-VPC Tjeltveit v. McDaniel, No. 3:2011cv00163 - Document 7 (D. Nev. 2011)
Court Description: THEREFORE IS ORDERED that the petition is DISMISSED with prejudice as time-barred. FURTHER ORD P's # 3 Motion for appointment of counsel is DENIED. FURTHER ORD that a certificate of appealability is DENIED. FURTHER ORD the Clerk additio nally shall serve a copy of this order, the judgment, and as attachments to this order ## 1, 5 and 6 upon Rs by effecting informal electronic service of the order and judgment upon AG. No response is required from Rs, other than to respond to any or ders of a reviewing court. The Clerk of Court shall enter final judgment accordingly, in favor of Rs and against P, dismissing this action with prejudice. The Clerk shall provide P a copy of # 6 with this order along with a copy of ## 1 and 6 from No. 3:08-cv-00054. Signed by Chief Judge Robert C. Jones on 6/20/2011. ( Attachments: # 1 Attachment "#1", # 2 Attachment "#5", # 3 Attachment "#6" )(Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM) Modified on 6/20/2011 to reflect NEF regenerated to effect electronic service upon AG(DRM).
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
-VPC Tjeltveit v. McDaniel Doc. 7 Att. 1 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 1 of 20 (tE ED tR à E) AII ' . ' ! y ( . . e' ) j, ! . ' . ' ' , Nane J3:,$/ i ccms tp lî CFliûl t E/a ls lc lp i '' ' ' c E rt : tq ) 3 ' ' Bt s l iTl c tl # 1t 0 I l Fk '' 2 el R7SR I olr OP S' J' I ï . t Pic ofConfn ae i ement . vlI - 2 21 F 21 . Prs N umbe ion r fE ! ' ( ( C(/ ) E IE S R Iû? E VEJ l . - UNI TED STA TES DI STm CT C O URT DI STR I O F NEVA DA û CT . : : .. . i l 3: cv11- 00163 I . e . . ( INa ) FuI me vs . G4 ; ?l l/ ' Y : azœ1 l , Peii r ) ttone, f ) CASE NO l . . ) ( b s ple byteCl kl To e up id h er ) . . .. . ,r odn ) Rs net) p , l eo W ad n, u eitn e tj i ro Nmn f r e S p rne d n ,al r o a horz dpes nha ngc t ofp ttone) ut ie ro vi usody eii r Dd TheAtor Ge rlo t Stt ofNe da t ne nea fbe ae va PETI O N FO R A TI ) W R I OF H ABEA S C OR PUS T ) S. ) PURSUANT TO :8U. C.j2254 BY A PERSO N I STA TE C USTO DY N ) . (NO T SENTENCED TO DEATHJ ) Na a dl atonof our, ndn ofudge ta e erdtej dgme ofc ci yo ae me n oc i o ta ame j , h t nt e h u nt onviton u r c lgg ', ?o- , y jn ( t h e i : ;4 ' ivk., - t4 ti, ' . . , . ' , c'?e' l ><v # e / Fl.tjd Fdrovci wsnc : bl7 pD7.ie:t/a/ r : ulat.o n.. ni o aet . t Iele - nldyma) 4 e 0u ol o n de $ o 0 t xd . ' ( z mo 2 Diyuapatecnitn I Ye No Daeapadcdd l/ak /(y . . d o pelh ovci ? X s 3. 4, Di y Il apeii f p tc nv ci mle 'rpeii f rha asc pu i t sae c r? d ou ie tton or os- o i ton ifo tton o be or s n he tt ou t f Ye N .Iysn eh cltn dtteeio wsid Ik..'>lX1 // s o fe, teorad a hpti afe: j Jrf ?k c tn l te * k ' hèl- e-fks ,*e.e ' hrla?>Atw 1 e . # f cr l 2, /T l;# .Di yuapaio ted nao t ptinrr d o p elkm h eil fl eio o w t pscnit nrlfreio fr io hba cmu?Y ot ovci ei o ptino wr faes o s - o e t t . Ye s N o.Da e t e a a w a t h ppe I s ' d cd d l / 1 / I .Ha eal fh go n ssae i t sptto b e prs ne t ti ' ie : e 3 i v Io te ru d ttd n hi eiin e n ee td o h stspe cut/* s N .In, hcgonsaco? teurmeor Yc o fow i rudhv nt a ? h 5 . Daey uaemal g(r adn t cn cinl fcrti p t int ti c r: n I 5 I I,. / t o r in o bnigo o x t aos e)hs ei o o hs ou t 3 i o t 1/ / A t a h t t s pe ii n a c py ofaI s at c twr t e de l l r gar ng tls c t c o hi tt o o I t e our lt n c l ons e di li onvi ton. ci j 54 For z; - m et 19 f /7 pz m$r.B Nt A34: l aA l 1N : 3 7 l I r ep #Kîht s' Ilas 7L. ucil t t ' nt l sa - i ( 7 . Dockets.Justia.com ' r Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 ' Filed 03/03/11 Page 2 of 20 . E I . j 6. ' I t st l1 rdealpeii f wrtofh a c s hi he 'ste r tton or i abe s omusc lngi t sc vi i i hale ng hi on cton? ves X No ln , awa te r r aen mbr Jt c- rt -G n i whto rwa te . f owht sh pi cs u e ? t ee /z / dn a c ut sl o f-f. l pircinIe? ( ,) pl.- rr at i d / Il 'h o o l , c ? l# (; #êo.., v x , : i ' : Wm t prora ton s he i ci 1 i o c.Daeor e iin: L /J9 l O . Ar a yo tcise i tipeiinrie i te n) t d cso e n rh su sn hs t o asd n h t de e ont meis o . dimis d f pr e urlra ons (hek nid he rt r s se or oo d a e s c c . i piretn Y' s r pti ? Ye o io . Cic tCou tofAp al gi n yo pe s i n t ll t ss ce s v pe ii r ui r pe s ve u nni s o o ie hi uc s i e tton? ! 7. ' i N . Ite r rmc mdne o temei,m te nh o fh pi cqw s ei nh rshsh Ni o d t t Y es N o, Doy ha a yp ii a iato moto ora pe l(rbyan oherme n )now pe n i ou ve n et on, pplc in, in p a o t yt as ndig n ! a yc ute adn tec n cinta y uaec aln igi tiato ? n o rrg rig h o vito h t o r h l gn n hs cin c : Ye X - . s No l ,s at t name oft courtand t nat e oft pr ryes t e he he he ur he oceedi ngs: ; j i 8. # c sn mbr rhjdmet rovoinbigcalne: CP ae u e o teu g n o cn it en hl gd o e <. 0/Px7:1 . : q Ln,adtms fet ct:To Ax w; zo-at r <d -l eg n e osne es s r n ) em: l'k ' r r yz - e s/ e . ' ' 1 0 sat ae n poetdrlaedt: l- J- q t'e trdta d rjce ees ae I3 nr - -Jo 1 . ë I wht s( r)s orncsor ihyuweecnitd # vz ' .,. / .. 1 awa weete f st) whc o r ovce, t.s g'h >. e e f vs .a - . I s.: . e î /, .m . i 12. i ! W hatw asyourpl ea? ' N otGuit ly N ol Cont o ender I you pl e. f eaded guit ly o no o c e r pur ua t apl aba ga n,s a e t t nns a c dii oft a e m e t r l ont nde e s nt o e r i t t he e ad on tons he gr e n : i j ; ' i Guit ly . ' 1 3. i ' ' , W ho wmst a t e t tr pr e d you i t pr œ di gs i s a e c t I ntf w he h he tom y ha e es nt n he oc n n t t our? de iy t er teat ne wmsa poi e rti d, wheh ryo rprsntdyourer os ( to t one) h tor y p ntd,eane or te u e e e e ' slpr e wihu ou ,l. Nl ofAtor e me t ny i ari n a dpe rarme t n la 6 . j ' ! tagiy la rlul pe i/ t J,k (.6f' e v t1 . -, i Knec t ng n J , rwte .,h ' y r/ . di c a p a r t p el e ' 1s post t i .' x : l apafmpscniin ..1 #. c azhpcl' otovoo 4z. ? k l. r o t .- r p 7 r : 2n pos - vi ton p ii n d tcon o i etto Pr . o% e Ax i Re ai d t ne X- f t ' Appoi ed nt 5 / II ' P X' - cnitnptin A>l A .?i,l+ovci eio o t ' zll, z tl. I appealfom 2nd posr ' toonvi i cton 1 ! ! j 4- m . zzs For ! er1: r. /7 i i t I 2 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 3 of 20 ! ! I l : . o lc l u l bat le s at our o to nd/ ' e e e s St t c nc s l e r gr a e o l e y ve .y onnd f r wli l yo c i m t tl ' t e c tc nd c i n a or s nt nc l . . unconsiutonal Sum marzebre l t f t s tt l . i ify he acs uppor i ea h gr tng c ound.You ma atac up t t y t h e wo ' ext pagesst i addil ra atng tonalgr ounds and/ s or upportng f i acl.You m ustraie i t spèt ton aI s n hl ii l gr ounds f r le t r l t t t sc c l A ny gr or e i f hat e a e o ài onvi ton. oundsno r s d i t spe li w illke y t aie n hi tt on l i l : ! bebare fo h igIiae i as b e u nt to . rd r m en l j td n u sq e acin t' G R O UN D I Ileee t m v s at cour convi i and/ s ence a e uncons iutonal i vi aton ofm y l hat te t cton or ent r tt i , n ol i f h ph . rh t ?k - L ll .d , Amed n r h t J f lv m nmeti to ? : . g oc h ..,# ct p:e . xœol bas on t e f s: ed hes act pe l yz-ef r/hvcn q oa e(-le As . rA ? : s ' lf, ' ) il . f e - # ff ' b q . srt tlf ' e ' v' wxk t+ . ' . ke F . .- u , t Vefu ll e dp .? hrtl -znv f l . - t , f ze < h 1 - ( ! , '-z ces Ql ' ' v ' -k , e l o r e t l . ' pv . 1 l . . ,t ï P fb % c n vs 4t , r . . ,2 r? ' . k #' . '' cx e. s . 1 1 .s .l v; t q n . p . : l 1w It - y o y,. . . r . . -' ' t-, ' n ' .z . # . . 1 , .- k I ' ' m , f l ,P y ' , ., e; , . alv -, t - qe zJ 1 r ' w, - ' p ' n1. ' ; .k . ' w kk z c J à oe. ' . # . . ' - tl wI . b ut. f s , t ' t > ' .r e(. . .i w ' r .. '' ' ' .p a -' t l .?I , . ' . e? +l . 7 $ 35 1 b 1. 9 ' 4 '' ' '' , ' .ç w 1 . - K. l - T 5 5 . !; ' ' - , 5 (-) k , z . 'y 1) l ou . é l 4h/ . ' ' w: r . ' : .' , x J-' 1, . .' w h ' e K1 . ' A $' v q, . . ' ' wx - R , s s :- h5 s . 1 e 1 ml z I1 M. , ; 1 ; ' '' 1 . . . z y, l ? J :t t 1 $ ,)s ' ( w s '-- ) ) a, #,V ' (l . . ... ) v' ' . . %' p s e t '. ; t 1 ' / v b , 4 : 3 .* % os : j ' w ' 'l ' e . .. ..z ,. k s ' . 4 0 - t. ' ' I '.t . 7 . $ l Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 4 of 20 Exhaus i ofs at c tou t e ourtr m e e r ar ng G r e dl s eg dl ound 1: Dl Appeal red : Di you r s ti is ondr c a a fom t c ci t t eNe a Su e Cour? d aie hs s ue ie t ppe l r he onviton o h v da pr me t Y es > . No. I rno,cxpl n w hy not ai : Fi tPts Convi im ; rs lt ctt D ï you r s t s i s e i apetton f pos c c i r i ' s a e petton f ha e c us d aie hi s u n ii or t onvi ton elcfor t t ii or b as om ? ' K Ye s No I n e panwh n t . f q x li y o: . lysnmeo cut f e, a fo r : dtptinle 8 / C /5 F . ae eio i d t l Di y urc iex e d nir h mig? d o cev n vie t y e n a C ourt ? Y es Ye . No Di y ua p a t teNea aSu rme s X- . d o p elo h v d pe N o. I rno,expl n w hynot ai : ly s diy urietiise . . s f e, d o as hs su ?X Ye No.l-o e panwh n t t ,x li y o: n . ' Se o Pos C onvi ton: c nd t ci D i you r i et i is i a s c nd pe ii n f rpos co c i r lefors a epe ii n f rha asc us d a s h s s ue n e o tto o t nvi ton e i t t tto o be om ? Y es No. I ye , x a n wh f s e pl i y: I es na eofc ur : ry , m o t da e pe ii f l d t tton ie D i you r c i an e de i he rng? d c e ve vi ntmy a i Cou t r? Ye s / . N o. D i m u a al o t N e a Supr m e d ppe t he v da e No. l no, xpi i why not f e an : l e di y r i e t s i s ? fy s, d ou a s hi s ue . ' Yc s / Yg s No, I no e ai whynot f , xpl n ; O t Pr her oceedi ngs: H a e you pu s c a y ot rp o d e pr c si a a t p t ha y c nvi to a d/ v r u d n he r ce ur / o es n n tem t o ve our o c i n n or s ntnceov rume bae ont sis e(uc a a nsrtverme e ) ee et d sd hi su s h s dmiitai e dis? expl n: ai j 4- m z25 For ef 197 f. / 4 Ye s No. l ye , f s Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 i Filed 03/03/11 Page 5 of 20 St t tonc s l e er g ound f w hl h you c ai tl tt s at courtc ae ier v y r or c l m la he t e envi ton and/ s nt nc i ci or e e e s unc tt i . Sum m ar z br e l tl f c s s ons l utonal l e if y le a t uppor i e g ound. You m ay at a up t t tng acb r t ch o wo i : r e t tng ddllnal oundsand/ s or uppor l f t . You m ustrai i t spettl al tng ass ext s pag ss a l a tn gr se n hi l on l i gr undsf r le t tr lt t t sc c i Anygr o or elf ha ea e o hi onvl ton. oundsnotr ie i t spe ii wllIkel a s d n hi tton l l y bebar dfom ben Itg edI as e ntaci re r ig iiat n ubs que ten. c Ro r N o z j Ialget a my saec tc vito an ors ntnc a e unc tt i l i vi aton ofm y le h t -t our on c in d/ e e e r t onsiutona , n ol i i fr k , h p q. K#c ,w, l I Amed nr ht c ànmbyk a? k/ oe nmeti to -t t tv - pz s g ba ed on t s f c s s he e a t : n p. ; . . 1c' / v . .l : , i : k r . ' k ,k ' u cl r .fb, t > m% ! . . ' ! 1 . - s zJsz /l / xa 1 Ir# -, . okep t - owr ' oy- e z . $ . , t, . a . k 1 I $, < . . t . e J : E ( , $e 2 q , w / , ï, j 1 ! , . I , , . ' I ; : ! 1 ' . ! I i ! i ! . j l4 Forn zs a . - ef.197 f/ 5 ' Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 ! ! I Filed 03/03/11 Page 6 of 20 Exl to ofs a ec tr m e e r gar ng Gr lausi n t t our e dis e ' di eund 2: . . Dle tAppeal rc : Di you r i et s i s on diectappealf om t convi ton t t N evada Supm m ecour? d t a s hi s ue r r he c i o he Y es No. I n e pl i w h not f o, x a n y : Fl tPos Convi t an: rs t ci Di y r s t sis i apeii f pos c viton r iforsaepe ii f h be sc d ou aie hi s ue n tton br t on c i ele tt tton or a m omus ? ' Y es N o. I' expl n why not lno, ai : Iysnmefor fe,a ocut : (' ' ' c ? l kt D i you r c i a e d nta y he ng d e cve n vi e i r mi ? C our?' Yes t Y% dtptinfe fI.-/ . aeeio id V 5V t l N o. D i y ap a t t N e da Supr m e d ou pe l o he va e N o. 1' expl n why not fno, ai : l ye .di y r i e t s is e f s d ou a s hi s u ? Ye s No. I no, xpl i why not f e an : . Second Pos Convl i t cton: D i you r ie t s is i as c pe ii f po tc c i r le orsat pe ii f ha m co us d a s hi s ue n e ond tton or s onvi ton e i f t e tton or be s m ? Y es No. l yes,cxpl n why; f ai I ye ,n m eofo r : f s a ou t D i you r c i a e d nta y he rng? d e e ve n vi e i r a i Cour? t Yes . N o. I rno,expl n why not ai : I ye , d y r iet sis ? f s di ou as hi s ue # ' Ye s d t pe ii f l d a e tton ie / / No. D i y a ca t t Nev da S'pr me d ou pp l o he a u e Ye s N o. l no, l i whynot f exp an : O tl Pr e di ; l er ec e ngs Ha yol urue a yote po e epr esi a ate t ha ey rc vitona d/ ve tp s d n h r rc dur/ oc s n n tmpto v ou on ci n or s nt c ov tmcdba e o ti is (uc a a nit i r dis? c en e eru s d n hs sue s h s dmi smtvc emc c ) Ye . No. I es s ry , cxpl n: ai jz 4- rm 25 Fo e f 19 f. /7 ' Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 7 of 20 st ec i e y e r gr und f w ll l y c ai t t s at c at onc s l ve y o or lc l ou l m hat :e t e ourtt c i and/ s enc i onvl ton or ent e s unc tt i l Sum m ar z br e l t f ct s ons lutona . i e i fy he a s uppor l ea gr tng ch ound. You m a atach up t t y t o wo e r page s atn addl nalgx und:and/ s xt a s t ig eo or uppo reng f t . ou m us r l e i t spe l aI ac s Y t a s n hl et on l j o dsf r le t a rlt t t i c n ieo An g o d no r ie i t i peiinwi Ik l r un or èif h t eae o h s o vc n. r r un s t a sd n h s t o l iey t l bebar e f om be ng ltgat I a s e ntac i rd r l il ed n ubs que ton. G R O UN D J d Ilg tamysac odcnitnado snec aeucntuinl i voainomy k al eht ttc1 ovci n/retne r nosit a,n ilt f e o to o . 'f j ! 1.,y 1 t A ed nrut bx y yzo k- K g mnmeti o g pc s , b s d o t s f cs m e n he e a t : ' r ( 9 1.. ' x . ' / x? b . . ;,t .Lo llA o $ , v56 ' v ,z ç . e ' ' 1. . . f - e' <. e i . ,. v c ' z ' me l . zeln . / . e.. vlfi j ' . ! . d jt e a' z ct 7 t' . F 'pê e 'h /e ( z ' ee l x ki ,yAe #k : ? ( /te l . .l q ù v a'. t ? . cx' z ï -' a 1. e .. u e; t' k . ' ' I 1 . f . w. .m; t /t6y 7 to' , 1 u. G e l &. q ' f n p , + . . a h, ' l a rr i , x t o ' e . i . q ' a . 1' w .j . < zv k ' . ' .' ' ' / o ' k . . . s . I .a . . ' ! i. 7 f )j o v l MMl ' a. , w vx ( - J . , 9 b s ' c ' J wn @ h ..' b . K.c . t. sl . ' ' wr 6 e.4 . -. x. v A . k ' - e s z 1 , z q . , e ' k l w. ! ' ' y ' jf 4r2.197 m f25/ For 7 @ ' I Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 8 of 20 1 I Ex haus l ofs at c ton t e ourtr m e e r g dl G r e dl s e ér ng ound 3: . w i D i you r s t s i s o d r c a alfom t co c i t t e Ne daSupr e Co t d aie hi s ue n ie t ppe ' he nvi ton o h va r em ur? I ! Dj A ppeal rect : Ye s No. I no, x ai why not f e pl n . I ' . 1 D i yo r s t sis i ap ii f pos c vito r le o saepetton f rha a c d u aie hi s ue n etton or t on c in e if r t t ii o be s omus ? i FlstPostC onvi i r cton: Y es N o. I no,expl n why not f ai : E lysnm ocut .eczllablr/ ' rt l dtptinne s /s-/,p. fe,ac for s prto, ' c .v . a et l :n . ' . / r - e io d s s, e! Di y urc iea e d nir h a ij d o e ev n vie t y c r ? a n ' C ourt ? E i I i i ' i Y es ' No Di y ua pe loteNe a aSu rme . d o p at h vd pe No. I rno,expl n w hy not ai : I yes di yo r i e t s is e f , d u a s hi s u ? . Y% Yes N o. I rno, xpl i wh not e an y : Se ond Pos Con c i c t vi ton: , D i you r ie t i is i a s c pe ii f rpo tco c i r le orsa e pe ii f ha m co us d a s h s s ue n e ond tton o s nviton e i f t t tton or be s m ? Y es N o. I yes expl n why: f , ai I y s, me oloo t f e na - ur : D i you r ve an evi i y he i d ecei dentar >rng? cour? t Yes da e p ii f l t ctton ied Y es / / . N o. Di yo a pe t t Ne aSupr me d u p al o he vad e N o. I no,expl n why not f ai : E . ; ! I y , d y r s t s is ? f es di ou aie hi s uc Yc s N o. I no, pl i wh n : f ex n n y ot ! i ; ( . . o t r Pr ce dl : he o e ngs H a you p s d a o h pr e ur oc s i a ate ptt ha e y c c i a or ve ur ue ny t er oc d &pr e s n n t m o v our onvi ton nd/ i ' s nt ceov rume bm e ont sis e(u a a nitai rme e) e en et d sd hi s u s ch s dmi srtve e dis? I ex a n: pl i ; i ; I ! i ! ' jz Fo n zs4- rr e f 19 f. /7 8 Ye s x No. I ye , f s : Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 9 of 20 St e çonc s l e r gr at l e y ve y ound f whl h yoa cl m t tl s at c ' r c l and/ s e e i or c al hat le t e our onvl ton t er ent nc g uncons lutona . Sum m ar z br efy t f t s tt l l l e l l he ac s uppor l ea g ound. Yeu m ay at ach up t t @ tng ch r t o w e r pagu s atng a to gr xt a t l ddl l nal ound: and/ s or uppor l f œ You m us r s l tl: pètt on al tng ae t al e n ll ll I gr ounds f r le t atr at t t : cm vl eon. A n gr @r e l f b el e o hl l t y oandg notr s d l t :pe kl w lllke y ale n àl t on l l l be barred f rom be ng Itgat I a subsequentacton. l ll ed n l cRoc ' xo / IAlcge t my s at cour convi i and/ s ence ar unconstt i , i vi aton ofm y l hat te t cton or ent e e iutonal n ol i - $:. K me pkk- A nmetiht n(. wt s .igr? i tt mcd nr t p ax .: go s ba ed on t s f c s s he e a t : ?,I ., rpy ?, uml/Ju, , L'Lb< t . s>/ <t o.(, sw sx/.. l e +,,g m,l-a z ,. . ' o - , / e pll ' /w sr', 8 ' '/ s ..) . . J w r /. // o k. I 1 :k h . t ' J' k' . . ' ' p r fs e gd . bo(g-.. Gr v w lkjwt 7p53: ,'1 kz.ç, &?Jx w u ga l ' 5 .) / . akp k ;3 , f#q).w? u w ? e . s e l) f tr l ' , 6t 8r ' , z # .. - - 1 ' ) 1 t tj .) 7 t '1 . , ' , .' ' 1 7 r .& ' 5 . I >l ,. . , l p . ' j , r' . l e Ae ' I k eh . e e c h k x 4 te'. .m ' 'e . K z ' th, k ' 1 l . k . . '( . ,1 ' gij( 'x r s' ss e. e/ :. / et . $ , 1 1 qr / e f l '' '- & , . . t .A f, e q w1 ' k ' ) . 1' ï !. q It . v 1 v ' .' ' ' $! . kvwe 1 , p , , v. e ..' 1 . - e ' e, e ' - k ... . -'' . bq. )IM1 j, t . ' kt d .. p , 1 . e- l . ' nr x. > lb : i hy<.J . . . '' ' - Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 10 of 20 Ex haus l o s at ç tr m edl sr gar ng G r ton f t e our e e e dl ound . Di e tAppe : rc al Di yQu r iet sis on d r ta pea fom t c vi i n t t eNe d as hi sue iec p l r he on cto o h vadaSu e Cour? pr me t Y es -- No. J a ex a n why not f o, pl i : Fl stPl Convl i r nt cton: D i you r ie t s is e i a petto f pos c cton r i fors a e petton f h a c us d a s hi s u n ii n or t onvi i ele t t ii br abe s om ? Yes No. I no,expl n why not f ai : Iysnme ror r c/ J Ii bç c v dtptinse q / , /o F . re,a o cut '. p cml lwl pov k- a et l : e e io d < . Di you r ve an evi i y hearng? d ecei dentar i Court ? Yes ' N o. D i m u a pe lt t N e da Supr m e d p a o he va e No. I no,expl n w hy not f ai ; Ityes,di you r s t s isue? d aie hi s e Yes Y es N o. I no,expl n why not f ai : Se cond PostConvl t on: cl Di you r ie t s is i a s c nd petton f pos c d a s hi s ue n e e ii or t onvi to r l ors ae pdii n f habe s c p ? c in ei ef t t to or m or us Y es N o. I ,expl n why: ryes ai I yes na eofc t f , m our : . d t pe ii tl d a e tton i e D i y r c i an e de ta y he rng? d ou e e ve vi n i r a i Court ? Yes / . N o. Di y a alt t N ev da Su e e d ou ppe o he a pr m N o. I no,expl n w hy not f ai : I yes.di you r se t s i ue? f d ai hi u * Y> / Y es No. I no,lxpl n why not f ai : O t Proceedi her ngs: H a e you pu s a ot rpr e r oc s i an a t ptt h e y c cton a or v r ued ny he oc du /pr es n tem o av our onvi i nd/ s nt eov rurcdbae onti is ( c a a nitai rme e ) e enc et n sd hs sue su h s dmi srtve c dis? c pl n: x ai Yes ' No Iyes f . . j225 For 4- m ef.197 f / # ) . : i Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 ' ' . l ' . St e cone s l e q gr at l ey ve ound f w hl you e al t att s at co tc l ton and/ s e l or ch l m h he t e ur onv c l or eat nce s unc tt l nal Sum m ar zebr e l t f t s ons luto . l l fy he ac a uppor l e h gr tng ac ound. You m ay atac up t t o t h o w ext a pag satngaddll gr r e tl tenal ound:and/ rs o uppo l r t Y@u m us r s l elspè l al rtng pc l t lle n l teon I gr ounds f r le t r l e t t sc l tt . Any gr or e l f hat eat e :l oav c lm ounda notr l d l t :pe ll w lllkel a R n hl tt on l l y be bar ed f om beng ltg e I a s e nta l . p r l ll at d n ubs que cten G R O U ND ' . . llege t my st e cotr convi i and/ sent l hat at lt cton or ence ar uncons iutonal i vi aton ofm y e tt i , n ol i . *. n me t :t 1 j K . 4, j f Ame d n dgto x Col èyf A n ., ,.) . ba e on t s f c s sd he e a t : Pe !1q / coklî.-w/. 'b# nz e. . v <)1.. .. qoyzvt s wl, / .y, fs #y, :. t c l. .s al z r . , e ( - r $ v . u pr p' .? ,ep! ' ts e ç ( y g s ,y - . c , y . .j e r. @ I , . . u xs -k,,.s ,e ?t / k ,w vt r ' . . . . . i i Filed 03/03/11 Page 11 of 20 . ip q a A 1 rf . ! % (' . 1 P I .& t . , ' ' k. î ' $ t , ' '- sf ', pk : , ' h , . lZ ' . ' E E ' ! E q ' E j : . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 12 of 20 Exhausl ofs i ecourtr dl r gardl Gr ton t t eme e e ng ound Die Xppe : rd al . . Di you r iet sis o dr cta ea fom t c cto t teNe daSupr Cour? d as hi s ue n ie pp l r he onvi i n o h va eme t ' . ' Y es . No. I n # xpl n why not f o e ai : ' K r tPos Convlton: s t cl Di your iet sis e i apetton I pos c cton r leforsaepetton I habe sc us d as hi s u n ii br t onvi i ei tt ii br a om ? . Y es N o. I no, expl n why not f ai : Iy s n meor out fe, a c r; '' a D i y r c i a e de i e he i d ou e c ve n vi nta arng? cour? t Yes Ye ' s # d t p tinfld F / ç- &F . ' ae eio i t e . 1 . o. D i you a alt t N e a Supr m e d ppe o hr vd e No. l , expl n w hy not sno ai : I ye ,di you r s t sis ? f s d ai e hi s ue . à / ' Ye s No. I no,e ai wh not f xpi n y : Second Pos C onvl l t cton: D i you r ie t s is i a s end pe ii f pos convi i r le ors a e pe ii f ha >q c r l d a s M s ue n œ tton or t cton e if t t tton or be o pts? Y es N o. I yes e ai why: f , xpl n I ycs,nam eofcour ; f t . dat petton fl e ii ied / / . D i m u r c ve a e de i r he i g? d e ei n vi nta y -rn Cou t r? Yes No. Di m u ap alt t Neva Su e d m o he da prme N o. I no,e ai why not f xpl n : I ye ,di yo r i e t s i s ? f s d u a s hi s ue w Ye s Ye s N o. I no.expl n why not f ai : O t Pr e dl : her oc e ngs Hav youpu s d a o h pr c epr c si anatemptt ha eyou c nviton a / e r uc ny t er o edur/ oc s n t o v r o c i nd or s e o rune b s do t sis (uc a ad nitai rmedis? entnce vctr d a e n hi sue s h s mi srtve c c) Yc s No. l yes, f cxpl n; ai j2 5 For 2 4- m ( r l97 ?./ f / Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 l 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Filed 03/03/11 Page 13 of 20 POI AND AUTHORI ES NTS TI GROUND 6 Mat ne l ra ' ' el a-'l t purueas g- f s te r d t =s f lb - a obetv t- rstll- ns t --on o s e deen e l y he e el el n jtle sa ar ofra on lx twtprj e Mao e - l I e l l o hlrg oefecl . '' n e tnd d e s abe l eudl.a t wo tn aton f s lhtt f t e t = un et de hefe a lon --eln' 5 # 6 #z*an 1 * a dmen s un rt e c ' o :* * d 4 men u. . Ma t e -el tstil ou e s oul n tha epu s edas l d f s t eor t a s g se th w r wei ra c ns l h d o v ru j ' ef een e h y h t ug e t d M athew waspr edl hi chld agal tan unsubs anti ed t eatt t vi i bad no pr ent t ot ng s l ns t at hr hat he d m es 9 1 . 0 abl t p m a t etmet evdi u t r dt et r a .Tra c s ' p f manc i p s iga i o edor t h i h i m te e h h e t il oun el eror e n urun w s s l d f ns t e o t ec s f lbeow anobediesan r o r a on l e st tprj c ef e e e h ow f h a e el l l v t da d f e s aben s ha eudied 11 Mat hew. I t t i c t nsead, ral euns s d have pur ued avol ar mansaught t y oft c el houl s unt y l er heor he ase.Tral i 1 2 1 3 1 4 c n e' i fedies l-e e s t e yof h c s al gwihti c un el r i n as l- f s j w ou s l ne f v efd f n e h or t e a e on t ral o s povdig efdeen e u s isr dl t t ej r p eu c Ma t ew a wo k dt hiexr mede rme t Bttf til oun el n tu on o h uy rj died th nd r e o s te ti n . f or ra c s ' s ie fc ien si pu s igas l d f ns t eor o t -a et a p eu c Ma tew,hewoul h e n fe t es n run ef e e e h y f hec s h t rj dled th v d av 15 16 17 18 19 beenacqult f frtdegr m ur and i t woul have been c ded ofvol ar ted or is- ee der ns ead d onvi unt y m ansl aught . er The St t sc e t M a hew kll t vl m wasabou asaitghtasa c c d be becaus a e' as hat tt led he di t ri ase oul e M athew adm lt kilngt vi m t fve separ e I vl s aIofwhor wer M at hew' f i or t t ed l he di o i i at ndi dual, l n e t s rends ac nt esand aIofwhom wer c l durngt St e' cas i c ef SeeTral ans i of. quai anc l e aled i he at s e-n- hi . i Tr crot 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 Mon v, rh1 a Tu s a Qarh2 2 07 a 1 0: - 1 1 :9-3 1 1 l1( heeR ed , da Mac 9 nd e d v c 0. 0 1 t 6 10 1 , 611 2 , 67:0- M I e y fi do Ma t e ,1 1 - 0 1 : 3 l 6: -4(a onHol , r o Ma t w)27 2 - 4, 5:ren f th w) 92:8 2 , M 2-, 9 212 Js derfi f the , 4:2 2 27 1 end 2 2 9:-4( t 1 lf me I ei gilren wihMa t w an ha s t g t r,2 0:2 2 ,2 :, 7 12 Klsa Gar or r i -n rfi d t the d d on o e he ) 9 2 - 4 911 , v 4 & 1 1 Kr t Ga dl, c it nc a onfl dl t r wihMa t e . d29 2 2 2 :6-4. 7-9, i a d s a quan a e nd ren y e ms t th wlan 6:2-4, 981 2 s 2 :- 3 0;- 0 B e nn Camb a f meryen a ed' Ma t e a dsi h sf el g f Ma t e . 9918, 0 3 l ( r a e r ,or l g g t th w n tl a e i s or th w) o l n Ma tew as t siidan di n tde yklngt evci !.At 9:th lo e t e d d o n ii h itm. # 31 37. f l Th s equ si f t ej r wa wh t ert kln s oul bepu s da frtd gr mur e ol e ton or h p y s e h he iig h d l nihe s is e ee der orma sa gh e a s l-e e ewa f t al i s i e.Th j r h v n v wasf c dwîhs c a n lu t r s efd f ns s acu l mpo sbl e uy owe er e er y ae t uh 28 dihot c omousdecsi l t i on. nsead,M athew? t i c t s ral ouns pur ued as fdef e t y oft c ethat el s elt ens heor he as 2 9 3 0 a yIwy o j ciel I kn a t efcsof hi c es oul h ek wnwoul c vi en rton l n a er b e t y oo lg t b a t t s as h d av no v d on nc o a i a j r rt a quiMa tew. u o o c t th 31 ' Mat hew t tfed andadmit t sbootngt vl i i t head aferhethr ened t cu up t es ii t ed o l he d m n he t eat o t 3 2 3 3 his a s hss t hi i pic s I Ma t e so wor ,h 'n p 'a 'mmeda eW s on nd end i on o m n e e . n th w' wn ds e s ap ed' nd i it l ' othiert l fi di t ef c 1 . 3 3 7.R t rt anr t h c n en i o v un ay s h s swhi ren n h a e. 1 At 19:- a be h ebu t e o t ton f ol t r e 34 35 36 mansaught ,t S at sc e i chi f us on c l wines est whom M at hew admiled kil l er he t e' as n ef oc ed ali ng t s o t t li ng t vi m i medlt y aferhe t eat he di m a el t hr ened t cutuphi s M hl Reedy afi ofM at hew', o s on. ey , rend t s t tfedt tM a hew t d hert he had s t vi l i t headi r es ii ha tt ol hat hot he d m n he n espons t t vi i e o he d m 37 t eaenn t cluphss nit pe es J . 1 9:3 1 J s Hol rafi do Ma t e s hr t ig o k t i o n o ic . #.At 6 1 - 8. a on de, ren f th w', 38 t tfed i even m or bl t ms k atng t M athew t d hi t he ' uck up' and e nappedes ii n e unt er , t i hat t ol m hat f ed ' s 39 a dt a t evc i wa d a M. 1 23 2 No a y i t eSa esc s -n c e,t eSa ene er n h t h itm s e d. At 96: - 4. t bl,n h t t ' a ei-hif h t t v 40 a em pt t i peachanywines thatpr ent M at hew as havl onl shotthe vi m i r ont tt ed o m t s es ed t ng y di n eadi o 41 hit r a r g r n Ma te ss Ise d, heS aef u edons owigt ej yt a Mat ew i f c s h e t e a dig th w' on. n t a t tt oc s h n h ur h t th n a t 42 43 44 45 di klt vi i The S a e t ough isown c e-n- hi l topen ie. eat af ualdiput d il he ctm. t t hr t as i c ef ef - cr ed act s e r di whet t kli waspr ediat and delber e ort r ul ofa r i s w her t egar ng her he ilng em t ed i at he es t ash mpule e he voi ofr ce easonand humaniydi noti er ene. I shor i wastheSt e t cr edt f t d nt v n kt at hat eat he adual di e ofwhet t vi m' mur s d be puni sput her he di s der houl shed asfrtdegr e m ur orvol ar is e der unt y ' 46 47 48 r'e Ma tans pt frMa . 19an 20 2X Faœ one v lr? nu l h /r cd s o m. h d , ' zr mbeM f pa 1 à e mm > 452. ' >alrnsc ntf r he ta n or Ma 21 2* 7 t l. da o &ef t-aspr mh , , he aW y f #a epa* D ade l c llrpoleraldbe nsagai al y i Bnt otr e f l gi n page f . 49 . Suppl ementt Petton f W rtofHabeasCor o ii or i pus 13 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 14 of 20 1 man lu h er Ye , r c n e i or t we n s ( pe h p ivt ton)nt eS aesc s t sa g t . tti ou s lgn ed he ak e s or r a s n ia i i h tt ' a e o al 2 3 ar l vol al m ansl gte unt ' y aught and l t purued a s fdef e t er ns ead s el- ens heol suppor ed by absol el no t ut y evi denceatti . ral 4 5 6 T prj dc t ti r dt Ma te i s sa il Frtd gr r urerc ri ama i he e u ie ha nu e o th w s ub t nta. is e ee n d a r es xmum p lyo lewih tt ep sbit o paol wh e sv unar ma l g t c risal xmu enat f i t ou h osi ly f r e era ol t y nsau h er a re na i m f i pen lyof1 y r wihmi mum p r eel biN o 1y a .S NR 2 0 M ( ) NR 2 0. 0. at 0 eas t ni a ol i l f e r ee S 00.3 b, S 0 08 gi i 7 8 9 10 . 11 1 2 as fd f ns t e yo t ec s b c u enortona j r woudh v f dt a Ma tew a t i s f el-e e e h or f h a e e a s a i lu y l a e oun h t th ced n el - 13 14 1 5 def e undert cicums anc Tral ens Ne r t es. i counselwoul adm i t t si t cl si ca ofaf d t hat hi s he as c se adual diput r di whet t def s e egar ng her he endantc omm it vol ae mansaught and t bttf hi ted unt l er hat l or s i e f tv e M a t w woul ha e be n a qut e o frtd gr e m ur era c v de df n fec ien H, t he d v e c it d f is e e ' d nd on i d 1 6 1 7 man lu t .Tra c s wouda tt a t i t or o t ec s f l elw a obe t esa ar o sa gher il oun el l dml h t hs he y f h a e elb o n j ci t nd d f v r as a e es an t a hit or of h c s prj c Ma te b a es l-e en ewa s p t e on bln s d h t s he y t e a e eudiet th w ec us efd f s s up ored 18 19 20 I BA f ti couns ' i or ral els nesedi venessi pur ng asel- ens t yoft cas suppored b n sul fdef e heor he e t y no evi dence,M a hew woul ha beenacqult offrtdegr m ur and c ct ofvol t tt d ve t ed is ee der onvi ed un aw m ansaught .l gr ed an eki i yhearnp M a hew' t i c el l er f ant dentar i tt s ral ouns woul t tiyasf l d es f olows:He woul adml t had heact l t oughl dicus and r ewed t f t oft scas wih hi cl d t hat ualy hor y s sed evi he ac s hi e t s i ent and bas uponthes andar ofwha ar onabl l ed t d t eas e awyerwoul do,he woul have declned t pur ue d d i o s byno evi dence,butvol ar mansaught wa!suppored by ampl evi e. unt y l er t e denc Mat hew woul t tf asf l t d es iy olows:M athew neveragr wih hi t i couns t pur uea s f t eed t s ral el o s eldef enset heow ofthe c e orany ot tbeor f t ma t .l f ti c elneverdicus ed hi as her y or bat t er n ack ral ouns s s s 2 1 22 tilsrtn wihhscin .Ha til o s t ou hl a dpr er dic sidti sr t gyw1h hs ra tae t i l t d ra c un elhor g y n op l s u s r ta e t i e y al cin ,Ma te wo dt xiyt thss ef u a til db t c vn et ej r t a quthm of l t th w uf e f ha i ol oc s t ra woul e o on ic h u y o c i i e 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 frtdegr m ur and convi hi ofvol aw m ansl ls - ee der d m unt aught . er 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 Suppl entt Petton f W rtofHabea Cor em o ii or i s pus 14 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 1 2 Filed 03/03/11 Page 15 of 20 3 4 5 6 . POI AND AUTHORI ES NTS TI . GROUND 7 Matw Tll l' * 1 oun f fi et a kf aI yI - .t one nMat fr t erqulleIt t tl et t: t Ml al o $ @r uf ne c*n ve ur te o med h e st nen t mmmlt al ge r er ef h dt m f l el anobe tv Aa r e ra on ina t tprjdle o the l d obb y t e ' elb e e ltle ndad f e s abe ha eu t d ' Mate4 amendmenttn@h rbteft a e n Oullneteeeaœn ttn s#* t wV I tn ll fW ktef o ulaœ leudrh fdrl Al l Y *6# h MIIe ao e uo % aï 1 * rd : . 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 . 18 Bas upont evi e pr ed he denc oduced att i ,t e wassubsantaldiput ast whet ral ber t i s e o her M a hew shott vi î bec e oft vi i st eatt cl hi s upi o I l pi esordi s t r tt he ctm aus he ctm' hr o tt s on nt i e ec tt d o o ob t vi i ofhi pos es ons Thi i i poran bec et St e pr eeded upon aler t theoresof he d m s s si . s s m t t aus he at oc t na e i sr tdegr m ur asalowed by I f ony m ur wlh r s ee der l aw; el der t obber oratempt r y t ed obber bel t y ng he underyi f onyand mur oc rngwih mal pr l ng el der curi t i ce, emedia i and delbeo ton.See l ct ent t ton i i ndi m , 5I Decem ber7,2007,onfl her n. I wasundl ed t M athew wasl pos es on t vi i s ed le ei t sput hat t n s sl he d m' pos sonssuchashi caraferthe kil t pl The quesi i whet M at hew f m ed t ses i s t li ook ace. ng ton s her t or he i entt r bef eorafert kilng.J yi tr on 21defnedf ony mur i t c es oft nt o ob or t he li ur ns udi i el der n he ont t he St t st y ofr a e' heor obber Tralc el y. i ouns howevermade no r eques f an i t udl thati t i entt t or ns r on f he nt o com mi t r t he obber oratt pt r y em ed obber ofthevitm wasf med afert kilng,t the St e has y ci or t he li hen at notpr oven t M at hew i gui yoff onym ur beyond a r sonabl doubtbecaus the r sie hat t s l t el der ea e e equi t 1 9 it tt c n en o ommir be ywa n p e e tdu i t ekln .I o h wo d ,it ej r f dt t t ob r s ot r s n rng h iig n t er r s ' h u y oun ha l f 20 21 22 23 24 25 M athew di i f kil hevi i i r i t t vi m' comm enl abou hi s and onl a t t d t ad lt ctm n ead on o he di s t s on y fer kilngt vi i di Matt pani andt t vi r scar t Mathew c d notbe guit asa li he d m d hew c ake he din' , hen oul ly ' m a eroflw off ony m ur based upont St e' t y. tt a el der he at s heor Mat hew' beha ori medi el afert kilng s t s vi m at y t he li uppoc at yofan i vi who s heor ndi dual hot t vi i i he ctm mpuli y i r i t thet eathe madet svel n eacton o hr owar hi s and onl a t paniked and ds s on y fer c dr of i the vi m' ca . M a hew frtcaled hi f i J on Hol ,who waswih hi gilrend ove f n di s r tt is l s rend as der t s rfi 26 M hl r ee eedy.Akhl Reedyi tal pi ed upt phone i t eary mor ng hour i medi el afer ee nii l ck y he n he l ni sm at y t 27 t kli and not M a t he il ng ed thew' pani edvoie.See Mar 19 and M ar 20.2007Tral ans i a s ck c ch ch i Tr crot t 28 1 :0 2 . th sv c wasalosrs e ou , rou an s aed M. 1 111 Th sa es 632 - 3 Ma t ew' oie s te s d- t ne v s d c r . At 64:.-5. e tt ' 29 30 own ques i andsubs ton equentanswerbyM hl r ee eedy s upporsMat hew' pot il ens t f ony t t s enta def e o el m ur t he di notI end t r t vi m butonl t t vi m' c a t he pani der hat d nt o ob he di y ook he di s ar f er cked. 31 Q:F iwa i r p s t t a en e tb (h vc m) b lt ed en ntsc l enan p t s n es on e o h t t men y t e i a ott h ef da ' hi o li dr d 32 cbttngt I o pl esand s ng t t hl ac di t t def i hem nt ec endl hem o m, cor ng o he endantt 'caused hat 33 34 35 36 37 hi t r and s m o ead hoott vl i i t head. he ctm n he A:Cored . r !. 1 0:1 1 Th Sat ddn podu easn ewin s t tp o c dadif en r s f wh # At 7 1 - 5. e t e i ot r c igl t e s ha r du e fer t ea on or y . M athew shott vi m i t head ass t by M athew t any St ewiness t he di n he o ed t o at t . Thedef endantneed notbe t onet pr entevi e t s he o es denc hat upporshi theor ofdef t s y ense. 3 8 3 9 R a v S ae, 22Ne . 2 ,1 7 P3 1 01 .1 8(006.Tra c s s l h v i os s . t t l v 1 58 4 .d 1 ,1 0 2 1 il oun elhoud a e mmeda ey it l n tc t i p t ni t et s i o ied hs ater n h e tmonyo t eSa eswine s san a k df anis r ont a t j r f h t t ' t se d s e or n tudi h t he uy 40 makea det m l i whet M at hew f med t i entt r bef e ora t t kllng and i t er naton her t or he nt o ob or fer he li f he 41 it n wa f me a t t a t ej r mu ta qutMa t e off on mur . n e t s or d fer h t h u y s c l th w el y der 42 ' Theevi dencef tadii frtdegr mur r rngpr or r tonal is ee der equii emedla i delber i t ton, i aton 43 wif le sa d maieaort g wa wea .T S aes bmitdg ne aj yv di f mswih t lun s n l f e hou ht s k he t t u te e r lur er d or l c t ou 44 r rng unani iyast t t y of5+ degr mur asal equii mt o he heor ee der l owed by Sc d v.Arz ha iona.50l U. 524 S. 4 5 (9 )a dCrwf r v. tt 1 1Ne 7 , 0 121P. 582 5 (0 5) Ii l eyt a t ej y 1 91 n a o d S ae. 2 v. 45 75 , 3d , 86 2 0 . t s i l h t h ur k 46 47 c vded Ma t e o frtde ee mur rba e up f on r de wi z anyc i a i o on i t h w f is gr de s d on el y pur r t t hot onsder ton f when he f m ed t i en t r bef e ora t t kilng. Butf t i c el i f i or he nt t o ob or fer he li or ral ouns ' nefed venes i s sn 4 8 fin t r qu ta isrdi rgadigajlyd t miatonof nMat e f me t eit tt al g o e es n n tu on e r n t e er n i whe th w or d h n en o i r Suppl entt Pettonf W rtofHabeasCor em o ii or i pus 15 . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 16 of 20 1 r t evdi Ma t w woul h v be a quitdo f l ymur er T j ywoul h v as unl el ob h i m, the d a e en c te f eon d . he ur d a e lo i y k 2 3 convl Mat hew oftadli fr tdegr mur and I t convl M a hew ofvol ar ded t r tonal is ee der ns ead ded tt unt y m ansaught .Ofc se, he pr l er our t osectton i goi t diagr Butthe poi i t i wasuli el f li s ng o s ee. nt s hat t tmat y or 4 t ej yt de i wh t er n tMa tew f me t elt n t r b f eora t t kln a d h ur o cde e h or o th or d h n e t o ob e or fer he iig n l 5 Ma t e sie fdietil oun e prv t dt ej r r ma i t sdeer na i . th w' n fe v ra c s l e en e h u yfom kng hi t mi ton 6 7 8 I gr ed an evi i hearng,Mathew woul t tf t he di notf m t i entt t f ant dentaw i t d es iy hat d or he nt o ake t vi i svehi e untlaferhe i pul vel shott vi i i t head a a r toft vi i he d m' cl i t m si y be ctm n he s esul he d m t eat ng t cutuphi s He onl ookt vehil aferhe pani ed asaconfr hr eni o s on. yt he ce ck imed byt St s he at' 9 ownwin sesp e en e d igt esa esc s -nc i .Hewoul t siyce bya dt ej ywoud t e s r s t d urn h tt ' a e i- hef d e t rdil n h ur f l 10 have belev and ac ted hi offr tdegr m ur and c ded hi ofvol aw mansl i ed quit' m is ee der onvi m unt aught . er 11 Tr c n el l a t ha hes ou d h v a k d f aj yI s r t r g r l g t e p e ie i ou s woud dmi t t h l a e s e or ur n tuc l e a d n h r cs al on 12 tm eoft f m a on oft i entt t t vi m sposs si i he or ti he nt o ake he di es ons.Hewoul adm i t butf hi d t hat or s 13 f in t a kf a isr di r g r n aj yd t r n tono wh hi cin f me t eit tt al g o s or n n tu on e a dig ur e e mia i f en s l t or d h nen o i e 14 15 r t vi m,M a/hew woul have been acquit off ony mur and frtdegr m ur and ob he di d t ed el der is ee der c c ed ofmansaught . onvit l er 16 17 18 19 20 zl 22 23 24 2s 26 27 28 29 ? 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 . 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 ' Suppl ementt P ii f W rtofHabeasCor o etton or i pus 16 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 1 2 3 4 Filed 03/03/11 Page 17 of 20 . POI AND AUTHORI ES NTS TI GROUND 8 . Ma t Te- lI av l ap a de latx dal u erNe at R u ef - l- M xedu ee llq t te j tl al pe l prv l as d m nd v j ul Ap l a r thtwqn l oefet1 1 2- . nt !c uN . 5' Ne a r eof pel t P o e r 4()alwsf t eun i l n tc of pe l r a v da ul Ap l e r c du e c l or h tmey o ie ap a fom a o 6 j d nto c vdi povde apo tc nvdl p tto f wr ofh bea c pu h be tmey u gme f on i on r i d s-o i on e iin or i a s or s as en i l t 7 fl and as elsavibl cl m thatt pettonerwasunl ul deprved ofthe rghtt atmel died ied s a e al he li awf l y l i o i y r 8 appeal . 9 M at hew fl hi orgi post ied s i nal tconviton petti ofaugus 5,2009.TheNevadaSupr ci i on t eme 10 Cour isied t r ttt fom M athew' untm el pr pernotc ofappealonJ ts he emi iur r t s i y o ie anuar 25,2008. y 11 M au hew pettoni t ef e tm el pr li s her or i y operyfl i acc danc w iht pr sonsofNRS34. and l ied n or e t he ovil 720 12 NRS34. 830. 13 . M at hew' tral t s i couns al unl tl deprvedt hi rghtt diedl appealhi ver s i el so awfil y i o si o r y s y erous 14 convi onoffrtdegr m ur wiht us ofafr m .l gr ed anevi aw hearng,M athew di is ee der t he e iear f ant denti i t 1 5 i medi el afers enci t he woul appealhi convi i Matt wast i medit y afer m at y t ent ng hat d s cton. hew hen m a el t s enci unabl t cont hi ator r di hi appealbecaus hi at or di notyii hi ent ng eo ac s t ney egar ng s e s t ney d st m, r pond t hi I t soracc hi phonecal M at hew t fld apr pernotceofappeal hatwas es o s eter ept s l s. t hen i e o i t 1 9 dimis d W t eNe ad S emeC tnanun s h dwrte o ni onDec mbe 2 2 7fom s se h v a upr our i pubi e it n pi on s e r 7, 00 r 20 21 ' woul t si a f lwsr g dighi a e l prv toncai Ma t w wa t db hi ti c ns l d e tW s ol e ar n s pp a de ia i l m. the s ol y s r ou e o al 16 17 18 ' whi the r ttt i ued on J ch emi iur ss anuar 25,2008. I al y f l owed t diedl appeal sc di he woul o r y hi onvi on, d r set f l ng Is whi woul lk y r tI r s and r al he ol owi s ues ch d iel esul n everal emand ofhi c e f a new tral s as or i. 2 2 Pai e r a d pos mora mic c s if dedMat e s u yi tu on t a t es l n ror n r ec il sondu t o n e th w'j r nsrdi s h t h e 23 i t uctonal r sr r t scour t r s and r ns r i eror equie hi t o ever e emand M athew' fr tdegr m ur c di t s is ee der onvi on 2 4 wihu eof frar f ane ti . il ou el e e obe t a u yisr c i s Thi W ur t s a i m or w ralTra c ns n v r jded o nyj r n tu ton . s t e 2 5 2 6 2 7 mus t nrviw t ej yisr on f pl neror Gacav. t t 1 Ne 327 3 4,1 3P2 8 6 t he e e h ur n tudi s or ai r . ri S ae. 21 v. , 3 1 3d 3 8 ( 05) T sc r ha adu yt pot d Math srg tt r v ra an r ndo hi c s b c u e 40 20 . hi ou' s t o r e t t ew' ih o e es l d ema f s a e e a s t e eror we es pli an pa en l pr j d ca t a t i c ur mu 's us n e s e i an pr èd h r s r o a n d t ty e u i il h t h s o ' s u po t t p n d ot t t 2 8 Ma t e sr h t af itil Mc en av Sa e. 1 Ne . ( ,1 52 9 P2 73 ,45( 9 ) th w? i t o ar ra. K n . t t 1 4 v 1M4 0 , 68 .d 97 1 98 . g 29 30 31 The S at pr t e oceeded uponaler t t i offr tdegr m ur asal t na e heores is ee der l owed by l f ony aw; el m ur wih r der t obber oratem pt r y ed obber bei the underyi f on and m ur oc rngwlh y ng l ng el y der cur i t malce,pr l emedi ton and delber i see I ct ent fl Decem ber7,2007,on5l her n.W hen i m i i aton. ndi m , ied e ei t . 32 c metmet s tl j r is r onsa t cos o tilt til our r tld aIn tu on wiht e - i o e t u y n tudi t he l e f ra,he ra c ts te Iisr di s t h a e e 3 e c tonofisr di 2 # h f l ymur r ul i tu onwhiht pr s u l a ar t di no 3 x ep i n tu on 1 t e eon de j nsr di c he o ec ton pp en l d t y 3 p o det elh rt ec r or ral ou s p i t t mor n ofMarh2 ,2 09 whe j y 4 r vi o t e h ou t ti c n el ror o he nig c 1 0 , n ur 35 i r i wer s ted i cham ber .See M ar 21 2007,ti t ans i a 4: 23 & 7: 9. nstuctons e et l n s ch , ral r crpt t 207- 36 lsr ton21 t ef l ymur rj yisr di ; st enp o e byt eSa esa t n yi n tuci , h eon de ur n tu on wa h r duc d h t t ' tor e n 37 chamber pferI and prort afer s t unch i o t noon cl i ar osng gumenl.Tral i couns f Matt di not el or hew d 3 8 obe t isrdi 21 n i i de pt isr di 21b n a ic rd saemen of eon mur ra jd o n tu on . s s s ie n tu on eig n n ore t t t f l y de s aleged byt St t t. 8:- 2.Th S aepr e de up at r a et ore o frtde r emur r l he a e. At 12 e t t oc e d on le n t he is f i g e s de 39 40 41 42 . asal l owedbyI f onym ur wih r aw; el der t obber orat pt r ' y lem ed obber bei the underyi f onyand v ng l ng el m ur oc rngwih malce,pr der cur l t i emedla i and delber i See I dm ent fl Dec t ton l aton. ndi .i ed ember7,2005, on 5l her n.Ye ,t St e' i r i 21 now her r er esahy i r on ont el e ei t he at s nstud on e ef enc nstudi be ement of s 43 a t t dr b v S eJ r Isr din21 fldMarh2 , 00 onfl he en Ise S a esj temD e ob er. e u v n tu o .i e c l 2 7, i r i. n t ad t t ' uw e M 45 i t ucton 21r er ns r i ef encest r he obber oratem pt r y t ed obber asanel entoff onym ur and doesgo ' y em el der ont defne r o i obber butc pl el I esoutanvdefnii orexpl tonoft el y om et v eav i ton ana i he ement of s 4ç a tmp edr bev J. l f c n er i an of hej yisr dinsiana tmp u erNe a Iw te t ob r. #. n a k owh e n y t ur n tu o s te t nd v da a 47 pr l defned i t c extoff onym ur and a opery i n he ont el der tem pt r ed obber y. Suppl ementt Pettonf W rtofHabeasCor o ii or i pus 17 ' Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 1 T ej yc no lgc l c vi s on ofaci f whc t e d n tk o t el l. h ur an t o ial on d ome e y r or lh h y o o n w he emen . me 2 M a r ul M att sconvi l mus be overur and hl c r es t hew' cton t t ned s ase emande f a new tral t a d or i w1h 3 pr er eon mu d j e isr ci . op f l y r er u a tu ton 6 7 s mitn a i ompe ean h c i orec j l isr di wa i r e;a t ,t c r mu t ub tig n nc lt d en e nc r tu n tu on s mp op r nd wo he ou t s c ierwhe h t ei r pe j yIsr ons bmitdbyt epr e u or ran.r v s .Vade onsd t er h mp o r ur n tudi u te h os c t wa r t e eral l z s 8 v. t e Ne w w 1 6P3 46 47 ( 0 ) S mitn ani r per dic lt j yisr dl i Sat, v 9 .d 5, 6 2 08 . ub tig mp o an n ompe e ur n tu on s 9 . ' i op r T qu tont enbe ome whe h a i r eryisr ce jr r a hn av di b s mpr e . he esi h c s t er n mp op l n tu td u y e c ig er d a ed 4 5 ' ' ' ( Filed 03/03/11 Page 18 of 20 Thi c ts d alo c i t af em entoned I tr onal r cl m I t c extof s our houl s onsder he or i ns udi eror ai n he ont pr ec oralmic os ut i s ondud.Fis t Cour m us de mi whet t pr ecut ' c r t he t t ter ne her he os ors ondud of 10 1 1 12 cons iutonaldi enson,t t sCour m us r er e unl stheSt t demonsta es beyond a tt i m i hen hi t ' ev s es t ae rt , 1 4 1 5 r a o bedo t t t hee r rdi n tc ti t t t ev dit J e s na l ub ha t ro d o on rbue o h er c. #. Th p os uors bmlt ga ic e ea i ope j ' Isr di c siu e e r ec t u ti n n omplt nd mpr r ur n tu on on tt t s n y 16 . pr ecu oralm ic os t i s ondud ofacons im i di tt onal menson t r r r s ofM a hew' m ur i hat equies ever al tt s der 1 7 c vdi Lk s t efln mur eru? is rc i c s iu e pai e r rt a r ur srve s l . on i on. iewie h e/ y d j n tu ton on tt t s l n ro b t eq ie e ra. 18 19 ' pr s c or mlc c o i r eryIsr Mlgaj r ont eeemen ofel ymu d rasalge o e ut l sondu t f mp op l n tu n u y h l u f on r e al l d e byt eS aei o ac si in di son.It p o e uori r ryisr digt ej yiofa h tt s f on tt o al men i f he r s c t mpope l n tu n h ur s ut 13 ' upon f ' i t uu i sh d be ov auly ns r ons oul t elur and r er ed.Thl ques ont nson whet t ned ev s s ti ur her he Eac cl m s a el and even mor s t hercombi t r h ai epar t y e o oget ne o enderM athew' mur convi i t s der d on c tiutonaly i im,l ngt scour wihqnl t r s and r ons t i l nfr eavi hi t t y o ever e emand Mathew' cas f a new t s e or 20 21 22 23 24 2s 26 ti . ral 27 28 29 3 0 31 32 33 34 35 . 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 Suppl ementt Petton f W rtofHabeasCor o ii or i pus :8 . ' . : -o1 .' .. :1 h- . * . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 19 of 20 . t.j g. ' . .y) , . , 2:. - W H ER EFO RE,pe ii e p a st tt cou twil a hi s h r ieft whih hei tton r r y ha he r l gr nt m uc ei o c s ' e tte i t sfdeal tto f wrtofha msc spu smn t 28U. C.9225 byapes i nild n hi b r peiin or i be omu rl t o S. 4 ron n sat cust te ody. ( mcofpes wb wr cti Na ron o ot bs c ai i notPli if) ompl nt f antf ( g r ofP ai i Sin e ntm . 5s/ / x. l v/ d I ( t) Dae i ( g tr ofat ne ian Sinau e tor y.f y) ( t ne sa e s& tlpb n Ator y' ddrs ee one umbe ) r DECLA R ATIO N UN D ER PEN ALTY O F PERTUR Y Iu rt dt aflesae nto a we t a yquetoni ti de lrtonwils bec met ndesan hat as ttme r ns r o n si n hs caai l u j t o pe te ofpej y IDECLARE UNDER PENALTY OFPERJURY UNDER THE LAW SOF nalis rur. T I E U NI I TED STATES O F A M ERI THA T T H E FO REGO I I TR IE A ND C O RR EC T. CA NG S J Se 28U. C.9 1 46 a d.8U. C.9 1 . e S. 7 n 1 S. 621 Eeudt xct a e c ', ma o pm/zyz1 , n (Dat/? 1 ye) , ( ato Loc in) . q T&T ) ! - -- , ( gn r ) Si v (nmaeprs numbe) l t ion r j 54 For 22 - m e., fl, , . 9 9/ l; - l, - )k # . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 1 Filed 03/03/11 Page 20 of 20
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
