MINATEE v. DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS et al, No. 2:2010cv00770 - Document 8 (D.N.J. 2010)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION fld. Signed by Judge Peter G. Sheridan on 4/26/10. (sr, )

Download PDF

Cl) CD CO S H- f-If-I- CO CO pi CD (1 CO CD f-f H- CD P1 I--h f-I- CD HCOQ P1 HCD CO CD CO P1 - -j ft C) pi f-I CD CO 0 CD H CO H CD CD CD P1 CD >< < H CD f-IH- CD -I CD -. CD CD d r1 Hrt H- 0 C) CD CD CD 5 0 H H CD CD 0 < CD < CD ft 0 1 H- H- CD P1 CO CD 0 H- H- CD f- H- H CO S CD CO CD p f-I0 h P1 CO CD Ct CD P1 S CD f-I- HC) 0 ft 0 CD ft CD H p1 h H- [CD H ft H- P1 - H- H H CD P1 C) J p CD 0 H- CD f-IH- H- Q- CD ft CD h H h rt HC) Pi CD H CD H- P1 H- H C) CD f-I- HH CD - rt H- S c1 (V CD H CO CD Cl) H- p Pi rt CD 11 f-I- H H- P1 HCO HHH COCD U CD Cl) H H P1 C) lCD H P1 ftHCO HP1 P1 0 Hi ft i CO CO ft 0 o H H P CO H- CD HII CD C) rt 0 C) CD Ã§1 CD HH Ã§t H H H°r HCO 0 P1 CD HCO CO CO H- 0 I) CD CD H- CO CD < * CD H P) H- CD C) H rr 5 rt H- * ct H f-I- 1Q H- < Hht C) H P1 CD f-IHf-I- CD a CD H C CD C) O ty C) rt W HC) H P1 CO ft H- H H H- HH CD H- Cl) H P1 (1) tCO Q l- P1 CD g CD H P1 S CD Ã§u f-I 0 P1 CO CD Q < H- CD CD ft S CD 0 CD 0 Ct CD 0 C) CD -3 M H Z ft CD ft C 0 Cl) CD CD S I-t Ã§t CD CD CD >< CD fr 0 H- Ã§t t H- d (V 5 IC) ft CD 5 Q 0 P1 CD < CD H- CD 0 H CD -j H Q M M 0 H H Cl) ft CD H CD CO Q Cli CD til 0 t1 Cl) r 0 H z H 0 L Ic CD 0 H- ft H- CD C/) CD H CD 0 0 HH H- C) H Cl) 0 0 H < C1 tC) b:i0 CH ZH On) H Htz N) CD CD CD CD SD CD CD -Q CD CD CD CD H- 0 C) 0 ft CD HC) ft H- 51 CD LQ ft H- Hft H0 - Hft ft H- (1) p CD ft HH H H0 ft CD ft H CD HH CD 0 -< ft l- L I CD CD l CT < CD ft H- CD 1-5 H- 51 CD -j Q CD ft H- H H- H 0 0 lH 51 CD CD l 0 H- CD ft Hft CD CD CD Cl) Hft CD ft H- ct CD ft Hft H- - H SD 0 Hft H- 51 SD Hft CD 1 0 H- CD H SD Hj a CD CD Q Q CD C) ft H- Q H- bIl rr CD ft H0 j H H- ) H- H- b PJ CD lH CD ft 1-5 C) C 0 CD -< Hft 1-5 ft rJ 0 CD 0 CD h ft H0 CD P1 H H Q CD ft ft CD ft Cl ft CD H- 0 H CD h ct 5 51 CD 0 ft CD SD SD f-t C) 0 CD CD CD ) () Ui z 9 -< ft 1-5 CD -< CD H H- pi HCD H- 1 ft 0 ft Hft 0 Q H- ft C CD ft H- H i Hl-Q H- C) < CD CD 1-5 0 0 SD Ht H() - CD CD CD CD Q CD 1 CD CD CD 0 () HCD ft Hi U H- H, 0 ft H CD CD H- 1 CD ft H- Q ft HH CD I-h H CD ft H- h CD 0 H H- CD 1J ft ft CD CD 1-5 SD ft CD H, 0 H- CD CD Q CD Cl) CD C) H CD 0 ft H H i H (T1 9 rj CD 0 C) CD CD CD H- SD 51 H CD CD H- CD CD CD C) ft H- H- CD 0 SD C) C) CD HCD CD ft CD 1 1J $1) Ãª- H0 ft H- CD CD 51 CD CD rt CD CD 0 Q ft H- CD CD ft 0 Hft C) 51 SD 0 H- CD ft H- CD 51 CD SD H- CD C) ft 0 C) ft CD 0 SD CD l. ft SD ft ft CD CD CD CD H CD P1 HCD H- CD d CD 1 CD J ft CD C3 J H- CD ft H CD CD HC) H, 0 ft CD - - CD CD H CD ft ft CD ft o 0 H CD CD ¢ 0 CD CD 0 H- CD ft Hft H- CD ft H- )J Cl) HCD ft CD CD CD lCD Hft H0 CD CD 51 CD SD SD Hft ft CD 51 CD CD CD ft HtQ lCD 0 Ix HCD Q CD CD ft Hft HQ HCD CD < ft II Ci CD C) Q [CD Cl) lCD CD CD CD H- CD i-Q SD H H CD ft < ft 0 CD 51 CD ft SD HH CD 0 CD 0 I-S CD SD CD ft H- 0 Hft H- H CD CD CD ft Cl) CD CD Cl) H 0 ft 51 CD 1-5 0 H CD 1f5 CD SD H H CD CD ft i-J CD ft 0 tt CD CD P CD CD 0 H tY j 0 13 Hi F o F 00 ,- cv to F 0 cv 0 F < 0 a a 13 - to F C 0 0 0 i-s P1 < a -1 C P,Hi F e to 0 F- o 0 U * F tt HO, P1 C n i CD F to 13 cv to to cv P1 ctfl 0 0 to 0 Hi a F a < cv P1 cv a Hi -5 0 B 0 P1 II to Hi Hi F F H F 0 cv 13 P1 cv -. cv cv H F to U cv 0 Hi a 0 0 a P1 cv to H F- <to tocva ii F cv F o U F P1 cv C to CD cv F cv F 0 ii a F 0 cv F 0 13 < 0 ii 0 Hi Hi F 0 F P1 H to to cv 0 F I-i U to a F 0 a H a P1 to to cv to cv a P1 H C Hi F cvii F 0 , 0 Hit U a P1 0 C cv a 0 cv Ui-i F to to cv cv g 0 P1 cv cv F j cv to C 0 to a I-i cv F cv F 0 ii 0 Hi a F ij P1 cv cv to a P1 0 F- F-I C cv i- a U a a to aHit 0 ii C II Hi 0 Hi 1 cv F 0 ii a i-i F cv a o cv cv C a cv P1 13 F cv 0 i-i c a i-s cv P1 F 13 F 13 P1 cv a 0 F 0 0 P1 F a i-s cv F 13 F a ii to a < C E a - a 13 a i B a B F P1 0 0 1 a Ii cv H i-5 tj C a H a F < F F cv F a F- P1h< cv -a F P1 H 0 13 0 to E to a cv 0 P1 cv - 13 a cv U P1 cv F cv C H H F F 0 Hi cv g to F cv F a F to U 0 Hi cv F cv a P1 to cv P1 cv F i-i cv cv F 0 a F to 0 F B to H P1 F a U , cv 0 Hi cvii a to 0 CD cvcv IF cv n < WcvO P1 g U F a F c cv to i-a cv cv Hi F F Hi U I F cv (1 F 13 F 0 F P1 0 0 F 0 0 cv to a ii a 13 a 130 P1P1i-icvH cv C cv to Hi a cv a Ua a F cv P1 F * P1 to F H° 0 F P1 aai-i F an cv F a a - a 0 -% a Ã¤ a,-, U Ij pi cv i-i a P1 g I 13 g g C a a cv H 13 , to U U cv a U to a F a F i-totoagotogHi a H C a a C a H I to F U cv 0 a H F a cv a C 13 a Pcvcv to C B U 13 Hi cv to cv F a to U F to Ccv too F F on P1 0 cv acvcv cv 11 0 Hi 0 to P1 a to U F cv cv a F a F- cv Hi 0 a .-o 0 tJ CD CD CD rH- c-f o $2) o o Hc-I CD o o CD H- HCD H- o CD d CD H- U t$2) h CD CD (Q CD 4 C CD CD 1 c $2) H 0 H H0 3) c-I H- d d CD o C) o CD h H- 1f2 CD rt C4 CD H CD CD 0 ti CD Ã§t H Ã§t H 0 i $2) hh H H CD CD $2) c-t H[-h HCD CD 0 H $2) CD CD c-i- $2) CD c-f c-f o i CD CD Q- CD h h $2) 0 (Q H 0 CD 0 ci) c-I CD Hi $2) c- H0 H- c-I tI c-f CD c-f CD M 0 c-f CD 0 d CD 0 H 0 CD CD CD H- c-f t J CD c-f. 0 U f< H H cii ji- CD -Q CD $ CD CD CD H- h-$ c-f CD H- 0 0 Ãª-$ CD ((2 H- $2) H o o H -$ c-f H- fr H$2) H HN H- CD CD CD CD - 1c-I H- CD CD CD $1 H- r H- CD c-I < j CD c-I 0 U 0 (f2 CD CD l-$ H- H- c-I $2) H 0 H- CD ic-f 0 H CD $2) 0 H- t-t c-f CD c-i CD CD c-f b CD $2) CD 0 H CD $2 f CD H 0 CD 0 c-f H- CD H H- c-i- 0 c-I cii 0 C$ h c-i- CD i- CD H0 CD CD CD CD 0 CD $1 CD F Cl) c-f c-f f-$ CD Q c-iH- H c-i- CD CD H i- b. CD (C) CD -, H i- - H CD c-f - -j t ) C) HCD H- H- U pi CD CD CD CD 0 ct H CD ( CD c-I 0 H- $1 CD CD - d CD CD CD ci lQ Ci c-f c-i- H- c-f $3) -1 0 CD c-f H CD f-h f-h H0 H- CD CD CD cii H- - H- o o (Q CD 0 CD f-h cii 0 CD c-i 0 l-$ hh H0 cii c-f H tQ c-f CD CD - H CD c-f CD CD c-f c-f 0 H H CD c-f HH HCD 0 CD $1 H 0 o 0 cii CD CD H 0 0 CD c-f H HCD Hc-f c-f CD CD - CD H0 c-f H- d CD c-f H- - CD CD CD CD CD 0 f- o cii CD 0 H HCD c-I H c-f CD fHIQ HCD CD CD c-I cii H o H- ci) lQ 0 ci) c-f H- H- c-f H0 cii CD o i c-I Hj 0 0 0 f-h cii H H- CD ci c-f Ã§ 0 H- H 0 0 (Q f-h H f-h CD c-I Hf-ti - - Hc-f CD LI 0 lQ 0 iH f-h c-I 1 H - n Ã§ S 0 f ci CD c-f CD CD H H H c-i- CD HCD CD 0 H c-f c-iH- f-ti CD ci ci) N CD H H cii H cii c-f CD CD c-I ci cii 0 CD l- 0 f-h ci) CD CD H- $1 $3) H- CD CD f-$ 0 - c-f 0 ci HCi CD CD CD H- c-f H CD c-i- C Hc-f CD C c-f H- o 0 l- $ CD ci) cli cii H f-h c-i- 0 C ly 0 ci) ct 0 f-ti c-l l l c- H ci C a 0 H H ti- CD C 0 f-$ CD 0 0 H- 5 0 H- i f cii - c-i- (Q ci) c-I Hl1 CD c-t H- o (Q o H l $ f-h HCD CD it c-I ci) c-f 0 CD H- CD CD CD 0 H CD 0 HcH- CD d $2) c-i- c-f H 0 c-f Hc-I CD CD c-I U1 H- PiPi n3_ CD Cl S CU CD HCU CD CDClft ClCDCDCl C))iHCDCD S(0HCD 0 CiCDC)CD rtCDM CD 5 CUHICl 0 iHCjCl 5C))C)) CU0CD- H-QCU Q HICDCl-C-t fr0H00 frCDftIft rtH-C))CD CDclC)J CD 00 0CUp-(H < jÃ§tClCD -0 H-tICDD ClCDCU jH,H CDQ 0SCD CDH-CD iCDH-H,° CD< oh0 H5 LQ o-tC)yHrtCD c1 H- C))0CDH H, OCD CDCD 1,jQ H-Q 0 ) HCD H H 0CDH-CDCD H r H- H d H- ti 0 0 J d 0 0 CD CD CD CD Q H H CD C)) CD f-3 Cl CD rt CD CD Hd C)) rt H0 Cl0 CU H CD H- H, 0 H0 C)) Cl (0 H 0 H, CD 0 0 t H ft H5 C) rt CD CD ;i 0 Cl- (0 CU ft Cl- H- Cl H 0 H H, CD - H- C)) rt H0 H0 H- CD- Cl CD CD H- CD CD HCD Q I CD Cl- H- CU (0 CD Q H- 0 0 Q 0 Y CD C)) 5 ct H- (0 CU CD CD (0 CD 0 5 CD CU H- CU h 0 H CD HCD 0 i CD CD < CD hCD CD ft CD 5 HCD CD CD Cl Ic-t C)) H- CD Cl HCD HCD Cl CD C)) Cl Q 0 H0 ft HCD CD H CD 0 H, H- C 0 C)) CD CD 5 0 Ci h t- CD CD 0 H- 3 - H 3 CO H H- Cl W , Q - CD H 1° - Cl- CD CD H C1 H- 0 0 H H H- CU CD HCD fr C)) CD CD rr 5 0 CD CD CD H- CD CD (0 C)) H H CD 0 rr 0 0 H- CD H CD CU CD CD CD 0 0 - CD CD HCl CD H H 0 H, 0 0 H0 rt H 0 rt H- C)) CD Cl 0 Cl CU CD CD J CD ft Cl CD HCl (0 H- 0 H- Cl H CD H, H CD CD Q H, C) CD (t 0 rt H- 0 ct CD 0 CD CU C)) b CD ) H- Cl CD C)) HCD CD H Cl H H, H CD 0 CD CD H- l HCD Cl H0 0 0 F CD CD ct 0 CD H H cC CD CD CU 0 CD CD H- H H Cl- 0 Cl H- CD 0 H, H H- CD Cl- 0 rt ( i 0 0 C)) H CD H H CD (-0 H, C)) H J 0 H, Cl CD H CD CD HCD Cl CD CD C)) CU H H CD 0 CD CD 0 H CD rr H- Ã§t 0 f-3 w CU r( CD IC!) H CD H- < H ) CD Cl- H- ft H CD Cl H, H- CD 0 H- CD CD CD CD H- CD i:I CD t.Q CD 0 rt C)] CD Ã§t CD r CD CD (0 H CD H C)) 0 HCD H, CD C C 0 CD CU E H- H, 0 C)) CD Cl - C)) CD C)) H d CD C)) CD 0 Cl Cl 0 H CD ct 0 CD CD 1 t Q Q ft 0 H Ã§ H- CD CD CD CD t 0 Cl C)) j H 0 o- ) CD CD C) 0 CD :i i-C) j f h 0 CD CD C) Ã§3) CD CD H CD CD It H- 0 Q CD HCD CD H- CD C) HCD CD QHCD It CD CD i h Ã§t CD p) CD 0 It CD CD CD CD It H It -h CD H CD It - 0 0 C) H HCD 0 0 h CD t h rt rt HCD 0 H 0 0 CD w p w Co Co co Co N) X d t3 CD 1 W U] CD 0 - : 0 pj CD h W i CD P- . S H Di Q t- CDDi Mi Di H-ItH - Mi Ã§-tCD H 0 CDhICD ItCDk<I. It Hi 0 It H CD It0H!0 CD o Dirt CD 1Di FCD CDDiItMiiDiDiCD5Mi[Mi DiOO 1ftCDi 0 H- x 0 H pi S CD CD II rt CD CD HCD H0 It LQ H 0 H CD C) CD (t t3- pi H It CD CD H k< H CD It Di H- Di C) CD 91 It f It Cl Dl 0 H CD Cl h Cl CD CD CD Di It 0 Mi It C) 0 - It - It Di C) It Mi CD It 0 frj CD H- IH0 It - Cl HC) It H0 CD It CD H- h LJ < CD 0 C) 0 CD H- H- Cl CD () H CD Di CD -t:1 It CD Di H - H CD Cl) Di cS t j Mi 0 It CD CD 0 CD 0 H CD CD 0 Mi It 0 CDgCD CD C) HCD CD It H CD 0 N) DC)QC)N)] C)It It CDHIt1tItCDCD,ItCD 0 CD iHHQC) CDSCDCD Dl0O- It H-MiCDdj ItCDC)0 IthhDiH iDlc -Hi CDCD H0 C) CDQ HIt CDCD 0 H0 CD H{HH H It 0 pi Q 0 HjC)It Di H-It Itrt CDCDHCDHDiItCD CDItItHIt 1 t Ã§t H, OHItCD CD It CDCDH CDIt0i0Di1gC - H- 0 CD CDH ft w U] It H H Di DiCDH jCD CD CD tIt CDM, 5 It CD CD H- N) DiDi H, 0 It It H-CD S hHc1Qct °0H- ItIt H-CD CDSIt gCD0 Dictk< b<0rtC) CD H0CDC)Mict ItCDH Ã§1Mi CD CDpiJ HCDCD CD - C-) 0 CD H-d 0 OPIOH-1 0CD C)C)H-Dl x -i o H- CD c3 S CD hpi C) CD It CD tT (DC)CD QCD S CDdCDQ (-tHH-DIPiCDOCD r1 C)pJ DiODi HCD C)3MiDiCDH-Di H- H H i H HCD hCD CDCDQ rtrCD HCD :i C)CDItH< H- CD CDH0 t3Pi -piH 0 FMiC)CDC) MDC) w k<C) C)CDCDHCDH k<0 0 C) CD OD 0 Mi H Di C) 0 Mi CD CD CD Cl Cl CD H H Di CD H0 It Di It H- CD It It -Q jh Mi o H o CD :i CD CD FCD Mi 0 H Cl H CI) CD CD Cl CD Mi H- - Di CD CD 0 CD It HC) Cl CD CD ci HIt H0 C) 0 CD It CD Di It It y It CD Mi H C) 0 h U) U) H- I CD (U H (U (U It It H- H H- H- U) 0 CD (t rt 0 H CD 0 0 fl 0 HU) c-t d hh 0 0 CD It Q CD U) H0 CD U) H- 0 CD r It It CD H 0 H I IH- IC) Ic s:u H- U) 0 0 - CD r1 CD H- 1Q H H- U) H0 p CD 0 CO co P Ã§t - CDCDH CD HH- H CD PJQI1CD ItCD HQWtIt - U)H0 H c-rpJ tCDQpQ. H- (flU) H P H pco H CD - f i EU) Ã§t(j HOCDCD IHH CD H- CD U) CDCD 0 H-HCD CD 1 (-CD CDHH, It 00 OCD<H, H Hi H-JIt H H floi IXCDrt It It Ã§thJjCOCOH-HH U) IH(U(UItH3)JH-0 H-3(U(fl(UU)COOQ -<COItH-(U00H HU)CDU)CDct0Ihh(UWCDItCnCDItCD HH-iItQ It CDCD Hoc H 0 0 rr U)Cfl 0UiItCD CD PiH CD°H CUItHhtJH l_-- HH0jN HMCD H-rH-pJ 0 f-tCDH 0 0 CD 0M-i0CDU)ItCDCO CDHjCDXo0 i ° H 0 0 OH lHj)JCD 0dcrHCDp)fU) rr QH-IHU) H-H- IctJ. hfiHnH-H,ooCoa3O O ¢ U)0flJO0flH )pJCDp)U)p)I0H-oo><c-rrpJMi CDH-QCD0HH-O(DdH00XQU)0IQU)CDu1 ct(flH.i ohoh dih H-H-pJCDH-I1 Mi0 (D0U)HrtH p)pJU5 OjI(DHfl rt HHU) CDHI)CiHcH , ¢ HQCDHU) -p)IH-PiH H-HU) HH.IH(Dirt. rtdH-CD DU) FCDH CDOO) HHCDCfl0iD1J QIH.CflI1t k<Eui rt0 JIX0HctCD( CDjI0(Dk< tJctCDICD -(tU) CD CD U) 0 H CDHH-I 0 c1 M -1Jjk< 0CD <I HH0 CD CDCfl IiQ 0H--tF° lCD OPi 1 HU) 0CD CD CDU)CDhH CD N CD MPO -CD Cflt CDHHCD CD H U)HQCD SO)m CDPCDICDtfl>< Ã§t U)Ht-. cn0H-i - CD -H-U)CD-QH. CD 0 O CD0 00 itjCDo H0 Qjj 0 HHH-Ui HlCd H Ui 0 OrtQH C H-pJ 3H ijH-rtW(Do H-QH H CX) 1 H- 0 CD CD H 0 H rt 0 rt t h CD CD ) hh - Cx) CO W It H CD lCD KID -< H- H- 0 E;- CD 0 0 0 U H-i H < CD (U It H- It CD H 0 < H CD H- CD 0 CD 0 Co 0 - HCD 0 c-I- H- H H- CD H- 0 Co 0 H-c-I-CD CD 0H-c-I-H0CDc-I-c-iH.ciH.CD cr1 0H-H-ii IiCDCD CD HH-0 0frtCn° -dpi CDH c-tCDCDCD H- CD b c-i- 0 H ci HICD CD I c-I- H- CD P 0 i c-iH- CD 0 CD CD i- CD < CD c-iHc-iH- HCD CD 0 0 CD c-i- c-I- CD HCD c-i- H- 0 c-I- CD H H- c-i- 1) c-i- Q Ã§u CD c-i- ci HCD CDQCD H- CD c-iHHc-i-iQ CDH° H- CD0H0 H- H cl-c-I-H-ct HCD ci CD ci U i 0 H CD H0 H 0 ( h 1t110t!I jjO CD 0 clHCD JCD . cicl-CDc-i-CD {CD[CD CDCD<CD H- CDQOO Ã§tHQ 0 H- 0 0 0 rt 7J H- H CD - H- Pi H 0 M ci H- CD CD Pi -< CD H- HCD - l\) 0 0 H CD CD CD ci CD i- H- < CD H Pi CD d d pi 0 CD t l U CD CD CD 0 CD H- ci CD h d CD H- 0 CD 0 HCD H- ci CD CD -Ic-IH- CD CD 0 c CD H CD H ct pi CD H- CD CD CD 0 t- C! ci c-IH- H- CD c-I- h CD 0 CD CD CD H- c-i- CD CD c-i- CD c-i- c-I- 0 c-i- H- c-iH- ) HCD H- c-iCD CD H H CD Ã§l- 0 HCD H- CD CD - CD CD Q (.Q I-d CD Cl- CD 0 CD 0 HCD H- CD CD CD ci 0 0 CD H- CD 0 o CD l- 0 c-iH- 0 HCD H- c-i- c-I- CD ci H- CD CD CD H CD H- H- ci 0 H- H CD CD H 0 c-i- 0 c-I- ci Pi c-I- ci P 0 H- H- CD H- c-i- CD CD CD H CD P c- 0 ci 1 CD CD c-IHc-iH- pJ c-I- c-i- HN CD 0 I i- HCD fl CD c-I- H CD c-IH h 0 --- ci P) ci CD c-iCD pi CD CD 1 ci HCD CD CD H- CD 0 c-i- (C CD CD CD H H CD CD 0 t) CD c-iHc-iH- - pi c-iit CD I- CD CD HCD c-i- CD () 0 c-IH- 0 H- ci HCD CD P M ct 0 CD c-i- I h H- X CD iCD c-I- 0 0 0 H H (if H- CD c-iPi c-ICD CD 0 CD CD H CD CD H H c-i- H- CD -< c-i- 0 J iCD CD CD H 0 CD CD CD c-i- (if ci CD H- 0 HCD Ã§t C1- - (C) CD CD Cl) CD H CO CO Ui CD CD c-iHc-iH- CD 0 c-t H 0 c-I- H- ci H CD U. CD < PJ ci H 0 h I ic-I- 0 HCD CD CD CD CD H- CD CD CD H0 CD H 0 0 CD - c-i- 4Q IH- CD i h 0 H ci H 0 CD c-i- frh 0 CD CD H- 0 H . CD pi CD t) )) H- ci CD H- c-t c-ICD tj CD 1 0 iH 0 H H- CD g CD CD H H CD 0 CD - CD -i 0 CD c-I H c-IH l) . .1H-CD UHH, HCD-hl--h H-CD C)pJQCD ftHH-QP.1 0 H-CDCD C)HHCD PJftft CDHH.Pi ftftft P.1 brJrJ CDCDCD 3ft CDH CD 3 P)CD CD° hIH CDftQ CD PJ H,H-H CDH 0 CD0 1 CDft HH-Q H0 HH-1. H- CDPi CD ftCDHN ftMCD hhH bC) CDHCDHi HiPJ bC) ft ( CX] - P.1 CD 0 0 H- 0 (2 CD H- 0 u HH H- 0 t- H, H CD Pi H- C) H- 0 -CD H HCD C) CD CD CD 0 CD P.1 H H- H- < HCD H H 0 CD CD H H CD Pi C) CD CD ft Hft H0 CD N CD Cl - H CD ft P.1 CD 0 CD CD CD P C) CD b CD 0 HCD HCD CD ft Pi Pi i Pi CD H- CD CD 0 H- CD ft H- ft - CD H 0 ft H0 0 H CD HN CD - CD ft p CD 0 CD H- 0 Pi CD t3 H- CD CD ft CD H- C) 0 0 CD CD 2 0 HCD ft H, H CD CD Pi H H ii H- H Cl HH 0 H, 0 H H H- H CD I -Q CD CD C) CD H- CD Pi CD Pi C) C) CD CD CD H H CD C) ft 1 H- (.Q H CD CD < CD CD 0 ft - CD CD CD ft 0 hh ft CD 0 P.1 CD HQ p.1 ft H 0 P.1 CD d CD P H 0 Q CD CD CD CD P.1 H H CD C) CD 0 CD ft Hft H0 CD CD CD p.1 C) CD 0 CD CD ft Hft 0 CD H H- HCD CD H- C) H- ft ft CD CD CD H- CD CD ft C) 0 ft CD Pi CD ft H- HCD H- P.1 CD t Pi ft Q. H- CD H 0 Hl-Q J HC) 0 0 ft CD CD CD CD hj Z5 i 0 H0 CD H- ft CD P CD H H CD ft CD 0 CD tY CD ft P.1 CD >< ft 0 HH H, 0 H, CD H- CD ft ft L.Q 0 Pi H ft HCD CD Pi H CD H- Q ft 0 C) CD CD H CD CD CD ft CD 0 HCD 0 CD ft y CD H H H- g H CD Hft CD Q C) CD - HCD CD HCD CD - CD -t H- CD ft 0 (2 til CD ft H, 0 - -< ft CD HCD 1Q H- CD CD CD 0 CD ft H- CD M 0 Z CD ft Hi ft CD CD P.1 0 H H H ft CD Pi H- CD Q P.1 ft CD CD CD H- CD Hft P.1 ft H0 H H- CD CD ft CD ft 0 H, 0 C) H Pi CD ft Pi HH CD h ft CD 0 CD ft Hft CD CD H- H H H H- H, 0 CD h Q (Q N P.1 H HCl P.1 CD CD ft Hft H () CD -j p.1 ft CD CD CD H- 0 ft 0 H- ft 0 H CD Hhh CD < CD - CD CD 0 H < CD H CD - H C) CD CD - H CD CD CD H CD g ft 0 0 H h) CD C!) 0 P1 Cl CD PJCDMi 0 ft 0H- H-ft o CDCDCD Cl CD ft P1 CD Cl H HCD rJ < Cl < CD CD ft HH H- CD 0 0 CD ft - H H CD CD h Cl H CD CD Pi ft CD P1 H 0 H- ft Q o Hft CD p) pj CD H HCD 0 tCD H ° CD CD P-) H- 0 F CD fl H Cl Hft ft CD 0 S 5 0 k< HH H H- 0 P1 HCD CD CD CD 0 H- W CD ft H- 0 CD CD H- CD ft ft 0 H CD H H 0 P1 P1 Cl CD CD CD - pj H PJ - 0 CD CD Cl P1 CD HCD P1 < Cl HCD CD p) CD H Pi H- 0 tQ H- CD CD H- CD 0 Hi 0 H- Cl H CD CD CD ft P ft CD 0 C) CD H- CDft Clj ftH-P1P1 1 H- CD H OftCDCDQClCDHCD ftCDOP1 ftj QH-MiCD ftCD .P1MiLQ CDftft Pip) S1 CD -H ftCDiOCl 0_Pi HCDCDCl0 CDH-CDPi HftHpj ftCDHftCDCD - - H ft WCDCD CD 0 CD CDft HCDaO Pi ftMipi 0 Qj Clft CDPiHHCDHCDHCl. ctHCDCD H Pi-ClH-CD. - H-OS Pi CDMi° IPiCD ft Hpi 0 H CD CDc3 P 0 H()Hft tH-H-ftHtPl iCDOp) H-pj HH-H 0 C1)Hi P 0 PiQCD0ft Cl 2 CD P)H.CDCDCD Pi k< H- H- ft ft 0 Mi 0 0 ft 0 ft CD H CD 1 H- 0 H- H0 OClCD H-CDft O PilQCD0H-_ CD W H- Cl s H- 0 HCD Hft - 0 H- H tQ H < CD - HH- 1 0 0 Pi CD H- Q CD HCl CD CDCD H- rt H H Ã§t frh 0 CDCD CDCDW CDH-° 5 CD CDCD CDCl CD CD OH rpi CDIi 00 ctHCDI CD 0 Mi 0 H H Pi Cn Cl CD H- CD < ti H Hft 0 - H- 0 ft CD CD - CD o H Hi 0 H H- Cl - o CD CD CD Cl CD H- CD CD CD CD a H CD CD ft Mi 0 H CD CD o ft CD CD CD H CD 0 CD H W Ui H CD Cl IH fr lCD HQ H 1W CD H CD CD H H Pi S CD H- CD Cl CD CD H 0 Pi rt H Pi H H CD P1 0 ft H0 CD H Cl CD CD CD CD Cl Cl H- - Ui H co H- H Cl CD CD CD CD P1 Cl Cl OCD a ((2 Cl HH CD o CD H- o CD 0 H i H- H H H CDCD H-CDftHQ CD If)1C)CDQ oo 1 horQ ft o- ftI H-CD HO L-JCD Ti WCD hhHCUCDftft i CDQ<CD H-5 LQ CU 3 Ti CDCUfrhCUCU H&HH I ¢ CDCDCDjftCD ftCD 1 ft0ti CU CDCD 1 ZH-tiftMCDCDH tISTiCDCU 0ftCUtiTi 0 C)Ti0C)ft CD5H ¢ ftH Hftft CD Z CD UCD0 1 *HHQ 0ftftI CU CU ftHH-H-QCDft 1 CD HCDCDHHCD H-(X)LX)<1CUft5 CUCDC)QH1 ft ftHCUC4 CDH1 ctH ctQH-. H0-<hjCU ft >< CD < CD C) jH lQ -h to HH 1 <CDC1 CDHjHWCI) 1 ftCD OftHftQiCU N) 1 0H ft CD-N)HftH1 CUCDQCD -)ft H CD CDQft CDr<H-C!)cn CD ) ¢ hCDC)cx) OH-!Q OCDCDCICDM h o H rt CD 0 h rtH UD Ã§tÃ§t H-ctrt. Hp)H0CD]) T)HJhfrjCDi)pJ0HCD H-htH C) CD LCDCDU]0j rHCD CDh 0N)uHCflQHCDH-LX) Ã§-t C p.<() JH-CDrtCT)rtCD-jCD CDCDO Q1CD -HH-CD boCD H-QCDCDoN(flCDct CDU1rtrt OCD CD<rt ctQCD t3H-HQCDct -P)-C)CD Ã§t HPiSiHrr 3CD CDIH(f)J O(-tH 1 0PiCD 0CD rfrhCDQ Ui C)CDPiH-H ct-JC) rt :CDCDhCDHCDCD H-(3p)t3 r(HrttyC)CDIHC)CDCDctCU CDCDCUCD ¢rrCDCDj(n C!)Ift C!) CD C)QPJ1 HftCDCD- CD QjHQct CDI 1 (n i C)CDPJ ) HQctQfl Ci C) HhhH---. xI 0 hI ¢ CD CD CU H H CD C) CD H 5 0 HH H- 0 0 P H- - CD 0 C) H- 1) i (1) ft CD ti Ti CD Ti X CD H C) CD CD CU H C) H- Ht H CD CD Pi H- LX) CD D ct H H M (- J CO o H ¢ C) H- Ti C) N) ) CD 0 H 0 0 (fl C) rt CD -- CD CD I. H Ip Iti CD CU H Ti lCD 1 lCD jo H- CD 0 >< CD C!) - fr Ti CD 0 ti LX) H- ti H- Pi ft H- CU 3 H- ct CD H CD CD ft CU ft C) CD H CD C) 0 Pi < 0 ft CD CU CD ft CD CD CD ft H- < h CD H H- CD - HCD CU ct CD H- 0 5 5 HH H 0 H- LJ CD IC!) jP) ft ti CU ft Ti CD ft CU H- H- pj -< 5 H H CU CD CD Hft C) H- H- H CT) (1 H CD Ti rt H- S 0 0 CU ft H- 0 H CU Ui pj Cj) H C) Q CD 3 jQ jH- CD CD S ft CD CD < CD H CU CD H- H CD CD ft H0 CD CD H- 0 C) CD HCD Q frt rt H- j C) ft H0 ti CU ft CD Pi CD H- CD HH CD LX) CD < H- h Pi 0 i Ã§t H- rt H- H H- 1 0 hI CU H CU Ti H- -< CD CD CD C) CD CD ft ft 0 b CU (1) H- - CD U H- CD H HCU CD ft -T Ti CU ft CD S Hft 5 0 C) H H- H- CD H H- 0 H- C) CD H- H frh H I)) CD CD (f) lCD CU ft ft Ã§t H0 H- CD 0 Q CD CD H H- b CU ci- CD CD H 0 CD ft 5 0 F CD CD CD CD ft o ti 0 Pi CD CD H CD 0 LX) Tj H < H C Z U W Ui a H L: l tE HCD C) C) C (Y N) v: ct li - rt H- Q l C) o - ) l HCD rt H- CD CU ft H0 H 0 H CD CD H CU H H CD CD H CD rJ H H C) H rt CD Ã§t H 0 C) H N) H- Cl Q p CD Cl CD 0 [h Ct H- H H HCD CD CU H 0 CD Cl CD i- CD CD CD H0 HCD C) Cl H CD Ct HCt H0 Ct Mi -CD Cl HCD Cl Cr ° H- H- C) CD CD Ct CD CD CD CD C) Ct U. CD CD pi CD -Q CD CD H- Cl CU Ct Ct CD U CD CD (Q CD H H C) 0 C) CD CD CD Z CD Cl CD Cl 0 - CD h 0 CD Mi Ct - H Z CD Ct C) 0 C) Ct 0 HCD C) Ct H- H CD rt C H H Cl Ã§t CD CD CD HCl CD Cl 0 < C) C) CD CD CD C) CI CU H > CD CD CD Ct - CD CD C) CD CD CD CD H CD Cl HCD 0 - 0 Ct Cl CD H d CD Ct CD Cl CD CD H- Ct CD CU Ct CD HCt 0 H CD Ct Cl CU 0 CU H < H H < CD CD CD 0 CD CD HH HC) J Ct H- )J CD - CD i-1 CD Ct HCt HQ Mi 0 Ct CU Ct CD HCr 0 C) HH < C) H- HCD H CU Ct Ct Ct CD CD CD CD CD 0 H- 0 H- CD 0 Ct H- CD - CD CD w CD Ct QH.CUClHCt CtH-CtCD°(t)CD H-CthCl CDCD CD CDCUC)Q H-Ct <CDH-i--h CtCtH-CU OCDCDCDCDCUHCU 0 Ct CDHCD HHCDCUHCDCDMi 0 CDH-Ctj Ct CD CUCDHCDH CDCD H-OCD tiC)Clb ClH CD H CDCU CD CDCU HCU CD 0CUCD -° CU CD CD CDCDCt HH- Cl Cl Mi c-rH H-Q CDCtCtCDCD CDQQHHfr HCUHHCtCD C)JjCD(ICDC)Q P)H-H-CDCDfrjj-CDCIJCDSX><CDH-< CDHCtH-5CD HJP)rtCDI HCDH-PJHH5 H-C)HHCD Ct CDrt Ct CtCU H-Q 0 Clc-t HiQ << 0 Ct H- H- H- < 0 CU 0 Ct I H- Cl j CU H CU 0 Ct H0 H- Cl CD CD - Ct 0 C) HC) Ct Ã§t HCD Ct CD Cl C) 0 Ct CD H- HH C) H- HCD i h CD LQ CD CU CD CD Cl H H CD h ¢- CD - H- 0 CD CD CD >< Cl HCt h HCD 0 CU PJ CD CD Ct Ct CU CD CD H- j H CD Ct 0 U H- k< CD H i- CD Ct Cl CD Mi Mi H- CU H Ct C) l- H- Cl H- CD - Q 0 H- Cl Q) H - d 0 CU Cl CD N) I F F H j CD IF-A- H- - H 0 Q H- w rt i H < rJ Cl CD w N) CD CD C) Ct 0 CU Cl CD Ct H 0 < CU H H -< CD CD rt 0 - C) H- C) CU Ct CD CD H H 1i IH- 1Cl Ii CU 1 Ct) j H CD Irt H- Cl CD CD 0 Mi Mi l- CU CD j CD CD < Cl Z Cl Ct CD CD Ct < j Ct H0 CD Ct H- H 0 Ã§t Cl HCt Ct CD 5 5 C) < HH H C) H Ct Cl - H CD rj CD CU H CD 0 Mi Ct C) 0 - Ct) I 1<1 I CD CD CU CD H- CD Ct H H It li) CD Cl) LQ ¢ H- hI Cl) It CD i-J a hI H pj , H hI a CD g hI H- S H P1 H- It H- a 0 H a Q 0 P1 hI It hI H- P1 It i-b H- a -t H- < H - CD a CD It Cl) 5 hI CD Ii 0 Cl) hI H- CD It H- H 0 P1 H 0 It H- Cl) It HIt 0 0 LQ CD hI P1 It Cl) 0 CD a H- P1 H < P1 It CD c-ip1 H c-iH- H hI It 0 Cl) CD 3 CD It CD H H CD ) CD a It H- H- It Cl) 0 0 H P1 H- CD a CD rD H 0 H- H- It CD 0 hI 0 0 hI P1 Cl) It 0 CD Ã§t Q H- P1 0 iCD It 0 It : H- a 0 hI P1 H hI 0 0 0 CD It H- d Cl) CD b lJ CD 0 M P1 Cl) HCD CD a c-i- 0 0 P1 CD C) o t\J Ui CO - P1 CD U) HCD P1 5 hI It 0 CD H ¢ H CD Cl) H- a HhI H CC) CD CD CD Cl) Cl) H- a 0 Cl) HH HIt H P1 It H0 It P1 CD a CD It 0 P1 H- H 0 0 P1 hI It HMi P1 HIt Cl) It H- 0 0 P1 Cl) It It CD It 0 It CD C3 CD P1 H P1 t3 Pi H 0 U) 0 o P1 0 H CD a CD Mi Q 0 H p1 It H- H U It CD It rt - H Cl) C1 b H- -Q C) P1 CD It P1 It Cl) It CD HH u Mi CD 0 CD It HIt H- 0 Ã§t H- 5 0 H P1 H- 0 CD Cl) Cl) 0 H HU 0 P1 It CD CD a H CD hI It HMi H- N P1 CD 0 p1 CD hI c-i- CD CD H- S l- CD It CD a It It 0 fl CD It < Pi H H Z H- H H Ii H- a CD It hI P1 fr P1 Cl) CD P1 CD hI f-i- a (I) H H H a P1 It 0 P1 It H0 H- d d CD It Mi H- P1 It N H- P1 hI P1 0 0 CD a P1 HCD a S CD hI CD Cl) It P1 It CD Cl) c-t i >< 0 It hI CD H H- pi 0 hI Mi H0 CD a LJ CD hI Q It 0 H CD It H- P1 0 CD a H- J- CD - HIt a CD Cl) 5 H- a < CD P1 f-iH- P1 H It CD H hI 0 - H0 rt a Cl) H- LJ Mi 0 H hI a CC) Cl) Cl) H- HCl) a CD HH H 0 HIt H- - ti CD It Cl) CD Pi Cl) 0 Ii (Q H- CD I b CD c-I- h i 0 a It CD hI LQ CD 0 P1 CD H H CD y H- 0 S H- P1 0 P1 CD It P1 It It 0 CD HH p 0 hI Cl) P1 It H0 H CD P1 H CD Cl) ct HIt H0 0 Mi H H- 5 H- a j H- It H U) CD hI H 0 HIt 0 CD H - HH CD rt H- b CD a It H P1 H t, t 5 0 0 H H- H 0 pi It 0 H 0 H- -r 0 H H- P1 It Cl) rt ) Cl) hI CD It 0 Mi 0 Ã§t H HN P1 0 0 hI P1 CD (Q Q H- hI 0 -j CD H CD ft H- cui CD ft CD 0 o CD Q o H CD o -, HCD CD CD HCD HCD ft H CD H cu ft H- CD ft CD i hI CD u-tI CD ft Hft H- CD ti. 0 u-ti CD ft Hft H- CD ft CD CD ft 0 H CD CD CD H cui 0 pi I h CD hI Cl ii hI ft 0 CD CD hI 0 u- ft Cl CD ft H CD H o pi ft H- H H H u-ti CD ft Hft H0 CD ft 1:1 H- H Cl H- H- CD CD CD H H C) 0 C-) til H CD H H H- hI CD ft hI i-h CD CD hI CD CD Cl CD 0 CD Cl CD CD hI pi Cl CD CD CD C) CD CD u-ti hI 0 u-ti hI 1 CD ti 0 H 0 0 ft 0 C -) C ) Cr2 ft 0 ft CD CD cui hI 0 Cl U- 0 H CD ft HCD hI LJ CD CD hI f-u- -. CD 0 i CD ft Hft 0 0 0 H H CD H H- CD CD CD hI - CD hI CD W a a t\) 1 ) w - HCD ft ft CD Hft CD CD hI 0 H- ft CD ft H Pi ft ft o hI CD 0 o H CD CD CD ft (Q H- h CD CD CD HCD CD ft CD Cl H 0 0 Cl H 0 CD ft CD H- hI Li. ft hI 0 CD H- cui 0 H H- H Cli 0 ft H- CD ft Hft 0 0 - 0 htu ft H0 0 H Hft H CD Cli t hI CD CD Cl H 0 0 CD 0 hI CD 0 CD hI CD CD hI Li. ft ft cui ft H hI CD ft 0 CD Cl HCD ft CD - hI ft 0 hI H- CD Cl CD ft CD Cl CD ft Cli H H 0 tY hI ft CD CD ft CD CD I h H- CD ft H- Cl) CD CD hI i ft H- u-ti CD coi C) Co M ft -Q H- hI H 0 H- - ft H- CD 0 0 I-h CD ft H- 0 H hu H CD CD - H H H- Cli tY H CD Cli u-ti -ti Cli I-h 0 H ft H ht CD 0 CDk< H- CD Cli CD CD p l ft Cl) 0 u-ti HCli 0HCD W M Ui t J CD ft r CD Hft hI CD CD ft CD Cl Cli 0 hI ft F- 2 ft HC) HCD Cl CD ft CD CD hI CD u-ti CD Cl) ,- ,- CD ft H- u- -u 4 H- 0 hI H hI CD H- Cli ft hI ft 0 0 ft o H- h ft CD H- Cl CD ft ft p-u ft hI CD H- ft Cl CD a 0 0 -u Cl CD ft H- 0 H H < 0 HCD ft hI Li. H- Cl H- hI CD CD H- S C!) H- Cl H hI CD ft hI I-h Cl CD hI 0 ft Cl 0 H H CD -- Cl H 0 ti CD u- Cli H- uH 0 CD H Cl-u 0 CD Cli CD hI Cl) CD CD 0 Cli CD ft 0 [-I-u CD 0 CD H- Cl 0 Hft 0 CD H- hI 0 0 H- H Cl CD Cl Cli CD hI CD CD u-ti HCD hI pi Cli CD 0 - 0 ft CD 0 hI hI Q 0 Cli CD hI CD a a a M 03 w J) Ui H HCD Cli C) Cli 0 C ) H H CD rt 4 C CD H- H- 0 CD 0. CD CD H- HCD 0 C) C) CD o CD H 0 CD H- 0 HH H HH H CD CD rt Hfrh H- 0 CD pi H- H- C) CD - H- H CD 0 H ct H- CD 0 rt CD (fl CD D CJ2 D) H rt 0 H H Ã§t HH H- b H H- S H- CD H H H0 H- CD rt 0 0 H- ID 0 M CD 0

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.