-ES WILLIAMS v. BOROUGH OF CARTERET POLICE DEPARTMENT et al, No. 2:2010cv02082 - Document 2 (D.N.J. 2010)

Court Description: OPINION. Signed by Judge Peter G. Sheridan on 12/2/10. (dc, )

Download PDF
CD H CD C) 0 ft CD ft hC CD H- CD - M CU H CD H Ui H ft 0 ft Hft CD ft CI CU CI CD CI d ft CD -CI CD H CU H- 0 C) CD H- CD ft CD ft CD CD Cl ft UI H ft H- U] U] - HCD ft ft C) ¢ Cl) CX) o ft Pi I- ti 0 MX H- Cl C) CD CD 0 I zI Q ft I-) 0 ft ft CU C) CD ti CI -CI HCD ¢ ft U] C) CO C) 0 H CU H- Q) C) CD ft CD I h HH ft 0 ft ti C) C) 0 CD ttl CD HCD ft CU t- CQ HH H ft C) 0 C) CD ft C) CD CD CU ft Cl H- Mi C) Hft -X HCl I ti CU Cl] I-h I-ti ft H- H- )J H 0 H- Mi 0 C) H CD CD ft t Cl CD 0 CU CU H U] H HC) U ft H0 i H < HCD ft L H- ft 0 CD CD CD CD CD CD - CD C- CD HC) CD w h- CU C) ft H- tCI CU H H CU t- 0 0 t-ti H- ft CD H- i CU H 0 ft H- CD ft Hft 0 C) HCD 0 frh CD H CU ft H0 0 H- H- H- CU CD CD Cl CO U) h CD CD Ui CI CD C) CU H CO H U] C) CO C) CO 0 ft ft CU ti CD - Ml CD CD CD h 0 ft CD CU CD rt 0 Hft CD C) C) C) ft CD ti C) CD H CU 0 H- ft C) CD ti h 0 C) H ft < ft C) 0 >< H CD CD CD H- CD ft ft CD H- Mi 0 fl ft H CD t- II C) CD HH H HCU Q ]J CU CO Mi frti ft H- d H CU H- CD L 4 C rt C) rt rn t - H lzj Cl) CD C CX) 0 Cl - CD ft C) CD H CU 0 CD C) ft H- 11 0 C) H ft Q ft C)o]Q H-CDfl CO CD 0 CD HH H HCU ¢QHpJ W HCOtY WCD QCD 0 I<CD CD >< QQa fCf) CD H-Lnpi Cl) 0 tLl tJ ft CD CU CD CD Mi rtQ Z C) H Z H 0 Mi ft H- H- H CU 0 CO CU 0 C)) CU H 0 Z 0 0 C) ft H H H C) H- Dockets.Justia.com C) H -, 0 3 CO -Ci ¢ CU HO CD 3 -o -tj L IQ CO H H 0 W CO H H Cl) H 0 Z H H 0 W 0 Z 0 cC CD HLf C) cC HH, Cl) C-C H, 0 -< Cli H H Cl) CD C-C H- 5 H- 0 C) l- Cl) CD CD H- CD cC Cl) 0 Ci CD H Cl Cl) cC CD 0 5 -C TI CD I C Cl HH CD Cl) H, cC CD Ci Cl Cl) Ci 0 Cl) H, Ci cC CD 5 C-C CD Cl CD ft C-C CD -C H, Cl) c-C Cli C-C CD CD H H CD Cl) C CD cC H, C-C Cl) h-C C-C Cl) C) Cl) HH, H, CD CD -< CD S)) H C HIQ H- 0 C-C H $)J H- cC 0 cC Cl CD tC Cl) -C CD H, HCD cC Ci Q rt H- H H- C) C3 CD CD C) CD CD Cl) -C CD H0 < CD C 0 C-C CD C-C H- Cl) Cl) - C-C Q C) Q H- H, cC H- HcC cC CD C-C C-C C) Cl t 0 C) HCD H, Cl) CD CD CD Cl) CD CD CD C-C C CD O Cl) H, O H- C-C CD HH Cl) C-C 0 tY Cl) ct 0 cC H- - S Ho H < Hti H C) CD Cl) ct C-C --C Cl) Cl) C-h o CD - H- H, 0 CD C-C Cl) CD CD CD CD C) C) C-h 0 < HCD H, 0 Cl 0 H- HN Cl) cC 0 cC U CD çt CD CD cC HC-C C) C CD cC H, CD cC Cl) cC cC CD CD 0 CD C-C Cl) CD cC CD 0 C-C Cl) tQ C-C C- Cl Cl H- cC Cl) C-C C Cl) C) - CD CD Cl) CD Cl) cC H CD Q HC-C H- 0 d CD C) Ci CD C-C Cl 0 Ci -< tr CD Cl Cl-i CD CD C) Cl) H CD tY Cl) 0 C-C t3 C-C 0 HC-C Cl) CD C) CD CD J H- Cl) H (-Q 0 cC H H- CD CD C-C Ii C cC HH, C-C Cl) C-C 5 CD H- Cl) C) H H, 0 C-C CD Cl) cC D cC CD CD CD H, C-C Cl) 0 cC cC Cl) C-C CD CD Cl) Cl 5 Cl) CD C) C-C h-C Cl) HCD H, 0 CD Q Cl) -C IQ Cl) H- cC CD CD CD )) cC ) CD 0 cC CD CD Cl) C) H CD Cl) tY 0 tY C -< H, CD C-C H- U. Cl H 0 HC) Cl CD C) Cl 0 C d CD Cl) C) CD CD CD < H- 0 Cl) cC cC cC tT CD C) Cl CD C-C CD CD H- HCD CD CD Cl) - C C) 0 cC cC Cl) C-C Cl) C C) C-C CD CD Cl) Cl) ct CD HcC H- Q H CD C-C )) 0 CD C) H- Cl - H, H, cC H- H- Cl) H CD 0 Cl) Cl) CD Cl C-C C-C CD CD cC CD Cl) H H -< H, cC CD Cl) Cl CD H, CD Q tY CD HH H cC Ci H- Cl) H CI S 0 C) Ci C) CD S C- 0 H, CD Ci 5 5 H- HCD 0 ft Cl) CD H, CD Cl) Cl Cli 5 0 C-C H, H, CD H- CD H - -< Cl) C-C CD 0 CD CD CD CD CD I-C CD LQ H- 0 LJ CD -C H H 0 H, CD C-C C-C 0 j CI C-C 0 ft H- H, CD H HCD I-j CD H l) M Q Q H CXI C CD 5 tJ CD C) CD 0 C-C Cl) ft CD CD cC Cl) cC CD H, H, H- C-C ti H ) H- HCD CD CD Cl HCD CD - 5 CD i C-C Cl) C-C cC CD C) CD H H- 0 C-C CD C-C CD ct -C Cl) C) CD ct HC-C CD HC) CD H, H, 0 CD cC Cl) ct C-C CD CD cC CD CD CD CD Cl) C) H CD Cl) 0 t1 fr C3 C-C 0 Hit J H- HcC CD CD Cl) CD C) tY 0 11 Cl C-C CD 1C C Cl) CD Cl) S H, C-C CD H HCD HC) rJ C) C) H Cl) H- Cl) CD cC PcC CD H- 0 cC C-C CD HH Cl) C-h 0 H, CD 0 )) H HC) H- S 0 CD 0 H 0 < -C H- I h Cl) CD Cl CD CD CD 5 CD Cl H- CD H 0 CD H H CD 0 * ( 1 03 ft CD H H CD H- o H H P2 0 03 H0 (Ii (/3 CD CD H, HH, rt d H pi H- S CD (12 (12 H- P2 Cl S P2 0- ft CD ft P2 C]) Hft CD Cl 0 S H o 2 H - 02 H 0 P2 EH 02 (/3 CD CD H -1 0 _2 o H H H 02 (12 ¢ 0 H U] H H (/2 H H H (12 H H H U, (-0 H (Si f2 0 CD 11 S CD hI o H, H CD H- H- Q CD ft H, 0 hI 0 P2 H, H CD hI P2 H H H H ft H- CD ((2 ft hI 0 0 ft H H, H- H- S CD ft ft 5 H P2 H- S o 0 02 CD o P2 o H, (2 S H(3 HCD H, H, (13 CD ft H- S (13 CD Cl h 0 H, (Q H- CD CD hI (12 0 (1) P2 5 P2 (12 5 CD Cl H- CD (3 0 H(12 5 P2 hI CD (2 ft H P2 H (12 U] H H H l P2 0 H CD H H H U] to (O CD 5 Cl P2 02 P2 (12 ft 0 CD (3 ft LJ (12 (12 H 0 5 ft 0 H CD H H H U] EO (3 (13 0 5 0 H Co 5 (I) 0 S ft 0 1-1 Cl CD hI H- P2 H(13 H HH, P2 ft H(12 S P2 H- (12 H- H CD (2 P2 ft CD hI CD Cl ft tx -. H H H U] CD (12 ft ft 0 S Cl H- S 0 5 (12 CD CD (12 - 0 - CD ¢ (2 H, CD H H- (/3 hI P2 * ((2 0 H- S tQ 0 S p2 ft CD P2 ft ( 3 Q ft (13 HH H, p2 - (13 0 ft CD 5 0 02 P2 ((2 ft 0 Cl 5 p2 ((2 5 H- H p2 (2 CD H H 0 H- t5 H P2 S H H ft hI H 0 0 0 hI t5 t S 0 S (3 P2 5 CD ¢ < H- hI 0 H(12 H H- (2 H p2 S h ft 13 H- P2 ft Hft S IP2 I ¶zI CD H P2 0 hI H, 13 H- HCD CD hI 0 CD hI o < CD CD o (-(2 s H- Cl ft ft hI (3 0 ft hI H((2 (2 CD H 02 HH hI -3 3 I H H H 0 ft 02 02 I H H H P2 ft ((3 0 (12 ID H H 0 00 0 -0 -(11 0 ft S hI 0 H, CD S 0 Hft H (Q p2 ft H S 0 0 -0 hI H(12 H((2 S CD 5 02 hI Cl P2 ((2 CD HhI CD hI H- P2 S (3 H- 5 S H- H O2 13 CD S 0 H 0 H CD H H H H 0 ft H- P2 p2 ft s CD S (2 0 H < hI -< H- h N Cl <1 o (Q P2 CD H CD 5 ft Cl H- P2 H 02 0 13 (13 ft ft 0 Cl H, H, (12 H- ft P2 5 ft S CD P2 (13 (12 hI CD Cl CD hI ;; c (12 CD CD (12 LQ P2 H hI H- P2 CD CD (12 CD H hI CD H 02 (2 H 5 -< p2 H(12 ((2 hI ft 0 (3 ft 5 hI P2 (- CD b -< P2 5 H, CD H HCD H(3 5 5 zI 0 5 S 5 P2 H- (13 0 H CD ft ¢ H, HCD H CD hI o (12 S hI 0 H, CD S S S H- H((2 S o ft P2 5 Cl CD H, Cl CD P2 S o hI H, C ) H H C ) 0 z H 0 C,) Cl) H -0 H H, hI CD H H CD hI CD 5 ft Cl P2 CD S 0 S hI 0 H, (I) P2 112 H, H, ft H- S H P2 hI ft P2 -ci 0 CD H H(3 CD 0 -0 ft CD hI CD ft hI P2 (2 CD (12 hI CD ft CD H P2 CD -(2 S P2 Cl H Cl S P2 S H P2 hI ft 0 ft (/3 HF- P2 H, ft S (3 H S H, H, 0 CD 0 H H0 ft 02 H- CD H(12 hI CD (12 H, 0 5 (-(2 0 0 0 S ft P2 Cl S CD H, CD Cl ft P2 ft ft (/2 hI (/2 CD P2 (12 H, H, ft H- S H H P2 H P2 H H S h CD P3 H CD H Ci P3 P1 0 Ci C) it Q - C CD P1 CD CD it jH H- H H- HCD C) 0 5 < H H P3 H- P3 C) Hi HCD 5 H- P-I C) H CD Q it l- C p1 it CD - C 1 it it 0 CD C it l it it CD l- C CD C it 0 C) CD it CD 0 P1 H H P3 5 H P3 it it Q H, it C) 0 S CD H CD CD tT H HP1 l- C C)) CD HCD it P3 CO - CD H, H U) it CD CD CD it it H- - HCD it C) H, p1 P3 C!) CD CD Q CD H H CD P3 0 CD it 5 it H- P3 H 5 d 0 C) HH C) H- P3 - CD P3 H CD H- 5 HCD l- P3 5 5 CD P3 it CD < HC) HCD H, H, d CD it H CD C) CD tY CD H- H Pi CD hCD H, H- it CD (1 Pi H H CD 0 S -_ IH - Q 0 0 it HH H C) it H0 P3 H, 0 tY it 0 - it P1 it H CD it 1 C) 0 CD 5 H- 0 it U) H U) it P3 C) it C!) H CO U) - P3 H I--i CD (Q H- P3 Q H CD P3 r-. it P3 it 0 CD Hit H- 0 d 0 p1 H, 0 CD i it CD S CD H CD CD it H, 0 P3 it H0 Ui c!) a Ui Ui - H 0 5 5 < I- 0 C) it HC) H it H ) H H W CD H- i P1 CD it - C 0 H, CO C) C -0 H- 0 H- 0 z5 1 H- it CD CD C) -C CD P3 CD H CD it H it 0 $1 CD H it it H- CD HCD CD t- C P3 1 C d CD it it P3 it LQ H- 0 CD S C) H J H- CD it H, 0 it CD 5 CD CD it Pi it H CD Hit H- C) CO 1 CX) < H- C) Q J CD H, CD CD H H- - CD CD h H, H, 0 P3 it CD C) Hit it C HC) P1 H 5 0 H, P3 - 0 -j CD i 0 CD H- H C) CD CD C) P) C) d C!) CD it - Ui Ui Ui it P1 C!) a Ui Ui - < IH 10 IS b < H P1 H- p3 I- C it 0 CD 1 1 Hi it C) 0 CD it 5 i it H- P3 H 5 d C) 0 P3 P3 it it H(1 CD CD 0 h d HC) - C CD CD C) 0 I- HH C) H- H, 0 CD CD H H P3 CD hC Q CD zJ CD it H, 0 t-J P3 Co CD H ) CD Q H- S P3 >< CD C it C) 0 CD a C o CO H 0 H it C) - C!) o H CO - H b P3 H - it H, 0 C) CD 5 I- CI C!) CD it -< CD S it H C) CJ CD CD H- 5 H P1 H- C) P3 CD CD it P1 it it 0 HH CD P3 H, pi it it it H- P3 H H CD CD H0 C) H 0 C) H CD 1Q P-I H hC 0 CD CD P1 H b P3 CD - H, H, it H- H P1 H- CD CD 0 I C P1 Hit CD C) CD fr CD 0 C) it 1 CD CD CD - C CD H0 -C it 0 H, P1 - C P3 CD it CD H- it CD Q H- H, CD C I-i it 0 C) 0 5 d 5 CD C) P1 H, 0 HCD CD p3 H S HCD Q < Pi 5 CD H --C it C) 0 CD -3 - H U) U) 3 Hl C) H (1 a) C CO w a P H - C CD -C 0 Ci CD CD 0 - H, H, it H- H- P3 H CD it 0 it CD ¢ b P1 0 C < P-I H, CD it 0 5 it H H1Q CD it H- ij H H CO HCD it H 0 0 C) C!) 0 H- X CD h S CD it CD H P3 - S 0 h H, CD -C CD it P1 Q CD b 1 C) it P3 it C) CD CD fr CD CD H, H- CD H P3 f 0 Cl) 1 CD H H P3 P3 it H P1 H- S d 0 C) CD it H- CD 0 it H- P1 P-I H H CD CD it H, 0 H H P CD it PJ CD it C) C) CD P3 CD it 5 - C it C) 0 CD H U) U) CO C) H H CO - H Q xJ O 0) -D - Pi t3 fr ¢ H 0 0 H- H- H H < 0 ¢ 0 ID H HCD 0 - ¢ H ID Cx) H H CD 10 CD H 0 CD CD CD CD Cl 10 CD H Q 0 0 CD H- rt H- H- CD H 10 H CD CD H- C) H- CD CD CD Cl Cl 0 In 0 CD CD 0 H H- CD H- U CX) M (Cx CD H- IQ 0 rt H- CD 0 CD CD Cl CD CD 0 CD rt CD Cl 0 0 CD CD Cl CD CD CD CD 0 Cl CD Cl CD H- CD 0 CD H CD 0 (Cx 0 Cl CD H- 0 0 CD CD H0 CD H- H0 0 H- CD 0 Cl CD CD CD CD (Cx CD CD H CD CD < H CD CD Cl CD CD H- CD CD 0 H H CD CD H0 H CD CD 0 Cl CD 0 0 Cl CD 0 CD CD 0 0 CD CD < CD Cl CD 0 H- H CD H- CD - w H ID 0 t CD Cl 0 CD H HCD 0 CD H- 0 H CD CD 0 - 0 CD CD 0 10 H- CD 0 H0 CD H0 H CD CD H- CD 10 H H CD H- ClCD H-H-H-OCD CD 0 - H- - CD H-CD CDCDpJCD 0( CD CDCD CD O0CD- CD0CD 0CDCD H-0ClH0 CDQO OCDH-CDCD0 0 HCD CDCDQ 0 HCDCl HCDQCD H-CDCDCDO CDCD H0H-Q CD CDCD0<10CD CDQCl CDCD CDH-CD00 CD CDH-CDo ClH ClCDOO CDQ CDH0O H CD-HZ CD OHClCDOCD 0 QH-H0 CDCD<o CD H-Q CD 10 CDHH-. Cl H-CDCDO 0 HO 10 CD H-HCDCDCD 0CDOH-0 0 CDH-CD0H 0CD -10CD 0 CD CD CD H CD H- CD Cl CD H- 0 H ID 0 0 Cfl CD CD H10 CD H 0 H- 0 H- CD 0 0 HCD 0 CD H0 CD H 0 H- < H- 0 CD 0 W H ID ¢ 0 (Cx Cl CD 0 H0 CD 0 0 CD CD 0 0 CD CD CD CD CD H- H- H W 0 H 0 H 0 H 0 ¢ 0 0 ID Q H- Cl 0 w W Cl In - CD Cl CD H- CD Cl Cn 0 H CD 0 - - CD C 0 (H 0 S 0 CD H CD CD CD CD -. 0 In ID ID H CD Cl H- (Cx CD CD H CD CD H- 0 H CD CD H- H 0 0 HCD 0 CD 0 H- CD H H CD 10 CD CD CD CD CD CD 0 Cl CD 0 CD H H CD H CD CD CD CD CD H N CD ft ft - CD C) H- Cl LJ Cl P1 CD Ft 0 Fl C) CD CD CD H- CD >< C) CD Ft 0 S H- 0 H P3 P1 Q CD 1 H H CD CD CD CD ft < CD 1 P1 CD CD < Fl 0 P1 ¢H H CD ft ft CD Ft ft 0 P1 C) Fl CD H- ft Ft 0 CD LJ H- 0 CD CD P1 CD CD CD Fl Ft ft C) ft Cl C) 0 Ft Ft CD CD ft P1 ft ft CD S P1 ft CD CD ft 0 Fl < CD C) H C) 0 CD ft CD CD 5 pi HFt Ft ft H p1 H- CD C) P1 CD HCD ft H 0 Fl C) Ft P1 ft 0 -< H CD Fl ft P1 H- < CD C) CD CD Ft 0 HC) ft H- P1 p1 CD CD CD CD H- C) P1 5 H- C) H P1 PJ ft ft ft 0 Fl CD P1 CD ft CD - -< Fl LJ H- CD H- S H- P1 ft 5 H- CD ft CD P1 0 ft Fl CD C) CD H- 0 CD 0 ft ft HFt Ft P1 P1 CD H 1 H- ft CD < CD ft HFt Ft Fl - 0 Fl C) d Fl CD Q PJ CD ft p1 CD Q S Fl P3 P1 H- H - H CD Q d Hft CD HCD CD 5 HCD b CD CD ft S ft H- d H P3 S C) 0 HCD . D 3 ft P1 Cr) W 0 5 P1 Fl P1 Q Q ft H- 0 .Q Ui o H O Fl H- C) 1 L-.J W a) - a) NI CO Q 1 - - P1 P1 H P1 P1 Ft 0 H- CD 0 - < P1 Q Fl 0 S H- < H < 0 CD Ft < H H- Fl P1 Q P1 P1 H- C) CD Fl ft CD CD ft CD - ft CD 0 Fl CD p1 C) H- 0 H- ft pi C) 5 0 H HC) CD CD ft 0 Ft CD CD C) 1 ft CD C) HFl C) CD ft ft 0 CD H- LQ CD H 0 CD 0 ft H- Z pi ft ft CD t5 Fl 0 d Fl HP1 ft CD P1 0 Fl CD 5 CD Fl Fl ft W C) a) ft P1 - P H- CD CD Cr) ft Ft H HLQ b < CD CD ft Fl pi Fl Fl Cl CD P1 CD < ft 0 LQ H- tJ ft 5 CD ft ft P1 0 Fl CD ft CD P1 Fl LL Fl CD CD CD ft Fl CD ft CD CD HCD CD ft 1 CD H- C) Fl CD ft M o CD ft CD Fl CD ft Cl P1 CD Fl CD ft HP1 ft CD Cl CD S S H- P1 CD d 0 CD CD CD C) ft Fl 0 d 0 C) CD Fl CD Ft Ft H- 0 CD ft Ft 0 ft CD CD HCD ft H- CD H CD P1 Ft CD ft 0 ft ft 1 CD Fl -t -< < CD P1 C) ft H- HCD ft C) CD d CD CD H- - P1 Ft 0 - CD CD CD CD H b p1 0 1 CD Fl CD ft H- C) 0 P1 CD ft 0 Ft HC) CD Fl Ft ft CD CD -Q CD ft H CD Ft 0 Fl Hft Cl CD tj CD ft 5 Fl C) CD Ft 0 0 Ft CD CD H P1 Fl CD Cl S 0 ft P1 Ft Fl CD Fl Fl P1 ft CD CD C) CD H- H ft 0 H H- {Q CD Q CD H- Fl b p1 d P1 CD CD < Fl CD 1 Ft 0 < CD ft H- C) CD Fl CD d CD CD ft Ft 0 0 < HCD H- k) 0 . t) Q CD ft ft H0 CD CD CD ft Fl CD HCl CD C) 0 < P1 5 ft Fl C) 0 CD ft < CD - H- CD C) ft LJ 0 ty HCD CD CD CD H CD b P1 0 CD P1 CD CD o H 3) CX) S O -1 - (.1 CO a) Cl) C) 0 Fl CD 0 0 < S P1 b t P1 0 H H- LQ H- ft 0 Ft Fl C) 0 CD CD H <1 H- ft CD C) i 0 CD Fl p1 CD P1 C) CD 0 ft P1 C) CD Fl C) CD 0 Ft Ft H- C) CD 0 P1 CD Fl CD ft Ft 0 0 ft H- ft H S CD C) HFl C) Q P1 CD ft P1 C) Ft CD ft Ft 0 ft Q H H- H- H CD b P1 C P1 CD H 0 ff3 CD P1 CD < P3 S (1) CD H- P1 Ft 0 Fl H CD H C) P1 S H P1 H C) C) CD Fl 0 Ft CD CD H C) CD CD CD ft CD CD Fl ft 0 s3 - Q < CD Pi CD CD 0 5 0 Hft HMi . C) CD ft CD CD CD ft CD f-F 5 C) 0 CD f-F 51 cv HH- CD LQ 1CDq CD o Mift HCDCDcv H- CD r 0 CD H o H CD CD OfQ H h cv HCD CD CD Z HCD SI CD CD CD 0 H cv H- CD H Mi H CD CD CDSH CD cv CD CD ft CD CD CD 0 HC) ft H0 CD H CD CD CD HCD CD CD 51 S HCD 51 tJ CD CD ft S ft CD C) 0 ft ft Mi N 5 H 5)) H- f-F 5)) CDQj (Dcij CD ¢ CD SI f-F 5)) f-F H 0 h5 HC) ft H0 < C) 0 HCD 0 Mi -< cv H H51 Hft H- CD f-t -< < H cv Hi ft HMi Mi CD ft 0 Mi 0 Mi cv Hi ft CD 5 (.Q 51 -- 5)) CD )- 5 CD ft cr cv 5 CD H CD CD CD CD 0 HCD CD H HCD Mi t- - CD t 5 HCD 0 Cl CD 51 f-F HC) <1 0 C) U HCD ft )Ho ft - CD CD CD ft cv H- 51 Hcv H ft CD tl cv 0 ft HCD HMi Mi f-F H cv H- HMi 0 F-5 CD 5 h CD f-F 1 zi 53 Cl CD 51 CD 51 h ft cv ft ft H- 51 0 H H -0 W ) CX) - - i) FJ H- 51 CD - H 5 f-F H- F- Ui 51 H - CD CD 0 C) CD ft HH H- CD 5 CD S f-F F )) ft e 0 C) F CD C) CD CD CD cv H Q 0 H- 5)) H 1 CD C) ft HMi Mi H- cv H ft H iCD cv ft DCD 0 CDCD nd CD H CDOHJ P) H CDrt < H- CDCDCD OCD p)o b H H CD h çt CD 5 QCD $)i H Z CD C) ft -< cv cv H HH H CD HCD cv CD CD CD h5 ft < cv 5 CD HC) H- U CD CD CD 51 H- C) H 5)) H- 0 C) Cl CD f-F CD ft 5i) 0 Hi (Q Q - CD CD HN CD Q Pi 0 CD Pi C) CD CD CD & CD ft 51 cv - CD CD CD ft cv H- Hcv H CD ft ii cv HCD HMi Mi f-F H 5)) H- f-F 5)) ft CD CD ) -Cl Hft )J CD CD HCD ft H S )-Q CD 0 C) CD CD 51 H- H 5)- H- S H- C) CD f-F 5)) f-F CD 5 Mi h5 0 CD ft CD i ft H0 Si) (Q CD CD CD H- Q ) 1 - H 0 ) H W Cl) CD H HCD 5)) < CD 0 -< Cl) CD CD )Q CD H- 0 C) CD CD d CD F cv ft CD 5)) CD ft 0 Mi CD CD -1 C) 0 CD ft H- -< cv ft CD H Q cv SI CD 51 CD CD CD CD 51 )-5 5)) 51 CD b -< 5 Q CD < 0 H H- CD CD HCD CD cv f-F CD b U CD f-F 5 )-Q CD CD CD H- 51 51 5)) S 0 h )- H- 51 -5 0 C) CD CD f-F C) 0 CD Mi cv f-F H- f-F CD rt ) (C cv Hi CD LJ cv H ft H0 CD ft Hft CD H HCD Mi CD < C) 0 ft C) 0 Mi CD 51 CD 1 cv H - CD (Q H- 51 Hi h5 0 C) CD CD 0 d 1 -< 51 HC) H5)) H ft 0 )ft CD C) 0 cv H CD 51 Mi CD CD ft 0 Mi 0 H CD I- CD ft H H Mi CD f-F CD CD C) ft H- CD ft cv CD Q H 0 Q CD CD 0 CD )-Q 5)) CD ) 5 Q CD f-F 0 HCD f-F H- cv CD Q H H- F -J- 5)) ft CD f-F CD t-Q H- 51 CD Cl H- CD Mi CD f-F CD H- cv n CD 5 0 Mi ft cv H- CD b cv CD ft 5 f-F H- cv f-F f-F 51 CD Mi H- f-F Q 0 HCD fQ H- CD CD CD C) ft CD 0 lCD t3 cv CD CD <i H- < CD ft 0 Mi cv HH CD H CD 0 5) CD CD HN CD 51 Pi CD CD J êC) H cv HH H CD Lr cv cv CD 0 S CD HCD 0 Mi C) CD CD cv CD t rF 5)) f-F H 0 f-F H CD LO 5)) H 5)) CD -. ft H Mi Mi H- t H C-) 1) tn t:zI H Co Iftp15OCDh P1CDSCDH-bHi. 0 ft Cl CD C) ft CD LJ YCl) CD Hi ftOP1 SftOpl HC)ftCD Cl)ft P1CD -CD ft CDO l <CjWftC)ft C H-HftH- OIP1 L -1OC C)ftClH-CDC)ClHin C) 0 ft Cl)ft P1 C) -jClCD CP)CDP1LftCDP1 PJCl HCDOft-3 C)HftOCDCD- -cJCDplCDft OHi CDH HiP1PJSHCD -< - HCDdClftftH ft H-ClCD iH-wQ iCDHCICDO OP1 Cl)ftCl)p)HCD H-flft l)Wct ftCDH-*CDf-tCD QC)HCDCl) M *H-L1h-CDCl)HH 3 HH-QCD: CDH-Cl) -QC) CDH-CD ftCDM CD ClftCDQft Cl HP1CDCDH-HQ -ij IPICl)Cl) ftQHC) ftOQCl1< OHHC)H OP) HPlO CDCDC) CIOCl) - CDCl)CDHpiCD CDdftQ 1Qj CD ft Hi C)H-CCD 50 HiftCC C)PICD HCD OCl)P1 Ct)HCflftCDftC,) H CDp)N CDCl)CDjCl) ftH OCDC)CDftQç-tCD MH-ft < HH1 t ti 1hfl LP)ctHH-CDftWCDfrbQ t-h -i Cl)C) ctQ :l)Cl2ICDOHCDbi rt 5CDCDPHQC) rf51CDftCD H )HiHQ C)HCl)PJP)Co P1Hi <rrftHCDbHtfj)C) ClQCD CDH-*CD t5 CDCD H-HCDJ LQ r<pJQQCDH pi tY H q 4 C * ft P1 Cl -- LO U] H C) H i C ) 0 H 0 - H W H -< Co Co W - Co t J Co $1 w 3 M LO Hi P1 fr 0 H - 5 P1 Cl) CD ft CD 5 0 tHCl) - H- C) P1 Hi HCD H CD Cl) ft CD CD p1 CD ft - ft CD Cl) P1 h P1 CD P1 S CD CD C- h CD < 0 CD 0 X H LO Co Co C) H- W . Cl Cl H Co (-.1 1 P1 P1 Cl) CD CD CD Cl) ft Hi 0 Hft C) H H- ft HHi Hi H- P1 CI H p1 - Cl) ft CD P1 h h CD H Cl) 5 CD Cl) ft l- P1 CD ft ft 0 ft CD P1 H H CD ft ft P1 Cl) Cl p1 U 0 - Cl) CD CD Cl) CD p1 C) H CD P1 p1 H Cl) CD ft 0 0 Hi 5 C) H Pi H- ft CD Q S CD H Q P1 ft 0 < Cl) 5 P1 H- HH H Cl) CD p1 ft P1 ft ft H ft Cl) CD CD H CD M 0 CI ft 0 Hft CD )J )J Cl) Hi -j CO vi U] 1D Hui HH i QCD H H - CD Cl) ft Hi p1 C) CD Co W LO 0 C J C Z5 C) H H coi CD 5 H- jj C) H d U 0 H HC) CD CD Co p1 ft r1 J Cl) P1 ft 0 ft ft p1 Cl) Z, ft H0 CD rr CD M t- M Q H 0 - ft U CD 0 H H C) CD H 1 P1 0 5 -1 GD (.Q C) Hft H- ft -xl 0 CD H HN P1 0 C) p1 CD ft P1 ft Cl) 0 ft Cl CD l 0 H - Cl) CD Cl) C) P) LQ H- ft C) H- S H 0 Co W C) H- Cl W Co U] C -) -si Co 3 M HP1 CD H H P1 H Cl < CD Cl) H 5 H E P1 CD Cfl CD H LO Co io CD Q H CD P1 C) ft H- C) P1 0 H- ft H P1 0 H- ft CD 5 Cl CD S f 1 ft 0 j P1 HCl) Cl) CD p1 C) H CD P1 Q h d rt 0 H ft Cl) HCl) 0 Hi C) CD Cl) ft - l-j P1 p1 P1 ft ft Hft C) H H- C) CD C) Cl 0 h ft 0 Cl P1 H H CD Hi C) CD CD Cl 3 H CD P1 b 1 C) ft 0 H ft CD Cl CD Cl) ft P1 Cl) P1 CD ft p1 ft ft Cl) 1 CD P1 5 Cl) P1 HHi Hi ft H- CD CD H- Ci H j Cl) CD ft pi Hi ft CD H- ft Cl) p H- tQ $)) C) CD CD Cl) C) CD Cl) H- ft H- CD Q H H Cl) b ft P1 Cl) CD CD H H HCl) H ft CD H1 CD i X H C) bl 0) -3 CC t:l U) ft HCDct(C P1 CD H-h$. 5 H- 0 jft 1-4 H, ¢ - Cl HC) CD ft CD Cl P1 1--i 1-4 CD (Cl ft HC CQ 0 (.Q 1-4 P1 C) 1-4 0 H, (Cl CD C) P1 H CD b P1 0 1-4 i C) (Cl P1 CD (Cl C) 0 frj CD 1-4 ft CD ft p1 ft ft Cl P1 Cl C) ft p1 H, CD ft 0 0 Hft Cl H(Cl (Cl CD S H(Cl Cl CD 1-4 CD - CD -< P1 5 1-4 CD H HCD H, HC) 0 S (Cl ft 5 H- P1 H, H, CD -$ (Cl 0 C) H C) ¢ P1 -4 h$ CD (Cl ft CD -< (fi ft H(Cl H p1 H- H, H u H H CD CD ft P1H-ft CD ClSftPi H-CDft C)IP1CD 5 CDftHCD 1 ft1-1 CDP1H nCD ftCClO(C C) 0 H-tift ft ft C) H-ft (ClP1 (C (Cl(CH, CDH-P1ft Cl(ClHHCD S 0 ftt Qft 5 H-P15 1 (nHCDp bP1dH CDC)P1(Cl o ftCDH (ClH-ft P1 HHCDH, (CO H, H P1 (Cl ft P1 ft CD SCD Oft 0 CD Ct ) 0 CD H, HH CD CD CD H, ()CD WCDH. (ClH-ft C) CDft ctQft Cl P1 1:l H ft (1) t3 P1 H IH H Q tY CD H-4 -Q h4 CD (Cl P1 Cl CD (Q (Cl P1 CD ¢ (Cl U) tJ H P1 H ft 0 1-4 H, CD H H HP1 b H(Cl ft P1 Cl CD H, CD Cl CD ft P1 ft ft C) CD CD H, CD -$ H, H, H- (Cl Cl CD P1 H H CD ft 0 H CD h4 ft 1 H- C) P1 (Cl ft HH, H, tJ H Pi H- ft 0 ft 1-4 C) 0 CD ft CC P1 ft ft 0 (Cl ft 0 (Cl C) ft P1 H, ft 0 C) HCD i p1 H H ft P1 ft 0 1-4 H CD b (Cl H- H P1 < H- H CD H1 H H C) 1 H, H(Cl 5 C) H Pi H- CD ft b P1 ft 1 H H CD 0 C) CD P1 F- CD ft $]J Q (Cl Cl 0 5 H(Cl C) CD ft CD CD (Cl H- HH, H, ft H- P1 H tY CD -4 CD H, 0 H, H(Cl pl ft ft H H CD H O pi ft ft C) H(Cl ft H i 5 H(Cl (Cl P1 H P1 H IH IQ b < CD Cl H- rJ 1-4 0 P1 (Cl P1 H C) ft P1 H, ft HC) HCD H, H, (Cl H H CD U CD 1 P1 0 ft P1 (12 < H(Cl H, hj Cl H, P1 S S (I) 1 CD P1 1-4 0 CD ft -4 P1 ft H(Cl Q 5 1 -< -4 < C) Cl 0 b H(Cl CD CD H CD 5 d )J >4 CD 1 H CD CQ p1 H -< b Cl CD H CD (Cl 0 5 CD C) b CD t-4 CD (Cl ft CD P1 CD ft CD H(Cl ft Pi ft i H- H(Cl 1 5 H- ¢ 1 Q l1 CD 0 CD Cl H- 1--4 0 H, (Cl Cl CD ft CD 5 (Cl 11 P1 1-4 CD U) CD 0 i C) CD (Cl P1 (Cl CD ( H- H0 Cl CD 1-4 (Cl 0 H- ft P1 ft P1 H (Cl CD CD C) 5 H H- CD ft (Cl h$ C) C) C) CD (Cl ft 1 -4 H CQ H, -4 0 -< H H CT) LQ CD Cl H p H, < Cl H CD CD P1 H H CD ft CD H -< 0 )-$ CD <1 CD 0 0 ft UI UI CD (1) U) U] - ft 0 P1 ci C) CD P1 H H P1 (Cl (Cl CD H P1 H- CD P1 CD < ft H- - -4 P1 CD ft H C) Pi H- 5 C) 1 H- C) h$ 0 ft I) ft ft CD S 1-4 ft H CD W P1 - ci (Cl CD 0 - ¢ CD H U) C) Hh4 Cl W CD H H t-J CD W CD 2 (Cl HH CD H, i C) P1 CD CD (Cl ft CD -4 -$ P1 H H U) CD D ¢ -4 C) H- Cl W - U, H CD w CD ft C)) P1 (Cl 0 0 (Cl - UI UI H Cl tJ ¢ i ft P1 H H- H H, CD 5 -4 j CD 0 5 H- (Cl CD 1 CD 0 ft 0 CD CD (1) (Cl ft U) H U] CD ft 0 (Cl CD C) C) 1-4 1 < H H C) P1 H- -< ft ft (Cl CD P1 H (Cl CD P1 -1 f-$ t-4 0 H, 5 H- P1 P1 (Cl Ct HH, H, C) H d H p1 H- UJ CD Ct H o CD 0 H, ft CD 5 CD UI CD ft p1 UI I p1 0 Q C) Hct H- U) U) U) H 4 C Z 1 U] U] UI 1 Cl (1) I U] UI ft 0 C) H C) ç-t P1 H ft Pi 5 )i H Q CD it Cu it1j ci LiD CD 4 C HCD it U)Z it CDL i U) H CuCn it it C) H--3 rtbj CD CD Cu Cu H < 0 ci H it it CD 5 U) H- 0 0 Cu Hit CD H Cu it CD H- W H- M it CD 5 H CD CD < Cu U) U) CD CD CD CD it Hi 0 CD CD CD Q CD it H- 0 h CD HH H 1 W Ui H Ui Cu it it 0 H- it CD it Cu CD CD H CD b Cu 0 U) Cu CD Cu CD HU) Cu 0 it Cu CD it U) Hi LiD 0 CD 0 < Hi h CD 0 U) it H- d - CD Cu H H U) < 0 HU) it HCD U) Cu 5 o CD CD Cu CD o Cu it CD H- h 0 d Cu HU) CD Q [HIH [H jH- I I-t it tY CD Q Cu U) it L H- Q H CD Cu CD it Cu it çt CD S CD H- CD it Cu b HH H- b h 0 Cu CD U) 0 5 H- it 0 CD U) 0 - HU) it CD S CD H CD CD H- CD CD it U) it LiD CD U) 0 it CD it it U) Cu CD it Cu it CD 5 Cu H Cu it Cu CD Hi 0 CD it H- it H- Cu - U) it Cu it HI - U) it ci CD S S U) CD t3 Cu CD H Cu C4 S Q Cu it U) LiD H- Cu H CD d CD it Cu 0 CD Cu CD U) H- CD hj 5 H- CD H - ci CD -< CD Cu H- CD Q H H- 0 t3 3 Cu it HC) S 0 CD U) < Cu 0 it Li H- CD it it Cu Cu it H- H Cu 0 S CD it 0 0 it H- 0 5 Cu Hi HH CD 0 it Hi Hi H- it H- Cu H 0 H H )J H H H- it C) C) HU] it - 1 U) HHi Hi it Cu H- ti H H- i U) H 0 S CD ft 0 U) CD H- H pi >< CD CD 0 Cu CD it H it CD U) C) U) CD ci CD -j (fl Cl- H- Cu H 5 CD 0 H- C4 CD 5 Cu it ci Cu CD 0 H- Cu CD HCD U) CD CD Hi HCD H- CD çt CD U) U) CD U) h Cu CD H- it H- H Cu 0 S zI CD CD C1 CD 5 Cu U) Li) CD it 0 it CD CD C4 Cu it U) S it HHi Hi H- Cu H d -< H H Cu CD CD HHi HCD u CD 0 Cu H >< CD Cu U) HCD - Hit CD H- C) H- f-3 CD it 0 Hi U) Cu i- CD t3 d Hi 0 it i 0 0 CD it

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.