Jackson v. NYC Department of Correctional Services et al, No. 1:2015cv07519 - Document 49 (S.D.N.Y. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER re: 35 MOTION to Dismiss . filed by Corizon Health, Inc., City of New York. Defendants' motion to dismiss is GRANTED. Plaintiff is given leave to file an amended complaint no later than 30 day f rom the date of this order. The Clerk of Court is directed to terminate the motion pending at Dkt. No. 35. The Clerk of Court is further directed to mail a copy of this order to Plaintiff Stacey Jackson, along with copies of the unpublished decisions cited herein. (As further set forth in this Order) (Signed by Judge Gregory H. Woods on 11/15/2016) (lmb)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Jackson v. NYC Department of Correctional Services et al U I E S A E DS RC C U T NT D T T S I TI T O R S U H R DS RC O N Y R O T E N I TI T F EW O K ---------------------------------------- X -------------------: S A EJ CS N TCYA KO, : : : Pitf : l nf a i, : v : : CT O N Y R ad OI O I Y F EW O K nC RZ N : H A T, N. E L HI C , : : D edn. : e nat f s : ---------------------------------------- X -------------------- Doc. 49 UD S N S C D Y D C ET O UM N E E T O I A L FL D L C R NC L Y I E D C# _________ O : ________ D T FL D 1/51 A E I E: 11/6 1 5 v 59 HW : - - 11c7 G M OA D EM R N UMOI I N PNO A DO D R N R E G E O YH W O S U tdt e DtcJde R G R . O D ,ne St irt ug i a s si : I . IN R D C I T O U T ON Pitftcyako poed gp s b ns h l wu aa s h Cy fN wYr l nf S eJcsn rce n r e r gt sa st g n te i o e o ai a , i o, i i i it t k adCr o HahIc ae ntadr g htm h w d a e bte e Yr Cy n ozn et n,l g g h u nte e e a ei d y h N w o i i l, . l i t i i s tn k t Dp t et fCr c o h w dpvd f dqa md ac es ewtd osre t ea mn o o ein e a er e oaeu e e c a a h ae fr u r o r rt , s i t il r i gy rpr h n ta w u m e nv po dd Bcu Pitfas o dqal aee h ea a e i h a l al ee rv e eas l nfflt aeu e l gte i r a t s t ty r i . i e ai i ty l rq sel mn oal m o die tidf ect siu md anesud teE hh eui e et f ci fr eb a n f rne oe os e c ed ne h i t it e s a l r e ie r il r g A ed et o h U tdt e Cni t n D edn’mt noi mslb g n d b mn mnt te ne St osti , e nat o ot d i w e r t , u i as tu o f s i s si l ae t Pa tflb g elae o mn te o p it l nfi ei nevt a ed h c m a n ii w l v l . I I . BC G O D A K R UN Pitfldic m a to Sp me 2 21 D.N 2 adD edn mvd o l nffe h o pi n et b 2 05 k o , n e na s oe t ai i s ln e r , , t . f t d ms h c m a toflrt st al m nAgs121 D.N 3 Il h o i i te o pi frau ot e ci o uu , 06 k o 5 n gt f ss ln i e a a t , t .. i D edn’mt n oi ms te or i ud n reo Ags221 g n n Pitfev e nat oo t d i, hCu s e a od n uu , 06 r t g l nf ae f s i ss t s r t ai a i l t a edic m a t oa r hnAgs3 21 D.N 4 TeCu’ Ags2 re o mn h o pi nl eta uu 1 06 k o 1 h ors uu od s ln t t , . t . . t t r ave Pitf h,f ei nt eee h a ed g h c m a twu crtel gd d sd l nftaih d o bivta mn nte o pi o d u h aee i ai t d l t i ln l e l Dockets.Justia.com di ec sr etdnD edn’mt n oi msh so dn edl a ops o t te ec n e p sn i e nat o o t d i, e hu is a fe n pot n o h fi i e e f s i ss l t i i i mt nnl eta Ags3 21 o o oa r hn uu 1 06 i t t , . O Ags821 Pitfet lt t teCu rqeig n x n o ote mt n uu , 06 l nfsnaee o h or eu t a e es n f ht e o t , ai tr t sn t i i fe n mne c m at r n pot n oD edn’mt n oi msD.N 4 ad n i a a edd o pi oa ops o t e nat o o t d i, k o 5 n o l ln i i f s i ss t . , Ags2 21 , h Cu e edd h daie oet me 3 21 D.N 4 A o te uu 4 06 te or x ne t s edn t Sp b 0 06 k o 6 s f h t , tt i l e r , , t . . n w edn Pitf a sbie ntea a edd o pit o a ops o t e daie l nf h d u mtd e h n mne c m a nr n pot n o l , ai t i r ln i i D edn’mt n oi msad e a nteu td fr ee es notmt mk e h e nat oo t d i, n h hd orqe e a u h x n o f e o aei e f s i ss s tr t i i tr f n Nv tes iih o Pitf p ssts n g e tea ta Pitf ml g i g ee h e, n g f l nfs r et uadi n hfc h l nfs a n l . r ls l t i a i’ o a v t t a i’ i i ad sapa d o ae hne dr g h cu ef h l ginteCu o Sp me 3 dr s pe e t hv cagd u nte or o i i a o, h or n et b 0 e r i s t st t i t e r , oe t a i’ i ln e f s i 21 sap te eddPitf tmt a ed h c m a t r po D edn’mt n o 06 us n x ne l nfs e o mn te o pi o ops e nat o o t d mst O oe 2 21 D.N 4 Te Sp me 3 od a ot e “ Pitf o i i, oc b 8 06 k o 7 h e e b 0 re l std I l nf de ss t r , . t . . t r r s a : f ai s ntl a a edd o pit r pot n oD edn’mt n y O oe 2 21,h ofe n mne c m a o ops o t e nat o o b [ c b 8 06te i ln i i f s i t r , ] Cu epc t dc eD edn’mt nn h od a cu e w hute eet f or xe s o e d e nat o oi te r n y or, i o h bni o t t i f s i ir s t t f ops o be nfo Pitf I T d e Pitf a nt mne te o pitnr a pot n rf gr m l nf ” d o a, l nf h oa edd h c m a , o h i i ii a i. . t ai s ln s hfe a ops o t D edn’mt n oi ms ei d n pot n o e nat o o t d i. l i i f s i ss Pitf ai m et h Cl sCr c oa Fi yt htm hfe te o pitn l nf, nn a ate o n o ein al ate e ei d h c m a i ai t l i r t l ct i i l ln t s a,a d a e i te u oy f h N wYr CyDp t et fCr c o fr o e h c e s ei d n h cs d ote e o i ea mn o o ein os m i sw tn t k t r rt pid f m p ot h t n et st cs d 1 Pitfl g ta Cr o Ha hIcs e o ot e r r oi r s r ot e u oy l nfaee h ozn et n’ r i i s af a t . ai l s t i l, . ( Cr o”“fcl ot n w ta tevds h “ e c u tfr h N wYr Cy “ ozn oi aps o” a h is e ate md a n” ote e o i i ) fi i i s t r il i k t Dp t et fCr ein C m.t.Te us nv aea osn h c m a ted n u ea mn o o rc o o p a2 h sb at el gini te o pi ra i fl r t . l t i l t ln , l : S c 621 I ae enwt g osre fr “en rpr I e vdn i e /04 hv be a nfr u r oa h i ea ” ’ l ei n i i gy ra i . vi ecu a n p n o wl v a e.I eee e y en oik ai x ct g a fr e oe ya ’ rpa d be t s cln r ii i l r r v tl c l n m osN C o ein fcts I e en o oh W tFct adB ve u e u Y cr c oa al e ’ be t bt e aly n e u r r t l ii. v i s i i l [c Hst n m os m. Mf my a ee cld 1i ae p t g s] opa u e ut e yai h vn ae 31nt mt o e i il r i s l s l t s t h p o m b a h be t n aa I mt cr ny v gw h h s m e fr e u l a en o o vl a sl u et li i tea e l tl s i . i r li n t l Atemt n oi mstg tel gini te o pitr acp d sre adlraoa e t h o o t d i s e h aea osn h c m a a cet atu ,n a e nb i s s a, l t ln e e l s l if ec a d wi Pii’fvrCa bs Tm W n,n. 8 F d 4 122 C 20. n rne r r nn l nfsao h mrv ie a e I 22. 17 5(d i 02 e s e a a tf . e. rr c 3 , r . ) 1 2 cnt n—u e n,w h h hptateN S o w h pm wh h od o sf r g i te oe h h Y dc i e e i t s i i fi t t sl l l t i md acnt n e c od o il i . i C m.t. Pitfa es h te ostin bifri ci ud 4 U.. 18i o p a5 l nf s r ta h cni t a as o h l m ne 2 . C§ 93s l a i st t tu o l s sa r S “ ot n f h E h A ed etiht md ac e i,w cteCu cnreaa vli ote i t mn mnr t o e c a, d h hh or os u s i ao gh g il r ” . i t t s ci fr eb a idf ect siumd anes neteE hhA ed et o h l m o die t n f rne o e ose c ed ud h i t mn mnt te a l r e ie r il r g U tdt e Cni t n ne St osti . i as tu o I . S AN A D O R V EW I I T D R F EI “ o uie mt n oi msa o pitmsc ni sfc nfc a mt, cetd T sr v a oo t d i, c m a v i ss l n u ot n ui eta u ae acp t a fi t l tr e S , atu t‘ a al m oeeta slu b oi fc’ Acfv qa, 5 U. 6 68 sre ost ci t ri h i p sl n sae” srt. b 56 . 62 7 , te a lf t a i e t . ho I l (09(ut ge A C pv To b , 5 U. 4 5020 ) “ ci h fcllu bt 20 qonB t o.. wmy 50 . 54 7(07. Al m a a ap si y ) i l l r l . l S , ) a s i a il i we tel nf p asa u cn ntaao s h cu t d w hraoa en rne h hn h pitfl dfc a ot t h l wte or o r tee nb if ecta ai e tl e tl t a s l e t te e nats a e otemcnu aee ”d (t gwmy 50U.t 5.I s o h d edn l b fr h i odc l gd I c nTo b , 5 . a56 t nt f ii l s tl . . i i l S ) i eog fr pitf ol gfc taa cns n w h aly h c m a tms“ug” nuh oal nft aeea s h r ost t i l bt te o pi u nde ai l t t e ie t i i ; i ln t ci s a o te nfo cne a e olu b. To b , 5 U.t 7 Te or ms l m “c s hl er m oc vb t p sl ” wmy 50 . a50 h cu u a rs i i l ai e l S . t t acpa fc aeei te o pitsre n d wlraoa en rnei tel nfs cetl a sl gdn h c m a atu ad r a e nb if ec n h pitf l t l ln a l s l e s a i' fvr BcvPnrCd Ror I. 51F d 2 142 C 20 (ecr m ao uh.i e ri evy n 5 . 12 2(d i 08 p ua ) . r oe et ce, c , 3 , r . ) r i . Fr e mr “] ou etldp sit bl el cnre.. n ars c m a t u h o,[ dc mnfe r es o e b ay os ud. ad p e o pi, tr e a i o i rl t o ln h wv iafl p ae ms b h d oe signs nadta fr ap a ns rtd y o ee n tuyl dd u e e tl st nett d s hn o m l d g d f b r rl e , t l s r a r l ei ae l we. Ecs vP d , 5 U. 99(07 Cusrt “b ay os u p a ns n a y s rk n. a u 51 . 8 420. or a ol el cnrel d gad r” i o rs S , ) t e i rl t ei be sbie b p sl gn ..ed g uh u ms nt rstetog tru ette rf u mtd y r ei at . ra n sc sbii s oae h s ne a mn hy is t o t s i i so i r s g s sge. Bt v Ut St , 7 F d 8 412 C 20.[ ] ms oa rs c m a ts ug t e n. n dte 48. 49 9(d i 07 “ Dsi a f p e o pi i s” r i i as e 3 , r . ) i sl o ln nv tesaport we al nf h c ayae t me mi u p a n ee h e prpa h e pitf a l r fld o e i m ml d g r ls i e r a i s el i t n ei rq r mn. RhavSro 2 FSp 3 3530SDNY21 (t goi ev Wr , eue et ” a mn.ci , 2. up d 0 1( ... 04 c nR ru . ei i s hr . , . )i i dg z pn 16F d 26(dC 19 ) 1 . 6 52 i 97 3 , r . ) . 3 I. V DS US ON I C SI A L bi . i it a ly Te n t o e nat n mdnPitf c m a trteCy fN wYr ad h o y w d edn a ei l nfs o pi a h i o e o n l f s a i’ ln e t k Cr o Pitf a nt a e ayn v u d edn. I swl s bse tateCy f ozn l nf h o n md nidi a e nat t e- t l hd h h i o i . ai s i dl f s i le ai t t N wYr aamnia y my n b h d a e ne 4 U.. 18 we a ostin e o,s u c l , a o y e e l b ud 2 . C§ 93 h e cni t a k i pi t l l il r S r tu o l dpvinsn c d u unt a oi apiy r u o .e M e v D’oS. es 46 er a oiif t pr at o n fcl oc ocs m S ol. etf o Sv, 3 it le s i fi l t e n l p c r. U. 5 6017 ( u c ai my e e l b ud §18 ci s we ..h ain . 68 9(98 mni l e a b h d a e ne 93l m “ h e .te c o S , ) i pi s t l il r a r t ta sl gd o e nostin i p mn oeeu s piyt e e, r nne h iaee t b ucni t a m e et r xc ea oc st mn od ac t l tu o l l s t l a t i , rg a o o dcin fcl aotd n po u a d ytemnia y] fc s) eut n r es oi ay dp ad r m g e b[ li , i o fil e lt h u c l ’ oie.. i pi s f r” t Smay wl Cr oia r a etybcu i po ddmd as v efr h N wYr iir, he ozns pv e nt eas t rv e e c e i s ote e o ll i i i t i, e i il r c k CyDp t et fCr c o ads e g udasc a ev e rv e i e o te eet f i ea mn o o ein ni b n se s uh s i po d , “n y h bni o t r rt i rc i rt j s f n l i s ni e, t l il i pi ” s t teol rq r mn ” n “ t s otxite uc oaeu a n otemnia y Bs hM e eue et adi h cn t s hfnin q v et f h u c l . e v Cyf NwY k N 1c- 0( P )21 W 1699a*( DNY M. 921 . i o e o , o 1v 64 T G 03 L 141 t 2S ... a 1 03 t r . - 7 , , . r , ) (oeig a s s aoea o v Cyf NwY k N 0c- 5( S ( P 21 W 6589 clc n c e;e l Mc d . i o e o , o 8v 85 BJ H) 01 L 073 lt s ) e s rr t r . - 2 ) , , a* n 0SDNY Dc521 (Cro t et e..a t a d h s m aamnia y t 7. ( ... e , 01 “opr e nts. r r t tea es u c l 1 . . ) a i i e ee i pi t we p frig h pbc uc o orn n aa ” hn e o m te uifnin f un g jl) r n l t i i . . I od t st al m omniaibt al nf msaee( a oi apiy r n re ot e ci fr u c l aly pitf u l g “ ) n fcl oc o r a a i pl i , a i i tl 1 fi l cs m h ( cu s h pitf o e u e t ( a e aoa ostin r h”Zh v u o ta 2 as tel nft b sb c o3 dnl f cni t a i t a a. t t) e ai jt ) i tu o l g . r Tw oS tl, 8F d 7 652 C 19 (ut gatv R ru , 0 F d 9 372 onf o hd 4 . 64 8(d i 95 qo nBia. oi e 72. 33 9(d uo 3 , r . ) i t s dg z 3 , C 18 ) Te fr ,n ret st al m g n e h teCy fN wYr o Cr o i 93. h eo i od ot e ci aa s i e h i o e o r ozn r . ) r e r a a itt r t k i , Pitfms a og h o erq r mn stdna a aeu e aee h dnl f l nf u, m n te t reue et t ei Zh ,dqal l gte e aoa ai t h i sa r ty l i cni t n r h S CyfLsA es.H e 45U. 9 7918 ( Nn o or a s osti a i t e i o o nl v e r 7 . 76 9(96 “ oe f uc e tu o l g . e t g e l, l S , )[ ] s a hr e te w d f a aeaa samniacro t n a d n h ain o oe f s u oz] h a a o d mg g n t i[ r s i t u c l opri b e o te c os f n o t ip ao s t i t r, oie ..]a e o h sfrd o osti n i u ..” SavCyf NwY k 49 fc s .[f p sn a u e n cni t a n r ..;el.i o e o . 5 f r i r s fe tu o l j y ) g 4 F d 0 292 C 20 ( h e dtccu poey on n udl n cni t n . 27 1(d i 06 we “ si or rplfud o ney g osti a 3 , r . ) r irt t r ri tu o l vlin i w nt ee a t cn d ci s fmniaibt ud M e ) e v Aa, i a o ” a o nc s y o os e l m o u c l aly ne ol ; v . l n ot , t s sr ira i pl i i r n l Ly f o 4 F up d 8 48SDNY19 (I swleld h amnia ymy o b h d a e 7. p 2 48 9( .. .99 “ i e st ta u c l a nt e e l b S . , . ) t l te t i pi t l il we te i n udl n cni t n vlin y mniaoi a”(tin mtd h e h es o ney g osti a i a o b a u c l fcl)ca o oie. r r ri tuo l ot i p fi. it t ) “ cn c d r oesl m f eb a idf ect h md anes y hs A ovt psn’ci o die t n f rne oi e c ed b to ie i r a l r e ie s il e oe e n h c e . as fo teE hhA ed et po b o ocu ad nsa v se gi a ..re r m h i t mn mns rhi n fre n uuu r i s r is g ’ it i l l pn h et Cozv Ke a , 8 F d 36(dC 20 ( t n qot nm k oie. u s mn” az . o mn 51. 6 92 i 09 i e a uti a s mtd i . i o r 3 , r . ) nr l ao r t ) Cu ay “oerlp i md ac es cn i t n wog R h, psn fcli a s rcl , ntv yas n e c a ia os ti a rn a e a r o oi avl e il e e il r t uo l . tr i fi ot teE hhA ed et n we t oeue et oe b cv ad nsb cv a m. h i t mn mn o y hn w rq r mn g l i s—n o eie n oe u eie— e e” jt jt r t S aud v Gr, 6 F d 6 292 C 20 (tin nit n qot nm koie. a hd n. o d 47. 23 7(d i 06 ca o adn ra u a o a s mtd l i o 3 , r . ) it e l ti r t ) “ r, h aee dpvinms b i o eiee m ‘ui et siu ” a aav Fs tel gd er ao u e n b cvt s sfc ny e os H hw . it l it t , j t r , fi l r . t y ’ C gi , 7F d 36(dC 19 (tin oie. h s nad cn m a sa od o o hn 3 . 6 62 i 94 ca os mtd T st d “ot pt ‘ cnt n ul 3 , r ) it . t ) i a r e le i i o u ec ta myeui‘eee t no e r m p n”Cae.Amr g 13F d 9 f r ny h ar l ndgn a o r x e e a. hn v rso , 4 . 68 g ’ t st ri ’ ‘ t i’ c tn 3 , 722 C 19 (ut g a aa , 7F dt 6 Scn, h d edn“ u a w h 0(d i 99 qon H hw 3 . a6. eodte e nat ms c i a r . ) i t y 3 ) f tt t sfc ny u a et e fm d H hw , 7F dt 6“ eb a idf eciamnl ui et c pb st o i . a aa 3 . a6 Die t n f rnes et fi l l l a n” t y 3 . l r e ie a st eu a nt sb cvrc e n s ad rq r tate h gd fcl c ofl o c t e q v et o u eieeks e, n “ ue h h ca e oi aa rat a a il jt l s s” e is t r fi t i t wl a ul a a oa us nar k h siui m e a mw r u ” N s v Rb , 4 he c ay w e f sb atli ta e osn a h i tl r t i s tr t r i e l i e . a n 76 l st e n l . l i F d 86(dC 21 (ut gS aud , 6 F dt 8. Tu i od t st al m o . 5 32 i 04 qon a hd n 47. a20 hs n re ot e ci fr 3 , r . ) i l i 3 ) , r a a die tidf ect h siu md anesal nf msaee h te e nat ke eb a n f rne oi e os e c ed pitf u l gta h d edn“n w l r e ie sr il , ai tl t f oadi eadd n xeieik o pitf] et os e ad h sew bt a a o f n drg e a ec s r t[ a i’ ha h ra t n ta h a oh w e f s r sv s l nfs l fy t s r fc fo w c ten rne o d e r w taa us nar k fe os a m xtdad a sr m h h hif ec cu b d n h sb atli osiu h e s , n t i e l a t t i s r r ie a o r w hif ec ”Coz, 8 F dt 2 qo nF m vB w 51U.t 2 87 l d ten rne az 51. a7(ut ga e . r n 1 . a85 3 s e e . i o 3 i rr o, S , (94(t a os nit n qot nm k oie ) 19 ae t nadn ra uti a s mtd ) l ri e l ao r t ) . TeCu ne nt e rieweh teau t po d h n rprsre ud te h or ed o d e m t t n h e hflr o rv e e i ea u r ne h tr i e i ra i gy r 5 cc m ac aeei te o pits “ui el siu”md adpvin bcu te i u s ne l gdn h c m a ia sfc ny e os e c er a o, eas h r t sl ln fi t r il i t e c m a ts eo oayl gin w hepct te u eie rn oPitf E hh o pi i dv d f n aea os i r et o h sb cv pog f a i’ i t ln i l t t s jt l nfs g A ed etl m Te o pitas ol gta ayfcl c dw h hrq se u a e mn mnci. h c m a flt aee h n oi aa e i teeui c pb a ln i l t fi t t it l l st o m d Pitf h eo h ntt e al m oai ao oteE hhA ed et t e f i . l nfte fr a ostd ci fr vlt n f h i t mn mn a n ai r e s a a oi g adici s g n teCy fN w o adCr o msflbcu,si u e aoea n h l m aa s h i o e Yr n ozn u a eas a dcs d bv sa it t k i ti e s s , pitf antt e ci fr u c aibt we n udl n cni t n vlin a l nfcnost al m omni l aly h e o ney g osti a i a o h ai a a i pl i i r ri tu o l ot s be sfc nyl gd Acr n y D edn’mt n oi msms b g n dad en ui et aee cod g, e nat o o t d i u e r t , n fi l l . il f s i ss t ae Pitf ci s g n teCy fN wYr adCr o ms b d msd oflrt st a l nfsl maa s h i o e o n ozn u ei i e frau ot e a i’ a it t k i t ss i e a ci. l m a A ntd bv a l nfse nt e aihmniaibt msa ol gte s o aoe p a tfek g o s bs u c l aly u l aee h e , ii i tl i pl i i ts l e s ne f n oi apiy r u o ” u unt w c h cni t n r h w ei a d xt c oa “ fi oc ocs m pr at o h hi osti a i t e vl e ie fcl l t s i s tu o l g s r ot . G e ta Pitf c m a tms b d msd oflrt aeu e p a tel mn o h i n h l nfs o pi u ei i e frau o dqal l d h e et fi v t a i’ ln t ss i e ty e e s s ci, h Cu ne ntec te u t nh h Pitf aaeu e aee te xt c l m e or ed orah h qei we e l nf h dqal l gd h e sne a t t so t r a i s ty l ie osc a oc ocs m Nn h e, h Cu os v te b ne f n aea osn h f uh piy r u o. oe es te or b re h as c oayl gini te l t tls t e s e l t c m a t ug t g h sc a oc ocs m xt o pi sgei ta uh piy r u o e s. ln sn t l t is B Lae oAmn . ev t ed “ p s c m a t hu nt ei msdw huteCu g n nl vt a edt Ar e o pi so d o b d i e i o h or r t g ae o mn a o ln l ss t t t ai e la oc we a b ara n ote o pitieayn cin h a adl mm h b e t ne hn l eled g f h c m a g s nid a o ta vi ci i t e s ir i ln v it t l a g std Cas Caps 68F d 6 102 C 21 (rce,n raqot nm k ad t e ” hiv hp u, 1 . 12 7(d i 00 b k s t n uti a s n a . v. i 3 , r . ) a t i e l a o r, ca o oie.Mroe te Cu i m du h “p sl gn n aiur hu b it n mtd o v, h or s i f ta ar ei at p t l so d e ti t ) e r t n l t o t i rc a i l a odd v ye oa e po u tt d mnr e h h h a adl m N s v Rb, 4 f re ee ra nb opr ny o e osa ta e a vi ci. i e . a n 76 f r s l ti tt t s l a ”en l i F d 86(dC 21 (ut gMi a Ci, 2 F d 88(dC 20 )T u teCu . 5 22 i 04 qon a mv e 28. 6 12 i 00. hs h or 3 , r . ) i t .l l 3 , r . ) , t g n Pitfevt a ed h c m a t o n cr ay ec n e nl eta 3 dy r t l nflae o mn te o pi t ad u n di ecs oa r hn 0 a as a i ln e fi i, t s 6 fo te a ot s re Pitfsw nd h i h de nt mn te o pitw h t s r m h d e f h od. l nfi a e ta f e o oa ed h c m a i i h t i r ai r t s ln t n i tm pid h c ew b c sd i e e o t s a i el e r ,i s l l o . C S t L wCim . te a l s a a Ud 2 U.. 16 c 3, h eei osp e et jr dt n v al nfst e ne 8 . C§ 37) ) e x ce f up mnlus c o oe pitf st r S (( t rs l a i ii r a i’ a l wl mi w h teCu’dc t nf h “ si e a ci s v w ci h og a a ci ss ii h or i ri i t a d msdl l m oe h h a ri l a tn t s eo i s i s l a s r i t si n jr dt n Te eodCct one aa s eei n sp e et jr dt nn uh us c o ” h Scn i u cu ss g n x cig up mnlus c oi sc a i ii . ri l i t rs l a i ii suin“]teeell ma d msd eo ta ee tog ntnus na n i a o [f hfd aci sr i i e b r rl vn huh o sb atl a tt : I r a ess f e i, i t ii jr dt n sn, h stci s hu b d msdswl Fr Cpa Ae Mm I.. us c oa es tet e amso d ei i e a e ” it at st gt n v i ii l e a l l ss l . s il s .c , 3 , r ) t . sl o . ue l 2 , Siw d n, 8 F d 5 132 C 20 (uig aea vB o Tse, 3 F d 5 78 ano, c 35. 19 8(d i 04 qon Ct n . d f rts 97. 72 5 t o I. (dC 19 )H ets oc a weh Pitfn ns oaeayt ea ci s n dt n 2 i 91 e, i ntl r h e l nf t dt rs n stl wl mi ad o r . ) ri . e t r a ii e i a a i i t h fd acni t n c m o die tidf ect siu md anes T te x n oi eel osti a l fr eb a n f rne oe os e c ed o h e et s r tu o l a i l r e ie r il . t tate o pit a b cnre t rs stl wl m teCu dcn t eei h h c m a cn e os ud oaet ea ci s h or eie o x ce t ln t i a a , t l s rs sp e et jr dt n v to ci sad hs ci si b d msd w hu pjd e up mnlus c o oe hs l m n to l mw ei i e i o r u c l a i ii r ea , ea l l ss t t e i. V . C C UI ON L S ON D edn’mt n oi mssG A T D Pitfsielae ol a a edd e nat oo t d i i R N E. l nf g nevt fe n mne f s i ss a ii v i c m a t oa r hn 0 afo te a ot s re o pi nl eta 3 dyr m h d e f h od. ln t t i r TeCr o Cu i de e t t m a temt n ed gtD.N 3 TeCr h l k f or si c d oe i t h oo pn n a k o 5 h l k e t rt r ne i i t .. e o Cu ifrh de e t ml cp ot s ret Pitftcyako a n w h o e f or s u e i c d o a a oy f h od o l nf S eJcsn l g i cps t t r rt i i r ai a , o t i ote nuihd es nce h e. f h upbse dci si d ei l io t r n S O DR D O R E E. D e Nv me 1 21 a d oe b 5 06 t: r , N wYr N wYr e o, e o k k _________________ _________________ G E O YH W O S R G R . O D U tdt e DtcJde ne St irt ug i a s si 7
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
