Opinions From the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit - April 2000

Valero Terrestrial Corporation; Lackawanna Transport Company; Solid Waste Services, Incorporated, D/b/a J.p. Mascaro & Sons, Plaintiffs-appellants, v. James H. Paige, Secretary, Department of Tax and Revenue of the State of West Virginia; Darrell v. Mcgraw, Jr., Honorable, Attorney General of the State of West Virginia; B.f. "cap" Smith, Chief of the Division of Waste Management for the Division of Enviromental Protection; Laidley Eli Mccoy, Director, Division of Enviromental Protection, of the Department of Labor, Commerce and Environmental Resources of the State of West Virginia, Defendants-appellees,andjohn Ranson, Secretary, Department of Labor, Commerce and Enviromental Resources of the State of West Virginia; Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Defendants,andlarry Harless, Respondent.valero Terrestrial Corporation; Lackawanna Transport Company; Solid Waste Services, Incorporated, D/b/a J.p. Mascaro & Sons, Plaintiffs-appellees, v. James H. Paige, Secretary, Department of Tax and Revenue of the State of West Virginia; Darrell v. Mcgraw, Jr., Honorable, Attorney General Ofthe State of West Virginia; B.f. "cap" Smith, Chief of the Division of Waste Management for the Division of Enviromental Protection; Laidley Eli Mccoy, Director, Division of Enviromental Protection of the Department of Labor, Commerce and Enviromental Resources of the State of West Virginia, Defendants-appellants, and John Ranson, Secretary, Department of Labor, Commerce and Enviromental Resources of the State of West Virginia; Public Service Commission of West Virginia, Defendants,andlarry Harless, Respondent
Date: April 20, 2000
Citation: 211 F.3d 112

Plaintiff v. Defendant
Date: April 4, 2000
Citation: 209 F.3d 353