Dean v. Sparks et al
Filing
25
ORDER DISMISSING CASE with prejudice for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. Clerk shall close case and enter judgment accordingly. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 4/21/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - EDS)
<![CDATA[
' :
1
1 .
Jt1 1 q ''t J . ù:. ! ! '-) J1 ! (1 . t
'
1 2
.
.
J
1
.
J
4
5
6 7
UN I ED STATES DISTRICT CO U R T T DISTRICT O F N EV A D A
8 ROCKY DEAN, 9 l vs 0.
Pli tf, an if
11 THE PUBLI DEFENDER OFFI E, C C e a. t l, l 2 Defnda t . c ns
l 3
) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
Ca eNo. 08- v 05 4- CJ RJ s 2: c - 4 R - J
ORDER
1 4
Pli tf, i ic r e a e a dpr c e i gpr s a di j r apau e i, ass bm it daCi i an if who s n a c r t d n o e d n o e n n b m p rs h u tc vl
1 Ri ht Compli tPur u ntt 4 U. . .j 1 83 (/ ) ThcCour ha s r e e Pli tf' ci i rgh s 5 gs an s a o 2 S C 9 /5 . t s c e n d an ifs v l i t l c m pli tpurua tt 28 U. . .j 1 1 A a d tndst a i mus be d s is d. 6 o an s n o S C 9 5 n i h t t t im s e
11 7.
l 8
Sc e ni gSt ndar Purua tt 28U.. .j1 1 A re n a d s n o SC 9 5
Fe e alco rs m us c nduc a pr lm i a y s r e i g i an c s i whi h a prs ne s ek dr ut to t ei n r c e n n n y a e n c io r e s
l r d es fo agove nm e tle tt orofi e ore pl yc o agov r m e t le tt .Se 28 U. . .j 9 e r s rm r n a n iy fc r m o e f e n n a n iy e SC 20 1 l A () I isr viw ,heCour mus i e tf a y c gnia l cai sa ddim isa ycai st a a e 9 5 a. n t e e t t t d n iy n o z b c l m n s s n l m h t r
2 1 f i ol us,m alci us,f i t s at acl i upon whi h r lefm aybegr nt d ors ck m onet r r leffcll rv o i o a lo t e am c ci ae c a y e i r )r
22 a de e da twho i i m u e fo s c r lcf Se 28 U. . .j 1 1 A ( ) 1 ,2) Pr s pla i gs fn n s m n rm u h ei . e SC 9 5 b ( )( . o e e d n , 23 h we e ,mus belbe a l c nsr e .Bal te ip Pactc Polc De ' 90lF.d. 699( t Ci. o v r t i r ly o tu d i r r . li a ie p t s , 2 696, 9 h r
24 1 88 ,Tosat acai unde 42U. . .j1 83, plitf mu t lget ocsnta ee c t:()ta 9) te l m r SC 9 a anif s ale w se îl lm ns 1 h t
25 arg ts c r dby t cCo siu in orlw soft eUnie St tswa vi l td,a d ( )t a t e al ge ih e u e h n tt to a h t d a e s o ae n 2 h t h le d
26 vi l ton was com m it d by ape s n actng undercol rofst t l w . See lr-fv.At i s,487 U . .42, o ai te ro i o ae a 'cç f kn S
27 48( 988 . 1)
1
I a dii n t t e s r e i g r q ie e t u d r j 1 l A ,pu s a tt t e Prs n Lii ai n . d to o h c e n n e u r m n s n e 9 5 n ru n o h io tg to
2 Re o m Ac of 1 I LlA I a f dcalc ur mus dim isa prs ne ' cai ,t ft eale ain o fr t 995 P l , e r o t t s s i o rs l m t h lg to f i
3 povery i untue,'ori t e acton 'i f i ol usorm alci us,f ist sat a cl i on w hi h r lefm ay t s r ' fh i 's r v o io al o t c am c ci 4 be gra t d,ors eks m onct r relefagai s a def nda twho i i m une f om s ch r lef.' 28 U . . . ne e ay i nt en sm r u ei ' SC
5 j 1 l e)2) Dim is lofac m pli tf rf iu et saeacli upo whih r le c n b gr ntd i 9 5( ( . s s a o an o a lr o tt a m n c eif a e a e s 6 pr vie f ri Fe e al eo Ci i Pr c du e1 b)6 , ndt eCour a plest es m esa d r unde o d d o n d r Rul f v l o e r 2( ( ) a h t p i h a tn ad r
7 jl 1 whe rviwigtea e ua yo ac mplitora a e de c mplit W he aco rdimiss 9 5 n e e n h d q c f o an n m n d o an . n u t s sc
8 ac m pli tu de j 1 1 ( ) t epl i tf s oul begi e la et a c dt ec m pli t t die to s o an n r 9 5 e ,h a n if h d v n e v o m n h o an wih r c in
9 ast curng isdefci nci s unl ssi i cl arfom t e f ce oft e com pl i tt att edefcinci scoul oit i e e, e t s e r h a h an h h ie e d
1 notbcc r dby a e dm e t Se Cat v Unie St ts 70 l.d.l 03,11 ( t Ci.1 ) 0 ue m n n . e o . td a e , 73 1 06 9 h r 995 .
11
Re iw unde Rul l ( )6)i e s nta l a r lng on a q esi n oflw . Se Cha pe v ve r e 2 b ( s s e ily ui u to a e p l.
1 Labor t ryCo p. fzme ia, F.d71 , ( t Ci. 0) Dim is l orfiur t sa eacli 2 ao. r q j rc 232 3 9 723 9h r 200 . s sa f al c o tt am 13 i pr pcronl i i i cl art att e pl i tf cannotpr ve any setotf ct i suppor oft e cl i t at so y f t s e h h a n if o -a s n t h am h
1 woul e ttehi orhe t r le .Se M ore v Wale ,1 F.d756, 9 ( t Ci.1 9) I ma i g 4 d n il m r o e if e ly . k r 75 3 75 9 h r 99 . n k n
15 t i det r i aton,t eCour t kesast l a1 alegatonsofm at ralf cts at d i t ecom pl i t and t e h s em n i h ta nc l l i ei a t e n h an , h 16 Cour consrues t e i t e lghtm ostf vor bl t t epl i tf .See War haw vXoma Cor . 74 F. d t t hm n h i a a e o h a n if s p, 3
l 955, ( t Ci.l ) Ale ai nsofap o s c m pli a ta ehe dt Is srngc tsa da dst a 7 957 9 h r 996 . lg to r e o an n r l o e s ti n tn r h n l f nnal e di gsd afe b lwy r .Se Hu he r doyg, 9 U. . 9( 98 ) Hai e v. r e , 4 8 o pla n r td y a e s e g s . v 44 S 5, 1 0 , n s Ke n r 40 .
l U..51 52 (972)(e c ra ) W hietesa dadun c Rul 1 ()6 d esnotrquiedeald 9 S 9, 0 1 p r u im . l h tn r d r e 2b () o e r tie
20 f ct alalegatons apl i tf mus pr vi em or t a m er l bel and concl si ns.Belz tantcCbr . au l i , an if t o d e hn ea s uo lll i r
21 v T o bl,1 7S. t 1 1 4- 5( 007 .A f r uli r c ttonoft eee e t ofac us ofa ton , w m y 2 C . 955, 96 6 2 ) o m ac e iai h lm n s a e ci 2 i i s fi int . .s ePa a a v Alai , U. . 5,28 ( 98 ) 2 s n u fce . f , e p s n . l n 478 S 26 6 1 6 . #
23 A l or pa to a c m pl i tt l d by a prs ne m a t e ef r be dim i s d s a s o t i t e l r f o an i e io r y h r o e s se u p n e f h 2 prs ne ' c a m sl c a a g a l ba i e t e i l w ori f c . Thi i c u esc a m sbas d o I ga 4 i o r s l i a k n r u b e s s ih r n a n at s n l d li e ne l
25 c ncusonst a a euntn bl ( ..cai sa ai s de e da t wh a ei m unefom s i orcam sof o l î h t r e a e eg , l m g n t fn n s o r m r u t li
26 ifige e t alg lntrs whihce rydoe n te it, swela camsba e c fncflfctal nrn m n of e a i ect c la l s o xs) a l s li s d , a iu a u n
27 2
l al g ton ( . . f n a tc o dcuso als c a i s . Se Netk v Wilams,490 U. .31 ,3 7- 8 le a i s eg, a t si r l in c n ro ) e i e . li z S 9 22 2 ( 98 ) s ealoM c e v rv Blc ,9 2F.d 7 5,7 8( t Ci.1 1 . 1 9 , e s K e e . o k 3 2 9 9 9 h r 99 ) .
3 I1 . 4 Scr eni g oft e C om pl i t en h an Pl i tf ls s t e f low i g def nda t i t e ca ton of t e com pl i t t e Publc Def nder a n if it h o l n e ns n h pi h an :h i e
5 Ofice,M aya Spar s and Dewayne Nobl s. How c er Pl i tf nam es M aya Spar s and Dew ayne t k, e v , a n if k
6 Nobl si t e def ndant s ci n oft e compl i ti t ei i di i ualand ofi i lcapacii s. Pl i tf e nh e s e to h an n h r n v d fc a te a n if
7 cl i st att edef ndant vi l t d hi rght unde t eFi s,Fourh, fh,Si t , ght ,a d Foureent am h h e s o ae s i s r h rt t Fit x h Ei h n th 8 Am endm ent .Pl i tf alegest att epolci s pr ctces, ocedur s and cust m sofCl r Count and s a n if l hh i e , a i pr e, o ak y
9 t eSt t ofNe a aa ebengus dasame nso ( )c e cngi di e t rm i al fnda t i t pla ig h ae vd r i e a f 1 o r i n g n c i n de e n s n o e d n
1 g it , 2)de yi g i d g ntc i i al f nda t af i he rngtil a d ( )de yng i di e tcrm i a 0 u ly ( n n n i e rm n de e n s ar a i a ra, n 3 n i n g n i n l /
11 dcf ndant efectve as it nce of couns l Pl i tf s eks compensat r and punii e dam agesand e sfi s sa e . an if e oy tv l2 decl r t r r lef a ao y ei . 1 3 l4 Secton l pr vi es: i 983 o d Evc y pe s n w ho,unde col rofany sat t ,or i ance,r gul ton,c som ,orusage, r ro ro t - e dn u e ai u t
1 5 l 6
1 7
o a yStt orTertl orteDititofColmbi s b e t, c us st bes be td, f n ae rio' h src y u a u j cs or a e o u jce a y cii e oft e Unied S ae oro he pe s n wlhi t ej rs iton t ce ft t e n tz n h t t ts t r ro t n h u id ci h r o o h
deprvaton ofa yr ght , i ieges, i m unii ss cur d byt eConstt ton and l w s, ii n i s prv l or m te e e h iu i a
pr ceedi g f rr dres .... o noe s
s albe la l t t epa t ij r d i a a ton atlw ,s i i e uiy orot e p ope h l ib e o h ry n u e n n c i a u t n q t, h r r r
1 4 U. . .j 1 83. 8 2 SC 9
19 W hen publcdef nder ar actng i t ei r l asadvocat ,t eyarenotactng unde col rofs at i e s e i n h roe eh i ro tc
20 Iw f rj 1 83pur os s Se Ge r i v M c olu ,505U. .4 , ( 99 ) Pol Co nt n Dods l, ao 9 p e . e o g a . c lm S 2 53 1 2 , k u y . ot 21 45 U. 31 320- 5( 98l ; k onv Br wn, 1 F.d 1 5 , 079( t Ci. ) M iandav Clr 4 S. 2, 2 1 )Jac s . o 5 3 3 0 7 1 9 h r 2008 , r . . ak 22 Count,Ne . 3l F.d 465, ( t Ci.2 03)( n b nc ;Un td St ts v DeGr s ,96 F.d 1 , y v, 9 3 468 9 h r 0 e a l ie a e . o s 0 2 433 23 1 n.2( t Ci.1 2)(nba c ; e as Kite v Rai e , F. d 1 88,1 - 4( t Ci. 3) 442 1 9 h r 99 e n l s e lo rly z n y 326 3 0 093 9 9 h r 200 . 24 ( ii gPol C'lr/zodee m i et a asaea poit dguadina lt m do sno ac unde c lrofsat ctn k tf/ t tr n h t tt p n e r a d ic e t t r o o t e py 25 1w f rpur o e ofj 1 ) Co v Hele sen,685F.d 1 98,1 99 ( t Ci.1 82)(eyi gonPol a o p ss 983 , x . lr ti . 2 0 0 9h r 9 rl n k
26 Count t d t r i et at e e al blcde e d r a enot c i g u de c l roff de a l w f rp r os s y o e e m n h f d r pu i f n e s r a tn n r o o e rla o u p e
27 3
1 ofBie sa ton) The Supr m eCo r ha c ncud d t a p blcde e d r d nota tunde c l ro v n ci . e u t s o l e h t u i fn es o c r oo f
2 st t l w becaus t ei conductasl galadvocat si contoled by pr f ssonals andar si depe dent ae a eh r e es rl oe i t dn n 3 oft e adm i it atve di e ton ofa s per i or Se Pol Ctln/' 454 U . .at321;s e al o Bl m v. h n sr i rc i u v s . e k ?f y, S esu
4 Ya es y, 7U. . 91 1 08 09( 98 )( ppl ig sm ia r to al t dee m i et a a m i itaor of r tk 45 S 9 , 0 - 1 2 a y n i lr ai n e o tr n h t d n sr t s 5 nuri g ho ewee n tsaea t rl M at i v Pac Ga ( Elc.Co. 8 1F.d 1 29,1 ( t Ci. sn m r o tt c o s ; hs . . s f e , 9 2 4 432 9 h r 6 1 9)( p l i g sm ia r tonaet dee ni et a e pl ye sc ndu tngps c iti e auai n we e 98 a p yn i lr a i l o tn n h t m o e o c i y h arc v l to r
7 notsat a tr) Butc Gon alsv S e c r 336F.d 8 2 8 4( t Ci.2 03)( e c ra ) t e co s. f z e .p n e, 3 3 , 3 9h r 0 p r uim 8 ( x li i g t a a p i ac atr e wh i r ti c t r pr s ntsa e c ttcsa d t ere pl y e i e p an n h t rv t to n y o s ea n d o c e e tt n ii n h i m o e s n
9 ltgaton act undercol rofs at 1 w becaus hi orherr l i 'anal goust t atofast t pr secut r ii i s o tea es oe s ' o oh ae o o
1 rte t a apublcdee de.'ciigPol Count, U.. t323n.3).Dee da t aenots be t 0 ah rh n i fn r'( tn k y 454 S a 1 ) fn ns r ujc
11 t s iunde j 1 f rt era tonsasPli tf sa v c t .Thus Pli tfm cam sa ans t e m u t o u t r 983 o h i ci an if d o a e , a n its li g i t h m s
1 be dim i sed. 2 ss
1 3
Even i pl i tf coul ari ul t cogni abl cl i s agai stt e def ndant ,t os cl i s ar f a n if d tc a e z e am nh e s h e am e
l bar ed becaus t ey i plcat t e l galt ofhi cust dy. W hen a prsonerchalengest e l galt or 4 r e h m i e h e iy s o i l h e iy l dur ton ofhi cusody,orr iesaconsiutonalchalengewhi h c ul enttehi t an eari rr l as , 5 ai st as tt i l c o d il m o lc e e e
1 hi s l fdea rm e yi awrtofha e sc r us Prie v Ro rgue,411U. . 5(97 ) Y u g 6 s oe e rl e d s i b a o p . es r . d i z S 47 1 3 ' o n ,
1 v Ke n ,9 7 F.d 8 4 ( t Ci.1 ) c r.de id 1 S. t 1 ( 9 1. M or o e , n s e i g 7 . n y 0 2 7 9 h r 990 , e t n e 1 C . 090 1 9 ) e v r whe e k n l da a e f ra al g dl unc nsiu i n l nvito ori prs nm c t taj l pli tf mus p ove 8 m g s o n le e y o ttto a co ci n m io n ,$ 983 an if t r 1 t att econvi tonorsc t ncchasbcenr ver ed ondiectappealexpungcdby cxecutveor er decl red 9hh ci ne es r , i d, a 20 i vald by a sat t i unala t orzcd t m ake s ch dc cnni aton,orcaled i t quesi n by a f der l ni t e rb uh i o u t ni l no to ea
2l c u tsis an eofawrto h be sc r us 28U. . . 2 54. He kr Hu phr y,51 U. . 487 o r' s u c i f a a op , S C j 2 ' c . m e 2 S 477, 5 22 88( 994) i cam f rd m ag sbe rngt a r ltons i t ac nvitonors n e c t a ha not n 1 . ç li o a e a i h t eai h p o o ci A e t n e h t s bec 23 s ivai ae i n tc g i a l undc j 1 ' / .a 48 . Pli tf ha notde onsr t d t a hi o n ld td s o o n z b e r 983. # t 8 ' an if s m tae h t s 24 c nviton ha be n ivai ac ,a d a s c , scam i no c gnia l unde j 1 3. o ci s e n ld t d n s u h hi li s t o z b e r 98
25 // / 26 // /
27 4
11 1.
Concl si n uo
B ecaus t e cour fndst att e pl i tf cannotpr vc any s toff ct i s ppor ofhi cl i s eh t i h h a n if o e a sn u t s am t a w oul entte hi t r lcf and a c dm entw oul be f tl ,t e com pl i twilbe dim i s d wih ht d il m o c i , mn d u ie h an l s se t
prj die. cu c
B as d on t e f r goi g,a d wih good ca se appea i g, e h oe n n t u rn
I I HEREBY ORDERED t a t i a to i DI M I SED wih pr j die f rf iur t TS h t h s c in s S S t eu c o al e o
s at a cl i upon whi h relefcan begrant d. t e am c i e
I IS FURTH E R O R D E R ED t at t e Cl r of t e Cour s al C LO SE TH IS CASE and T hh ek h th l
EN T E R JU D G M E N T AC C O R D I G L Y . N
o .oli .), dyfpi21. Ar :'s ;.- aoAr,00 E h ëJ $ î? - l
U NI ED ST f ' DI TRI T J D GE T 'S S C U
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
