Spilotro v. C R Bard Incorporated et al, No. 2:2019cv01586 - Document 29 (D. Nev. 2019)
Court Description: ORDER granting 27 Stipulated Protective Order; Signed by Magistrate Judge Nancy J. Koppe on 10/25/2019. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - JM)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Spilotro v. C R Bard Incorporated et al Doc. 29 Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 1 of 18 "" 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 : ; 32 33 "" GTKE"Y0"UYCPKU."GUS0" Pgxcfc"Dct"Pq0"8:62" ITGGPDGTI"VTCWTKI."NNR" 32:67"Itkhhkvj"Rgcm"Ftkxg."Uwkvg"822" Ncu"Xgicu."Pgxcfc":;357" Vgngrjqpg<"*924+"9;4/5995" Hceukokng<"*924+"9;4/;224" ""Gockn<"uycpkugBivncy0eqo" EJTKUVQRJGT"L0"PGWOCPP."GUS0" Admitted Pro Hac Vice" ITGGPDGTI"VTCWTKI."NNR" 3366"37vj"Uvtggv."Uwkvg"5522" Fgpxgt."Eqnqtcfq":2424" Vgngrjqpg<"*525+"794/8722" Gockn<""pgwocppeBivncy0eqo" """"""""""""" """""""""""""" Counsel for Defendants KP"VJG"WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" 34 35 36 37 38 39 3: 3; 42 43 44 HQT"VJG"FKUVTKEV"QH"PGXCFC" "" " UVGRJCPKG"URKNQVTQ."cu"Iwctfkcp"cf" ECUG"PQ0"4<3;/ex/237:8/THD/PLM" Nkvgo"hqt"LCUQP"FWGPCU." " " " Rnckpvkhh." " x0" " E0"T0"DCTF."KPE0="DCTF"RGTKRJGTCN" XCUEWNCT."KPEQTRQTCVGF." " Fghgpfcpvu0" " " "" " " "" "" " 45 RTQRQUGF"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" 46 1"1"1" 47 1"1"1" 48 1"1"1"" 49 1"1"1" 4: 1"1"1" 3" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Dockets.Justia.com Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 2 of 18 " 3 Vjg"rctvkgu."vjtqwij"vjgkt"tgurgevkxg"eqwpugn."uvkrwncvg"vq"vjg"gpvt{"qh"c"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"vq"iqxgtp" 4 vjg"fkuugokpcvkqp"qh"fqewogpvu."ocvgtkcnu."cpf"qvjgt"kphqtocvkqp."kpenwfkpi"vjg"uwduvcpeg"cpf"eqpvgpv" 5 vjgtgqh." fgukipcvgf" d{" cp{" rctv{" cu" eqphkfgpvkcn" cpf" rtqfwegf" d{"cp{" rctv{" kp" uwrrqtv" qh" oqvkqpu." kp" 6 tgurqpug"vq"ytkvvgp"fkueqxgt{."qt"fwtkpi"cp{"hqtocn"qt"kphqtocn"fkueqxgt{"kp"vjku"nkvkicvkqp"uwdlgev"vq"vjg" 7 vgtou"cu"ugv"hqtvj"dgnqy0"" 8 YJGTGCU." vjg" rctvkgu" vq" vjku" cevkqp." vjtqwij" vjgkt" tgurgevkxg" eqwpugn." jcxg" citggf" vjcv" c" 9 rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"rtgugtxkpi"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"qh"egtvckp"fqewogpvu"cpf"kphqtocvkqp"ujqwnf"dg"gpvgtgf" : d{"vjg"Eqwtv0" ; VJGTGHQTG."KV"KU"QTFGTGF"cu"hqnnqyu<" 32 K0" Fghkpkvkqpu" 33 30" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp0" " ÐEqphkfgpvkcn" KphqtocvkqpÑ" ku" fghkpgf" jgtgkp" cu" cp{" 34 kphqtocvkqp" vjcv" eqpuvkvwvgu." tghngevu." fkuenqugu." qt" eqpvckpu<" *3+" c" Ðvtcfg" ugetgv" qt" qvjgt" eqphkfgpvkcn" 35 tgugctej."fgxgnqrogpv."qt"eqoogtekcn"kphqtocvkqpÑ"vjcv"ku"uwkvcdng"hqt"rtqvgevkqp"wpfgt"Hgfgtcn"Twng"qh" 36 Ekxkn"Rtqegfwtg"48*e+*3+*I+="="cpf"*4+"kphqtocvkqp"vjcv"oc{"dg"rtqvgevgf"htqo"fkuenquwtg"wpfgt"c"rctv{Óu" 37 eqpuvkvwvkqpcn" tkijv" qh" rtkxce{" uwej" cu" eqphkfgpvkcn" cpf" rtkxcvg" ru{ejkcvtke." ru{ejqnqikecn." ogfkecn" 38 eqpfkvkqp"cpf1qt"gornq{ogpv"kphqtocvkqp0" 39 40" Vtcfg"Ugetgv0""C"rctv{."kp"fgukipcvkpi"kphqtocvkqp"ÐEqphkfgpvkcnÑ"dgecwug"kv"eqpvckpu"c" 3: ÐVtcfg"Ugetgv.Ñ"ujcnn"fgukipcvg"qpn{"kphqtocvkqp"vjcv"oggvu"vjg"fghkpkvkqp"qh"vtcfg"ugetgv"eqpvckpgf"kp"3:" 3; W0U0E0"¸"3:5;<"" " 42 vjg"vgto"Ðvtcfg"ugetgvÑ"ogcpu"cnn"hqtou"cpf"v{rgu"qh"hkpcpekcn."dwukpguu." uekgpvkhke." vgejpkecn." geqpqoke." qt" gpikpggtkpi" kphqtocvkqp." kpenwfkpi" 43 rcvvgtpu." rncpu." eqorkncvkqpu." rtqitco" fgxkegu." hqtowncu." fgukipu." rtqvqv{rgu." ogvjqfu." vgejpkswgu." rtqeguugu." rtqegfwtgu." rtqitcou." qt" 44 eqfgu." yjgvjgt" vcpikdng" qt" kpvcpikdng." cpf" yjgvjgt" qt" jqy" uvqtgf." 45 eqorkngf." qt" ogoqtkcnk|gf" rj{ukecnn{." gngevtqpkecnn{." itcrjkecnn{." rjqvqitcrjkecnn{."qt"kp"ytkvkpi"kh"Î"" 46 " *C+" "vjg"qypgt"vjgtgqh"jcu"vcmgp"tgcuqpcdng"ogcuwtgu"vq"mggr" 47 uwej"kphqtocvkqp"ugetgv="cpf"" 48 " *D+" vjg"kphqtocvkqp"fgtkxgu"kpfgrgpfgpv"geqpqoke"xcnwg."cevwcn" 49 qt" rqvgpvkcn." htqo" pqv" dgkpi" igpgtcnn{" mpqyp" vq." cpf" pqv" dgkpi" tgcfkn{"cuegtvckpcdng"vjtqwij"rtqrgt"ogcpu"d{."vjg"rwdnke0" 4: 4" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 3 of 18 " 3 50" Vjku"Cevkqp0""ÐVjku"CevkqpÑ"ogcpu"Stephanie Spilotro, as Guardian ad litem for Jason 4 Duenas v. C. R. Bard, Inc., et al.." Ecug" Pq0" 4<3;/ex/237:8/THD/PLM." rgpfkpi" kp" vjg" Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu" 5 Fkuvtkev"Eqwtv"Fkuvtkev"qh"Pgxcfc0"" 6 KK0" Kphqtocvkqp"Ykvjkp"vjg"Ueqrg"qh"vjg"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt" 7 60" Vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"ujcnn"iqxgtp"cnn"jctf"eqr{"cpf"gngevtqpke"ocvgtkcnu."vjg"kphqtocvkqp" 8 eqpvckpgf" vjgtgkp." cpf" cnn" qvjgt" kphqtocvkqp" rtqfwegf" qt" fkuenqugf" fwtkpi" Vjku" Cevkqp." kpenwfkpi" cnn" 9 eqrkgu."gzegtrvu."uwooctkgu."qt"eqorkncvkqpu"vjgtgqh."yjgvjgt"tgxgcngf"kp"c"fqewogpv."fgrqukvkqp."qvjgt" : vguvkoqp{." fkueqxgt{" tgurqpug" qt" qvjgtykug." d{" cp{" rctv{" vq" Vjku" Cevkqp" qt" kvu" tgrtgugpvcvkxgu" *vjg" ; ÐUwrrn{kpi"Rctv{Ñ+"vq"cp{"qvjgt"rctv{"qt"rctvkgu"vq"Vjku"Cevkqp"qt"vjgkt"tgrtgugpvcvkxgu"*vjg"ÐTgegkxkpi" 32 Rctv{Ñ+." yjgvjgt" rtqxkfgf" xqnwpvctkn{." rwtuwcpv" vq" hqtocn" fkueqxgt{" rtqegfwtgu." qt" qvjgtykug0" " Vjg" 33 Rctvkgu"citgg"vjcv"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"qh"ocvgtkcnu"cv"vtkcn"yknn"dg"fgvgtokpgf"d{"vjg"Eqwtv"chvgt"c"ugrctcvg" 34 dtkghkpi"cpf1qt"ctiwogpv"rtqeguu0" 35 70" Vjg" ueqrg" qh" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" rtqvgevkqpu" chhqtfgf" wpfgt" vjku" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt" fqgu" pqv" 36 kpenwfg"cp{"vtkcn"gzjkdkvu"qt"vtkcn"vguvkoqp{"gpvgtgf"kpvq"gxkfgpeg"fwtkpi"vjg"ecug"mpqyp"cu"Phillips v. 37 C. R. Bard, Inc., et al.."Pq0"5<34/ex/22566/TEL/YIE"*F0"Pgx0"Lwpg"3."4237+."cu"vq"yjkej"vjcv"Eqwtv" 38 gpvgtgf" cp" Qtfgt" fgp{kpi" DctfÓu" oqvkqp" vq" ugcn" vtkcn" gzjkdkvu" cpf" vtkcn" vtcpuetkrvu0""" 39 Kp"cffkvkqp."vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"fqgu"pqv"crrn{"vq"cp{"fqewogpv"vjcv"ycu"cfokvvgf"kpvq"gxkfgpeg"fwtkpi" 3: vjg"vjtgg"OFN"Dctf"KXE"hknvgt"dgnnygvjgt"ecugu"In Re: Bard IVC Filters Products Liability Litigation, 3; MDL 2641."nkuvgf"kp"Gzjkdkv"4"qh"vjg"OFN"EqwtvÓu"Uwiiguvkqp"qh"Tgocpf"cpf"Vtcpuhgt"Qtfgt."Fmv0"Pq0" 42 Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"qpn{"c"rqtvkqp"qh"c"fqewogpv"ycu"cfokvvgf."qpn{"vjcv"rqtvkqp"qh"vjg"fqewogpv"vjcv"ycu" 43 cfokvvgf"ujcnn"pqv"dg"uwdlgev"vq"rtqvgevkqp0" 44 Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi" vjg" hqtgiqkpi." vjku" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt" fqgu" pqv" cfftguu" qt" cnvgt" yjgvjgt" qt" pqv" 45 Fghgpfcpvu"oc{"ctiwg"vjcv"pqp/eqphkfgpvkcn"fqewogpvu"ujqwnf"uvknn"dg"gpvkvngf"vq"rtqvgevkqp"wpfgt"vjg" 46 yqtm/rtqfwev"fqevtkpg"cpf1qt"vjg"cvvqtpg{/enkgpv"eqoowpkecvkqp"rtkxkngig0" 47 KKK0" Fgukipcvkpi"Kphqtocvkqp"Cu"ÐEqphkfgpvkcnÑ"Rwtuwcpv"vq"Vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt" 48 80" Fqewogpvu0" " Cp{" Uwrrn{kpi" Rctv{" rtqfwekpi" fqewogpvu" vjcv" eqpvckp" kphqtocvkqp" vjcv" 49 oggvu"vjg"fghkpkvkqp"qh"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"cu"rtqxkfgf"kp"Rctcitcrj"3"cpf"4"jgtgkp."oc{"fgukipcvg" 4: vjg" eqpvgpvu" qh" vjg" fqewogpvu" cu" ÐEqphkfgpvkcnÑ" rtkqt" vq" qt" cv"vjg" vkog" qh" rtqfwevkqp" d{" rncekpi" vjg" 5" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 4 of 18 " 3 hqnnqykpi"fgukipcvkqp"qp"vjg"fqewogpvu<"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN"Î"Uwdlgev"vq"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0Ñ""Yjgtg"c" 4 fqewogpv"eqpukuvu"qh"oqtg"vjcp"qpg"rcig."gcej"rcig"qh"vjg"fqewogpv"ujcnn"dg"fgukipcvgf"cu"uwej0""Cp{" 5 fqewogpv" qt" kphqtocvkqp" hqt" yjkej" kv" ku" kortcevkecdng" qt" korquukdng" vq" chhkz" uwej" c" ngigpf" oc{" dg" 6 fgukipcvgf" d{" ytkvvgp" pqvkeg" vq" vjcv" ghhgev" ykvj" c" tgcuqpcdng" fguetkrvkqp" qh" vjg" ocvgtkcn" kp" swguvkqp" 7 kpenwfkpi"c"DCVGU"pwodgt."yjgtg"crrnkecdng0" 8 90" Kh"c"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"ocmgu"fqewogpvu"qt"kphqtocvkqp"cxckncdng"hqt"kpurgevkqp."tcvjgt"vjcp" 9 fgnkxgtkpi" eqrkgu" vq" cpqvjgt" rctv{." pq" ÐEqphkfgpvkcnÑ" fgukipcvkqp" ku" tgswktgf" kp" cfxcpeg" qh" vjg" kpkvkcn" : kpurgevkqp0" " Hqt" vjg" rwtrqugu" qh" kpkvkcn" kpurgevkqp" qpn{." vjg" fqewogpvu" ujcnn" dg" eqpukfgtgf" ; ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN0Ñ""Wrqp"rtqfwevkqp"qh"vjg"kpurgevgf"fqewogpvu."vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"ujcnn"fgukipcvg" 32 yjkej" qh" vjg" rtqfwegf" qt" eqrkgf" fqewogpvu" cpf" ocvgtkcnu" ctg" qt" eqpvckp" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" 33 rwtuwcpv"vq"Rctcitcrj"8"qh"vjku"Qtfgt0"" 34 :0" Ytkvvgp"Fkueqxgt{0""Kh"tgurqpugu"vq"ytkvvgp"fkueqxgt{"eqpvckp"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp" 35 cu" fghkpgf" kp" Rctcitcrj" 3" cpf" 4" qh" vjku" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt." vjg" Tgurqpfkpi" Rctv{" oc{" fgukipcvg" vjg" 36 tgurqpukxg"fqewogpvu"cpf"kphqtocvkqp."cu"ugv"hqtvj"kp"Rctcitcrj"8."ykvj"urgekhke"kpfkecvkqp"qh"vjg"rcig" 37 cpf"nkpg"tghgtgpegu"qh"vjg"ocvgtkcn"vjcv"ku"ÐEqphkfgpvkcnÑ"wpfgt"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"" 38 ;0" Fgrqukvkqpu0" " Vjg" rctvkgu" oc{" fgukipcvg" cu" Eqphkfgpvkcn" cp{" fgrqukvkqp" vtcpuetkrv." qt" 39 rqtvkqpu" vjgtgqh." kp" Vjku" Cevkqp" vjcv" oggvu" vjg" fghkpkvkqp" qh" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" rtqxkfgf" kp" 3: Rctcitcrju" 3" cpf" 4" qh" vjku" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt0" Eqwpugn" hqt" vjg" fgukipcvkpi" rctv{" ujcnn" cfxkug" vjg" eqwtv" 3; tgrqtvgt"cpf"vjg"rctvkgu"qp"vjg"tgeqtf"fwtkpi"vjg"fgrqukvkqp"qt"d{"ngvvgt"pq"ncvgt"vjcp"vjktv{"*52+"ecngpfct" 42 fc{u"chvgt"vjg"eqwtv"tgrqtvgt"rtqxkfgu"vjg"rctvkgu"ykvj"vjg"hkpcn"fgrqukvkqp"vtcpuetkrv0""Kh"cp{"rqtvkqp"qt"cnn" 43 qh"c"fgrqukvkqp"vtcpuetkrv"ku"fgukipcvgf"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp."vjg"eqwtv"tgrqtvgt"ujcnn"ncdgn"vjg"eqxgt" 44 rcig"qh"vjg"qtkikpcn"cpf"qpg"eqr{"qh"vjg"vtcpuetkrv"vq"uvcvg"vjcv"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ku"eqpvckpgf" 45 vjgtgkp."cpf"ujcnn"ncdgn"cu"ÐEqphkfgpvkcnÑ"gcej"rcig"qh"vjg"vtcpuetkrv"cpf1qt"gzjkdkvu"vq"vjg"fgrqukvkqp" 46 vtcpuetkrv"vjcv"eqpuvkvwvg"ÐEqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp0Ñ""Eqphkfgpvkcn"fgukipcvkqpu"qh"vtcpuetkrvu"qt"rqtvkqpu" 47 vjgtgqh."crrn{"vq"cwfkq."xkfgq."qt"qvjgt"tgeqtfkpiu"qh"vjg"vguvkoqp{0"Vjg"eqwtv"tgrqtvgt"ujcnn"engctn{"octm" 48 cp{"vtcpuetkrv"qt"rqtvkqp"vjgtgqh"rtkqt"vq"vjg"gzrktcvkqp"qh"vjg"52/fc{"rgtkqf"cu"ÐFQ"PQV"FKUENQUG"Î" 49 UWDLGEV"VQ"HWTVJGT"EQPHKFGPVKCNKV["TGXKGY0Ñ""Fgrqukvkqp"vtcpuetkrvu"qt"rqtvkqpu"vjgtgqh" 4: yknn"dg"vtgcvgf"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"wpvkn"gzrktcvkqp"qh"vjg"52/fc{"rgtkqf0""Kh"cp{"rctv{"fqgu"pqv" 6" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 5 of 18 " 3 fgukipcvg"vjg"vtcpuetkrv"cu"ÐEqphkfgpvkcnÑ"gkvjgt"cv"vjg"vkog"qh"vjg"fgrqukvkqp"qt"ykvjkp"vjg"52/fc{"rgtkqf" 4 fghkpgf" cdqxg." pq" rqtvkqp" qh" vjg" gpvktg" vtcpuetkrv" yknn" dg" fggogf" ÐEqphkfgpvkcnÑ" cpf" vjg" ÐFQ" PQV" 5 FKUENQUG/"UWDLGEV"VQ"HWTVJGT"EQPHKFGPVKCNKV["TGXKGYÑ"ngigpf"ujcnn"dg"tgoqxgf0""Vjg" 6 52/fc{"rgtkqf"oc{"pqv"dg"gzvgpfgf"ykvjqwv"owvwcn"citggogpv"qh"vjg"rctvkgu0"" 7 320" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" Rtqfwegf" d{" Vjktf" Rctvkgu0" " C" rctv{" kp" Vjku" Cevkqp" oc{" 8 fgukipcvg"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"cp{"fqewogpv."kphqtocvkqp."qt"vguvkoqp{"rtqfwegf"qt"uwrrnkgf"d{"cp{"rgtuqp" 9 qt"gpvkv{"pqv"c"rctv{"vq"Vjku"Cevkqp."vjcv"eqpuvkvwvgu"qt"oggvu"vjg"fghkpkvkqp"qh"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp" : cu" fghkpgf" kp" Rctcitcrju" 3" cpf" 4" qh" vjku" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt0" " Vjg" rctv{" enckokpi" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" ujcnn" ; fgukipcvg"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"cu"uwej"ykvjkp"vjktv{"*52+"fc{u"qh"kvu"tgegkrv"qh"uwej"kphqtocvkqp0""Cp{"rctv{" 32 tgegkxkpi"kphqtocvkqp"htqo"c"vjktf"rctv{"ujcnn"vtgcv"uwej"kphqtocvkqp"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"fwtkpi" 33 vjku"vjktv{"*52+"fc{"rgtkqf"yjkng"cnn"rctvkgu"jcxg"cp"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"tgxkgy"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"cpf"vq"fgvgtokpg" 34 yjgvjgt" kv" ujqwnf" dg" fgukipcvgf" cu" eqphkfgpvkcn0" " Cp{" rctv{" fgukipcvkpi" vjktf" rctv{" kphqtocvkqp" cu" 35 Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ujcnn"jcxg"vjg"ucog"tkijvu."fwvkgu."cpf"qdnkicvkqpu."cu"c"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"wpfgt" 36 vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"" 37 330" Rwdnken{" Cxckncdng" Kphqtocvkqp0" " Vjg" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" tguvtkevkqpu" cpf" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" 38 qdnkicvkqpu"ugv"hqtvj"jgtgkp"ujcnn"pqv"crrn{"vq"kphqtocvkqp"vjcv"ku"cv"vjg"vkog"qh"rtqfwevkqp"qt"fkuenquwtg." 39 qt"uwdugswgpvn{"dgeqogu."vjtqwij"pq"ytqpihwn"cev"qp"vjg"rctv"qh"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{."igpgtcnn{"cxckncdng" 3: vq" vjg" rwdnke" vjtqwij" rwdnkecvkqp" qt" qvjgtykug0" " Vjku" kpenwfgu" kphqtocvkqp" rwdnkujgf" fwtkpi" rwdnke" 3; jgctkpiu"cpf"vtkcnu."kh"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"fqgu"pqv"oqxg"vq"ugcn"qt"crrgcn"cp{"qtfgt"fgp{kpi"uwej"oqvkqp" 42 vq" ugcn" ykvjkp" vjg" vkog" rgtokvvgf" wpfgt" vjg" crrnkecdng" twngu0" " Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi" vjg" hqtgiqkpi." vjku" 43 Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"fqgu"pqv"cfftguu"qt"cnvgt"yjgvjgt"qt"pqv"Fghgpfcpvu"oc{"ctiwg"vjcv"pqp/eqphkfgpvkcn" 44 fqewogpvu"ujqwnf"uvknn"dg"gpvkvngf"vq"rtqvgevkqp"wpfgt"vjg"yqtm/rtqfwev"fqevtkpg"cpf1qt"vjg"cvvqtpg{/enkgpv" 45 eqoowpkecvkqp"rtkxkngig0" 46 KX0""" Nkokvcvkqpu"qp"Wug"qh"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"" 47 340" Cnn"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ujcnn"dg"wugf"hqt"vjg"rwtrqug"qh"vjku"ncyuwkv"qpn{."cpf"gzegrv" 48 cu"rgtokvvgf"d{"vjku"Qtfgt."vjg"rctvkgu"cpf"vjgkt"tgurgevkxg"cvvqtpg{u."cu"ygnn"cu"gzrgtvu"qt"eqpuwnvcpvu." 49 ujcnn"pqv"ikxg."ujqy."qt"qvjgtykug"fkxwnig"qt"fkuenqug"vjg"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp."qt"cp{"eqrkgu."rtkpvu." 4: pgicvkxgu"qt"uwooctkgu"vjgtgqh"vq"cp{"rgtuqp"qt"gpvkv{0"Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi"vjg"hqtgiqkpi"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku" 7" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 6 of 18 " 3 rctcitcrj."pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"Qtfgt"ujcnn"rtgxgpv"vjg"wug"qh"cp{"qh"vjg"fqewogpvu"qt"gngevtqpkecnn{"uvqtgf" 4 kphqtocvkqp"*ÐGUKÑ+"rtqfwegf"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"kp"qvjgt"cevkqpu"dtqwijv"d{"vjg"rnckpvkhhÓu" 5 eqwpugn."uq"nqpi"cu"c"eqorctcdng"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"ku"gpvgtgf"kp"vjqug"qvjgt"cevkqpu0"" 6 350" Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"ujcnn"dg"vtgcvgf"d{"vjg"rctvkgu." 7 vjgkt"eqwpugn."cpf"cp{"qvjgt"ukipcvqt{"vq"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"cu"dgkpi"eqphkfgpvkcn"cpf"rtkxcvg0""Cp{" 8 eqr{"qh"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ujcnn"jcxg"vjg"ucog"uvcvwu"cu"vjg"qtkikpcn0""Vjg"fkuenquwtg"cpf"wug"qh" 9 Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" ujcnn" dg" eqphkpgf" vq" vjg" rgtokuukdng" fkuenquwtgu" cpf" wugu" ugv" hqtvj" kp" vjku" : Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt."cpf"pq"qpg"ujcnn"fkuenqug"qt"wug"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"kp"c"ocppgt"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj" ; vjg"vgtou"cpf"vjg"kpvgpv"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"" 32 360" Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"oc{"dg"fkuenqugf"qpn{"vq"vjg"hqnnqykpi"rgtuqpu"cpf"ujcnn"dg"wugf" 33 uqngn{"hqt"vjg"nkvkicvkqp"qh"Vjku"Cevkqp"cpf"oc{"pqv"dg"fkuenqugf"vq" cp{qpg"pqv"cwvjqtk|gf"wpfgt"vjku" 34 rctcitcrj<" 35 c0" 36 37 cevkxgn{"gpicigf"kp."qt"cevkxgn{"qxgtuggkpi"Vjku"Cevkqp=" d0" 38 39 Eqwpugn"qh"tgeqtf."vjgkt"cuuqekcvgf"cvvqtpg{u."cpf"uwrrqtv"uvchh."kpenwfkpi"rctcngicn" cpf"ugetgvctkcn"rgtuqppgn"yjq"ctg"yqtmkpi"qp"Vjku"Cevkqp=" e0" 3: 3; Rctvkgu." vjgkt" tgrtgugpvcvkxgu." kp/jqwug" eqwpugn" cpf" tgiwnct" gornq{ggu" yjq" ctg" Gzrgtvu"cpf"eqpuwnvcpvu"*kpenwfkpi"vjgkt"gornq{ggu1eqpvtcevqtu+"yjq"ctg"eqpuwnvgf" qt"tgvckpgf"d{"c"rctv{"vq"cuukuv"kp"vjg"nkvkicvkqp"qh"Vjku"Cevkqp=" f0" Vjktf/rctv{"eqpvtcevqtu"cpf"vjgkt"gornq{ggu"yjq"ctg"eqpuwnvgf"qt"tgvckpgf"d{"qpg" 42 qt"oqtg"rctvkgu"vq"rtqxkfg"nkvkicvkqp/uwrrqtv"qt"eqr{"ugtxkegu"kp"eqppgevkqp"ykvj" 43 vjg"nkvkicvkqp"qh"Vjku"Cevkqp" 44 g0" Ykvpguugu"qt"rtqurgevkxg"ykvpguugu"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp=" 45 h0" Eqwtv"tgrqtvgtu."xkfgqitcrjgtu."cpf"qvjgt"rgtuqpu"kpxqnxgf"kp"tgeqtfkpi"fgrqukvkqp" 46 47 vguvkoqp{"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp=" i0" 48 49 Vjg" Eqwtv" cpf" kvu" rgtuqppgn." kpenwfkpi" cp{" ogfkcvqtu" cpf1qt" urgekcn" ocuvgtu" crrqkpvgf"d{"vjg"Eqwtv."qt"kh"cp"crrgcn."vjg"eqwtv"ykvj"crrgnncvg"lwtkufkevkqp="cpf" j0" Lwtqtu"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp0" 4: 8" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 7 of 18 " 3 370" Rtkqt" vq" vjg" fkuenquwtg" qh" cp{" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" vq" cp{" rgtuqp" kfgpvkhkgf" kp" 4 Rctcitcrj"36"cdqxg"*gzegrv"vjg"Eqwtv"cpf"kvu"rgtuqppgn"cpf"lwtqtu"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp+."vjg"fkuenqukpi"rctv{" 5 yknn"rtqxkfg"gcej"rqvgpvkcn"tgekrkgpv"qh"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ykvj"c"eqr{"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt." 6 yjkej"uckf"tgekrkgpv"ujcnn"tgcf0""Wrqp"tgcfkpi"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt."uwej"rgtuqp"ujcnn"ukip"cp"Citggogpv" 7 vq" Ockpvckp" Eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" *ÐEqphkfgpvkcnkv{" CitggogpvÑ+." cvvcejgf" vq" vjku" Qtfgt" cu" Gzjkdkv" C." 8 cempqyngfikpi"vjcv"jg"qt"ujg"jcu"tgcf"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"cpf"ujcnn"cdkfg"d{"kvu"vgtou0""Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi" 9 vjg"hqtgiqkpi"rtqxkukqp."Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"oc{"dg"fkuenqugf"vq"c"ykvpguu"yjq"yknn"pqv"ukip"cp" : Eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" Citggogpv" kp" c" fgrqukvkqp" cv" yjkej" vjg" rctv{" yjq" jcu" fgukipcvgf" vjg" Eqphkfgpvkcn" ; Kphqtocvkqp"ku"tgrtgugpvgf"qt"jcu"dggp"ikxgp"pqvkeg"vjcv"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"rtqfwegf"d{"vjg"rctv{" 32 oc{" dg" wugf0" " Vjgug" Eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" Citggogpvu" ctg" uvtkevn{" eqphkfgpvkcn" cpf" ujcnn" dg" ockpvckpgf" d{" 33 eqwpugn"hqt"gcej"rctv{"cpf"qpn{"ykvj"iqqf"ecwug"ujqyp"cpf"ugrctcvg"eqwtv"qtfgt"yknn"vjg"Eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" 34 Citggogpvu" dg" fkuenqugf" vq" vjg" qrrqukpi" ukfg0" " Rgtuqpu" yjq" eqog" kpvq" eqpvcev" ykvj" Eqphkfgpvkcn" 35 Kphqtocvkqp"hqt"engtkecn"qt"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"rwtrqugu."cpf"yjq"fq"pqv"tgvckp"eqrkgu"qt"gzvtcevu"vjgtgqh."ctg" 36 pqv"tgswktgf"vq"gzgewvg"Eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"Citggogpvu"dwv"owuv"eqorn{"ykvj"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg" 37 Qtfgt0"" 38 380" Cnn"rgtuqpu"tgegkxkpi"qt"ikxgp"ceeguu"vq"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"kp"ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj"vjg" 39 vgtou"qh"vjku"Qtfgt"eqpugpv"vq"vjg"eqpvkpwkpi"lwtkufkevkqp"qh"vjku"Eqwtv"hqt"vjg"rwtrqugu"qh"gphqtekpi"vjku" 3: Qtfgt"cpf"tgogf{kpi"cp{"xkqncvkqpu"vjgtgqh0" 3; 390" Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ujcnn"pqv"dg"rncegf"qt"fgrqukvgf"kp"cp{"uqtv"qh"fcvc"dcpm"vjcv"ku" 42 ocfg" cxckncdng" hqt" kpfkuetkokpcvg" qt" igpgtcn" ektewncvkqp" vq" ncy{gtu." nkvkicpvu." eqpuwnvcpvu." gzrgtv" 43 ykvpguugu"qt"cp{"qvjgt"rgtuqpu"pqv"yqtmkpi"qp"Vjku"Cevkqp"cpf"pqv"ukipcvqtkgu"vq"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"" 44 Vjku"rctcitcrj"cpf"vjg"qvjgt"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Qtfgt"ujcnn"pqv"crrn{"vq"ocvgtkcnu"yjkej."kh"ejcnngpigf"d{" 45 cp{"rctv{."vjg"Eqwtv"twngu"ctg"pqv"gpvkvngf"vq"rtqvgevkqp0""Vjku"rctcitcrj"fqgu"pqv"nkokv"qt"tguvtkev"kp"cp{" 46 yc{"vjg"ocppgt"kp"yjkej"c"rctv{"oc{"uvqtg"cpf"ocmg"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"cxckncdng"vq"vjg"cvvqtpg{u." 47 uwrrqtv"uvchh."gzrgtvu."cpf"cp{"qvjgt"rgtuqpu"qt"gpvkvkgu"yqtmkpi"qp"Vjku"Cevkqp."rtqxkfgf"vjg"igpgtcn" 48 vgtou"qh"vjku"Qtfgt"ctg"hqnnqygf0"" 49 3:0" Vjg"rctvkgu"cpf"vjgkt"eqwpugn"cu"ygnn"cu"vjgkt"vgejpkecn"eqpuwnvcpvu"cpf"gzrgtvu"ujcnn"cnuq" 4: pqv" ugnn." qhhgt." cfxgtvkug." rwdnkek|g" pqt" rtqxkfg" wpfgt" cp{" eqpfkvkqp" cp{" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" 9" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 8 of 18 " 3 rtqfwegf"d{"cp{"qvjgt"rctv{"vq"cp{"eqorgvkvqt"qh"cp{"fghgpfcpv"qt"vq"cp{"gornq{gg"qt"cp{"eqorgvkvqt" 4 *kttgurgevkxg"qh"yjgvjgt"vjg{"ctg"tgvckpgf"cu"cp"gzrgtv"d{"c"rctv{"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp+0" 5 3;0" Kp" vjg" gxgpv" vjcv" gkvjgt" qh" vjg" rctvkgu" ku" ugtxgf" d{" c" pqp/rctv{" ykvj" c" uwdrqgpc" hqt" 6 Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"vjcv"ycu"qtkikpcnn{"rtqxkfgf"cpf"enckogf"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"d{"cpqvjgt"rctv{."vjg" 7 Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"yknn"ikxg"pqvkeg"vq"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{."yjgtg"tgcuqpcdn{"rquukdng."pq"nguu"vjcp"vgp"*32+" 8 dwukpguu"fc{u"rtkqt"vq"fkuenquwtg"d{"rtqxkfkpi"c"eqr{"qh"vjg"uwdrqgpc."vq"cnnqy"c"tgcuqpcdng"qrrqtvwpkv{" 9 hqt"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"vq"qdlgev"vq"uwej"rtqfwevkqp"dghqtg"cp{"rtqfwevkqp"vcmgu"rnceg0"" : 420" Kh"c"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"ngctpu"qh"cp{"wpcwvjqtk|gf"fkuenquwtg"qh"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp."kv" ; ujcnn"vcmg"tgcuqpcdng"ghhqtvu"vq"koogfkcvgn{"*c+"kphqto"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"kp"ytkvkpi"qh"uwej"fkuenquwtg." 32 kpenwfkpi"vq"yjqo"vjg"ocvgtkcn"ycu"fkuenqugf="*d+"ocmg"c"tgcuqpcdng"ghhqtv"vq"tgvtkgxg"cnn"eqrkgu"qh"vjg" 33 Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" qpn{" vq" vjg" gzvgpv" vjg" Tgegkxkpi" Rctv{" jcu" eqpvtqn" qxgt" vjg" wpcwvjqtk|gf" 34 fkuenqugf"fqewogpvu="*e+"cpf"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"rctv{"jcu"eqpvtqn"qxgt"vjg"rgtuqp"qt"rgtuqpu"vq" 35 yjqo"wpcwvjqtk|gf"fkuenquwtgu"ygtg"ocfg."kphqto"vjg"rgtuqpu"qh"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"" 36 X0""" Ejcpigu"kp"cpf"Qdlgevkqpu"vq"Fgukipcvkqp"qh"Kphqtocvkqp" 37 430" ÐEncydcemÑ"qh"Kttgngxcpv"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp0""Kh"c"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"rtqfwegu" 38 cp{"fqewogpv"eqpvckpkpi"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"vjcv"vjg{"kfgpvkh{"vq"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"cu"kttgngxcpv." 39 vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"oc{"pqvkh{"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"qh"vjg"Kttgngxcpv"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"kp"ytkvkpi0"" 3: Kh"c"rqtvkqp"qh"vjg"fqewogpv"eqpvckpu"kphqtocvkqp"tgngxcpv"vq"Vjku"Cevkqp."vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"ujcnn"cnuq" 3; uwrrn{"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"ykvj"c"pgy"eqr{"qh"vjg"fqewogpv"yjkej"ujcnn"dg"uwduvkvwvgf"hqt"vjg"gctnkgt" 42 rtqfwegf"fqewogpv0"Wrqp"tgegkrv"qh"vjg"uwduvkvwvg"fqewogpv."vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"ujcnn"rtqorvn{"tgvwtp" 43 qt" fguvtq{" vjg" gctnkgt" rtqfwegf" fqewogpv0" " Wrqp" tgegkrv" qh" vjg"Uwrrn{kpi" Rctv{Óu" ytkvvgp" pqvkeg." vjg" 44 Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"ujcnn."ykvjkp"c"tgcuqpcdng"vkog."pqv"gzeggf"vygpv{"*42+"fc{u."*c+"vtgcv"uwej"ocvgtkcn"kp" 45 ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj"vjku"Qtfgt="*d+"vcmg"tgcuqpcdng"uvgru"vq"pqvkh{"cp{"rgtuqp"vq"yjqo"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{" 46 fkuenqugf"uwej"kphqtocvkqp"qh"vjg"pgy"eqphkfgpvkcn"fgukipcvkqp="*e+"vcmg"tgcuqpcdng"uvgru"vq"rtqewtg"vjg" 47 tgvwtp"qh"cnn"eqrkgu"qh"uwej"ocvgtkcn"htqo"cp{"uwej"rgtuqpu"yjq"ctg"pqv"gpvkvngf"vq"tgegkrv"qh"Eqphkfgpvkcn" 48 Kphqtocvkqp"wpfgt"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt="*f+"tgswguv"kp"ytkvkpi"vjcv"uwej"rgtuqp"rtqewtg"vjg" 49 tgvwtp"qh"uwej"kphqtocvkqp"htqo"cp{"rgtuqp"vq"yjqo"uwej"rgtuqp"oc{"jcxg"fkuenqugf"vjg"kphqtocvkqp0" 4: 1"1"1" :" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 9 of 18 " 3 440" Ejcnngpigu" vq" Fgukipcvkqp" qh" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp0" " C" Tgegkxkpi" Rctv{" oc{" 4 ejcnngpig"c"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{Óu"fgukipcvkqp"qt"tg/fgukipcvkqp"d{"pqvkh{kpi"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"kp"ytkvkpi" 5 vjcv" vjg" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" fgukipcvkqp" fqgu" pqv" oggv" vjg" fghkpkvkqp" qh" ÐEqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp0Ñ" " Vjg" 6 fgukipcvkqp" d{" cp{" rctv{" qh" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" tckugu" pq" rtguworvkqp" vjcv" vjg" kphqtocvkqp" qt" 7 fqewogpvu"ctg"gpvkvngf"wpfgt"vjg"ncy"vq"rtqvgevkqp0""Kh"cp{"rctv{"eqpvgpfu."kp"ytkvkpi."vjcv"cp{"fqewogpv." 8 ocvgtkcn."GUK."qt"qvjgt"vjkpi"jcu"dggp"gttqpgqwun{"fgukipcvgf"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp."vjg"rctv{"yjq" 9 fgukipcvgf"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ujcnn"kpkvkcvg"c"oggv"cpf"eqphgt"ykvjkp"vgp"*32+" : fc{u"ykvj"vjg"qrrqukpi"rctv{"cpf"vjg"rctvkgu"ujcnn"ocmg"c"iqqf"hckvj"ghhqtv"vq"tguqnxg"kuuwgu"tgncvkpi"vq" ; uwej"fgukipcvkqpu0""Chvgt"vjg"oggv"cpf"eqphgt."vjg"rctv{"yjq"fgukipcvgf"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn" 32 Kphqtocvkqp"ujcnn"hkng"c"oqvkqp"ykvj"vjg"Eqwtv"ykvjkp"vjktv{"*52+"fc{u"qh"tgegkxkpi"uwej"ytkvvgp"pqvkhkecvkqp" 33 guvcdnkujkpi"vjcv"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"ku"gpvkvngf"vq"rtqvgevkqp"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"wpfgt"vjg"ncy0""Kh" 34 vjg" fgukipcvkpi" rctv{" hcknu" vq" vkogn{" hkng" uwej" c" oqvkqp" ykvjkp" vjg" cnnqvvgf" vjktv{" *52+" fc{" rgtkqf." vjg" 35 fqewogpv."GUK."ocvgtkcn."qt"qvjgt"vjkpi."yjkej"ku"fgukipcvgf"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp."ujcnn"hqtvjykvj" 36 dg" rtqfwegf" cpf" dg" fggogf" pqv" vq" dg" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp0" " Cp{" kphqtocvkqp" qt" vjkpi" dgkpi" 37 ejcnngpigf" cu" kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{" fgukipcvgf" cu" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" ujcnn" pqpgvjgnguu" dg" vtgcvgf" cu" 38 Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"wpnguu"cpf"wpvkn"gkvjgt"*c+"vjg"fgukipcvkpi"rctv{"ikxgu"ytkvvgp"rgtokuukqp"vq"fq" 39 qvjgtykug." *d+" vjg" fgukipcvkpi" rctv{" hcknu" vq" hkng" c" oqvkqp" guvcdnkujkpi" vjcv" vjg" ejcnngpigf" ocvgtkcn" ku" 3: uwdlgev"vq"rtqvgevkqp"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"wpfgt"vjg"ncy"ykvjkp"vjg"vjktv{"*52+"fc{"vkog"rgtkqf."qt" 3; *e+"vjg"Eqwtv"twngu"vjcv"vjg"fqewogpv."ocvgtkcn."GUK."qt"qvjgt"vjkpi"ujcnn"pqv"dg"vtgcvgf"cu"eqphkfgpvkcn0" 42 Ujqwnf"vjg"Eqwtv"twng"vjcv"cp{"kvgo"fgukipcvgf"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ku"pqv"gpvkvngf"vq"rtqvgevkqp" 43 wpfgt" vjg" ncy." vjg" fgukipcvkpi" rctv{" ujcnn." ykvjkp" hqwtvggp" *36+" fc{u" chvgt" cnn" crrgcnu" ctg" gzjcwuvgf." 44 rtqxkfg"vjg"rctv{"ejcnngpikpi"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"fgukipcvkqp"ykvj"eqrkgu"qh"gcej"kvgo"htgg"qh"cp{"ncpiwcig" 45 kpfkecvkpi"vjcv"vjg"kvgo"ku"uwdlgev"vq"c"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"C"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"ujcnn"qpn{"ejcnngpig"fqewogpvu" 46 wpfgt"vjku"Rctcitcrj"vjcv"vjg{"jcxg"c"iqqf"hckvj"dcuku"hqt"wukpi"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp0" 47 450" Pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"ujcnn"dg"fggogf"vq"ujkhv"vjg"dwtfgp"qh"rtqqh"vq"vjg"rctv{" 48 ejcnngpikpi"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcn"fgukipcvkqp"ykvj"tgictf"vq"yjgvjgt"vjg"ocvgtkcnu"rtqfwegf"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjku" 49 Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"ctg"gpvkvngf"vq"rtqvgevkqp"wpfgt"vjg"ncy"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp0" 4: 1"1"1" ;" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 10 of 18 " 3 XK0"""" Hknkpi"Wpfgt"Ugcn" 4 issued 460" Yjgtg" c" Rctv{" Hkngu" Fqewogpvu" cpf" Eqpvgpfu" vjg" Fqewogpvu" Ujqwnf" dg" Mgrv" See order concurrently herewith 5 Ugcngf0"Yjgtg"c"rctv{"kpvgpfu"vq"hkng"fqewogpvu"vjcv"eqpvckp"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ykvj"vjg"Eqwtv." 6 uckf" rctv{" owuv" hkng" c" oqvkqp" hqt" cp" qtfgt" ugcnkpi" vjg" fqewogpvu" eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" crrnkecdng" ncy" cpf" 7 eqorn{"ykvj"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"HTER"704"cpf"NT"KE"8/3"qh"vjg"nqecn"twngu0""C"eqr{"qh"vjg"oqvkqp"owuv"dg" 8 ugtxgf"qp"cnn"rctvkgu"vjcv"jcxg"crrgctgf"kp"vjg"ecug0" 9 470" Yjgtg"c"Rctv{"Hkngu"Fqewogpvu"Enckogf"cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"d{"Cpqvjgt"Rctv{0""C"rctv{" : vjcv"hkngu"qt"kpvgpfu"vq"hkng"ykvj"vjg"Eqwtv"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"rtqfwegf"d{"cpqvjgt"rctv{"dwv"fqgu" ; pqv"kpvgpf"vq"tgswguv"vq"jcxg"vjg"tgeqtfu"ugcngf."owuv"fq"vjg"hqnnqykpi<" 32 c0" 33 34 Ocmg"cttcpigogpvu"eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"HTER"704"cpf"NT"KE"8/3"qh"vjg"nqecn"twngu"vq" nqfig"vjg"fqewogpvu"wpfgt"ugcn0" d0" Hkng"tgfcevgf"eqrkgu"qh"vjg"fqewogpvu"*kh"crrtqrtkcvg+"uq"vjcv"vjg{"fq"pqv"fkuenqug" 35 vjg" eqpvgpvu" qh" vjg" tgeqtfu" vjcv" ctg" uwdlgev" vq" vjg" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" citggogpv" qt" 36 rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt=" 37 e0" Ugtxg"c"eqr{"qh"vjg"oqvkqp"qp"cnn"rctvkgu"vjcv"jcxg"crrgctgf"kp"vjg"ecug="cpf" 38 f0" Ikxg"ytkvvgp"pqvkeg"vq"vjg"rctv{"vjcv"rtqfwegf"vjg"fqewogpvu"vjcv"vjg"fqewogpvu" 39 yknn"dg"rncegf"kp"vjg"rwdnke"eqwtv"hkng"wpnguu"vjg"rctv{"hkngu"c"vkogn{"oqvkqp"vq"ugcn" 3: tgeqtfu0" 3; Kh"vjg"rctv{"vjcv"rtqfwegf"vjg"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"cpf"ycu"ugtxgf"ykvj"vjg"cdqxgogpvkqpgf" 42 pqvkeg"hcknu"vq"hkng"c"oqvkqp"vq"ugcn"vjg"tgeqtfu"ykvjkp"hkhvggp"*37+"fc{u"qh"tgegkrv"qh"vjg"pqvkeg"tghgtgpegf" 43 kp"Uwdrctcitcrj"470f0"qt"vq"qdvckp"c"eqwtv"qtfgt"gzvgpfkpi"vjg"vkog"vq"hkng"uwej"oqvkqp."vjg"engtm"owuv" 44 rtqorvn{" tgoqxg" cnn" vjg" fqewogpvu" hkngf" wpfgt" ugcn" rwtuwcpv" vq" vjku" rtqxkukqp" htqo" vjg" gpxgnqrg" qt" 45 eqpvckpgt" yjgtg" vjg{" ctg" nqecvgf" cpf" rnceg" vjgo" kp" vjg" rwdnke" hkng0" Kh" vjg" rctv{" hkngu" c" oqvkqp" qt" cp" 46 crrnkecvkqp"vq"ugcn"ykvjkp"hkhvggp"*37+"fc{u"qh"tgegkrv"qh"vjg"pqvkeg"tghgtgpegf"kp"Uwdrctcitcrj"470f0"fc{u" 47 qt"uwej"ncvgt"vkog"cu"vjg"Eqwtv"jcu"qtfgtgf."vjgug"fqewogpvu"ctg"vq"tgockp"eqpfkvkqpcnn{"wpfgt"ugcn"wpvkn" 48 vjg"Eqwtv"twngu"qp"vjg"oqvkqp"qt"crrnkecvkqp"cpf"vjgtgchvgt"ctg"vq"dg"hkngf"cu"qtfgtgf"d{"vjg"Eqwtv0" 49 1"1"1" 4: 1"1"1" 32" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 11 of 18 " 3 Vjku"ugevkqp"ujcnn"pqv"crrn{"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"fqewogpvu"cfokvvgf"kpvq"gxkfgpeg"cu"gzjkdkvu"cv"vjg" 4 vtkcn"qh"vjku"ocvvgt0"Vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"tgugtxgu"vjg"tkijv."jqygxgt."vq"rgvkvkqp"vjg"Eqwtv"hqt"rtqvgevkqp" 5 ykvj"tgurgev"vq"uwej"fqewogpvu"cfokvvgf"kpvq"gxkfgpeg"cu"gzjkdkvu"cv"vtkcn0" 6 "XKK0" Okuegnncpgqwu"Rtqxkukqpu""" 7 480" Cogpfkpi"qt"Oqfkh{kpi"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0""D{"ytkvvgp"citggogpv"qh"vjg"rctvkgu."qt"wrqp" 8 oqvkqp"cpf"qtfgt"qh"vjg"Eqwtv."vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"oc{"dg"cogpfgf"qt"oqfkhkgf0""Vjku" 9 Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"ujcnn"eqpvkpwg"kp"hqteg"wpvkn"cogpfgf"qt"oqfkhkgf"d{"eqpugpv"qt"citggogpv"qh"vjg"rctvkgu" : qt"d{"qtfgt"qh"vjg"Eqwtv."cpf"ujcnn"uwtxkxg"cp{"hkpcn"lwfiogpv"qt"ugvvngogpv"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp."kpenwfkpi"dwv" ; pqv"nkokvgf"vq"cp{"hkpcn"cflwfkecvkqp"qh"cp{"crrgcnu"rgvkvkqpu"hqt"gzvtcqtfkpct{"ytkvu."wpnguu"qvjgtykug" 32 xcecvgf" qt" oqfkhkgf" d{" vjg" Eqwtv0" " Vjg" Eqwtv" ujcnn" jcxg" eqpvkpwkpi" lwtkufkevkqp" qxgt" vjg" vgtou" cpf" 33 rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"" 34 490" Chvgt"Hkpcn"Cflwfkecvkqp0""Wrqp"ytkvvgp"fgocpf"d{"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"ocfg"ykvjkp" 35 vjktv{"*52+"fc{u"chvgt"hkpcn"cflwfkecvkqp"qh"Vjku"Cevkqp."kpenwfkpi"dwv"pqv"nkokvgf"vq."cp{"hkpcn"cflwfkecvkqp" 36 qh"cp{"crrgcnu"cpf"rgvkvkqpu"hqt"gzvtcqtfkpct{"ytkvu."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"ujcnn"cuugodng"cpf"tgvwtp"cnn" 37 Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"vq"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"qt."cnvgtpcvkxgn{."ujcnn"fguvtq{"cnn"uwej"ocvgtkcn"cv"vjg" 38 Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{Óu"gzrgpug0""Vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"ujcnn"xgtkh{"vjg"eqorngvg"fguvtwevkqp"qt"tgvwtp"vq"vjg" 39 Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"cnn"uwej"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"d{"gzgewvkpi"cpf"ocknkpi"vq"eqwpugn"hqt"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi" 3: Rctv{" cp" Cempqyngfiogpv" kp" vjg" hqto" cvvcejgf" jgtgvq" cu"Gzjkdkv" D0" " C" eqr{" qh" gcej" uwej" gzgewvgf" 3; Cempqyngfiogpv"ujcnn"dg"ockpvckpgf"d{"eqwpugn"hqt"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"cpf"eqwpugn"hqt"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi" 42 Rctv{0""Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi"vjg"hqtgiqkpi"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"rctcitcrj."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"oc{"ockpvckp"kvu" 43 rtkxkngigf"eqoowpkecvkqpu."yqtm"rtqfwev."Eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"Citggogpvu"cpf"Cempqyngfiogpvu"rwtuwcpv" 44 vq"vjg"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt."ocvgtkcnu"tgswktgf"vq"dg"tgvckpgf"rwtuwcpv"vq"crrnkecdng"ncy."cpf"cnn"eqwtv/hkngf" 45 fqewogpvu"gxgp"vjqwij"vjg{"eqpvckp"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp."dwv"uwej"ocvgtkcnu"ujcnn"tgockp"uwdlgev" 46 vq"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0""Vjku"rtqxkukqp"oc{"pqv"dg"kpxqmgf"yjkng"vjg"rnckpvkhhÓu"cvvqtpg{u" 47 qh"tgeqtf"jcxg"cevkxg"rgpfkpi"ecugu"tgncvkpi"vq"KXE"Hknvgtu"ocpwhcevwtgf"d{"E0"T0"Dctf."Kpe0"cpf1qt"Dctf" 48 Rgtkrjgtcn"Xcuewnct."Kpe0"" 49 4:0" Vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"fq"pqv"rtgenwfg."nkokv."tguvtkev."qt"qvjgtykug"crrn{"vq" 4: vjg" wug" qh" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp"cv" vtkcn0" " Vjg" wug" qh" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" fwtkpi" vtkcn"yknn" dg" 33" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 12 of 18 " 3 cfftguugf"kp"c"ncvgt"citggogpv"dgvyggp"vjg"rctvkgu."qt."kh"vjg{"ecppqv"tgcej"cp"citggogpv."d{"hwtvjgt"qtfgt" 4 qh"vjg"Eqwtv0"" 5 4;0" Pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"Qtfgt"ujcnn"dg"fggogf"c"yckxgt"qh"cp{"rctvkguÓ"tkijv"vq"qrrqug"cp{"oqvkqp" 6 d{"cp{"qvjgt"rctv{"hqt"c"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"qt"vq"qrrqug"cp{"qdlgevkqp"vq"vjg"fkuenquwtg"qh"cp{"kphqtocvkqp" 7 qt"fqewogpvu"qp"cp{"ngicn"itqwpfu."kpenwfkpi."dwv"pqv"nkokvgf"vq."vjg"itqwpfu"vjcv"vjg"rctv{"uggmkpi"vjg" 8 rtqvgevkxg" qtfgt" jcu" pgkvjgt" vkogn{" pqt" cfgswcvgn{" qdlgevgf" vq" fkuenquwtg" qh" uwej" fqewogpvu" cpf" 9 kphqtocvkqp"qt"oqxgf"hqt"c"rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt0"" : 520" Vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"fqgu"pqv"tgnkgxg"cp{"rctv{"qh"kvu"qdnkicvkqpu"vq"tgurqpf"vq"qvjgtykug" ; rtqrgt"fkueqxgt{"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp0""Pqvjkpi"eqpvckpgf"kp"vjku"Qtfgt."qt"cp{"cevkqp"vcmgp"rwtuwcpv"vq"kv"ujcnn" 32 yckxg"qt"korckt"cp{"rctv{Óu"tkijv"vq"cuugtv"enckou"qh"rtkxkngig"qt"yqtm"rtqfwev"rtqvgevkqp."qt"vjg"tkijv"qh" 33 cp{"rctv{"vq"qdlgev"vq"vjg"tgngxcpe{"qh"cfokuukdknkv{"qh"fqewogpvu"qt"kphqtocvkqp"uqwijv"qt"rtqfwegf"kpvq" 34 cuugtv"qdlgevkqpu"vq"tgswguvgf"fkueqxgt{"qp"itqwpfu"qvjgt"vjcp"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp0""Vjku"Rtqvgevkxg" 35 Qtfgt"cnuq"ujcnn"pqv"chhgev"qt"etgcvg"cp{"rtguworvkqp"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg"tkijv"qh"cp{"rctv{"htqo"uggmkpi" 36 qt"qdvckpkpi"cffkvkqpcn"rtqvgevkqp"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"cp{"fqewogpvu."ocvgtkcnu."qt"kphqtocvkqp"yjgtg"cnnqygf" 37 d{"ncy0" 38 530" Gngevtqpkecnn{" Uvqtgf" Kphqtocvkqp" *ÐGUKÑ+" Fqewogpv" Rtqfwevkqp" Tgxkgy" Rtqeguu0""" 39 Vq"gzrgfkvg"fqewogpv"rtqfwevkqp"qh"GUK"htqo"Fghgpfcpvu."vjg"rctvkgu."vjtqwij"vjgkt"tgurgevkxg"eqwpugn." 3: jcxg"citggf"vq"c"rtkoctkn{"Ðpq/g{gu/qpÑ"fqewogpv"rtqfwevkqp"cu"vq"tgngxcpe{"yjkng"uvknn"rgthqtokpi"c" 3; rtkxkngig"tgxkgy"hqt"GUK"yjkej"Fghgpfcpvu"yknn"dg"rtqfwekpi"uwdugswgpv"vq"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"Vjg" 42 Rctvkgu"tgeqipk|g"vjcv"c"uwduvcpvkcn"rqtvkqp"qh"vjg"fqewogpvu"vjcv"yknn"dg"rtqfwegf"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp"ygtg" 43 kpkvkcnn{"rtqfwegf"kp"In re: Bard IVC Filters Products Liability Litigation, OFN"Pq0"4863."kp"vjg"Wpkvgf" 44 Uvcvgu" Fkuvtkev" Eqwtv" Fkuvtkev" qh" Ctk|qpc" *ÐKXE" Hknvgt" OFNÑ+." rwtuwcpv" vq" c" Ðpq/g{gu/qpÑ" fqewogpv" 45 rtqfwevkqp"cu"vq"tgngxcpe{"kp"qtfgt"vq"gzrgfkvg"rtqfwevkqp"kp"vjg"OFN0"Cu"c"tguwnv."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{" 46 citggu" vq" ocmg" c" iqqf" hckvj" ghhqtv" vq" crrn{" vjg" vgtou" qh" vjku" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt" eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" vjcv" 47 rtqfwevkqp0"Vjg"Rctvkgu"hwtvjgt"citgg"vjcv"cp{"cffkvkqpcn"fqewogpv"rtqfwevkqpu"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp"oc{"dg" 48 ocfg"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjku"Ðpq/g{gu/qpÑ"tgxkgy1GUK"rtqfwevkqp"rtqeguu"*vjg"ÐRtqeguuÑ+0" 49 540" Vjg"Rctvkgu"cpf"vjgkt"eqwpugn"citgg"vq"vjg"gpvt{"qh"vjg"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp." 4: cpf"vq"vjg"Rtqeguu."yjkej"ujcnn"iqxgtp"vjg"rtqfwevkqp"qh"fqewogpvu."ocvgtkcnu."cpf"qvjgt"kphqtocvkqp." 34" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 13 of 18 " 3 kpenwfkpi" vjg" uwduvcpeg" cpf" eqpvgpv" vjgtgqh=" cpf" wug" qh" cp{" uwej" fqewogpvu." ocvgtkcnu." cpf" qvjgt" 4 kphqtocvkqp"fwtkpi"fkueqxgt{."kp"eqplwpevkqp"ykvj"eqwtv"hknkpiu"qt"jgctkpiu."fwtkpi"cp{"qvjgt"rtg/vtkcn" 5 cevkxkv{." cpf" fwtkpi" vtkcn0" " Vjg" Rctvkgu" cpf" vjgkt" eqwpugn" jcxg" cnuq" citggf" vjcv" cnn" GUK" rtqfwegf" d{" 6 Fghgpfcpvu"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjg"Rtqeguu"yknn"dg"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"hqnnqykpi"vgtou<"" 7 c0" Cv"vjg"vkog"qh"rtqfwevkqp."Fghgpfcpvu"yknn"kfgpvkh{"vjg"fqewogpvu"qt"GUK"cu"dgkpi" 8 rtqfwegf"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjg"Rtqeguu"cpf"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"tguvtkevkqpu"qh"vjku"Rctcitcrj" 9 *vjg"ÐRtqeguu"GUKÑ+0" : d0" ; cevkqpu"dtqwijv"d{"vjg"RnckpvkhhÓu"eqwpugn."uq"nqpi"cu"c"uwduvcpvkcnn{"eqorctcdng" 32 33 Pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"ujcnn"rtgxgpv"vjg"wug"qh"cp{"Rtqeguu"GUK"kp"qvjgt" rtqvgevkxg"qtfgt"ku"gpvgtgf"kp"vjqug"qvjgt"cevkqpu0" e0" Rtkqt"vq"wukpi"cp{"fqewogpv"qt"GUK"htqo"vjg"Rtqeguu"GUK"cu"rctv"qh"c"hknkpi."cv"c" 34 fgrqukvkqp."qt"cv"c"vtkcn"qt"jgctkpi"kp"vjku"ocvvgt."Rnckpvkhhu"ujcnn"ocmg"c"iqqf"hckvj" 35 ghhqtv"vq"kfgpvkh{"yjgvjgt"vjg"fqewogpv"qt"GUK"eqpvckpu"cp{"kphqtocvkqp"vjcv"ku" 36 uwdlgev"vq"tgfcevkqp"wpfgt"Rctcitcrju"55/56"*ÐTgfcevkqp"TgswktgogpvuÑ+"qh"vjku" 37 Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt" cpf" eqttgurqpfkpi" Gzjkdkv" E" *ÐTgfcevkqp" RtqvqeqnÑ+" cpf" vq" 38 tgfcev"cp{"uwej"kphqtocvkqp"kp"ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj"vjku"Qtfgt"cpf"tgfcevkqp"rtqvqeqn0" 39 f0" Fghgpfcpvu"ujcnn"kpfgrgpfgpvn{"jcxg"vjg"tkijv"vq"kfgpvkh{"cp{"fqewogpvu"qt"GUK" 3: htqo" vjg" Rtqeguu" GUK." kpenwfkpi" fqewogpvu" kfgpvkhkgf" d{" Rnckpvkhhu" rwtuwcpv" vq" 3; Uwdrctcitcrj" 540e0" cdqxg." cu" uwdlgev" vq" vjg" Tgfcevkqp" Tgswktgogpvu" cpf" 42 Tgfcevkqp"Rtqvqeqn"cpf"vq"tgswktg"vjg"tgfcevkqp"qh"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"ugv"hqtvj"vjgtgkp=" 43 kp"vjcv"gxgpv."Fghgpfcpvu"ujcnn"rtqxkfg"Rnckpvkhhu"ykvj"c"tgfcevgf"xgtukqp"qh"vjg" 44 uwdlgev"fqewogpvu"qt"GUK"ykvj"vjg"ucog"rtqfwevkqp"Dcvgu"pwodgt*u+"cpf"Rnckpvkhhu" 45 ujcnn"fguvtq{"cp{"wptgfcevgf"eqrkgu"qt"xgtukqpu"qh"vjg"fqewogpv"vjcv"vjg{"rquuguu0" 46 g0" Fghgpfcpvu"ujcnn"jcxg"vjg"tkijv"vq"kfgpvkh{"cp{"fqewogpv."hkng."qt"qvjgt"hqto"qh"GUK" 47 rtqfwegf"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjg"Rtqeguu"cu"dqvj"dgkpi"kttgngxcpv"vq"vjg"ocvvgtu"kp"fkurwvg" 48 kp"vjku"ecug"cpf"eqpvckpkpi"vtcfg"ugetgv"qt"qvjgt"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocvkqp"cpf"vq" 49 Ðency"dcemÑ"uwej"GUK"qt"fqewogpvu"htqo"vjg"rtqfwevkqp0"Chvgt"Rnckpvkhhu"wug"c" 4: fqewogpv"qt"GUK"htqo"vjg"Rtqeguu"GUK"cu"rctv"qh"c"hknkpi."cv"c"fgrqukvkqp."qt"cv"c" 35" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 14 of 18 " 3 vtkcn"qt"jgctkpi"kp"vjku"ocvvgt."Fghgpfcpvu"ujcnn"jcxg"52"fc{u"vq"uggm"ency"dcem"qh" 4 vjg"rctvkewnct"fqewogpv"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjku"Rctcitcrj="vjku"ncvvgt"tgswktgogpv"fqgu" 5 pqv"crrn{"vq"Rtqeguu"GUK"vjcv"jcu"pqv"dggp"wugf"d{"Rnckpvkhhu"cu"rctv"qh"c"hknkpi."cv" 6 c"fgrqukvkqp."qt"cv"c"vtkcn"qt"jgctkpi"kp"vjku"ocvvgt."yjkej"oc{"dg"encygf"dcem"cv" 7 cp{"vkog0" 8 h0" Rnckpvkhhu" ujcnn" jcxg" vjg" tkijv" vq" ejcnngpig" cp{" fgukipcvkqp" qt" ency" dcem" d{" 9 Fghgpfcpvu"wpfgt"Uwdrctcitcrju"540f0"qt"540g0"cdqxg"d{"uwdokuukqp"qh"vjg"GUK"qt" : fqewogpv" vq" vjg" Eqwtv" wpfgt" ugcn." cpf" cp{" hknkpiu" vjcv" tghgt" vq" vjg" rtqvgevgf" ; uwduvcpeg"qh"vjg"GUK"qt"fqewogpv"owuv."nkmgykug."dg"ocfg"wpfgt"ugcn0" 32 i0" k0""Vjg"rtqfwevkqp"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp."wug"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp."qt"cp{"qvjgt"fkuenquwtg"kp" 33 Vjku" Cevkqp" qh" vjg" uwduvcpeg" qt" eqpvgpv" qh" fqewogpvu." ocvgtkcnu." qt" qvjgt" 34 kphqtocvkqp" vjcv" ku" rtqvgevgf" d{" vjg" cvvqtpg{/enkgpv" rtkxkngig." yqtm/rtqfwev" 35 rtqvgevkqp."qt"cp{"qvjgt"rtkxkngig"qt"rtqvgevkqp"ujcnn"pqv"coqwpv"vq"yckxgt"qh"vjg" 36 rtkxkngig" cpf1qt" rtqvgevkqp" kp" Vjku" Cevkqp." qt" kp" cp{" qvjgt" hgfgtcn" qt" uvcvg" 37 rtqeggfkpi."cpf"Rnckpvkhh"cpf"RnckpvkhhÓu"eqwpugn"uvkrwncvg"vjcv"vjg{"yknn"pqv"ctiwg" 38 kp" cp{" qvjgt" cevkqp" qt" rtqeggfkpi." yjgvjgt" kp" hgfgtcn" qt" uvcvg" eqwtv." vjcv" vjg" 39 rtqfwevkqp." wug." qt" qvjgt" fkuenquwtg" qh" uwej" fqewogpvu." ocvgtkcnu." qt" qvjgt" 3: kphqtocvkqp"kp"Vjku"cevkqp"eqpuvkvwvgu"yckxgt"qh"vjg"rtkxkngig"qt"rtqvgevkqp0" 3; kk0"" 42 vjcv"tgcuqpcdn{"crrgctu"vq"dg"rtqvgevgf"d{"cp{"rtkxkngig"qt"qvjgt"rtqvgevkqp."vjg{" 43 ujcnn" rtqorvn{" pqvkh{" vjg" Uwrrn{kpi" Rctv{" kp" ytkvkpi0" " Kh" vjg" Uwrrn{kpi" Rctv{" 44 fgvgtokpgu" vjcv" vjg" fqewogpv." ocvgtkcn." qt" qvjgt" kphqtocvkqp" ku" rtkxkngigf" qt" 45 qvjgtykug"rtqvgevgf."kv"ujcnn"ocmg"uwej"cp"cuugtvkqp"kp"ytkvkpi"ykvjkp"52"fc{u"qh" 46 tgegkrv"qh"pqvkhkecvkqp0""Chvgt"dgkpi"pqvkhkgf."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"owuv"rtqorvn{" 47 tgvwtp."ugswguvgt."qt"fguvtq{"vjg"urgekhkgf"kphqtocvkqp"cpf"cp{"eqrkgu"kv"jcu="owuv" 48 pqv"wug"qt"fkuenqug"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"wpvkn"vjg"encko"ku"tguqnxgf="owuv"vcmg"tgcuqpcdng" 49 uvgru"vq"tgvtkgxg"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"kh"vjg"rctv{"fkuenqugf"kv"dghqtg"dgkpi"pqvkhkgf="cpf" 4: oc{"rtqorvn{"rtgugpv"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"vq"vjg"eqwtv"wpfgt"ugcn"hqt"c"fgvgtokpcvkqp" Kh"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"kfgpvkhkgu"c"fqewogpv."ocvgtkcn."qt"qvjgt"kphqtocvkqp" 36" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 15 of 18 " 3 qh"vjg"encko0"Hcknwtg"vq"cuugtv"vjg"rtkxkngig"qt"rtqvgevkqp"ykvjkp"52"fc{u"qh"tgegkrv" 4 qh"pqvkhkecvkqp"ujcnn"coqwpv"vq"yckxgt"qh"cp{"rtkxkngig"qt"rtqvgevkqp"qpn{"qh"vjg" 5 fqewogpv."ocvgtkcn."qt"qvjgt"kphqtocvkqp"kfgpvkhkgf"kp"vjg"pqvkhkecvkqp0" 6 Wpnguu" yckxgf" wpfgt" uwdugevkqp" *kk+" cdqxg." cv" cp{" vkog." c" rctv{" vjcv" rtqfwegu" cp{" fqewogpv." 7 ocvgtkcn." qt" qvjgt" kphqtocvkqp" vjcv" kv" dgnkgxgu" vq" dg" rtqvgevgf" d{" vjg" cvvqtpg{/enkgpv" rtkxkngig." yqtm/ 8 rtqfwev" rtqvgevkqp." qt" cp{" qvjgt" rtkxkngig" qt" rtqvgevkqp" oc{" cuugtv" vjg" rtkxkngig" qt" rtqvgevkqp" kp" 9 ytkvkpi0"" Chvgt" dgkpi" pqvkhkgf." vjg" Tgegkxkpi" Rctv{" owuv" rtqorvn{" tgvwtp." ugswguvgt." qt" fguvtq{" vjg" : urgekhkgf"kphqtocvkqp"cpf"cp{"eqrkgu"kv"jcu="owuv"pqv"wug"qt"fkuenqug"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"wpvkn"vjg"encko"ku" ; tguqnxgf=" owuv" vcmg" tgcuqpcdng" uvgru" vq" tgvtkgxg" vjg" kphqtocvkqp" kh" vjg" rctv{" fkuenqugf" kv" dghqtg" dgkpi" 32 pqvkhkgf="cpf"oc{"rtqorvn{"rtgugpv"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"vq"vjg"eqwtv"wpfgt"ugcn"hqt"c"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qh"vjg" 33 encko0" 34 j0" Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"vjg"fqewogpvu"qt"GUK"rtqfwegf"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjg"Rtqeguu"eqpvckp" 35 cp{"cfxgtug"gxgpv"tgrqtvgt"pcogu"qt"kphqtocvkqp"qh"c"rcvkgpv"yjq"ku"pqv"c"rctv{"vq" 36 vjku" nkvkicvkqp" cpf" yjkej" yqwnf" qvjgtykug" dg" tgfcevgf" kp" ceeqtfcpeg" ykvj" vjg" 37 Tgfcevkqp"Tgswktgogpvu"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt."Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"vjgkt"eqwpugn"cpf" 38 cigpvu"ujcnn"pqv"eqpvcev"vjg"rcvkgpv"qt"tgrqtvgt"qh"cp"cfxgtug"gxgpv"wpnguu"cpf"wpvkn" 39 vjg" rctvkgu" iq" vjtqwij" vjg" rtqeguugu" qwvnkpgf" kp" Uwdrctcitcrju" 540g0" cpf" 540i0" 3: cdqxg" ykvj" tgurgev" vq" tgfcevkqp" qh" kphqtocvkqp" cpf" vjku" Eqwtv" fgvgtokpgu" vjg" 3; kphqtocvkqp"ku"pqv"uwdlgev"vq"tgfcevkqp0" 42 550" Tgfcevkqp"qh"Cfxgtug"Gxgpv"Tgrqtvgt."JKRCC."cpf"Qvjgt"Kphqtocvkqp"Rwtuwcpv"vq" 43 Gzjkdkv"E0""Fghgpfcpvu"jcxg"rtqfwegf"kp"vjg"KXE"Hknvgt"OFN"cpf"oc{"rtqfweg"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp"cffkvkqpcn" 44 cpf" wrfcvgf" cfxgtug" gxgpv" tgrqtvu" cpf" eqornckpv" hkngu" ockpvckpgf" rwtuwcpv" vq" 43" W0U0E0" ¸" 582k." 43" 45 E0H0T0"¸":2503:"cpf"43"E0H0T0"¸":4203/0472."cu"ygnn"cu"fqewogpvu"tgncvkpi"vq"vjqug"cfxgtug"gxgpvu"cpf" 46 eqornckpv"hkngu0"Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"Fghgpfcpvu"ctg"cdng"vq"kfgpvkh{"yjgvjgt"vjgug"tgrqtvu"cpf"eqornckpv" 47 hkngu"tgncvg"vq"vjg"Rnckpvkhh"cv"vjg"vkog"vjg{"ctg"rtqfwegf"kp"Vjku"Cevkqp."vjg"rctvkgu"cpf"vjgkt"tgurgevkxg" 48 eqwpugn" jcxg" eqpugpvgf" vq" cpf" citggf" vjcv" vjg" Fghgpfcpvu" ujcnn" tghtckp" htqo" tgfcevkpi" vjg" hqnnqykpi" 49 kfgpvkhkcdng"kphqtocvkqp."cu"fghkpgf"kp"43"E0H0T0"¸"42085*h+."kp"vjg"dgnqy"ektewouvcpeg<" 4: 37" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 16 of 18 " 3 c0" 4 5 Kfgpvkhkcdng" kphqtocvkqp" qh" vjg" Rnckpvkhh" kp" vjku" nkvkicvkqp" ujcnn" pqv" dg" tgfcevgf." rwtuwcpv"vq"43"E0H0T0"¸"42085*h+*3+*kkk+0" Qvjgtykug." kp" ceeqtfcpeg" ykvj" 43" E0H0T0" ¸" 42085*h+" cpf" qvjgt" crrnkecdng" ncyu." uvcvwvgu." cpf" 6 tgiwncvkqpu."vjg" Fghgpfcpvu" ujcnn" qpn{" tgfcev"uwej" kphqtocvkqp"cu"ku"ugv" hqtvj"kp"vjg" citggf" Tgfcevkqp" 7 Rtqvqeqn"cvvcejgf"vq"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"cu"Gzjkdkv"E."cpf"Rnckpvkhhu"ujcnn"jcxg"vjg"tkijv"vq"qdlgev"vq" 8 cp{"tgfcevkqpu"ocfg0" 9 Vjg" rctvkgu"cempqyngfig" vjcv"vjku" Uvkrwncvgf" Qtfgt" ku"kpvgpfgf"vq" cpf" fqgu" ucvkuh{" vjg" ytkvvgp" : eqpugpv"tgswktgogpv"qh"vjg"hgfgtcn"tgiwncvkqpu0" ; c0" Cp{"fqewogpvu"eqpvckpkpi"cp{"tgrqtvgt"qt"rgtuqpcn"kfgpvkh{kpi"kphqtocvkqp"ujcnn" 32 dg"fgukipcvgf"cpf"dtcpfgf"cu"eqphkfgpvkcn"kp"ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj"vjku"Qtfgt0"Vq"vjg" 33 gzvgpv" vjcv" cp{" cfxgtug" gxgpv" tgrqtvgt" kphqtocvkqp" qt" rcvkgpv" kphqtocvkqp" 34 dgnqpikpi" vq" cp{" kpfkxkfwcn" qt" gpvkv{" yjq" ku" pqv" c" rctv{" vq" vjku" nkvkicvkqp" ku" 35 fkuenqugf."dgecwug"uwej"kphqtocvkqp"ku"pqv"tgswktgf"vq"dg"tgfcevgf"kp"ceeqtfcpeg" 36 ykvj"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"*ugg"Rctcitcrj"4;/52+."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"cpf"vjgkt" 37 eqwpugn"cpf"cigpvu"ujcnn"pqv"eqpvcev"vjg"rcvkgpv"qt"tgrqtvgt"kpxqnxgf"kp"cp"cfxgtug" 38 gxgpv0" 39 d0" Cp{" cffkvkqpcn" fqewogpvu" qt" GUK" Fghgpfcpvu" rtqfweg" kp" Vjku" Cevkqp" yknn" dg" 3: rtqfwegf"uwdlgev"vq"vjku"Qtfgt"cpf"octmgf"Eqphkfgpvkcn0""Vjwu."cp{"fqewogpvu"qt" 3; GUK" eqpvckpkpi" cp{" cfxgtug" gxgpv" tgrqtvgt." rgtuqpcn" kfgpvkh{kpi" kphqtocvkqp." qt" 42 cp{"qvjgt"kphqtocvkqp"rtqvgevgf"htqo"fkuenquwtg"cu"fguetkdgf"kp"Gzjkdkv"E"ujcnn" 43 eqpvkpwg"vq"dg"vtgcvgf"cu"eqphkfgpvkcn"kp"ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj"vjku"Qtfgt0" 44 560" Kh" vjg" Tgegkxkpi" Rctv{" kpvgpfu" vq" hkng" ykvj" vjg" Eqwtv." wug" cv" c" fgrqukvkqp." qt" qvjgtykug" 45 fkuenqug"c"fqewogpv"vq"c"pqprctv{"*eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Qtfgt+."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"ujcnn" 46 ocmg"c"iqqf"hckvj"ghhqtv"vq"tgfcev"vjcv"fqewogpv"eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"Gzjkdkv"E"rtkqt"vq"uwej"fkuenquwtg0"Chvgt" 47 uwej"hknkpi"qt"qvjgt"wug."vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"ujcnn"jcxg"hkhvggp"*37+"fc{u"vq"rtqxkfg"vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{" 48 ykvj"cp"cogpfgf"eqr{"qh"vjg"fqewogpv"ykvj"cp{"cffkvkqpcn"tgfcevkqpu"kv"fggou"pgeguuct{"rwtuwcpv"vq" 49 Gzjkdkv"E0"Kh"cp"cogpfgf"eqr{"ku"rtqxkfgf."vjg"Tgegkxkpi"Rctv{"yknn"gpuwtg"vjcv"vjg"qtkikpcn"eqr{"ku" 4: tgrncegf"ykvj"vjg"cogpfgf"eqr{"kp"vjg"eqwtv"hknkpi"qt"fgrqukvkqp0" 38" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27 Filed 10/24/19 Page 17 of 18 " 3 570" Gcej" rctv{" ujcnn" tgvckp" cnn" tkijvu" cpf" tgogfkgu" cxckncdng" vq" kv" wpfgt" vjg" ncy" hqt" vjg" 4 gphqtegogpv"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"cickpuv"cp{qpg"yjq"xkqncvgu"kv0" 5 580" Pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"ujcnn"dg"eqpuvtwgf"vq"rtgxgpv"vjku"Eqwtv"htqo"fkuenqukpi" 6 cp{"hcevu"vjg"Eqwtv"tgnkgu"wrqp"kp"ocmkpi"cp{"hkpfkpiu"qt"kuuwkpi"cp{"twnkpi."qtfgt."lwfiogpv."qt"fgetgg0"" 7 Ykvjkp" vjktv{" *52+" fc{u" qh" cp{" kphqtocvkqp" vjcv" jcu" dggp" enckogf" cu" Eqphkfgpvkcn" Kphqtocvkqp" 8 dgkpi" fg/fgukipcvgf" qt" ocfg" rwdnken{" cxckncdng." vjg" Uwrrn{kpi" Rctv{" ujcnn" rtqxkfg" pqvkeg" qh" vjg" 9 Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"vjcv"jcu"dggp"fg/fgukipcvgf"cpf1qt"ocfg"rwdnken{"cxckncdng0""Uwej"pqvkeg"ujcnn" : dg"ocfg"d{"kfgpvkh{kpi"dcvgu"pwodgtu"qt"d{"qvjgt"ogcpu"uwej"cu"kfgpvkh{kpi"ecvgiqtkgu"qh"kphqtocvkqp" ; yjgtg"vjg"kfgpvkhkecvkqp"qh"dcvgu"pwodgtu"ctg"pqv"rquukdng"qt"pqv"hgcukdng0""Rwdnken{"cxckncdng"kpenwfgu" 32 fqewogpvu" vjcv" jcxg" dggp" hkngf" ykvj" cp{" eqwtv" qt" gpvgtgf" cu" cp" gzjkdkv" fwtkpi" vtkcn" pqv" wpfgt" ugcn." 33 rtqxkfgf."jqygxgt"vjcv"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"ku"pqv"tgswktgf"vq"rtqxkfg"pqvkeg"qh"fg/fgukipcvkqp"ykvj"tgictf" 34 vq"uwej"fqewogpvu"wpvkn"cp{"oqvkqp"qt"tgswguv"vq"ugcn"vjqug"fqewogpvu"ku"fgpkgf0""Vjku"rctcitcrj"qpn{" 35 crrnkgu"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"vjg"Uwrrn{kpi"Rctv{"mpgy"qt"ujqwnf"jcxg"mpqyp"vjcv"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"enckogf" 36 cu"Eqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp"ycu"fg/fgukipcvgf"qt"ocfg"rwdnken{"cxckncdng0" Tgurgevhwnn{"uwdokvvgf"vjku"46vj"fc{"qh"Qevqdgt"423;0" 37 38 39 3: 3; 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 " YGVJGTCNN"ITQWR."NVF0"" " D{<"/s/ Peter C. Wetherall RGVGT"E0"YGVJGTCNN."GUS0" " ""Pgxcfc"Dct"Pq0"6636"" " " rygvjgtcnnBygvjgtcnnitqwr0eqo"" " "";567"Y0"Uwpugv"Tqcf."Uwkvg"322"" " ""Ncu"Xgicu."Pgxcfc":;36:"" ""Vgngrjqpg<"*924+":5:/:722"" " ""Hceukokng<"*924+":59/72:3" " " " " " " " " ""Eounsel for Plaintiff"" " " "" " " " " " "" " " " " " " " SO ORDERED. " " " " " IT IS Dated: October 25, 2019 ". " " " " " " " " " " . " " ______________________________ " " Nancy" J. Koppe """""ITGGPDGTI"VTCWTKI."NNR" D{<"1s/ Eric W. Swanis """"""GTKE"Y0"UYCPKU."GUS0" """"""Pgxcfc"Dct"Pq0"8:62" """"""32:67"Itkhhkvj"Rgcm"Ftkxg."Uwkvg"822" """"""Ncu"Xgicu."Pgxcfc":;357" """"""EJTKUVQRJGT"L0"PGWOCPP."GUS0" """"""ITGGPDGTI"VTCWTKI."NNR" """"""3366"37vj"Uvtggv."Uwkvg"5522" """"""Fgpxgt."Eqnqtcfq":2424" """"""Vgngrjqpg<"*525+"794/8722" """"""Gockn<"pgwocppeBivncy0eqo" " Counsel for Defendants " " United States Magistrate Judge 4: " " 39" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27-1 Filed 10/24/19 Page 1 of 2 EXHIBIT C Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27-1 Filed 10/24/19 Page 2 of 2 " 3 GZJKDKV"C" 4 KP"VJG"WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" HQT"VJG"FKUVTKEV"QH"PGXCFC" "" " UVGRJCPKG"URKNQVTQ."cu"Iwctfkcp"cf" ECUG"PQ0"4<3;/ex/237:8/"THD/PLM" nkvgo"hqt"LCUQP"FWGPCU." " " " Rnckpvkhh." CITGGOGPV"VQ"OCKPVCKP" " EQPHKFGPVKCNKV[" x0" " E0"T0"DCTF."KPE0="DCTF"RGTKRJGTCN" XCUEWNCT."KPEQTRQTCVGF." " Fghgpfcpvu0" " 5 6 7 8 9 : ; 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 3: 3; 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 K."aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"*Pcog+."jcxg"dggp"ikxgp"cpf"jcxg"tgcf"c"eqr{"qh"vjg"Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt."fcvgf"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa."42aa"kp"vjg"ecug"qh"Stephanie Spilotro, as Guardian ad litem for Jason Duenas" v. C. R. Bard, Inc., et al.." Ecug" Pq0" 4<3;/ex/237:8/THD/PLM." rgpfkpi" kp" vjg" Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu" Fkuvtkev"Eqwtv"Fkuvtkev"qh"Pgxcfc0"" K"wpfgtuvcpf"cpf"yknn"uvtkevn{"cfjgtg"vq"vjg"eqpvgpvu"qh"uckf"Qtfgt0"K"wpfgtuvcpf"vjcv"rtqfwegf" ocvgtkcn"fkuenqugf"vq"og"ku"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"Qtfgt"qh"vjku"Eqwtv"cpf"vjcv"K"co"rtqjkdkvgf"htqo"eqr{kpi." fkuenqukpi"qt"qvjgtykug"wukpi"uwej"ocvgtkcn"gzegrv"cu"rtqxkfgf"d{"uckf"eqwtv"Qtfgt0""K"wpfgtuvcpf"vjcv"o{" wpcwvjqtk|gf"fkuenquwtg"qh"cp{"ÐEqphkfgpvkcn"KphqtocvkqpÑ"qt"eqpvcev"qh"c"rcvkgpv"qt"tgrqtvgt"qh"cp"cfxgtug" gxgpv"oc{"eqpuvkvwvg"eqpvgorv"qh"eqwtv"cpf"K"citgg"vq"dg"rgtuqpcnn{"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"lwtkufkevkqp"qh"vjku" Eqwtv"hqt"vjg"rwtrqug"qh"gphqtekpi"o{"qdnkicvkqpu"wpfgt"vjku"Citggogpv."vjg"Qtfgt."cpf"cp{"eqpvgorv" rtqeggfkpi" vjcv" oc{" dg" kpuvkvwvgf" hqt" o{" xkqncvkqp" qh" vjg" vgtou" qh" vjku" Citggogpv" vq" Ockpvckp" Eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" cpf" vjg" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt0" " K" cnuq" wpfgtuvcpf" vjcv" o{" ukipcvwtg" qp" vjku" ÐCitggogpv" vq" Ockpvckp"Eqphkfgpvkcnkv{.Ñ"kpfkecvkpi"o{"citggogpv"vq"dg"dqwpf"d{"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt."ku" tgswktgf"dghqtg"K"oc{"dg"cnnqygf"vq"tgegkxg"cpf"tgxkgy"cp{"rtqfwegf"fqewogpv"cpf"ocvgtkcnu"vjcv"ctg" fgukipcvgf"cu"ÐEqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp0Ñ" Fcvg<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" " " Rtkpv"Ukipcvwtg<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" " " " Ukipcvwtg<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" 4: " " " " " 3;" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27-2 Filed 10/24/19 Page 1 of 3 EXHIBIT D Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27-2 Filed 10/24/19 Page 2 of 3 " 3 GZJKDKV"D" 4 5 6 7 8 9 : ; 32 33 34 35 KP"VJG"WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" HQT"VJG"FKUVTKEV"QH"PGXCFC" "" "" "" UVGRJCPKG"URKNQVTQ."cu"Iwctfkcp"cf" ECUG"PQ0"4<3;/ex/237:8/"THD/PLM" nkvgo"hqt"LCUQP"FWGPCU." " " " Rnckpvkhh." CEMPQYNGFIOGPV"QH" " FGUVTWEVKQP"QT"TGVWTP"QH" x0" EQPHKFGPVKCN"KPHQTOCVKQP" " E0"T0"DCTF."KPE0="DCTF"RGTKRJGTCN" XCUEWNCT."KPEQTRQTCVGF." " Fghgpfcpvu0" " " "" "" K." aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" *Pcog+." co" qxgt" vjg" cig" qh" 3:" {gctu" cpf" co" c" tgukfgpv" qh" 36 aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" Eqwpv{." aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa0" " K" ocmg" vjku" Fgenctcvkqp" dcugf" wrqp" o{" rgtuqpcn" 37 mpqyngfig."cpf"K"co"eqorgvgpv"vq"vguvkh{"vq"vjg"ocvvgtu"uvcvgf"jgtgkp0"" 38 K" jcxg" tgswguvgf" cpf" tgegkxgf" htqo" aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" cnn" qh" vjg" ÐEqphkfgpvkcn" KphqtocvkqpÑ" 39 eqpvckpgf" kp" ocvgtkcnu." vtcpuetkrvu." cpf" qvjgt" vjkpiu" ykvjkp" vjg" ueqrg" qh" vjku" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt" cpf" 3: rtqfwegf"kp"vjku"ecug."Stephanie Spilotro, as Guardian ad litem for Jason Duenas v. C. R. Bard, Inc., et 3; al0."Ecug"Pq0"4<3;/ex/237:8/THD/PLM."rgpfkpi"kp"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Fkuvtkev"Eqwtv"Fkuvtkev"qh"Pgxcfc0" 42 K"jcxg"gkvjgt"fguvtq{gf"qt"jcxg"cvvcejgf"jgtgvq"cnn"qh"vjg"ÐEqphkfgpvkcn"KphqtocvkqpÑ"eqpvckpgf"kp" 43 vjg" ocvgtkcnu." vtcpuetkrvu." cpf" qvjgt" vjkpiu" ykvjkp" vjg" ueqrg" qh" vjku" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt" kpenwfkpi" vjqug" 44 ocvgtkcnu"yjkej"ygtg"tgvwtpgf"vq"og"d{"vjg"gzrgtvu"cpf"eqpuwnvcpvu"ogpvkqpgf"cdqxg"kp"ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj" 45 vjg"rtgegfkpi"rctcitcrj."cpf"cu"fguetkdgf"kp"vjg"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"tgncvgf"vq"vjku"ocvvgt0""Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi" 46 vjg" hqtgiqkpi" rtqxkukqpu" qh" vjku" rctcitcrj." vjg" Tgegkxkpi" Rctv{" oc{" ockpvckp" kvu" rtkxkngigf" 47 eqoowpkecvkqpu." yqtm" rtqfwev." Eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" Citggogpvu" cpf" Cempqyngfiogpvu" rwtuwcpv" vq" vjg" 48 Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt." ocvgtkcnu" tgswktgf" vq" dg" tgvckpgf" rwtuwcpv" vq" vjg" crrnkecdng" ncy." cpf" cnn" eqwtv/hkngf" 49 fqewogpvu"gxgp"vjqwij"vjg{"eqpvckp"ÐEqphkfgpvkcn"Kphqtocvkqp.Ñ"dwv"uwej"ocvgtkcnu"ujcnn"tgockp"uwdlgev" 4: vq"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0"" 42" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27-2 Filed 10/24/19 Page 3 of 3 " 3 K"fgenctg"wpfgt"rgpcnv{"qh"rgtlwt{"wpfgt"vjg"ncyu"qh"vjg"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"vjcv" 4 vjg"hqtgiqkpi"ku"vtwg"cpf"eqttgev0"" 5 " 6 Fcvg<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" " " Rtkpv"Ukipcvwtg<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" 7 " " 8 " " Ukipcvwtg<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" " " " 9 : ; 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 3: 3; 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 4: 43" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27-3 Filed 10/24/19 Page 1 of 4 EXHIBIT E Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27-3 Filed 10/24/19 Page 2 of 4 " 3 GZJKDKV"E" 4 Tgfcevkqp"Rtqvqeqn" 5 " 6 3+" Tgfcevkqpu"wpfgt"vjg"Jgcnvj"Kpuwtcpeg"Rqtvcdknkv{"Cev"qh"3;;8"*JKRCC+" cpf" wpfgt" 43" 7 EHT"42085."tgfcev"vjg"hqnnqykpi<""" 8 " 3+" 9 : Tgfcev"vjg"hqnnqykpi"hqt"vjg"rcvkgpv."tgncvkxgu."jqwugjqnf"ogodgtu."qt"gornq{gtu<" *3+" ; Pcogu" ‚" *k0g0."vjg"uwdlgevu"qh"vjg"tgeqtfu+"cpf"qh"vjgkt"tgncvkxgu."gornq{gtu."cpf"jqwugjqnf" 32 33 34 ogodgtu"ctg"tgfcevgf0""Fq"pqv"tgfcev"fqevqtu."pwtugu."gve0"hqt"JKRCC0" *4+" 35 36 37 38 39 3: 3; 42 43 44 45 48 49 4: Eqwpv{."Ekv{"cpf"Uvtggv"cfftguu"cpf"ncuv"vyq"fkikvu"qh"|kr"eqfg" ‚" ‚" *5+" FQ"PQV"TGFCEV"EQWPVT[."UVCVG."QT"HKTUV"VJTGG"FKIKVU"QH"¥KR" EQFG0" Ycujkpivqp."FE"ku"eqpukfgtgf"c"uvcvg"hqt"JKRCC"tgfcevkqp"rwtrqugu0" Dktvjfcvgu"cpf"fcvgu"qh"fgcvj" ‚" FQ"PQV"TGFCEV"VJG"[GCT" *6+" Vgngrjqpg"pwodgtu" *7+" Hcz"pwodgtu" *8+" Gockn"cfftguugu" *9+" Uqekcn"ugewtkv{"pwodgtu"*gxgp"kh"kv"ku"qpn{"c"rqtvkqp."qt"vjg"hwnn"pwodgt"dwv"oquv"ku"ZÓf" qwv"Î"tgfcev"kv"cnn+" *:+" Ogfkecn" tgeqtf" pwodgtu." Ceeguukqp" Pwodgtu." GOT" *Gngevtqpke" Ogfkecn" Tgeqtf" Pwodgt+."RJT"*Rgtuqpcn"Jgcnvj"Tgeqtf+."ROT"*Rgtuqpcn"Ogfkecn"Tgeqtf+."Enkpkecn"Vtkcn" 46 47 Pcogu" qh" vjg" kpfkxkfwcnu" cuuqekcvgf" ykvj" vjg" eqttgurqpfkpi" jgcnvj" kphqtocvkqp" Tgeqtf"Pwodgtu" *;+" Jgcnvj" rncp"dgpghkekct{"pwodgtu." Itqwr" Rqnke{"KFu." Rqnke{" Pwodgtu." gve0" *dwv" pqv"vjg" pcog"qt"cfftguu"qh"kpuwtcpeg"eqorcpkgu+" *32+" Ceeqwpv"pwodgtu" 44" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27-3 Filed 10/24/19 Page 3 of 4 " 3 *33+" Egtvkhkecvg1nkegpug"pwodgtu" 4 *34+" Xgjkeng"kfgpvkhkgtu"*nkegpug"rncvg"pwodgtu."XKPu."gve0+" 5 *35+" Ugtkcn"pwodgtu"qh"fgxkegu" 6 *36+" WTNu." hqnfgt" rcvju." hkng" nqecvkqpu" *kh" vjg{" kpenwfg" cp{vjkpi" nkmg" vjg" rcvkgpv" KF." qt" vjg" 7 rcvkgpvÓu"gornq{gt+" 8 *37+" KR"Cfftguugu" 9 *38+" Dkqogvtke"kfgpvkhkgtu"uwej"cu"hkpigtrtkpvu."rcvkgpv"ejctv"dcteqfgu" : *39+" Hwnn"hceg"kocigu"*pqv"ukfg"rtqhkngu+" ; *3:+" Cp{"qvjgt"wpkswg"kfgpvkhkgt" 32 ‚" Vjku"ecp"kpenwfg"cp{vjkpi"vjcv"ku"wpkswg"gpqwij"vq"kfgpvkh{"vjg"rgtuqp"ÐRtgukfgpv" 33 qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"UvcvguÑ."Ðewttgpv"Rtqxquv"qh"vjg"Wpkxgtukv{"qh"VgppguuggÑ."Ðhktuv"ocp" 34 vq"ycnm"qp"vjg"oqqpÑ."Ðhktuv"jgctv"vtcpurncpv"tgekrkgpvÑ" 35 PQV"TGFCEVGF<" ‚" 36 ‚" 37 ‚" 38 Dctf"Eqornckpv"KFu"" Kphqtocvkqp"cdqwv"c"rgtuqp"yjq"jcu"dggp"fgcf"72"{gctu"qt"oqtg" Cwvqru{"tgrqtvu" 39 " " 3: 4+" Tgfcevkqpu"qh"Tgrqtvgt"Kphqtocvkqp"/"43"EHT"42085" 3; Vjg"pcogu." cfftguu" *kpenwfkpi" ekv{." uvcvg." cpf" eqwpvt{+." qh" cp{" tgrqtvgt" *gzegrv" kh" kv" ku" c" Dctf" 42 Gornq{gg"qt"HFC"tgrtgugpvcvkxg+."kpenwfkpi"vjg"pcogu"qh<" 43 *3+" 44 Pcogu"qh"cp{"fqevqt."pwtug."kpvgtp."qt"gornq{gg"qh"vjg"tgrqtvgt"kpuvkvwvkqp0""Vjku"kpenwfgu" kpkvkcnu0" 45 *4+" Pcog"qh"vjg"jqurkvcn1kpuvkvwvkqp0" 46 *5+" Cnn"igqitcrjke"kphqtocvkqp"kpenwfkpi"ekv{."uvcvg."eqwpvt{."|kr"eqfg."gve0" 47 *6+" Rjqpg"pwodgtu."hcz"pwodgtu."qt"rcigt"pwodgtu"hqt"vjg"kpuvkvwvkqp."fqevqt."gve0" 48 *7+" Gockn"cfftguugu."ygdukvgu"hqt"vjg"jqurkvcn."gve0" 49 ‚" Dctf"Gornq{ggu"ctg"pqv"tgfcevgf"dgecwug"pqv"eqpukfgtgf"xqnwpvct{"tgrqtvgtu" 4: 45" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" Case 2:19-cv-01586-RFB-NJK Document 27-3 Filed 10/24/19 Page 4 of 4 " 3 4 ‚" Kh" tgrqtvgt" ku" cp" cvvqtpg{" qt" ncy" hkto" uwdlgev" vq" rctvkguÓ" uvkrwncvkqp" tgictfkpi" tgfcevkqp."fq"pqv"tgfcev"vjg"cvvqtpg{1ncy"hkto"cu"vjg"tgrqtvgt0" 5 6 7 8 9 : ; 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 3: 3; 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 4: 46" ]RTQRQUGF_"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT"
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
