Bai v. Reubart et al, No. 2:2019cv00739 - Document 87 (D. Nev. 2021)

Court Description: ORDER GRANTING 86 Motion for Copies. The Court ORDERS Defendants to promptly serve a copy of 81 on Plaintiff. As a one-time courtesy, the Clerks Office shall to send a copy of the public docket to Plaintiff. (attached herein for distribution through law library) Signed by Magistrate Judge Nancy J. Koppe on 9/24/2021. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF, docket sheet enclosed - DRS) # 1 Docket Sheet added for distribution through law library) (DRS).

Download PDF
Bai v. Reubart et al 01231245ÿ2788ÿ9 Doc. 87 Att. 1 1 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,-. /01234ÿ627238ÿ9182:1;2ÿ<=>:2ÿ 9182:1;2ÿ=?ÿ@3A747ÿBC78ÿD3E78Fÿ <GDGCÿ9H<IJKÿLHMÿ<N6JÿOPÿQPRST;ATUUVWSTXY@T@ZI [\]ÿ_`ÿabcd\efÿbfÿ\g \fbÿ-]gblnÿ z {} { |}ÿ hii]jkblÿfmnÿop]bqÿrcljbÿsgme]\ÿt`ÿu\_\eemÿ rcewÿ b \klnÿ bqbkl\kfÿ abqbeeblÿfmnÿt\j]ife\fbÿrcljbÿu\kvwÿr`ÿxmyybÿ u\fcebÿmqÿ c]fnÿ ÿ.e]imkbenÿo]_]gÿa]jpfiÿ o\cibnÿz{n|}~ÿ.e]imkbeÿo]_]gÿa]jpfi rce]il]vf]mknÿ-blbe\gÿ cbif]mk 71021?? 17= 3ÿ 71ÿÿ ebyebibkfblÿdw 96 ÿC7 ÿC1 :7: ÿ | }}~} ÿ \]gnÿ . \ ]de\ew lmv`k_`jm_ÿÿ ]jpÿ bibefÿ f\fbÿ.e]imkÿÿ ÿ ¡¡¢£¤ ¥ÿÿ . ÿ[m ÿ ÿÿ ¡¡¢£¤ ¥ÿ¡¢ÿ¦ ÿ¤¢¡§¨ ,kl]\kÿ ye]kji ÿu ÿ~} `ÿ 93?304702 M3> 7:2 93?304702 7003 ÿ ·¸¹ºÿ»¼º½¼ÿ·¹ÿ \ bg 93?304702 < 7:® 711 0 1 ! " 1 # $ %&033 8'82(0 24() *+4+8 4 ebyebibkfblÿdw<©:182=ª©3:ÿY1;©73 ÿX> ÿ qq]vbÿmqÿhffmekbwÿsbkbe\gÿ ÿ ÿ«\ip]kjfmkÿh_bÿ fbÿ} ÿ \iÿ bj\i ÿu ÿ~}| |ÿ { z~ { ÿ \]gnÿvjcw \j`k_`jm_ÿÿ ¡¡¢£¤ ¥ÿ¡¢ÿ¦ ÿ¤¢¡§¨ ÿ ¬743ÿZ­ÿD7061;® 3ÿ qq]vbÿmqÿub_\l\ÿhffmekbwÿsbkbe\gÿ ÿ `ÿ«\ip]kjfmkÿh_b` ÿ fb`ÿ} ÿ \iÿ bj\i ÿu ÿ~}| |ÿ { z~ {| ÿ -\ nÿ { z~  ÿ \]gnÿ _\ki]v¯gb \j`k_`jm_ÿÿ ¡ £°§¤ ¡ ±ÿ²³´µ¶´µ²µ³ ebyebibkfblÿdw<©:182=ª©3:ÿY1;©73 ÿX> ÿ ¾ bbÿ\dm_bÿqmeÿ\llebii¿ÿ ¡¡¢£¤ ¥ÿ¡¢ÿ¦ ÿ¤¢¡ÿ§¨ ÿ ¬743ÿZ­ÿD7061;® 3ÿ 410 Dockets.Justia.com 01231245ÿ2788ÿ9 HIJIKLMKN OMPQIR HIJIKLMKN HMKMÿO[lYR HIJIKLMKN mNN[YKIRÿ`IKIYMPÿjNMNIÿ[JÿnIoMLM 1 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,-..ÿ0123.ÿ425ÿ0665.778ÿ 9:;<=>?9:@AÿCDEFGEFCFD 5.S5.7.TU.6ÿ1VWXYZQN[\XIYÿ^Z_XMIPÿ`aRÿ ,-..ÿ0123.ÿ425ÿ0665.778ÿÿ ?99b;>:cÿ9bÿd:ÿ>b9=e:@ÿ fMLIÿghÿiMKjZ_kPIÿ ,-..ÿ0123.ÿ425ÿ0665.778ÿÿ 9:;<=>?9:@AÿCDEFGEFCFD 5.S5.7.TU.6ÿ1VWXYZQN[\XIYÿ^Z_XMIPÿ`aRÿ ,-..ÿ0123.ÿ425ÿ0665.778ÿÿ ?99b;>:cÿ9bÿd:ÿ>b9=e:@ÿ fMLIÿghÿiMKjZ_kPIÿ ,-..ÿ0123.ÿ425ÿ0665.778ÿÿ 9:;<=>?9:@AÿCDEFGEFCFD 5.S5.7.TU.6ÿ1VmNN[YKIRÿ`IKIYMPÿjNMNIÿ[JÿnIoMLMÿÿ pqrÿ-sÿ mMY[KÿHhÿt[YLum`ÿ v.3060ÿwUU25T.Vÿx.T.50yÿ z{{ÿv25U|ÿ}0572Tÿ-U5..Uÿ }0572Tÿ}~UVÿv ÿ {zÿ zz{{ÿ 0 ÿ zz{ ÿ s 0~y ÿ 76 4~y~T 7 0 T3 23ÿÿ 9:;<=>?9:@AÿC EFDEFCFCÿ fMLIÿghÿiMKjZ_kPIÿ ,-..ÿ0123.ÿ425ÿ0665.778ÿÿ 9:;<=>?9:@AÿCDEFGEFCFD HMNIÿtZPIL H[_kINÿ I N { {z ÿ}07.ÿ50T62 yVÿ077~ T.6ÿU2ÿ}|~.4ÿ 6 .ÿxy25~0ÿ ÿv030552ÿ0T6ÿ 0 ~7U50U.ÿ 6 .ÿv0T Vÿ 2SS. ÿ,q 8ÿ,sTU.5.6 ÿ{ { {z 8 { {z zÿwpp }w rvÿ425ÿ .03.ÿU2ÿp52 ..6ÿ~Tÿ425 0ÿS0 S.5~7ÿ4~y.6ÿ1Vÿpy0~TU~44ÿ ~02V.ÿ 0~ ,wUU0 | .TU7 ÿ ÿzÿ}2 Sy0~TU8, ¡}8ÿ,sTU.5.6 ÿ{ {z {z 8 { {z {z ÿw¢ -rq£ÿ s sqÿU2ÿy~U~ 0TU ÿ, ¡}8ÿ,sTU.5.6 ÿ{ {z {z 8 { {z ÿpqrpr-s¢ÿ-¤ rv-ÿU2ÿ1.ÿ~77 .6ÿ1Vÿpy0~TU~44ÿ ~02V.ÿ 0~ ÿ,- ¢8ÿ,sTU.5.6 { {z 8 { z { { ÿ-}qssv vxÿrq¢sq ÿ |.ÿ}y.5¥ÿ24ÿ}2 5Uÿ~7ÿ6~5. U.6ÿU2ÿ066ÿwUU25T.Vÿx.T.50yÿU2ÿU|~7ÿ 07. 0T6ÿU2ÿ4~y.ÿU|.ÿzÿ zÿ}2 Sy0~TU ÿ |~7ÿ 0UU.5ÿ~7ÿ5.4.55.6ÿU2ÿ T 0U.ÿ .6~0U~2Tÿp52 50 ÿ0T6ÿ~7 7U0V.6ÿ425ÿ {ÿ60V7ÿU2ÿ0yy2¦ÿ425ÿ .6~0U~2Tÿ0T6 25ÿ7.UUy. .TU ÿp.U~U~2T.5§7ÿ Tÿ 25 0ÿp0 S.5~7 711 0 1 ! " 1 # $ %&033 8'82(0 24() *+4+8 4 210 01231245ÿ2788ÿ9 GQJQCJBGBG GvJBCJBGBG GkJBBJBGBG GIJBFJBGBG GIJQGJBGBG GyJGCJBGBG GzJCyJBGBG CGJGIJBGBG CGJGFJBGBG CGJCBJBGBG CGJCQJBGBG 1 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,-.-/,ÿ1,ÿ23435532ÿ6372178ÿ9/-:9;3ÿ94ÿ;321.-197<ÿ=9-197,ÿ495ÿ3>:?/,197ÿ459;ÿ17;.-3 ;321.-197ÿ65985.;ÿ.53ÿ2/3ÿ@1-A17ÿBCÿ2.D,<ÿEA3ÿFGH2.Dÿ,-.Dÿ53695-ÿ1,ÿ2/3ÿIJBFJBGBG< K18732ÿLDÿM/283ÿN?951.ÿ=<ÿO.P.559ÿ97ÿQJQCJBGBG<ÿRSTUVÿTXÿSTYUZ[\]^ÿ_`]^ÿ^Tÿabcd9613, A.P3ÿL337ÿ21,-51L/-32ÿ6/5,/.7-ÿ-9ÿ-A3ÿOefÿHÿghKiÿce7-3532jÿGQJQCJBGBGi kÿdl=mnopOEÿ.8.17,-ÿd?.5qrÿs.?,3Drÿs.773?rÿg.7.ÿs9@5Drÿh3/L.5-ÿLDÿt1.9D3ÿu.1<ÿc::jÿm HÿghKiÿce7-3532jÿGQJQCJBGBGi IÿOlEpdeÿ94ÿo663.5.7:3ÿLDÿ.--9573Dÿw.23ÿM<ÿx.7K1:q?3ÿ97ÿL3A.?4ÿ94ÿg34372.7-,ÿg.7. s9@5Drÿh3/L.5-<ÿcx.7K1:q?3rÿw.23iÿce7-3532jÿGvJBCJBGBGi yÿOlEpdeÿ94ÿdA.783ÿ94ÿo2253,,ÿLDÿm?.17-144ÿt1.9D3ÿu.1<ÿ=5ÿu.1ÿ1,ÿ79@ÿA9/,32ÿ.-ÿs18A g3,35-ÿK-.-3ÿm51,97<ÿcsgKmÿn1L5.5Dÿ.2232ÿ495ÿ3;.1?ÿ,35P1:3ÿHÿghKiÿce7-3532jÿGkJBBJBGBGi zÿKEoE{KÿhemlhEÿLDÿg34372.7-,ÿo--9573DÿN3735.?ÿK-.-3ÿ94ÿO3P.2.rÿg.7.ÿs9@5Dr h3/L.5-<ÿcx.7K1:q?3rÿw.23iÿce7-3532jÿGIJBFJBGBGi FÿlhgehÿHÿEA3ÿd9/5-ÿe>-372,ÿ-A3ÿK-.Dÿ,3-ÿLDÿvÿK:5337178ÿl5235ÿ/7-1?ÿBÿ2.D,ÿ.4-35ÿ-A3 17;.-3ÿ3.5?Dÿ;321.-197ÿ:9743537:3ÿ-.q3,ÿ6?.:3<ÿEA3ÿl441:3ÿ94ÿ-A3ÿo--9573DÿN3735.?ÿ,A.?? 41?3ÿ-A3ÿ53695-ÿ538.52178ÿ-A3ÿ53,/?-,ÿ94ÿ-A3ÿ,-.Dÿ79ÿ?.-35ÿ-A.7ÿ-@9ÿ2.D,ÿ.4-35ÿ-A3ÿ17;.-3ÿ3.5?D ;321.-197ÿ:9743537:3<ÿK18732ÿLDÿ=.81,-5.-3ÿM/283ÿO.7:DÿM<ÿ|9663ÿ97ÿIJQGJBGBG<ÿcd9613, A.P3ÿL337ÿ21,-51L/-32ÿ6/5,/.7-ÿ-9ÿ-A3ÿOefÿHÿghKiÿce7-3532jÿGIJQGJBGBGi CGÿ=lEplOÿd97:357178ÿ=321-.-197ÿLDÿm?.17-144ÿt1.9D3ÿu.1<ÿh3,697,3,ÿ2/3ÿLDÿyJCkJBGBG< cghKiÿce7-3532jÿGyJGCJBGBGi CCÿlhgehÿ,3--178ÿp7;.-3ÿe.5?Dÿ=321.-197ÿd9743537:3<ÿo7ÿp7;.-3ÿe.5?Dÿ=321.-197 d9743537:3ÿ1,ÿ,3-ÿ495ÿCGJFJBGBGÿ.-ÿCCjCkÿo=ÿ17ÿnxÿdA.;L35,ÿL34953ÿ=321.-95ÿg.P12 K-36A37,<ÿEA3ÿo--9573DÿN3735.?},ÿl441:3ÿ@1??ÿ;.q3ÿ-A3ÿ73:3,,.5Dÿ.55.783;37-,ÿ495 6?.17-144ÿ-9ÿ.663.5ÿLDÿP1239ÿ.72ÿ@1??ÿ659P123ÿKA.597ÿs.5217ÿ.-ÿyGBHvIvHkkIQÿ@1-Aÿ-A3 P1239ÿ:9743537:3ÿ53,35P.-197ÿ7/;L35ÿ.72ÿ-3?36A973ÿ7/;L35ÿ.-ÿ@A1:Aÿ-A3ÿ6?.17-144ÿ:.7ÿL3 53.:A32<ÿEA3ÿ;321.-197ÿ,-.-3;37-,ÿ,A.??ÿL3ÿ23?1P3532ÿ-9 p7;.-3=321.-197u5134~7P2</,:9/5-,<89Pÿ79ÿ?.-35ÿ-A.7ÿvjGGÿ6<;<ÿ97ÿFJBkJBGBG<ÿglÿOlE fpneÿEseÿ=egpoEplOÿKEoEe=eOEKÿglÿOlEÿKehxeÿoÿdlm ÿlOÿlmmlKpON dl{OKen<ÿK33ÿ-A3ÿ.--.:A32ÿ95235ÿ495ÿ,63:141:.-197,<ÿK18732ÿLDÿ=.81,-5.-3ÿM/283ÿO.7:D M<ÿ|9663ÿ97ÿzJCyJBGBG<ÿcd9613,ÿA.P3ÿL337ÿ21,-51L/-32ÿ6/5,/.7-ÿ-9ÿ-A3ÿOefÿHÿghKi ce7-3532jÿGzJCyJBGBGi CBÿ=lEplOÿ538.52178ÿCÿ=9-197Jo66?1:.-197ÿ495ÿn3.P3ÿ-9ÿm59:332ÿ17ÿ495;.ÿ6./6351,ÿLD m?.17-144ÿt1.9D3ÿu.1<ÿcghKiÿce7-3532jÿCGJGIJBGBGi CQÿ=pO{EeKÿlfÿmhldeegpONKÿHÿe.5?Dÿ=321.-197ÿd9743537:3ÿA3?2ÿ97ÿCGJFJBGBGÿL34953 =321.-95ÿg.P12ÿK-36A37,<ÿd5-5;ÿo2;171,-5.-95jÿ ÿ ÿm?.ÿd9/7,3?jÿ ÿ ÿ ÿg34ÿd9/7,3?jÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ¡ ÿ¢ £ ¡ ¤ ÿ ÿ ÿ ¥ ÿ¡ ¦ ÿE1;3ÿ94ÿs3.5178jÿ§§¨§©ÿ ª§¨«©ÿ¬ ÿC,;321.-197ÿ,3,,197<ÿoÿ,3--?3;37-ÿ@.,ÿOlEÿ53.:A32<ÿEA1,ÿ:.,3ÿ1,ÿ53-/5732ÿ-9ÿ-A3ÿ795;.? ?1-18.-197ÿ-5.:q<ÿR]Tÿ\Y[­`ÿ[^^[S®`¯bÿcd9613,ÿA.P3ÿL337ÿ21,-51L/-32ÿ6/5,/.7-ÿ-9ÿ-A3ÿOefÿH Ksiÿce7-3532jÿCGJGFJBGBGi CvÿKEoE{KÿhemlhEÿ °¬¬ ÿ ÿ± ¬ ÿ £ÿ ÿ ÿ± ¨ÿ± ° ÿ £ÿ²«ª ÿ LDÿg34372.7-,ÿg.7.ÿs9@5Drÿh3/L.5-<ÿcx.7K1:q?3rÿw.23iÿce7-3532jÿCGJCBJBGBGi Ckÿlhgehÿ85.7-178ÿCÿ=9-197Jo66?1:.-197ÿ495ÿn3.P3ÿ-9ÿm59:332ÿ17ÿ495;.ÿ6./6351,<ÿm?.17-144 1,ÿ.??9@32ÿ-9ÿ659:332ÿ@1-A9/-ÿ6536.D;37-ÿ94ÿ41?178ÿ433,<ÿoÿ:96Dÿ94ÿ-A1,ÿ95235ÿ,A.??ÿL3 495@.5232ÿ-9ÿp7;.-3ÿK35P1:3,ÿ495ÿ6.D;37-ÿ17495;.-197<ÿÿ EA3ÿd?35qÿ1,ÿ2153:-32ÿ-9ÿ,35P3ÿ.ÿ:96Dÿ94ÿ-A3ÿkÿd9;6?.17-.72ÿ-A1,ÿ95235ÿ3?3:-5971:.??Dÿ/697 -A3ÿo--9573DÿN3735.?},ÿl441:3ÿ495ÿ-A3ÿK-.-3ÿ94ÿO3P.2.<ÿEA3ÿoN},ÿ9441:3ÿ,A.??ÿ41?3ÿ79-1:3 @1-Aÿ-A3ÿ:9/5-ÿ538.52178ÿ53653,37-.-197ÿ.72ÿ,35P1:3ÿ.,ÿ9/-?1732ÿ17ÿ-A3ÿ95235ÿLDÿCCJQJBGBG<ÿÿ 711 0 1 ! " 1 # $ %&033 8'82(0 24() *+4+8 4 10 01231245ÿ2788ÿ9 <=NA=NA=A= <=NA<NA=A= <=NA<NA=A= <=NAANA=A= <=NAbNA=A= <<N=ANA=A= <<N=ANA=A= <<N=~NA=A= <<N<=NA=A= <<N<ANA=A= <<NAONA=A= <<NO=NA=A= <<NO=NA=A= 1 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,-.ÿ01234ÿ5234-.3ÿ6.78.9ÿ:9ÿ;114ÿ<=ÿ>14817ÿ3.?:3@87?ÿ;.@8:4817ÿ:7@ÿ4-.ÿ<Aÿ>14817ÿ41 B31C..@ÿ87ÿD13;:ÿB:2B.389EÿF..ÿG3@.3ÿD13ÿ:@@84817:Hÿ87D13;:4817ÿ:7@ÿ@.:@H87.9Eÿ F8?7.@ÿIJÿ>:?8943:4.ÿK2@?.ÿL:7CJÿKEÿM1BB.ÿ17ÿ<=N<ONA=A=EÿP01B8.9ÿ-:Q.ÿI..7ÿ@89438I24.@ B2392:74ÿ41ÿ4-.ÿLR5Sÿ00ÿ41ÿ587:7C.ÿ:7@ÿT7;:4.ÿF.3Q8C.9ÿUÿ6VFWÿPR74.3.@Xÿ<=N<ONA=A=W <Yÿ>G,TGLÿD13ÿF.3Q8C.ÿ41ÿI.ÿ01;BH.4.@ÿIJÿ4-.ÿZFÿ>:39-:H9ÿIJÿ[H:8748DDÿ\8:1J.ÿ]:8E V.9B179.9ÿ@2.ÿIJÿ<<NONA=A=EÿP^44:C-;.749Xÿ_ÿ<ÿ[31B19.@ÿF2;;179.9WÿP^]WÿPR74.3.@X <=NA=NA=A=W <`ÿGV6RVÿ6.7J87?ÿ:9ÿB3.;:423.ÿBH:8748DDa9ÿ<Yÿ>14817ÿD13ÿF.3Q8C.EÿF8?7.@ÿIJÿ>:?8943:4. K2@?.ÿL:7CJÿKEÿM1BB.ÿ17ÿ<=NA<NA=A=EÿP01B8.9ÿ-:Q.ÿI..7ÿ@89438I24.@ÿB2392:74ÿ41ÿ4-.ÿLR5ÿU 6VFWÿPR74.3.@Xÿ<=NA<NA=A=W <bÿ>G,TGLÿD13ÿ^BB1874;.74ÿ1Dÿ01279.HÿIJÿ[H:8748DDÿ\8:1J.ÿ]:8EÿP6VFWÿPR74.3.@X <=NAANA=A=W <cÿdR,,RVÿD31;ÿ\8:1ÿe.ÿ]:8ÿ3.ÿ<Aÿ>14817ÿPd.44.3WEÿ>3ÿ]:8ÿ:@Q89.9ÿ4-.ÿC1234ÿ4-89ÿH.44.3ÿ89 :C42:HHJÿD13ÿ:ÿ@8DD.3.74ÿC8Q8Hÿ:C4817fÿ714ÿJ.4ÿD8H.@EÿP6VFWÿPR74.3.@Xÿ<=NAANA=A=W A=ÿVRF[GLFRÿ41ÿ<bÿ>14817ÿD13ÿ^BB1874;.74ÿ1Dÿ01279.HÿIJÿ6.D.7@:74ÿ^44137.Jÿg.7.3:H F4:4.ÿ1DÿL.Q:@:EÿV.BH8.9ÿ@2.ÿIJÿ<<NhNA=A=EÿP^44:C-;.749Xÿ_ÿ<ÿRi-8I84ÿ^ÿF4:4.;.74fÿ_ÿA Ri-8I84ÿ]ÿ^VÿAhcfÿ_ÿOÿ6.CH:3:4817ÿ1DÿK:Cj2.9ÿg3:-:;WÿPk:7F8ClH.fÿm:@.WÿPR74.3.@X <=NAbNA=A=W A<ÿLG,T0Rÿ1Dÿnoopqrstopÿvwÿxpyz{opÿIJÿ:44137.Jÿm:@.ÿKEÿk:7F8ClH.ÿ17ÿI.-:HDÿ1D 6.D.7@:749ÿ|:H9.Jfÿ6:7:ÿ|1}3JfÿV.2I:34EÿPk:7F8ClH.fÿm:@.Wÿ>1@8D8.@ÿ.Q.74ÿ17 <<NONA=A=ÿP>>>WEÿPR74.3.@Xÿ<<N=ANA=A=W AOÿLG,T0Rÿ1DÿZ7@.3ÿF.:HÿF2I;899817ÿ1Dÿd:94ÿM71}7ÿ^@@3.99.9ÿIJÿ|:H9.Jfÿ6:7:ÿ|1}3Jf V.2I:34ÿ3.ÿ<hÿG3@.3EÿPk:7F8ClH.fÿm:@.Wÿ>1@8D8.@ÿ17ÿ<<NONA=A=ÿ41ÿ3.DH.C4ÿC133.C4ÿ@1Cl.4 .743Jÿ3.H:48179-8BÿPR74.3.@Xÿ<<N=ANA=A=W A~ÿ>G,TGLNd.44.3ÿD13ÿT992:7C.ÿ1DÿF2;;179ÿD13ÿ279.3Q.@ÿ@.D.7@:749Sÿ:7@ÿ3.ÿR05ÿL1Eÿ<Y >14817ÿD13ÿ9.3Q8C.ÿIJÿZFÿ>:3-9:H9fÿIJÿ[H:8748DDÿ\8:1J.ÿ]:8EÿV.9B179.9ÿ@2.ÿIJ <<N<cNA=A=EÿP6V>WÿPR74.3.@Xÿ<<N=~NA=A=W AhÿVR[deÿ41ÿV.9B179.ÿPR05ÿL1EÿA=ÿWÿ41ÿR05ÿL1Eÿ<bÿ>14817ÿD13ÿ^BB1874;.74ÿ1Dÿ01279.HÿIJ [H:8748DDÿ\8:1J.ÿ]:8EÿP^]WÿPR74.3.@Xÿ<<N<=NA=A=W AYÿGV6RVÿ@.7J87?ÿ<bÿ>14817ÿD13ÿ^BB1874;.74ÿ1Dÿ01279.HÿF8?7.@ÿIJÿ>:?8943:4.ÿK2@?. L:7CJÿKEÿM1BB.ÿ17ÿ<<N<ANA=A=EP01B8.9ÿ-:Q.ÿI..7ÿ@89438I24.@ÿB2392:74ÿ41ÿ4-.ÿLR5ÿUÿ6VFW PR74.3.@Xÿ<<N<ONA=A=W A`ÿGV6RVÿ?3:7487?ÿA~ÿ>14817ÿD13ÿF.3Q8C.ÿIJÿZF>FEÿ,-.ÿ0H.3lÿ89ÿ@83.C4.@ÿ41ÿ;:8Hÿ41 [H:8748DDÿ,mGÿC1B8.9ÿ1Dÿ:ÿZF>UAchfÿ:7@ÿ41ÿ8992.ÿ92;;179ÿ41ÿ6.D.7@:749ÿ0H:3lÿ:7@ |:;;.HÿZL6RVÿFR^dÿ:7@ÿB31Q8@.ÿ9:;.ÿ41ÿ4-.ÿZF>FÿD13ÿ9.3Q8C.Eÿ}84-ÿ:ÿC1BJÿ1Dÿ4-89 13@.3ÿ:7@ÿ4-.ÿhÿC1;BH:874Eÿ[H:8748DDÿ-:9ÿA=ÿ@:J9ÿ41ÿC1;BH.4.ÿ:7@ÿD23789-ÿ4-.ÿZF>UAchÿ41 4-.ÿ>:39-:Ha9ÿ9.3Q8C.ÿP6.D4ÿ:@@3.99.9ÿ1;844.@WEÿZB17ÿ3.C.8B4ÿ1Dÿ4-.ÿD13;9fÿ4-.ÿZF>Fÿ9-:HH -:Q.ÿA=ÿ@:J9ÿ41ÿ.DD.C4ÿ9.3Q8C.EÿF..ÿG3@.3ÿD13ÿ:@@84817:Hÿ@.4:8HEÿF8?7.@ÿIJÿ>:?8943:4.ÿK2@?. L:7CJÿKEÿM1BB.ÿ17ÿ<<NAONA=A=EÿP01B8.9ÿ-:Q.ÿI..7ÿ@89438I24.@ÿB2392:74ÿ41ÿ4-.ÿLR5Sÿ,}1 C1B8.9ÿ1DÿZF>ÿAchÿ;:8H.@ÿ41ÿ[Sÿovqÿvwÿ y pyÿrvÿ x xÿUÿ6VFWÿ>1@8D8.@ÿ17ÿ<<NA~NA=A= P6VFWEÿPR74.3.@Xÿ<<NA~NA=A=W Abÿ>G,TGLÿUÿV.j2.94ÿD13ÿV.9B179.9ÿ3.ÿR05ÿL1Eÿ<Yÿ>14817ÿD13ÿF.3Q8C.ÿ41ÿI.ÿ01;BH.4.@ÿIJ 4-.ÿZFÿ>:39-:H9fÿR05ÿL1EÿA~ÿ>14817Nd.44.3ÿD13ÿT992:7C.ÿ1DÿF2;;179ÿD13ÿ279.3Q.@ @.D.7@:749fÿIJÿ[H:8748DDÿ\8:1J.ÿ]:8EÿV.9B179.9ÿ@2.ÿIJÿ<AN<~NA=A=EÿPMVWÿPR74.3.@X <<NO=NA=A=W O=ÿGV6RVÿ6.7J87?ÿ:9ÿ;114ÿAbÿ>14817EÿF8?7.@ÿIJÿ>:?8943:4.ÿK2@?.ÿL:7CJÿKEÿM1BB.ÿ17 711 0 1 ! " 1 # $ %&033 8'82(0 24() *+4+8 4 310 01231245ÿ2788ÿ9 ,,-./-0/0/ ,0-/,-0/0/ ,0-/0-0/0/ ,0-/u-0/0/ ,0-,,-0/0/ ,0-,l-0/0/ ,0-,~-0/0/ ,0-0.-0/0/ ,0-0q-0/0/ /,-/~-0/0, /,-/e-0/0, /,-,,-0/0, /,-0e-0/0, /,-0e-0/0, 1 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,,-./-0/0/12345678ÿ:;<7ÿ=77>ÿ?68@A6=B@7?ÿ5BA8B;>@ÿ@4ÿ@:7ÿCDEÿFÿGHIJÿ2D>@7A7?K ,,-./-0/0/J .,ÿLMNOMCÿFÿPQRSQTUÿWXYÿUZQÿ[\QY]ÿUXÿ[X^_\QUQÿUZQÿ`aYQbUQcdÿA7ÿD3EÿC41ÿ0eÿMA?7Adÿ=f gh;6>@6iiÿj6;4f7ÿk;61ÿH7854>878ÿ?B7ÿ=fÿ,0-,l-0/0/1ÿ2mHJÿ2D>@7A7?Kÿ,0-/,-0/0/J .0ÿCMNO3Dÿ4iÿ34n5h6;>o7ÿA7ÿpILF0qrdÿ=fÿj6;4f7ÿk;6ÿ2GHLJÿ2D>@7A7?Kÿ,0-/,-0/0/J ..ÿMHGDHÿG7>f6>sÿ;8ÿn44@ÿ.,ÿL4@64>1ÿI6s>7?ÿ=fÿL;s68@A;@7ÿtB?s7ÿC;>ofÿt1ÿm4557ÿ4> ,0-0-0/0/1ÿ2345678ÿ:;<7ÿ=77>ÿ?68@A6=B@7?ÿ5BA8B;>@ÿ@4ÿ@:7ÿCDEÿFÿGHIJÿ2D>@7A7?K ,0-/0-0/0/J .lÿLMNOMCÿ@4ÿ34>i6Anÿ87A<6o7ÿ=fÿp1I1ÿL;A8:;hdÿ=fÿgh;6>@6iiÿj6;4f7ÿk;61ÿH7854>878ÿ?B7ÿ=f ,0-0.-0/0/1ÿ2GHLJÿ2D>@7A7?Kÿ,0-/u-0/0/J .rÿvCIwDHÿ@4ÿrÿ34n5h;6>@ÿx6@:ÿtBAfÿG7n;>?ÿi6h7?ÿ=fÿy;h87fdÿG;>;ÿy4xAfdÿH7B=;A@1 G68o4<7Afÿgh;>-Io:7?Bh6>sÿMA?7Aÿ?B7ÿ=fÿ,-,/-0/0,12z;>I6o{h7dÿw;?7J CMNO3Dÿ4iÿ37A@6i6o;@7ÿ4iÿO>@7A78@7?ÿg;A@678ÿA7|B6A7n7>@Kÿp>?7Aÿ}4o;hÿHBh7ÿe1,F,dÿ;ÿ5;A@f nB8@ÿ6nn7?6;@7hfÿi6h7ÿ6@8ÿ?68oh48BA7ÿ8@;@7n7>@ÿx6@:ÿ6@8ÿi6A8@ÿ;557;A;>o7dÿ5h7;?6>sdÿ57@6@64>d n4@64>dÿA7854>87dÿ4Aÿ4@:7AÿA7|B78@ÿ;??A7887?ÿ@4ÿ@:7ÿo4BA@1ÿ2D>@7A7?Kÿ,0-,,-0/0/J .~ÿI3yDGp}OCÿMHGDH1ÿG68o4<7Afÿ?B7ÿ=fÿ.-,r-0/0,1ÿL4@64>8ÿ?B7ÿ=fÿl-,l-0/0,1ÿN:7 5;A@678ÿ8:;hhÿi6h7ÿ;ÿt46>@ÿgA7@A6;hÿMA?7Aÿ@:6A@fÿ2./Jÿ?;f8ÿ5;8@ÿ@:7ÿ?;@7ÿi4Aÿi6h6>sÿn4@64>8ÿi4A 8Bnn;Afÿ B?sn7>@1ÿO>ÿ@:7ÿ7<7>@ÿ?685486@6<7ÿn4@64>8ÿ;A7ÿi6h7?dÿ@:7ÿ?;@7ÿi4Aÿi6h6>sÿ@:7ÿ 46>@ 5A7@A6;hÿ4A?7Aÿ8:;hhÿ=7ÿ8B857>?7?ÿB>@6hÿ@:6A@fÿ2./Jÿ?;f8ÿ;i@7Aÿ;ÿ?7o6864>ÿ4iÿ@:7ÿ?685486@6<7 n4@64>8ÿ4AÿB>@6hÿiBA@:7Aÿ4A?7Aÿ4iÿ@:7ÿo4BA@1ÿI6s>7?ÿ=fÿL;s68@A;@7ÿtB?s7ÿC;>ofÿt1ÿm4557ÿ4> ,0-,l-0/0/1ÿ2345678ÿ:;<7ÿ=77>ÿ?68@A6=B@7?ÿ5BA8B;>@ÿ@4ÿ@:7ÿCDEÿFÿGHIJÿ2D>@7A7?K ,0-,l-0/0/J .eÿvLDCGDGÿLMNOMCÿi4AÿH7o4>86?7A;@64>ÿA7ÿD3EÿC41ÿ0~ÿMA?7Aÿ4>ÿD3EÿC41ÿ,uÿL4@64> i4Aÿv5546>@n7>@ÿ4iÿ34B>87h1ÿ=fÿgh;6>@6iiÿj6;4f7ÿk;61ÿH7854>878ÿ?B7ÿ=fÿ,0-./-0/0/1ÿ2mHJ 2D>@7A7?Kÿ,0-,~-0/0/J .qÿHDIgMCIDÿ@4ÿ.eÿL4@64>ÿi4AÿH7o4>86?7A;@64>ÿ=fÿG7i7>?;>@8ÿy;h87fdÿG;>;ÿy4xAfd H7B=;A@1ÿH75h678ÿ?B7ÿ=fÿ,0-./-0/0/1ÿ2z;>I6o{h7dÿw;?7Jÿ2D>@7A7?Kÿ,0-0.-0/0/J .uÿLMNOMCÿWXYÿ ^Q cÿ bZQcS\a ÿ YcQYQcdÿA7ÿD3EÿC41ÿ.~ÿIo:7?Bh6>sÿMA?7Adÿ=fÿgh;6>@6ii j6;4f7ÿk;61ÿ2mHJÿ2D>@7A7?Kÿ,0-0q-0/0/J l/ÿLMNOMCÿ@4ÿD @7>?ÿN6n7ÿi4AÿI7A<6o7ÿi4Aÿ;>ÿv55A45A6;@7ÿg7A64?ÿA7ÿD3EÿC41ÿ,rÿMA?7Aÿ=f gh;6>@6iiÿj6;4f7ÿk;61ÿ2vkJÿ2D>@7A7?Kÿ/,-/~-0/0,J l,ÿvCIwDHÿ@4ÿrÿ34n5h;6>@ÿi6h7?ÿ=fÿ3h;A{dÿy;h87fdÿG;>;ÿy4xAfdÿH7B=;A@12z;>I6o{h7dÿw;?7J 2D>@7A7?Kÿ/,-/e-0/0,J l0ÿ}DNNDHÿ@4ÿ3h7A{ÿA7ÿC4ÿH7854>87ÿ34>o7A>8dÿ=fÿgh;6>@6iiÿj6;4f7ÿk;61ÿ2mHJÿ2D>@7A7?K /,-,,-0/0,J l.ÿMHGDHÿsA;>@6>sÿ.uÿL4@64>ÿ@4ÿD @7>?ÿN6n7ÿi4AÿG68o4<7AfÿG7;?h6>781ÿG68o4<7Afÿ?B7ÿ=f r-,0-0/0,1ÿL4@64>8ÿ?B7ÿ=fÿ~-,l-0/0,1ÿgA45487?ÿt46>@ÿgA7@A6;hÿMA?7Aÿ?B7ÿ=fÿe-,l-0/0,1 I6s>7?ÿ=fÿL;s68@A;@7ÿtB?s7ÿC;>ofÿt1ÿm4557ÿ4>ÿ,-0e-0/0,1ÿ2345678ÿ:;<7ÿ=77>ÿ?68@A6=B@7? 5BA8B;>@ÿ@4ÿ@:7ÿCDEÿFÿGHIJÿ2D>@7A7?Kÿ/,-0e-0/0,J llÿMHGDHÿA;>@6>sÿ6>ÿ5;A@ÿ;>?ÿG7>f6>sÿ6>ÿ5;A@ÿ.lÿL4@64>ÿ@4ÿo4>i6Anÿ87A<6o7ÿ=fÿ@:7ÿp>6@7? I@;@78ÿL;A8:;h1ÿN:7ÿ3h7A{ÿ8:;hhÿ?7h6<7Aÿ@4ÿpILIÿ@:7ÿpILF0qrÿh4o;@7?ÿ;@ÿ.0ÿdÿ51ÿr1 ?7;?h6>7ÿ@4ÿ7ii7o@B;@7ÿ87A<6o7ÿ4>ÿG7i7>?;>@ÿy;nn7hÿ68ÿ:7A7=fÿDjNDCGDGÿ@4ÿv5A6hÿ,0d 0/0,1ÿ N:7ÿ34BA@ÿiBA@:7AÿA;>@8ÿ6>ÿ5;A@ÿ;>?ÿG7>678ÿ6>ÿ5;A@ÿl/ÿL4@64>ÿ@4ÿD @7>?ÿN6n7ÿ@6n7ÿ@4 711 0 1 ! " 1 # $ %&033 8'82(0 24() *+4+8 4 )10 01231245ÿ2788ÿ9 VRSTUSTVTR VRSTUSTVTR VRSTgSTVTR VRSTgSTVTR VRSTgSTVTR VTSVTSTVTR VTSV\STVTR VTSTbSTVTR VTST`STVTR VTST]STVTR VTSTcSTVTR VbST]STVTR V`SRTSTVTR V`SRbSTVTR V`SR`STVTR 1 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,--,./01/,ÿ3,456.,7ÿ89,ÿ:;/6;<ÿ63ÿ=>?@8ABÿC6/9ÿ4,3D,./ÿ/;ÿB,-,<E1</ÿF1::,Gÿ1<E BA@HABÿC6/9ÿ4,3D,./ÿ/;ÿB,-,<E1</ÿIG14J7ÿK6L<,EÿMNÿO1L63/41/,ÿP0EL,ÿ@1<.NÿP7ÿQ;DD,ÿ;< RSTUSTVTR7ÿWI;D6,3ÿ915,ÿM,,<ÿE63/46M0/,EÿD04301</ÿ/;ÿ/9,ÿ@AXYÿ.;DNÿ;-ÿZKO[T\]ÿ3,</ÿ/; ZKOKÿ[ÿB>K^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿVRSTUSTVTR^ `]ÿa>BA>ÿB,<N6<LÿbUÿO;/6;<ÿ-;4ÿ>,.;<36E,41/6;<7ÿK6L<,EÿMNÿO1L63/41/,ÿP0EL,ÿ@1<.NÿP7 Q;DD,ÿ;<ÿRSTUSTVTR7ÿWI;D6,3ÿ915,ÿM,,<ÿE63/46M0/,EÿD04301</ÿ/;ÿ/9,ÿ@AXÿ[ÿB>K^ÿWA</,4,E_ VRSTUSTVTR^ `cÿa>BA>ÿ>,_ÿ`Tÿd,//,4ÿ-4;:ÿe61;N,ÿf167ÿK6L<,EÿMNÿO1L63/41/,ÿP0EL,ÿ@1<.NÿP7ÿQ;DD,ÿ;< RSTUSTVTR7ÿWI;D6,3ÿ915,ÿM,,<ÿE63/46M0/,EÿD04301</ÿ/;ÿ/9,ÿ@AXÿ[ÿB>K^ÿWA</,4,E_ VRSTUSTVTR^ `UÿOa8Ha@ÿ[ÿ>,h0,3/ÿ-;4ÿ>,3D;<3,3ÿ/;ÿAIXÿ@;7ÿbUÿO;/6;<ÿ1<Eÿa/9,4ÿ>,G,51</ÿO;/6;<3 WAIXÿ@;7ÿbgÿ1<Eÿ@;7ÿ`Vÿ^iÿMNÿjG16</6--ÿe61;N,ÿf167ÿ>,3D;<3,3ÿE0,ÿMNÿTSRTSTVTR7ÿWQ>^ WA</,4,E_ÿVRSTgSTVTR^ `\ÿ@a8HIAÿ;-ÿI91<L,ÿ;-ÿB,D0/Nÿ?//;4<,Nÿ=,<,41Gÿ;<ÿM,91G-ÿ;-ÿB,-,<E1</3ÿF1G3,NiÿB1<1 F;C4Niÿ>,0M14/7ÿB,D0/Nÿ?//;4<,Nÿ=,<,41Gÿk1E,ÿP7ÿl1<K6.JG,ÿ/,4:6<1/,E7ÿW=0Ni I9463/;D9,4^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿVRSTgSTVTR^ `gÿa>BA>ÿB,<N6<Lÿ13ÿ:;;/ÿ`UÿO;/6;<7ÿK6L<,EÿMNÿO1L63/41/,ÿP0EL,ÿ@1<.NÿP7ÿQ;DD,ÿ;< RSTgSTVTR7ÿWI;D6,3ÿ915,ÿM,,<ÿE63/46M0/,EÿD04301</ÿ/;ÿ/9,ÿ@AXÿ[ÿB>K^ÿWA</,4,E_ VRSTgSTVTR^ ]VÿafPAI8Ha@ÿ/;ÿAIXÿ@;7ÿ`]ÿa4E,4ÿ;<ÿO;/6;<ÿ/;ÿ>,.;<36E,4iÿMNÿjG16</6--ÿe61;N,ÿf167 WB>O^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿVTSVTSTVTR^ ]RÿI;DNÿ;-ÿ@AXÿ-;4ÿAIXÿ@;7ÿ]Vÿ1<EÿafPAI8Ha@ÿ/;ÿAIXÿ@;7ÿ`]ÿa4E,4ÿ;<ÿO;/6;<ÿ/; >,.;<36E,4iÿMNÿjG16</6--ÿe61;N,ÿf167ÿW?DD,143ÿ6E,</6.1Gÿ/;ÿAIXÿ@;7ÿ]VÿaMm,./6;<iÿ,n.,D/ 36L<1/04,ÿ1EE,Eÿ;<ÿD1L,ÿ-65,7^ÿWQ>^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿVTSVgSTVTR^ ]`ÿOa8Ha@ÿ[ÿ>,h0,3/ÿ-;4ÿ>,DG6,3ÿ/;ÿAIXÿ@;7ÿ]VÿaMm,./6;<ÿj04301</ÿ/;ÿd>ÿHfÿb[RW1^WM^iÿMN jG16</6--ÿe61;N,ÿf167ÿ>,3D;<3,3ÿE0,ÿMNÿbSgSTVTR7ÿWQ>^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿVTSTbSTVTR^ ]]ÿopqrstuvÿxyÿz{ÿ|q}uq~ÿOa8Ha@ÿ/;ÿ>,h0,3/ÿO,,/ÿ1<EÿI;<-,4ÿO,,/6<LÿMNÿjG16</6--ÿe61;N, f167ÿ>,3D;<3,3ÿE0,ÿMNÿbSRVSTVTR7ÿWF?O^ÿO;E6-6,Eÿ;<ÿTSTcSTVTRÿWB>K^7ÿO;E6-6,Eÿ;< TSTcSTVTRÿWABK^7ÿWA</,4,E_ÿVTST]STVTR^ ]cÿ=,<,41Gÿa4E,4ÿ[ÿX6-/9ÿ?:,<E,Eÿ=,<,41Gÿa4E,4ÿTVRT[VRÿ4,ÿ:1<E1/;4NÿA[-6G6<Lÿ-;4ÿ.13,3ÿMN 6<:1/,3ÿ1/ÿ@@IIiÿdIIiÿAKjiÿ1<EÿFBKj7ÿAG,./4;<6.ÿ-6G6<Lÿ;-ÿD463;<,4ÿ-6G6<L3ÿ913ÿM,,< 6:DG,:,</,E7ÿ?GGÿD463;<,4ÿ-6G6<L3ÿ6<ÿ1GGÿ-,E,41Gÿ.13,3ÿM,-;4,ÿ/963ÿI;04/iÿ6<.G0E6<Lÿ.656G 46L9/3ÿ1<Eÿ91M,13ÿ.;4D03ÿ.13,3iÿ:03/ÿM,ÿ-6G,Eÿ,G,./4;<6.1GGNÿ1/ÿ/9;3,ÿ-1.6G6/6,3ÿC96.9ÿ915, 6:DG,:,</,Eÿ,G,./4;<6.ÿ-6G6<L37ÿWF?O^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿVTST]STVTR^ ]Uÿa>BA>ÿ3/46J6<Lÿ]]ÿO;/6;<ÿ/;ÿ>,h0,3/ÿO,,/ÿ1<EÿI;<-,4ÿO,,/6<L7ÿK6L<,EÿMNÿO1L63/41/, P0EL,ÿ@1<.NÿP7ÿQ;DD,ÿ;<ÿTSTcSTVTR7ÿWI;D6,3ÿ915,ÿM,,<ÿE63/46M0/,EÿD04301</ÿ/;ÿ/9,ÿ@AXÿ[ B>K^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿVTSTcSTVTR^ ]\ÿK,.;<EÿOa8Ha@ÿ>,h0,3/ÿ-;4ÿ>,DG6,3ÿ/;ÿAIXÿ@;7ÿ]VÿaMm,./6;<iÿMNÿjG16</6--ÿe61;N,ÿf167 >,3D;<3,3ÿE0,ÿMNÿ`S\STVTR7ÿWQ>^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿVbSTcSTVTR^ ]gÿOa8Ha@ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ  iÿMNÿjG16</6--ÿe61;N, f167ÿ>,3D;<3,3ÿE0,ÿMNÿ`STcSTVTR7ÿWQ>^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿV`SRTSTVTR^ cVÿ@a@[ajjaKH8Ha@ÿ/;ÿ]gÿO;/6;<ÿ/;ÿ?:,<ESI;44,./ÿMNÿB,-,<E1</3ÿF1G3,NiÿB1<1ÿF;C4Ni >,0M14/7ÿW=0NiÿI9463/;D9,4^ÿWA</,4,E_ÿV`SRbSTVTR^ cRÿo ÿ uqÿ ÿdA88A>ÿ/;ÿI9463/;D9,4ÿO7ÿ=0Niÿ-4;:ÿe61;N,ÿf167ÿW?//1.9:,</3_ÿ ÿR I;5,4ÿd,//,4^ÿWB>O^ÿO;E6-6,Eÿ1..,33ÿ;<ÿ`SRcSTVTR7ÿd,//,4ÿC13ÿ6</,<E,Eÿ;<GNÿ-;4ÿ/9, 711 0 1 ! " 1 # $ %&033 8'82(0 24() *+4+8 4 10 01231245ÿ2788ÿ9 JKLMOLNJNM JKL[JLNJNM JTLJYLNJNM JTLMKLNJNM JTLMOLNJNM JTLNKLNJNM JTLNTLNJNM JTLNTLNJNM JTLNZLNJNM JPLMMLNJNM JPLNNLNJNM JYLMNLNJNM JYLMPLNJNM JYLNNLNJNM JYLNPLNJNM 1 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,-./ÿ122345ÿ678ÿ79:ÿ:9ÿ;5ÿ<=6458ÿ97ÿ:>5ÿ894?5:@ÿA9<Bÿ/57:ÿ:9ÿ,-./ÿ122345@ÿCDEFG@ CD7:5H58IÿJKLMKLNJNMG PNÿ1QEDQÿA97/:HR37SÿTOÿU9:397ÿ6/ÿ6ÿU9:397ÿ:9ÿDV:578ÿ8568=375/Wÿ678ÿ:>5ÿDV:57/397ÿ3/ -H67:58@ÿE3/49X5HBÿ8R5ÿ;BÿYLMNLNJNM@ÿU9:397/ÿ8R5ÿ;BÿZLM[LNJNM@ÿ\H9<9/58ÿ]937:ÿ\H5:H36= 1H85Hÿ8R5ÿ;BÿOLMKLNJNM@ÿF55ÿ1H85Hÿ29Hÿ6883:3976=ÿ8568=375/ÿ678ÿ37/:HR4:397/@ÿF3S758ÿ;B U6S3/:H6:5ÿ]R8S5ÿ^674Bÿ]@ÿ_9<<5ÿ97ÿKLMOLNJNM@ÿCA9<35/ÿ>6X5ÿ;557ÿ83/:H3;R:58ÿ<RH/R67:ÿ:9 :>5ÿ^D`ÿaÿEQFGÿCD7:5H58IÿJKLMOLNJNMG P[ÿU1bc1^ÿ29Hÿ,<<937:d57:ÿ92ÿA9R7/5=ÿ;Bÿ\=637:322ÿe369B5ÿf63@ÿC,fGÿCD7:5H58I JKL[JLNJNMG PKÿ1QEDQÿ857B37SÿTKÿU9:397ÿH5ÿQ5gR5/:ÿ29HÿQ5<=35/hÿ1QEDQÿ857B37SÿTZÿU9:397ÿH5 Q5gR5/:ÿ29HÿQ5<=35/@ÿF3S758ÿ;Bÿ]R8S5ÿ-=9H36ÿU@ÿ^6X6HH9ÿ97ÿTLYLNJNM@ÿCA9<35/ÿ>6X5ÿ;557 83/:H3;R:58ÿ<RH/R67:ÿ:9ÿ:>5ÿ^D`ÿaÿi,UGÿCD7:5H58IÿJTLJYLNJNMG PTÿQDF\1^FDÿ:9ÿP[ÿU9:397ÿ29Hÿ,<<937:d57:ÿ92ÿA9R7/5=ÿ;BÿE5257867:/ÿi6=/5BWÿE676 i9jHBWÿQ5R;6H:@ÿQ5<=35/ÿ8R5ÿ;BÿTLNMLNJNM@ÿC-RBWÿA>H3/:9<>5HGÿCD7:5H58IÿJTLMKLNJNMG PPÿQD\klÿ:9ÿDA`ÿ^9@ÿPTÿQ5/<97/5ÿH5ÿDA`ÿ^9@ÿP[ÿU9:397ÿ29Hÿ,<<937:d57:ÿ92ÿA9R7/5=Wÿ;B \=637:322ÿe369B5ÿf63@ÿCEQUGÿCD7:5H58IÿJTLMOLNJNMG PYÿmnopqrstÿvwxÿyzÿ^1bcADÿaÿA9<Bÿ92ÿA9HH5/<9785745Wÿ;Bÿ\=637:322ÿe369B5ÿf63@ C,::64>d57:/Iÿ{ÿMÿA9X5Hÿ79:5GÿC_QGÿU9832358ÿ6445//ÿ97ÿTLNTLNJNM@ÿk5::5Hÿj6/ÿ37:57858 97=Bÿ29Hÿ:>5ÿ,-./ÿ122345ÿ678ÿ79:ÿ:9ÿ;5ÿ<=6458ÿ97ÿ:>5ÿ894?5:ÿC/55ÿ6::64>d57:G@ÿCD7:5H58I JTLNTLNJNMG PZÿ1QEDQÿE57B37SÿP[ÿU9:397ÿ29Hÿ,<<937:d57:ÿ92ÿA9R7/5=@ÿF3S758ÿ;BÿU6S3/:H6:5ÿ]R8S5 ^674Bÿ]@ÿ_9<<5ÿ97ÿTLNTLNJNM@ÿCA9<35/ÿ>6X5ÿ;557ÿ83/:H3;R:58ÿ<RH/R67:ÿ:9ÿ:>5ÿ^D`ÿaÿEQFG CD7:5H58IÿJTLNPLNJNMG POÿ1QEDQÿFbQc_c^-ÿPYÿ^1bcADÿaÿA9<Bÿ92ÿA9HH5/<9785745ÿ678ÿPMÿkDbbDQÿ:9 A>H3/:9<>5HÿU@ÿ-RB@ÿE5257867:ÿ3/ÿ68X3/58ÿ:9ÿ456/5ÿ23=37Sÿ49HH5/<9785745ÿ:9ÿ85257/5 49R7/5=@ÿF3S758ÿ;BÿU6S3/:H6:5ÿ]R8S5ÿ^674Bÿ]@ÿ_9<<5ÿ97ÿTLNTLNJNM@ÿCA9<35/ÿ>6X5ÿ;557 83/:H3;R:58ÿ<RH/R67:ÿ:9ÿ:>5ÿ^D`ÿaÿEQFGÿCD7:5H58IÿJTLNPLNJNMG YJÿ1f]DAbc1^ÿU6S3/:H6:5ÿ]R8S5ÿ9H85Hÿ9HÿHR=37SÿR785HÿkQÿcfÿ[aNC6GÿH5ÿDA`ÿ^9@ÿPZÿ1H85H 97ÿU9:397ÿ29Hÿ,<<937:d57:ÿ92ÿA9R7/5=Wÿ;Bÿ\=637:322ÿe369B5ÿf63@ÿQ5/<97/5/ÿ8R5ÿ;B PLMMLNJNM@ÿCFAGÿCD7:5H58IÿJPLJMLNJNMG YNÿQDF\1^FDÿ:9ÿYJÿ1;|54:397L,<<56=ÿU6S3/:H6:5ÿ]R8S5ÿ1H85HLQR=37SÿkQÿcfÿ[aMÿ;B E5257867:/ÿi6=/5BWÿE676ÿi9jHBWÿQ5R;6H:@ÿC-RBWÿA>H3/:9<>5HGÿCD7:5H58IÿJPLMMLNJNMG Y[ÿQD\klÿ:9ÿDA`ÿ^9@ÿYNÿQ5/<97/5ÿ:9ÿDA`ÿ^9@ÿYJÿ1;|54:397L,<<56=ÿU6S3/:H6:5ÿ]R8S5 1H85HLQR=37Sÿ;Bÿ\=637:322ÿe369B5ÿf63@ÿCFAGÿCD7:5H58IÿJPLNNLNJNMG YKÿU1bc1^ÿ:9ÿDV:578ÿE568=375/ÿH5ÿDA`ÿ^9@ÿPNÿ1H85Hÿ;Bÿ\=637:322ÿe369B5ÿf63@ÿCFUQG CD7:5H58IÿJYLM[LNJNMG YTÿUc^}bDÿ1QEDQÿc^ÿAi,UfDQFÿ92ÿ:>5ÿi979H6;=5ÿU6S3/:H6:5ÿ]R8S5ÿ^674Bÿ]@ÿ_9<<5 97ÿYLMPLNJNM@ÿ}7=5//ÿ:>5ÿ49RH:ÿ9H85H/ÿ9:>5Hj3/5WÿjH3::57ÿ83/49X5HBWÿ374=R837Sÿ83/49X5HB H5gR5/:/Wÿ83/49X5HBÿH5/<97/5/Wÿ85<9/3:397ÿ79:345/Wÿ678ÿ85<9/3:397ÿ:H67/4H3<:/WÿdR/:ÿ79:ÿ;5 23=58ÿj3:>ÿ:>5ÿ49RH:@ÿl9RHÿ894Rd57:/ÿ6H5ÿH5:RH758ÿ>5H5j3:>@ÿF55ÿk946=ÿQR=5ÿNPaZ E94Rd57:/ÿd63=58ÿ;64?ÿ:9ÿ\@ÿC,::64>d57:/Iÿ{ÿMÿE3/49X5HBÿ894Rd57:/GCA9<35/ÿ>6X5ÿ;557 83/:H3;R:58ÿ<RH/R67:ÿ:9ÿ:>5ÿ^D`ÿaÿEQFGÿCD7:5H58IÿJYLMPLNJNMG YPÿ^1^a1\\1Fcbc1^ÿ:9ÿYKÿU9:397ÿ:9ÿDV:578LF>9H:57ÿb3d5ÿ;BÿE5257867:/ÿA=6H?Wÿi6=/5BW E676ÿi9jHBWÿQ5R;6H:@ÿC-RBWÿA>H3/:9<>5HGÿCD7:5H58IÿJYLNNLNJNMG YYÿ1QEDQÿSH67:37SÿYKÿU9:397ÿ:9ÿDV:578ÿb3d5hÿE3/49X5HBÿ8R5ÿ;BÿZLMMLNJNM@ÿU9:397/ÿ8R5ÿ;B 711 0 1 ! " 1 # $ %&033 8'82(0 24() *+4+8 4 (10 01231245ÿ2788ÿ9 0X-.0-/0/. 0X-.X-/0/. 0X-.,-/0/. 0X-/0-/0/. 0,-.K-/0/. 0,-.K-/0/. 0,-.K-/0/. 1 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,-./-/0/.1ÿ34565789ÿ:5;<=ÿ348=4;>?ÿ@4984ÿ9A8ÿBCÿ.0-.D-/0/.1ÿE;F<89ÿBCÿG>F;7=4>=8ÿ:A9F8 H><ICÿ:1ÿJ5668ÿ5<ÿK-/L-/0/.1ÿMN56;87ÿO>P8ÿB88<ÿ9;7=4;BA=89ÿ6A47A><=ÿ=5ÿ=O8ÿHQRÿSÿTUEV MQ<=8489Wÿ0K-/L-/0/.V K,ÿG@YZ@Hÿ[U8\A87=ÿ:A9F]8<=[ÿ48ÿQNRÿH51ÿK0ÿ@B^8I=;5<_ÿBCÿ3?>;<=;``ÿa;>5C8ÿb>;1 U8765<787ÿ9A8ÿBCÿX-/D-/0/.1ÿMEGUVÿMQ<=8489Wÿ0X-.0-/0/.V X0ÿG@YZ@HÿcdefdghÿjklÿmggnghopqdÿBCÿ3?>;<=;``ÿa;>5C8ÿb>;1ÿU8765<787ÿ9A8ÿBCÿ,-.-/0/.1 MEGUVÿMQ<=8489Wÿ0X-.X-/0/.V X.ÿrH@33@EQTÿG@YZ@HÿY@ÿEYstÿTZE3@EZYZuQÿTQsTvZHQEÿ48ÿKKÿ@4984ÿ5<ÿG5=;5< =5ÿQw=8<9-EO54=8<ÿY;]8___ÿBCÿT8`8<9><=7ÿN?>4x_ÿy>?78C_ÿT><>ÿy5z4C_ÿU8AB>4=1 Ms==>IO]8<=7Wÿ{ÿ.ÿQwO;B;=ÿsÿT8I?>4>=;5<ÿ5`ÿN5A<78?VÿM|AC_ÿNO4;7=56O84VÿMQ<=8489W 0X-.,-/0/.V X/ÿGZHrYQÿ@UTQUÿZHÿNysGbQUEÿ5`ÿ=O8ÿy5<54>B?8ÿ:A9F8ÿ|?54;>ÿG1ÿH>P>445ÿ5< X-/0-/0/.1 38<9;<FÿB8`548ÿ=O8ÿN5A4=ÿ;7ÿ=O8ÿX.ÿr<5665789ÿG5=;5<ÿ=5ÿE=>CÿT;7657;=;P8ÿT8>9?;<87ÿ`;?89 BCÿT8`8<9><=7ÿT><ÿN?>4x_ÿT>P;9ÿy>?78C_ÿT><>ÿy5z4C_ÿ><9ÿ};??;>]ÿU8AB>4=ÿMI5??8I=;P8?C_ [T8`8<9><=7[V1ÿT8`8<9><=7ÿ48\A87=ÿ=O>=ÿ=O8ÿN5A4=ÿ7=>Cÿ=O8ÿ9;7657;=;P8ÿ]5=;5<7ÿ98>9?;<8ÿ`54 =O;4=CÿM~0Vÿ9>C7ÿ`54ÿ=O8ÿ6>4=;87ÿ=5ÿ65=8<=;>??Cÿ78==?8ÿ><9ÿ4875?P8ÿ=O8ÿ;<7=><=ÿI>781ÿ3?>;<=;`` a;>5C8ÿb>;ÿ9587ÿ<5=ÿ566578ÿ>ÿ~0S9>Cÿ7=>C1ÿMddÿT8I?1ÿ5`ÿNO4;7=56O84ÿ|ACÿ>=ÿ/_ÿQw1ÿsÿ=5 r<5665789ÿG5=1ÿE=>C_ÿQNRÿH51ÿX.S.V1ÿsII549;<F?C_ÿ`54ÿF559ÿI>A78ÿ7O5z<_ÿ=O8ÿN5A4= ÿ=O8ÿX.ÿr<5665789ÿG5=;5<ÿ=5ÿE=>CÿT;7657;=;P8ÿT8>9?;<871ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ=O>=ÿ>??ÿ68<9;<FÿG5=;5<7ÿ>48ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ _ÿz;=O ?8>P8ÿ=5ÿ48`;?8ÿ><9ÿ>]8<9ÿ=O;4=CÿM~0Vÿ9>C7ÿ>`=84ÿ=O8ÿ7=>Cÿ;7ÿ?;`=891ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ=O>=ÿ=O8ÿ6>4=;87ÿ7O>??ÿ7AB];=ÿ>ÿ:5;<=ÿE=>=A7ÿU8654=ÿ5<ÿE86=8]B84ÿ.K_ÿ/0/._ >994877;<Fÿ=O8ÿ7=>=A7ÿ5`ÿ=O8ÿI>78ÿ><9ÿ65=8<=;>?ÿ78==?8]8<=1 MN56;87ÿO>P8ÿB88<ÿ9;7=4;BA=89ÿ6A47A><=ÿ=5ÿ=O8ÿHQRÿSÿHtVÿMQ<=8489Wÿ0X-/0-/0/.V X~ÿEYsYrEÿUQ3@UYÿBCÿT8`8<9><=7ÿN?>4x_ÿy>?78C_ÿT><>ÿy5z4C_ÿU8AB>4=1ÿMs==>IO]8<=7Wÿ{ÿ. QwO;B;=ÿsÿT8I?>4>=;5<ÿ5`ÿN5A<78?VÿM|AC_ÿNO4;7=56O84VÿG59;`;89ÿ5<ÿ,-//-/0/.ÿMQTEV1 MQ<=8489Wÿ0,-.K-/0/.V XDÿrH@33@EQTÿG@YZ@HÿY@ÿEYstÿTZE3@EZYZuQÿTQsTvZHQEÿMEQN@HTÿUQ rQEYV 48ÿX/ÿ@4984ÿ5<ÿ@B^8I=;5<-s668>?ÿG>F;7=4>=8ÿ:A9F8ÿ@4984-UA?;<FÿvUÿZbÿ~S._____ÿ@4984ÿ5< G5=;5<__________ÿ@4984ÿ5<ÿr<5665789ÿG5=;5<_____ÿG;<A=8ÿ@4984____ÿBCÿT8`8<9><=7ÿN?>4x_ y>?78C_ÿT><>ÿy5z4C_ÿU8AB>4=1ÿMs==>IO]8<=7Wÿ{ÿ.ÿQwO;B;=ÿsÿT8I?>4>=;5<ÿ5`ÿN5A<78?VÿM|AC_ NO4;7=56O84VÿMQ<=8489Wÿ0,-.K-/0/.V X ÿGZHrYQÿ@UTQUÿZHÿNysGbQUEÿ5`ÿ=O8ÿy5<54>B?8ÿ:A9F8ÿ|?54;>ÿG1ÿH>P>445ÿ5< ,-.K-/0/.1 38<9;<FÿB8`548ÿ=O8ÿN5A4=ÿ;7ÿ=O8ÿXDÿr<5665789ÿG5=;5<ÿ=5ÿE=>CÿT;7657;=;P8ÿT8>9?;<87 ME8I5<9ÿU8\A87=Vÿ`;?89ÿBCÿT8`8<9><=7ÿT><ÿN?>4x_ÿT>P;9ÿy>?78C_ÿT><>ÿy5z4C_ÿ><9 };??;>]ÿU8AB>4=ÿMI5??8I=;P8?C_ÿ[T8`8<9><=7[V1ÿT8`8<9><=7ÿ48\A87=ÿ=O>=ÿ=O8ÿN5A4=ÿ7=>Cÿ=O8 9;7657;=;P8ÿ98>9?;<87ÿ`54ÿ><ÿ>99;=;5<>?ÿ7;w=CÿML0Vÿ9>C7ÿ`54ÿ=O8ÿ6>4=;87ÿ=5ÿI5<=;<A8ÿ=O8;4 78==?8]8<=ÿ9;7IA77;5<71ÿMddÿT8`71 ÿr<5665789ÿG5=1ÿE=>Cÿ~W/S _ÿQNRÿH51ÿXDÿV1 sII549;<F?C_ÿ`54ÿF559ÿI>A78ÿ7O5z<_ÿ=O8ÿN5A4=ÿ ÿ=O8ÿXDÿr<5665789ÿG5=;5<ÿ=5 E=>CÿT;7657;=;P8ÿT8>9?;<871ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ=O>=ÿ=O8ÿ6>4=;87ÿ7O>??ÿ7AB];=ÿ> :5;<=ÿE=>=A7ÿU8654=ÿ5<ÿH5P8]B84ÿ.L_ÿ/0/._ÿ>994877;<Fÿ=O8ÿ7=>=A7ÿ5`ÿ=O8ÿI>78ÿ><9ÿ65=8<=;>? 78==?8]8<=1 MN56;87ÿO>P8ÿB88<ÿ9;7=4;BA=89ÿ6A47A><=ÿ=5ÿ=O8ÿHQRÿSÿHtVÿMQ<=8489Wÿ0,-.K-/0/.V 711 0 1 ! " 1 # $ %&033 8'82(0 24() *+4+8 4 '10 01231245ÿ2788ÿ9 1 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,-./0./,/1 23ÿ567869ÿ:;<ÿ=;><?ÿ@>AABCDEÿF;ACD@ÿ;:ÿ:CBCGHÿ21ÿ5;?C;Gÿ:CBDEÿIJÿ6AA;@CGHÿ=;>G@DBKÿIJ LBMCG?C::ÿNCM;JDÿOMCPÿQD@A;G@D@ÿE>DÿIJÿ1,.R./,/1PÿSTQUVÿSWG?D<DEXÿ,-./Y./,/1V ,-./Y./,/1 2Rÿ6QTWQÿZQ[9789Zÿ23ÿ5;?C;Gÿ:;<ÿ=;ACD@Pÿ7\Dÿ=;><?ÿ6QTWQUÿTD:DGEMG?@ÿ?;ÿA<;]A?BJ @D<^DÿMÿF;AJÿ;:ÿ21ÿ;GÿLBMCG?C::Pÿ[@ÿMÿ;GD_?C]DÿF;><?D@JKÿ?\Dÿ=BD<`@ÿ6::CFDÿ@\MBBÿ?;ÿ@DGEÿM F;AJÿ;:ÿ?\DÿA>IBCFÿE;F`D?ÿ?;ÿLBMCG?C::PÿUCHGDEÿIJÿ5MHC@?<M?Dÿa>EHDÿ9MGFJÿaPÿb;AADÿ;G -./Y./,/1PÿS=;ACD@ÿ\M^DÿIDDGÿEC@?<CI>?DEÿA><@>MG?ÿ?;ÿ?\Dÿ9WcKÿE;F`D?ÿ@\DD?ÿDGFB;@DEÿ_ TQUVÿSWG?D<DEXÿ,-./Y./,/1V 711 0 1 ! " 1 # $ %&033 8'82(0 24() *+4+8 4 010

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.