Chanel, Inc. v. chanelbagsforsale-us.com et al, No. 1:2012cv22076 - Document 35 (S.D. Fla. 2012)
Court Description: ORDER granting 32 Motion for Default Judgment and Closing Case Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 10/31/2012. (mg)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Chanel, Inc. v. chanelbagsforsale-us.com et al Doc. 35 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA CASE NO.1:2-v1 c 22076- TZ/ M ON TON SEI S1 CHA N EL,l C . N , Pli tf, a n if CHANELBAGSFORSALE- COM ,e al US. t , Def nda s e nt . / O R DER G R ANT I G PLA I TI S M O TI N FO R ENT RY O F N N FF' O FI AL D EFA U LT JU DG M ENT A N D CLO SI G CA SE N N THI CAUSE i bef e t Cour on Pli tf s M oton f Enty of Fi De a t S s or he t a n if i or r nal f ul J d me t ( 3 .Plitf, Ch n l l c ' a l o d anif' mo e f r fna d fut u g n DE-21 an if a e, n .(Ch ne' r t i tf ) v s o i l e a l ' pl j d me ta ans De e d n s te Pa te s i a d Unic mo ae Aso it nsI e iid o u g n g i t fn a t, h rn rhps n n o r td s cai d nt e n o f S h d lsC ' n t ' rt ( olci ey l fnd n s' f ralg d voa inso t La h m c e ue C a d t heeo c l tv l ç e a t' o le e ilto f he n a A' B' e De ) Ac,c dfe a 1 U. C.j 1 1 ,1 25 a,a d 11 ( ) AsDee a t h v fie t a p a, t o iid t 5 S. j 1 4 1 () n 25 d . fnd n s a e ald o p e r plad oro he wie de end t s a ton,and gi n t doc e t r s f hi ci ve he umentr e de s itd i s a y vi nce ubm te n uppor t ofism oton,t Cour s l g a Pl ntf' M oton f rFi lDe aul J m e . t i he t hal r nt ai ifs i o na f t udg nt 1 Dockets.Justia.com 1. Fact and ProceduralBackzround ual Ch n l I c ($ a 1)i a c r rto d l o g nz d u d rte lwso t e S ae o a e, n . t ne' s opo ain uy r a ie n e h a f h tt f Ch ' Ne Yor wih is prnci plc ofbusne s i t Unied Stt l a ed a Ni W e t 57 h w k t t i pal a e i s n he t a es oc t t ne s t Sre,Ne Yo k,Ne Yo k 1 01 . ( mp .! 3) Ch n l i e g g d i t e p o to te t w r w r 0 9 Co l . a e s n a e n h r moin, diti i n,a s l i Unied St t s i e sae c me c of hi qualt goods unde t srbuto nd a e n t a e ntr t t om r e gh iy r he Cha lM aks ( clr in of Adre Ha Siba r i Suppor of Pli ifs Ex Pare ne r . De aato inne hn s ro n t antf t Ap iain f rEnr o Te o ay Re tanngOr e a d P ei n r Ij n to (tlh De l pl to o ty f mp rr sr ii c d r n r l a y nu cin ç- n c. mi la i S pp r o Plitf sExPa t Ap ' !!4, ( 54) Ch n li, n a a1 i srlv n n u o t f anif re p.) ' 5 DE- - . a e s a d t 1 tme ee a t ) he eo hasbee t ownerofa 1rght i a t t f l ng Fede aly r git r d ta m a ks rt n, he l i s n nd o he olowi r l e se e r de r : T r mar ade k Regit aton sr i Number CHANEL 0, 2, 9 61 16 CH AN EL 0 626, 035 , CH AN EL CHANEL CH AN EL Dat e Cl se lGoods as ts/ Se e955r1 j (1 . x e kl ce pt1 mbe 3, c ) 4 c a s M ay 1 1 , 956 I 01 - W om e , Ha ags C 8 n s ndb 0, 1 902, 90 N o m be 1 j (j . ve r 0, c ) 4 1 970 sr c e s pi ,a Ea ngs a elt , ns nd ni 0 91 1 5, 39 J 1 1 une 5, 971 I 025 -W ome , Shoe C ns s , CH AN EL R egit aton sr i 0, 07 955, 4 1 241265 , , M a 973 3, rh 1c 1 j (j w a c s c )4 t he - I 025 -Suis J c t ,Ski t,D r s es C t , a ke s rs e s , Pa s B l e ,Tuni s Sw ea e s nt , ous s c, tr , J ne7,1 3 C u 98 ar ga , t ,Ranc t ,Sca ve , di ns Coa s i oa s r s Shoesand Boot s 2 0 2 X CHANEL I 0 -Cl hi Na ey,Coa s C 25 ot ng- m l t, D r s s Bl es Rai oa s Suis es e , ous , nc t , t , Skit,Ca di ans Swe e s, nt, rs r g , atr Pa s J cke s Bl e s and Shoe a t, az r , s jz jg.6 , y y ' ' M a c 27, rh 1 984 1314, 511 , Jn 9851 , H 01 -Le te Go d - mey a 1ay 5 I 8 ah r o sNa l, ur C 1 I 01 -Leahe Goods na ey, C 8 t r - m l J y 9,1 ul 985 H andbags . 347, 677 , a ndbags I 006- Ke hai C yc ns I 01 -Cosume J wer C 4 t e ly 1 A 501898 , , ugus 30, t 1 988 I 01 -GitW r ppi Pa r C 6 f a ng pe I 0 - ous s Shoe ,Bet , C 25 Bl e , s ls Sca ve ,J c t ,M e sTi s r s a ke s n' e I 0 - Br hesa Butonsf C 26 ooc nd t or Cl hi ot ng CHANEL . CHANEL 1 51 757 , 0, 1 65 252 , 4, 1 733, 051 , Nove r1 I ((9 mbe , c j, 1 988 sungl s e ass - xug 91 0 j () ut ( 1 s 2 , c ;q 9 . sungj s es as I 01 -Le t rGoods nnme y, C 8 a he ; l Ha ndbags W a lt , a Ba , , le s Tr vel gs No mbe 1 Lugga Busnes and Cr di Ca d ve r 7, ge, i s e t r 1 992 C as ,ChangePur e ,Tot Ba , es ss e gs Cos tc Ba Sol Em pt and me i gs d y, G a m entBags f Tr ve r or a l I 01 -Le t rGoods nn e y, C 8 a he ; m l r 1734, 22 , 8 xo mbe 2 Ha d a sW alt, a e Ba s ve r 4 n b g , lesTrv l g, 1 992 3 , sugga Busne s Ca d Cas , ge, i s r es Cha e Pur e , e Ba ,a ng s s Tot gs nd Cos e i Ba Sol Em pt m tc gs d y X 305934 2 , , Dec mbe 1 j (jg ua s a e r 3, c l nj gs 2045 ) . I 009 -Eye a sFr m es Sungl s s C gl s a , as e r 3025, 936 , Dee e 1 , I 0 -Glv s S mwer c2005 3 C 25 o e, wi a mb r I 026 -HarAc s oresname y C i ce s i l Ba r tes re t CHANEL 3,1 13 33, 9 Augus 22, I c1 . p we r a w a c t c 4 ly nd t hes 2006 (h i n lM aks' wh c aer gsee o tePrn ia Re itroft eUntd S ae Pae t te s e r ' ih r e itrd n h icp l g se h ie tts tn cha ) and Tr de a k Ofi a a e us i co c i wih t m a a t e and diti i ofhi a m r fce nd r ed n nne ton t he nuf c ur srbuton gh qualt goodsi t caegoresi iid a iy n he t i dentfe bove.( 1 Dec.i Suppor ofPl ntf sEx Pare Ham ln t ai if t Ap !4a dCo Ex. atc e t eeo ( 5 5) p. n mp. A ta h d h rt DE - 1. De e f ndan sha a ried,ofe ed f s e,a o s d ha t ve dve ts f r or al nd/ r ol ndbags wales s , l t, hoes boot , , s s n lse ,wac e ,a d c su jwer ,icu n n c lc s b a ees a d e ri g b ai u ga s s th s n o t me e ly n ldig e ka e , r c lt, n arn s e rng c u tret,r p o u to s a d o c l rbe i tt ns o t Ch ne M ak .( h De l i o n ef is e r d cin , n / r o o a l miai f he a l r s Ha n c . n o S p r o Plitf s Ex Pa t Ap ! 11 1 ;De lrto o Erc Roslr i Su po to u po t f anif re p. ! - 6 caain f i ae n p r f Plitf sAp iai nf rTRO gRo ae De li Su po t fPlitf sfxPa t Ap ' !4a d an if pl to o c s s lr c.n p r o anif ç re p.) n ' Co Ex. t eeo,DE 5 8 59 ; caaino S e h n M . fi a i S p o t Plitf mp. A h rt ( - , -2 De lrto f tp e Ga fg n n u p r of an ifs Mo inf rEnr o Fia Dea l J d me t(Gafg nDe l i Su p r o M oi nf rFDJ' ! to o ty f n l fut u g n d fia c .n p o t f to o t ' ! ) 3,4;De a aton o Adre Hn Siba r i Su clr i f i nne hn s ro n ppor ofPl i ifs M o i f rEnty ofFi l t antf ton o r na Dea l J d me tllam De l i S p r o M o in f rF ' ! 1 - 6;De lrto o Erc fut u g n s- l c. n u po t f to o DJ' ! 1 1 çl ! ca ain f i Ros l i Suppor ofPlitf sM oi f Enty ofFi lDeaul J aer n t anif ton or r na f t udgme (t alrDe l i nt 6 Ros e c. n S p o to Mo in f rFDJ' ! 5 6a d Co Ex. atc e teeo; n r lva twe p g s u p r f to o ' ! , n mp. A ta h d h r t a d ee n b a e ) fo Dee a t'l tr e we i so e ai u d rte Su jc Do i Na s rDee a t' r m fnd n s n en t bst p r t n e h b e t man me l d fnd ns e ng W e sts' atc e a Co Ex.B t te Ha n De l i Su po to Plitf' Ex Pa t Ap b i ' ta h d s mp. e q o h h c. n p r f an ifs re p. a datc e a Co Ex. t t Ha n De l i S p o to Mo in f rFDJ) Dee d nsa e n ta h d s mp. A o he h c.n u p r f to o . fn a t r notnow,norhavet y eve bee aut i d orlce ed t us ,r pr ce,orm a countr et , he r n, horze i ns o e e odu ke e f is rpr tons a or c orbl i ttons of t Cha lM aks ( hn De l i Suppor of e oduci , nd/ ol a e miai he ne r Ha c. n t Plitf ExPa t Ap !9) anifs re p. . Plitf rti e ErcRo ae (ç s 1r' o AED l v siains l .al e s dp i ae anif ean d i s lr $ ae' f Ro ) n t tg to ,nc, i n e rv t c i si a i fr i Fl i t i ve tg t s pe t s e of countr et Cha l br nded nve tg tve im n orda, o n si a e us ced als e fi ne a pr d t b De e d n s ( 1 De li Su po t fPlitf ExPa t Ap ! l ; ae De l o ucs y fn a t. Ham c .n p r o anips re p. 0 Roslr c . i S p o t fPlitf' ExPareAp ! 3)I M a 2 2 Roslra c s e t eI tr e we ie n u p r o an its t p. . n y 01 , ae c e s d h nen t bst ope a i unde t domai na c r tng r he n me haneonlnes l i hoppi a.om ,a pl e a o de f t ngus c nd ac d n r r or he p rhaeo aCh n l rn e h n b g ( s lrDe l i S p o to Plitf sExPareAp . 4 u c s f a e b a d d a d a . Ro ae c.n u p r f anif t p! a Comp.Ex.A ata he t rt )Ros e ' purha e wa pr ese entr l onlne,whi nd tc d heeo. alrs c s s oc s d iey i ch i ude pr di s ppi a bilng i or ai pa nt a c im ai of hi or r ncl d ovi ng hi ng nd li nf m ton, yme , nd onfr ton s de . ( eja se g. l alr c s d nd Pl ntf r pr enttve i pe t a a l ed t ha ai ifs e es a i ns ced nd nayz he ndbag Ros e pur ha e a r c i dzvi t c e eve a he haneonlnes l i hoppi ngus c we ie,aswel a t we pa lsi a a.om bst l s he b ge itngs nd 1Afe t flng oft Compli a t Applcai f TRO,Chane dico r d De enda s tr he ii he ant nd he i ton or l s ve e f nt 6,8,a 9 we e wr uly c i ng t us t Cha lM a ks i vi a i oft Pr i i r nd r ongf l ontnui o e he ne r n olton he elm na y Ij n to ( 1 )b a v riig o frn f rs l,a d s lig v ro sie t e te Ch ne nu cin DE 8 y d e tsn , fei g o ae n eln ai u t ms md r h a l M ar ,wihoutChane ' a ho i a i i c me to wih t I t ne webst ope a i unde ks t ls ut rz ton, n or c i n t he nt r t ies r tng r t addii ldoman na s lsed i Sc he tona i me it n hedul tB' n xe heeo (he i tona Do i e $ ' nne d rt t t i l man Addi Na s' ( e Gafg n De l i S p o to M o in f rFDJ ! 3 4. Th Orgn lDo i me .) S e f a c. n u p r f to o ' ! , ) e i ia man Nn s a d t e Ad t na Do i Na st g t r ae h ra trr fre t a t e t be t me n h dio l man me o ehe r e e fe eer d o s h é j c i su D om ai N a e ' n m s. ' Ros lr i ta l s l ce a c t ae niily e e td hesnut c o e Cha ol r d nel br nded ha a ndba fom t g r he c ne o i hoppi a.om we ie;howeve ,afe he c ha l nlnes ngus c bst r tr omplt d hi pur ha e t De e nt e e s c s , he f nda o ai t c ne o i hoppi a.om we ie i or per tng he ha l nlnes ngus c bst nf med hi t t t orgna c or he m ha he i i l ol he ndbag wa a no g ne s n- enui de al we page c pt es of t ie ,a s deer ned t ha t ied b a ur he t m nd he t mi Ch n l r d c. Ha nDe li Su o t fPlitf sExPa t Ap ! 1 Ha nDe li S p o t a e p o u t ( h c.n pp r o anif re p. 2; h c.n u p r of anifsM o in f rF ! l ,1 ,1 . Plitf' to o DJ ! 1 2 6) Afe t flng of t Co pl nt and Pl i ifs Ex Pare Applca i f Enty of tr he ii he m ai antf t i ton or r Te o ay Re tanng Or e a d Pr l n r Ij n to (he* PareAp lc t n',Ch n l mp rr sr ii d r n ei ay n u ci n t %x t p iai ' a e mi o ) ds o ee t a Dee d n 6 c a eh n a sh mec m,Dee d n 8 -c a ej wer u ac m, ic v rd h t f n a t h n la db g -o .o fn a t h n le ly s .o a De e n 9 -c ne onlne hoppi ac we e wr ngf l co i ng t us t Cha l nd f nda t ha l i s ngus .om r o uly ntnui o e he ne M aksi v oain o t ePr l n r Ij n to ( 1 )b a v riig,o frng f rs l,a d r n i lto f h ei ay n u ci n DE 8 y d e t n fei o ae n mi s s li va i usie sunde t Cha lM aks wihoutCha lsa horzai i c elng ro t m r he ne r , t ne ' ut i ton, n onne ton wih ci t t l e e we ies oper tng t a tonaldom an names lse i Sc dul t 'ame he nt m t bst ai he ddii i it d n he e i r xed B' her t t Addii na Dom an Na .( e Ha n De l i S p r o M o in f rFDJ ! 1 eo, he to l i mes S e h c. n u po t f to o 3; Ga fg nDe li Su po t fM o inf rF ! 3 4; e as Not 1 if a. Hn nr ve da d fi a c. n p r o to o DJ ! , s e lo e ,nk ) h e iwe n viua l i pe t d t ie sbe rng t Cha lM a ks ofe e f s l on t I e ne we ies s ly ns c e he t m a i he ne r f r d or a e he nt r t bst ope a i undert pa t r hi a u nc or e a s iton na e i ntfed on Sc r tng he rne s p nd ni om atd s oca i m s de i hedulsA e a d B h r t,t e S b e tDo i Nn s a d s d tnnie te p o u t wee n n g n ie n eeo h u j c man me , n he ee n d h r d cs r o - e un Ch ne p o u t.( l De l i S p o to Plitf sEx Pa t Ap ! 1 - 5 Ha n De l i a l r d cs Ham c. n u p r f anif re p. ! 3 1 ; h c . n Su po t fPlitf sM o inf rF ! 1 - 6. p r o anif to o DJ ! 4 1 ) On J 4,201 Pl i iffld is Compli agans Def nda s f f r tade a k une 2, antf ie t ant i t e nt or ede al r m r coun e f tng and i rnge t f le desg ton of o i n,c r quatng,and c t reii nfi men , a s i nai rgi ybe s ti omm on lw a u arc mp tto . DE- J 0nJ ne6 20 2, aniffldisExPa t Ap lc to ( S . nfi o eiin ( I . u , 1 Plitf ie t re piain. DE- J On J 1 201 t s Cour is d a Or rGrntng Pl ntf sEx Pare Applc to ( 9) une 3, 2, hi t sue n de a i ai if t iain DE- , slce wa no l ravalbl.( e Ros l Dec.i Suppor ofM oton f FDJ .Ros lr ee td s onge ia e Se aer l n t i or ) ae s l t a r c ved a bl k Chane br nde ha eeced nd e ei ac l a d ndbag i a smia syl t t che t ha n i l r t e o he snut ndbag he i tal ptrhas vi t c neo i hoppi us c we ie.( e i.a Comp.Ex.A niily lc ed a he ha lnlnes ng a.om bst Se pa nd atche t eo. ta d hert ) 6 t mpor rl r tani De e nt fo i rngi t Cha lM ar a is TheCour f t e a iy esr i ng f nda s r m nfi ng he ne ks t s ue. t urher or r d Pl ntf t s r a c ofisEx Pare Applcai a t Cour' J 1 201 Or r de e ai if o e ve opy t t i ton nd he ts une 3, 2 de on De e nt vi t i known e- a l a e s a by posi a c f nda s a her m i ddr s es nd tng opy of t Ex Par e he t Applc ton a ia i nd t he Co ts J ur' une 13, 201 Or r on t 2 de he I e ne we ie ntr t bst htp:/e i notc c ba t /s a ng ie.om/ gage nde ht . Pl i if fld no i e i c pla e wih t nvi x. ml antf ie tc s n om i nc t he Co r' Or e o J n 1 ,2 2a d J n 2 , 01 ( I ;DE- 2 , e t yngs r ieo t eEx u ts d r n u e 4 01 n u e 2 2 2 DE- O 1 ) c ri i evc f h f Pare Applc ton a s ppori pa s a of t Cour ' Te t i ai nd u tng per nd he ts mpor r Resr i ng Or r ay tani de . Su sq e l,te Co r e ee a Prlmi r lj n to a ans Dee d nso J l 2,2 2. b e u nt h u t ntr d ei nay n u cin g i t fn a t n uy 01 y ( 1 . On Au u t3 2 2 Pli tf fld isMo in f rOr e Auh rzngAlen t Se vc DE- 8) g s , 01 , anif ie t to o d r to ii tr ae r ie o Pr c s ( 21, iht eCo r g a td o Au u t9 2 2 ( 2 . On Au u t1 , 01 f o e s DE- ) whc h u t r ne n g s , 01 . DE- 3j g s 3 2 2, De e n s we e s r d wih t i r peci Sum monsa co esoft Co pl ntvi e mai f nda t r e ve t her es tve nd pi he m ai a - l s r ce orvi publcai s vi purua t t Cou ts Or r a horz ng a tr e s l c of e vi a i ton er ce s nt o he r ' de ut ii le nat evie p o e s ( 2 DE- ; 28J r c s .DE- 3; 27 DE- . On Se e r27,201 t Clr ofCour,purua t Rul 55()o t Fedea Ruls ptmbe 2, he e k t s nt o e a f he rl e ofCi lPr e e,entr d de a tagans De e vi oc dur e e f ul i t f ndan s f r f l e t a a ,pl d,orot r s t o aiur o ppe r ea he wie dee t sa ton.( eDE- )To dae Defnda sha nots ug t va ae t de a tor fnd hi ci Se 30. t, e nt ve o ht o c t he f ul ot r s a he wie ppea a d e t s a ton.0n Oct r 1 201 Pli if fld a s r ed t r nd ef nd hi c i obe 2, 2, a ntf ie nd e v he isa tmoin f re ty o fn ld f utj d me t t whih De e d ns h v as fie t n tn t o nr f i a ea l u g n , o c fn a t a e lo ald o o rs e pond. I. I LEG AL STANDARD FedealRul ofCi lPr dur 55( ( a horz ac r t e era dea tj me r e vi oce e b)2) ut ies ou t o nt ful udg nt ag ns a pr ry s r e de e ai t ope l e v d f ndan ,who,lke Def ndant he e,f l t fl a tmel r ponsve t i e s r aied o ie i y es i pl di By s a de a t a 1ofPl ntf we lpld a l to i t Compli a e dee ea ng. uch f ul, 1 ai ifs l- e legai ns n he a nt r med 7 ad te SeeBuch mitd. ananv Bowman,820F. 359,361( 1hCi.1 ;Peme Ex e s I .v . 2d 1 t r 987) t d pr s nc . M epot.om, 336 d sc Supp.2d 1 3, 1 7 ( D.Fl 2004) I t ad ted fcs i t 21 21 S. a. . f he mit a t n he Compl i esa ih la lt t n t Cour mus de e m i a opra e da ant tbls i biiy, he he t t t r ne ppr i t mage W he e a lt s. r l he e s tale de i on r c d,an e d i r he i on dn s en i vi nce s e or vi enta y arng mage i no r quie Se SEC v s s t e r d. e . Smyt 420 F. 1 , 1 n. 1 ( 1h Ci.2005 (' e 55b)2) s a of evi ntay h, 3d 225 232 3 1t r ) ' Ru1 ( ( pe ks de ir he rngs i a pe misve t ...W e ha hel t t no s h he rng i r quie whe e a l ai n r s i one ve d ha uc a i s e rd r l e sn ile i e c i ara y o rc r ' (iain o te ) s e as Peme Ex e s 3 6 F. se ta v d n e s le d f e o d.) ctto s mi d ; e lo t d pr s , 3 ' t S p 2 a 1 2 (n ei d fulj d me t p r n n ij n to a d sauo y d ma e i a u p. d t 2 3 e trng ea t u g n , ema e t n u cin n tttr a g s n La m Ac c e wihouta he rng .I t s c s a he rng on da a i unne esay a nha t as t ai ) n hi a e, a i nAges s c sr s Pl i ifi no s e ng da a . a ntf s t e ki m ges 1 11. A. Li lt abii v T radem ark Infri ngem ent Th alg t nsi Plitf sCo lit i c nu cin wih r c r e ie c ,s pp r a e le ai n anif mpan , n o j n to t e o d vd n e u o t o fn ig o la iiya ans Dee d nt f rta e r ifi e n .'T1 p e i o ata e r i dn f ib l g i t fn a s o r d mak n rng me t ' o rval n r d ma k t ( i rn e n cam aplitf mu td mo srt t t( )isma kh sp irt ()d f n a tu e nfi g me t li an if s e n tae ha 1 t r a ro i 2 ee d n s d y; ismak i c t r n ommec ( t c e q a ( def ntsmak i lkey t c e c umer re wihout onsnt; nd 3) enda ' r s i l o aus ons co uson. Peme Ex e s 336 F.Supp.2d a 1 1 1 (ii l ' Co is Exc l v. nf i ' t d pr s , ' t 2 7- 8 ctng ntl smetc k, nc. Ga r sHe l ( Be uy I c, 0 F.d 1 4 ( 1hCi. 00 )a dFr h igEn e I c v I t pa di at f a t n .3 3 3 2 3 1 t r 2 2 n e ln tn, n . . n ' h l See tGr p,I . 1 2 F. 13 ( 1h Ci.1999) Plitf ha esa ihe e ch oft s lc ou nc, 9 3d 30 1 t r ). anif s tbls d a he e elmensbec us ( )Pli ifs o rhi a r itai oft tade r a is pr e e t a e: 1 antf wne s p nd egsr ton he r maks t s ue ec de Dee d n s ifigng c n u t( mpl ! 1 ;Ha n De l i Su po to Plitf s fx Pa t fn a t' n rn i o d c Co , 3 h c . n p r f an if re App. 4) ( Dee nt a rie ofee f s ea o s d goodsbe rngPl ntf smaks ! ; 2) fnda s dve ts d, frd or al nd/r ol ai ai if r i itrtt c mme c wi o t Plitf s c n e t ( mp .! 28 Ham De l i S p r o n ne sae o r e t u anif o s n Co l h ; l c. n u po t f 8 ta her o; .n Plitf sEx Pa t Ap ! 9 1 a d Co Ex .B a d C at ched t et Hnhn Decl i anif re p. ! - 6 n mp. s n S p o to M oi nf rF ! 1 - 6a d Co Ex. atc dt eeo ; nd( )temaksu e u p r f to o DJ ! 4 1 n mp. A ta he h rt ) a 3 h r s d on t goods Defnda s a ried,ofe ed f s e a / s d a e s s m iar t Pl i ifs he e nt dve ts f r or al nd or ol r o i l o a ntf mak ta c n u rc nf so i lk l ( mp .j 2 ,3 , fn a s W e stsa tc e a r s h t o s me o u in s iey. Co l j 4 0 De e d nt' b i ta h d s e Co mp.Ex.B t t Ha De .i Sup tofPl ntf ' Ex Par e App.a at c d a Co o he hn cl n por ai ifs t nd ta he s mp. Ex. t teHa nDe li S p o t Mo inf rFDJ) A o h h c.n u p r of to o . B. FaleDesgnaton ofOrgi s i i i n P an ifalg sfled sg t n o o ii u d rj4 ()o t Lala Ac,1 U. . j litf l e as e inai f rgn n e 3 a f he r m t 5 SC. e o h 11 a .Tha s ci pr de a f l ; 25() t e ton ovi s s olows Any pe s who,on o i co ci wih a goodsors vi s orany c ane r on r n nne ton t ny er ce , ont i r f goods us s i c or , e n omm e c a wor tr na e s bol or de c or a r e ny d, e m, m , ym , vie, ny co bi ton t r of o a f le desgna i of org n, f le or mil a ng m na i he e , r ny as i ton ii as se di des rpton off c , f leorm iladi r pr entton off c ,whihci i a t or as se ng e es a i at c ( i lkeyt c ec uson,ort c us mit ,ort de i a t t A) s i l o aus onf i o a e sake o ceve s o he afii ton,c flai onne ton,oras ocato ofs h pe s wih a he pe s n, ci s i in uc r on t not r r o orast t orgn,s or hi ora ova o hi o he goo ,s r i e , o he i i pons s p, ppr l f s r r ds e v c s oc r omm e c a aci te byanot rpe s or r i l tvii s he r on, ( i c mmeca a v riig o p o to mirp e e t t n tr , B) n o r il d e t n r r mo in, se r s ns he au e s c r t itcs qualtes or ge a c orgi of hi or he or ano he ha acersi , ii , ogr phi i n s r t r pe s n' go ,s vc ,orco me ci a i te ss lbe la e i a c vi r o s ods er ies m r al ctviis hal ibl n i l a ton by a pe s n who be ives t t he or s i or i lke y t be ci ny r o le ha he s s i l o da a d by s h ac . m ge uc t 1 U. C.j 1 25a () 5 S. 1 () 1. The s me s of f t al ng Pl ntf t pr vai unde j 111 1( wilr s ti a et acs lowi ai if o e l r 4( )a) l e ul n rc y unde j 11 Se Babbi Elc . 38 F. a 11 1 ( lh Ci.1 ( tng Mar hon e over r 25. e t e s, 3d t 8 1 t r 994) cii at Mf .Co v En riePr d .Co p. 7 7 F.d 21 21 ( t Ci.1 5 s ealo Cl r lI c v g . . e l o s r , 6 2 4, 7 5h r 98 :9 e s aio n . . t s'vc l z I s,I . 21 U. P. 459,469-0 ( D.Fl 1 .S-hi i be a e Se ton t -ct ndu . nc, 0 S. Q. z y 7 S. a. 980) ç s s c us ci f 11 ()i bo de t a Se to 1 1 i ta i c v r f lea v riig o d s rp in wh te o 25a s r a r h n cin 1 4 n h t t o es as d e t n r e cito eh r r s 9 noti i vesta maki rnge . BabbiElc .38F. a 1 1(ii Sivesa Entr . t nvol r de r nfi ment' ' t e s, 3d t 18 ctng l rtr e s, I c v Ad y, 3 F. u p. 3 ( D. Y.1 2 Aswi ta e r ifig me tcams t ets n . . a 5 7 S p 2 6 S. N. 98 :. t rd mak n rn e n li ,h et h f la lt f flede i tonoforgi unde j43()i as l t rt publci lkeyt be or ibiiy or as sgnai in r a s lo ç he he i s i l o whe de eve orc us d by t sm ia iy oft m a ks a i s ' Fwt Pe o ,l v.Tac Cabana ci d onf e he i lrt he r t s ue. ' ? s s nc. o , I . 505 U. 763, 780, 11 S.Ct 2753, 7 ( 99 . As dicused a nc, S. 2 . 63 1 2) s s bove,Pli if ha antf s s fc e l s ufii nty hown t e i a sr lkelhood ofco uso t t a ies bec us of t us by her s tong i i nf in ha rs a e he e Dee d ns o t e Ch n lMa k .Th s an ifi e tte t d futj d me ton is fle fn a t f h a e r s u ,Plitf s n i d o e a l u g n l t as desg ton oforgi cli . i nai i n am C ybe s r quati t ng The Aniybe s ti Cons r Pr e ton Ac (W CPA') 1 U. C. j 1125( , tc rquatng ume otci t i ', 5 S. d) i mpos labiiy upon a peron f t ba f ih i e t pr i f o a pr e t d ma k by es i lt s or he d at nt nt o oft r m otc e r r it rng orusng a dom a n na t t i i i lo co usngl sm ia ,o diu i of t t eg se i i i me ha s dentca r nf i y i l r r ltve , ha mar Pet dEx e s 336F.Su 2dat1 1 Topr i unde 1 U. C.j 11 d) Pl ntf k. me pr s , pp. 2 8. eval r 5 S. 25( , ai if mus de tat t t( 1 ismak i ditnctve orf t monsr e ha t ) t r s si i ( amousand e il t pr e ton;( t ntted o otci 2) he Dee ntsd i na i i ntc lo conf i y smia t t Pl ntf smak;a ( t fnda ' oman me s de ia r usngl i lr o he ai if r nd 3) he De e ntr git e orus d t domai name wih a ba f ih i e t pr i. Bav o Pal e f nda e ser d e he n t d at ntnt o oft' ' ar ac , S. v.Vac i Tour,I . 203Fe App' 252,256 ( 1h Ci.2006) n t sc e,t wel A. aton s nc, d. x 1t r .I hi as he lpl al ga i de onsr t Pli ifs M a ks a e ditnci a f m ous t t i rngi ed le tons m tae antf r r si tve nd a , hat he nfi ng domai nn e a e c usng y smia ,a t tDe e n m s r onf i l i lr nd ha f ndant r se ed t c s ti dom an s egit r he yberqua tng i na e wih t bad-at i e t t pr h f om t m . As s h, De enda s a e la e f m s t he f ih nt n o of r he uc f nt r i bl or c rquatngunde 15U. C.j 11 d) ybe s ti r S. 25( . 10 D. C om m on L a U nf r Com pe i i w ai t ton W hehera de e nts us ofa pli ifs tade a ks c eaed a lkei t f nda ' e antf r m r r t i lhood ofconf son ui bet e pl i ifs a def nda ' pr ct i alo t de e m i ng f c or i t anayss of we n antf ' nd e nts odu s s s he t r ni a t n he l i unf rcompe ii unde t c mon 1w ofFl i .Rolx Wat U S. ,l .v For ese ,No. ai tton r he om a orda e ch A. nc . r t r 83 -8381 v- i ,1 W L 1 -Ci Pane 986 5668,a *3 ( D.Fl Dec 9,1 7)(t- a opraet tf t S. a. . 98 i-he ppr it es or l dee ni whehe t e i a lkelhood of c uson,and t ta ma k i rnge t f le tnni ng t r her s i i onf i hus r de r nfi men , as de i ton o o i n,a unf i c sgna i f rgi nd ar ompetton unde t co mon lw o Fl i ,i s tf t i ii r he m a f orda s e orh n JohnH Ha l I .v Cl keChe s l ,711F. 9 972 ( 1h Ci.1 )'.Chane has ranJ nc . ar ck, nc. 2d 66, 1 t r 983 ' ) l esabls d t r i a lkelhood ofconf i r ga di De enda s us oft Cha M a kson t ihe he e s i i uson e r ng f nt ' e he nel r t i countr eta i rngi pr her e f i nd nfi ng oduct.Ac r ngl Cha hass c ded on t m e isofis s co di y, nel uc ee he rt t co on l w unf rcompe ii cai . mm a ai tton l m I V. I NJUNCTI RELI VE EF Plitf i e tte t te rq e td ij n t e rle p ru n t 1 U. C.j 1 1 .A an if s n i d o h e u se nu ci eif u s a t o 5 S. l v 16 plitf s e ig ap nn ne tij n to mu td mo taet a ( )i ha s fe e a irpaa l an if e kn e a n n u cin s e nsr t h t 1 t s u fr d n re rb e ij r ( )r me isa lw,s c a mo eay d ma e ,ae ia e uaet c mp nst f rt t nu y; 2 e de t a u h s n tr a g s r n d q t o o e ae o ha ij r ( )c n iei g t b ln e o h r hp bewe n pli tf a d d fn a t a rme y i nu y; 3 o sd rn he aa c f ads i t e anif n e e d n, e d n e t i war e a ( t t publc i ee two d notbe disrv d by a pema nt quiy s rantd; nd 4) hat he i ntrs ul se e r ne ij n to Se e y I c v Me c c a g , C, 47U. 3 8 3 ( 0 6 . nu cin. e Ba , n . . r Ex h n e LL 5 S. 8 , 91 2 0 ) He e, t wel- e alegai ns and r c d evi e de r he lpld l to e or denc monsr e t t Pl ntf ha tat ha ai if s de ope goodwila ong t c um i publc whih wo d beunde mi d i Def nda sa e vel d l m he ons ng i c ul r ne f e nt r notpr bie fom f t ri rngeme .Def nda s'co e f i pr ducswilc e t ir pa a e ohi td r urhe nfi nt e nt unt ret o t l r ae re r bl har and c uson,pa tc a l be a e t c e f i pr ucsbea i ntc m a ki a r al m onf i ri ulry c us he ount re t od t r de ial r ngs s e Cha l me cha s a a e no m a a t e t Cha ' quaiy sanda ds Furhe m o e ne r ndie, nd r t nuf c ur d o nels lt t r . t r r , 11 Def nda swiluly i rnge t Cha M ar ,a s ve aloft De e n s c tn d t do e nt lf l nfi d he nel ks nd e r he f nda t on i ue o s e n afe s r c of t Co pli i t s mate upon t m . Suc wilul c o ve tr e vi e he m a nt n hi tr he h lf onduc t de monsr t a lkei taes i lhood t tDe e nt woul c i t ha m Pl ntf s ta ha f nda s d ontnue o r ai if r dema ks i t r f he Co r d cie t is e a ij n to Peme Ex e s 3 6 F.S p 2 1 2 2 (nei g u t e ln d o su n nu cin. t d pr s , 3 u p. d 22 - 3 e trn pema n ij cin u d r 1 U. C.j 1 1 t p e e tf rhe i rn e n o f d rly r ne t nun to n e 5 S. 1 6 o r v n u t r nfi g me t f e ealprtce ta mar ) oe td r de ks, C onc us on l i Fo t r s satd above,ti he e r he ea ons t e i s r by ORDERED THAT Pl ntf ' M oto f En r o Fia De a l J g n ( 3 ) i ai ifs i n or ty f n l fut ud me t DE- 2 s GRANTED. Fi l Def t J m e i f vor of Pl ntf Cha l nc. s l be ENTERED na aul udg nt n a ai if ne ,I hal a i tDe e nt ,t Parne s ps a Uni or a e As ocatons I ntfe o Sc ul gans f nda s he t r hi nd nc por t d s i i de ii d n hed es t 'a ( 'he e o,wih as pa a eFi J $ nd S A' B' r t t e r t nal udgme t be is conc r nty wih t sOr r nt o s ued ure l t hi de . () 2 Th sc s i CLOSED. i ae s DONEAND ORDE i MimiFl i thisJ/ -a o RED n a , orda ef- f dy , , 2(1 . )2 PATRI A A.S Z C UNI TED STATES Dl TRI J CT UDGE c c: A1 Couns lofRe or 1 e c d 12 SC H ED UL E A O RIG I AL D O M A I N A M ES N N Def nda No. e nt Dom ai Nam e n 1 c ne bags or a e us c ha l f s l - . om 2 c nebagsor alus com ha l f s e a. 3 c nebags lt ne ha l oute u. t 4 c ne bags o e . t ha l t r s ne 5 c nehandba e. t ha l gs ne 6 c neha ha l ndba gs home. com 7 c a l wee y ol . t h nej lr z zne e 8 c a ej wer us .o h n le ly ac m 9 c neonlne hoppi us c ha l i s ng a.om 10 c neoute o i ha l lt nlnezol c z.om 11 c ne o l t t e z. ha l ute s or zol com 1 2 c ne s s z. m ha lhoe zol co 13 c ne s s i ne ha lhoe onlne. t 1 4 c ne s ha l hopp. com 15 c ne sor zol c ha l t e- z. om 1 6 c ne s as es l ne ha lungl s a e. t 1 7 c a hr ehr dbagsor ae. t he pc l f s l ne 1 8 c i tr l k s i ouboutns onlne. g i hoes i or 1 9 of i i - ha l l tc f c alc ne oute . om 20 onlne- k itanl i c s i ouboutnoute . i l tnet 1 3 21 s as e i a e c ungl s s ns l . om 22 uk- a ndba onlnene che pha gs i . t 23 wordt pba zol c l o gs z.om 14 SC H ED ULE B ADDI ONAL DOM AI NAM ES TI N Dee f ndantN o. Dom ai N am e n 6 c hanehandba home. t l gs ne 6 c ne ba outeu.om ha l gs lt c 6 c l - ene hanebagshom . t 8 c n le lyu ane ha ej wer s . t 8 c a l wer u ao g h ne e ly s .r j 8 c ha l ltc c neoute .om 8 cha l ute z. t ne o l t ne 8 c nel l t or ha oute z. g 8 c a ej wer z z.r h n le ly-ol o g 8 c a ej wer - ol .e h n l ly z zn t e 8 c a ej wer -ol c m h n le lyz z.o 9 c ne onlnesor sne ha l i t e . t 9 buyc nel onlne. t ha bags i ne 9 c nepur e -or ae.om ha l s s f s l c 9 c ne onlneso e . g ha l i t r sor 9 c nel ndba f s e a. ha ha gsor alus com 9 c neba - a. ha l gsus net 9 c a hr e hr dba f r a e.om he pc l gs o s l c 9 c nt ptr es a e. t ha l ts s l ne
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
