Bennett et al v. Hayes Robertson Group, Inc. et al, No. 4:2011cv10105 - Document 78 (S.D. Fla. 2012)
Court Description: ORDER Denying Rule 23 60 Certification with respect to Count I, Granting Conditional, Section 216(B)Certification as to Count II Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 7/20/2012. (jw)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Bennett et al v. Hayes Robertson Group, Inc. et al Doc. 78 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA KEY W EST DI SI VI ON CASE N0.11 01 - V- NG -1 05 CI K1 J ESSE BENNETT,e . . t a1, Pli if , antf s VS. HAYES ROBERTSON GROUP, 1 C- e . . N' , t al, De e nt . f nda s / O RDER DENYI RULE 23 CERTI CATI W I RESPECT TO CO UNT 1 NG FI ON TH . NAL.SECTI N 21 )CERTI CATI AS TO COUNT 11 O 6* FI ON GM NTI CONDI O NG TI - - - - THI CAUSE comesbe o et Cour upon Pli tf s M o i f De l r ton o aCl s S f r he t a n if ' ton or c a a i f as Acin (h ç oin' ( # 0 ,fld J e 1 ,2 2 Th r i Plitfs s e t c riy a to t e s to ' DE 6 ) i un 5 01 . een, an if e k o e t M ) e f t y rd'ca sa to , n o a sn aRu e2 ( )3 rp e e tt ca st p o e ueCo n 1fr i bi ' ls ci n e c mp s ig l 3 b ( ) e r s nai ls o r s c t u t o h ve Flrd mii m wa ev oain a da29U. C.j21 ( )o ti ca st p o e ueCo n 1 f r o ia n mu g i lto s n S. 6 b p -n ls o r s c t u t 1 o f i r t p y o e t u e t eFarLa orSa ad Ac ( A' , U. C.j2 , t s q al e o a v ri nd r h i b tnd r s t d u me TLS ' 29 S. ) 01 e. e . Dee d nso p s ca ste t n o a y o Pli tfs cams S eRe po e ( # 5 .Upo f n a t p o e ls r ame t f n f anif' li . e s ns DE 7 ) n c r ulc i r to of t a gument s t f t i t pl di a t pa tes e de i r a ef onsde ai n he r s e orh n he ea ngs nd he ri ' vi nta y s m iso t Cour fnds t Pl ntf shav f ld t m e tt r quie e sofRul 23 f ub s in, he ti hat ai if e aie o e he e r m nt e or casc riiai a t Count1 buthaves ife t mor lni rquie nt of29U. C.j ls e tfc ton s o , ats d he e e ent e rme s S. 21 ( )f rc n iin l c le tv a to c riiain a t Co n 1. 6 b o o dto a, olcie ci n e t c t s o u t I f o BA C K G R O UN D Thi i a a ton by t nt onecu r nta f me e oye offve Ke W es,Fl i s s n ci we yr e nd or r mpl es i y t orda r t a s whi h Pl i if al ge ope a e t esaur nt, c antfs le r t mder t c he ommon owne s p a c r of t e r hi nd ontol hr e Dockets.Justia.com c por t a t i vi lDe e nte pl r .1Pli if a lge t t Def nda s f ie t or a e nd wo ndi dua f nda m oye s a ntfs le ha e nt a ld o pa Pli if a o he sm ia l st t e o st r quied mi mum wa fom J 1 y antf s nd t r i l ry- iuaed mpl yee he e r ni ges r une 5, 2007t oug M ar h 11 2011a t r quied ove tme wa sfom J me l 2009 t ough M ay hr h c , nd he e r ri ge r t 5, hr 30,201 Se M oton,a 6, 1 Spe ii a l Pl i if a lge t tt Com or t De e 1. e i t 6. c fc ly, antfs le ha he a e f ndant, s un e te die to a d o eain l c nr l o te I dvd a Dee d n s ( ) manan d a d r h rcin n p rto a o to f h n iiu l f n a t; 1 itie d fe polc 'ofde tng $3. pe s h fom tppe e oye ,whih ha t efec of û i d iy' uni duci 00 r hi r i d mpl es c d he f t rd cn e l y e ' g sb l w t erq ie nso mi mu wa e ( )a wi f l f i dt e u i g mp o e s wa e eo h e u rme t f ni m g , 2 nd l ul al o l y e pa e pl est c r c o any ove tmewag . d. t1 1 1 9. y m oye he or e t r ri es I a G-1 , 8-1 Th iiil Co li ( #1 wa fld o De e e 3 , 2 1 b f u f r r e nta mpant DE ) s ie n c mb r 0 01 y o r o me e o s of one or m o e of t De enda s r tur nt s ki t r c r un d mi m u mpl yee r he f nt ' esa a s ee ng o e ove pai ni m wa es The Compli thmssnc bee n e d t e tm e t a s ve e n a tonalPl ntfs g . an i e n m nde hr e i s o dd e nt e ddii ai if , wh aealg dt h vep ro me t esmeo s b tnil smi r o sa sre s b re d r, n o r l e o a efr d h a r u sa tal i l j b s ev r , a tn es a d e y a h ses s a wel sa a dto a cam fro e t wa evilto st u t1) a dc ranca s o tse , s la n d iin l li o v ri me g oain co n 1, n e ti ls a to alg to . eF u t Ame e Co an (F ' ( #3 ) fld M ac 2 , 01 i cin l ains Th o rh nd d mplit ç AC' DE 5 , ie rh 3 2 2, s e ç ) now t ope a i pl a ng. he r tve e di De e nt ge r ly deny t e ie y oft FAC a a fr tvel de end on t bass f nda s ne al he ntr t he nd fima i y f he i t a Dee a t a e n ta çon e o r'u e t e saue,Plitfs a e n t G i lry h t fnd n s r o j it mplye' nd r h ttt an if r o t mial s st t 't e c o he or a ot r pe s f r pu pos s of t FLSA, c iuaed' o a h t r ny he r on o r e he nnno s ts y t t a if he r quie e s f a c l ci aci unde t FLSA,a we e pa d alc pe a i t whi h e r m nt or ole tve ton r he nd r i l om ns ton o c 'P an if'ç ite ly r'alg to s a e sae i p r g a h 8 5 o t Fo rh litfs jon mpo e ' le ain r ttd n aa r p s -1 f he u t Ame d Compl i . The de enda c por tons Ha nde ant f nt or a i , yes Robe ton Gr rs oup, I , Re ih nc. dfs Bl fs l , a d 37 Cour l sme s I , a e r e r d t her i as t çco por t ueih, nc. n t nve t nt , nc. r ef re o en he ç r ae De e f ndan s' The i vi l de e nt,Ca e W i fe De e and J e H. W a s ar t .' ndi dua f nda s r n nnir d m nt os ph lh, e r e r d t her i ast tl vi ef re o en he tndi dualDef nt s who,t t wih t Com or t De e enda s' ' ogeher t he ae f ndant, s ar c lc i l r f red t asG ef nt.' e ole tve y e e r o r enda s' 2 t y wer e tted unde t FLSA or Fl rda St t e Se Ans r a Afima i De e e he e n il r he oi aut s. e we nd fr tve f ns s ( # 9. DE 3 ) Beo et e Co tn w i P an if'Mo in f rDe lrto o a Cls Aci n ( # 0 , f r h ur o s litfs to o caai n f a s to DE 6 ) fld i a c r a c wi t e Co r' S h d l Or e ( #5 ) wh c sta J y 1 ,2 2 ie n c o d n e t h u ts c e ui h ng d r DE 6 , ih e ul 6 01 cole tve a ton ce tt a i de dlne.De enda s o lc i c i rik ton a i f nt ppos cas c rii ton t r et r Rul e l s e tfcai mde ihe e 23 o FLSA a t kei s wih t f r notc a tc d t Pl i if 'M oton atExhi t 8 and r nd a s ue t he o m ies ta he o antfs i bis 9. eRes e, t1 9. Se pons a 2-1 Fort r s s tf t f l bel t Cour fndsi mus dt Pl i if 'M oton a t he ea ons e orh uly ow, he t i t t ny antf s i so CountI whih f is t m e t t r quie e s f Rul 23 ce tt ai a gr n Pl i if ' s c a l o e he e r m nt or e rik ton, nd a t antfs M o i a t Cot 1 f co tona coleci a ton c tfc ton i pa t ton s o mt 1 or ndii l l tve c i erii ai n r. AN A LY SI S Pl i tf s m o t s Co t unde t b e .Fis ,Pl i if s e cl s ce tfc ton unde a n if ve hi ur r wo as s r t a ntf s e k as rii a i r Fe r Rul o Ci lPrce ur 23a a d ( ( frvi ainsofFl i M i mum Wa Se nd, deal e f vi o d e () n b)3) o olto orda ni ge. co Plitfss e cls c riiain unde 29 U. C.j 21 b fr vi ai un rt Far La r anif e k as e tfc to r S. 6() o oltons de he i bo Stnda dsAc. a r t Hy rd ca sa to s isu de Ru e2 (o saelw mi i m wa e )a d 2 U. C. b i ls ci n ut n r l 3 f r tt a nmu g s n 9 S. j 21 ( )(o o e t )ma p o e dwih u c nlc. e ge e al Ad io y Co te ' No e 6 b fr v ri me y r c e t o t o fit S e n r l v s r mmite s t s y t Fe ea Rue23b ()(Th p e e tp o iin o 2 U. C.j 21 ( )aeno itn e t b o d r l l ( )3 $ e r sn r v so s f 9 S. $ 6b r t ne d d o e afce by Rul 23,asa nde ' .Se alo,e. ,Prck t v.De b Couny,3 F. 1 4, fe td e me d.) e s g. i et ' Kal t 49 3d 29 1 9 ( 1h Ci. 0 )(itn u s i o ti p o e u eun e FLS a Rue 2 ) S anln v 2 7 1 t r 2 03 d sig ihng p -n r c d r d r A nd l 3 ; c t d . a Jf y Kngh,I .No 8:9 eh i t nc, . 0 -CV-1 5 T-1 TBM ,2 0 W L 41 7 3 a * ( . Fl.S p . 98 - 7 01 1 68 , t 4 M D. a e t 29 2 0 (e o nzn G y rd ca s a to ' (iig fid a v Go e nme Emplye s , 01 ) r c g iig l b i ls cins' ctn n s y . v r nt h ) o e I s r n eCo,4 8 F.d 41 ( C. r 2 0 :; vn v OS Re tu a Se vc s I c,6 2 F.d n u a c . 4 3 6 D. Ci. 0 6 Er i . sa r nt r ie , n . 3 3 9 ,9 7 (t Ci.201 ) (i dn ta t ee i ç mpe e ie c t t a c mbn d a to i 71 7 7h r 1 fn ig h t h r s f l vd n e ha o ie cin s a 3 c n itn wi t er gmeCo r s ha etbl h d i teFLSA.) Ass c t li s b e tt o sse t t h e i h nge s s sa i e n h s ' . u h,t ams u j c o ' c c riiain u d rj 21 ( ma a p o raeyb brug ti te smelws i a cam ss b e t etfc to n e 6b) y p r p it l e o h n h n a ut s li u j c t c rik ai unde Rul 23 whe e ...,t e s n i f c sa is r r ng ea h s tof o e tf ton r e r, he s e tal a t nd s ues ega di c e oc edi r i l o e r ul cli s a e lkel t be t s me and pr e ngs a e not lkey t be r nde ed und y am r i y o he a b r e o b i cu in o b t st o cams' Jme e - o c v Ba e Ro hn Co,No. u d ns me y n lso f oh es f li . i n zor z o . k r o g . ' 50 - 3 FL, 0 7W L 4 6 9 2 a * ( D. C. c 2 , 0 )( e t yn h b i a to ) :5 CV-4- 2 0 5 8 7 , t 6 E. N. De . 1 2 07 c ri ig y rd cin . f 1 Rul 23 Ce ii aton:Fl i M i mum W aeeCl i sf . e rtfc i orda ni a m count1 ) W ih r s c t Co mt1 Pl ntfss e t ce tf a sngl c a sunderRul 23 t ltgae t e pe t o t , ai if e k o riy i e l s e o ii t D ' lege vi ai of Se ton 448. 1 of t Fl i St t t sz The Cour ha l d olton ci 10 he orda a u e . t s ee f ndan s a t consde e Pl ntfs M oton,he p o e cas de i ton, heFourh Am e d Com pl nt and i r d ai if ' i t r pos d l s fnii t t nde ai , e de e c r nty i t r or a fndst tt c e i noti a posur t beti d a acl s vi nc ure l n he ec d, nd i ha he as s n teo re s a s aci Spe t al t cls de to slc ofpr cii t l c oft c iy oft pr e ton. cik ly, he a s fnii n' a k e son, he a k ypi alt he opos d cas r pr e ai s a t i vi lz is s a p oof r ar ng e h empl l s e es nt tve , nd he ndi dua ied s ue nd r eg di ac oyee' s kno edge oft çi c e t'polcy,asw ela t valdiy of ç i pool' alm iia e a ns wl he t p r di' i t l s he i t çp t , 1 ltt gai t ' a j iai t scli i aca sa ton. or ngl t Cour fndst timus de Pl ntfs dudc tng hi am n ls ci Acc di y,he t i ha t t ny ai if' M oto a t Cot 1 i n s o mt . A. Le St ndar f Rul 23 Ce t c i gal a d or e r m aton To be en ild t cas ce tfc ton t r Fede a Rul ofCi lPr e e 23,t pa t tte o l s rii a i mde rl e vi oc dur he ry s e ng c rii ton mus ha sa ng,a mus m e t e c oft r quiemen s s cii d i e ki e tfcai t ve t ndi nd t e ah he e r t pe fe n Rue2 () a wela a la to es b e to o Ru e2 ( ) Se Kly v Hu a I c, 2 F.d l 3 a , s l s t e s n u s cin f l 3 b . e a . man , n .38 3 1 41 1 0 ( 1h Ci. 0 4 .I a dto ,$a p an ifs e i g c rikai n o acam frca s 2 , 25 1 t r 2 0 ) n d i n t() litf e k n e t to f li o ls i f 2Seci 448. 1 oft Fl i St t e pr de i r l va pa t ha ç m pl r s l ton 1 0 he orda aut s ovi s n e e nt r t t t oye s ha l e pa e pl esam i m um wa a a ho l r t of$6. 5 f a lhotr wor i Fl i ,' y m oye ni ge t n ury ae 1 or l ls ked n orda'and aloi om o at spr so ofSe tons21 a 21 oft f r FLSA ,a i e r t by s nc r e ovi in ci 3 nd 4 he ede al s nt m eed a ia ef der lr a i a i plm e e by t De rmen ofLa . pplc bl e a egultons nd m e nt d he pa t t bor te t e mus pr e an a qua e y dei cas t ts tsi st r r m e sof Rul 23. r am nt t opos de t l tned l s ha aite he equie nt e ' ' Kee s n v Ch vo ,USA.I c, 6 F. D. 6 , 6 ( D. a 2 0 ) Th c u t t n ur, lc e y . e r n . , n .2 2 R. 6 0 6 7 S. Fl. 0 9 . e o r mus e s e t ough t i ousa yss't te c a e r e e ntofRul 23 i esa ihe a t tm e of hr ç gor r nal i, ha a h nd ve y l me ' e s t bls d t he i ce tfc ton.Se Advio y Commite' N o e t Fe R.Ci P.23.I i we ls tld t t a rii a i e sr te s t o d. v. t s l- ete ha pl i ifbe r t bur t me e r e e ntofRul 23.Ve v T- obie USA,I . 56 antf a s he den o et ve y l me e ga . M l nc , 4 F.d 1 5 ,1 6 ( 1h Ci. 0 9 .I a dto ftma b n c s ayf rt c u t op o b hid 3 2 6 2 7 1 t r 2 0 ) n d i n,ç y e e e s r o he o r t r be e n i i t epe dng b fr c migt r s o tec ri ainq e to . Ge .T lCo o w.v Fac n h la i s eo e o n o et n h e t to u sin' n e. . fs . lo , fc ' 4 7 U. 1 7 1 0 ( 9 2 .Sp cfc l $ c u tma c n ie t e s bsa tv ee n so t e 5 S. 4 , 6 1 8 ) e iial 1 o r y o sd r h u tn ie lme t f h y, a pl ntf s c e i o de t e son t f m t t a til on t e is s woul t ke. Se ai if ' as n r r o nvii he or ha ra hos s ue d a ' e ' g n r l Ne o v M e rl L n h Pir e Fe n r d7 mi ,I . 25 F.d 1 4,1 6 ( d Ci. e ea l wt n . r i y c , ec , n e S t nc, 9 3 5 6 3 r y l h 20 1 ( u tn 5M o r ' Fe rlP atc j2 4 4 :. 0 ) q oig o es dea r cie 3.6(1 B. Cl sDe i ton as fnii Be or c i rng t r quie e s of Rul 23,t Cour mus de e m i whe he a f e onsde i he e r m nt e he t t t r ne t r ca se it ta c n a e uaey b d fn d. ige v AT &T Cop. 1 F. D.6 ,68 ( D. ls x ss h t a d q tl e ei e Sn r . r , 85 R. 81 5 S. Fl .1 9 ) (ii De e e k r v S o t 4 3 F.d 73 ,7 4 ( t Ci.9 0 ) d h l t e a 9 8 ctng Br ma c e . h r, 3 2 3 3 5h r1 7 ). ç ie h W de i ton oft c a smus notbeva ordifc tt a y,t i i i de i ton r r m e fnii he l s t gue fi ul o ppl he mplct fnii equie nt doe notr uie a o ry src de e ofc rant a i t belbe al a id. f Pl i if ' s eq r n ve l tit gr e e ti y nd s o i r ly pple ' #. antfs ' pr e c a sco it of opos d l s nsss : A 1 houry pa d e o e oft Def n nt ,who w e e e pl e by De e nt f o J ne l l - i mpl ye s he e da s r m oy d f nda s r m u 1 ,2007 t oug M a c 11 2011 a who t De e nt pumore t pa wa st oug 5 hr h r h , , nd he f nda s td o y ge hr h t us ofaS i c e t' b pa ng a r uc d wa a tki atp c e tof$3. pe hour he e s p r di ' y yi t ed e ge nd a ng i r di 02 r , a whos wa s we e r du ed b t e c tofunio ms a $ 00- -hi de ton;who nd e ge r e c y h os f r , 3. pers h duci we e r quie t s r tps w ih e pl ye s w ho di no wor i t p es nc of c t e s r e r d o ha e i t m o e d t k n he r e e usom r a who we epai ar t o $ 1 pe hou a rJ y 24,2009,wh n t Fe r lmi mum nd r d ae f 4. 9 r r ûe ul e he de a ni w a esi r a e g nc e s d. M oto a 6in, t 7. Upon consd a i oft pr e cas defnii t Cour fnds t i i va , i er ton he opos d l s i ton, he ti hat t s gue id fnt, n o eb oa . re n l,h p o o e ca sd fn to i ld s: a1 h rypad n ei ie a d v rr d Fo x mpe te r p s d ls eiii n ncu e E J1 oul - i ( empl s' but f l t ditnguih be wee tppe an non-i d empl e . Thi f c ua oyee , ' ais o si s t n i d d tppe oye s s at l lm ia i i nec s ar t e ur t pr ed c a si ma up onl oft e Pli if who s r i tton s e s y o ns e he opos l s s de y hos a ntf s ha e c omm o lt CountI ce t r on t al ga i t tDe e n s e oye a unii d polc of naiy. ne s he le ton ha f nda t mpl d fe iy de tng $3. pe s h fom ist pe e o s ie.s r r,hose s ,a ba tnder,t t duci 00 r hi r t l d mplyee , . , eves tses nd re s ha p Pl n if aleg ha t efe tofbrng ng Pli if a ot r sm iary- iuaed' wage be ow aitf s l e d he f c i i antfs' nd he s i l l st t s s l t emii m wa e Un e 2 U. C.j 2 3m) a e ly ri p r te t tk a tp ce i h n mu g . d r 9 S. 0 ( , n mp o e s e mitd o a e i r dt t wa d ismii m wa e o iain a ln a :1 tetp e e o e i if r d o te tp o r t nmu g blg to s o g s ) h ip d mply e s n o me f h i ce i p o iin ,a d 2 t e tp e e ly e rtie a1o t e tp .Po ln o t i as rdt r vso s n ) h ip d mpo e ean d 1 f h is oi g f i s lo ps pe misbl u rt l w asl a t pooldoe noti ude d r s i e nde he a ong s he s ncl s oyee who c t empl s usomarl a iy nd r g al rc ie tp , s ha ds wa h r , o k , h f, n j nt r. e U. De rme to e ulry e ev d is' uc s ih s e s c o s c e s a d a io s S e S. pat n f ' La o Fa tS e t#1 Tip d Emp o e sUn e t eFarLa o Stn ad Ac ( A) b r c h e 5: p e l y e d r h i b r a d r s t FLS . He e,Pli if f i t lmi t pr ed c a st t e tpped e oyee who we e not r antf s a l o i t he opos l s o hos i mpl s r i or nf med of t tp cr di polc a o wer not a e t r t i a1 of t r tps by vit of he i e t iy nd/ r e bl o e an 1 hei i rue pm i pai i a i i tp pool I t a Pl ntfs cl spur rst i ude e oye s who ci tng n n nvald i . nse d, ai if ' as po t o ncl mpl e we e smpl r quie t s r tps wih ç mpl es who di no wo k i t pr e e o r i y e r d o ha e i t s oye e d t r n he es nc f i . ii o ke hes ' c t e s' but m a ha s il u us o a iy a r gul ry r c ved tps' Fa lng t m a t e usom r ,' y ve t l c t m r l nd e a l e ei ditn tonspl e t bur n on t f c - rt dee mi on a i vi lze bass whe he sic i ac s he de he a tfnde o tr ne, n ndi dua i d i, t r De e nt ha va i a fr ai def es The c a s s s c ptbiiy t i vi lz f nda s ve ld fim tve ens . l s ' us e i lt o ndi duai ed afr tv d fn e as miiae a ans ca ste t n u e Ru e 2 ( )3 .S e Whi v fimaie e e s s lo tg ts g i t ls r ame t nd r l 3 b ( ) e t . e Detn Cop.6 F. D. 60 5 4 ( D. a 1 7 )(i dngd tr nai no wh t rid vd a lo a r , 6 R. 5 , 6 S. Fl. 9 5 fn i ee mi to f ehe n i iu l camsaeb re b afr tv d fn e miiae a an tp e o n nc u d rRul 2 ( )3 ) li r ar d y fimaie e e s s tg ts g is rd mia e n e e 3 b ( ). 6 Be a s ca sme e s i c n o b d fn db o j ci eciei,teCo r fn sta teca s c u e ls mb rhp a n t e e e y be tv rtra h u t i d h t h ls i notr diy a c rai e. s ea l s e t nabl Ac or ngl t Cour tnds t t t pr e cas de ton doe no me t t c di y, he ti ha he opos d l s snii s t e he r quie e sofRul 23. e r m nt e C.Rul 2 a e 3() Rue2 ()h sf u r q ie n s n meo i ,c mmo aiy tpiaiy a d a e u c o l 3 a a o r e urme t: u r st o n lt , y c l , n d q a y f y t r pr e a i The nume ost r uie e ne es iaes a de e mi ton a t S e es ntton. r iy eq r m nt c st t t r nai s o l he çhe whet r t ca si s n me o t a j id ro a1me esi i rcia e' V ga 5 4F. da 1 6 . 7 ls s o u r us h t on e f 1 mb r s mp a tc bl.' e , 6 3 t 2 6' 6 ( u tn F d R. v. 23a ( ). mmo ai rq ie t tte eb t u si n o 1w o fc q oig e . Ci P. ( )1) Co n lt e ur s ha h r e G e to s f a r a t y q c omm o t t c a s' Spe ik a l pl ntfs ha t bur n t ç n o he l s ' c t ly, ai if ve he de o t demonsr t t t t c a s tae ha he l s me e sh v s fe e t s meij r . Wa- r S o e , nc v Du e ,1 S. . 41 2 5 mb r a e u f rd he n nu y' lMa t tr s I . . k s 31 Ct25 , 5 0 ' 51( 01 )(n e lq o ai n o te ) F rh r i i is fce tf rp an if meeyt a sr a 2 1 itma u tto s mitd . u te ,t s n ufiin o litfs r l o se t srng ofc m mon quesi wiho de ti o tons t ut monsr tng how r s u i oft e quesi e de e tai e olton hes tons vi nc s c mmo ij r f ç- piaiyme s rswh t e as fiin ne u e it b t e t ecams o n n u y.#.çl c l lly t a u e eh r u fce t x s xss ewe n h li oft nn e r pr e ai s a t e oft cas a l ge. Coo rv.v.Sout r Co. 390 F. he m d e es nt tve nd hos he l s t ar ' ' pe he n , 3 6 5 71 ( 1hCi. 0 4 .4 ca srp e e tt emu t.. p s s . .h smeij r a te d 9 , 3 1 t r 2 0 ) t ls e r snai A v s . ose s . t e a nu y s h casme es'no d rt bet pc lmd rRue2 ()3 . a o- ema e r lPr dov Bu h ls mb r'i r e o y ia t e l 3 a( ) Pr d sti n x c a . s , 221F.3 1 6 ,1 7 ( 1h Ci.20 0 .La ty a e u c ofrp e e tto t n o a s st d 2 6 2 9 1 t r 0 ) sl, d q a y e r s nain ç c mp se wo e s p rt iq iis ( ) wh te a y s bsa ta c n lcs o itr s e it bewe n t e e aae n ure : 1 eh r n u tnil o fit f n ee t x s t e h rp e e ttv sa d t ca s a d ( )wh t e te rp e e ttv swi a e u tl p os c t t e e r sn ai e n he ls ; n 2 eh r h e r s naie l d q aey r e ue h l a to 'Vale Dr g Co.v Ge vaPhar ,I ,350F. 1181,118 (11hCi.2003) cin. ly u ' . ne m. nc. 3d 9 t r . i . N um erosiy t Th frtrq ie n ofRue2 ()i ta t ca smus b Eo n me o st t ond ro e is e u rme t l 3 a s h t he ls t e l u r u ha j i e f s alme es i i r cia e' F d R.Ci .P.2 ()1 .EAJn meia y r sik i n tt l mb r s mp a tc bl. e . ' v 3 a( ) I u rc l ad t s o he I c dee m i ntf cas c rii a i r t ra c ts d e m i t numbe s i ve t s i tr na or l s e tfc ton; a he our houl xn ne he r nvol d o ee f j id ro a1i i o sb eo i a tc bl. Ha tn sM u tgh v T x sAi Cop. 1 9 F. D. on e f 1 s mp s il r mprcia e' sig - ra . e a r r , 1 R. ' 4 0 4 9 ( D.Fa 1 88 . riss e i g ca sc ri to d n tne d t kn w t e S rcs 5 , 5 S. l. 9 ) Pa t e k n ls e tkai n o o e o o h t e ie e t p nlmbe ofcas m e r s butt y m us makeç ea ona eesi a e wih s ppor a t t sz l r l s mbe s' ' he t t s bl tm t s t u r t s o he i e o tep o osd ca s'Fulrv Be k rd Po ikf P. ,1 7F. D. 9 , 9( . Fl. 0 ) f h r p e ls . l . c e r la of A. 9 R. 6 7 69 M D. a 20 0 . ' e Th Elv nh Cic i h sh l ta K ge eal,ls ta t ny-n i ia e u t,mo et a e e e t rut a ed h t < ln r l e s h n we t o e s n d q ae r h n g y f ry a q t . Ch n y v Cy e gu r Co p. 21 F. D.4 4 4 0 ( D.Fl.2 0 )( u tn o t de uae' e e . b r a d r , 3 R. 8 , 9 S. a 0 3 q o ig ' Co v Am. s Io Pi Co, 8 F.d 1 4 ,1 53( 1h Ci. 98 ).M o e ve,md rKi ov x . Ca t r n pe .7 4 2 5 6 5 1 t r 1 6 ) ro r t e l . g Bo n T a s, 7 9 F.d 8 9 8 ( 1h Ci. 1 8 ) n meo i ma b s tsid whee wma r n . 8 2 5 , 78 1 t r 9 6, u r st y e aife y r pl ntf si ntf a l s 31c a smembe sç r awi geog a ca ar a.' ai if de iy t ea t l s r s om f de r phi l e ' I t pr e a ton,ove t nt i vi shaveco ef wa d s e ngt fl n he es nt c i r we y ndi dual m or r e ki o ie m i mum wag cai t ough va i n ndm e st t Compl n . ai if 'a fda t a s ni e l ms hr rous me nt o he ait Pl ntfs fi vis l o i c t t tt r a e ot r smia l st td a esi t t cl st numbe a l a tffy ndia e ha he e r he s i lry iuae nd tma e he as o r t e s it idv d l. eM oi , t8 W hl temao iyo ten me Plitfsrsd i tes me n iiuas Se ton a . i h j rt f h a d an if e ie n h n e geog a car ast De e r phi ea he f ndan s Pli if a guet tcls ac i i nonet l s f a e t , antfs r ha a s ton s he e s avor bl be a edt r i apotnta f r l an nmo cas m e r t c i t r sde i Key c us the e s e il or euct ce ng l s mbe s o ontnue o e i n W e tt s i vi aly f rf a ofbengbl c lsed. 1 De e s o ue ndi du l o e r i a k-it ' d. f ndant do nots ii a l c e t ' s pecfc ly ont s ml r iy i t rRes e. me ost n hei pons Acc di y, heCour tndst tt numer iy r quie e ofRul 23 i s tsi or ngl t tl ha he ost e r m nt e s a ifed. i. i Com m onalt and Typi alt iy c iy tf e t c lt a c monalt r quieme s a e ditnc but i e r l t a t t' ypi a iy nd om -h iy e r nt r si t nt re aed, s he S p e Co r ma ece r 'hec mmo ai a dtpiaiyrq ie nso Rue2 ()tn t u rme u t d la ;t o n ll n y c l e ur me t f l 3 a e d o r t 8 m e ge.Bot s r e a gui poss f de e mi ng whe he un r t pari ul cr um sanc r h e v s de t or t r ni t r de he tc ar ic t es mait na e of a cas a ton i e no i la whehert na e pl i ifs ca m a t n e nc l s c i s co m ca nd t he m d antf li nd he cls c ams a e s i t relt d t t t i e ess of t cls m e r wil be f il a a s li r o n e r a e ha he ntr t he a s mbe s l ary nd a e u tl p o e td i t era snc . 'Co pe ,3 0 F.d a 71 (u tng Ge .T l Co o h d q aey r tce n h i b e e' ' o r 9 3 t 3 q o i n e. . fte So t we tv Fac n 45 U. 1 7 1 7 n.3 ( 98 :,o e r ld o o h rgr u d b As v uh s . lo , 7 S. 4 , 5 1 1 2 v r ue n t e o n s y h . T s nFo d , n .5 6U. 45 , 5 ( 0 6) y o o s I c, 4 S. 4 4 7 2 0 . ç omm o lt r r t pli ift de f naiy equies he a ntf o monsr t t tt cas m e r have s f e ta e ha he l s mbe s ufer d t e sme ij l 'a d t e panipsc mmo c tn in t s b o s c a n tr t a i i h a n uy' n h litf o n one to & t e f u h au e h t t s mu ca bl of cas wi r s uton pa e l s de e ol i -whih mea t t deer naton of is tut or f liy wil c ns ha t mi i t rh ast l r s vea i s t ti c nta t t vai t ofe ch oneoft c am si one sr 'D u s,1 e ol n s ue ha s e r l o he ldiy a he l i n toke. ke 31 ' S. . t 5 (n en lq tto sa dctto o t d . Ct a 25 1 itr a uoain n iain mit ) e Typi lt dif sfom c caiy fer r omm onaiy i t ti f us on t na e cas r pr en a i s lt n ha t oc es he m d l s e es t tve' i vi lc a t rsi si c pmis t t pr e c a s Pi z v.EBSCO I du .Co. 27? ndi dua har c e itc n om on o he opos d l s . az a n s , F.d 1 41 1 4 ( 1h Ci. 0 ) Pr d - ti nv Bu h 2 F.d 1 6 ,1 6 ( 1hCi. 0 0 . 3 3 , 3 6 1 t r 2 01 ; a o s ema . s , 21 3 2 6 2 9 1 t r 2 0 ) Acc di y,t pialt r quie t t dhe c am s o def ns s of t r pr e a i pa te a e or ngl y c iy e r s ha ç l i t r e e he e es nttve ris r tpc lo te camso d f n e o te ca s' Fe R.Ci P.2 ()3 .Ty c lt i s tsid y ia f h li r ee s s f h ls . d. ' v. 3 a( ) piaiy s aife whe e t nn r he med pl i if ' cai f rs fom t s m e e nt orpa tr orpr tc and a e antfs l ms i ie r a he n ve te n aci e r bas d on t s me l alt y' ast cai soft cas .Kor r v.Car v Cruie Li s e he a eg heor ' he l m he l s nbe g nial s ne , I c, 41F.d 1 3 ,1 3 ( 1h Ci.1 8 ) c r. e id 4 0U. 1 0 ( 9 5 . n .7 2 3 2 3 7 1 t r 9 4 , e td ne , 7 S. 0 4 1 8 ) As alege t c l d, he omm on is a ie fom De e nt 'pum oredl l fe 'polc of s ues rs r f nda s t y ç i d' iy uni de tng $ 00 pe s f fom is tppe e oyee.Pl i if ,howe r f i t alege f c s or duci 3. r hit r t i d mpl antfs ve , al o l a t p e e te i e c ta s p r a fn ig ta t e alg d çi ce i'poiy ij rd a1ca s rs n v d n e h t u po t i dn h t h le e çp r dt l nu e 1 ls t ' c m e r i t s m ewa a ge r td c mbe s n he a y nd ne ae omm o a we sc nta t t vi lt oft ca m si n ns r e r l o he abiiy he li f 9 t sc s wee t p o e d t til C Du e ,1 S.Ct a 2 7 ( o dn p an if fie t hi a e r o r c e o ra . f k s 31 . t 55 h l ig litfs ald o s tsy t e c mmo ai r q ie n b c u e te S r vd l ) n c n icn p o o a aif h o n ly e urme t e a s h y ç o ie d o o vn ig r of f t p co nm i dic i i t y pay a pr mpa de s rm na or nd omoton polcyy a wihouts h pr ,i woul have i i ' nd t ' uc oof t d bee i n mpos i e t pr e a c sbl o oduc omm o a we t t que to ofwhy e c cls me be wa n ns r o he si n ah as m r s d sa o e ) P an if p e e tn rc r e i n e fre a l,h tDee a t ween t nild if v r d . litfs r sn o e o d vde c , o x mpe t a fnd ns r o e t e t t t tp c e texe i bec us t et rf ie t i or t e oy soft polc ordi o he i r di mpton a e hey ihe a ld o nf m he mpl ee he iy d n talw e l y e t r ti alt ertp .Se 2 U. C.j 20 ( .l e d,t e d p sto o lo mp o e s o ean l h i is e 9 S. 3 m) nd e h e o iin tsi n o Plit f Detn M o to r a dJ seBe n t ( # 2, 4 s p o t afn n e t y f ani s siy ng me y n e s n et DE 7 7 ) u p rs idig mo f t t Pl ntfs we e i or d a ha ai if r nf me bout t tp c e t polc i t e oyme a i tons a he i r di iy n he mpl nt pplcai nd e oyee ha mpl ndbooks t y sgne Se M on gomer De ,a 36: he i d. e t y p. t 20-25,37:-7,5 1 -1 99; 1 2: 5 8, Beme tDe ,a 77:-24,Ex.4. r t p. t 2 The r c d i alo de d ofa e de e t s e or s s voi ny vi nc hat upporsPli if alega i t tG he tp t antfs' l ton ha f i t c edi wa i i t d due t s rngt tpswih empl st two ke outi t pr e e of r t s nvalda e o ha i he i t oyee ha r d sde he es nc c so r. M oin,a 1 ;s ealo F a !20 (l gn i c n l s r fs in t a çhe çi u tmes' to t 0 e s AC, t ' al ig n o cu o y a ho h t t tp e t c e t i una ii be a e t Em pl rt c r ofPl i if ' tpsa us d t m t pay r di' s valng c us he oye ook ontol antfs s i nd e he o t ewa e o oh re o e swh c tmaiywore o tiet ep e e c o c tmes' Th h g s f te mply e o uso rl k d u sd h r s n e f uso r. t ). onl e de e t tt tp poolwasi lde by i l i ofnon-i d e pl si c aned y vi nc ha he i nvai d ncuson tppe m oyee s ont i i te afd v t o f u ( f t ny o e n me P an if, who wo k d a o e ( f sv ) n h fia is f o r o we t- n ) a d litfs re t n o e r sa an s a a l dl s r d t i tps wih one pe s Er t who, ac or ng t e t ur t , nd lege y ha e her i t r on, neso, c di he a fda t ,was She peron r ponsbl f maki da q rs ..pe f r e hi wor ou sde t fi vis ç t s es i t or ng i uii . r o m d s k t i he p e e c o c tmess a d ddn th v a y rs nsbiie i t p e e c o c t me s'Se rs n e f uso rl) n i o a e n e po i l is n he r s n e f uso r . e t ' Mo tomeyAf. 8 Lo u Af. 9; l t Af. 8 Le n r Af. 8 ( # 0, tExs 1 2 n g r f ! ; g e f ! Bemet f ! ; o a d f ! DE 6 a . , , 5, 6 .Thi,of c s , f l fr s r of esa ihi t t Pli if' cai ae c pa e of ) s oure als a ho t tbls ng ha antfs l ms r a bl 1 0 cls wi r s uton ort tt ca msorde e esoft r pr s nttve pari a e t pialoft a s de e ol i ha he li f ns he e e e a i tes r y c he cli sordef e oft cls . am ens s he a s Abs nts e ome evi nc be de e yond t c l o y al ga i oft FAC t tt e ie tp he oncus r le tons he ha he ntr i cr di polc wa unlwf ,t Cour i t bl t de e mi whet rt m i m um wa c am s e t iy s a ul he t s ma e o t r ne he he ni ge l i r ieis sc mmo t te ca s S eDu e ,1 S.Ct a 2 5 -51 St eo a v Bl eBid as sue o n o h ls . e k s 31 . t 5 0 , at fAl. . u r . Bo y Co., I c,5 3 F.2 3 9 3 3 ( t Ci.1 7 ) ( lni t fnd whet r t e was a d he her n. 7 d 0 , 2 5h r 9 8 5 deci ng o i common que ton o cons r c whe er c d de d ofe de e due t r tit d dico r a si f pia y r e or voi vi nc o esrc e s ve y t t ed src c u te e) Ac o d n l, h Cou t i d ta Panif'camsf ru p i mii m h itit o r lv l. c r i gy t e r fn s h t litfs li o n ad n mu wag pr s nume ous dicr t l ga is s a a f c t t es e ent r s ee e l s ue nd fe t he ypesofdamage a l e t t s vaiabl o he i vi lPli if ,weghi a i ta fndi ofcommonalt ort ca iy. ndi dua antfs i ng gans i ng iy ypi lt ii A de i. quac y Un e Rul 2 ()4 ,t Co r mus b stsid ta t e le r sn aie pa t s wil d r e 3 a( ) he u t t e aife h t h s p e e ttv ri l r e f il a da e uaeyp o e tteitrsso t ca s'Thi rq ie n i stsidwh n ()te ary n d q tl r tc h ne e t f he ls , s e ur me t s aife e i h ' ca srp ee ttv sha en itr ssc nlcigwiht eca s a d(i terprs n ai e a ls e r s naie v o ne et o titn t h ls ; n i) h e e e ttv s nd t eratr e swil r p ryp osc t t c s .So n v I wa 41 U. 3 3 40 ( 9 5 ;V le h i to n y lp o e l r e u e he a e s a . o , 9 S. 9 , 3 1 7 ) a ly Dr g,350 F. a 1l Ade c e ss whe e t name pl ntfs s r comm on i e ess u 3d t 89. qua y xit r he d ai if ha e ntr t wih t cas me be sa s k t s met ofr i f t m s l a t s e f t cas . t he l s m r nd ee he n ype elef or he eves s hey e k or he l s Poti r 720 F.Supp. t959. tnge , a The Cour ha s t taldoubton whehe ade cy ofr pr s nt ton i s tsi d.As t s ubsan i t r qua e e e a i s ai fe dic s pror t Cour tndsi lkey t ast c s t f dst r wilbe i r - l s c lc s s us ed i , he t s t i l hat he a e m ol he e l nta c a s onfit t tpr c ud a fndi ofa qua y ofr pr e a i Forexa e t e denc s ha e l e i ng de c e es nt ton. mpl, he vi e ugge t t ss hat 5De i i oft Unie St t sCour ofAppea sf t Fit Cic tha c sons he t d a e t l or he fh r ui nded down by t cl e ofbusne son Se e be 30,1 a ebi ng aspr ce nti t Elven h Cicui. he os i s pt m r 980 r ndi e de n he e t r t Bo n rv C# o ih r , 61F.d 1 0 1 0 ( 1hCi. 98 ) ne . fprc a d 6 2 2 6, 2 7 1 t r 1 1 . 11 s ome oft i vi Pl i if m a ha s r d tps wih non-i d e pl es whie o her he ndi dual antfs y ve ha e i t tppe m oye , l t s di no . I a to t Cour i not s tsi d t t t lad Pl i if and t fnn s ki d t n ddii n, he ts a ife ha he e antfs he i ee ng a n me a cls c ppoi t nt s a s ouns lwilpr ry a a quael pr ec et sc e.W hie c e l ope l nd de t y os ut hi as l ouns li e s e ince i Fl i m i m um wag c am s t va i us a nd e s t t Compl nt xpere d n orda ni e l i , he ro me m nt o he ai , c m i i i Cour i e v i n t i ul natng n t ntr ento o mpos a de dlne f Pl ntfst m ove f cas te t nt e a i or ai if o or l s r a me , r iesdoubtt ta as ha dequa ofcas r pr e ai ha be n demonsr t d t cy l s e es nt ton s e ta e mderFe R.Ci P. d. v. 23g) ( . D.Ru e2 ( ) l 3b Be a s t eCou t sn tstsid ta alo t eee nso Rue2 ()h v b e me,t cue h r i o aife h t l f h lme t f l 3 a a e e n t i n e n ts itt a a ay i u d rRue 2 ( )3 .Asd tie a o e i dvdu l e lg la d e d o hf o n n l ss n e l 3 b ( ) eald b v , n ii ai d e a n z f cua is her pr dom i t ove c mon is s a r s uton oft c a t l s ues e e na e r om s ue , nd e ol i he ommon is s i a s ue n snge,c di t d pr e ng i nots pe i t i vi llws t.See Sacr d He tHealh i l oor na e oce di s u ror o ndi dua a uis e ar t S s, n . . ma aM ii r He tc r S r s, n .6 F. 11 9 1 7 ( 1h Ci. 1 ) y .l c v Hu n lt y al a e e v.l c, 01 3d 5 , 1 0 1 t r 20 0 . a h I . Se ton 216( :Cole tveAc i ast Ove i eCl m s( I ci b) lci ton o rtm ai CountI ) I l a ton t Rul 23 c tfc ton,Pli if s e Cour-upe vie notc t sm iaryn ddii o e erii a i antfs e k ts r s d ie o i l l stae s l r, a tn es a do h se s so tero ti rg t p ru n t 1 U. C. 21 ( ) iu td eves b re d r, n / r o tse f h i p-n ihs u s a to 9 S. j 6 b i rlto t Co n I.S e FAC a ! 5 . 9 l s p o tte e : Plitfs alg ta te n eain o u t I e t ! 7- . n u p r h ro anif le e h t h 6 f l wig camsa e c mmo t t ca s ( )Dee d nsp i a i o r c o ri rt o ol n li r o n o he ls ; 1 fn a t ad n nc re t vet ae f o me $ .8 p rh u (n t a o $ 08 p rh u )t e lye st a woke a o e r sa rn ;( ) 62 5 e o r ise d f 1 .8 e o r o mpo e h t r d t n e tu a t 2 De e nt f ie t pa a ove tme wage t e oye t two ke a t r sa ant f f nda s al d o y ny ri s o mpl es ha r d t wo e t ur s or co ne hour t t e e f t hour we kl a ( Defnda s' o ri wa mbi d s ha xce ded ory s e y; nd 3) e nt vetme ge r quieme vi a i we ewilul Fort r a onse ai d m or f ly bel t Cour gr nt e r nt oltons r lf . he e s xpl ne e ul ow, he t a s Pl ntf s M oton f coleci a ton c rii a i a t Count1 i pa t ai if ' i or l tve c i e tfc ton s o 1 n r. A. Condii tonalCole tveAc i Cer i aton St lci ton tnc i andards S cin 21 () o t e F A a t o ie o e o mo e e ly e t b ig a c le t e et o 6b f h LS uh rz s n r r mpo e s o rn o lci v a to a ns t i e oye f unpad m i m um wa s o un i ove tm e G ora on be l ci n gai t her mpl r or i ni ge r pa d ri t nd f ha f ofhi s fo t m s l s a ot rempl ssm iary st t d.'29 U. C.j 21 b) Unlkea m el r he eve nd he oyee i l l iua e ' S. 6( . i Rul 23 c a s a to i whi ea h pe s f li wihi a c ris d cl s i bound by t e l s ci n, n ch c r on a lng t n e tte as s he j d me tu ls h o s o t o t e c p tt eplitf mu ta fr tv l o tit aSe to u g n n e s e r he ps u , a h uai an if s fimaiey p n o ci n v 21 ( )ca sa to DeLe n Gr n d sv Ele a d So s T e s I c,4 7 F.d 1 4 ( 1h Ci. 6b ls cin. o - a a o . lr n n r e n . 9 3 21 1 t r 2 0 ) Th Elv nh Cic i s g et t a dsrc c u t u e a t -tg p o e s i d cd n 0 7 . e e e t rut u g ss h t itit o rs s wo sa e r c s n e ii g whehe t c ea ea opti c a sa t f c lt t notc . Hi v fi ry Nat Lf I .Co.252 t r o r t n -n l s nd o a iiae ie pp . be t ' /' ns , l e F. d 1 0 ,1 9( 1hCi. 0 ) 3 2 8 21 1 t r 2 01. The fr t sag whe e t Cour c r nty snds is l,i known a t çnotc ' or is t e, r he t ure l t ef s s he t i e' t ondii lc rii ton'sa .M or v Fami DolarSt e , I . 551F.3d 1 t c tona e tfcai ' tge gan . l y l or s nc, 233,1 .61 260- ( 1h Ci.2 08 .At t s sa e a c u t ma g a t c ndt na c riiai n i a plitf 1t r 0 ) hi tg , o r y rn o io l e t c to f i f an if d mo tae ara o a l b sst b l v ta : 1 t r ae oh re ly e o te Dee d n e nsrts e s n be a i o ei e h t ( ) hee r t e mp o e s f h fn a t e wh d sr t o ti a ()ta t e eoh re o e sae( di lry stae wi r s e tt o e ie o p -n nd 2 h t h s t e mply e r ç smi l i td' t e p c o a u h t erj b rq ie n sa d wi rg r t terp y p o ii n . Dy a hv Stt o a De to h i o e ur me t n t e ad o h i a r v so s' b c . ae fFl. p' f h ' Co r.9 2F. 1 6 ,1 6 - ( 1hCi. 9 ) rs, 4 24 5 2 5 7 68 1 t r 1 91 . To s ts y t r as bl bass t s ,a pl i if mus ha ç e t n G y c ms ' a if he e ona e i e t antf t ve l mor ha onl ot el s u s p o td a s rin ta FLSA volt ns (r )wiep e d a d t a a dto a pli tfs ' n u p re se t s h t o i ai ae d s r a n h t d iin l anif ' ' o e it Mo g n 5 F.3 a 1 61 ( u tn Ha e v Sige Co,6 6 F.2 8 4 88 ( 1h x s. r a , 51 d t 2 q oi g yn s . n r . 9 d 8 , 7 1t Ci.9 3 ) Ho v r ap an ifn e n ts w t a hsp sto i td nia't tepo i o hed r1 8 ). we e , litf e d o ho h t i o i n s t e tc l o h st n l i i ' i by a ot rputtve da sm e ra t y me tt sbm de whi h i nothea ,' by ma ng ny ht ai s mbe nd t ma e hi n, c s vy ' ki l t ie al ga i s f a ld le tons uppore by a fda t whih s c s u l e ge def ndan s a tda t t de td fi vis c uc es f ly nga e t ' fi vis o 1 3 te c n rr . Gr y o v K M a tCop. 7 F.d 1 8 ,1 9 -1 9 ( 1h Ci.1 9 )(ne n l h o tay' a s n . ' r r , 9 3 0 6 0 6 0 7 1 t r 9 6 itr a ctt n a d q o ai n o te ) I t e plitfs me t ti iiil b r e , te c u t wil iai n u tto mi d . f h anif e h s n ta u d n h o r l o t c tona l c riy a cl s a a l pli if t s nd no ie t sm iary st td po e i ondii ly e tf as nd low a ntfs o e tc o i l l iuae t ntal pli if . antfs TheEl ve h Cic tha sa e t ta f src c tsbr dic ei n a t notc sa e nt r ui s t t d ha f ti t our' oad s r to t he i e t ge di g e d cdn wheh rt c ndt nal c riy aca s i t u c nsr i d,o s mee tn , y wh n t i ig te o o io l etf ls) s h s o tane t o x e t b i y t lninc oft sanda d f t e r ie oft tdi c ei n-'M or he e e y he t r or he xe c s ha s r to ' gan,551 F.3 a 1 d t 261. W he e dic r ha not be n co plt d,t t c r ul i t t t m oton i gr nt d. r s ove y s e m e e he ypi al es t s ha he i s a e Ca r n Gr ntv Ma i He lh a e S r s,I c, 3 7 F.3 1 4 , 1 4 ( 1h Ci.2 0 ) me o - a . xm a tc r e v . n . 4 d 2 0 2 3 1t r 0 3 ( u t g Hip,2 2 F.3 a 1 6 . eas Mo g n,5 1F.3 a 1 62 (ttn t tS ea ld q oi p 5 n d t 21 ) Se lo r a 5 d t 2 saig ha ç tie d pl d ngs a a ûda t' ma s t et de onsr t r as bl basst to here oye s a e ea i nd f vis' y ufk o m ta e t ona e i ha t mpl e z t i lry stae ' a d rf sngt f od t a te (eaiey s b tn il momto d so e y t mial iu td' n eu i o t l h t h r ltv l u sa ta)a l f ic v r s h t a p e e e t frtsa ec ri to h r i r q ie ' h t r c d d he s-tg e tkain ee s e urd). t B. Ot rO ptl Pl ntfs he - n ai if Pli tfsa gue t ta r vi w oft doc ts a n if r ha e e he ke upporsafndi t to he e oyee de ie t i ng ha t r mpl s sr t o ti t ti l i ain.S cfc ly Plitfsct t t ny-nen me Plitfs( #3 ) o p -n o h s i g to pe i al, an if ie o we t o a d an if DE 5 , t j n dt r u hn meo sn n me t t t c mp an , n a a dto a t re idv d aswho oie h o g u r u me d ns o he o lit a d n d iin l h e n ii u l h v s r e p e s tn tc wiht eitn ino j i igt es i ( # ) Plitfsas s b t a e e v d r -ui o it t h ne to f o nn h ut DE 41 . an if lo u mi a fda t oft ee e oye ,whih i c e t y a e s pa a e y a r oftfy o he sm iaryfi vis hr mpl es c ndiat he r e r t l wa e l t t r i l l st ae e ly e wh we e n tp i o e t .S e M o to r Af.! 9 Go s Af.! 9 iu td mpo e s o r o ad v ri e ng me y f ; me f ; me Ber t Af.! 9 ( #60,a Exs 1 3,5) Alhough t e c numberi notprs nty known, met f DE t ., . t he xa t s ee l Pl i if f t ral t c a snumbe i ove onehund e i vi l .M oton,a 2. antfs urhe lege he l s rs r r d ndi dua s i t 1 4 Co rsi t sdsrc h v h l t a t ee itnc o j s o eo h rc - k rwh d sr s u t n hi itit a e ed h t h xse e f u t n t e o wor e o e ie t j i i i s fkin t ça se t e Plitf s c n e to b y n o e o p r s c lto ' o on n s u t e t o ç ilq h anif o tn in e o d n f u e pe u ai n. r ' Gue r v Bi Johns Conc et Pl ra . g on r e umbig,I . No.05- 4237- V,2006 W L 229051 a +4 n nc, 1 C1 2, t ( . F a M a 1 , 0 6 .ti tee o ece rf rpupo e o ac n iina c ri to a ayss SD. l. y 7 2 0 ) l s h r f r la o r s s f o dto l e tkain n l i t t t a r as bl bass e s s t bele t r a e o he e o e who desr t opti Se ha e ona e i xit o ive he e r t r mpl ye s ie o -n. e Vo d ik v Prmir Mo t. Fu d n ,I c, 5 4 F.u p.d 1 3 1 3 ( . Fl.2 0 ) n rs a . e e rg n ig n . 6 S p 2 3 0, 3 4 M D. a 0 7 ( iee n d caain e prs iga d sr t o ti hed t s tsy ti frtp on ) Belv Myn nn te e lrto s x e sn e ie o p-n l o aif h s is r g : l . t Enm' L G 22 F. D.6 0 6 3 ( D.Fl.2 0 )(fi a is o s ve plitfs idc tn tt L , 3 R. 8 , 8 S. a 0 4 a fd vt f e n anif n iai g ot r desr t opti a detii ale tonsofwa vi a i hed s fcentf condii l he s ied o n nd a lng lga i ge oltons l uf i or tona c ri ain . et to ) sc C. Si iarl siuat d Em plye s m l y- t e o e Pl ntf s a g t t ot r smia l st t cu r n a f m e e oye a e ai if r ue ha he i lry- iuaed r e t nd or r mpl es r as ra na e a i ntfa e by a r e of De e nt ' r or a a e notce of t s ce ti bl nd de ii bl eviw f nda s ec ds nd, bs nt i hi l ui,s h e oye wilf lt ln n oft i po e il rghtt r ove un i ove tme aws t uc mpl es l ai o e r her t nta i o ec r pad ri wa s Pli if s k t s nd Cour-uper i e no i et t f l ng pr e ca s: ge . antfs ee o e ts v s d tc o he olowi opos d ls ( )A1 h u l p i s r e s b re d r a d h se ss wh m wo k d fr De e d n s 1 l o ry-ad e v r, a tn es n o tse , o r e o fn a t bewe n J 15, t e une 2009 a M a 30,2011 a t ormor l a i oft De e nd y , t wo e oc tons he f ndan sa t nd t erc mbie h u se e d df ryp rwe k b tweeno p i o e t wa s ()Al h i o n d o r xc e e o t e e , u r t ad v ri me ge .2 l t e e oye who wor d ata oft Def ntr t ur t fom Jt 1 2009 a hos mpl es ke ny he enda esa an s r me 5, nd M a 30,2011 and who we e pad an ho l wa t ough t us ofa ti c e t'but y , r i ury ge hr he e t p r di' t we enotpad t co r toveri er t . r i he rec tm a e Mo in a 1 . I s p r o c n iin l e ti ai n Pli tfsct t t ec n iu u j id ro to , t 6 n u po t f o d t a c ri c to , anif ie o h o tn o s on e f o f smia l st t d s r r ,bm e r a hoses es as w el a t a fdavis of t e nn e i l ry- iua e e ve s nde s nd t s , l s he fi t hr e m d Pli if ,Go e ,M ont om e y,a Beme t who i c t t y a e a e ofa l s ffy ot r antfs m s g r nd r t, ndia e he r war t ea t i t he empl swho ar smia l st t d t Pli if .Pli if a gue t tt s e de e mee st oyee e i lry iuae o antfs antfs r ha hi vi nc t he 1 5 m i ma r quieme ofs ni l e r nt howi Pl i if hed postons t a e d i iar noti ntc ,t t ng antfs l ii hat r E m l , s de i al o he postonshed by t puttve cas m e b s'f . t1 (iigGr y o 7 . 3 1 8 ,1 9 ) ii l he a i l s m er . '# a 8 ctn a s n, 9 F. d 0 6 0 6 . De e nt c e t t de pie t s 1 t e hol , Pl n if 'pr ed c a s f l t f nda s ontnd ha , s t hi ow hr s d aitfs opos l s ais o i ntf a c de iy ompany pln orpolc t vi a e FLSA' ove tmepr sons o he t n g ne aly a iy hat olt s S ri ovii , t r ha e r l sai t tce t n a s ct Pli if occ sonaly wor d i e es off ry hour a di t tng ha rai nd pe ik antf s a i l ke n xc s o t s nd d no r c ve ove tme compe a i Se Res e a 1 De enda s f rhe c e t t t t e ei ri ns ton. e pons , t 7. f nt u t r ont nd ha he s co gr up ofe oye i Pl ntfs pr e ca s who we e al gedl pai a i or e t e nd o mpl es n ai if ' opos d ls , r le y d n nc r c ove tme r t s ul be e l d snce t r or e de s ri ae, ho d xcude i he ec d vi nce hows Def ndan s r ogni d t e t ec ze he mit a s nt a ca hirs c c t t De t t of La f i ope l computng sake nd e s e ' he k o he parmen bor or mpr ry i ov ri p y ns Se i. ctn Ex. .oM o in . et a me t. e d (iig 7 t to ) me At t no it sag c t or nmiy do not enga i c edi lt de e mi to ; he tc t e, ours di l ge n r biiy tr nai ns S e ntsbur i,f a1pr c i lpur e ,t a tmptt de o ta e t ta pl i ifha ç nda ' den s or 1 a tca def pos s o te o m nsr t ha antf s p e e td ism ce t n tfcu ly wr n ,e ie c . Re sv WF F Co#. 8 F.Su p.2 rs ne n u in, o a t al o g vd n e' ye . A ' r , 01 p d 1 5 ,1 5 ( D.Fl.2 1 (ç ke pn wi te p a tc la pr a h whc s t ce i lt 3 0 3 8 S. a 01 ) çn e ig t h r cia p o c ih hms rdbii I h y bat sa te frtsa e ln a1b tah n f lo c s s ( e ed so e y h sar a y oc u r d) tl t h is t g ,ç l u a d u f a e , wh r ic v r a le d c re , e i t i vi f t a yssi s ve f t s ond sa ofc rii ton.' (n en lf on t, he ndi dual acual nal i s a d or he ec t ge e tfcai ' itr a o t oe ) q o ain mak , n ctto so te )(mp a i i t eo i ia) Ho ve , nl i Re sa d u tto r s a d iai n mitd e h ss n h rgn l. we r u i n ye n ke ot rc esct d t r i t pa te he e ha bee pa tci tng i dic r f s ve mont . he as ie he e n, he ri s r ve n ri pa i n s ove y or e n hs The Cour wil t r f r c i r t de ii t tmony a ot r r cor e de e i t l he e o e onsde he poston esi nd he e d vi nc n c tui Pl ntfs afi vist be trde e mi wheherornott ca e i m a onsr ng ai if ' fda t o te t r ne t he s s nage bl as a a e c l c i ac i n. Se Bout r v. Cl v and Cons r, I cv N o. RD B-I1 ole tve to e hne e el t. n , -0244, 201 W L 2 738578,a * ( Md.Ma.5,201 (sonsde ai ofis srl i t t ma ea lt ofa t 4 D. r 2) s i rton sue eatng o he nag biiy c 1 6 p o o e c le tv a to i a prp it a t n tc sa e o a FLS a to ) (ne l r p s d o lcie cin s p o rae t he oie t g f A cin itma q o ainsa dctto so te ) u tto n iain mitd . W ih r s c t t fr tg oup ofe pl es i Pl i if 'pr pos d cl s t e de t e pe t o he is r m oye n antfs o e as , he vi nce de monsr t st ta fa swor d ashoury- i s r e s ba tnde s a o hose s a t or ta e ha fi nt ke l pa d e v r , re r , nd/ r t s es t wo m or l a i of t Def nda s r sa an s durng t s ci d tm e pe i , a t r e oc tons he e nt ' e tur t , i he pe fe i rod nd hei co bi d hour e ede f t hour, f whi h t y we e not pai ove tme. See, e. , m ne s xce d ory s or c he r d ri g. M o t o r Af. 9.Atti sa e t er lv n iq iy i wh te o n tPlitfsa d t e e ng mey f ! h s tg , h ee a t n u r s eh r r o an if n h s p ttv ca sme e sa eE di lry stae wih rs c t t i j b rq ie nsa dwi uaie ls mb r r t smial i td' t epe t o her o e u rme t n t u h r r t t i pa pr sons' Se Dybach,9 F.2d a 1 ega d o he r y ovii . e ' 42 t 567-68. The Cour fnds t t ti hat he e o s a sda t ,t t r wih t o he e de ta y s mpl yee ' f vis ogehe t he t r vi n ir ubmi sons c an s fc e l s i , ont i ufi i nty de a ld a l a i t de o tae a r a ona e ba i f a c lc i c am te mentof t s t ie leg tons o m nsr t e s bl ss or ole tve l i r at hi s c f g oup wih r pec t ove tm evi a i i Cot I . pe ik r t es t o ri oltons n mt 1 W ih r s c t t s ond g oup ofe oye s who we epad t ough a tp cr t t t e pe t o he ec r mpl e , r i hr i edi, he Cour fnds t t Pl ntfs ha f ie t pr de evi nce of a t fe polcy or s m e ti ha ai if ve a ld o ovi de mii d i che e o by Defnda st tvi ae FLSA.I t a Pli if s e t s e t c riy a c a sof mpl yed e nt ha ol ts nse d, antfs e m o e k o e tf l s e pl es who we e sm pl pai a a i r e toveri e r t of$6. per hour i tad of m oye r i y d t n nco r c tm ae 285 nse $1 8 p rho r S e eg.Le n r Af. 9 Asd ti da o e t er c r e ie er ltdt t e 0.8 e u . e , . , o a d f! . eal b v ,h e o d vd nc eae o h e a lge 'i c edi' polcy r ies s r l i vi lze is s t t r nde t gr le d ç p r t' i t as eve a ndi dua i d s ue ha e r he oup unma nage bl a a c lc i cas .M or over Def nda sad itd t tt y pa d t i ore a e s ole tve l s e , e nt m te ha he i he nc r ct r e a c r c e t a lge vi a i by ma lng a c k t t De rmentof La . Se at nd ore t d ht le d olton ii hec o he pa t bor e M oto a Ex.7;s e alo Letr fom J e W as ( #50- .Thi aone woul rie in, t e s te r osph lh DE 7) s l d as i vi is a t whih e pl eswe e r i ndi dual sues s o c m oye r embm s a wo d l d t pot nta i r - l s ed nd ul ea o e il nta c a s co c . Acc di l t Cour fnds t ce tfc ton f t s c niit or ng y, he ti hat rii a i or he e ond gr oup of Pl i if ' antfs pr e cas i notwa r n e opos d l s s r a t d. D. N otce i Dee a t o j c t t ef r Noies b te b Plitfs( # 0 8 b c u ei f i fnd ns b e t o h o m tc u mitd y an if DE 6 - ) e a s t al s s ae De e nt 'poston i t lws t a s potntalpl itfsa tt f nda s ii n he a ui dvie e i an if boutt rg t ha t i he i ht o ve her own a t ne a a s pot nta pl i if a tor y, nd dvie e i l antfs boutt pos i lt ofha ng t pm ii t i t he sbiiy vi o cpae n he dic r pr es a ti .SeeRe pons ,a 1 TheCour he e m odii st pr e Notc s ove y oc s nd ral s e t 9. t r by fe he opos d ie t ta k t f r us d i t c e ofBelv MyntEnt ' LLC, 2 F. D. 8 ( D. a 2 0 ) o r c ht o m e n ht as l . m t , 23 R. 6 0 S. Fl. 0 4 . Se a tche N otce e ta d i . CONCLUSI ON Afe ca e u c i r ton,and beng f ly a vie a s f t a ve a i a o da tr r f l onsdt ai i ul d s d s d orh bo nd n cc r nce wiht ûndi he ei i i he e t he ngs r n,t s r by O RDERED,DECREED,AND ADJUDG ED asf l : olows Plitfs M oin fr De lrto ofa Cls Aci n ( # 0 i DENI i an if' to o caain a s to DE 6 ) s ED n part G M N TED i par : , n t a. W ih r pec t Cot 1 of t Fourh Am e d Compli t a pur ua t t es t o mt he t nde a n , nd s nt o Fe r lRul ofCi lPr e e 23, he Cour de esPl ntfs m oto t c tf acl sa i . de a e vi oc dur t t ni ai if ' i n o eriy as cton b. W ih r pec t Count1 oft Fourh Am e d Compl i ,a puruan t 29 t es t o 1 he t nde ant nd s t o U.. j21 ( ) t eCo r g a t P an if'mo in f rCo r- r ee n tfc to t smi ry SC. 6 b , h u t rn s litfs to o u to d r d o iiai n o i l l a st t d e oye c am i unpai ove tmewag a c rii t f l ng c tona cl s: iua e mpl es l i ng d ri es nd e tfes he olowi ondii l as Al hom l pad s r e s ba tnde s a hose s ,who wor att orm or 1 y- i e v r , re r , nd t s es ked wo e l a i of t De enda s r sala t be we n Jme 1 2009 and M a 30, oc tons he f nt ' e t tr n s t e t 5, y 2011 a whos combi hou se e de f t pe wee f whih t y we e , nd e ned r xc e d ory r k, or c he r no pad ove tm ewage . t i ri s 1 8 2. W ihi 60 da oft sOr r oron orbe or Tue da . Se e be 1 201 tn ys hi de , f e s v pt m r 8. 2, Dee d nss al d n iy a dpr d c t Plitfsals c nanngt en mes, j btte s, ae fn a t h lie tf n o u e o an if it o tii h a t) o ilt) d ts ofe o e s a l s known a e s s t lphonenum be s and e m a la es es f rper o mpl ym nt, nd a t ddr s e , e e r, - i ddr s , o s ns i ntfe i t ove tm ecas sa e a de ii d n he ri l s tt d bove. Thea t he no i ofc lc i a ton a opti c e f m i a ove . The tac d tce ole tve c i nd -n ons nt or s ppr d Pli if s l m alt snotc vi r gul rU .S. a l on orbe or Oc ober 1 201 . Potnta antf s hal i hi i e a e a M i, f e t 8. 2 e il o -n,smia l st t pli if mus cons n t opti t t sltga i by Fr dav. November pti i lry iuaed a ntfs t e t o -n o hi ii ton i 1 201 6. 2. 4. Thepr e Sc dulng Or rofJ 11 2 2( # 6 ,sh rb es nt he i de une , 01 DE 5 ) i ee y CANCELLED. w dico r a m o i pr c i de i wilbeent e a trt opti Ne s ve y nd ton a tce adlnes l er d fe he - n pe i rod. DONE and ORDERED i c mbe sa t J mesLa e Ki Fe r lJ tc n hn r t he n wr nce ng de a usi e Buidi a Unied St t DititCourhous , M i , ordat s20 h da ofJ y, 2. l ng nd t aes src t e nmi Fl i hi t y ul 201 R > œ x'J . cc: Al Co elofRe r l uns co d 1 9 ES LAW REN CE KI NG I TED STATES D I STRI J CT U SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLO CT ' A UN I TED STATES DISTRI CO UR T CT FOR THE SO UTH ERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA ThsiaCoutAuho ie iean i n aS iiainko aLJwye is r- t rzdNotc d s ot olctto m r T CoutHa Ma NoFi ngast t Me iso h Caeatti Ti he r s de ndi o he rt fte s hs me I FO& , F 4#F OR WERE zlSER VERyBARTENDEAzAND/ H OSTESS OR EMPLOY BYC ED AROLI SC X FOG NE' AF ARTY'KEYWEST J K FLAT , S AC S RED FI BLUE FJ AND/ M AN GOES I KEY WEST,FLOM DA, SH R OR N 4 COLLECTIVE A CTION LA W SUITM A YAFFECT YOUR RIGH TS. . * For s ver ,ba e s and hos es eshave s t owner ofCar i sCaf Fogary' Key mer er s rtnder , t s ued he s olne' é, ts W es ,J k Fl s Red Fih Bl Fih,and M angoes,l t d i Ke W es,Fl i i f alcour i t ac at, s ue s oca e n y t orda, n eder tn K e W es,Fl i alegi t tt y wer unl uly and wiluly deprved oft roveri wages y t orda, l ng ha he e awf l lf l i hei tme , whiht yalg weeu a ul rtie byt rsa rnt'oitown r. er tua t de y c he le e r nlwfly ean d he etua sj n es Th esa rns n jito es pa da ywrng ng. c ena iJes Be et e. .v. ye Ro rs on wn rhi n n o doi The as me s se nn t tal k Ha s beton , ç Grou I et al,Cas No. 11-10105-CIV-K1 . p, nc, . . e : NG TheCour hasper it t Pl ntf st s N otce t al sm iary- iua ed cur e and f mer t m ted he ai if o end i o l i l l st t r nt or sresb re esa hotse a vii te oft irg t o it or on,hi lws toasr ev r, atnd r, nd sess d sng h m her ihto ptno, j i t s a uit set t rsmiarl rght . hei i l egal i s @ The Cour hasnotye deci whet a oft r t ant have doneanyt ng wr Ther i no t t ded her ny he esaur s hi ong. e s mo e a alben w a dn g aa te ta teewi b . we e, o h v ac oc t asry u n l v ia l o n o u rne sh t h r l e Ho v r y u a e h ie o set o r l l rght i t scas egal l s n hi e. YOUR LEGAL RI GHTS & OPTI S ON DoNohn tig DoNo hn . s Noh n (x e tr s ligfo t ep sa eo tme. t ij Loe t i g e c p eutn r m h a s g f i )By doi not ng,you r ai yourl rght t brng a s at s ta ns a ng hl et n egal i s o i epar e ui gai t ny o tea o eme to e rsa rnsfru lwfl th ligo y u f h b v - nin d etu a t o na u wi odn f o r h As t Bel uded ko ncl overi ew ages.I money orbeneft ar lt awar i t scas you w il tm f is e a er ded n hl e, l nots e i t . har n hem Com pl t O pt n Cons Form . e e -l ent By çoptng i ' you gai t pos biiy ofge tng money orbeneft t may s i n,' n he si lt ti is hat r ul fom ati ors tement butyou gi up yourrghtt se a el s es t r ral etl , ve i o par t y ue tea o eme to e rsa rnsfr h smeIg l li bo j ti t i h b v - nin d etua t o te a e a cams r u h n hs I ui and may be r r d t pm i pat i dic y and at l . aws t equie o ci e n s over ral Y ouroptonsa e i uded i t sN otce. opti you m us compl et Opt n Cons For and i r ncl n hi i To -n, t et he -l ent m for d i t t ator ysdesgnat i t N otce by Fri N ovem ber 16.201 war t o he t ne i ed n he i dav. 2. I you have any quesi orconcer ,pl e cont t f tons ns eas ac : Eddy 0 .M arban,Es q. The Law Ofi ofEddy 0.M ar Es fces ban, q 1600 Poncede Leon Boul d,Suie 902 evar t Cor Gabl ,Fl i 33134 al es orda ( )44892 305 - 92 ( 05 448 477(a 3 ) -9 f x) Emalmar na i: ba lw@gmalc m i.o OPT-I CONSENT FORM N Je s Be t,e aIv Ha sRobers Gr p, I . e.a1 s e nnet t . J. ye ton ou nc, t . Ca eNo.11 0105 s . -1 -C1V ng -ki Na me: Addr s' es . Complt and M ai t ee l o: Eddy 0.M aba Es r n, q. n eLaw Ofi esofEddy 0.M a ba Es tc r n, q 1 Po deLe Boul ar Suie902 600 nce on ev d, t Co alGa es Fl i 331 r bl , orda 34 ATTN: BENNETT FLSA COLLECTI ACTI VE ON S.S. (pinal # o to l: W or Phone: k Hom ePhone: Cel Phone l : E- i: mal CONSENT TO JOI COLLECTI ACTI N VE ON Pur uantt t Fai LaborSt s o he r andardsAd 2 U. C. 2 6 b 9 S. j 1 ( ) lco en a a e t puruemy cai arsng outofmy empl ns t nd gr e o s l ms ii oyme a as v rwair s , ba tnder a or nt s er e / te s re , nd/ hoses a Car i sCaé,Fogat sKe W es, J kFlt,Re FihBl Fih,a o Mangoe Re tur nt i t s t olne' f ry' y t ac as d s ue s nd/r s sa a s n c onneci wiht a ton t he bover f enc d lws t eer e a ui. 2. Iwo kwok di tep sto t)o r / re n h o iin s f ( nh, e r t ono a o t mo t y a) o r b u fo o o a o t rm n r b u ( nh y a) mo t, e r. 3. Durngt a i he bovetmeperod,lwor a t ormor l to a pa toft r sa a s'polc ofs i i i ked t wo e ocains s r he e tur nt iy harng empl es oye . Durngt a i he bovetmepe i lwo ke c i rod, r d ombi d hotsexc di f t hour aweek. ne tr ee ng ory s Durngt tmeperodt Iwor combi hour e edi f t hour awe , Iwa notf l i he i i hat ked ned s xce ng ory s ek s uly c pe aed. om ns t 6. 1undertndt tt slws ti br sa ha hi a ui s oughtunde t Fai La St r Actof1 , a mne d d, 9U. C. r he r bor anda ds 938 s n e 2 S. j 201e sq. h rb c n e ta rea do ti t b c meaPanifh ri a db bo ndt a yj d me tb , t e l ee y o sn, ge n p-n o e o litf een n e u o n u g n y t Cour oranys tlme oft sa ton. he t ete nt hi ci Ihe e de i t TheLa OfiesofEddy 0.M aban,1 PoncedeLeon Boul r , Suie90 Cor r by sgnae w fc r 600 evad t 2, al Ga es Fl i 331 t r r s tmef alpur esi t sa ton. bl , orda 34 o ep e en or l pos n hi ci 8 Ias d sr aetec l cieato Re ee ttv t)a mya e ts t ma ed cso so myb h l . lo ei t h ol tv cin prs naies s g nt) o k e iin n e af e c er ngt ltgai i udi t mehodandma rofc onc ni he ii ton,ncl ng he t nne onduc i t sltga i , e e i i o tng hi ii ton nt rng nt s te etlmenta e gr emen s t e erngofa a e ntwihPli if Couns lconc ni at neys f sa t, he nt i n greme t antfs' e er ng tor 'ee nd c t,a alot rmatr pe t ni t t slws t oss nd 1 he te s rai ng o hi a ui. ( in tr) Sg aue ( t Sg d Dae ine ) Prnt i Na e m wwxoTEww Stt eoflmiai c e nsma t t tyour ur t sf m a s as aut i t tons onc r ndae ha et n hi or s oon pos i et pr e v yourrght no e tltrt n byFrdav.Nove ber16.2012. sbl o es r e i s ven ae ha i m
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
