-VPC Snook et al v. Sierra Pacific Mortgage Company, Inc. et al, No. 3:2011cv00471 - Document 16 (D. Nev. 2011)
Court Description: ORDER GRANTING 5 Motion to Dismiss. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that defendants Ticor Title of Nevada; Stanley S. Silva; Cal-Western Reconveyance Corporation; Nationstar Mortgage, LLC; Sierra Pacific Mortgage Company, Inc.; and Greenhead Investments, Inc., are DISMISSED as defendants in this action. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 9/15/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - KO)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
' j . ' q * ' ) , ,. ( y j h' , FIEB L ENTEREO < 1 d -- - . - RECEI VED OISI WWSoFeE o XE F* SR coan E VD : . 2 SfP /9 z j ' . gj 3 6 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COI RT CT J 7 DI STRI 0F NEVADA CT g *## ) 9 TERRY L.SNOOK andANGELA S NOOK, ) ) 1 0 Plitfs anif, ) ) 11 v. ) ) 1 SI 2 ERRA PACI C M ORTGAGE FI ) COM P ANY, C.e a. m ; t l, ) 1 3 ) Dee nt. fnda s ) 1 4 ) 1 5 3: 1CV-471LIH1 - 0 - t VPC ' ORDER Beor t c m i deenda sSiraPa ii M o t geCompa l .C% eraPa fc' a f e he ol s f nt er cfc rga ny, nc si r cii') nd 1 Gre he dl v sme t,n .s(Gre h a ' moi nt ds s ( c /5)t whc d fn ns 6 e n a n e t ns lc' t e n e d' to o imis Do ./ 1 o ih ee da t t ) 1 TiorTil ofNeva (t c ';Stnl S.Siva(t 1 ' ;Ca- e tr Recmvey e 7 c te da tTior' a ey l tSiva' lW se n c anc ) ) -VPC Snook et al v. Sierra Pacific Mortgage Company, Inc. et al Doc. 16 1 Cor ai (t '; ndNai trM org ,LLC (W ai t 'j ne ( c.* 1 1 . 8 porton t CRC' a ) tonsa tage t tonsml) oi d Do 0, 4) 1 P an if Ter Sn o a dAn eaS o k( olci l ç litfs' fl a o po iin ( c #8 t 9 litfs ry o k n g l n o c l t y t an if' i n p sto Do . ) o e ve p ) e 2 whc S er Pa ii a dGr e h a rp id( c /1 ) 0 ih ira cfc n e n e d e le Do ./3 . 21 1 . Fac s and Pr edur H i t y t oc al s or ' 22 On Ocober11 2005,pli tfsplr hms r lpr t t ough a morg not a dee t : a n if zc ed ea opery hr tage e nd d 23 oftus exe ut d by de e an Sira Pa fc Pl ntfsde auled on t l n and de e nt r t c e f nd t e r cii . ai if f t he oa f nda s 2 i iitdn nj d ca f rco kepr c e ig . 4 ntae o -u iil o e l st o e dn s r ' 25 26 ' Ref st t cour ' docketng num ber er o he ts i . Dockets.Justia.com , . Q 1 Su equ l on M ay l 2011 pl ntfsfld acompl nta i tde end sale ngni bs enty, 2, , ai if ie ai gans f ant lgi ne 2 c esofaci ( )d c lctonvi ains ()Nev Unai an De eptv Tr ePrcie aus ton; 1 ebt ole i olto ; 2 ada f r d c ie ad a tc s 3 Ac, tNRS598. 0923;()Ne daUnfi Le ngPrciesAc, 3 va ar ndi a tc tNRS 5987.00;( brac o t 1 1 4) e h f he 4 c v n n o g o f i a df i d aig'5 'RS 1 7. 0; 6 que tte ()fa d ( )sa e o o e a t f o d at n ar e ln , )N h ( 0 08 () it il; 7 ru ; 8 lnd r f 5 tte;a ( a eofpr s . c.#1 Exhi tC.Ther fer movi defnda sfldt pr e il nd 9) bus oce s Do , bi ea t , ng e nt ie he esnt 6 moton t dim is Doc. i o s s. #5. 7 H. Le St gal andar d . 8 Dee d n ssq d s sa pt s a tt Fe eaq l o Ci iPr c du el ( )6 f rfil e f n a t e k imis l z u n o d rlRue f vl o e r 2 b () o alr e r z 9 t sae ac am upo whih r le c n be grnt d. s vveamoton t dim isf rf iur t sa e o tt li ' n c ei f a a e To ur i i o s s o a l e o tt , k 1 acli ac antmus stsyteFe rlRul ofCi lPr e e8()2)noiepl di 0 am, ompli t aif h dea e vi oc dur a( tc ea ng 11 sa r Se M e ondov.Ce i l Hop.Me Cr 5 1F. 1 11 ( . Ci.2008 . t tndad. e ndi ntnea s d. n, 2 3d 097, 03 9t r h ) Tha 1 i acompl ntm us c ai T s ta pli sae e oft cl m s 2 s, ai t ont n K hor nd an t tm nt he ai howi t tt pl de i a ng ha he ea r s 1 e ildt rle . Fe R.Ci P.8a ( . eRul 8a ()pla ngsa ddoe notrqur 3 ntte o eif' d. v. ()2) Th e ()2 e di tndar s e ie ' 1 de a ld f t ala lga i ;howeve ,apl a ngt tofer tta sa c usons'orç 4 t ie ac u le tons r e di ha f s tl bel nd oncl i a 15 f mul i r ctton oft elm e sofac eofaci 'wilno s fc As r f v I ,1 S. or ac e i i he e nt aus ton'' l t ufie. hc o t . qbal 29 . 16 Ct 1 1 ( . 937, 949 2009)( i BelAtantcCor v Twombl 550U. 5 555( quotng l l i p. . y S. 44, 2007:. . l7 Furhemo e Rul 8( ( r rsac ai t lc ai s cintfcual te , t r r , e a)2) equie ompl nto lont n um e a t matr 1 a ce tdastue t ttt acli t r ift ti plusbl onisf e.'f a 1 (uotng 8 c pe r ,o sae am o ele ha s a i e t ac '' #. t 949 q i 1 Twombl 550U. a 570)A cli ha f i pl i lt whe t plade fc u lc entalows 9 y, S. t . am s acal ausbiiy n he e d a t a ont l 20 tec u t od a t era o bei frn e ba e o tee u ts u ca e pein ea c mmon h o r t r w h e s na l n ee c , s d n h o r'j diil x re c nd o 21 s e t tt def nda i labl f t mico c ale ens , ha he e nt s i e or he s ndu t lged. eff a 1 Se t t 949- tlheplusbiiy 50.l- a i lt '' 22 sa r i no a n t apr biiyr r m e s i a ksf m o e t an as e pos i lt t ta t nda d s t ki o oba lt equie nt but t s or r h he r sbiiy ha 23 de e ntha a t d unlwf l W 'e ea c f nda s ce a uly. h r ompl i pladsf t t tar mer l c it twih a ant e acs ha e ey onssen t 24 def nda ' la lt i sopss r oft lne b t e pos i lt a piusbiiy ofe il me t e nts ibiiy, t t ho t he i e we n sbiiy nd a i lt ntte nt o 25 r i 'd a 1 (nt na quottonmar a ct in omitd) elef'l t 949 i er l ai ks md iato te . 26 2 ' 1 I r e i a m oton t di m i s t c ta c pt t f c s a l ge i t co pl i as n evi w ng i o s s , he our c e s he a t le d n he m a nt 2 1 . we e,taea srin . . t gn )t n ti gmo et a af r acrctto o d Ho v r l r se t s . mnomtig o oh n r h n o muli e i in f b o a 3 t ee e sofa... am ...a eno e ild t a as umpton oftu h.' os v.U S.Se r t he lm nt cli r t ntte o n s i r t 'M s ce 4 Se .572F.d96 96 ( hCi.2009 (uotngI ,1 S. . 1 1 ( a t i o i na) rv, 3 2, 9 9t r ) q i qbal 29 Ctat 95 ) brckes n rgi l 5 (ntr lquoGtonmakso te . cour dico st s algai be aus the d nohi i ena i r mitd) The t s unt he e le tons c e t y o t ng t 6 mor t sa eal lc uson ve i t tconc u i i c s i t f ofa f c ua e h% t t ega oncl i --e n f ha l son s a t n he onn at l 7 algai 'I (ii I ,1 S.Cta 1 . tns frac antt s veamotont le ton. d. ctng qbal 29 ' . t 951) t um, o ompli o uwi l i o 8 di m i s t non- nc us y ta t a c t nt'a r a ona e i e enc f om t tcont t m us be s s , he co l or f c u l on e , nd e s bl nf r es r ha en , t 9 pl us bl s a i y ugge tve o a c ai e ilng t pl ntf o r i ' d. s i f l m ntti he ai ift elef'1 1 I . 0 H D icus i s s on l1 A. DebtC olec i V i at ons l ton ol i 1 2 Purua t NRS j649,i i avi ato o saelw t vi aea pr so oft fdea s nt o t s ol in f tt a o olt ny oviin he e rl 1 FarDeb Cole tonPr tc ActCC 3 i t lci acies FDCPA' ,1 U. C.jj 1 2 e s q. ' 5 S. ) 69 t e NRS j649. 0. r 37 Hee, 1 plitfsalget tdeen nt vi ae t FDCPA b iiitnganon-udii f e oslewihout 4 anif le ha f da s oltd he y ntai j cal orcl tr t 1 f l i t pr perp oc dur f a t m ptng t c l tade . 5 olow ng he o r e es or te i o olec bt i l ! l i wel sa l h dt a n nj dca f rco t e aen ta atmp t c l c ad b u d r t s le tbi e h t o -u iil o e lsz s r o n te t o o l t e t n e s r e l i t FG De Cole to Pr tceActa sm ia sae sa u e . See e. ,H ul e v.Ocwen Fed.Bank he bt lc i n aci nd i l r t t t t t s g. s FSB,l F.Supp. 11 (7 Or 200 .Cha ovv Pe r 2010U. DitLEM S 65798() Nev. 95 2d 88 1. . 2) r . ry, , S. s. 1. 201 ( di t trc di anotc ofdea ti nota atmptt c lc ade be aus t 0) hol ng ha e or ng ie ful s n te o ole t bt c e he bonowe ale dyc e edt alow t f e os et seet r c dt notc u dea t. r ra ons nt o l he orcl ur nlt o e or he ie pon ful) 21 n er or t c t i t tpli if f i t sa ea cai a ns m o ng de enda sf rvi a i ef e, he our fnds ha antfs al o tt l m gai t vi f nt o olton 22 oft FDCPA, t r yNRS j6 he and heeb 49. 23 B. N e vada U nf r and D e ptve T r Pr t c s A c ai ce i ade ac i e t 24 Pt s ntt NRS 598. l ua o r 0923 i i ade p i e tad pr c ie t c t s ce tv r e a tc o onduc busne si t St t gf t i s n he a e 25 Neva wihouta1rquie sae, ou yorciylc ns . da t l e rd tt c nt t ie es NRS 598. 0923( ) Pl ntfsalgest 1. ai if le hat 26 3 .; ' 1 1 de e f ndan svi a e t saut byr co di t t l i no i eofde a twihou ha nga sae t olt d he t t e e r ng he mdery ng tc f ul t t vi tt 2 bus ne s lce e How e r pur ua t N e a La ,t ac i ofa t m ptng t c l ton a d i s i ns . ve , s nt o vad w he ton te i o olec ebt 3 s cu ed by r a pr r y ora t m p i t e f r e a m o t ge s cu iy i er s doesnotc tm t e r e l ope t te tng o n o c r ga e r t nt e t ons i e 4 doi busn si t sae. eNRS 8 015h) Be us dee nt wer atmptngt e orea ng ies n he tt Se 0. ( . ca e fnda s e te i o nf c 5 s urt i ees i ra p o rybyi tatngnon-udiilf ecos epr e ngs t yweenot ec iy ntr t n e l r pet nii i j ca or l ur oc edi ,he r 6 r quie t ha a s ebusnes lce e a t st y di notvi aet Ne e r d o ve Ot i s i ns , nd hu he d olt he vadaUnf i a ar nd . 7 D e e i Tr de Pr c i sA c m a m a t rofl w . c ptve a a tce t s te a 8 C. Ne vadaUnf rLendi Pr tce Ac ai ng ac i s t 9 N RS 598 . 00 pr b t l nde s f om m aki l nsAw ihou de e ni us ng D l ohi is e r r ng oa : t t t nni ng, i 1 co me calyr a ona em e ormec nim s t tt borowe ha t a lt t r pa t home 0 m r i l e s bl ans ha s , ha he r r s he biiy o e y he 1 la 'NRS 5 8 1 0 1( ) Ho v rt i s i blt ln u g wa a de i mi- 0 wh nt e 1 o n. ' 9 D.0 ( )b . we e ,hs ut i y a g a e s d d n d 2 07 e h a i 1 sa u ewa a e d.Alhough pli if a lget tde e nt vi atd t pr s ntve son oft 2 t t t s m nde t a ntf s le ha f nda s ol e he e e ri he 1 sa u e t rl o i na e i 2005, i t t cure ame e . r f e, ai if 'l n 3 t t t , hei oan rgi t d n pror o he r nt ndm nt The e or pl ntf s oa 1 ca tha vi a e t c r nts a u o y l ngua r quii a det r i ton t ta bor owe hm 4 nno ve oi t d he ur e t t t r a ge e rng e m na i ha r r s 1 t a lt t r pa t l n. 5 he biiy o e y he oa 1 6 Addii l pl ntf s unf rl ndi pr tc s c a m i ba e by t a i a e s a ut of tonaly, ai if ' ai e ng ac i e l i s n'd he pplc bl t t e 1 lm ia i .Fhe sa eoflm ia i on a t ai l ng pr c i scai t rNRS 5 1 i t 7 i t tons ' t mt i ttons n mf r endi a tce l m mde 98 7 s wo 1 ()y a s S eNRS j 1 .9 ( )a . an if pt c a e t p o ryi 20 5 a dd dno (l t 8 2 e r. e 11 03 ()Plitfs l h sd he rpe t n 0 , n i tt e he r i 1 pr s nta ton t i 2011 o rf t yea sa trt sa ut o lm iai ha e r Ac or ngl 9 e e c i mtl , ve otr r fe he t t e f i t tons d xpied. c di y, 20 t cour s l gr ntm ovi de en nt moton a t t i is . he t ha l a ng f da s' i s o h s s ue 21 D . B r ach ofG ood Faih a Fai D ealng. e t nd r i 2 2 Un e Ne a lw,ç l eyc n rc i o e u one c pat aduyo g o f i d r v da a te v r o ta tmp s s p a h ry t f o d at g h 23 a f i de lng i ispe f man a exe uton.' C.k/tw Consr v Was Ctpn/ 784 nd ar a i n t ror ce nd c i 'A. s2 'z t. . hoe l y, z 2 P.d9 9( v.1 8 )( u tn Re ttme t( e o d o Co ta t j2 5 . e tbihacam f r 4 2 , Ne 9 9 q o ig sae n S c n ) f n rcs 0 ) To sa ls li o 2 b e c o tei idc ve a to g o f i a dfi d ai g ap an ifmu ts o ta : 1 t e 5 ra h f h mpl o n n f o d at n ar e ln , litf s h w h t () h e h 26 4 h 1 pl ntf a dee ntweepate t ac rc;()t deenda owe adut ofgoodf t a ai if nd fnda r ris o onta t 2 he f nt d y aih nd 2 fi de i t t pl ntf;()t deen ntbrac dhi dut bypef mi i ama r ar alng o he ai if 3 he f da e he s y ror ng n nne 3 t atf l otep r o eo tec n c; n ( t epanifs u tfe e p cain weed n e mf ih u t h u p s f h o ka ta d 4) h litf'j siid x e tto s r e id. o tl r . th wi 4 Se Pc rpv J r a ,1 4P.d6 8 7 2( v 20 6 ( iigHitnHoesCop.v Buc Le s e r . . o d n 3 3 9 , 0 Ne . 0 ) ctn l 5 Pr I 808P. 91 922- t v.1 ) od. nc, 2d 9, 23 ' Ne 991 . 6 . l ta l t c rt est tt r i no c nii ly, he ou not ha he e s onla tbewe n pli if a de enda sTior c t e antfs nd f nt c , 7 Sivw CRC , a i t rorGr nhe d. e onl c r ta i s i t e m or g not o i na e by l N tons a ee a Th y ontac t s ue s h t age e r gi t d 8 d e ntSi n. Pa ii .The ef e t cour fndst tpl ntfshavef ie t al gea s t na e ef nda e a cfc r or , he t i ha ai if a ld o le usai bl 9 c a m f br ac oft cove nt ofgood f ih a f rde i ast t s de end s. l i or e h he na s a t nd ai alng o he e f ant 1 0 Ast de e ntSira Pa ii pl ntfsale t tSi raPa fc b ea ed t i id o f nda e r cfc, ai if lge ha e r cii r ch he mple 11 c oven by f ii t ofe t em a1 n modiiaton. ant alng o f r h oa fc i Howeve ,i i undiput d t Sira Pa ii r ts s e hat e r cfc 1 2 s d t e morga no eove fvey r a prort pl i if 'de a ta de ief al n ol h t ge t r i ea s go i o antfs f ul nd sr or oa . 1 m odiiaton. t ,i i undiput d t tt ei no l n m odii a i c r c b t en pl ntfb 3 fc i Furher t s s e ha her s oa tc ton onta t e we ai if 1 a a oft d e nt . 4 nd ny he ef nda s Ther f e t c t e or , he our Gndst tpl i if f i t ale ac am f br ac ha antf s a l o l ge l i or e h 15 oft co he vena s ofgood f ih a f i dea i nt a t nd a r lng. 1 6 E. NRS 1 080 07. l7 l t rc n hei ompl i , ai if a lget tdef nda si ope l f ecos on t i pr pery ant pl ntfs le ha e nt mpr ry or l ed her o t 1 b a et pr m is yno ewa s ve e for t dee oftus a no oft de e # ec us he o s or t s e r d r n he d r t nd ne he f ndan shol t t d he 1 orgi m orga no e. Doc.#l Exhi tA . 9 i nal t ge t See , bi 20 Ne vada1 w doesnotr quiet pr ton oft e orgi not be or o oft sa u orl a e r he oduc i h i nal e f e ne he t t t iy 21 e t rtdp risiiitsan nj dca f rco u e Wen re v Ch s Ho Fian e LLQ nl ae a t ntae o -u iil o e ls r . iga tr . a e me n c , me e 22 702F.Supp. 1 1 0( Nev.201 .n eefr ,pl ntfsf lt aleg acam uponwhih 2d 276, 28 D. 0) r o e ai if ai o l e li c 23 r i ca be g a e elef n r nt d. . 24 // / 25 // / 26 5 ' 1 F. QuitTil e te 2 UnderNe a lw,aquittte a ton ma bebr vad a e il c i y oughtby s onewho cl m sa a r e ome ai n dve s 3 i ees i pr ry. ntr t n opet NRSj40. 0.Hee movi def nt donotcai a i ee ti t 01 r, ng enda s l m ny ntrs n he 4 pr t a ret pl ntfs i e e ti t pr ry. er f e pl ntfsha no gr opery dve s o ai if ' nt r s n he ope t Th e or , ai if ve oundst qui t o e 5 tte agai m ovi def il nst ng endant s. 6 G . Fr aud 7 t n aleg ng f aud orm i t e,a pa t m us sat w ih pa tc a iy t c r s a e t l i r l s ak ry t t e t r i ul rt he icum t nc s 8 c tttngfa ormitke. FED. CI P.9( .l or rt me t hei tne pladi onsiui rud sa ' ' R. V. b) n de o et he ghe d e ng 9 r uie e t a pl ntf us s iy t tm e,pl ce a c e oft m i r pr s nt t o m wel eq r m n s ai ifm t pec f he i a , nd ont nt he s e e e a i n s l 1 ast na oftepate i ved. eIours v CalAmpl ,1 F. 983, n.0 (t 0 he mes h ris nvol Se ' ih . . 6er 91 3d 993 l 9h 1 Ci.1 ;s eJft Pa ne v.Gat y 2000,1 F. 53 5 5 (t1Ci.1 )(equii a 1 r 999) e .) r s ç, ewa 22 3d 9, 49-0 8l r 997 r rng 1 plitf oalget r st who,wha, e,whe a how o'hemir prs ntton) 2 anift le he equiie twher n, nd lt se e e ai . 1 3 H e e, a ntf ' f i t a l ge an ii m or t de e ant de r ded t r pl i if a l o le s yttng e h% f nd s f au hem durng t l i he oan 1 pr e s n e ea e n aleg i nsofwho f ie t pr dei or a i orwha i o m a i wm not 4 oc s . r r o l ato a ld o ovi nf m ton t nf r ton s 1 pr de Furhe , antfsf i t s ii l al get r quiiet i e plce, nd s cii c ent 5 ovi d. t r pl i if al o pecfcaly le he e st ç m , a a pe fc ont t 16 oft f ler pr e ai n a wel ast e i ntte oft pa test t mir pr e a i .' he as e es nt to s l h de iis he ri o he se es nttons' l7 Edwar sv M a i Par I .356F. 1 1 ( hCi. 04) Theeor t cour fndst t d . rn k nc, 3d 058, 066 9t r 20 . rf e,he t i ha 18 pli tf s a lga i a ei ufi e t s a n if ' le tons r ns fcint o uppor t i cli f fa t her a m or r ud. 1 9 H .Sl ande ofTil r te 20 A c am f san roftteti ve f lean m alc o c l i or l de il çnvol s as d ii us ommunia i ,dipa agi t c tons s r ng o 21 one' ttei l d,a c sng s cilda es'Exec i eA. z/,ft v TiorTil Co. 963 P. s il n an nd au i pe a mag . ' utv f l. d . c g te , 2d 22 465,478( v.1 . Ne 998) 23 He e t r c de no i ofde a ta notc oftu te' s ear notf s a m ai i r , he e or d tce f ul nd ie r se s al e ale nd lc ous 24 c m t c tons di pa a ng pl i tf s tte. r t pl ntf s c om mi a i s r gi a n if ' il Fi s , ai if once t tt y wasi de a ton des ha he n f ul 25 t erla . u t n tc o d f utato g alge l rc r db f r CRC wa a toj e t d h i o n n s he oie f ea l l u h l dy e o de eo e , h e s uh lz d o o 26 6 1 s d no ma af s sa e nta o, oes t ke ale tt me boutt ttet t pr t Sec he il o he opery. ond,i i notf s t tt ts ale ha he 2 pr ry w a t be s d a a t u t e' s l The ef e,t c ttnds t tpl ntf s ha f ie t ope t s o ol t r s e s a e. r or he our i ha ai i f ve a l d o 3 s a e a cl m f r s a roftte. tt ai o l nde il 4 1 A buse ofProces . s 5 Toe t ihacli fra eofpr e sapat mus s t ta o i pat (1 had sabls am o bus oc s ry t how ha n pposng ry ) 6 a ulei pur ef brngi alga a tonot rt nrs vi algaldiput a ( us dt n tror pos or i ng e l ci he ha e ol ng e s es nd 2) e he 7 l alpr es i a w a t ti notpr ri t r ul rc eg oc s n y ha s ope n he eg a onduc oft pr ee ng. t he oc di Las Ve Fe i gas tsh 8 a dFa ts Hal we nBa lI c v Ah r Re t l,l 2P.d 7 4, 67( v. 08 ; o giu n na y lo e l n . . e n n as 8 3 6 7 Ne 20 ) Ge r o , 9 St o I v Boul ar nv s,LLC,663F. udi, nc. . ev dl e t Supp.2d973,982(7. v. 9) 1 Ne 200 . 1 0 He e t cou ttndst tpl n if ha f ie t ale a f c sde onsr tng t r , he r i ha aitfs ve al d o lge ny a t m ta i hat 1 d fn a t ha a utro mo iei iiit gn nj diil o e ls r p o e dn soh r h nt e 1 ee d n s d n leir tv n ntai o -u ca f rco u e r c e ig t e t a h n 1 r s uton oft r de a ton t m o t ge not .Fu t r t pr e sati s i t sa i i a non2 e ol i hei f ul he r ga e r he , he oc s s ue n hi cton s 1 j dca f rco u ewhc i n t h c aa trsi lg la to c ne ltdb a a u eo p o e s 3 u iil o e l s r ih s o te h r ce itc e a cin o tmp ae y n b s f r c s 1 cai Se eg.Smihv Wac i M o t Cor , 9W L 1 4 l m. e . , t . hova rgage p.200 948829,* ( D.Cal2009) 5 N. . . 1 The ef r t cour t n t tpl ntf sha f ie t sa e a cl m f abus ofpr e s 5 r o e, he t i ds ha ai if ve a l d o t t ai or e oc s . 1 Acc di y,t c ts l gr ntm ovi def nda s'moton t dim isz 6 or ngl he our ha l a ng e nt i o s s. l7 // / 18 // / 1 // 9 / 20 // / 21 // / 22 // / 23 ' 24 2Th ' e c t i gr i def our n antng endant motonst dim i ,not t tpl ntf sdi notr s' i o s ss es ha ai ir d eques l t t eave o 25 a nd t i co p ai .Howe e ,e e i t e di r q s la t a e , h c r woul d ny t e r q s me he r m l nt v r v n f h y d e ue t e ve o m nd t e ou t d e h e ue t becaus t y havef ld t makeany s e he aie o howi t amendme i t spari arcas woul notbef ieort ng hat nt n hi tcul e d utl hat 26 t y c ul ov r om et i e tfe pl a ng d f c s he o d e c he d n ii d e di e e t . 7 . ' j . 1 I I THEREFORE ORDERED t tdee nt'moi t ds s ( #5)i TS ha fnda s tons o imis Doc. s 2 G RAN TED . e e D f ndan s Ti orTil ofN e da;St e S.Siva;Ca - e t n Rec t c te va anl y l l W s er onve nc ya e 3 Com or ton; a i t rM orga ,LLC;Si r a Pa fc M orga Com pa i and Gr e a i N tons a t ge e r cii t ge ny, nc; e nhea d 4 l s m en s l a e D I I nve t t , nc. r SM SSED a de e nt i t sa ton. s f nda s n hi c i 5 I I SO ORD ERED , T S 6 D ATED t s hi 7 A;dyo spe e 2o11. ' a f etmbr + , . < 8 L 9 1 0 11 12 13 14 1 5 1 6 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 ' 26 . R.HI S CK UNI STATESbI CT J TED STRI UDGE 8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
