-CWH Queen v. Hard Rock Hotel and Casino, No. 2:2011cv00279 - Document 43 (D. Nev. 2011)
Court Description: ORDER Denying 15 Plaintiff's Motion to File Third Party Complaint. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that 37 Plaintiff's Motion to Appeal Decision is DENIED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that 38 Defendant Hard Rock Hotel's Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED. Clerk of Court to close the case. Signed by Judge Roger L. Hunt on 12/21/11. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - EDS)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 UNI TED STA TES D I STR I T CO UR T C 8 9 D ISTR I O F N EV A DA CT 1 0 *** 1 J ESP. 1 AM QUEEN , , 1 R. 1 2 Pli it antf 1 3 vs . 1 HAlD ROCK HOTEL AM lCASW O, 4 t 1 5 Defnda t e n. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) Ca eNo.2: -v0027 RLH- H s : 11c - 9- CW O RDER ( oint FieThidPa t M to o l r ry Dee a e l fnd nt s; M oint Appe l s7; to o a-/ M oinf SummayJ dgme - o to or r u nte 1 6 1 7 -CWH Queen v. Hard Rock Hotel and Casino Beor t Cou ti Pli iflme P. e J sM otont FieThidPary f e he r s antf a s Que n n' i o l r t Doc. 43 1 Dee a t( 5 fldJme2 , 01 ) ae o Rue1()o teF d ll lsof vl rcd r, 8 fnd n #1,i l 2 2 1 b sd n l 4b fh e e' Rue CiiPo e ue e a I 1 a dM oi nf rApp a De iino M o int Comp l # 7 f e Oc. 7, swela Dee da t 9 n to o e l cso n to o e ( 3 ,i d t2 )a l s fn n l 20 HadRoc HotlsM o i f Summar Judg nt(/ GldOc. ) TheCo t as r k e' ton or y me /38, e t31. ur has lo l i i r 21 c ns de e t opposto a r ple t t s m o i ns o i r d he ii ns nd e i s o he e to . 22 23 24 BAC K GR O UND Thi i a e om e dici nai c s .Quee af me mane c e gi e s s n mpl nt s lmi ton a e n, or r itnmle n ne r a t H a d Roc Hot ,a l ge t tHa d Roc Hot la s m e ofhi c wor r a t Ha d t he r k el le s ha r k e nd o s o- ke s t he r 25 Ro kHotldsrmi tdag i thi o t bai ofhi dia lt OnOcobe 4, 1 ,Que n c e ici nae ans m n he ss s sbiiy. t r 20 0 e 26 s d t Ha d Ro k Hot f rhn q m e , s rm i ton a f l e t a c m oda e u rt e ue he r c el o m s nt di c i na i , nd aiur o c om t nde h AO 7 2 ( v 88 ) Re . /2 1 Dockets.Justia.com 1 Ameia wihDia lte Ac (t ', U. C. 1 l e s q.a f vi ainsoft rc ns t sbiiis t t ADA' 42 S. 2 0l t e , nd or olto ) he 2 Co oldae Onmi Re nclai Ac (t ns i td bus co iiton t Q COBRA' a dNRS j 68 248a 68 283. ) n j 98. nd 98. 3 Quee no s kst blngat r pat i ot c s-Mora HotlGr p s a t Rul n w ee o i hid ry nt he ae g ns e oup- uru nt o e 4 1 09.Qu e i as a p aigar l gb teHo o a l Cal . fma o HadRo kHoe' 4 e n s lo p e ln ui y h n rb e r W Ho r n n r c tls n 5 moint c mp l HadRo kHoe h sn w fldamoin frs mmayj d me t nQu e s to o o e. r c tl a o i e t o u r u g n o e n' o 6 cams Fort r s dic s dbeow,heCo tde e Que n' moi a grnt t Had li . he eaons s use l t ur nis e s tons ad a s he r Roc Hot l sm oton. k e' i 8 9 DI SCUSSI N O 1 . Que n' M otont FieThidParyDee e s i o l r t fndant( 5) #1 1 0 Que ns ek t brngt r pat Mor sHot Grupi ot sc s be a ei e e s o i hid ry gml el o nt hi ae c us t l alg dypa e amao ma g me t oei ted pt -a o eaino teHadRo kHoe. l l e l ly d j r na e n r l n h a od y p rto f h r c tl e 1 Rul 1 pr de t tçE he acai i a sre a i tapli iftl pantf yblngi a 2 e 4*) ovi s ha 4wl n l m s setd gans antf,le li ifma i n 1 t r pat i t sml woul al adee ntt dos ' Que nar e t tbe a et Had 3 hid ry fhi e d low fnda o o. ' e gu s ha c us he r 1 Roc Hotlrquetda a r ofat n y' fe a dc t i isa we ( i a sre a4 am' 4 k e e se n wad tore s e s n oss n t ns r #4) t se td kli ' 1 a ais Que n.A rquetf at ne sfe , ve,i notac us ofa ton, ndt rf e n a 5 g nt e e s or tor y' e s howe r s a e ci a heeor, ot 1 l li ' rRul 1 b) Fo Rul 1 b)t a y,h HadRoc Hot woul ha t asr a 6 l am'unde e 4( . r e 4( o ppl te r k el d ve o se t c 1 c ecam a i tQue n,at i h sn d s Wrg & Milr Fe rlPrciea 7 ountr li gans e rd t a ot one o. iht le, dea atc nd 1 Prc ur:Ci l3dj1 Theef e t Cou t nisQue n' moto t fl t r pat 8 o ed e vi 464. r or,he r de e e s in o ie hid ry 1 9 de e da . f n nt 20 I. I 21 Que n' Appe lo JudgeHo f sOr r(57) e s a f fman' de / Bef et Cou tsa Ore ( 3)e ee byteHono a eCa l . f n or he r i n d r #3 ntrd h rbl r W Hofma 2 rg r ngteHadRoc HotlsMotont Compe Dic r Res nss( . 2 e adi h r k e' i o l s ovey po e #28) 2 3 Qu e tldObe o st (ra Ap e l 9 Ma itaeJ d eHo f n' Or e e n ie j din o o n p a o gsrt u g fma s d r 2 (53 i a c r nc wihLo lRul I 3 1o t RulsofWa tc oft Unie SttsDitit 4 / ) n c oda e t ca e B - f he e cie he td ae src 2 Co r frteDitit f v d .HadRo kHoe h sfldaRep n et teOb e t n (10 , 5 u t o h src o Ne a a r c tl a e s o s o h j ci s 8 ) o 4 26 AO 7 2 ( v 88 ) Re . / 2 a t sm atrwa r f re f c nsde i nd hi te s e e r d or o i mton. 2 1 The Co t s c nduc e a d nov r vi w o t r co d i t i c e i a c r nc ur ha o t d e o e e f he e r n h s as n c o da e 2 wi 2 U.. 9 3 (X1( ,B)a d( a dLo a Rue I 3 1a d32a dd tr n sta te t 8 SC. 6 6 b )A) ( , n C) n c l ls B - n - n eemie h th h 3 Or rofM a sr eJ de gitat udgeHofma i no cla l e r ne orc nta yt 1w a s dbe f n s t e ry ro ous o rr o a nd houl 4 a f ne f m d. 5 11 Har RockHoelsM ai frSummar Judgment(38) 1. d t ' ton @ y # 6 7 A. Lega St ndar l a d 'hepur eofs I ' pos ummayj gme i t a oi un e s til whe t r i no r ud nt s o v d nec smy ras n hee s 8 ds u ea t tefcsb f r tec u t #w. try l As ' v US De 'o rc,1 F.d ip t s o h a t eo e h o r. Moo c ce sn . . p tfAg i. 8 3 9 1 6 ,1 71( t Ci.9 4 .Su r ud me tsa p o raewh n<h pe dn s tedso ey 4 8 4 9h r1 9 ) mmayj g n i p rp it e t e la ig ,h ic v r t 1 0 a dicl u e m a e i l on f l a d a a ida is s w t r i no g nui diput ast a nd s os r t ra s ie, n ny fi v t ho he e s e ne s e o ny 11 maeilfcta t mova i e tte t j me a amatroflw. Fe R. v. 56() tra a nd he nts nild o udg nt s te a ' d. Ci P. c. ' 1 2 a n i s i Sg nui ' i t r i a s fc e e de i r ba i on whi h a r a o bl f c - i r X s ue s ç e ne ' f he e s ufi i nt vi nta y s s c e s na e a tfnde 1 3 c ul fnd f t no o ng pa t a a diput i ç a e i l' fi c d a f c ti ou c m e oft o d i or he nm vi ry nd s e s ç t r a ' i t oul f e t ie t o m he 1 s tt rt g r n lw.Andes v. bet Lobb f .477U. 242, -4 ( 98 . 4 ui mde he ovenig a ron Li ry y, nc, S. 248 9 1 6) 1 W h r ra o bemidsc uddfe o temaeil at a is , o v r sl r u g n i 5 ee e s na l n o l ifr n h tra fcs t sue h we es l mmayj d me t s 1 n t p r p it.Wa r nv Ci o rs a , 8F.d4 9 4 (t Ci. 9 5 .Qr ea u t f 6 o a po rae re . t fca lb d 5 3 3 , 41 9h r 1 9 ) th mo n o y 1 e ie c n c sayt rieag n neis eo maei l a t se o g tor q ieajvyo j d et 7 vd n e e e sr o as e ui su f tla fc i n u h t e ur .t r u g o 1 8 r ol e t pa te ' f e il ve s o o t e t%t1a t l''Aydi Co p.1 Lo alCtr ,71 F. es v he ri s dif rrg r i ns f h , , t Ha .' 1 1 n r z r . 7#. 8 2d 1 8 902( , Ci.1 3)(uotngFis Nat Bankv CiisSe ieCo.391U. 253, 8 9 9 97, 9t r 98 q i rt ' h l . te rvc , S. 28 -8 2 (9 8) I e au t gas mmayj d me t to ac u t iwsa1 a t a dd a al 0 1 6 ). n v lai u r u g n mo in, o r ve lfcs n r ws l n 21 i e e ce i t lg m os f vo a et t nonm ov ng pa t Kaie Ce ntCo p.v Fihb h nf r n s n he i ht t a r bl o he i ry. s r me r . s ac 22 t Moo e I 7 F. 11 l 03( hCi.1 ) : r ,nc, 93 2d 00, l 9t r 986. 23 The m ovi pa t bea s t b de ofs ng ry r he ur n howi t tt r a e no g nui i s sof ng ha he e r e ne s ue 2 maeilfc.Zo l v M CA Diti Cbrx, 3F. 87 88 (t Ci.1 2) çnor rt c ry 4 tra a t saw . srb. / 69 2d 0, 3 9h r 98 . ç de o ar l I 2 i bre o pout n temo igpr mut i e pou eeiec n gt ga esnil 5 t udn f rdci ,h vn at set r rd c vdn e eai n set s o y h n a 1 2 6 e e e oft n m ovhl pa t sc a m o de e e o s w t a t no ovi pa t d snot l m nt he on g ry' l i r f ns r ho h t he nm ng ry oe I I AO 7 2 3 ( v 88 ) Re . /2 / 1 I 1 h ee av nough e de e ofa es e ta e e e t c ny is uli a e bu de ofpe s a i n a ti l' vi nc n s n i l l m nt o a t tm t r n r u s o t ra .' 2 Nis Fie(2 ieI .Co.v Fr/ Cos, 0F. 1 11 2( hCi. san r 1Marn ns . fz .21 3d 099, 0 9t r2000) Onc t . e he 3 mo ng pa t s ts isRul 5 sr quie nt,t bu de s hst t p ryr ssig t mo i t vi ry aife e 6' e r me s he r n hi o he a t e itn he ton o 4 Gs tf t s c fc f c ss Ge orh pe ii a t howi g t tt r i age i i s f t i l' Ande s 477 U . a 25 n ha he e s nu ne s ue or ra . ' r on, S. t 6. 5 The no o ng pa t t a no r l o de a s i t pln ngsbutm ls pr e s c fc nm vi ry s y t e y n ni l n he e di m zt oduc pe ii 6 e de e t oug a da t o a i sbl di c ve y m a e i l t s vi nc , hr h m vis r dm s i e s o r tr a , o how t tt diput e s s' ha he s e xit ,' 7 Bhanv. NME Hos .I 929F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) a Kmus domor ta1smpl ps, nc, 2d 404, 409 9t r 991, nd i t e h1 i y 8 s w ta t r i smemea sc ldou ast t maei fcs'Ban o ho h t hee s o tphy ia bt o he trala t. k fAme iav.Or, ' rc r 285 9 F.d7 4 7 3( t Ci. 0 2 (nen lctto so te ) t emeee itn eo asit l o 3 6 , 8 9, r 2 0 ) itra i in mitd . ç h a Th r xse c f cni a f l 1 0 11 e de e i s po t t pl i ifsposton w ilbe i u lc e . Ande s 477 U . a 252. vi nc n up r of he a ntf ii l ns f i i nt' ' r on, S. t B. A nal i ys s 1 2 1 . A DA Faiur t A c om m o t l eo c da e 1 3 TheADA m a si unlwf lt ç s rmi t a a n taquaiid i viua ont ke t a u o t c i nae g i s di lfe ndi d l he 1 bm i ofdia lt ' U. C. 1 1 a , yQ tma ngr%o bl a o 4 ss sbiis'42 S. j 21 2() b l no ki e na e cc mmodai t t tons o he 1 5 kno physc o me a lmiainsofalot l ieq lfe i di d lwih adia iiy .. . wn ial r nt l i tto r hew s ua i d n viua t s b lt .' ' 1 I a j1 1 b( ( .Ho ve, eemuli ea c 6 d. t 21 2()5)A) we rwh r tpl c ommodainse sat e o ri no to xit he mplye s t 1 rq ie t gvetee ly etea c mmo aino h r h ie Co n l v Ene If . ' v' 27 7 e urd o i h mpo e h c o d t f e c oc . n ol . tx n o s r, o y . c , 1 Fe Ap 876,8 ( , Ci. 01.Fu temor,arms bl delyi pr di a 8 d. px. 78 9t r20 ) rh r e e ona e a n ovi ng n h 1 9 a c m m oda i n i n a vi a i oft AD A .Ki z v UPS,766 F. pp. 1 co to s ot ol ton he nt . Su 2d 245,1 25* 57 2 ( . A1 , b. 2 1. 0 M D. a.Fe 7, 01 ) 21 OnJ n r 1 2008 Que nsi da fl o s mesaiswhiewol a t a uay 9, , e lppe nd el n o t r l rdng t he 2 HadRo kHo e.( , eiinf r mo a, . , mpan E 1. Hes tie ij re t 2 r c tl #1 P tt o Re v lEx 1 Co lit x. ) o usan d nu is o 23 hi ba k hi gr n, nda easars loft fl.(#..Ove tec ls oft ne 1 mont , s c p, oi a nkl e ut he al f ) r h otre he xt 0 hs 24 Quen' co to fucu tdbewe nttlytmpo aiydia e a c pa eofwor ngwih e s ndiin l tae t e oal e rrl sbld nd a bl ki t 25 c ranrsrci .( M oinf Su r J dpne tQue nDe Ex. .n e onOcobe e ti etitons #38, to or mmay u n, e po. F) n, t r I ! : I I I j 26 27,Dr AubrySwat e mi dQue na ddee ne t thewa c pa eo pefr nghi jb . e rz xa ne e n tnni d ha s a bl f romi s o AO 7 2 ( v./2 Re 88 ) 4 è 1 wiho rsrci s.(d. tEx. .Nor Gaca aHe dngOfie wiht Ne aDep rme t ut e titon I a H) a ri, a fc r t he vad a t nt 2 ofAd nitai n, fl d Dr Swat sme c ldee mi ton i awor r 'c mi sr to a fnne . lz' dia tr na i n ke s ompe ai n ns to 3 a ea tldbyQuee (d. tEx.1 M o De l, M) Que nrq se t rnlnt wor wih pp lie n. 1 a , on c.Ex . e e uetd o e r o k t 4 ac ne butt HadRoc Hotlrfke be a eiwa c ene t tQue nwoul ij ehi ef a , he r k e etsd c us t s onc r d ha e d nur ms l 5 o ot r whiepef tgc ranj dute .(d. Ex.1 M oo De l,(1 .I M ac 2009 r hes l rbnnii eti ob is 1 at , n c.! 8) n rh , 6 a rt Ha dRoc Hotlr eve adoc ntfom Dr De s Stre i c tngt tQue n he he r k e ec i d ume r . nie a ly ndia i ha e 7 ne d dac net pef m c ranj f cinsteHadRoc Hot al dQue nt rtr t e e a o ror eti ob un to ,h r k el lowe e o eun o 8 wor i a lg - y pos ton a t s c iy po um on t ca i loo a t e H a d Roc Hot l k n i htdut i i t he e urt di he sno l r t h r k e. 9 (d. t!21 . 1 a ) 1 0 Que nalge t tt HadRoc Hotlfie t ma raona e e le s ha he r k e ald o ke e s bl 11 a c mmodai t Qu n' c dii bynotal n hi t rt nwihac net hi posto a co tons o ee s on ton lowig m o eur t a o s iin s 1 amane ncee ne r ( , ttonfrRe a, l Co ait!Il -21.Howe r Had 2 itna ngi e . #1 Peii o mov lEx. , mpl n,! 9a ) ve, r 1 Ro kHoe' e ie c d mo srtsta Qu e ddno n e ac n t pefr hs o . 3 c tls vd n e e n tae h t e n i t e d a e o ro m ij b 1 4 Sp cii al t Ha dRoc Hot pr de ame c e mi i r por fom Dr Swa t whih e tc ly, he r k el ovi s dial xa naton e t r . rz c 1 i c tst tQue nc drtmlt wokwihnor tito .( M otonfrSlmmay 5 ndiae ha e oul et o r t esrcins #38, i o l r 1 J m e ,Que nDe ,Ex. .HadRoc Hotl s t r or,wihhlisrght t rquie 6 ud nt e po. H) r k e wa ,heef e t t i s o e r 1 Que nt rtm t wor i Ocobe 2008, e Swat e mi to wasdo , toutt us of 7 e o eu o k n t r wh n rz' xa nain ne wih he e 1 8 ac ne W he t Ha d Ro k Hot lr c i dDr S a ly' rpor i M a c 2009 i c tn t t a . n he r c e e eve . t re s e tn r h ndiai g ha 1 Qu e n e dac n t p ro m h s o fncin teHadRo kHoe wa t nrq ie t 9 e n e de a e o efr ij b u t s h r c tl s he e urd o o 2 a c mmo aeQu e t rteADA.Idds byp o iigQt e wi aj ba tes c rt 0 c o d t e n mde h t i o rvdn t n t o th e uiy e h 21 po um o t cai loo .(d. tEx.1 M o De .!2l.Thel we kdea i f ngQue di n he sno l r I a , on cl, ) o- e ly n mdi en 2 apo ii i nota ton bl dici nain.Ki zv UPS,766F.Sup 2d 1 1 2 ston s ci a e srmi to nt . p. 245, 256-5 ( D. 7 M. 2 Al.Fe . , 01 ) 3 a, b 7 2 l. 2 4 W hiewoki a t s urt p um Que nrmane o t mantn nc l r ng the ec iy odi e e i d n he i e a e 25 e n elng pa r le m i mo et n $1 mor pe hom t n ot re oy si t s c iy ngie i y ol, a ng r ha 0 e r ha he mpl ee n he e urt 26 de rme t ( , otonf SummayJ e , 1 M o De l, 22) Alh ht s pat n. #38 M i or r udm ntEx. , on c.! . toug hi AO 72 ( v 88 ) Re . /2 5 1 sc iypostonma notha b nQue n' frtchocef ala c e urt ii y ve ee e s ts i or r c ommo ton,twm rm o bl dai i s e s na e 2 i lghtoftefc t tHadRoc Hot wm c ene frQu n' s ey a tes ft of ni h a t ha r k el s onc r d o ee s aft, nd h aey 3 otl s weeQue nt pef t j f ltonsofama e nc e iee whieusngaca e. l , r e o ronn he ob urci er ltna e ngc r l i n 4 (d. t!1 ) Nora o bl tiroffc c ddeemiefom t e de ep ee e t tt Had I a 8 . e s na e re a t oul tr n r he vi nc r sntd ha he r 5 Roc Hoe f ldt ra o bl ac ormodaeQue n.n eef e t Co tgrnst HadRoc k tl aie o e s na y c n t e r or,he ur a t he r k 6 Hoe' motonwihr pe tt Qut n' fiur t a c tls i t es c o e s al e o c ommodaecam. t li 7 2. AD A H os ie W or Envi onm e tl k r nt 8 A cl i f hos ie wor e iom ne t rt ADA r qui e a pl i t f o s w a m or tl k nv r nt mde he e r s a n ift ho 9 ( )s ei aq aiidid vd a wihad sbl y ()whowa sb e t ou wec meh rsme t 1 h s u l e n iiu l t ia it ,2 f , i s u j c t n lo aa s n , 1 ( be a eofhe dia lt,( whihhaas n afce t tr ,c tons orprvieg so 0 3) c us r sbiiy 4) c rsme t fe td he ems ondii , i l e f 1 he e o nta ()t e oy rkne ors dha eknownoft haasme , t kno 1 r mplyme , nd 5 he mpl e w houl v he r s ntbutoo 1 2 a i t pr ve i. Gr c v. ane Hol ood Re or d; s no I c , o. 1 c cton o e nt t ani h Pl t l m s t Ca i . n . N 2: 0- v 0091 2- 1 PMP- 201 U. Dit LEXI 97 *11( Ne , 26 201 ) Tobeato e te 3 PAL, 0 S. s. S 956, D. v.Aug. , 0 . cinabl,h 1 haasngc duc mus bes jci l hosiea da i t t dia e e o eml 4 rsi on t t ube tvey tl n busve o he sbld mplye d 1 o jcieyh si a da u iet arao a l p ro Ame ia r f Dia ite Ac: o e 5 be tv l o tl n b sv o e s n be es n. rc u ' / s bl is t Emply e e Wl i 1 Ri san 6 ght dEmplye Obi ins 15ADA:Empo eRiht 5. 3() Ane oye i not o r lgato , lye g s 07()c . mpl r s 1 la ef t har s ntc ttzigt al e hotl woke r me i ()t e oy r 7 ibl or he asme onsit n he leg d sie r nvion ntf a he mpl e t 1 e rie ras bl caet prve a c re tpomptya hnm sngb ha o,a d()te 8 xecs d e ona e r o e nt nd orc r l ny rqi e vir n b h 1 9 e oye ln e ona y f ie t t k a ntg ofpr v ttveo c r ci eoppo tniis mpl e lr as bl a ld o a e dva e e en ai r ore tv ru te 2 0 pr vi dbyt e oy r ort a d h rnot r s Bu ln onI tis I .v Ele t 5 o de he mpl e , o voi n r he wie. rigt ndn re , nc . lrh, 24 21 U. 7 7 ( 998; aghe v Ci o aRat 52 U. 7 8 ( 998. S. 45, 65 1 )Far r . t fBoc on, 4 S. 75, 07 1 ) y 22 Que ni ntfest flo nga t c e de ii he olwi s he onduc t tce tdt hosiewor tha rae he tl k 23 e rnme a t HadRoc Hotl ()s o wr etz wor <fg'onapic o e pme i nvio nt t he r k e: 1 ome ne ot le d 'a ' e e f qui nt n 24 t sgns wheeQue nwor d,( s o atc daha c ppe plc r t hi l ke,3 he i hop r e ke 2) ome ne ta he ndia d a ad o s oc r () 25 s o c ldhm aGci 'o oneo cai ( s onema c mme st hi a uthi ome ne ale i trp' n c son,4) ome de o nt o m bo s 26 g tigmo yfom hi wor r c nstonc s ( hewaswrte u f a c si a t etn ne r s kes ompe ai ae,5) itn p or c esng dul Ao 72 ( v 88 ) Re . / 2 6 1 i g so hi co e,6)hewasgie poi sfra s ntes a ( hss r iosi ma e n s mputr ( v n nt o b e e im, nd 7) i upe vs r n 2 s c iy a ke hi t dot n hec anl hewa n quaiid t do. e urt s d m o higs l i s s ot lfe o 3 TheCo tlndst ttea ina ehaa sngc ur i ha h cto bl rsi onduc al edbyQu nwaswhe t leg ee n 4 s e pl ce t e ha c ppe pl c r t hi l c a w he h w a c l d a t rp ' o om one a d h ndi a d a a d o s o ker nd n e s ale G i ' on ne c 5 o a i n.Ther s oft alge c ndud i e s i l va al wholy u up td b cc so e t he le d o s xce svey gue r d l ns pore y 6 e de e n hosieora ki t ar a ona epe s ,ioltd a i r que ,o no vi nc , ot tl btsve o e s bl r on s ae nd nfe nt r t 7 d mo srtdt b c n e tdi a ywa t Qu e sdsblt.Ast teh n ia pe pa ado e n tae o e o n ce l n y o e n' ia ii l y o h a dc p d lc r n 8 Que n' l ke,heHadRoc Hotlse ie edmnonsrtst tit krasna ese un r e s oc rt r k e' vd nc tae ha t oo e o bl tps de 9 tecr un tn e t c re th h s n.DeGr c v Ru u ed 6l F.d7 6 8 5( s Ci. h ic rsa c s o o rc t e mw me t a e . n f l, 4 2 9 , 0 1t r 1 1 8 ) S e i c l , seMo n Asitn Die tro Hu nReo re frteHadRo k 0 9 0 . p ct al Ca i o , ssa t rco f ma s u c s o h r c i y 1l Hot , tt ,ithe d c a ton,ha whe s dic r dt plc r s eor r dt a i be eisaes r r e lm i t t n he s ove e he a a d h de e h t t 1 rmo d.( Moto f Slmmay J dgme , e De , .Que nco lme t tiwa 2 e ve #38, in or l l u ntQuen po.58) e nfr d ha t s 1 rmove i Msde ston.(d.a Qu nDe ,1 1 36: .Ast s o c li Que na 3 e dn po ii I , t ee po. 35:8-1 6) o ome ne alng e 1 4 ci t Ha d Roc Ho e a gu t ti i e ildt a a fr tvede e ef t talge rp,he r k t l r es ha t s ntte o n ftmai f ns or ha le d 1 5 i i e be a ei e r ie r as bl c r byha ngawelpu ii d a ihaasme nc d nt c us t xe cs d e ona e a e vi l- blcze nt- r s nt 1 pr e ur a dQue ndi notus t spoce ur t corc t ale dco t Ele t 5 U. 6 oc d e n e d e hi r d e o re the lge nduc. lrh, 24 S. 1 a 76 Far r 5 U. a 8 Qu nprvi sn e de et t c r Theeor, 7 t 5) aghe , 24 S. t 07. ee o de o vi nc o he ontmy rf e 1 Que n' ho tl wor e r ntcam fisa amatroflw. 8 e s sie k nvionme li al s te a 1 9 3. D i lt Di cri i i sabii y s m naton 20 A c am f dia lt dic i na in r quie apli ift s ow t ts i a l i or s biiy s rmi to e r s antf o h ha he s 2l quaiid i v d l t adia lt who s f e a ad r ee o nta to be a eo he lfe ndii ua wih s biiy uferd n ve s mplyme c in o us f r 22 diablt San sv. neonPr s.91F.d 1 ,1 3(99 .Que n' dia lt s iiy. der Ar s od , 3 351 35 1 6) e s sbiiy 23 dic i i to c a m f isa a m a t ro l w be a l e hedi no s f ra ad r e e pl s rm na i n l i a l s te f a c ts d t uf e n ve s m oymen t 24 a ton.Totec rr,Har Ro kHotlse de ces wsta Que nvol aiyquihi o ci h ontay d c e' vi n ho h t e t rl t sj b mt 25 wiht s c rt d pa t nt ( ,Moto frSummayJ t he e u iy e rme . #38 in o r udgme tEx.1 MoonDe l, P) n, , c.Ex. . 26 Que nc nno manti acam f c nsr tvedic r be a eth sandadf d monsrtn e a t i n li or o tuci shage c us ç e t r or e taig t A0 7 2 ( v 88 ) Re . /2 7 l a c t c i di c r e i gr a e t a t tf de ons r tng a hos ie w or e r nm e ,' onsnz tve s ha g s e t r l n ha or m t a i z tl k nvio nt' 2 Uria v Me o, 3: cv001 LRHrz ga . me No. 05- - 99- VPC, 2007U. DitLEXI 4521 *1 -1 ( S. s. S , 5 6 D. 3 Ne ,J 1 2007)a a dic sda ove Que nha nocam frhosiewor e ionme t v. an. 9, , nd s suse b s e s li o tl k nvr n. 4 HadRoc Hoe prvie Quee wiharasna ea c r k tl o d d n t e o bl c ommodai b a sr i Que nt a ton y si ng e o 5 pos ton w ih t s c iy de rm e whe e heco d us hi ca n,a he c i d o t ii t he e urt pa t nt r ul e s i nd ontnue n he 6 mantme ee ne rngpa ol.Que nprvi snoe d nc s ri acam frdia lt i e mc ngi ei yr l e o de vie e uppo tng li o sbiiy 7 dici nain.Theeoe,heCo t a t t HadRo kHotlsmotonwihrs c t Qu e s s rmi to rfr t ur grns he r c e' i t epet o e n' 8 A DA c ai s lm . 9 4. C O BR A and NR S Cl m s ai 1 0 Que n' NRS cai f i a am atro lw be a et s utsh ct si s ppo t e s l ms al s te f a c us he tt e e ie n u r 1 ofhi cli ( jj6898. 68 8. 3)d nota pl t t HadRoc Hotlbe a et 1 s ams NRS 248, 98 28 o p y o he r k e c us he 1 2 Ha d Roc H ot le o m or t n 2 e p o e . Bute n i t s s a u e d d a y t t r k e mpl ys e ha 0 m l ye s ve f he e t t t s i ppl o he 1 HY Roc HotlQu enhmspovi dnoe de tays ppor f t s cl ms Theeor,h 3 k e, e r de vi niz u tor he e ai . rf e te 1 Cour ga st Har Ro kHoe' moinwihrs c t Que n' NRScai . 4 t nt he d c tls to t epe to e s l ms 1 5 Qu e sCOBRA cai as fisa amatroflw be u eQue nwasnotapln e n' l m lo al s te a ca s e a 1 6 pa tc pa a t tm ehe vo unt r l r sgne h se pl e i 200 Spe ik a l i D e e b r ri i nt t he i l a iy e i d i m om nt n 9. c t ly, n c m e 1 7 20 t Ha d Roc Hot lc nduc e o n e ol e f rt f l ng ye r sb e isp o a s 08, he r k e o t d pe nr l nt o he olowi m a ' en ft r gr m . 1 (/ , oi f SummayJ 8 /38 M ton or r udgme oEx.1 Mo De .11 .HadRoc Hoelsntalte t nt , on cls13) r k t e etr o 1 Que nwho, tt tme waso ala eofa e e i omi hi t theha u iJ nuay1 , 9 e a he i , n e v bsnc ,nfr ng m ha d ntl a r 6 20 20 t e olf tef l ngy rsbe ft pr a s (d. Ex.1 M o De .Ex.) 09,o nr lor l olowi ea' neis ogrnl. I at , on cl, 1. z 21 Be a eQue ndi n elc be lt byJ nu y1 hewa nol raplnpa t pa .(d. tEx. c us e d ot e t neis a ar 6 s onge a ri nt I a ci 22 1 Moo Dec.Ex. ) Th , e sv untl rsr ai fom t HadRoc Hot i Jme , n 1, J. us Quen' ol ay e i ton r he r k eln t 23 200 di notc us hi t l e c ve a )hi c m gew a l ti J nua y 2009 whe he f ie t 9 d a e m o os o r ge s ove s os n a l n ald o 24 ee be is Que n' cam t tt noiesntoutfo teHa. Roc Hot wa i de t lct neft. e s li ha he tc e rm h z d k el s na quae 25 fisbe aket notc clal wansQue nt tr nr l nti t plnwa ma t ya t t al c t he ie e ry r s e ha ee olme n he a s ndaor nd ha 26 hene d dt ee t neisbyJ nuay1 t a dacncelto ofhi be ft pac a (d.a e e o lc be tt a r 6 o voi a lain s neis k ge. 1 t AO 72 ( v 88 ) Re . /2 8 1 Ex 1 MoonDe l,Ex.) Theeoe,heHadRoc Hotlse de c de nsrtst tQuen' c. 1. rfr t r k e' vi n e mo tae ha e s 2 COBRA cam fisasamatroflw,ml Que pr ie n e de et t c rr. li al te a d en ovd s o vi nc o he ontay 3 Ac o d ngl t Cour gr nt t H a d Roc Hot lsm oton wih r s c t t sc a m . c r i y, he t a s he r k e' i t e pe t o hi l i 4 CO NCLUSI N O 5 Acodi l,ndfr o dcuea p aig cr ngy a o g o a s p ern , j 6 I I HEREBY ORDERED t tQue n' Motont FieThr Pa Dee nt TS ha e s i o l id dy fnda 1 7 8 ( 5 i DENI #1 ) s ED. I I FURTHER ORDERED t tQue n' M oi t App lDe ii ( 7)i TS ha e s ton o ea cson #3 s 9 DENI . ED 1 0 I I FURTH ER O RD ERED t tt H a d Roc Hot l sM oto f rSum m a y T S ha he r k e' in o l l1 J udpne ( )i GRAN F nt#38 s ED. 1 2 The Cour i t c st Cl r ofCour t c os t c s t nsnl t he e k t o l e he a e. 1 3 Da e De e be 21 20l1 t d: c m r , 1 4 1 5 Jr 1 6 ROG . U NT U ni e St D it i tJu ge t a s rc 17 l 8 1 9 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 AO 72 ( v 88 ) Re . /2 9 ,
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
