2003 Federal Circuit US Court of Appeals Case Law

Consolidation Coal Company, Consol of Pennsylvania Coal Company, Consol of Kentucky Inc., Eighty Four Mining Company, Helvetia Coal Company, Island Creek Coal Company, Kent Coal Mining Company, Keystone Coal Mining Corporation, Laurel Run Mining Company, Mcelroy Coal Company, Nineveh Coal Company, Quarto Mining Company, Eagle Energy, Inc., Elk Run Coal Company, Inc., Goals Coal Company, Green Valley Coal Company, Independence Coal Company, Inc., Knox Creek Coal Corporation, Marfork Coal Company, Inc., Martin County Coal Corporation, Peerless Eagle Coal Company, Performance Coal Company, Rawl Sales & Processing Company, Sidney Coal Company, Inc., Stone Mining Company, Apogee Coal Company, Arch Western Resources, Llc, Canyon Fuel Company, Llc, Catenary Coal Company, Coal-mac, Inc., Dal-tex Coal Corporation, Hobet Mining, Inc., Mingo Logan Coal Co., Kingston Resources, Inc., Paynter Branch Mining, Inc., Pioneer Fuel Corporation, Plateau Mining Corporation, Rag Cumberland Resources, L.p., Rag Emerald Resources, L.p., Twentymile Coal Company, Coastal Coal Company, Llc, Coastal Coal-west Virginia, Llc., Eastern Associated Coal Corporation, Evergreen Mining Company, Mid-vol Leasing, Inc., Mountaineer Coal Development Company, Old Ben Coal Company, Shipyard River Coal Terminal Company, Riverside Energy, Inc., Virginia Crews Coal Company, Clintwood Elkhorn Mining Company, Gatliff Coal Company, Premier Elkhorn Coal Company, Perry County Coal Corporation, Glamorgan Coal Company, Llc, Terry Eagle L.p., Nicholas-clay Land & Mineral, Inc., Nicholas-clay Company, Llc, and Alex Resources, Inc., Genwal Resources, Inc., Jim Walter Resources, Inc., Pacific Coast Coal Company, Usibelli Coal Mine, Inc., Powder River Coal Company, West Ridge Resources, Inc., United States Steel Mining Company, Llc, and Covenant Coal Corporation, Plaintiffs-appellants, Andrapoca Energy Company, Plaintiff-appellant, v. United States, Defendant-appellee
Date: December 11, 2003
Citation: 351 F.3d 1374
Rowdy D. Adams, Ricardo E. Aguirre, Sheri L. Althoff, Luis R. Alvarado, Luis A. Amavizca, Paul H. Ammerman, Paul A. Anderson, Jaime M. Arras, Larry G. Arthurs, Larry H. Arthurs, Martha I. Arvizu, James R. Ash, David J. Astle, John T. Attanasio, Meri L. Axberg, Albert Bailey, Jr., Robert v. Bakowski, Donald L. Barley, John C. Bates, James W. Baumann, Paul A. Beeson, James S. Bendorf, David P. Bennett, Frank J. Beverly, William L. Black, Paul Blocker, Jr., Robert A. Bollier, Robert A. Bonbright, Alfredo Borrego, Jr., Candice M. Brady, Dennis G. Brady, Gilbertina Bravo-paisley, Ronald C. Bright, John C. Brinning, Pierce L. Brown, Ronald W. Busch, Gabriel Bustamante, Joseph D. Cabral, Domingo Camacho, Francisco Camacho, Travis R. Canada, Felix Cantu, Jr., James E. Carroll, Eugene J. Carter, Fabian M. Casas, Alfredo L. Casillas, David J. Castaneda, Ernesto Castillo, Alfredo C. Ceniceros, Reuben E. Champion, Ben A. Chavez, Claudio R. Chavez, Roy S. Chavez, Alan C. Christensen, Wayne L. Chumbley, James W. Clifford, Brian P. Cogley, Ron S. Colburn, Dennis L. Connor, Danny J. Conway, Bruce L. Cooke, Juan M. Corona, Adan Cortez, Norma C. Cortez-lopez, Thomas E. Corvinus, Rory Craft, Robert J. Cranston, C. Alan Creamer, John R. Crockford, George K. Cronin, Madelenee L. Cruz, Michael K. Dalton, John W. Davies, Amado Davila, Jr., Ralph E. Davis, Dennis W. Davis, John R. Day, Ramiro R. De Anda, Jesus E. De La Vega, Rolando De Pau, Manuel P. Diego, Charles E. Dill, William M. Doolittle, Daniel B. Doty, Jerrold C. Duncan, Daniel G. Duran, James P. Economy, Jose Escareno, Romeo L. Escobar, Gary A. Estes, David Estevis, Adan Estrada, Jr., James C. Evans, Dale F. Feist, Sherry L. Feltner, Jeffery M. Fields, Robert L. Finley, Nicholas C. Fisher, Manuel Flores, Kenneth E. Foley, Arnold Forsyth, Charles R.foss, Christopher E. Foulsham, Marvin Foust, John France, Paul Franco, Randy Gallegos, Agustin Garcia, Charlie E. Garcia, Isaac Garcia, Juan A. Garcia, Mario Garcia, Jr., Uvaldo Garcia, Steven Garcia, David L. Garrett, Glicet C. Garvey, Jesus M. Garza, Oscar H. Garza, Jr., Raul G. Garza, Edward F. Gerber, Robert W. Gilbert, Joseph E. Gleason, Paul D. Glenn, Frank J. Gonzalez, Hector Gonzalez, Narcisco H. Gonzalez, Roland A. Gonzalez, R.t. Goodman, Richard M. Graham, Carlon J.w. Green, Bennie A. Greenfield, Richard J. Greenier, Roberto G. Guevara, Reynaldo Guillen, Jr., Franklin D. Gunter, Hugh O. Gustafson, David R. Gutierrez, Jorge Gutierrez, Roy P. Gwaltney, Jeffrey A. Hamrin, Michael D. Hance, Walter L. Harwell, Robert H. Haynes, Edward M. Head, Ronald H. Henley, Mark R. Henry, James G. Henry, Stacy A. Henry-swarberg, Patricio Hernandez, A.b. Hibbert, Jr., Steven A. Higgs, Larry L. Hill, Stephen L. Hill, John C. Hines, Jerry Hjelle, Donn R. Hoberg, Lane Horger, Tommy L. Hubble, John Hubert, David Jackson, Larry D. Jackson, John G. Jacobs, Herbert H. Jefferson, Kim G. Jenkins, Albert Johnson Iii, Dwight L. Johnson, Thomas S. Johnson, William E. Johnson, Andrew R. Jones, Marvin D. Jones, Robert A. Judd, William S. Jumbeck, Mark R. Kemp, Norma A. King, Loren G. Klein, Ronald A. Knight, Stan J. Kozlowski, Frank S. Kopczynski, David L. Krohn, John A. Krupa, John R. Krzeminski, Harold W. Kuenstler, Louis L. Laabs, Jerry C. Lasher, Larry G. Laudner, Patrick T. Lauer, Leo H. Laurel, Thomas J. Lawrence, Frank E. Longoria, Benito Lopez, Roberto S. Lopez, John W. Lotz, Gary R. Lucey, Michael E. Macbeth, Carlos Malandris, Jr., Richard A. Marroquin, Alfredo Martinez, Armando Martinez, Antonio v. Martinez, Ernesto Martinez, Jr., Francisco J. Martinez, Mario Martinez, Xavier Martinez, Stanley N. Matthie, Richard P. Mauer, Guadalupe J. Mauricio, Thomas S. Maxwell, Michael B. Mcclarnon, Donald G. Mcdermott, Rodney Mcdonald, Thomas E. Mcdonnell, William Mciver, Robert J. Mcnamara, Thomas F. Mcshane, Fernando Melendez, David W. Merrell, Clark J. Messer, Aaron K. Miller, James R. Miller, Rudy J. Miranda, Robert W. Mitchell, Daniel Molina, Jr., Michael Molloy, Herbert J. Monette, Kenneth J. Moniere, Benjamin Monsivais, Mark R. Moody, Arturo E. Moreno, Lisandr
Date: November 25, 2003
Citation: 350 F.3d 1216
Elan Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Mayo Foundation
Date: October 2, 2003
Citation: 346 F.3d 1051
John M. Taskett, Appellant, v. Dale H. Dentlinger, Appellee
Date: September 26, 2003
Citation: 344 F.3d 1337
Barry J. Abell, Petitioner, v. Department of the Navy, Respondent
Date: September 9, 2003
Citation: 343 F.3d 1378
In Re Coors Brewing Company
Date: September 8, 2003
Citation: 343 F.3d 1340
In Re Mbna America Bank, N.a
Date: August 15, 2003
Citation: 340 F.3d 1328
William J. Musick, Petitioner, v. Department of Energy, Respondent
Date: August 12, 2003
Citation: 339 F.3d 1365
In Re Pacer Technology
Date: August 4, 2003
Citation: 338 F.3d 1348
In Re Les Halles De Paris J.v
Date: July 11, 2003
Citation: 334 F.3d 1371
In Re the Boulevard Entertainment, Inc
Date: July 9, 2003
Citation: 334 F.3d 1336
Peggy A. Knight, Petitioner, v. Department of Defense, Respondent
Date: June 19, 2003
Citation: 332 F.3d 1362
In Re California Innovations, Inc
Date: May 22, 2003
Citation: 329 F.3d 1334
John F. Welch, Petitioner, v. Department of the Army, Respondent
Date: March 25, 2003
Citation: 323 F.3d 1042
Jose Carreon, Petitioner, v. Office of Personnel Management, Respondent
Date: February 28, 2003
Citation: 321 F.3d 1128
In Re Richard A. Berg, Paul D. Toman, and Donald G. Wallace
Date: February 20, 2003
Citation: 320 F.3d 1310
Arjun Singh, Appellant, v. Anthony J. Brake, Appellee
Date: January 29, 2003
Citation: 317 F.3d 1334
Geraldine Sacco, Petitioner, v. Department of Justice, Respondent
Date: January 21, 2003
Citation: 317 F.3d 1384
Ronald F. Koenig, Petitioner, v. Department of the Navy, Respondent
Date: January 16, 2003
Citation: 315 F.3d 1378
Kimberly Adams, Dale Anderson, Jr., Kenneth Baalman, Patricia C. Ball, Debbie Barkman, Celeste B. Berry, Debra Billings, Linda Bland, Monica A. Boyd, Anita Brewster, Trenace R. Brown, George Burkel, Annette Brown-burnett, Victoria R. Carthen, Jimmy Chan, Kathy Collier, Paul D. Collier, Racheal Collins, Joyce Dunlap, Elizabeth L. Eaglin, Maggie L. Ester, Juanita Esters, Kathleen Flynn, Carolyn Ford, Richard L. Frierdich, Jr., Michael Gaffney, Lauren Glass, Doris Gilmore, Kathleen Glauber, Patricia Gramm, William Grawe, Josephine C. Gray, Lyonette Gordon, Karen L. Griffith, Doris Grinston, Carol Hadley, Karriem Hale, Kay Lepp Hefflinger, Denise M. Hemmer, Consuela S. Henderson, Latanya Henderson, Shurketia Herring, Theresa Holland, Kimberly E. Holton, David Hotard, Peggy Hubbard, Theresa M. Huxhold, Judith Jackson-buckner, Felicia Johnson, Jeffery P. Johnson, Kimberly Johnson, John J. Jones, Tracy Jones, Tequella Jones-dee, Pamela Joseph, Bernard S. Kim, Lisa Kitners, Katherine P. Krause, Richardine Lawrence, Sandra Lenoir, Hannah Lewis, Shueyan Lim, Emma G. Lingelbach, Lashonda Lofton, Steven Love, Linda J. Mack, Matthew Maney, Debra A. Martin, Diana J. Martin, Lashonda Martin, April Mays, Sheila Meeks, Ruby Mitchell, Karen P. Moore, Lavonda Morehouse, Sonya G. Muhammad, Sonja M. Mcdonald, J.l. Mcmahan, Norma Mcmullen, Charlotte Mcroberts, Stacie Nash, Gail Nunn, Jacqueline Pegues, Robert Penning, Carolyn Pennington, Deborah Pickens, Merindia Poe, Donna M. Pollihan, Thomas J. Porter, Sheila Pratcher, Karen Pugh, Christopher Quinn, Jane Rea, Deidre A. Richardson, Elaine Riley, Linda M. Robertson, Aida M. Rocafort, Thomas J. Rodgers, Ii, Marilyn Rolf, Mark A. Russell, Cordelia J. Sadowski, Mary Sanders, Adrienne J. Scott, Karen E. Sedor, James J. Smith, Stuart A. Smith, Taisha Smith, Marilyn Starks, Patricia Steyer, Pamela A. Sturm, Samuel P.b. Steward, Iii, Jennifer Taylor, Robert M. Taylor, Sherri A. Taylor, Alitha Thomas, Beverly A. Thomas, Tanya Thompson, Osiris Tucker, Asha Turner, Zelma Walker, Keith Ward, Joddie M. Ware, Lynda Washington, Adrienne Wenecki, Janet Werths, Clarence Westbrook, Michelle West, Valerie West, Heidi Wetzel, Katherine Wick, Elicia Wilson, and F.f. Zielinski, Petitioners, v. Internal Revenue Service, Respondent
Date: January 8, 2003
Citation: 314 F.3d 1367
In Re Lance G. Peterson and Ioannis Vasatis
Date: January 8, 2003
Citation: 315 F.3d 1325
In Re Majestic Distilling Company, Inc
Date: January 2, 2003
Citation: 315 F.3d 1311

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.