43 V_b Q^Q¥_W Y^ce¥Y^' iUd ^UfUb Q¥¥UWUc dXQd ceSX _fUb`Qi]U^dc gUbU ]QTU TYbUSd¥i d_ 9UVU^TQ^dc)o%) 7USQecU =QbbYc 8_e^di S¥QY]c dXQd +% Yd `Qic dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc TYbUSd¥i V_b Q¥¥UWUT _fUbSXQbWUc Q^T ,% dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc ce``¥i c_]U _V dXU Qd(YcceU TbeWc TYbUSd¥i d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di dXb_eWX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq ]QY¥(_bTUb `XQb]QSYUc' 5QQNSTNX .WNHP T_Uc ^_d RQb =QbbYc 8_e^di Vb_] `ebceY^W Ydc F>8D S¥QY]c QWQY^cd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Qd dXYc cdQWU Y^ dXU ¥YdYWQdY_^) HXec' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcq ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T Yc 9:C>:9) +$ /N#/NMQOHP@RNP W1UBDORHNMX >^ S_^dbQcd d_ Ydc Q¥¥UWQdY_^c QWQY^cd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc' =QbbYc 8_e^di T_Uc ^_d Q¥¥UWU dXQd Yd `Qic Q^i _fUbSXQbWUc TYbUSd¥i d_ dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc) 9[d) ,*) =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d Q¥¥UWUT dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc cU¥¥ Y^ce¥Y^ dXb_eWX ]QY¥(_bTUb `XQb]QSYUc _b dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di `Qic Q^i Q]_e^d _V ]_^Ui TYbUSd¥i d_ dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc) 5I( HXec' dXUbU QbU Y^dUb]UTYQbYUc RUdgUU^ =QbbYc 8_e^di Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc) 5I( =_gUfUb' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU S_^c`YbUT d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i bQYcU `bYSUc _V Y^ce¥Y^ Q^T _dXUb TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c' Q^T 5QQNSTNX .WNHP T_Uc ^_d RQb Y^TYbUSd `ebSXQcUbc Vb_] VY¥Y^W ceYd QWQY^cd S_(S_^c`YbQd_bc Y^ Q^ Q¥¥UWUT `bYSU(VYhY^W S_^c`YbQSi) 5I( Qd .2l//) ;UTUbQ¥ S_ebdc XQfU ¥_^W bUS_W^YjUT Q^ UhSU`dY_^ d_ 5QQNSTNX .WNHPqc Y^TYbUSd(`ebSXQcUb be¥U gXU^ `¥QY^dYVVc Q¥¥UWU dXQd dXUi `ebSXQcUT TYbUSd¥i Vb_] Q S_(S_^c`YbQd_b Y^ Q `bYSU(VYhY^W S_^c`YbQSi) >JJ& J(L(' <FUJW >^X( 5SH( [( :NUUTS <FUJW 5SIZX( /T(' ,2+ ;)-T 0,3' 0-+l-, $1dX 8Yb) ,**,% $X_¥TY^W dXQd dXU VYbcd `ebSXQcUb Vb_] _edcYTU dXU S_^c`YbQSi Yc dXU nbYWXd `Qbdi d_ ceUo%5 >YFYJ TK -WN_( [( >MFRWTHP 2TTIX /T(' 1,3 ;),T +,++' +,+/ $3dX 8Yb) +32.% $n5QQNSTNX .WNHP T_Uc ^_d `bUfU^d ) ) ) `bYSU(VYhY^W S¥QY]NcO)o%5 8FZRFSS [( :FY#Q 4THPJ^ 8JFLZJ' 3*1 ;) Ge``) ,T .0/' .2, $G)9)C)M) ,*+,% $X_¥TY^W dXQd dXU VYbcd `ebSXQcUbc gX_ QbU ^_d `Qbd _V dXU S_^c`YbQSi QbU U^dYd¥UT -, Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 33 of 43 d_ S_¥¥USd TQ]QWUc%5 2ZSJWFQ /TSXZRJWX -QQ(& 5SH( [( >JW[( /TWU( 5SY#Q' C_) 8J =(*/(--3.' ,**0 KA 2../1+2' Qd &+, $G)9) HUh) GU`d) +.' ,**0%' WJUTWY FSI WJHTRRJSIFYNTS FITUYJI' ,**0 KA 2../1,* $G)9) HUh) DSd) +2' ,**0%5 =JNYJW [( >TSTYTSJ /TWU(' .20 ;) Ge``) ++/' ++3l,* $9) BY^^) +32*% $X_¥TY^W dXQd Q^ Q¥¥UWUT¥i _fUbSXQbWUT `¥QY^dYVV gQc ^_d RQbbUT Ri 5QQNSTNX .WNHP RUSQecU dXU `¥QY^dYVV `QYT dXU _fUbSXQbWU TYbUSd¥i d_ Q ]U]RUb _V Q^ Q¥¥UWUT `bYSU(VYhY^W S_^c`YbQSi%) >^ dXU <FUJW SQcU' dXU GUfU^dX 8YbSeYd bUQc_^UT dXQd nYd g_e¥T RU RUddUb d_ bUS_W^YjU dXQd 4FST[JW >MTJ Q^T 5QQNSTNX .WNHP Q¥¥_SQdU d_ dXU VYbcd ^_^(S_^c`YbQd_b Y^ dXU TYcdbYRedY_^ SXQY^ dXU bYWXd d_ S_¥¥USd +**" _V dXU TQ]QWUco bQdXUb dXQ^ SQbfY^W _ed Q^ UhSU`dY_^ Uh`¥YSYd¥i) ,2+ ;)-T 0-+l-,) HXU S_ebd VY^Tc dXU GUfU^dX 8YbSeYdqc bUQc_^Y^W S_]`U¥¥Y^W Q^T Q``¥YUc Yd XUbU) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd Yd Yc dXU VYbcd ^_^(S_^c`YbQd_b Y^ dXU `bYSY^W SXQY^ RUSQecU Yd `Qic _fUbSXQbWUc V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c TYbUSd¥i d_ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dcm_fUbSXQbWUc gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc QbU RQcUT _^ `bYSUc gXYSX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ Y^V¥QdU V_b dXUYb _g^ WQY^) 9[d) ,* Qd 10l+,.5 9[d) .2 Qd +.) =QbbYc 8_e^diqc Q¥¥UWQdY_^c QbU cY]Y¥Qb d_ dXU `¥QY^dYVVcq Q¥¥UWQdY_^c Y^ >MFRWTHP 2TTIX) >MFRWTHP 2TTIX /T(' 1,3 ;),T Qd +,++) >^ >MFRWTHP 2TTIX' dXU `¥QY^dYVV S_^ce]Ubc Q¥¥UWUT dXQd Wb_SUbi cd_bUc S_^c`YbUT gYdX TQYbi `b_TeSUbc d_ VYh dXU `bYSU _V TQYbi `b_TeSdc) 5I( AY[U Y^ >MFRWTHP 2TTIX' =QbbYc 8_e^di S_^VY^Uc Ydc TQ]QWUc d_ dXU Q¥¥UWUT _fUbSXQbWUc bUce¥dY^W Vb_] dXU Q¥¥UWUT `bYSU(VYhY^W S_^c`YbQSi) /TRUFWJ NI( Qd +,+.' ¥NYM 9[d) ,* Qd 1+) HXec' ¥Y[U Y^ >MFRWTHP 2TTIX' dXU 5QQNSTNX .WNHP 8_ebdqc S_^SUb^c QR_ed Q``_bdY_^]U^d `b_R¥U]c QbU ^_d `bUcU^d XUbU) 1,3 ;),T Qd +,+.) AY[U Y^ >MFRWTHP 2TTIX' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ VYh dXU `bYSU =QbbYc 8_e^di `Qic V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Q^T QbU c_¥U¥i nbUc`_^cYR¥U V_b dXU bU`_bdUT `bYSUc _^ gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^diqc `Qi]U^dc QbU RQcUT)o 9[d) ,* Qd 10l+,.5 HTRUFWJ 1,3 ;),T Qd +,++' ¥NYM 5S WJ -?9 2JJ -SYNYWZXY 8NYNL(' -- Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 34 of 43 020 ;)-T 1.+' 1/+ $3dX 8Yb) ,*+,% $X_¥TY^W dXQd dXU S_(S_^c`YbQd_b UhSU`dY_^ TYT ^_d Q``¥i RUSQecU `¥QY^dYVVc TYT ^_d TYbUSd¥i `Qi Q¥¥UWUT _fUbSXQbWUc Q^T dXU `¥QY^dYVVcq dXU_bi _V ¥YQRY¥Ydi gQc RQcUT _^ n`Qcc(_^ TQ]QWUco%' FSI 9H/FWYM^& 5SH(' 2* ;)-T Qd 2/, $X_¥TY^W dXQd dXU S_(S_^c`YbQd_b UhSU`dY_^ TYT ^_d Q``¥i RUSQecU `¥QY^dYVVc TYT ^_d TYbUSd¥i `Qi Q¥¥UWUT _fUbSXQbWUc%) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd dXU ;YVdX 8YbSeYdqc TUSYcY_^ Y^ 5S WJ .JJK cX_gc dXQd dXU S_(S_^c`YbQd_b UhSU`dY_^ Yc Y^Q``¥YSQR¥U XUbU RUSQecU dXUbU Yc Q bYc[ _V ]e¥dY`¥U ¥YQRY¥Ydi) 9[d) .+ Qd 1 $SYdY^W 5S WJ .JJK 5SIZX( -SYNYWZXY 8NYNL(' 0** ;),T ++.2' ++0- $/dX 8Yb) +313%%) HXUi QbWeU dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QT]YddUT dXQd dXUbU Yc Q bYc[ _V ]e¥dY`¥U ¥YQRY¥Ydi XUbU Ri ^_dY^W dXQd dXUbU QbU _dXUb `QbdYSY`Q^dc Y^ dXU `XQb]QSUedYSQ¥ Y^Tecdbi gX_ XQfU RUU^ Y]`QSdUT Ri dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq Q¥¥UWUT S_^c`YbQSi) 9[d) .+ Qd 1) 7ed n5QQNSTNX .WNHP TYT ^_d `eb`_bd d_ RQb ]e¥dY`¥U ¥YQRY¥Ydi dXQd Yc e^bU¥QdUT d_ `QccY^W Q^ _fUbSXQbWU T_g^ Q SXQY^ _V TYcdbYRedY_^)o -UUQJ' +-3 G) 8d) Qd +/,/) =QbbYc 8_e^di T_Uc ^_d Q¥¥UWU dXQd Yd XQc RUU^ Y^ZebUT Ri fYbdeU _V Q n`QccY^W(_^o _V _fUbSXQbWUc Qc Y^ 5QQNSTNX .WNHP) 9[d) ,* Qd 3*5 9[d) .2 Qd +.) >^cdUQT' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd Yd `Qic _fUbSXQbWUc TYbUSd¥i d_ Q^ Q¥¥UWUT S_(S_^c`YbQd_b' dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc' Y^ Q `bYSU(VYhY^W S_^c`YbQSi RUdgUU^ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc) 5I( >V _dXUbc XQfU RUU^ cU`QbQdU¥i Y^ZebUT Ri dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq Q¥¥UWUT S_^TeSd' dXQd XQc ^_ RUQbY^W _^ dXYc SQcU) ;ebdXUb' 5S WJ .JJK TYT ^_d Q^cgUb dXU aeUcdY_^ _V gXUdXUb Q¥¥UWQdY_^c _V Q `bYSU(VYhY^W S_^c`YbQSi S_e¥T Qf_YT dXU RQb _V 5QQNSTNX .WNHP) 0** ;),T Qd ++0+) HXU 5S WJ .JJK S_ebd TUS¥Y^UT d_ QTTbUcc dXU YcceU RUSQecU dXU `¥QY^dYVVc Y^ dXQd SQcU TYT ^_d Y^S¥eTU QbWe]U^dc QR_ed dXU S_(S_^c`YbQd_b UhSU`dY_^ Y^ dXUYb S_]`¥QY^d Q^T n^_ QWbUU]U^d d_ VYh `bYSUc NgQcO Q¥¥UWUT)o 5I( HXec' dXU S_ebd X_¥Tc dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di Yc ^_d RQbbUT Ri 5QQNSTNX .WNHP Y^ `b_SUUTY^W gYdX Ydc F>8D S¥QY] QWQY^cd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc) HXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXYc Wb_e^T Yc 9:C>:9) -. Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 35 of 43 .$ 0<9- @MC 2P@SC /K@HLQ =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc fY_¥QdUT dXU HUhQc 9USU`dYfU HbQTU EbQSdYSUc(8_^ce]Ub Eb_dUSdY_^ 6Sd $dXU n9HE6o%) 9[d) ,* Qd +.,5 HUh) 7ec) # 8_]) 8_TU 6^^) k +1).+) nN8O¥QY]c Q¥¥UWY^W ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^ Q^T VbQeT Y^ fY_¥QdY_^ _V dXU ) ) ) 9HE6 QbU ceRZUSd d_ dXU XUYWXdU^UT `¥UQTY^W bUaeYbU]U^dc _V Fe¥U 3$R%)o 9Y( ;QN[J 9NXXNTSFW^ .FUYNXY /MZWHM [( @SIJW¥WNYJWX FY 8QT^IaX& 8TSITS' C_) 8J =(+0(,-.' ,*+0 KA ..3..-3' Qd &. $G)9) HUh) 6eW' ,0' ,*+0%) nFe¥U 3$R% Q``¥YUc Ri Ydc `¥QY^ ¥Q^WeQWU d_ Q¥¥ QfUb]U^dc _V VbQeT' gXUdXUb dXUi QbU `Qbd _V Q S¥QY] _V VbQeT _b ^_d)o 8TSJ >YFW 8FINJX 5S[( /QZG [( >HMQTY_XP^aX 5SH(' ,-2 ;)-T -0-' -02 $/dX 8Yb) ,**+%) nEed cY]`¥i' Fe¥U 3$R% bUaeYbUc dXU S_]`¥QY^d d_ cUd V_bdX dXU pgX_' gXQd' gXU^' gXUbU' Q^T X_gq _V dXU UfU^dc Qd YcceU)o >JJ 0TWXJ^' /.* ;)-T Qd --35 XJJ FQXT XZUWF EQbd >>)7) 7_dX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc S_^dU^T dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^diqc 9HE6 S¥QY]c T_ ^_d ]UUd dXU XUYWXdU^UT `¥UQTY^W cdQ^TQbTc _V Fe¥U 3$R%) 9[d) .* Qd --l-.5 9[d) .+ Qd -/) =QbbYc 8_e^di T_Uc ^_d TYc`edU dXQd Fe¥U 3$R% Q``¥YUc' Red Yd QbWeUc dXQd Yd QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UQTc dXU ngX_' gXQd' gXU^' gXUbU' Q^T X_go _V Ydc 9HE6 S¥QY]) 9[d) .2 Qd ..l./) HXU S_ebd TYcQWbUUc) nNHOXb_gY^W _ed Q ^QbbQdYfU QSS_e^d _V dXU VQSdc Q^T dXU^ cU`QbQdU¥i SYdY^W d_ cdQdedUc Red `eddY^W dXU _^ec _^ dXU S_ebd _b TUVU^TQ^d d_ TUdUb]Y^U gXYSX VQSdc ]YWXd ce``_bd gXYSX ¥UWQ¥ S¥QY]c Yc TUVYSYU^d `¥UQTY^W)o /QNHP [( >YFYJ 2FWR 8QT^IX' C_) +4+1(8J(**+*2(7A' ,*+2 KA +-,,+01' Qd &- $C)9) HUh) BQb) +-' ,*+2%) >^ Q S_^S¥ec_bi VQcXY_^' =QbbYc 8_e^di ¥Ycdc cUSdY_^c _V dXU 9HE6 gXYSX Yd Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU fY_¥QdUT5 Yd T_Uc ^_d Y^S¥eTU Q^i VQSdeQ¥ Q¥¥UWQdY_^c' UhSU`d Ri bUVUbU^SU d_ dXU n`bUSUTY^W -/ Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 36 of 43 `QbQWbQ`Xc)o!% 9[d) ,* Qd +.,) ;ebdXUb' dXU 9HE6 WU^UbQ¥¥i T_Uc ^_d Q¥¥_g S¥QY]c gXYSX QbYcU nVb_] Q dbQ^cQSdY_^' Q `b_ZUSd' _b Q cUd _V dbQ^cQSdY_^c bU¥QdY^W d_ dXU cQ]U `b_ZUSd' Y^f_¥fY^W d_dQ¥ S_^cYTUbQdY_^ Ri dXU S_^ce]Ub _V ]_bU dXQ^ !/**'***)o HUh) 7ec) # 8_]) 8_TU k +1).3$W%) HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd nNYOd Yc Y]`¥QecYR¥U ) ) ) dXQd dXU S_^dbQSdc dXb_eWX gXYSX dXU 8_e^di _RdQY^UT E7B cUbfYSUc _b `ebSXQcUT Y^ce¥Y^ V_b =QbbYc 8_e^di ZQY¥c g_e¥T RU c]Q¥¥ U^_eWX d_ aeQ¥YVi V_b `b_dUSdY_^ e^TUb dXU 9HE6)o 9[d) .+ Qd -.) =QbbYc 8_e^di T_Uc ^_d QTTbUcc dXYc YcceU Y^ Ydc S_]`¥QY^d) 9[d) ,*) >^ Ydc bUc`_^cU' =QbbYc 8_e^di QTTbUccUc Yd _^¥i Ri QbWeY^W dXQd dXU d_dQ¥ Q]_e^d _V dXU dbQ^cQSdY_^c RUdgUU^ =QbbYc 8_e^di Q^T dXU TUVU^TQ^dc Yc Q TYc`edUT VQSd dXQd SQ^^_d RU bUc_¥fUT Y^ Q ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc) 9[d) .2 Qd .,) =_gUfUb' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc ^_ VQSdc QR_ed dXU Q]_e^d _V dXU dbQ^cQSdY_^c V_b dXU TUVU^TQ^dc d_ TYc`edU) =QbbYc 8_e^di ]ecd `¥UQT ceVVYSYU^d VQSdc d_ TU]_^cdbQdU dXQd dXU cdQdedU Q``¥YUc) =QbbYc 8_e^di T_Uc ^_d QTUaeQdU¥i TUcSbYRU dXU ngX_' gXQd' gXU^' gXUbU' Q^T X_go _V Ydc 9HE6 S¥QY]c Y^ QSS_bTQ^SU gYdX Fe¥U 3$R%) HXUbUV_bU' dXU ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc dXU 9HE6 S¥QY]c QbU <F6CH:9) =QbbYc 8_e^di ]_fUc V_b ¥UQfU d_ Q]U^T' Q^T dXU ]_dY_^ V_b ¥UQfU d_ Q]U^T Qc d_ dXYc S¥QY] Yc <F6CH:9) >^ S_^dbQcd d_ Ydc 9HE6 S¥QY]c' =QbbYc 8_e^di `¥UQTc Ydc VbQeT S¥QY] gYdX dXU `QbdYSe¥QbYdi bUaeYbUT Ri Fe¥U 3$R% RUSQecU Yd S_^^USdc Ydc VbQeT S¥QY] d_ c`USYVYS Q¥¥UWUT VQSdc Y^ dXU S_]`¥QY^dm Yd T_Uc ^_d ]UbU¥i Y^S_b`_bQdU Q¥¥ `QbQWbQ`Xc Ri bUVUbU^SU) 9[d) ,* Qd +..) H_ `bUfQY¥ _^ Q S_]]_^(¥Qg VbQeT S¥QY]' Q `¥QY^dYVV ]ecd cX_g dXQd Q TUVU^TQ^d ]QTU Q VQ¥cU ]QdUbYQ¥ bU`bUcU^dQdY_^ gXYSX dXU TUVU^TQ^d [^Ug gQc VQ¥cU _b gQc ]QTU nbUS[¥Ucc¥i Qc Q `_cYdYfU QccUbdY_^ gYdX_ed Q^i [^_g¥UTWU _V Ydc dbedX)o 1WSXY " DTZSL& 8(8(<( [( <FH( 9ZY( 8NKJ 5SX( /T(' /+ G)K)-T /1-' /11 $HUh) ,**+%) 6 `¥QY^dYVV ]ecd Q¥c_ cX_g dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^d nY^dU^TUT d_ Y^TeSU NdXU =QbbYc 8_e^di `b_fYTUc VQSdc bU¥QdUT d_ dXU 9HE6 S¥QY]c Y^ Ydc bUc`_^cU d_ dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc' Red dXYc Yc ^_d ceVVYSYU^d e^TUb Fe¥U 3$R%) 9[d) .25 XJJ XZUWF EQbd >>)7) -0 !% Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 37 of 43 `¥QY^dYVVO d_ QSd e`_^ dXU bU`bUcU^dQdY_^o Q^T dXQd dXU `¥QY^dYVV nQSdeQ¥¥i Q^T ZecdYVYQR¥i bU¥YUT e`_^ dXU bU`bUcU^dQdY_^ Q^T dXUbURi ceVVUbUT Y^Zebi)o 5I( =QbbYc 8_e^di S_^dU^Tc dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc g_b[UT gYdX dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Y^ Q S__bTY^QdUT UVV_bd d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdU bU`_bdUT `bYSUc V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Q^T dXU^ `eR¥YcX dX_cU QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc Y^ Q VZNI UWT VZT _V ]_^Ui V_b `bUVUbbUT `¥QSU]U^d _^ V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycdc) 9[d) ,* Qd .1) >^ SQcUc gYdX cY]Y¥Qb VQSdc' VUTUbQ¥ S_ebdc XQfU XU¥T dXQd dXU QSd _V `eR¥YcXY^W QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc YdcU¥V SQ^ S_^cdYdedU Q VbQeTe¥U^d cdQdU]U^d) >JJ& J(L(' 9>< =JHT[JW^ /QFNRX' ,*+3 KA +.+2+,3' Qd &+3 $X_¥TY^W dXQd `¥QY^dYVVc XQT QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT S_]]_^(¥Qg VbQeT Ri Q¥¥UWY^W dXQd TUVU^TQ^dc XQT U^WQWUT Y^ n]QdUbYQ¥' VQSdeQ¥ ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^co Ri `eR¥YcXY^W Y^dU^dY_^Q¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc V_b Y^ce¥Y^%5 5S WJ 8ZUWTS 9PYL( " >FQJX <WFHX( 8NYNL(' ,3/ ;) Ge``) ,T +.2' +01 $9) BQcc) ,**-% $nN9OUVU^TQ^dc dbe]`UdUT Q ¥YU Ri `eR¥YcXY^W dXU Y^V¥QdUT N`bYSUcO' [^_gY^W $Q^T Y^dU^TY^W% dXU] d_ RU ecUT Qc Y^cdbe]U^dc _V VbQeT)o%) >^ Ydc S_]`¥QY^d' =QbbYc 8_e^di QbWeUc dXQd R_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc [^Ug dXU `bYSUc gUbU VbQeTe¥U^d Q^T bUce¥dUT Vb_] dXU Q¥¥UWUT >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U) 9[d) ,* Qd 02l1+) HXU TUVU^TQ^dc Q¥¥UWUT¥i Y^dU^TUT d_ Y^TeSU =QbbYc 8_e^di d_ _fUb`Qi V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Ri `eR¥YcXY^W QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc e`_^ gXYSX =QbbYc 8_e^di bU¥YUT Y^ `ebSXQcY^W dXU Qd(YcceU ]UTYSQdY_^c) 5I( Qd +.0) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥c_ QbWeUc dXQd dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc ]QTU ^e]Ub_ec _dXUb `eb`_cUVe¥ ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^c c`USYVYSQ¥¥i d_ Y^TeSU =QbbYc 8_e^di d_ `Qi Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c' Q¥¥UWQdY_^c gXYSX Y^S¥eTUT ^Q]Uc _V Y^TYfYTeQ¥ c`UQ[Ubc' dXU S_^dU^d _V dXU Q¥¥UWUT ]YcbU`bUcU^dQdY_^c' TQdUc' Q^T gXUbU Q^T X_g dX_cU cdQdU]U^dc gUbU ]QTU) >JJ XZUWF EQbd >>>)6)+5 9[d) ,* Qd 0+l1+5 9[d) .2 Qd /2) HXec' =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT dXU ngX_' gXQd' gXU^' gXUbU' Q^T X_go _V Ydc VbQeT S¥QY] Qc bUaeYbUT Ri Fe¥U 3$R%) -1 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 38 of 43 7_dX dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd dXU VbQeT S¥QY] cX_e¥T RU TYc]YccUT RUSQecU =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT bU¥YQ^SU _b SQecQdY_^) 9[d) .* Qd -/5 9[d) .+ Qd -2) =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT SQecQdY_^) >JJ XZUWF EQbd >>>)6).) ;_b S_]]_^(¥Qg VbQeT S¥QY]c' bU¥YQ^SU Yc Q aeUcdY_^ _V VQSd gXYSX Yc ^_d Q``b_`bYQdU V_b dXU S_ebd d_ QTTbUcc Qd dXYc cdQWU) >JJ& J(L(' /JQFSJXJ /TWU( [( /TFXYFQ BFYJW -ZYM(' .1/ ;) Ge``) ,T 0,-' 0-2 $G)9) HUh) ,**1% $X_¥TY^W dXQd nbU¥YQ^SU Yc _bTY^QbY¥i Q aeUcdY_^ V_b dXU VQSd(VY^TUb ) ) ) Yd Yc ^_d Q `b_`Ub ]QddUb V_b TYc]YccQ¥ _^ dXU `¥UQTY^Wc)o%5 5S WJ 1SWTS /TWU( >JH(& 0JWN[FYN[J " !1=5>-! 8NYNL(' /.* ;) Ge``) ,T 1/3' 11, $G)9) HUh) ,**1% $cQ]U%5 *))* 9H7NSSJ^ 8YI( [( /WJINY >ZNXXJ 2NWXY .TX( 9TWYL( /FU(' +3, G)K)-T ,*' -* $HUh) 6``)m=_ecd_^ N+.dX 9Ycd)O ,**/' `Ud) TU^YUT% $n8_ebdc XQfU e^YV_b]¥i dbUQdUT dXU YcceU _V ZecdYVYQR¥U bU¥YQ^SU Qc Q aeUcdY_^ V_b dXU VQSdVY^TUb)o%) =QbbYc 8_e^di S¥QY]c Ydc bU¥YQ^SU gQc bUQc_^QR¥U RUSQecU dXU TUVU^TQ^dc XQT UhS¥ecYfU [^_g¥UTWU QR_ed dXU `bYSY^W _V TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Q^T `eb`_cUVe¥¥i S_^SUQ¥UT ]QdUbYQ¥ VQSdc Vb_] =QbbYc 8_e^di QR_ed dXU bU`_bdUT `bYSUc _V dXU Qd(YcceU ]UTYSQdY_^c) 9[d) ,* Qd +.0) HXQd Yc U^_eWX Qd dXYc cdQWU) HXec' dXU ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc dXU S_]]_^(¥Qg VbQeT S¥QY] QbU 9:C>:9) /$ 6NMDV 3@C @MC :DBDHTDC @MC =MISQR 1MPHBGLDMR /K@HLQ =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUc SQecUc _V QSdY_^ V_b ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT Q^T e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d) 9[d) ,* Qd +.1l.2) H_ UcdQR¥YcX Q S¥QY] V_b ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT' dXU `¥QY^dYVV ]ecd cX_g ndXQd $+% NdXUO TUVU^TQ^d X_¥Tc ]_^Ui Q^T $,% dXU ]_^Ui Y^ UaeYdi Q^T W__T S_^cSYU^SU RU¥_^Wc d_ NdXUO `¥QY^dYVV)o ?TZW >YWFYJL^ 88/ [( >YFW'?JQJLWFR& 5SH(' C_) .4+2(8J(*1.(6' ,*+2 KA -,.,,2*' Qd &. $C)9) HUh) ?e¥i -' ,*+2%) n6 SQecU _V QSdY_^ V_b ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT Yc ^_d RQcUT _^ gb_^WT_Y^W Red Y^cdUQT' p¥__[c _^¥i d_ dXU ZecdYSU _V dXU SQcU Q^T Y^aeYbUc gXUdXUb dXU TUVU^TQ^d XQc bUSUYfUT ]_^Ui gXYSX bYWXdVe¥¥i RU¥_^Wc d_ Q^_dXUb)qo 0TXX [( 4TRJHTRNSL 2NS( :JY¥TWP& 5SH(' ,+* G)K)-T 1*0' 1++ $HUh) 6``)m8_b`ec 8XbYcdYl:TY^RebW ,**0' `Ud) TU^YUT% -2 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 39 of 43 $ae_dY^W -RTHT <WTI( /T( [( >RNYM' 3.0 G)K),T +0,' +0. $HUh) 6``)m:¥ EQc_ +331' ^_ gbYd%%) 6 ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT S¥QY] Yc n¥Ucc bUcdbYSdUT Q^T VUddUbUT Ri dUSX^YSQ¥ be¥Uc Q^T V_b]Q¥YdYUc dXQ^ Q^i _dXUb V_b] _V QSdY_^) >d QY]c Qd dXU QRcdbQSd ZecdYSU _V dXU SQcU' Q^T ¥__[c c_¥U¥i d_ dXU Y^aeYbi' gXUdXUb dXU TUVU^TQ^d X_¥Tc ]_^Ui gXYSX ) ) ) RU¥_^Wc d_ dXU `¥QY^dYVV)o 93- 5SX( /T( [( /MFWQJX =( /MJXSZYY& <(/(' -/2 G)K)-T 2*2' 2+- $HUh) 6``)m9Q¥¥Qc ,*+,' ^_ `Ud)% $ae_dY^W @SNYJI >YFYJX [( 6JKKJWXTS 1QJH( 9KL( /T(' ,3+ I)G) -20' .*,l*-' /. G) 8d) ..- $+3-.%%) 6 `¥QY^dYVV SQ^ bUS_fUb e^TUb Q^ e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d dXU_bi gXU^ Q TUVU^TQ^d n_RdQY^NcO Q RU^UVYd Vb_] Q^_dXUb Ri VbQeT' TebUcc' _b dXU dQ[Y^W _V Q^ e^TeU QTfQ^dQWU)o 4JQIJSKJQX .WTX( [( /NY^ TK /TWUZX /MWNXYN' 2-, G)K),T -3' .+ $HUh) +33,%) 7_dX di`Uc _V S¥QY]c QbU aeQcY(S_^dbQSdeQ¥) >JJ 2TWYZSJ <WTI( /T( [( /TSTHT& 5SH(' /, G)K)-T 01+' 02- $HUh) ,***% $nI^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d S¥QY]c QbU RQcUT _^ aeQcY(S_^dbQSd)o%5 -RTHT' 3.0 G)K),T Qd +0. $nB_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT ) ) ) Yc Q aeQcY(S_^dbQSdeQ¥ QSdY_^ ) ) ) )o%) HXU TUVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d Yc ^_d Q SQecU _V QSdY_^ Y^ HUhQc) 9[d) .* Qd -05 9[d) .+ Qd -2) =_gUfUb' dXYc S_ebd XQc XU¥T dXQd e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d SQ^ RU Q^ Y^TU`U^TU^d SQecU _V QSdY_^) >JJ 9TWF [( 7T^' C_) 8>J)6) =(+,(-,++' ,*+- KA ,,23221' Qd &/ $G)9) HUh) BQi ,-' ,*+-%) n6¥dX_eWX e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d Yc eceQ¥¥i SXQbQSdUbYjUT Qc Q RQcYc V_b aeQ^de] ]UbeYd bUS_fUbi' Yd SQ^ RU NQ^O Y^TU`U^TU^d SQecU _V QSdY_^)o 5I( nI^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d _SSebc gXUbU dXU TUVU^TQ^d gb_^WVe¥¥i cUSebUc Q RU^UVYd _b `QccYfU¥i bUSUYfUc Q RU^UVYd gXYSX g_e¥T RU e^S_^cSY_^QR¥U d_ bUdQY^)o 5I( HXU ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc dXU e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d S¥QY] RUSQecU Yd Yc ^_d Q TYcdY^Sd SQecU _V QSdY_^ QbU 9:C>:9) HXU TUVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ QbWeU dXQd dXU e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d Q^T dXU ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT S¥QY]c cX_e¥T RU TYc]YccUT RUSQecU aeQcY(S_^dbQSdeQ¥ S¥QY]c bUaeYbU Q n^Uheco RUdgUU^ dXU -3 Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 40 of 43 `¥QY^dYVV Q^T dXU TUVU^TQ^d' gXYSX dXUi S_^dU^T T_Uc ^_d UhYcd XUbU)!& 9[d) .* Qd -15 9[d) .+ Qd -2l -3) ;_b Q^ e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d S¥QY]' dXUbU ]ecd RU nc_]U e^TUb¥iY^W S_^dQSd _b ^Uhec RUdgUU^ dXU `¥QY^dYVV cUU[Y^W dXU bUS_fUbi Q^T dXU TUVU^TQ^d Vb_] gX_] dXU bUS_fUbi Yc c_eWXd)o /Y^( TK 1Q <FXT& ?J]( [( 6TSJX' C_) :E(*3(8J(**++3(@8' ,**3 KA .1-*-.-' Qd &+, $K)9) HUh) 9US) .' ,**3%) HXU `¥QY^dYVV ]ecd Q¥¥UWU dXQd nY^ c_]U gQi' NdXUO TUQ¥Y^Wc NRUdgUU^ dXU `QbdYUcO ]ecd XQfU RUU^ Y^UaeYdQR¥U' Y^ VQf_b _V dXU TUVU^TQ^d Q^T Qd dXU Uh`U^cU _V dXU `¥QY^dYVV)o 5I( ;bQeT Yc Q^ nQSdYfUo V_b] _V e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d) 5I( =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT VbQeT Q¥¥UWQdY_^c) >JJ XZUWF EQbd >>>)7) =QbbYc 8_e^di S_^dU^Tc dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc gUbU e^Zecd¥i U^bYSXUT dXb_eWX dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq Q¥¥UWUT¥i VbQeTe¥U^d >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U Q^T dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di gQc dXU c_ebSU _V dXQd U^bYSX]U^d) 9[d) ,* Qd +.1l.3) HXec' =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ceVVYSYU^d¥i `¥UT Q ^Uhec RUdgUU^ dXU bUS_fUbi dXUi cUU[ Q^T dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq Q¥¥UWUT U^bYSX]U^d) HXU SQcUc d_ gXYSX dXU TUVU^TQ^dc SYdU QbU Y^Q``_cYdU) 9[d) .* Qd -1 $SYdY^W 0F[NX [( BJQQX 2FWLT .FSP& :(-(' C_) 04++(8J(***.1' ,*+. KA /2/.*-' Qd &- $G)9) HUh) ;UR) +.' ,*+.% $X_¥TY^W dXQd `¥QY^dYVVc gUbU d__ bU]_dU d_ bUS_fUb RUSQecU dXUi TYT ^_d Q¥¥UWU dXQd dXUi gUbU dXU c_ebSU _V dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq U^bYSX]U^d Q^T dXUbU gQc ^_ S_^^USdY_^ RUdgUU^ dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq WQY^ Q^T dXU `¥QY^dYVVcq ¥_cc%%5 9[d) .+ Qd -2l-3 $SYdY^W 6TSJX' ,**3 KA .1-*-.-' Qd &+,% $X_¥TY^W dXQd `¥QY^dYVV gX_ TYT ^_d Q¥¥UWU gb_^WT_Y^W QWQY^cd cUfUbQ¥ TUVU^TQ^dc S_e¥T ^_d bUS_fUb RUSQecU TUVU^TQ^dc XQT ^_d RUU^ e^Zecd¥i U^bYSXUT%%) HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dg_ QTTYdY_^Q¥ bUQc_^c V_b TYc]YccQ¥ _V dXU e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d Q^T ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT S¥QY]c) 9[d) .* Qd -1) HXUi S_^dU^T dXQd $+% =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc nVQY¥NUTO d_ Q¥¥UWU dXQd dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc U^WQWUT Y^ Q^i e^¥QgVe¥ S_^TeSdo HXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc QWQY^ SYdU d_ =QbbYc 8_e^diqc _bYWY^Q¥ `UdYdY_^ Y^ cdQdU S_ebd) 9[d) .+ Qd -3) HXU S_ebd QWQY^ TUS¥Y^Uc d_ S_^cYTUb =QbbYc 8_e^diqc _bYWY^Q¥ `UdYdY_^ RUSQecU Q^ Q]U^TUT S_]`¥QY^d ce`UbcUTUc dXU _bYWY^Q¥) >JJ XZUWF EQbd >>>)6).) ^)+-) .* !& Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 41 of 43 Q^T dXec' ndXUbU Yc ) ) ) ^_ Y^ZecdYSU d_ UaeYdQR¥i S_bbUSd'o Q^T $,% dXUi ^UfUb bUSUYfUT ]_^Ui Vb_] =QbbYc 8_e^di' Q^T dXec' dXUi T_ ^_d XQfU ]_^Ui dXQd S_e¥T `_ccYR¥i RU¥_^W d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di) 5I( HXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc _^ dXUcU Wb_e^Tc Yc 9:C>:9 RUSQecU $+% =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc Q¥¥UWUT e^¥QgVe¥ S_^TeSd' Q^T dXU S_ebd ]ecd QSSU`d =QbbYc 8_e^diqc Q¥¥UWQdY_^c Qc dbeU Qd dXYc `_Y^d Y^ dXU ¥YdYWQdY_^' Q^T $,% gXUdXUb dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc XQfU RUU^ e^Zecd¥i U^bYSXUT Ri =QbbYc 8_e^di Yc Q TYc`edUT aeUcdY_^ _V VQSd gXYSX dXU S_ebd SQ^^_d QTTbUcc Y^ Q ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc) 9[d) ,* Qd +.1l+.35 XJJ XZUWF EQbd >>>) AQcd¥i' R_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd Q^ Uh`bUcc S_^dbQSd RUdgUU^ dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T =QbbYc 8_e^di W_fUb^c dXU ceRZUSd ]QddUb _V dXU TYc`edU' gXYSX V_bUS¥_cUc dXU `_ccYRY¥Ydi _V bUS_fUbi e^TUb Q aeQcY(S_^dbQSd dXU_bi) 9[d) .* Qd -15 9[d) .+ Qd -2l-3) KXU^ Q^ Uh`bUcc S_^dbQSd S_fUbc dXU ceRZUSd _V Q TYc`edU' Q `¥QY^dYVV WU^UbQ¥¥i SQ^^_d bUS_fUb e^TUb Q aeQcY( S_^dbQSd dXU_bi( :( /^UWJXX 9JI( /YW( ;UJWFYNSL /T( [( /NLSF 4JFQYMHFWJ' 12+ ;)-T +2,' ,*. $/dX 8Yb) ,*+/%) =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc ^_d Q¥¥UWUT Q RbUQSX _V S_^dbQSd S¥QY] Q^T T_Uc ^_d S_^SUTU dXQd dXU ceRZUSd ]QddUb _V dXU TYc`edUc Yc W_fUb^UT Ri Q^ Uh`bUcc S_^dbQSd5 Yd S¥QY]c dXQd Ydc ¥_ccUc QbU `Qbd _V Q ¥QbWUb VbQeTe¥U^d cSXU]U) 9[d) ,* Qd /1l/3) CUfUbdXU¥Ucc' nY^ c_]U SYbSe]cdQ^SUc' _fUb`Qi]U^dc e^TUb Q fQ¥YT S_^dbQSd ]Qi WYfU bYcU d_ Q S¥QY] V_b ) ) ) e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d)o :( /^UWJXX 9JI(' 12+ ;)-T Qd ,*. $ae_dY^W >¥( 1QJH( <T¥JW /T( [( .ZWQNSLYTS :( =(=( /T(' 300 G)K),T .01' .03l1* $HUh)+332%%5 ANQQFWWJFQ [( 2NWXY <WJXNINT .FSP' ,2- ;) Ge``) -T /.2' /// $K)9) HUh) ,*+1% $nNHOXU HUhQc Ge`bU]U 8_ebd XQc ]QTU S¥UQb dXQd dXU RQb QWQY^cd aeQcY(S_^dbQSd _b UaeYdQR¥U S¥QY]c gXU^ dXUbU Yc Q^ Uh`bUcc gbYdY^W TUVY^Y^W dXU _R¥YWQdY_^c _V dXU `QbdYUc Yc ^_d Q^ QRc_¥edU RQb' Red Q WU^UbQ¥ be¥U)o%) =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i Q¥¥UWUT Ydc ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT Q^T e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d S¥QY]c) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdU `bYSUc _V TYQRUdUc .+ Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 42 of 43 ]UTYSQdY_^c Y^ Q VZNI UWT VZT _V ]_^Ui V_b `bUVUbbUT V_b]e¥Qbi ¥Ycd `¥QSU]U^d) 9[d) ,* Qd .1' /+) =QbbYc 8_e^di S_^dU^Tc dXQd' Qc Q bUce¥d _V dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq >^ce¥Y^ EbYSY^W GSXU]U' Yd XQc _fUb`QYT V_b TYQRUdUc ]UTYSQdY_^c Ri `QiY^W QbdYVYSYQ¥¥i Y^V¥QdUT `bYSUc Q^T dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc XQfU RUU^ e^Zecd¥i U^bYSXUT RUSQecU =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc _fUb`QYT) 5I( Qd +.2l.3) >d Yc `¥QecYR¥U dXQd TUVU^TQ^dc XQfU RUU^ e^Zecd¥i U^bYSXUT dXb_eWX =QbbYc 8_e^diqc Q¥¥UWUT _fUb`Qi]U^dc) AY[UgYcU' Yd Yc `¥QecYR¥U dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc XQfU ]_^Ui gXYSX bYWXdVe¥¥i RU¥_^Wc d_ =QbbYc 8_e^di) HXec' RUSQecU dXU S_ebd dQ[Uc dXU VQSdc Q¥¥UWUT Y^ dXU S_]`¥QY^d Qc dbeU' dXU ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc dXU e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d Q^T ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT S¥QY]c QbU 9:C>:9) 0$ /HTHK /NMQOHP@BV /K@HL AQcd¥i' =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥¥UWUc dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ S_]]Yd dXU d_bdc _V VbQeT' e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d' Q^T ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT)!' 9[d) ,* Qd +.3) 7_dX Wb_e`c _V TUVU^TQ^dc QbWeU dXQd dXU S_^c`YbQSi S¥QY] cX_e¥T RU TYc]YccUT RUSQecU S_^c`YbQSi Yc Q TUbYfQdYfU d_bd' Q^T =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc VQY¥UT d_ QTUaeQdU¥i Q¥¥UWU dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc U^WQWUT Y^ Q^i d_bdY_ec S_^TeSd) 9[d) .* Qd -25 9[d) .+ Qd -3l.*) HXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q¥c_ S_^dU^T dXQd =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc VQY¥UT d_ cX_g Q n]UUdY^W _V dXU ]Y^Tc)o 9[d) .* Qd -2 $ae_dY^W 6ZMQ [( -WWNSLYTS' 3-0 G)K),T 0.*' 0.. $HUh) +330%%) HXU S_ebd TYcQWbUUc) =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT Ydc S¥QY]c V_b VbQeT' e^Zecd U^bYSX]U^d' Q^T ]_^Ui XQT Q^T bUSUYfUT) >JJ XZUWF EQbd >>>)7 Q^T EQbd >>>)8) =QbbYc 8_e^di XQc Q¥c_ QTUaeQdU¥i `¥UT VQSdc dXQd ceWWUcd Q n]UUdY^W _V dXU ]Y^Tco RUdgUU^ dXU BQ^eVQSdebUb 9UVU^TQ^dc Q^T dXU E7B 9UVU^TQ^dc d_ U^WQWU Y^ d_bdY_ec S_^TeSd) >JJ 9[d) ,* Qd -+l.*' /+' 10l+,.) HXec' dXU ]_dY_^ d_ TYc]Ycc dXU SYfY¥ S_^c`YbQSi S¥QY] Yc 9:C>:9) =QbbYc 8_e^di Q¥c_ Q¥¥UWUT dXQd dXU TUVU^TQ^dc S_^c`YbUT d_ fY_¥QdU dXU HUhQc ;bUU :^dUb`bYcU Q^T 6^dYdbecd 6Sd Q^T dXU 9HE6' Red dX_cU S¥QY]c XQfU RUU^ TYc]YccUT) >JJ XZUWF EQbd > ^)- Q^T EQbd >>>)7) ., !' Case 4:19-cv-04994 Document 66 Filed on 09/29/20 in TXSD Page 43 of 43 1$ 4MISMBRHTD :DKHDE 6d dXU U^T _V dXU S_]`¥QY^d Q^T Y^ fQbY_ec cUSdY_^c dXb_eWX_ed' dXU `¥QY^dYVVc bUaeUcd Y^Ze^SdYfU bU¥YUV Y^ Q S_^S¥ec_bi ]Q^^Ub' Red dXU RbYUVY^W Yc Y^QTUaeQdU) 9[d) ,* Qd 3+l3,' +*1l*2' +,-l,.' +-.' +.+' +..' +.3l/*) HXU bUaeUcdc TYT ^_d UfU^ Y^S¥eTU Q bUSYdQdY_^ _V dXU U¥U]U^dc bUaeYbUT V_b Q^ Y^Ze^SdY_^' ]eSX ¥Ucc RbYUVY^W _^ dX_cU U¥U]U^dc) HXUbUV_bU' dXU bUaeUcdc V_b Y^Ze^SdYfU bU¥YUV QbU 9:C>:9 gYdX_ed `bUZeTYSU) 444$ /+*"(0.&+* ;_b dXUcU bUQc_^c' dXU TUVU^TQ^dcq ]_dY_^c d_ TYc]Ycc QbU <F6CH:9 Y^ E6FH Q^T 9:C>:9 Y^ E6FH) HXU S_ebd <F6CHG =QbbYc 8_e^diqc bUaeUcd d_ Q]U^T dXU 9HE6 S¥QY]) =QbbYc 8_e^di cXQ¥¥ VY¥U Ydc Q]U^TUT S_]`¥QY^d gYdXY^ V_ebdUU^ TQic _V dXYc ]U]_bQ^Te] _`Y^Y_^ Q^T _bTUb) =QbbYc 8_e^diqc bUaeUcd V_b Y^Ze^SdYfU bU¥YUV Yc 9:C>:9 gYdX_ed `bUZeTYSU) GYW^UT Qd =_ecd_^' HUhQc _^ GU`dU]RUb ,9' ,*,*) PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPP PPP PPPPPPPPPP PPPP PP P PPPPP <bQi <bbQi =) =) BY¥¥Ub B ¥¥Ub BY I^YdUT GdQdUc ?eTWU GU^Y_b I^ I YdUT GdQdU Uc 9YcdbYSd ?eTW .-

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.