Black v. Skolnik et al
Filing
35
ORDER ADOPTING 34 Report and Recommendations. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Ds' 21 Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED. Signed by Judge Brian E. Sandoval on 3/6/2009. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - PM)
<![CDATA[
.
7
F'RD E. E !: N' LE l D
l
2
t.g/::1N ) L k pS E) (SJS L? 8;E (FF CIE lt1E.2 ' S J EIII p'i CE I
rrq! tl/l yjr
l)F - 6 259 ! ( ( k
3 4
5
k
@!':- . 7. .
(Fi'l0S:IvllR 1i6tf'OFt..D T 2'olīG'II2,fb l fli tk '. B . ' 7 g; ' <' I .u .. . -. -) F. . s - . -- - uJ.h. .-. .
... .
6
7
UNI ED STATES DI TR I T CO UR T T SC
DI TR I T O F NEV A D A S C
8 ERI R.BLACK, K
9
10 v.
3: 7- V - 62- ES- A M OC 5 B R
Pl i tf , a n if O R D ER
l1 HOW A R D SKO LN I ,ela/, K .
1 2
13
Def ndant . e s
1 4
Bef r t e Coud i t e Repod and Recom m endaton oft e Uni d St t s M agitat oe h sh i h t e ae sr e
1 Ju ge ( 3 )(Re o m end ton' en er d on Febr ar 1 ,2009,i whih t e Magitat 5 d #4 ' cm i ai ) t e uy0 n ch sr e
1 Judge r com m ends t att i Coud ent r an or e r gr ntng def ndant 'M oton t D i m i s 6 e h hs e d ai e s i oss
1 ( 21 .No obeci nt t e Rep r a d Rec m m en at n h s b en fe . 7#) j to o h ot n o d i a e id o l
1 8 1 Dl cussl N .s o
1 9 2 0 21 22 23
Thi Coud ' a a c p , rj c , or mo i , i whol or i p r,t e fn ig or s ' y c e t ee t m df n y e n a t h idn s r c mm enda in ma e b t ema itat .28 U. . . 636( )1 .Furher un er U. . . eo t s d yh o gsr e ' SC j b ( ) t , d 28 S C j 63 ( )1 ,i a p dy mak s a t el obec in t t e magitat j d e' r c mm en at n, 6b() f a e i y j t oh m o sr e u g s e o di o t ent i Cour i r quied t ' ak ade novo det r iaton oft ose porins oft e (epor h hs ts e r o ' e m em n i h to hr t an r c m m en at n t whc obec in i ma e.l Nev rh ls ,t e sa u e do s n t d eo d i ) o ih j t s d ' o o ' e t ee s h t t t e o
2 'equr l s m eIss r e iw b (hi Cour) enn ob e t nsar fed.Thomasv. n, 4 4 ' i ) o e e r ve y t s re twh o j c i o ei ' l Ar 47 2 U. . 40, 49 50( 985 .Is ea , derhesa u e,hi Coud i n tr qui dt c ndu t'n 5 S 1 1 - 1 ) n t d un t t t t t s s o e r o o c' y e a
26 r viw ataI. .ofany isuet ati nott e subj ctofan obecton.L= at149.Si i ry,he ee l s hs h e j i ' d. mllt a
27 28
1Foran obectont be tm el,a parymus ser eandfl iwihi 10daysaferbeig jio iy t t' v i t tn e t n s redwi t e magitat j d e' r po an r c m men a i n. 8U. .. 6 6b() ) ev th h sr e u g s e d d e o d to 2 SC 5 3 ()1( C
l
l Nit Ci uih sr c gnz dt a adititc u ti no r qur dt r viw am a ita ejdge' n h r t a e o ie h t sr o r s t e i o e e c c e gs r t u s 2 r p r an r c m menda inwh r n obec insh v b enfld. Uni dSt t sv. na e ot d e o t o ee o j t o a e e i Sqe t a e ReM e e 3 Tani , F.d 1 4 ( t Ci.2 03 ( ir gar ig t e sanda d o r ve emply d byt e a 328 3 11 9 h r 0 ) ds e d n h t r f e iw oe h 4 ditit ou whenr viwigar poran r c m m en at nt whihnoo j c in wer m a e ' sr c d c e e n e t de o di o c o be t s e d l o ,
5 s e aio Sc m itv. oh son , 63 F. upp. 1 1 , 22 ( . i. )(ea igt e Nit e s h d J nt e2 s 2d 2 9 1 6 D Ar 2003 r d n h n h z
6 Cicui' decii n i Revnm -ani as adoptng t e viw t atdititcours ar notr quied t r ts so n la iheh s rc te ero
7 r ve ' n is e t ati n tt e s be tofan obeci n.) Thu ,it er i no obeci nt a e iw ' y s u h s o h u jc a j to '. s f h e s ' jt o o % ma ita ejdge' r c m m en a in,h nt i Cour mayac ep t e r c m m en a i nwi ou gs r t u s e o d to t e hs t c th e o d to t t h r viw .Seee. .Johnst ne, F. upp. at1226 ( cceptng, t outr viw , magitat ee a. o 263 s 2d a i wih e e a sr e j d e' r c m m en a i nt whc no o j c in wasfe ) ug seo d to o ih be to id . l I t i c s , ait fh s n tfld a o j c in t t e Magita e J dge' Repor and n hs a e Pl n i a o i n be t o h f e o srt u s t Rec m m en a in.Al ou h no o j c in wasfed,hi Cou tha r ve ed t e Rep r an o dt o tg h be t o i ts l r s e iw h ot d Rec m m en a in ( 3 ) an ac ep si.Ac or igl, o d t # 4 , d c t t c dn y o
I I HEREBY O RD ERE D t a def ndant 'M oton t Di m i s ( 21 i GRANTED. TS ht e s i o s s # )s I I SO O RD ERED . TS
DA T E D : s 6t day ofMar h,2009. Thi h c
U NI ED STATES DI TR I T JUDG E T SC
21
23
25
28
2
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
