Bailey v. Gillespie et al, No. 2:2010cv00047 - Document 21 (D. Nev. 2010)
Court Description: ORDER that the petition for a writ of habeas corpus is DENIED and that this action shall be DISMISSED with prejudice on the merits on the double jeopardyclaim, and without prejudice on the basis of abstention as to all other claims presented. I T FURTHER IS ORDERED that a certificate of appealability is DENIED. The Clerk of Court shall enter final judgment accordingly in favor of respondents and against petitioner. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 6/9/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - SD)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
W j- 9 t! ) ' ' ' . . m .ifIf) * ***'--spm'.w.l . T'F ,L O î. : ; -' - ' ' 'z -- ' ' lh : r ' j- --. . y , y;p C), t lo tj j. j: (2s . . c(jt,.j t. ' .j, y;; . g f r-. . .....u... . . . . .. .-t. ....u - .. . . ë g r t t .. ! . : ! I ' ) 1 ' t 1 ; t'c(' . ......y '. , j .r .. , . . , .,, , y . - .b: kt; t, ., . ). . - p j . p'' t r 1.. - 3 .. . ' J ' . ,.,' jy ) 7 . j . : r u ..-a.n-u,. . . z . u : ukr- . .r s : . u a . u . . . j a . .y. . . ) t . , . ty . rr . . ... ,. ... . ,. ; . j , . ' ' -- -- 4 5 U N I E D STA T ES D ISTR IC T C O U R T T 6 D ISTR ICT OF NEVA DA 7 8 A NTHO NY BA I LEY , Pettoner, ii 2: 0- 000471 cvRCJPAL 9 10 VS. ORDER 11 DOU GLAS C .GI LLESPI etal, E, . l 2 Re pondent s s. 13 1 4 Thi habeas acton c es bef e t Cour f a deci on on t m ert oft doubl s i om or he t or si he is he e l j pa d cai pr s td,Th Cour do n r c t mers o a o h camsi t 5 eo r y l m e ene e t es ot ea h he i f ny t er li n he t 1 petton becaus t case ot w i does n pr 6 ii e he her se ot esent r di y cicum s anceswarantng extaor nar r t r i 1 t i er i ofa f 7 he nt venton eder di t i tcour i a pendi s at crm i pr al s rc tn ng t e i nal eceedi ng, 1 8 Bailey v. Gillespie et al 1 9 B ackgr ound On Febr y 28,2009,pet i uar i onerAnt t hony Baiey was ares ed f ,i eral al l r t or nt i l a, eged Doc. 21 20 ofenses oc rng t dat i oli a gilrend,Cr t W ashi on, f curi hat e nv vng rfi ys al ngt who was t mot he her 21 ofhi chid. s l 22 On oraboutMar h 1,2009,Bai was char by a crm i c c l ey ged i nal ompl ntfl i t ai ied n he 23 j tc cour by t Cl kCount Di rc Ator wiht count ofsexualassaul,t ee usie t he ar y stit t ney t wo s t hr 2 count Ofpossessi t sal ortansf )off se i iyi document one countof 4 s on 0r e r er al dentf ng s, 25 coer on,and one countofbur ar Accor ng t t c pl nt t t sexualassaul ci gl y. di o he om ai he wo t 26 char wer based upon alegatonst Baiey,on orgi Count1,pl ges e l i hat l i nal aced hi peni i o s s nt 27 t genial he t openi ofW ashi on agai therwif ng ngt ns l and, orgi Count pl on i nal 2, aced hi peni s s 28 on ori t mout ofW ashi on agai herwi . The coer on char was based upon n he h ngt nst l l ci ge Dockets.Justia.com l alegatonst Bai t eat l i hat l hr enedW ashi on t keep her r calng f hel The bur ar ey ngt o fom l or p. i gl y 2 char wasbased uponal ge l i t Bai ent ed t dweli wih t i entt com mi egat ons hat l ey er he lng t he nt o t 3 sexualassaul and/ coer on. t or ci l 4 On oraboutM ar 6, ch 2009, l alo was char by a compl ntfl i t Norh Bai ey s ged ai ied n he t 5 Las Vegas m uni i cour by t C iy Ator w ih a m i dem eanor of bater dom estc c pal t he t t ney t s t y i 6 vi ence based upon al ol l i t Baiey com m it an ac of f c or vi ence upon egatons hat l ted t or e ol 7 W as ngt wih whom he had had a datng r atonshi and a chi ' hitng heron t hi on, t i el i p l ' ti d, by he 8 i nnert gh wih a bl r ot c r t he was hol ng i hi hand,z hi t ack em e ontol hat di n s ' 9 Cr st W ashi on t ii i era/ as f l att pr i nar hearng hel on y al ngt estfed,nt / a, olows he el mi y i d 1 Mar 25,2009, 0 ch and Aprl6, i 2009. I Febr y 2009,she I therhome,wher she I n uar ef e i ved 11 wihoutBai and she wentt s ay wih hersi eri an efor t getaway fom Bai He t l ey, o t t st n f to r l ey. 1 contnued causi pr em s at her si ers hom e, and her si er c l Bai t t 2 i ng obl st ' st al ed l o ake ey 1 W ashi on backt herhome.Once t e,Bai i s ed on goi i de agai herwi . 3 ngt o her l nsit ey ng nsi nst l l 1 I de herr dence, ver l abused her and he t hi heron herI w ih a t evi i 4 nsi esi he baly , hen t eg t el s on 1 r ot cont ol Subsequenty,overt cour e oft eveni and/ m or ng,he had her 5 em e r . l he s he ng or ni 1 engage i sexualac i tes agai therwil i udi havi heri er herfngeri o hi 6 n tvii ns l, ncl ng ng ns t i nt s 1 anus,engagi g i sexuali er se,i eri a ' ex t 'i o heranus,engagi i anal 7 n n nt cour ns tng ' oy' nt s ng n 1 i er s and havi herperor f l i on hi . 8 nt cour e, ng f m el o at m 3 1 9 Prort t c i i oft pr i nar hearng On Aprl 2009,he Cl kCoun y i o he ontnuaton he elmi y i i6, t ar t 20 Di rc Ator fl an am ended com pl ntaddi t o addii sti t t ney i ed ai ng w tonal count ofs s exual saul. as t 21 Amended Count1 al l eged t Bai c hat l aused W ashi on t i therfngeri o hi anal ey ngt o nser i nt s 22 23 1 , Ex. #19 2. 24 . 2 9, Ex 1( s d c me ti e hiij #1 . l t o u n n x bt. a 25 33) 75. es edi ly i ngs t her ac ual i ngs 3 9, Ex. 4,at6- Fx.5 at7- The Coud m ak no cr bii fndi orot f t fndi #1 rg rigtetuho fli o e ie c o sae nso fc itesaecu .T eCo rsmmaie e adn h rt rast f v1 ne rttme t fatn h tt o d h utu r s y z maei) N sae n o fc ma eidsr igsae nsisi n o oh r vdnei tesaec ut tr . o ttmet fat d n ecin ttmet,et y r te eiec n h tt o r a b mo 26 sam e s el asbac oun t t i uespr ol y kgr d o he ss esent i t s c andi doesnotsumm arze alsuch ed n hi ase t i 1 27 c si esafn igb ti Cout W a hn tnstsi n i rlv to t ed bl jop r Gam a on tut idn y hs r. s igo ' e tmo y s ee an n h ou e e ady li s t 28 back ound t show t aleged f t bassf t varouschar br gr o he l ac ual i or he i ges oughtagai tBaiey.The cr biiy ns l edi l t and ver t ofW ashi on' t i aciy ngt s estmonyi f t tiroff t wei atti . s or he re act c gh ral - 2- 1 openi agai herw i .A m ended Count2 car i f war t al ng nst l l red or d he l i oforgi Count egatons i nal 2 1 alegi sexual l ng assaul t ough engagi i sexual nt cour e agai tW ashi on' w i . t hr ng n i er s ns ngt s l l 3 A m ended Count3 al l eged t Bai pl hat l ey aced hi peni i o t anal s s nt he openi ofW ashi on ng ngt 4 agai her i ,Am ended Count c red f war t al nst w l l 4 ar i or d he l i egatonsoforgi Count al ng i nal z l egi 5 s exual aul vi f l i agai therw il The r ai ng orgi char ofpossessi of ass t a el o at ns l . em ni i nal ges on 6 f se i iyi docum ent c ci and bur ar w er car i f w ar i A m ended Count al dent ng f s, oer on, gl y e red or d n s 7 5 t ough 9. hr 4 8 Afert t i ony pr t he estm esent on Aprl6,2009,t Di rc Ator added anot ed i he sti t t ney her 9 char ofsexualass tbased upon alegatons t Bai pl ge aul l i hat l ey aced a ' t ' nt t anal ' oy'i o he sex 1 openi of ashi on agai ther il The pr 0 ng W ngt ns w l. osecut al al or so l eged w eapon enhancem ent s 1 on each oft fve s 1 he i exualas saul count based upon t i ony b W ashi on t Bai t s estm y ngt hat l ey 1 used a knie i t c m i on oft sexualass t s 2 f n he om ssi he aul s. 1 3 O n or abou Jul 9,2009,Baiey ent ed a nol cont t y l er o ender pl i t Norh Las e ea n he t 1 Vegas m uni palc ton t m i dem eanorcom pl nti t coud. Thi C our w i assum e, 4 ci our he s ai n hat s t l l 1 ar 5 guendo,t Bai ent ed a pl t a char of bater dom es i vi ence,n pror hat l ey er ea o ge t y tc ol o i s, 1 alhough t r 6 t he espondent m ai ai t he ent ed a pl t si pl bater ' s nt n hat er ea o m e t y. 1 7 Ther t ,i orar eafer n ound Sept ember2009,Bai wh was r esent att tme l ey, o epr ed hat i 1 by counsel n t s at di t i tcour , i a pr se orgi petton f a wrtofm andam us i 8 i he t e s rc t fl ed o i nal ii or i n 1 t Supr e Cour of Nevada t herw i a moton t pr 9 he em t oget t h i o oceed pr se i t coud, The o n hat 20 petton i uded al i i ncl l i t f t pr egatons hat urher osec i i t st e di rc c t uton n he at sti t our was bar ed by r 21 doubl j e eopar bec dy ause Bai had ent ed a pl t an al l ey er ea o l egedl I seri uded ofense y es ncl f 22 23 24 25 4 g19,Ex,3. 26 5 , Ex.5,at97- Ex.6. :19 98; 27 6 9, Ex.1. The exhi tsuppors bot r ngs. The dif enc i t fnalanal s,i not #1 bi t h eadi fer e,n he i ysi s 28 m at il era . - 3- 1 i t m uni palcour ' n he ci l. 2 On Ocober28,2009,t Supr t he eme Cour ofNevada deni Bai s petton. The t ed l ey' ii 3 sat hi courst ed,rf / t 'wl hav consi edt document bef et sc t t e gh t at Jlera/ hat l e e a, der he s or hi our, 4 and we c ude t t s c t i er i i t s materi notwarant ' oncl hat hi our' nt venton n hi s t s r ed.B ' 5 I t m eantm e,on O c ober20,2009,Bai s counselfl a m oton t di i n he i t l ey' ied i o sm ss 6 c t n n tat oubej op dyb r f ter r s u i ofh c a ge i t edsrc c ur on e dig h d l e ar ared urh p o ec t on t a h r s n h itit o t 7 f l ng upon t pl t t m i ol owi he ea o he sdemeanorchar i t m unii c t Folowi bre i ge n he c pal our. l ng ifng 8 and ar ent t st e di rc cour deni t m oton,concl ng t t m i dem eanor gum , he at sti t t ed he i udi hat he s 9 char was nota l eri uded ofense. ge ess ncl f g 1 0 Ido n ta ea ,o t e s owig ma t a t d bl j op d isu t er a t t es o pp r n h h n de,h t he ou e e ar y s e h e fer 11 w as pur sued - wih r t egar t t counsel moton t di i as oppos t t eari pr d o he ed i o sm ss ed o he ler o 1 se mandamus petton - î an appealorpetton i t Supr 2 ij n ii n he eme Cour ofNevada. t 1 3 Tralcurenty i seti t s at diti c i r l s n he t e s rct oud f June 7,2010,ac di t t l or cor ng o he ast 1 s at enti t f 4 t em n he eder r or i t s r d.o al ec d n hi egar l 1 5 1 6 Di scussi on Undert abst i docti gr he enton rne ounded i Youngerv.Hari 4O1 U. 37,91 S. . n rs, S. Ct 1 7 27LEd. 6 ( 9 )f de al ou rfanfo it re igwi p di saec i na 7 46, , 2d 69 1 71 ,e r c ds e r i r m n e frn t en ng t t rmi l h 1 p oc dig ab en e t oria ycrumsa e .Se g l a/ 8 r ee n s s t xr dn r i a c t nc s e er / er ycommen , d a lj ncie tFe er lnu t v 1 Rel Agai Pendi St e CiiPr eedi 9 i ef nst ng at vl oc ngs:YoungerDaysAr Her Agai 44 La. ReV. e e n, L. 20 967,970- ( 71 1984) However acl m t a pendi sat pr ecutonvi at t Doubt . , ai hat ng t e os i ol es he e 21 Jeopar Cl dy ause pr esent cicums ances al n f f al r ew whi t st e s r t l g or eder evi owi l he at e 22 23 7 , Ex.B,atel toni dock i pages 14- Respondent mai ai t pet i di notseek #1 ec r c etng 21. s nt n hat ioner d t 2 e taodiar r l fo ted bl jop ryis e.lap e sta h s ug tt d s i te ma da s 4 xr r n y ei n h ou e e ad s u t p ar h t e o h o o o n h n mu e petton,as ii sumi t pettonersfl c i accur e. See i ,atel r c docketng pages 1 1 19 & ng hat ii ' i opy s e at d. ectoni i 6, 8, 25 2O. Respondens di notfl a copy oft r d fom t mandamus pr t d i e he ecor r he oceedi ngs. 26 3 Ex.C. #2, 27 10: 3. 9 9- , Exhs.7- Ex.11,at2#1 2 28 1/17 at2. 0/ - 4- 1 pr oceedi ar ongoi i t c ai i exhaus ed. See, g. M annes v,G/ es e,967 F, ngs e ng, f he l m s t e. , / p/ / 2d 2 1310,1312 ( bCi,1992) Iwoul appearont showi made t pettonerexhaused 9t r .t d he ng hat ii t 3 t doubl j he e eopar cl m i hi pr seorgi pettoni t st esupr c t lf t dy ai n s o i nal ii n he at eme our, t urher 4 appear t pettoneri i c t f pur s hat ii s n usody or posesoff al eder habeasj idi i as,nt i urs cton, i eral a, 5 he i i phys calpr raldet i aw aii ti on t f ony char sn i eti enton tng ral he el ges. See al Just of so i ces 6 Bost M uni i Cotr l Lydon, on cpal /f ? . 466 U. 294, S. 300- 1O4 S. . 02, Ct 1805, 1809- 80 L. 2d 10, Ed. 7 311( 984)adef 1 ( endantwho hasbeenr eased on baioron hi ownr el l s ecogni zancependi ng 8 ti orappeali i cust f pur ral s n ody or posesoff alhabeasj i ctonll eder ursdi i .l 9 As a pr ral ai eti det nee,pettoneri notcur en l i cus ody pur uantt a c ii s r ty n t s o onvi ton, ci 1 0 l l 1 2 1 3 Hi petton t arses under28 U. C.j 2241 r hert 28 U. C,j 2254.The Cour s ii hus i S. at han S, t t ef er ewst doubl eopar cl m denovor hert underhesandar ofr ew her or evi he ej dy ai at han t t d evi t woul appl undert Antt r i and Efect Deat Penaly Ac ( hat d y he ierorsm f i ve h t t AEDPA)on a Secton 2254 petton.See, g,St t Mur ge,389 F. 880,888 ( bci.2004) i ii e. ow t ashi 3d 9t r . 1 4 Tur ng t t subst tve I , he Doubl J ni o he an i aw t e eopar C l e pl dy aus aces f ,i any, i is ew f Im t 1 on t poweroft f 5 he he eder and st e I sl ur t defne ofenses. See, g, Sanabra v. al at egi at es o i f e. , i 1 Uni St es, U. 54, 70,98 S. ,2170,21 82, L. 2d43 ( 6 t at 437 S. 69ed Ct 81- 57 Ed. 1978) Butonce . 1 t f 7 he eder ors at I sl ur has defned a s at or ofense by det m i ng t ' l al t e egi at e i t ut y f er ni he ' owabl al e 1 uni ofpr 8 t osecuton, t I sl i det m i i as t t scope oft ofense t di t es i ' hat egi atve er naton o he ' he f hen c at 1 t scope of pr ecton pr ded by t Doubl Jeopar Cl e. I That i once t 9 he ot i ovi he e dy aus d. s, he 20 alow abl uni ofpr l e t osecuton has been defned by t I sl ur t Doubl Jeopar t i i he egi at e, he e dy hen 21 bar a subsequent pr ecuton f t sam e ofense f l i an acqui al bar a s os i or hat f ol ng ow t , s t 22 subsequentpr ecuton f t sam e ofense f l i a prorc os i or he f ol ng ow i onvi i and bar m uli e cton, s tpl 23 c onsecutve puni ent f t sam e ofense w her t l sl ur di noti t m uli e i shm s or he f e he egi at e d n end tpl 24 puni ent Seer g. i .Jones v.Thom as,491 U. 376, shm s. e. , d. , S, 380- 1 S. . 82, 09 Ct 2522,252525 26 'l appear t pettonerhassew ed t tme i pos on t m i 't s hat ii he i m ed he sdem eanorchar . He I y ge i kel 27 woud b i c so frpupo eso fdealu idito e nih ise dwe qs vn tmeont a ch r l e n u tdy o r s f e r jrs cin ve f e n ta r erig i h t age wh tep io wa fed Se Wi o v Bel qu 5 4 F.d81 8 -4( tCi., et d ned 1 0S. . en h etin s i . e l n . l e' 5 3 6, 212 9n r) c r. e i , 3 Ct t l s e 28 7 ( 0 . 5 20 9) - 5- 1 26,05L, 2d322( 989) Ohi k Johnson, U. 493,497- 104 S. .2536, 1 Ed. 1 . o' , . 467 S. 500, Ct 25402 41,81L. 2d425 ( Ed. 1984) . 3 W hen asi eac ortansac i vi at t separ est ut t Bl bur s ngl t r ton ol es wo at at es,he ock geru aWe 4 evi dence' t t i used t det m i t al abl uni of pr ' es s o er ne he l ow e t osecuton, i , whet t i . e. her he 5 o f esc iut t ' fens onstt e he ' sameofense'ordoubl j f ' f e eopar pur dy poses,Undert Bl bur he ock ger 6 d ame evi ' s dence't t uhe t t be appled t det mi whet t e ar t ofens or 'es , t est o i o er ne her her e wo f es 7 onl one i whet eac pr si r r pr ofan addii y s her h ovi on equies oof tonalf t t ot does act hat he her 8 n . Bl bur v.Uni St es,284 U, 299,304,52 S. .180,182 76 L. 306 ot' ock ger ' t ed at S. Ct Ed, 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 ( 1932)a pr ( osecuton f a sngl mor ne sal t a si e pur erf f l e t selt i or i e phi e o ngl chas or aiur o lhe dr i t orgi samped packagei vi atonof26 U. C. 692andf f l et selt ug n he i nal t n ol i S. j oraiur o lhe dr g pu s a t a wrte or eri voa in o 26 U. C. 6 di n r utnpr e u i u r u nt o i n d n ilto f t S. j 96 d ot es li os c t on f t same o#ense becauseeach sat e r r pr fo af tt t ot di not.2 or he t ut equied oo f ac hat he her d )1 1 3 l t pr n he esent c ase, he Cour i notper t ts suaded t t s hat he exualas saul char ar t ges e 1 bared by doubl j 4 r e eopar bas upon pettoners ar dy ed ii ' gumentt he was c ced ofa hat onvit l l 5 esseri uded ofense when he ent ed a pl on t bater char ncl f er ea he t y ge. 1 6 The bater c ge i based upon a dif entcrmi actt t fve sexualass t t y har s fer i nal han he i aul 1 char 7 ges. The si char aI i vol t sam e vi tm ,and t char al occ r w hi x ges I n ve he ci he ges 1 ured l e 1 Bai wasi W as ngt sr denc durngt eveni and mor ng hour ofFebr yz78 l ey n hi on' esi e i he ng ni s uar 1 28, 2009. The bater char howe , was based upon Bai alegedl s rkng 9 t y ge, ver l ey l y tii 20 W as ngt i t l wih a t evi on r hi on n he eg t el si emot contol The sexualas tchar e r . saul ges,i n 21 contast wer based upon se r , e xual t alegedl engaged i agai W ashi on' wilnone ac s l y n nst ngt s l, 22 ofwhi i ved use o t r ch nvol f he emot Bai was notchar wih any s ualassaul bas e. l ey ged t ex t ed 23 upon hi sti i W ashi on i t I wih t t evi on r ot c r . s rk ng ngt n he eg t he el si em e ontol 24 25 26 Accor ngl now t t Cour hasa mor compl e r d,ti cl t t doubl di y, hat he t e et ecor i s ear hat he e 1The Bl kbur es,however i onl a r e ofst ut y constuci t ai i det mi ng t 2 oc gert L , s y ul at or r ton o d n er ni he l sl ie i entast t al egi at nt v o he l owabl uni ofpr ecuton whena sngl actvi at t sat es. See, g. e t os i i e ol es wo t ut e. , 27 Gar tk Uni dSt es 4 U. 7 7 8 7 1 S. . 40 2 1 1 , LEd. 7 4 (9 ) The ret ' t at ' 71 S. 73, 7 - 9, 05 Ct 2 7, 41 - 2 85 . 2d 6 1 85 . . e Bl kbur r eofc tucton t m us yi d t a pl nl expr ed c r y i entby t l st ur oc ger ul ons r i hus t ei o ai y ess ontar nt he egi at e 28 r di t alowabi uni ofpr egar ng he l e t osecuton. l i d. - 6- 1 j eopar cl m does noteven make ioutoft sari gat The bater and t s dy ai t he t t ng e. t y he exual 2 as saul char ar based upon dif entcrm i ac s,al tcom m it agai t sam e t ges e fer i nal t bei ted nst he 3 vi tm overt cour ofs ci he se ever hour The c ges ar notbased upon a si e crm i al s. har e ngl i nal 4 actgi ng rs t m uli e char vi i e o tpl ges. Thati t sam e actt gave rse t t bater char s, he hat i o he t y ge 5 - hi i W ashi on w ih t r t ng t ngt t he emot - di not al o gi rse t t fve dif ent sexual e d s ve i o he i fer 6 assaul char t ges,w hi al ch l egedl wer com m it w hi Bai had a kni or ac s t a y e ted l e l ey f e ces o 7 knie. f 8 The Bl ockbur doubl j ger e eopar anal s i addr ed t t siuaton wher uhe dy ysi s ess o he t i et 9 sam e actortansacton constt es a vi aton oft di i st ut y pr si ' 284 U . r i iut ol i wo stnct at or ovi ons.' S. 1 a 3 5 S. .a 1 ( 0 t 04, 2 Ct t 82 emph ss a ed) Her hii g W a hi t i t e Ig wi t a i dd . e, t n t s ngon n h e t he h 1 t evi i r ot con r di notconstt e a vi aton oft sexual 1 el s on em e t ol d iut ol i he assaul s at e as wel as t t ut l 1 t bater st ut Ther t i no doubl j 2 he t y at es. e hus s e eopar vi aton. dy ol i 1 3 The Cour acc di y hol on de novo r ew ,t pettoner has notest i t or ngl ds, evi hat ii abl shed 1 t hi pl t t bater c ge bar c i 4 hat s ea o he t y har s ontnued pr osec i on t pendi sexual aul uton he ng ass t 1 char 5 ges. 1 6 The Cour ot wi i not per t her se s suaded as t t r ai ng f ony c ges - t t o he em ni el har o he 1 ext t pettonerchalenges pr 7 ent hat i i l osecuton alo on t i s hese char on doubl j ges e eopar dy 1 gr 8 ounds- t doubl j hat e eopar bar pr dy s osecuton on t i hese char ges. The r ni f ony emai ng el 1 char ar based upon dif entf t and el ent None oft char 9 ges e fer ac s em s. he ges constt e t i ut he 20 sam e ofense as bater undert Bl kbur t . f t y he oc ger est 21 As t t r o he emai ng cai i t petton bas upon gr ni l ms n he ii ed ounds ot t her han doubl e 22 j eopar t Cour i notper dy, he ts suaded t t cas pr hat he e esent extaor nar cicumsances s r di y r t 23 warantng f ali er i i a pendi s at crmi pr r i eder nt venton n ng t e i nal oceedi ng, Pettoner has ii 24 avenues bot i t orgi crm i pr h n he i nal i nal osecuton and i st e postconvi i pr i n at cton oceedi ngs 25 t r se cl m sofc o ai ai onstt i iutonal r as t t actons oft s at cour and/ , appl eror o he i he t e t or as i e, cabl 26 counsel . 27 The petton t ef e wi be deni wih prj ce on t mert as t t doubl ii her or l l ed, t eudi he is o he e 28 j eopar cl m and wihoutpr udie ont basi ofabsenton ast t r ni cl ms. dy ai t ej c he s t i o he emai ng ai - 7- 1 2 Consi aton ofPossi e l der i bl ssuance ofa Cerii e ofAppeal lt tfcat abiiy UnderR ul 11 oft Rul G over ng Sec i 2254 Cas t di ti c tm us e he es ni ton es, he s rct our t 3 i ssue or deny a cediiat of appeal l y when i ent s a fnalor adver t t fc e abit i t er i der se o he 4 appl t A di ti cour or gr i ordeny ng a cedii e of appeal l y does not i , can s rct t der antng i fcat abi t i 5 elm i e t r r entt t pettonerm us fl a tm ef notc ofappeali or t i nat he equiem hat he ii t ie i y i e n der o 6 appealt coud' j he s udgmen . A moton t r t i o econsdert or r di a c tfcat o i he der egar ng erii e f 7 appeal l y does notext t tm e t appeall abii t end he i o .c 8 Ast t cl msr ect byt diti c tont mert under28 U. C. 2253( , o he ai ej ed he srct our he is, S. j c) 9 a pettonerm ustm ake a ' ii ' t i s subs antal how i oft deni ofa cons iutonal i 'i or ng he al tt i rghtf n der 1 t obt n a cerii e ofappeal lt S/ v.M cDani ,529 U. 473,483- 120 S. , 0 o ai t cat f abiiy, ack el S. 84, Ct 11 1595,1603- 146 L. 2d 542 ( 04, Ed. 2000) Hi a v N ood,195 F, 1098,1104 ( h Ci. , val . . i 3d 9t r 1 1 , To satsf t s sandar t pettoner' 2 999) i y hi t d, he i i mustdemonsr e t r onabl j i s tat hat eas e urst 1 woul fnd t dititcour' as smentoft constt i 3 d i he s rc t ses s he iutonalcl m debat e orwr ' ai abl ong. ' 1 Sl 4 ack,529 U , at484,12O S. .at1604. S. Ct 1 5 As t cl ms rj t on pr o ai eeced ocedur gr al ounds wihou r t t eachi t underyi ng he l ng 1 c 6 onstt i iutonal ai s, he pettonerm us show , n or t obt n a cerii e of cl m t ii t i der o ai tfcat appeal l y: abii t 1 ( )t a j rsso r s n woudfn id a abewhehe t e pe ion sa e avai cai o 7 1 h t u it f ea o l id t eb t l t r h ti ttd t l lm f d 1 adeni ofa c iutonalrghtand( t j i sofr 8 al onst i i ' 2)haturst easonwoul fndidebat ewhet t , di t abl her 1 t dititcour was corec i is pr 9 he s rc t r t n t ocedur r i S/ al ul ng. ack,529 U. at484,1 S. .at S. 2O Ct 2 1604, W hi bot showi mustbe m ade t obt n a ceriiat ofappeal l y,' c t 0 l e h ngs o ai tfc e abii ' our t a 21 mayfnd t i c dipose oft applcaton i a f rand pr i hat t an s he i i n ai omptmanneri i pr eedsfr f t oc ist 22 t r ve t i o esol he ssue whose ans i mor appar tfom t r d and ar wer s e en r he ecor gument ' 529 s. ' 23 U. at485,12O S. . 1 S. Ct at 604.W her a pl n pr e ai ocedur bari pr l i ed, appeal al s opery nvok an 24 i notwarant 529 U. at484,120 S. ,at1604. s r ed. S. Ct 25 I t pr n he esentcase,urst ofr j i s easonwoul notfndt r ectonofpeti ' doubl d i he ej i ioners t e 26 27 'A c tfcat ofappeal lt i r r d i t spr edur con ex . &ee W i 554 F. at 8243 erii e abii s equie n hi oc al t t y l son, 3d 28 25. - 8- 1 j p d cai t b deb t bl o wr g.Th b ter o bat r d eo ar y l m o e a a e r on e a t y r te y omesi vol c c ar tc i en e h ge 2 t whi he en er a pl i n based upon t s o ch t ed ea s ot he ame crmi ac as t sexualas t i nal t he saul 3 char ges. The bater char i based upon sti ng t vi i i t I w ih a t evi on t y ge s rki he ctm n he eg t el si 4 r emot c r . The s e ontol exual assaul c ges i ead ar based upon m uli e al t har nst e tpl l egedl y 5 noncons ensualsexualact pedor ed I ert s e eveni and/ m or ng. s m at he am ng or ni 6 Jurst ofr i s eason f udherwoul notfnd debat e orw r t C oud' concl on, d i abl ong he s usi as 7 t t r ai ng cl m s, t o he em ni ai hat t case ot wi does not pr he her se esent ex r di y t aor nar 8 cicum s anc war antng f r t es r i eder c ti er ton i a pendi st e crm i pr al our nt ven i n ng at i nal oceedi ng. 9 I THEREFO RE I O RD ER ED t he petton f a w rtofhabeas cor i DENI T S hatt ii or i pus s ED 1 andt t saci shalbe DI SSED wihprj ceont mert ont doubl j 0 hat hi ton l SMI t eudi he is he e eopar dy l1 cai and wihou prj ce ont basi ofabst i ast aIot cl mspr ent lm t t eudi he s enton o l her ai es ed. 1 2 I FU RTH ER I O RDERED t a cerii at ofappeal l y i D ENI T S hat lfc e abi t s i ED. 1 3 The Cl kofCourshalent fnaludgmentaccor ngl i f ofr er t l er i j di y n avor espondent and s 1 agai tpettoner 4 ns ii . 1 5 DATED: s 9t day ofJune,2010. Thi b 16 17 . 18 Unied St t 1 9 20 2l 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 - 9- Di rctJudge st i
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
