Milanes v. Commissioner of Social Security, No. 1:2015cv23171 - Document 19 (S.D. Fla. 2017)
Court Description: ORDER granting 16 Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment; denying 17 Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Magistrate Judge Chris M. McAliley on 3/22/2017. (nsy)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Milanes v. Commissioner of Social Security Doc. 19 UN I TED STA TES D I STRI COURT CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI A CT D CA SE N O .1 231 - V - CAL1 5- 71 Cl M LEY ( CONS ENT CAS E) MI LEN E M I LAN ES, Pl ntf , ai if N AN CY A .BERRYHI A CTI G LL N COY ISONE OFS I S C T I S I R V AL E URIY, D ef nt enda . / O RDER O N M OT I S FO R SUM M A RY JUD G M ENT ON Pe ng be o e t e Co ti Plitf sM o i n f Su r J e n ( 1 1 ndi f r h ur s an if to or mma y udg me t DE 6 , a Dee n ' M o i f rS nd fnda ts ton o ummay J e n.( 1 . smatri f lybref d. r udg me t DE 71 Thi te s ul i e For t r s s tbel ,l gr ntPl ntf s M oton f Sum m a y J he ea ons e ow a ai if i or r udge e and de m nt ny D ef nt sM oton f Sum m a y J enda ' i or r udgem e . nt 1 . O vervi w e Pl ntf tl f di a lt i ur nce bene is unde Til 1 i D ec be 201 , ai if ied or s biiy ns a ft r te 1 n em r 0 alegi diabiiy snce M a c 9,201 Tr 312-1 , 418- 9. Pl i i fs a i i w as l ng s lt i rh 0. . 4 1 2 a ntf pplcaton 1 a y A .Be r l be m e t A c i Com m i s one ofSoci Se urt on J nua y 23, 201 N nc r yhil ca he tng si r al c iy a r 7. Se S ca Se u iyAd nitain, h Acig Co s in ro ca Se u i e o il c rt mi srto T e tn mmiso e fso il c rt y, ltps/ww .s c a ncv/ommisone . ml Ptrua t Rul 25( oft Fe r Rulsof at :/ sa.ov/ge c si rht . zs nt o e d) he deal e Ci lPr dur ,Na y A . ryhili s tt t d f Ca ol W . vi ast d e vi oce e nc Be r l s ubsiu e or r yn Col n he ef ndan i t s t n hi Case. 2 Cia i t t ta c i ofpr ce ngs be or t Soci lSec iy A dm i s r ton, fl d a D E t tons o he r ns rpt o edi f e he a urt nit a i ie t 9 aet ç .( . r o ç #j' Tr ' 1 Dockets.Justia.com deni i taly on M a 3,2011 a de ed on r ons de a i on Oc ober 1 2011.Tr ed nii l y , nd ni ec i r ton t 3, . 31 21 324- Pl ntf t n r ques e a hearng by a A dm i s r i Law J 7- , 28. ai if he e td i n nitatve udge (WLJ'.Tr 3 9- The ALJhed a h a i o Se e e 5 201 a wh c Pli tf,a f ' . 2 30. ) l e rng n pt mb r , 3 t i h a n if medi exper and a voc i cal t atonale xper t tfed. Tr 49- . t esii 3 . 83 On O c obe 25,201 t ALJ i s a w rten dec s on i w hi he f t r 3, he s ued it ii n ch ound t t ha Pl ntf was notunder a di a lt as defned i t Soci Sec iy A c .Tr 25- The ai if s biiy i n he al urt t . 48. Appe s Counci deni Pl ntf s r ques f r e oft ALJ' dec s on,m aki t al l ed ai if e t or eviw he S ii ng he ALJ S decii t tnaldecii of t Com m i soner Tr 1 2.Pl ntf now a ks t t ' s on he s s on he si . . ai if s ha t s Cour r s and r a f t awar ofbe is or ale na i y,f t A LJ t hi t ever e em nd or he d neft , t r tvel or he o r c nsde t er c r a d hi c ncuso .( 1 , 1 . e o i r h e o d n s o l i ns DE 6 p. 51 I. I Procee ngsbe or t Com m i i di f e he sson A. The ALJ' D e son S cii I hi decii t ALJ f n s s on he ound fr t t t Pl ntf ha not engaged i s t i l i s ha ai i f s n ubsanta gai ula i t snce M a ch 9,201 t aleged ons t dat Tr 30.H e next f nf ctviy i r 0, he l e e. . ound t t ha Pl ntf has t s ver i paim e s of di e m elius obest s e a ai if he e e m r nt abet s lt , iy, l ep pnea a nd neur ogeni bl c adder Tr 30. The A LJ alo f , . s ound t t Pl ntf does not have an ha ai if i paim entorcom bi i ofi paim ent t m ee s orm edi l equal t s ve iy of m r naton m r s hat t caly s he e rt one oft lsed i paim ent i 20 CFR Par 404,Subpar P,A ppendi 1.Tr 32he it m r sn t t x . 37. The ALJ f und Pli if h s t p ia r sd lf nci na c pa iy ( o antf a he hysc l e i ua u to l a ct RFC) t o pe f r lg wo k a d fne i 2 CFR 404.5 * ) I pa tc l r t ALJ f un t t ro m i ht r s e i d n 0 1 67 . n riu a , he o d ha 3The he rng wa orgi ly s dul f Aprl201 bu wa r c ai s i nal che ed or i 3 t s es heduld t Se e be 201 a e o pt m r 3 t Pl i if s r que t Tr 343,380,38 a ntf ' e s . . 4. Pli ifc ul ()lf a c n' p h a orpu l20 po soc a i nal a 1 po ds antf o d i it nd a y, us nd l und c so ly nd 0 un fe u n l (i sa a / rwak f ra tt lo t ho si a egh - urda a stf r r q e ty, i) tnd nd o l o o a f wo ur n n i tho y nd i o sx hour i a ei i s n n ghthourday, (i)ne rci ldd r ors a f ds a d (v)oc a i nal ii ve lmb a e s c fol , n i c so l y clmb r m ps or sais bal nce, kneel s oop, cr h, or cr w l a d ( ) s ha t e i a t r, a , t ouc a , n v he s h addii tonal lm ia i of not bei abl t pi h w ih he rght hand. She has no i t ton ng e o nc t r i esabls t ihed viual or hea i lm ia i s rng i t tons. A s f e r ent lm iatons, Pl i if or nvionm al i t i a ntf s d avoi m oder t expos e t e r e col , ha dous m ac ne y a unpr ec ed houl d ae ur o xtem d zar hi r nd ot t hei s a s d avoi c entat d expos e t e r e heat w et s noi e, ght , nd houl d onc r e ur o xtem nes , s , vi a i f es odor dus ,gas ,a poorve ia i . Tr 37. br ton, um , s, t es nd ntlton . Appl ng t e lm ia i ,t A LJ f yi hes i t tons he ound t Pl ntf i ca bl ofpe f m i hat ai i f s pa e r or ng herpas r evantw or a a r e i s and m edi s et r , w hi a e bot cl s fed t el k s ec ptonit cal ecr a y ch r h as ii a s d nay j b i t Dito r ofOc up to lTils Tr 40.Gie t ALJS s e e tr o s n he cinay c aina te . . v n he ' fndi t Pl ntf can r t n t herpas r e ng hat ai if e ur o t elvantw or , he c uded t t Pl ntf i k oncl ha ai if s notdi a ed. .40- 1. s bl Tr 4 B. A dm i s ratve records ni t i The Cour hast oughl r vi w ed t entr r d i t s ac i w hih i udes t hor y e e he ie ecor n hi ton, c ncl Pl ntf' m edi r ds a t t a c i of t hea i bef e t A LJ. l w il ai i fs cal ecor nd he r ns rpt he rng or he l r e e e t a i sr tve r d w her i i r e ntt t i s addr s bel . ef r nc he dm nit a i ecor e t s el va o he s ues es ed ow 1 1. Anal i 1 ys s I e ua i a cl i f di a lt be l s,t A LJm us f l t tve sepss t n val tng a m or s biiy nett he t olow he s t e f rh i 20 C. R.j 41 92 a a 40 1 2 ot n F. j 6. 04) nd 4. 5 0: I t cl m a pe f m i s t i lgai ula tviy? l not t ALJnext s he ai nt r or ng ubsanta nf c i t f , he de er i , t m nes' 2. D oes t cl m a ha one or m or s r i paim ent l t cl m ant he ai nt ve e eve e m r ? f he ai does t A LJnextcons der , he i s; 3. D oes t cl m a have a s r i paim e t t m ee s or equal a he ai nt eve e m r nt ha t s n i par e s tcaly ls ed i 20 C .F. Pal 404,Subpar P,A ppe x 1 l s t m im nt pecis l i t n R. 4 t ndi ? f o, he cl i a i di abl i not t ALJ m us de e m i t cl i ant s RFC; a t am nt s s ed; f , he t t r ne he am ' nd hen det r i e m ne; 4. Bas on t RFC,ca t c ai a pe f m he pas r eva w or l s , ed he n he l m nt r or r t el nt k? f o s i not di bl l s ca he s sa ed. f he nnot per or he pas r e ntw or , t ALJ mus fnaly f m r t el va k he ti l de e m i t r ne; 5. W he he ,bas on he age,e t r ed r ducaton, and w or experence,and t RFC , i k i he c t cl m antper or ot rw or oft s tf an he ai f m he k he or ound i t na i n he tonaleconom y. l s t f o, he cl m a i notdi a ed.I not t cl m anti di a ed a e il d t benef . ai nt s s bl f , he ai s s bl nd ntte o ks Phil v Ba nh t35 F. 1 32,1 7( 1hCi. 0 ) lès . r ar, 7 3d 2 23 1 t r 2 04 . I r vi wi t ALJ S decii t Cour m us de er i whe he he a i t n e e ng he ' s on, he t t t m ne t r ppled he cor e l r ct egal s a r a w he her hi fndi of f t a e s t nda d, nd t s i ngs ac r uppore by s t i td ubsantal e d nc i t r c r Po r v Se k e ,738 F.d 1 51 1 52 ( 1h Ci. 1 4 . vi e e n he e o d. we s . c lr 2 1 , 1 1 t r 98 ) dSubsantal e de ' t i vi nce i m or t n a s ntla,but l s t pr ponde a s e ha ci il es han e r nce.l i s h t s uc re elvant e de e as a r onabl per on w oul a vi nc eas e s d ccept as a dequa e t s t o uppor a t c cuso ' Phil ,35 F.d a 1 40, 8 ( iai o itd) Th s bsa ile d n e on l in. ' ll ps 7 3 t 2 n. ct ton m te . e u tnta vi e c sa d doesnotpe m i a r vi w i cour t cons deronl t e pa t oft r cor t t ndar r t e e ng to i y hos r s he e d hat s uppor t ALJ; t c t m us vi w t entr r or a c i r e denc whi t he he our t e he ie ec d nd ons de vi e ch de r t fom t e dence r i on by t ALJ.M acki v.Asrue,N o.1: cvtac s r he vi eled he e t 07- 00098- M P- CS, 08W L 71 0,a # 1( D . a. a .1 , 008 . W 20 921 t N. Fl M r 1 2 ) W hie t Cour a i s a pr s l he t pple e umpton i f vor of t ALJ' sndi of f t no i n a he S ng ac , s h pr s uc e umpton a i s t t A LJ' l lconcl i . Thus t Cour m us r ver e i i pple o he S ega us ons , he t te s f t ALJ i r ty a i t lw , or i t decii f l t pr de t cour w ih he ncor ec l ppled he a f he s on ais o ovi he t t s t i r s ng t de e m i w het t 1w w aspr l a i . Per z v.Comm ' ufk ent ea oni o t r ne her he a opery ppled e r o So .S c.No. 06- 1 48 ORL- 9 f c e , 6: CV- 6 1 KRS,20 W L 1 03 #5( , Fl. a 2 08 91 6, M D. a J n. 2, 20 ) TheALJ Sf iur t s cf t eweg gi n t e i nc c nta yt hi de ii n, 08 . ' a l e o pe iy h iht ve o v de e o r r o s cso orf l e t gi t r on f dic edii evi aiur o ve he eas or s r tng dence, i r ver i e er or H artv.As r s e sbl r . t ue, No. 1 c 5 -- , 1W' 435 4 * 5 ( . FI Se .1 2 1 . Co r i 3:0-v- 31JTEM 201 L 61 9, M D. a. pt 9, 01 ) The u t s a h rz d t e traj gme a fr n modfig,o rvesng t d cson ofte uto ie o ne ud nt fimig, iyn r e ri he e ii h ALJ w ih orw ihoutr a Pe z,2008 W L 1 036,# 5;42 U . C . j ( ) , t t em nd. re 91 S. 405 g . The onl fndi t Pl i if cha l y i ng hat a ntf lenges he e i t ALJ' RFC de e m i ton. r s he S t r na i Pl ntf c e t t RFC i nots ai i f ont nds hat he s upport by s t nta e dence beca e t A LJ ed ubs a i l vi us he f l d t w ei or afor aie o gh, f ded i nadequa e w ei t t e m edi l opi ons of Pl i if s t ght o, hr e ca ni a ntf tea i phys ci r tng i ans, and t ALJ a s f ied t pr rl a s s Pl i if s c edi lt . he l o a l o ope y s es antf r biiy Be or Iaddr st e a gum e s,lnot t applcabl l w . f e es hos r nt e he i ea The RFC i an as es m e by t ALJ of a cl i ants a lt t w or des t he s s s nt he a m ' biiy o k pie r i ime t. wi v Cala n,1 F.d 1 6,1 40( 1h Ci.1 7) Thef c o t mpar ns Le s . lha 25 3 43 4 1 t r 99 . o us f he RFC i on doct s'e ua i oft cl m ant scondii a is m edi cons s or val tons he ai ' ton nd t cal eque s. nce Til nv. mm.fsoc S c,CaeNo. 1 c 9 9- 12 l ma Co o . e . s 6:2-v- 6 Or-2DAB,2 3W L 401 79, 3 01 49 * ( Aug. 2 1 M . F1) l d r ni t e RFC,he ALJmus c nsd ra1t r lva 6, 0 3 D. a . n de mi ng h t t o i e 1 he e e nt e de e. vi nc Lewi,1 F. a 1 s 25 3d t 440. I e la i me ia o nins ds u tn il i h mus begve t t o ni n, n vau tng d c l pi o , i l bsa ta we g t t i n o he pi o l di agnos s and m e calevi i di dence of a te i phys ci unl s t r i good caus t do r atng i an es he e s eo o h r s .'1 .S fj ALJ mus sa e wih pa tc a iy t we g gi n t dif r n t e wie ' d dl he gt tt t riulrt he i ht ve o fe e t m e c opi ons a t r s t r or' Wis h l . di al ni nd he ea ons he ef . ' n c e v Commiso ro sine fsocalS c rt i e ui y, 631F. 11 6,1 79 ( 1h Ci.2011.W ihou s h a sae n Eti i sbl fra 3d 7 1 1 t r ) t t uc ttme t ç s mposi e o i r e i c tt de e ne w het t uli a e deci i on t m e is oft cl m i evi w ng our o t nni her he tm t son he rt he ai s r tona a s a i l nd uppor ed by s t ntal evi nce.' 1 An A LJS f l e t s a e w ih t ubs a i de ' d. ' aiur o t t t pa tc a iy t wei gi t eac m e ca opi on i r r i e e r . Cal l v. ri ul rt he ght ven o h di l ni s eve sbl r or dwel Ba nh r,2 Fe App 1 8 1 0 ( 1h Ci. 008 ( iai n o te . r a t 61 dv x. 8 , 9 1 t r 2 ) ct to mit d) A. M e calO pi on ofD r Davi A dam s di ni . d Pl ntf com pl ns t t t A LJ f l t consde a Phys c Capa tes ai if ai ha he aied o i r i al cii Evauain a Que to ar d t d J nu r 3 201 c mpltd b Dr Da d Ada , l to nd si nn ie a e a a y , 2 o e e y . vi ms Plitf te tng n ur og s.( 1 pp.1 - 1 . so nin i no i t r c r The an ips r ai e ol it DE 6, 0 1 ) Thi pi o s t n he e o d. o y r f r nc t Dr Ada 'Physc lCa cte Evaua in a Que to nar i i a nl e e e e o . ms ia pa iis l to nd si n ie s n m em or ndum t tPl ntf s a i sr tve r e nt i s it pr ort t hea i a ha ai if dm nita i epr se atve ubm ted i o he rng. Tr 340. 42. Pl ntf r pr e a i di not a t h Dr A dam s opi on t her ai ifs e es nt tve d tac . ' ni o m em or andum , and t r i no evi nc t t Pl ntf pr ded i t t ALJ or t he e s de e ha ai if ovi t o he he com m i sone . TheA LJ c s i r; annotbe e xpee ed t w e gh a opi on t the di notr i t o i n ni ha d ece ve . Pl i if ar a ntf gues t t r and i ne rhel s war a e beca e t A LJ s d ha em s ve t es r nt d us he houl ha e is r dt tDr Ada s Ph i a Ca cte Evauai n a Que to iewe ep r v n u e ha . m ' ysc l pa iis l to nd sinnar r a t 4Att he rng t ALJ i t d Pl ntf sa t ne t s he a i he nvie ai if tor y o ubmi f t rdoc nt , buthe de lne t urhe ume s ci d t do s Tr 52. o o. . of t r cor Thi a gum e m i onsr t r e of t ALJ a t pari i he e d. s r nt sc tues he ol he nd he tes n aj dc tng s ca s c i c ss Alh gha ALJh sad yt de lp af 1 a d fi du iai o il e urt ae . tou n y a ut o veo u1 n ar r c r t c ama td a st b r e of o ngt t(l i d s bl d a c s qu n l , e o d,he l i n t r he u d n pr vi ha she s ia e , nd on e e ty be (le i r s nsbe fr pr d ig e d n i s ppo t o (ej cam. Elion sh s epo il o o ucn vie ce n u r f h r li ' ls ' Ba n r,3 F.d 1 2,1 6 ( 1h Ci.20 ) l wa Pli ifso i ton t prvie r ha t 55 3 27 27 1 t r 03 . t s antf blgai o o d Dr Ad ms Ph ia Ca cte Evau to a Qu si nar , nd e d n l s dd no . a ' ysc l pa iis la in nd e ton ie a vie ty he i t . For t f egoi r as ,Pl ntf has nots n t tt ALJ er ed i f lng t he or ng e ons ai if how ha he r n aii o we g Dr Ada 'Physc l pa iisEvaua in a d Que to a r i h . ms ia Ca cte l to n si nn ie. B. M e calO pi on ofD r A ndrade Bucknor di ni . - Pl ntf ne a guest tt ALJ i pr l afor tltl w ei ' t a Phys ca ai if xt r ha he m opery f ded site ght' o i l Ca tes Eval ton com pl t by Dr.Sha on Andr de- knor Pl ntf tea i pacii ua i e ed r a Buc ai ips r tng , c r o ogs .g 1 ,p.1 1 An ALJmus gi û su tnta we g t... o t o n o a dil it DE 6 2. t ve d l bsa il i h l t he pii n, di gnos s and m edi e dence of a t e i phys cin unl s t r i good c e t do a i cal vi r atng ia es he e s aus o o h r s ' Til ,201 W L 401 79,# i od c us e sswhe t ( )te tng t e wie. lman ' 3 49 3. s Go a e xit n he: 1 r a i p sca so n o wa no b se e b t e e d nc ( )e d nc s po td a c n r r hy ii n' pi i n s t olt r d y h vi e e; 2 vi e e up re o ta y tn ng;o () te tng ph iin' o iin wa c ncus r o i o sse t wih t i di r 3 rai ysca s pno s o l o y r nc n itn t he do trso me c lr c r . Phil s 35 F.d a 1 (iain o te .TheALJ co ' wn dia e o ds' li , 7 3 t 241 ctto mitd) ' p mus cl ary a tcul t hi r s whe gi ng a tea i physci s opi on l s t n t e l ri a e s ea ons n vi r tng i an' ni es ha s t ntalwei . #. ubsa i ght f Dr A ndr Buc . ade- knoropi t Pl ntf s f s f om f tgue whi h pr nt her ned hat ai if ufer r ai c eve s fom wor ng f ltm e,e n i a s nt y poston.Tr 1 r ki ul-i ve n ede ar ii . 208.The ALJ e aned hi xpl i s bass f a s gni t s opi on ltl w ei . I pa tcul , t A LJ s a ed t Dr. i or s i ng hi ni ite ght n r i ar he t t hat 7 A ndr Buc ade- knor' opi on conti t w ih hercont m por neous tea m entnot and t s ni lcs t e a r t es he m edi r d as a w hol cal ecor e.Tr 39- . H e pr ded s fc e . 40 ovi pecii xampl of s conoi t es uch c , s h ast abs nce of s uc he e uppori di tng agnos i fndi or e i tons and Dr Andr tc i ngs xam na i . adeBuc knors r com m endaton t t Pl i if e ci e f at l t 30 m i es a day. Tr 40. ' e i ha a ntf xer s or eas nut . The ALJ al o not t t Dr A ndr Bucknor pr s i a cons va i cour e of s ed ha . adee crbed er tve s tea m e . 1 By of e i t f e ng r ons t ALJ s ts r t nt d. f rng he or goi eas , he a i ûed hi oblga i t s i ton o m i a e good c e f gi ng D r Andr Buc cul t aus or vi . ade- knor' as es m entl st n cont oli s s s es ha r lng w ei . ght C. M edi alO pi on ofD r.Di c ni az The pa tes agr t tt ALJ di notas i a w ei t a A tendi Phys c a ri ee ha he d s gn ght o n t ng iin St t m e of Di a lt com pl ed by Dr. Yvonne D i one of Pl ntf tea i a e nt s biiy et az, ai ifs r tng p ysca .@ 1 ,p.8 ;( 1 p. .TheCo sine c ntn t tt ser ri h iins DE 6 ) DE 7, 9) mmiso r o e ds ha hi ro s har l s beca e t Atendi Phys ci St em enti nota m edi opi on but r her m es us he t ng i an at s cal ni , , at asae nto dia iiy. DE 1 p. q 1d s g e tt me f s b lt ( 7, 9 . ia r e. iW l ne raph iinofesasae n r fe tngj dg n sa utt nau e d he ve l ysca fr ttme t elci u me t bo he tr and s iy ofa cl i a ' i paim ent ,i udi s pt s di gnos s a pr evert a m nts m r s ncl ng ym om , a i , nd ognos s i, wha t cl i a can s ildo des t hi orheri paim e s a t cl m a ' phys ca t he a m nt tl pie s m r nt , nd he ai nts i l a m ent r s rc i , t sat e i a opi on r rng t ALJ t sat wih nd al e ti tons he t em nt s n ni equii he o t e t pari a iy t w ei gi tcul rt he ght ven t i a t r ons t r or ' Til an, 2013 W L o t nd he eas he ef e.' lm 401 4979, * 3.Dr D i s opi on m ee s t s des rpton, a i cont ns he s a em e s . az' ni t hi ci i s t ai r t t nt r r ng Pl ntf s ega di ai ifs ympt s,di om agnos a r sr c i es nd e ti tons.l al o i udest Doc or' n s ncl he t s opi on t Pl ntf i una e t w or due t he veri Tr 1 44.W hie ûa m edi ni hat ai if s bl o k o r tgo. . 243l t cal 8 s ce' opi on t a cl m ant i diabl i notcontoli ,' Beck- e v.Col n, our s ni hat ai s s ed s r lng ' Easly vi Cas no.1: 3- 02869- FK ,2015 W L 1 e 1 CVJ 401646, # 3 ( D.Ga M ac 2 201 ) a 1 N. . rh 6, 5 , n ALJ i s iloblgat d t w e gh t opi on and expl i t w ei acc de . S e Co l s tl i e o i he ni an he ght or d e fed Col n,Ca e no.6: 3- vvi s 1 c 2603DCN ,201 W L 733901 , #1 ( S. De 2 2 4) 4 3 0 D. C. c. 3, 01 (e ri g d cso ofCo miso ra r m a ngf rf t rpr c e i be a eALJ r ve sn e ii n m s i ne nd e ndi o urhe o e dngs c us f ie t weg Ate i Ph i in' S a e n ofDia lt ;s e alo Be k Ea ly al d o i h tndng ysc a s t tme t s biiy) e s c - se 201 W L 1 6 a *1 - 4 ( vauai wh t e ALJ er d i gvi ls t a 5 401 46 t 3 1 e l tng e h r re n i ng e s h n c nr li weg t a Ate ig Ph iin' Sae n o Dia lt) Ligef le v o tol ng iht o n tndn ysca s ttme t f sbiiy ; n netr . Asr e 5: 3 CV- 01 - D,201 WL 9 08 * ( D.Ca .M a c 1 ,201 (a ) tu , 1 - 0 01EJ 4 91 8, 4 N. l r h 1 4) s me . For t f egoi r ons Dr. Di z' Ate ng Physi an St t m ent of D i a lt he or ng eas , a s t ndi ci ae s biiy c tt esa m edi lopi on t t ALJhad a oblga i t w e gh. ons iut ca ni hat he n i ton o i Ia notper uaded t ti w a ha m l sse r f t ALJt nots a e t w ei he m s ha t s r e r or or he o t t he ght as i d t Dr D i z' opi on.The ALJ m ay notha as i s gne o . a s ni ve s gned s t ntalwei t Dr ubs a i ght o . D i s opi on f l tm a e r ons Thi Cour i l t t gues whe he t s i s az' ni or egii t eas . s t s ef o s t r hi s o; s e hi i c om t ng t annotdo. The El vent Cic tr centy r t r t t an ALJ' f iur t explcil s a e t e h r ui e l eie a ed hat S al e o i ty t t he wei as gned t an opi on ca l f r m a M ccl n v. Soc Sec Adm i , 625 ght si o ni ls or e nd. urki . . n. Fe App 96 96 3 ( 1h Ci. 2 5 (i c us t ALJ f ie t sae wi d. x. 0, 2- 1 t r 01 ) s a e he Be al d o t t t h p riulrt t we g ta sg dt (h me c l o ni o t r a on wh hem a ha a t a iy he i h s ine o t e dia! pi on r he e s s y c y ve di c de he opi on,w e vaca e a r m a t t dit it cour w ih i t uctons t s ar d r ni t nd e nd o he src t t nsr i o rt r t c s t t e Commison r f r pr c e i c nsse wih t s opi on.) eu n he a e o h s i e o o e dngs o itnt t hi ni ' . ' The ef e,t Cour w ilr and t s m a t t t ALJ f f t rpr edi See alo r or he t l em hi ter o he or urhe oce ngs. s 9 H ar ,2011 W L 4356149,#6;Chrit en v.As r N o 5: v154/ EM T,2008 W L t sens t ue, 07c RS. 41 71 #1 ( D.Fl Se .9 2 )(n s ca s c rt c s s (he g n rlr l i t 92 8, 1 N. a. pt , 008 i o il e u iy a e ,t e e a ue s o t r r e and r m a f addii eve s e nd or tonalpr oceedi whe er or occur' . ngs n r s . ' ) 0 n r m and, t ALJ s d explc ty consde , dicus and w ei Dr. D i s e he houl i il i r s s gh az' A tendi Physci n St t m entofD i biiy.Aferconsde i t f lm e ca r cor , as t ng i a ae sa lt t i rng he ul di l e d pr l w ei ed,t A LJ s opery ght he houl de e m i Pl ntf s RFC, a explcil s a e t d t r ne ai if nd i ty t t he bass f r t de e m i ton. A ppl ng t r vi ed RFC, t A LJ s d de er i i o hat t r na i yi he e s he houl t m ne whe herPl i ifcan r t n t herpas r e t a ntf e ur o t el vantwor a i not pr k nd, f , oceed t s e fve of o tp i t r r anal s t m a a tnaldet r i ton ofPl ntf s elgi lt f di a lt he equied ysi o ke i e m na i ai if i biiy or s biiy beneft . is D. Cre biiy A s es m ent di lt s s Pli ifc n e st tt ALJd d no p o ry a s s he c e i lt E 1 , antf o tnd ha he i t r pe l s e s r r d bii DE 6 pp. y. 1 1 G i t Cour ' fndi t t t ALJ er ed i f lng t wei Dr D i s 2- 4. ven he ts i ng ha he r n aii o gh . az' Atendi Phys ci St e ent t Cour wilnotr ach t s is The A LJw ilhave a t ng i an at m , he t l e hi s ue. l n o po t iy t r a s s Pli ifsc e bii ( nd ofe s ppo tf t ta s s me t o p runt o e s e s antf r di lt a y f r u r or ha s e s n ) n r a he m a r ch a dif r c us on r ga di t cr biiy of Pl ntf em nd; y ea f e ent oncl i e r ng he edi lt ai ifs t tm ony afe w ei ng D r D i z' opi on. es i tr ghi . a s ni I V. Conc us on l i Bas on t f egoi i i he e O R DERED t Pl ntf s M oton f ed he or ng, t s r by hat ai if i or Su r J ge nt ( 1 1 i GRANTED ,nd De e a ts M o i f Su r mma y ud me DE 6 , s a f nd n ' ton or mma y J dg me g 1 ) i DENI Th d cso o t Comm iso ri REVERSED a u e nt DE 7 , s ED. e e ii n f he s i ne s nd 10 t s c e i REM AND ED t t Com m i s one f f t r pr edi cons sentw ih hi as s o he s i r or urhe oce ngs it t t sOr r. hi de D ONE and ORDERED i cha be s i M i m i Fl i t s 22nd day of M a c n m r n a , or da hi r h, 201 7. l # * CHRI M CA LI S LEY UN I TED STA TES M A GI STRA TE J D GE U Copi st e o: Couns ofr d el ecor 11
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
