Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al, No. 2:2008cv01223 - Document 476 (D. Nev. 2010)
Court Description: ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 354 Motion for Attorney Fees. The Court awards Defendant Interstate Plumbing & Air Condition, LLC twenty percent (20%) of its requested attorneys' fees and non-taxable costs, including experts& #039; fees, in the amount of $53,831.25. The Court awards Defendant Interstate Plumbing & Air Conditioning, LLC taxable costs in the amount of $15,469.00. As such, the Court award Defendant Interstate Plumbing & Air Conditioning, LLC its attorneys' fees and costs in the total amount of $69,300.25. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
1 2 UNI TED STA TES DI STR I T CO UR T C 3 DI STR I O F N EVAD A CT 4 5 EDW I K .SLAUGHTEK REBECCA FLI N NN, Ca eNo. s : 6 2: - 01 RCJ GW F O8 CV- 223- - a SI a CAR OL HLAT , nd vi ly nd EL nd TY i i dua l a on be fofal ot rss m iary sitat o nd hal 1 he i l l tz ed 7 Pi a ntfs i if , 8 v s. 9 10 Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al UPON OR , N C . a M i ot co or ton; 1 , nnes a m a i OR DER ON DE FEN DAG I TEK STAI E N ' UPONOR NORTH AM ERI m C.a CA , PLUM BI & AI CONII OM NG, NG R I TI 11 M i e ou c r r to R CR PLUNI G A' r s m o po a i n; Bm ND I,, S M O TI N FOR ATTO R NEY S' I CS O M BCH ANI L,I C. a Ca io n a c r r ton; FEES A N C O STS CA N , lf r i o po a i m 1 m TERSTA IE PLUM BING & AI 2 ' I R 1 C ON DI ON W G , 3 TI LLC,a N e da l ie va i t d m la iiy o i b lt ompa UNI ny; TED PLLM BW G,LLC, F 1 a Ne da lm ie la it co pa l 4 va i t d i biiy m ry; FERGU SON EN TERPP JSES,m C. aV igi a , r ni 1 cor 5 i n;H UGH ES W ATER & SEW ER LP, o porat 1 aFl zdalm ie pa t rhi a s c s rby 6 oi i td rne s p nd uc es o m e ge t STAN DAR D W H OLESM . r ro E 1 SUPPLY COO AI , d s ol d N e da 7 W a i s ve va c o a i n;1 D SI PPLY CON STRU CTI op r to 1 J ON 1 stp ptv LI I 8 NITED PARTNERSHI aFl i P, orda . l lm ie pa t r hi ' D OES 1 30, 9 i t d rne s p, - ROE CORPORA TI S I XA- . ON - ' X Doc. 476 20 D ef ndant e s. 21 22 23 Thi c ei ac a sa to lws ta i tDe e nt , s as s l s c in a ui gans f nda s who ae al d t ha n a a t r d, r lege o ve a nuf c u e sr bu e nd/ ns a l d le l f tve um ng o ne s c antf s 24 m ar cd, dit i l d,a ori t le a l ged y de ec i pl bi c m po nt ,wbj b Pi i i f ket r 25 alege caused ha . o a e lke j t c us h l i t f tle t t i r i nc l t d i Cl r l rm r r i l ' o a e a ml n he u t . o he r esde es oca e n a k 26 Count'Ne a.Theca ehasbe n d s s dMrh pr j r Be or t eCou i Defnd t l. vad s e inés e i qudie. f e l t a n s e ma 27 I I NTERS TATE P I BI & .J CONDI ONI Ll ' M oîn f r - z ys F e a dCo t. LLM NG X R TI -NG. . ' to o Atone ' e s n ss Cs t 2 j J5 .AEsae h ri t àt to?i Gru e .l p r. F I ?4 p :td ezn.i t i: s a td i aL w o k I I Dockets.Justia.com 1 TheCo t wa dsDe e ntI ur a r f nda NTERSTATE PLL BW G & AI CONDI ONI LLC M R TI NQ 2 e1)pec nt( A)ofisr quetdatr y fe a non-a bl c t,i l i e pet fe 1 : re 20O 1 t e se tone s' e s nd txa e oss ncudng x rs' e s 3 a t a le pe es i t t t la o mto $53, 25. nd rve x ns , n he o a m t f 831. 4 The Cour a a dsD e e ntI tw r f nda NTER STATE PLI M BI G & AI COND I OO J N R TI G, LLC 5 t bl cossi t a o of$1 46 00. axa e t n he m unt 5, 9. 6 A ss h,t t ala a d o f esa o t t De e ntI uc he ot w r f e nd oss o f nda NTERSTA TE PLU M BL & A I NG R 7 CON DI ON L , TI NG LLC i $69 300. s , 25. 8 TheCour a r De e a W TERSTATE PLUM BI & AI CONDI ONI LLC t wa ds f nd nt NG R TI NG, 9 osju nti ee ta tl fdea j t dsne ntrs tle e rludgme rt.Thewe kl a rgeoftl ly rco tnt nt ae e y vea lc -ea nsa 1 m a u ij Tr sty yi l f t w e k be o e J nu r 27. 0 i . % . da l r t f rpos0 t rtr ew tt e d or he e f r a a y 201 s 31 The iy a e o ' t 11 'dm e i ee ti .00 4931 ( . / ) Pos-udgme i e etwila u aea $. / u ntntrs s 0 008 5 $0031365 . tj ntntr s l cc mult t 581% 1 t i stsid (000008 315*$69300. ) 2 mtl aife . 49 , 25 . 1 1 3 . FI DI S O F FA C T N NG 1 4 1. ( n J y 28, ) ul 2008, a ntf sEdw i K . a ght r Re c Flnn,M e H e l y a Pl i if n Sl u e , bec a i 1 a e nd 15 Ca o H ea e fl d t pr s n a to o be l oft m s l s a d a 1o he s sm ia st t d, n t . r l ly ie he e e t c i m n ha f he e ve n 1 t r i lr iua e i he 16 Ei h Judi i D itrctCourti Ci k Cot t N eva Pl ntff alege t D ef nt Uponor, ght c al s i n ar m y, da. ai i s l hat enda s umbi & M e hn c l I . i e saePlmbi & Ai Co totng LLC, t d ng c nia , nc, ntr tt u ng r ndii ri , Unie 17 l ., RCR Pl nc r o e prs s nc.a ' hc l tr nd we r nga d n he 18 Pl bi , LLC,Fe gus n Ent r ie ,l , ndIug sW ae a Se rLP aee ge i t um ng 1 busne s o de i i de l pi m a a t lng, s rbu i m a ke i s li a i t li t 9 i s f s gn ng, ve o ng, nuf c ui diti tng, r tng, e lug, nd ns a lng he 20 w îs PEX pl m bi s t m , nc ud ng W i s b a sf ti ,a pa toft pot bl w a e s ppl r bo u ng ys e i l i r bo r s itngs s r he a e t r u y 21 s tm sofr sde i ld lngsi Clr Co mt , vad yse e i nta weli n a k t y Ne a. 22 2. Pl i if al get t'y lo br s 'W is fti i t le a pad o W is antfs le ha çel w a s' rbo itngs nsal d s f rbo 23 pl bi s t m s i r s de i ldw e lngs i Cl r Count N e da, r de e tve d t a p oc s um ng ys e n e i nta li u a k y, va a e f c i ue o r es 2 r f r e t a de i ii a i Pl i if s d t D e e m s i l i I TERSTATE PLI V BI G 4 e e r d o s z nc f c ton. a ntf s ue he f nda , nc ud ng N J N ' 25 ( A . CON- TI t J R DT ONTNG,LLC.unde t f i ngt ore ofla lt'( J oduc la lt ( r he olowi he i s ibiil: 1 pr t ibiiy; 2) . . 26 src ia iiy;( ) ea h ofe r s wal np' ï ) e c o 'mple wa r nt ( )b e c ofwa r nt ti: l b lt 3 br c xp e s r- ' 4 br a h 1i id ra yt 5 r a b a : ra y o - 7 I me ha i lt;a t . n gi n e Panis og : zea adsci dmae i ecs o' of a ntbiiy nd 6 el ec. i tf suh gnr!u pca a gsn xes f ) g if l . -E I )?ttt.ll. ? '' S (.l h- o 0(. L è tt l I I j 1 1 - ! n - . .. . j(L t(.y, . ); j.k . 1s n ' 3. On Se e r 1 2 , e e ntUpo r l . e ove t l w s tfom Cl r pt mbe 5, 008 D f nda no , nc r m d he a ui r ak 2 Comt DititCo r t Fe ea Co rpu s a t oteCls AcinFamesAc (t A'.# 1 t y src u to d r l u t ru n t h a s t o i s tt CAF ' ( ) ) 3 4. OnAprl20,2009, antfsfldaM oin frCl sCetfo ton.g 11 ''e i Pli if ie to o as ri ai # 0J fh 4 Cou tt r a rpe te ape i ofdi c r a t r r he e ûe nnit d rod s ove y nd h ough v r o e t nsons s tahea i f r a i us x e i , e rng o 5 li if 'M oton f Cls Ce tic ton o J nua y 25 2010. antfs i or a s rii ai n a r , 6 5. 7 A s t i lpa toft di c ve y co ubsanta r he s o r nduc ed by D e e nt t da e i l i t f nda s o t , nc ud ng e e ntW TEI TATE PLUM BI & AI . f nda LS NG R CONDI ONI LLC,hasbe n t de e d a i t TI NG, e o f n gang 8 Pl ntfs M oton f Cl s Ce tfc to ni if ' i or a s riiai n. 9 6. l 0 Thr ougbo t dic or ro De e nt,i ud n De e ntI ut he s ove pe i d, f nda s ncl i g f nda NTFRSTA' I Y LIM BI & M R CONDI ONI LLC,a tnde a d pa tcpaediln e o de iirs J NG TI NG, te d n ri i t l um r us postox, l1 i l i a etmae ni ( o ofsaede ii ,e e a i si tdt ts ndsofpa s ncudng n si td ne 9) ut tt postons rviwed nd nve tgae hola gc 1 ofdoc m e a i di c os d by t Pl i if ,r t i e rs a tnde de tuc i t s i a lo 2 u nt ton s l e he a ntf s e n ned xpe t , t e d s r tve e tng nc r / 1 viualmpe tonsofatlm t:ve( )ho s a atnde meal giale tngofpl ng 3 s i ci e s i 5 me , nd te d tlur c tsi umbi 1 c 4 ompone ss e t dby Pli if a Se lLa r t i i ElSe ndo,Caio ni .Thi die r wa nt elc e antfs t a bo aores n gu if r a s s ove y s l a lprm a iy ge r d t w a dsde e tng Pl i if ?M o i f rCl s Ce tfca i 5 l i rl a e o r fai a ntf s ton o as r ii ton. 1 6 7. Si et i tato ofttsca e, beD e e a s ha c ge i nu e ousm oto nc he nii i n li s t f nd nt ve nga d n m r in 1 flngs a d a gu e sprm a i y r l tng t di c ! a co e s ofc a sce tf c ton. The e 7 ii n r m nt i z l e a i o s ove y nd nc nl l s r ii a i s 1 M oinsi l daMoto f Pr lmi r lj tona /rTe rr Re tani Or rfl. b) 8 to ncude in or ei nay nunci ndo mpoay sri ng de e , d 1 Dee nt Fegu o Entr ie ,nc. ndUnie Plmbi LLC ( 20 , c Dee nt 9 fnda s r s n eprss l a td u ng, # 9) whih fnda 20 PWERSTATB PLUM BI G & A. CONDI ONI LLCj ne a Pli if'Moto frLe ve N' I R TI NG, oi d, nd antfs in o a 21 t FieaSe o Ame dComplit( 21 , c t Dce nt,n l ngI o l c nd nde an # 91 whih he fnda s icudi NTERSTA' I Y 22 PLL M BI G & . I CON DI OM N G , T N /R t TI LLC,op e pos d. 23 8. On De e c mber3, 2009, ai if ûl d aNotceofW ihd a o M oton f rCl s Pi ntfs c i t r wal f i o as 24 Cetfc lon.f 27 Pli if (i no! e kl lcoft Co r ê fl i ame ds mpli t riiai # 8J antfs ld s e eaz he u t o ie m nde o anto 25 w ih a t cl s a l ga i f o t i pl d ng t dr w he a s lc tons r m hc r ea i s. 26 9. On Deccm ber7-3009.Pl ntf s fl a M oton t V olm triy Di m i t sltgaton ai i f ied i o t a l s ss hi ii i 27 i ise trt t 28 OnJ nua -7.2O1 t sCoutc ee a Or rp'ntngPiitfk'Moin n t niey.' 5j # a o' 2 0,hi r ntr d n de a i anlf to n8 f R- tnt l D in i s l i pa a di n i s x t sl v/u tvi h pr i c i udi g a 1 le to i or olz ap s l s a - n n. nd s l s t l hi a s i t e udi e. nzl l l a i ga i ns n l : . ;- . + I 1 t Co antg 34% TheCo t pr sl r me us ci t c i rM otonsf Atome s he mpli .# ur ex esy ma elu diton o onsde i or l y ' 2 Fe sa l Cossfldby t De e nt,i l ugI e rd t ie he f nda s ncudi NTERSTATE PLLT BI & AI M NG R 3 CO NDI ONI , TI NG LLC. 4 1 0. W TERSTATE PLU. BI & AI CONDI OM NG , M NC R TI LLC fl disM oto f r ie t in o 5 Atorlls Fec a Co t o Fe u r l 201 ( 35 OnM ac 11 2009 I t rer' s nd ss n br ay 0, 0.# 41 rh , , NTERSTATE 6 LUM BI & AI CONDI ONI LLC fld isRe yt Pli éfs Oppo iin t isM oto f r NG R TI NG, ie t pi o a n f ' sto o t in o 7 A tor ys Fe s a Cos s i w h c I t ne ' e nd t , n i h NTERSTA'E PLU M BI & A I CON D I ON W G, I NG R TI LLC 8 spplme e isM otonw11a tona fe a cossi ure snc ilngisorbna M oi a u e ntd t i t1 ddii l e s nd t nc rd i e ii t i l ton, nd . 9 i l eda Af vi fom Eie nMuli nMaks Es ,n c mplal wihLR 54- 6.g 36 ncud n fda t r le lga r , q.i o irce t 1 # 9) 1 0 1. 1 I TERSTA'' PLUAI NG & .. CONDT ONT NT TE BI AI R TI NG,LLC r que td a a r o r se u wa d f 11 a t ne s'f e a non-a bl c t ,ncudnge rs f sa ta c t f atndngnmne ol tor y e s ud txa e oss i l i xpe t' ee nd r vel oss or te i r ts 1 outofsaede ii nsno iedbyPli if , nt a l o $269, 56. I 2 t t posto tc antfs i he mo mt f 1 26. NTERSTATE 1 PLUNI NG & A I COND I OM NG , 3 BI R TI LLC a s r que t d t a e o t i t a ou o lo e s e U bl oss n he m nt f 1 $ 178. l al,I 4 17, 44. n l NTERSTATE PLI BI & AI CONDI ONI LLC r qu td is JM NG R TI NG, e ese t 1 a t ne 'f e , n-a bl coss a t xa ec t i t t a a ou of$ , 4. 5 tor ys e s no txa e t, nd a bl oss n he otl m nt 28633 70. 1 6 1 2. A tt he r ng o M a 1 201 t i Coa ta a de I he a i n y 0, 0a h s r w r d NTER STA TE PLU M BI & NG 1 A.k COND I OM N G , 7 ' I l TI LLC 20 ofisa t r ys f e a non-a bl c t , nd or r d t r % t to ne ' e s nd t xa e os s a de e he e l t xi ofc t t c m n t tno a ou ofatr y 'f sa no t a ec t we ei l d il 8 a ng oss o onf ha m nt to ne s ee nd n-u bl oss r ncude r 1 heo i ra txai ofcoss 9 rgill a ton t. 20 1 3. On M a 25, 0,I U RSTATE PLU M BW G & A I CON D I ON W G , y 201 N R TI LLC f ld te 21 isa nde bilofcossc nGr ngist bl c t i t ttla untof$1 1 .4( )a t me d l t o mi t axa e oss n he oa mo 7,78. /422 nd 4 22 fu hcrconfr i t t rt i m ng hat hose eos sdo noti ude am 'a t ne tr orany ott m ate notpr l t ncl tor ys' ine ter t r opery 2 txa eund rLR 54- tr 3 a bl e 1 houghLR 54- 5a 28U. C.j19 1 1 nd S. 20- 924. 2 4 1 4. OnJ ne4,2010 Pli if fl a Ob e to a a M oi t Re-a Coss(W3 . u , antfs ied n j ein nd ton o -r x t # 2) 2 ITT R EPL IIG&.RC N IINN ,L fe a eltPatfOjcoadl 5lN EL WT LABN z O DTO LGL C id Rp o lnf'bei n 1 S t l l y iis tn 2 k4 ïnt Refa o J n .l J 0443 . r Pli i sfldaRe l o J n 2 - O O(4 63 , 6 s oî o - x n u e2 .2 / 82al anlf ie o 01 d f pl n u e 8 2 1 t 4 .4 1 4 j ' 27 ii a' u'siel ol Aug t13.2(1 a t Oou-is d af r lOr ron Se e r2(. 1O r l e lng a l d ) us - i 1O nd he l s ue o ma dc t ptmbc .2t1 e , O ), S . l I c- . . i0, u .. , , . ... . i , 1 t ng I axi NRY RSTA TE PLU M BI G & Am COM XTI I ,LLC ' c t i t a o of N ON NG S os s n he m unt 2 $15469. (W53 , 00.* ) 3 H. C ON CLU SIO N S O F LA W 4 1 . 5 TheCo te prsl rti dj iditont rzeupo t Dee nt'M oi fr ur x e sy eane urs ci o tl n he fnda s tons o torreys'Fees and Coss. t t t 6 2. Loc lRul 5 6 ou lne t f l i f c o st co i rwhe a a d ng a t n ys a e 4-1 ti s he olow ng a t r o ns de n w r i tor e ' 7 fe :()t r ulsobaneda dtea t i l d;( t no l.a difcut oft que to e s 1 he es t ti n h momtnvove 2) he vet nd f ly he sins y 8 h le ;()tes il e u st t p rom t lg l e ie p o ry ()tep e lso o oh r wov d 3 h k lrq iie o efr he e a s nr s r pel ;4 h rcu in f te c 9 e oy n byt atr yd t t a c ptnc oft ca e ( whzhe tefei fxedor mpl me t he to ne ue o he c e a e he s ; 5) t r h e s l 1 c i e ;( t tmelmiainsi e byt cinto t cr msales ()t e re e, 0 ontng nt 6) he i i tto mpos d he le r he icu ttc ; 7 he xpeinc 11 e utEon,a a lt o t atr e ;()tl l srbiiyo t ca e i al ( t naur a p a nd biiy f he to n ys 8 le mde ia lt f he s ,f ry; 9) he t e ud 1 lngt oftt p oe so lrlto hi wiht cintaz ( 0 a r i sr lrc s s 2 e h le r fs ina eains p t he le ; ld 1 ) wads n inia a e . 1 3 1 4 3. ETF EKSTATE PLI AI NG & Am CONDI ONI LLC s m it d Afi viso J BI TI NG, ub te fda t f ie n M uli an M a ks Es w ih isM o i f Ator ys'Fee ard Cos s a Re y t Pl i if ' le lg r , q. t t ton or t ne s l t , nd pl o antf s 1 O p ii n t isM oto f Ato ne ' sa Cos s whi h m e t r r m e t o Loc lRul 5 posto o t i n or t r ys Fee nd t, c t he equie n s f a c 1 54-16. 6 1 7 1 8 4. I Afi aviss itdwih I n ld t ubm te t NTERSTATE PLUM BI & Al CONDI OM NG, NG R TI LC' M o ng a Re y Pa r , uns lf rI s vi nd pl pe s co e o NTERSTATE PLIM BW G & M R CONDI ONW G, J TI 1 LLC al sst tt lw f n i ta l bild f riswor a ar t of$1 00pe ho f rpa te tme 9 te t ha he a m niily le o t k t ae 40. r ur o rn r i , 20 $1 00pe ho f as oc aetm e a $80.0 pe ho f rpa ae ltm e Durngtt c m s o t s 23. r ur or s it i n nd 0 r ur o r lga i . i le o e f hi 21 ltg in, hef ewasi r s d t S16 O0pe ho f rpa m c tm ea $1 00pe hou f r ii ato t e nc ea e o 0. r ur o z r i nd 35. r r o 22 m s it tm c Co ms lf I C s oc ae i . t e or N ERSTATE PLUM BI & AB? CONDI ONVNG. NG TI LLC a s atss lo te t 23 t t nu rofhou st lw fnn s nton I o he mbe r he a i pe NTERSTATE PLLM BI G & AJ CONDI ONL N R TI NG, 24 LLC' def e i tksacton. S ens n li i 2 5 5. Pii if ha ha t op qtniyt r v e a r s ndt t e de e antfs ve d he pc- t o e i w nd e po o he vi nc u 26 I NTERSTATE PLUAI N G & ..R CON D I ON-NG , -- s it d i s BI AI TI L ItC ubm te - uppo tofisM oto f r l z r t in o 27 At o n ys Fe s a Cos s i i ng t Af i a 't ofc t r r ' e nd t - nc udi he f d Ais ouns la i i sf t xa e a d none né nvo cc or a bl n 2E , 1 1 txa ec t icur d.Pli if di notob ett t hotl bli rt o c unslnort ntmbe of a bl oss n re antfs d j o o he try ilng ae f o e, he t r 2 hou sbil di dee i I r le n fndng NTERSTATE PLI M BI & AI CONDI ONTNG,LLC. J NG R TJ 3 6. TheCour ge r ly fndst tt bul oft a tm e 'f e a no t xa ec t t ne a l ha he k he to ys c s nd n-a bl oss 4 i ure b t De e a s i l i I nc r d y he f nd nt, ncud ng NTERSTATE PLUM BI & A. CONDI ONI LLC, NG I R TI NG, 5 wilhav v leils e ntpr ee i a ma no bet s j to alat ne s'fe a r i l e au r ubsque oc dngs nd y t he ubec f r tor y e s wad n 6 t slt gaton. hi ii i 7 7. A r a a d ofs e pori n o tl r ue t d a t m e 'f e a t no t xa e c t p lw r om to f le eq s e t o ys e s rd n- a bl oss 8 i udi e r s f e a t a le ns f r al ndi num e ous o ofs a e dc ii nsno i e by ncl ng xpe t ' e s nd r ve xpe es o te ug r ut t t posto tc d 9 Pl i i f ,i r a o bl a a opra e i t sm a t rbe us oft r s t tt D e e nt s a ntf s s e s na e nd ppr i t n hi te ca e he i k ha he f nda s 1 i l ng I ERSTA TE PLUM Bm G & AI CON DI ON I LLC,w il nc d i a i 0 nc udi NT R. TI NG, l i ur uplc tve a tr ey 'fesi de e ng i ntc lis sitf t r pr e di ,ncudi but lmie t ,a to n s e n f ndi de i a s ue r u u e oc e ngs i l ng, not i t d o 1 2 ot nta r que tf rcl s c r i a i M or i pora l ,dl a t r y f e we e i c r d asa r s t e i l e s o a s e tfc ton. e m tnty e to ne s' e s r n ur e e ul 1 ofPll ir 'own de i i t s e c a s c ri i a i n, y t l t ri t c s w i r w t i M o i 3 r ntf s i c son o e k l s e tfc to onl o a e n he a e t a he. ton hd r 1 f r Cl s Ce tfc to a fl aM oto t D i m i s 4 o a s rii a i n nd ie in o s s. 1 5 8. TheCo indst tr que tng adei to off e i lneby lne d t - dae mt i ha e si lneain e s n i - i . a eby- t 1 f r a ,a orr quii m TERSTAT. PLUM BI & A' CON DI ON I , 6 o m t nd/ e rng E NG x TI NG LLC t p od e o r uc 1 e ctd bilngi c e ,wo dr quieI 7 da e li nv ùc s ul e r NTERSTATE PLUM BL & AI CONDI ONW G, NG R TI LLC l8 t ur ecess i y i t m or ator ls'f o m arl nctr e t ne r ees. 1 9 9. A sa r ul oft f c t ts ve a D e e nt a e r q si a t e 'f e a c t , es t he a t ha e r l f nda s r e ue tng tom ys e s nd os s 20 t Cour fndst ta i gr s nzi awa di at r ys f esa non-a bl cossi a o it he t i ha n n- o s lng r ng to ne ' e nd t xa e t s ppr prae 21 a fndst ta a r oft nt pec nt( nd i ha n wad ' y re 20%)oft at y fe a no t a ee t i urd we he tome s' e s nd n-n bl oss nc re 22 by e i oft M tv ngDe e nt,i l di J T STATE PLUM BI & altCONDI OM NG, acl he l i f nda s nc u ng NTFR NG i l k TI 23 LLC, sar as na e a r ofa tm e 'f esa no txa ec t ,ne udi e pe t'f e al ta l i e o bl wa d to ys e nd n-a bl oss i l ng x rs e s rd r ve 2 epnetaedhnmeudpsi sn ne osMie toDenatpnrn. l 4 xessotnteu r seoio iMi a l, l saf fdnUoo,cs t o tn n p i m o e i' 25 per m elnotced by t Pl ntfs. sol î be ai if 2 txabl lt iTcioigeunlofsatieeeaomisn.sno-xolne-sldj'.or ! ( 0 hMcieDfdtivruetdtryif . naboot.(l.) 1 ) o. o s nea shhc'mortantnlioexnaward fcttn n nnlg lqsh Sùe'e tae sfa 27 a ecss nac lctv m'o 7 4 ' i: f k 78 l veav pf c n:f 0% ) o-a t r ls f esa nop-a bl cossi ur e b3 I TERSTATE ' ll' r t . e . r t o oe '' e ud v 2 : xa e l nc r d . N ' - , i 1 LUM BI & AlkCONDF OM NG, NG l FI LLC, nd e c oft ot rM o rgDe e a s i r a ona e a a h he he vit fnd nt, s e s bl 2 unde t c r um sa san f di ass tf r h a r he ic t nce d m ngs e o t bove a r duc ng t f e r que t d by e c s b , s e i be c s e s e a h uc 3 De e ntpr vi esf rar s na ec lc i f e a r o a o m aey $2 000.Thi a ad of fnda o d o ea o bl ole tve e wa d f ppr xi tl 00, sw r 4 a t e s'f san non-axa ec t i s c lc l e e e a ns t na e Pl i if , not tom y ee d t bl oss s pe ii aly ntr d gai t he m d antfs and 5 co m s f rt Pli i f . t el o he a ntf s 6 1. 1 Tle Co tfndst t ti r a o bl a a op i t t a a d I T STA TE z ur i ha i s e s na e nd ppr r a e o w r N ER 7 PLUM BI & AI CONDI ONW G, NG ! R TI LLC t xa ec t i t a o mtof$15469. . a bl oss n he m t , 00 8 1 2. T NTERSTATE PLLI BW G & .m CONDI ONW G,LLC i note ild t pr M A TI s ntte o e 9 ' gm e i e e t Howe r I ud nt ntr s. ve , NTERSTATE PLUM BW G & M R CONDI OM NG, TI LLC i e itd s ntte 1 t po t g nti ee tfo t daeofe ! o t fna J 0 o sjud me ntr s rm he t nty f be i l udgme ofDi lslwihPrj c , nt m ' a t eudie s l1 Jam a y 2 201 untlt a a d i s ts d i f l t r 7, 0, i he w r s a ife n ul. 1 H1 2 . O R DER 1 3 The Cou ta a dsD e e ntI r w r f nda NTER STA TE PLU M BW G & . R CON DI OO M TI G, LLC 1 t nt pece ( %)ofisrquetdat ys fe a non-a bl c -,i l i e pe t fe,n 4 we y r m 20 t e se tome ' e s nd txa e oss noudng x rs' e si t 1 t a 5 he mountof$5 8 25. 3, 31. 1 6 The Cour a r De e ntI T t wa ds f nda NTERSTATE PLUM BW G & AI CONDI OM NG, R TI LLC 1 t a e c t i t a o of $1 469. 0. 7 r bl oss n he m unt 5, 0 1 8 A s s h,t Cou ta a dsD e e ntI TERSTATE PLI NI NG & AI CON DI ON I G, uc he r w r f nda N J BI R TI N 19 LLC is a t re 'f esa c t i t t t la o m tof$69 30 25. t tort ys e nd os s n he o a m t , 0. 20 .// / 21 /// 22 1// 1 23 //. / 24. '/, '/ 25 ''7 26 . ' . , , 28 I l ! 1 i l ' ! 1 The Co t w a dsD e e ur a r f ndmz I t NTER STATE PLU M BI G & A I COND I ONW G , N R TI LLC 2 os-udgme i ee ta t fdea j tj ntntrs the e rludgme rt.Thewe kl a rgeoft lye rc rsa t nt ae e y vea he - a olt' a 3 m a urt Tr a l y e d f rt w e k bef e J nu ! 27, 0 i . O . The da l r t f pos t iy e suy i l o he e or a a y 201 s 3IA iy a e or t 4 'dgme i e e ti . 0008 u nt nt r s s 00 4931 ( 00 / ) Pos-ud nti e etwilac lntlt a $. / y 5 $. 31365 . tj gne ntrs l cu zae t 58da . 5 untlstsid (000008 31 *$69, 25 . i aife . 49 5 300. ) 6 7 Dae Novem bqr29t 2010 td h, - uO 1yCpo noa j 6 - u y ua o s Untd S e ' 'tCC A ie ut s ) U . 9 10 11 Re pe t a l Subm it d: s c f ly te 12 T 1 M zu x s LA /,GR ol' ,s p H . s ; p 13 14 By: EI LEEN , ESQ. 005708 / 1 sl t A . ! 5 tu m > EsQ. 16 1l Town Cent D rve,Sui e 200 20 er i t asV eg% ,N evada 89144 17 Ator ysf rD e e ntI TERSTA TE t ne o f nda N PLLM BW G & AI CONDI ONI LLC T R TI NG, 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 ( 2% I i
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
