Crozier v. Endel et al
Filing
19
ORDERED Clerk shall FILE the complaint. FURTHER ORD this action is DISMISSED with prejudice for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. FURTHER ORD that all pending motions are DENIED as moot. FURTHER ORD Clerk shall CLOSE THE CASE and ENTER JUDGMENT ACCORDINGLY. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 4/21/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)
<![CDATA[
1
2 3
4 5
jp j y s j j g
6
7
UN ITE D STA TE S DI T R IC T CO U R T S
DISTRICT O F NEV A D A
8 J REM Y ALLEN CROZI R, E E 9 Plitf, anif 1 vs 0. 11 ADAM ENDEL, taL, e 1 2
1 3
Defnda t. e ns
) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
Cas No. (9-v- 326RCJRAM e 3:) c 0 - ORDER
Pl i tf ,w ho i a pr s ner i t e cus ody of t e N evada Deparm ent of Cor e tons, has a n if s io nh t h t rci
l s bm itd a Ci i Riht Compli tPu s a tt 42 U. . .j 1 ( 1- ) Pli tf ha as fld 4 u te vl g s an r u n o SC 983 # 2 . an if s lo ie
l5 num er usm otonswih t e Cour . Thc Cour hassc ec ed Pl i tf sci i r ght com pl i tpur uant o i th t t rn a n if v l i s an s
1 t 28 U. . .j 1 1 A. ndfndst a i mus bed s is d. 6o S C 9 5 a i h t t t im se
11 7.
l 8
Sc ee igPurua tt 28U.. .j1 1 A r nn sno SC 9 5
Fe e a c ur s m us c ndu t a pr lm i a y s r e i g i a y c s i whi h a p i on rs e s drl o t to c ei n r ce nn n n a e n c rs e e k
1 r d cs t'm ago c nm e tle tt orofi e ort plye ofag ve nm e tle tt .Se 28 U. . ,j 9 er si o v r n a n iy tc r m o e o r n a n iy e SC
20 1 l a .l isr viw,heCo r mus i e tf a yc g ia l cli sa ddim isa ycam st a a e 9 5A( ) n t e e t u t t d n iy n o n z b c a m n s s n li h t r
2l f i ol ts m alci us,f i t st t a cl i upon whi hr lefm aybe gra t d ors e m onet r r lcffom rv o l, i o a l o a e a m c ei ne ek a y ei r
22 adefnda twhe i i m u e ftm s c r lef 3e 28 U. . .j 1 5 ( ) 1,2( Pr s pladngs cn s m n r) u h e i . e SC 91 A b ( )( ) o e e i , . 23 howe e , t lbe al c nsr e .Bals r r v. ti aPolc De ', 01F.d. 96, 99( t Ci. v r mus be i r ly o tu d ite i Pacjc ie p t 9 2 6 6 9 h r
2 1 88.Tosaeaeli un e 42U. . .j1 aplitf mus alget oese ta ee e t: 1 ta 4 9) tt am d r SC 983, an if t le w sn il lm ns ( )h t
25 arghtsc rdbyteConsiuto orlwsofteUniedSttswa viltd,a d( )tattealge î euc h tt in a h t ac s oae n 2 h h le d
26 // /
1 vi l ton w ascom m it d by apc son actng undercol r ofst t l w . See Iz xfv.At i s,487 U . ,42, oai te r i o ae a zr c kn S
2 48( 988) 1. 3 l a dii n t t e s r e ig r quiem e t unde j 1 1 p rua tt t e Prs n Lii a in n d to o h c e n n c r n s r 9 5A, u s n o h io tg to
4 Reonn Ac of1 95I LRAI a tdea co l mus dim isaprs ne ' cli ,6ftealg tonof f t9P , k rl u' t s s t io rs am i h le ai i
5 po e t i t t l , ori t c a to 6i f i o o sorm a i i us f ist sat a c a m o whi h r le m a v ry s l n c ' f h c i n is r v l u n ' lc o , a l o t e l i n c e i f y 6 be g a t d,ors e s m o e a y r le a a ns a dc e d n w ho i i m une f om s c r le . 28 U . . . rnc ek n tr eif g i t f n a t sm r u h e i f' ' SC
7 j1 1 e() Dizislofac mpli tfrfiur t saeacli u o whihrle c nbegrntdi 9 5()2 . snsa o an o al e o tt am p n c eif a ae s
8 pr v d d f ri Fc cal l ofCi iPr c dur 1 ( )6) a dt eCo r a p ist es m esa da du de o i e o n d r Ru e v l o e e 2 b ( , n h u t p le h a tn r n r 9 j 1 5whe r viw ig tea t u c tfac m pli to a ame d dc m pli t W hc ac ur dim is s 91 n e c n h dt a y ) o an r n n e o a n . n o t s s e q 1 ac m pli t rj1 1 ( ) t epli tf s oul begi c la ct a e dt ec m pli twihdie tons 0 o an unde 9 5 e ,h an if h d v n e v o m n h o an t r c i
11 as t curng isdefci nci s unl ssi i cl arf (m t e f ce oft ecompl i tt att c defci nci scoul o i t i e e , e t s e r) h a h an h h ie e d
1 no bec r d b a e dm c t Se Cat v.Un tdSt ts, F.d.1l 3,11 ( t Ci.1 5) 2 t ue y m n n . e o ie a e 70 3 0 06 9h r 99 . 1 3 Re iw unde Rul l ( )6 i e s ntal a r ln o a qu sin oflw . Se Cl ppe I ve r e 2 b ( ) s s e i ly u ig n c to a e l lJ a .
1 Labo aor Cop.fzme ia, F.d71 , 23( t Ci. 00) Dimis lorfiur t saeacam 4 r t y r o j rc 232 3 9 7 9h r 20 . s sa f al e o tt li
I i pr peronl i ï i cl art att e pl i t f cannotpr vc any s toff ct i suppor oft e cl i t at 5 so y f t s e h h a n if o e a sn t h am h
1 woul e ttehi orhe t r le .Se M ore p Wale ,1 F.d756, ( t Ci. 999 .l ma i g 6 d n il m r o eif e ly . k r 75 3 759 9 h r 1 ) n k n
l t i d t nui a i n, heCou tt ke a tteaI a l ga ï nsof at ra f c sat d ï t ec m pl i t a d t e 7 h s e e n to t r a s s rl ( le to m c il a t t e n h o an , n h
1 Courtcons r est em i t elghtm ostf vor bl t t epl i tf .See I trçlk v. om a Cor . 74 F. d 8 ' tu h nh i a a e o h a n if ' z -/tw X F r p, 3
l 955, ( t Ci.1 . Aleg tonsofapr s c m pli a ta eh l t ls srnge tsa da dst a 9 957 9 h r 996) l ai o e o an n r e d o e s ti n t n r h n 2 f nna pla i gsd a tdbylwye s Se Hu he v Ao c 449U. . 9 ( 980 , ne v Ke n r 404 0 o l e d n r fe a r. e g s . w ' , S 5, l ) Hai s . r e , .
21 U. .5l 520( 972 ( e c ra ) W hietesa dadundc Ruc1 ( )6 doe notrq ied tied S 9, 1 ) p r uim . l h tn r r l 2b () s e u r eal
22 f ct alalegatons,apl i tf m us pr vi em or t an m er l bel and concl si ns.Belz tantcCor . au l i an if t o d eh ea s uo lq l i p
23 v Tbombl,l S. t1 ,1 4- 5( 0 7,A f r uli rctto ofteelm e t ofac us of cton . v y 27 C . 955 96 6 2 0 ) o m ac c iain h c n s a e a i 24 i is fiint / .s ePa a anv Alai, U..26 ,28 ( 98 ) s n u fce . #, e p s . l n 478 S 5 6 1 6 .
25 // / 26
2
1
A1 or par of a com pl i tfl d by a prsc er m ay t cr f r be di m i s d sta s ont i t e 1 t a n ie im h eoe s se t p e f h
2 prs ner' cl i s l ck an ar tabl bas s eiher i 1 w or i f tt Thi i cl des cl i sbas d on l gal io s a m a gz e i t n a na . sn u am e c
3 co cuso st a acuntna l ( . .cam sa ans dc c da t whoa ei m un lom s i trcli sof n l in h t r e b e cg , li g i t fn n s r m e i u t ) am
4 i fi ge e t alga i t r s whihce rydoe no e it, swela cli sba edo fnc f l a t al n rn m n of e l n e e t c la l s t x s) a l s am s n a iu f cu
5 ale at ns( .. fntsi o dcl so als cn ros . Se Netk ' Iïla s,490 U. .31 327- 8 lg i eg , a a tc r u in c a i ) e iz e p k li m o ' . S 9, 2
6 (989 , e aloMc ee e v. oc , F.d795, ( t Ci.1 91. 1 ) s e s K v r Bl k 932 2 . 798 9h r 9 )
7 1I . Screeni g eft e Cem pl i t n h an
8
Pl i tf s esDef ndant A da Endel Cat erne Corez- as o,Cl udc W ils,Debr Br oks, a n if u e sm , hi tMt a li ao
9 E. .M cD ani l l ow ar Skol i ,J m csG .Cox,J hn Doc Li ht ey,Ji Gi bt s,J hn D oc,M ar K e, l d nk a o gs m bm e k
10 Dr i ,Rcnee Baker and Ros M il ri bot t ei i di i ualand ofi i lcapacii s f rvi l ton ofhi an , s le n h h r n v d tc a te o o a i s
1l constt tonalrght . I Count1 Pl i tf cl i st athe wasdeni d fem r cci i g an er tc m agazi e iu i isn , an if a m h e r e vn oi n 1 publcaton becaus i w asdeem ed ts xualy c plci' i vi l ton ofhi FistAm endm entrght . l 2 ii et se l x i t' n o a i sr isn l3 Count1 , ai tf cl i st att i ccns r hi amount d t deni lofhi P'r tA m endm entrght w iheut 1 Pl n if a m h h s os p eo a s is ist 14 due pr cess i vi l ton of t e Foureent A m endm ent l Count 11,Pl i tf cl i s t at t ese o n oai h th .n 1 a n i f am h h 15 vi l tonsf r ed hi t s cnd hi tm c l am i g l w r s ar h s f1 andperon' l galr sear h i or er oai o c m op s i e n a e e c k 1s f ne e c n d l t brng hi cl i s i vi l ton ofPl i tf sFi s,Si t ,and Four eent A m endm e trght .Pl i tf 6oi s am n o ai a n if r t x h th n i s a n if
1 se smonetr dama e a wela ij nciea dd clrtr rlef 7 ek ay g s s l s nu tv n e aao y ci .
18 19 A. Countl Pl i tf cl i s t at hi Fist Am endm e t r ght w er vi l t d when he was deni d f om a n if a m h sr nis e o ae er
20 r c i i g a c otc pu lc to bc a s i w a dee e i e ua l e plci' by pr s n ofi i l. A e c v n n r i b i a i n c u e t s m d t x ly x i t' s i o tc a s 21 prs ne ' rght o r c i epublc tonsf o o t i et ep ion s oul bea a yz d i lg tof h Tur e io r s i t e e v i ai r m u sd h rs h d n l e n fh t e n r
22 f cor. eBe r v Banz'5 8U. . 21 53l 3 ( 006 . hr mpou v Lampe t 35 F.d969, a t sSe a d . l , 4 S 5 , - 3 2 ) Ba a , r. r, 6 3 975-
23 7 ( t Ci. 4) Mor io v Hal, 1F, 89 , I02( t Cï. 01 . au ov Ar ai ,1 8F.d 6 9h r 200 . rs n . l26 3d 6 90 - 9 h r 20 ) M r . p o 8 3 , , 2 1 5 , l 8- 9 ( t Ci. 1 9) ( n ba c . W he c nsdc i g p i o r gu ai ns on i c m i g 4 0 4 05 5 9 h r 99 e n ) n o i rn rs n e lto no n
25 pu lcains tglm ec ntn rg lto i pemisbl i tep ionc ntxt'Mc abev Ar v ,827 b i to ,tso o e t e u ain s r si e n h rs o e . c ' . ae
26 F. d634, 8( t Ci.1 ' e aloF/tr bl g'v. 2 63 9 h r 987)s e s kpn f / Abbot, 0U . . 1, l l ( 98 ) M aur , 88 , rl t49 S 40 4 5- 6 1 9 . , o1
3
1 F. d at1059. l lghtofconcem saboutpr ventng t e se ualhar ss entofprson guar sand ot e 3 ni eihx am i d hr 2 i m at s prs n ofi i l m ay pr hi i r cei tofsexualy e plci m at ral . Bahrampours356 F. d n e , io fc a s o b te p l x i t e i s See 3
3 a 976. o tv S migtn,1 F.d3 8,3 7(t Ci.1 . o,1 F.da 1 0. t , s . y n o 97 3 4 5 9h r 999)Maur 88 3 t 06 Fr ,
4 Taki g t ef ct i t elghtm os f vor bl t t ePl i tf ,t eCour tndsasam aterofl w t at n h a sn h i t a a e o h a n if h ti t ah
5 Pl i tf f ist st t acl i f ra Fis Am endm entpr cedur lduepr cessvi l ton. Pl i tf w asnot a n if a l o a e a m o rt o a o oai a n if
6 e ttc t r c i e a s xua l e plc tpublc ton u de t e Fis A m c dm e t The ef r ,Pl i tf s n ild o e e v e ly x i i ia i n r h r t n n. r o e a n if
7 camsi Countlaedimis dwihprj dceb ca s a e d e t dbef tl. li n r s se t eu i e u e m n m n woul uie
8 B. C ount1 1
9
Pl i tf cl i s t athi Fourcc t Am endm entdue pr ces rght wer vi l t d when pr s n a n if a m h s t nh o s i s e o ae io
1 of i il dcni d hi fom r cei i g an er tcpublcaton. Pl i tf m ai t i s t athe di notr cei e a 0 fc a s e m r e vn oi ii a n if n a n h d ev 11 hearng orr vi w ofhi i di i ualconduett det nni e w hct er deni lof hi er tc m agazf e was i ee s n vd oen h a s oi n 12 appr prat i hi siuaton. Pl i tf al o st t s t at he was not gi en w rten notfcaton of t e o icn s t i a n if s a c h v it ii i h
1 c ns rhi/ee ton butsae eswheei hi c mplitt a hedi rcevenotc ta hi ma a ie 3 e o s prjci tts le r n s o an h t d e i ie h t s g zn
1 wasw ihhcl be aus i w asts xualy explci.' 4 t d c et 'e l i t' 15 W he prs n of i i l i t r eptpublcatons,i tm us be actom pani d by m i i um pr cedur l n io fc a s n e c ii tt t e nm o a
l s fgua ds'Sor es v M c e , F.d 965,97 ( t Ci. 02)( ii g Pr c nirv. arie , l 6 a e r . r l . K e 290 3 ' 2 9 h r 20 ctn o u e M tn z 4 6 1 U. . 41 l8 ( 97 ) ov r u e r? ot e gr un s T o n u gh v Abbot, U. . 1 41 1 7 S 396, 7- l 4 , e r ld ?? h r o d , h r b r . t 490 S 40 , 3- 4
1 ( 989 )se alou' t r Lut, F.d6 2,69698(t Ci. 3) Spe iial,a imaeç a a 8 1 ) ; e s #/ g . z 329 3 9 w' - 9h r200 . cfc ly n n t t s h
1 Fou te t Am en m e td e pr c s lb ry i tr s i r c i i g notc t a hi i c m i g m a li be ng 9 re n h d n u o e s i e t n e e t n e ev n ie h t s n o n is i
2 wihhedbyprs na toiis' Fr s v S migtn,1 7F.d3 8,35 ( t Ci.99 ) 0 tl io uh rte . o t . y n o 9 3 4 3 9h r1 9 . '
21 Taki g t ef ct i t elghtm ostf vor bl t t ePl i tf,t eCour tndsasam ate of1 w t at n h a sn h i a a e o h an if h ti tr a h 22 Pl i tf f ist st t a cl i f raFoureent Am endm entpr cedur ldue pr ces vi l ton. Pl i tf a n ir a l o a e a m o th o a o s o ai an if 23 wasnotentte t a hearng orr vi w ofhi ï di i ualcicum sances oreven aw rten det r i aton il d o i ce s n vd r t , it em n i
2 t a hi publc ton w a de i d. Pl i tf a m it d t a he r c i e no i e t a t e p blc ton w a 4 ht s ia i s ne a n i f d te h t e e v d tc h t h u i a i s
25 deni d becausei w asSs xualy e plci,'whi h m eet t e due pr cessr quiem e t undert e e t te l x i t' c sh o e r ns h
26
4
1 Fourc nt Amcn me t Theeoc, antf'cam si Co ntlaedimis dwihprju iebc a s te h d n. rfr Pli ifs li n u l r s sc t e dc c u e
2 amcndm entw oul be f tl . d u ie
3 4
C.
CountI I I
Pl i tf cl i st att esevi l tonsf r edhi t s endhi tm el ar i g1 w r s ar h s il and a n if a m h h o ai o c m op s i e n n a e e c k ls
5 peror l galres ar h i vi l ton ofPl i tf sFi s,Si t ,and Foureent A m endm entri ht .A tt e fme e c n o ai a n if r t x h th gs h 6 out et t e Cour not s t at LW her a pari ul r a e dm ent i r vi es an cxplci t xt als ur e of s ,h t e h ,t e tc a m n po d ite u o c
7 c ns iu i na pr t c i n'a ai s a p r i ul rs r ofgo e nm e tbe a i r ûha A m e dm e t n tt e o tt to l o e to g n t a t a o t c v r n h vo ,t t n n, o h
8 mor ge eaie notonofiubsa tvcduepr c s, mus bcteg iefranay ig g plitf s e n rlz d i t tni s o e s' t h u d o lzn a anif l '
9 cli s . Al rghtv.Olve ,5l U. .26 ,27 - 4 ( 9 4)( e nquit C.. f rplr lt )( uotng am '' b i ' i r 0 S 6 3 7 1 9 R h s, J, o u a iy q i
1 Gr h m v Co nor 49 U. . 39j( 989 ) The eor , antf scli swil a ay e u d rt e 0 a a . n , 0 S 386, 1 ), r f e Pli if am l be n lz d n e h
ll Fi s A m endm entrghtofacces t t e coursr t erany ge e alzcd notonsofs bs antvedue pr cess rt i so h t ah nr i i uti o
12 undert c Fourt ent Am endm ent h eh .
1 3
A prs ne a l gi g avi l to o hi r g tofa c s t t ec ursm us de ons r t t a h ha i o r le n o ai n f s i h ceso h o t t m tae h t e s
I s feedt cualij r .'Le i v Ca e , 1 U. .3 3 3 9 50(1 .Thcrg to a c s t ec u t 4 u f r f t n u y ' w s . s y 5 8 S 4 , 4 - 996) a i h t c e s h o rs
15 i lm ied t diectcrm i a a peal ,habeas cor us pr cee i gs,and ci i rght actons chale gi g si t o r i nl p s p o dn vl i s i ln n
1 c n iinso co tne e t l . 35 - 5.t .imat c nno e tbls rlva ta ta ij l smpl by 6 o dto f ni m n . d at 4 5 t n n e a t sa ih ee n cu lnu' i y A y
l esabls i g t a hi prs n' 1 w lbr r or l galas i tnce pr gr m i s b- ar i som e t eor tcal 7 t i h n h t s io s a i a y e ssa o a su p n h ei 18 sens .'/ .at351.Rat er t ei m at çm us go one sep f rhera d dem onsr t t att c lbr r orl gal e' # h ,h n e i t t ut n ta e h h i a y e
1 assa c pr ga hid rdhi cf rst puruealga cam . l .Thea ta-nur rquie e t 9 sitn e o rm n ee s fo t o s e l li ' d ' cu lij y e rm n
20 m a dat st atan i m at idem onstat t atanonfi ol usl galcl i had been fusr t d orw asbei g n eh n es reh rv o e am r ta e n
21 i pc e . f . 35 . I Le i v Ca e , he Supr m e Cou tdci e prs ne s rghtofa c s t t e m d d ' J at 3 n w s . s y t ' e r tn d io r ' i ces o h
22 coursassi pl t e û i htt bri g t cour agrevance.'1d.at354. TheCo r s e iial rjce te t m y h tg o n o r ti ' ' u t p cfc ly ee td h
23 neton tattesat mus e a l aprs ncrt tiiat efctvey o c i c ut' . .(uotnga d i h h t e t n bc io o itg e fe i l n e n o r. J q i n l 'J
24 dica m i glngu gec nti c i Boun sv Smih, U. . l 8 5 26( 9 7), e aloCo netv s li n a a o an d n d . t 430 S 8 7, 2 - 1 7 ) s e s r t . .
25 Do ov n,51F.d8 4,8 8( t Cf.1 95 (eemiigta prs nes rght a c s t tecout i na 3 9 9 9h r 9 ) d tr nn h t io r' i of c e s o h rs s
26 lm ie t t epla i gsa eofacvi rg t a tonorpeii n f rwrtofha e sc r us . i t d o h e d n tg i l ih s c i tto o i b a op )
5
1
Plitfha not monsrtdta heha s fee a ya t a ij r .Thefc ta hcs e ttmc anif s de tae h t s u frd n cu lnu y a th t p n i
2 r s ar hi g t c lw f rhi cl i s,ort athe fndst e pr cessf racces i g l galm at ri l som ew hat e e c n h a o s am h iho o sn e e as
3 c mbes me d e nota o ntt a ij l ta woul rnde hi Fis Ame dme tcam lgal u ro , o s m u o n nuy h t d e r s rt n n li e ly
4 cogni abl .Pl i tf f ist s at acl i undert eFistAm endm entupon whi h r lefm ay be gr nt d. z e a n i f a l o t e am hr c ei ae
5 To t e ext ntt a Pl i tf m akesr f re ce t equalpr t cton vi l tons,Pl i tf f ist sat h e h t a n if ee n o oe i oai a n if a l o t e
6 a cl i unde t e Foureent Am endm e t Equalpr t cton cl i s arse when a char e i m ade t at am rh th n. oe i am i gs h 7 si iary s t at d i di i ual a e teat d dif r nty wihoutar tonalr ltons i t a l gii at sat m l l iu e n v d s r r e fe e l t ai c a i h p o e tm e t e
8 pur os .Se SanAntni Sc oo Diti tv Ro rgue ,411U. .1( 972 .l or e t saca j 1 8 pe e o o h l src . d i z S 1 ) n d ro tt 93
9 cl i base on avi l ton oft eequalpr t cton cl us oft eFoureent A m endm ent apl i tf m us am d oai h oe i a e h th , an if t
10 alcge and t at def ndant act d w ih i t ntonaldicrm i aton agai s a cl ss of i m at s w hi h l h e se t ne i si n i nt a ne c
11 icude teplitf.Lowev Ci o M on o i, F.d998,1 1 (t Ci.1 )Fe eal po i n l d h anif . t f r va 775 2 y 0 0 9h r 985, d r De st .
l I s Cor .v He de s n, 0F.d46 , 1( t Ci.1 1 .Pl i tf ha n tsae t a hei ame bc 2 n . p . n r o 94 2 5 47 9 h r 99 ) an if s o t td h t s m r
13 ofa pr t ct d cl s ort athehassufer d any dicr m i aton based on hi m em ber hi i s ch a cl ss oe c as h fe si ni s spnu a.
1 4 l5
Si iary,Pl i tf al o f ist s at any f ct t s ppor a cl i undert e Si t A m endm ent m l l a n if s a l o t e a so u t am h xh . Taki g t ef ct i t elghtm os f vor bl t t ePl i tf t eCour Gndsasam aterofl w t at n h a sn h i t a a e o h a n if h t t ah
16 Pl i tf f is t st t a cl i i Count1Iupon whi h r lefm ay be gr nt d. Ther f r ,Pl i tf s a n if a l o a e am n I c ei ae e o e a n if
1 cai si Co nt11aeds is dwihprj diebc a s a e dme twoul beftl. 7 l m n u 1 r im se t cu c c u e m n n d uie
l8 1 1. 1 l9 Concl si n uo Beca set epl i tf cannotpr veanysetoff c si s pport hi cl i st atw oul e ttehi u h a n if o at n u of s a m h d n il m
2 t rlc,a da e dme two l beftl,hec mplitwilbedimisdwihprj die. 0 o eif n m n n ud uie t o an l s se t eu c
21 I I H ER E BY O R D E R E D t att e Cl r oft e Cour shal FILE t e compl i t TS h h ek h tl h an .
2 2
24 // / 25 // / 26 // /
Ir I FURTHER ORDERED t a t i a ton i DI M I SED wih pr j dief rf iur t -S h t h s ci s S S t eu c o al e o
23 s at a c ai upon w hi h rele can be grant d. te lm c if e
6
I IS FURTH E R O R D ER E D t a al pendi g m otonsar D EN I D asm oot T ht 1 n i c E . IT I FURTH E R O R D E R E D t att e Cl r oft e Courts al CLO SE TH I C A SE S h h ek h hl S EN TE R JU D G M E N T ACC O R D I G L Y . N
4 5
D A TED :Thi J'h day ofAprl 201 s 'st i, 0.
6
7 8
I. J1
S'T iA
Il c'JJ GE sw r ID
17
18 19 20 21 22 23
7
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
