Proctor et al v. Applegate et al, No. 2:2007cv12414 - Document 202 (E.D. Mich. 2009)

Court Description: OPINION and ORDER granting in part and denying in part 132 Motion to Dismiss; granting in part and denying in part 147 Motion to Dismiss; granting in part and denying in part 165 Motion to Dismiss; adopting 193 Report and Recommendation and ORDERING SEVERANCE OF CERTAIN CLAIMS AND PERMITTING CERTAIN PLAINTIFFS TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINTS. Signed by District Judge Paul D Borman. (Attachments: # 1 Document Continuation) (DGoo)

Download PDF

Defendants' Motions to Dismiss_ GRANTED as to Following Complaint Paragraphs Defendant Complaint Paragraph(s) Andison 200,238,254,257,262,295 Armstrong 153, 155, 157, 166, 170, 171, 174, 176,193,203,210,235,238,239, 244,247,249,254,257,260,262, 264,265,266,268,269,270,274, 276,277,278,279,280,281,282, 284,285,286,287,289,291,292, 293,294,295,297,298,299,300, 301,302,303,306,307,308,309, 311,312,319,324,328,329, and 331 Bell 172,215,280 Caruso 179,186,205,223,224,305 Doering 244 Eaton 244,249,254,280,294,295,297, 298, and 299 Etelamaki (listed as Dostaler) 300,302,307,235, and 328 Defendants' Motions to Dismiss GRANTED AS TO Following Complaint Paragraphs Defendant Complaint Paragraph(s) Evers 262 and 293 Ezrow 319,321 Farley 175 Faulkenstein 250, 255, and 297 Gray 242 Hill 301,303, 304, and 331 Hofbauer 155, 16~ 166, 170, 171, 174, 17~ 181,182,185,192, 193, 19~203, 217,218,220,222,228, and 234 Horton 301,303, and 331 Hosely 209,210 (in part) Ingram 247 Jondreau 264,265,266,268,269,270,272, 274,275,276,277,279, and 300 Kotila 301,303 Krauss 242 Lalonde 302,315 LaPlante 319,324, and 329 Luoma 219,221,264,265,266,268,269, 270,274,276,277,278,279,281, 282,284,285,286,287,302,307, 319,324,328,329, and 330 Marschke 169 McKee 210 (in part) Mohrman 165, 167, 168, 190,227,229, and 232 2 Defendants' Motions to Dismiss GRANTED a~ to Following Complaint Paragraphs Defendant Complaint Paragraph(s) Monahan 243,244,292 Mullen 170,181,185,196,198,235 Napal 206 Niedenneyer 256,257 Niemisto 176,193,184,189,202,222 Pass 187,204,244,249,254,260,291, 294,295,297, and 298 Perry 209,210 (in part) Perttu 265,266,268 Pittsley 269,285,286,321 Pokely 203 Schooley 163 Smith 281,282,285,286,287,300,307,323 Sweeney 269,270,272,275,279,285,286 Travino 215 Watson 173,238,244,247,249,254,257, 260,262,291,292,293,294,295, 297, 298, and 299 Webb 172 and 173 Weisinger 176,220 Williams 241,247,262 York 158, 165, 168, 174, 182, 188,203, 232,235 3 Defendants' Motions to Dismiss DENIED as to Following Complaint Paragraphs Plaintiff Defendant Paragraph(s) in Complaint Proctor Applegate (ARF) 214,216 Petersen Applegate (ARF) 257 Chandler Applegate (ARF) 295,299 Petersen Bell (ARF) 258,261 Petersen Beny(ARF) 238,240,245,246,247 Petersen Burtovoy (ARF) 254 Chandler Butzin (AMF) 323,324 Peterson Caldwell (ARP) 252 Petersen Eaton (ARF) 239 Petersen Evers (ARF) 247 Petersen Ezrow(AMF) 265 Chandler Ezrow(AMF) 326 Proctor Farley (LRF) 166 Petersen Gibbs (ARF) 247 Chandler Gibbs (ARF) 292 Petersen Gray (ARF) 239,240 Petersen Hemry (ARF) 253,254 Chandler Hemry (ARF) 295,299 Proctor Hosely (IBC) 210 (as it relates to retaliatory transfer only) Petersen Jondreau (AMF) 263 1 Defendants' Motions to Dismiss DENIED as to Following Complaint Paragraphs Plaintiff Defendant Paragraph(s) in Complaint Petersen Kiser (ARP) 262 Petersen Krauss(ARP) 238,239,240,246 Chandler Krauss (ARF) 293 Chandler Lalonde (AMF) 300 Proctor McKee (IBC) 210 (as it relates to retaliatory transfer only) Proctor Mohrman (MDOC Lansing) 156 Petersen Monahan (ARF) 239 Chandler Nannberg (AMF) 301 Petersen Niedermeyer (ARP) 258,261 Chandler Olin (ARP) 295 Petersen Pass (ARF) 239 Proctor Perry (IBC) 210 (as it relates to the retaliatory transfer claim only) Chandler Petaja (AMF) 302 Petersen Pfeiffer-Lenart (ARP) 248,250 Petersen Pittsley (ANIF) 266,267 Petersen Sands (ARP) 249 Chandler Sands (ARP) 294,295 .Proctor Schooley (MDOC Lansing) 207 Petersen Smetka (ARF) 256,259 2 Defendants' Motions to Dismiss DENIED as to Following Complaint Paragraphs Plaintiff Defendant Paragraph(s) in Complaint Proctor Stapleton (MDOC Lansing) 165, 167, 168, 190 Petersen Stapleton (MDOC Lansing) 255 Chandler Weise (AMF) 310,314,318,320,322,331, 333 Proctor Weisinger (MBP) 190-191 Petersen Williams (ARF) 240,243,245,246,260 Chandler Williams (ARF) 291,298 Petersen Wilson (ARF) 238 Proctor York (Gormley) (MBP) 166 Hurd York (Gormley) (MBP) 217-218 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.